1: \begin{abstract}
2:
3: The main result of this paper is a collection of conservative naturalness bounds on minimal
4: extensions of the Standard Model by (vector-like) fermionic or scalar gauge multiplets.
5: Within, we advocate for an intuitive and physical concept of naturalness
6: built upon the renormalisation group equations.
7: In the effective field theory
8: of the Standard Model plus a gauge multiplet with mass $M$,
9: the low scale Higgs mass parameter
10: is a calculable function of $\overline{\rm MS}$ input parameters
11: defined at some high scale $\Lambda_h > M$.
12: If the Higgs mass is very sensitive to these input parameters,
13: then this signifies a naturalness problem.
14: To sensibly capture the sensitivity,
15: it is shown how a sensitivity measure can be rigorously derived
16: as a Bayesian model comparison,
17: which reduces in a relevant limit to a Barbieri--Giudice-like fine-tuning measure.
18: This measure is fully generalisable to any perturbative EFT.
19: The interesting results of our two-loop renormalisation group study are as follows:
20: for $\Lambda_h=\Lambda_{Pl}$ we find ``$10\%$ fine-tuning'' bounds on the masses
21: of various gauge multiplets of $M<\mathcal{O}(1$--$10)$~TeV, with
22: bounds on fermionic gauge multiplets significantly weaker than for scalars;
23: these bounds remain finite in the limit $\Lambda_h\to M^+$,
24: weakening to $M<\mathcal{O}(10$--$100)$~TeV;
25: and bounds on coloured multiplets are no more severe than for electroweak multiplets,
26: since they only directly correct the Higgs mass at three-loop.
27:
28: \end{abstract}
29: