1: %\documentclass[12pt,preprint]{aastex}
2: \documentclass{emulateapj}
3: %\usepackage{apjfonts}
4: %\usepackage{graphicx}
5:
6: % last modified 5 Apr 07 by GCS
7: % ms09.tex
8:
9: % to convert from preprint to emulateapj
10: % uncomment \rotate for Table 4-5, remove "*" after "deluxetable" (Tab. 2, 4-5)
11:
12: \newcommand{\vdag}{(v)^\dagger}
13: \newcommand{\mum}{\ifmmode{\rm \mu m}\else{$\mu$m}\fi}
14: \newcommand{\iras}{{\it IRAS}}
15: \newcommand{\iso}{{\it ISO}}
16: \newcommand{\msx}{{\it MSX}}
17:
18: \begin{document}
19:
20: \title{The unusual hydrocarbon emission from the early carbon star
21: HD 100764: The connection between aromatics and aliphatics}
22:
23: \author{
24: G.~C.~Sloan\altaffilmark{1},
25: M.~Jura\altaffilmark{2},
26: W.~W.~Duley\altaffilmark{3},
27: K.~E.~Kraemer\altaffilmark{4},
28: J.~Bernard-Salas\altaffilmark{1},
29: W.~J.~Forrest\altaffilmark{5},
30: B.~Sargent\altaffilmark{5},
31: A.~Li\altaffilmark{6},
32: D.~J.~Barry\altaffilmark{1},
33: C.~J.~Bohac\altaffilmark{5},
34: D.~M.~Watson\altaffilmark{5},
35: \& J.~R.~Houck\altaffilmark{1}
36: %A. Scott\altaffilmark{3,7},
37: }
38: \altaffiltext{1}{Cornell University, Astronomy Department,
39: Ithaca, NY 14853-6801; sloan@isc.astro.cornell.edu,
40: jbs@isc.astro.cornell.edu, don@isc.astro.cornell.edu, jrh13@cornell.edu}
41: \altaffiltext{2}{Department of Physics and Astronomy and Center
42: for Astrobiology, University of California, Los Angeles, CA
43: 90095-1562; jura@astro.ucla.edu}
44: \altaffiltext{3}{Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Waterloo,
45: 200 University Avenue West, Waterloo, ON N2L 3G1, Canada;
46: wwduley@uwaterloo.ca}
47: \altaffiltext{4}{Air Force Research Laboratory, Space Vehicles
48: Directorate, 29 Randolph Rd., Hanscom AFB, MA 01731;
49: kathleen.kraemer@hanscom.af.mil}
50: \altaffiltext{5}{Department of Physics and Astronomy, University
51: of Rochester, Rochester, NY 14627-0171; forrest@pas.rochester.edu,
52: bsargent@pas.rochester.edu, cbohac@pas.rochester.edu, dmw@pas.rochester.edu}
53: \altaffiltext{6}{Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of
54: Missouri Columbia, MO 65211, lia@missouri.edu}
55: %\altaffiltext{7}{COM DEV International, 1725 Woodward Drive,
56: % Ottawa, ON K2C 0P9, Canada}
57:
58: \slugcomment{Accepted in ApJ}
59:
60: %\slugcomment{PREPRINT}
61:
62: \begin{abstract}
63:
64: We have used the Infrared Spectrograph (IRS) on the {\it
65: Spitzer Space Telescope} to obtain spectra of HD 100764, an
66: apparently single carbon star with a circumstellar disk. The
67: spectrum shows emission features from polycyclic aromatic
68: hydrocarbons (PAHs) that are shifted to longer wavelengths
69: than normally seen, as characteristic of ``class C'' systems
70: in the classification scheme of Peeters et al. All seven of
71: the known class C PAH sources are illuminated by radiation
72: fields that are cooler than those which typically excite PAH
73: emission features. The observed wavelength shifts are
74: consistent with hydrocarbon mixtures containing both aromatic
75: and aliphatic bonds. We propose that the class C PAH spectra
76: are distinctive because the carbonaceous material has not
77: been subjected to a strong ultraviolet radiation field,
78: allowing relatively fragile aliphatic materials to survive.
79:
80: \end{abstract}
81:
82: \keywords{ circumstellar matter --- stars: carbon }
83:
84:
85: \section{Introduction} % Sec. 1.0
86:
87: Complex hydrocarbons are found in a wide variety of
88: astrophysical environments. \cite{gfm73} first detected
89: what became known as the unidentified infrared (UIR)
90: emission features, the strongest of which are at 3.3, 6.2,
91: 7.7--7.9, 8.6, 11.3, and 12.7~\mum. \cite{lp84} and
92: \cite{atb85} identified the carrier of these features as
93: polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs). The debate over
94: PAHs as the carrier of the UIR features raged for many
95: years, and while the identification now seems firm
96: \cite[e.g.][]{ahs99}, many questions still remain over
97: the origin, evolution, and exact composition of astrophysical
98: hydrocarbons.
99:
100: \cite{pee02} used data from the Short Wavelength Spectrometer
101: (SWS) on the {\it Infrared Space Observatory} (\iso) to group
102: PAH spectra into three classes based on the positions of peak
103: emission and profiles of the C--C skeletal deformation modes
104: within the PAHs at 6.2 and 7.7--7.9~\mum. The ``class A''
105: sources display features at 6.22 and 7.65~\mum\ and generally
106: include H II regions, reflection nebulae, galaxies, and
107: Herbig AeBe (HAeBe) stars still embedded in the regions where
108: they formed. The ``class B'' sources, which typically
109: include planetary nebulae and isolated HAeBe stars, show
110: these same features, but shifted to 6.26 and 7.85~\mum.
111: \cite{pee02} also identified two ``class C'' sources
112: including the well-known Egg Nebula (AFGL 2688) which are in
113: transition from the asymptotic giant branch (AGB) to the
114: planetary nebula phase. These two sources show emission at
115: 6.26~\mum, no emission near 7.65~\mum, and a broad feature
116: centered at $\sim$8.2~\mum. It remains unclear how these
117: different classes of PAHs arise in different astrophysical
118: environments.
119:
120: Observations with the Infrared Spectrograph
121: \citep[IRS;][]{hou04} on the {\it Spitzer Space Telescope}
122: \citep{wer04} have added to the small sample of class C PAH
123: spectra. \cite{kra06} reported the detection of a class C
124: PAH spectrum from MSX SMC 029, a transition object in the
125: Small Magellanic Cloud (SMC). \cite{jur06} detected a class
126: C PAH spectrum from HD 233517, an apparently single red giant
127: (K2 III) with a substantial infrared excess which most likely
128: arises from a circumstellar disk \citep{jur03}. This system
129: is remarkable because some of the hydrocarbons were probably
130: synthesized from the oxygen-rich disk.
131:
132: % \section{HD 100764}
133:
134: HD 100764 is one of a handful of red giants (luminosity class
135: III) with large infrared excesses characteristic of orbiting
136: disks. While most of these stars are oxygen-rich like
137: HD 233517, HD 100764 is carbon-rich. As part of a
138: program to better understand these stars, we obtained IRS
139: data for HD 100764. We have found that its IRS spectrum
140: reveals low-contrast class C PAH features not detectable in
141: the previous ground-based spectroscopy. In this paper, we
142: describe the PAH spectrum of HD 100764 in detail and relate
143: it to other class C PAH sources.
144: % and present a model to explain the properties of these systems.
145:
146: HD 100764, also known as CCS 1886 and CGCS 3066, is
147: classified as an early carbon star, R2 \citep{san44} or
148: C1,1 \citep{yam72}. Using optical spectroscopy, \cite{dom84}
149: found that the central star has a temperature of 4850 K, is
150: iron poor, and has an enhanced $^{13}$C/$^{12}$C ratio,
151: making this carbon star one of the uncommon J stars. The
152: Hipparcos parallax of 2.78 ${\pm}$ 1.18 mas yields an
153: uncertain distance of $\sim$360 pc and thus a total
154: luminosity of 73 L$_{\odot}$ \citep{par91}, indicating that
155: the star is a first-ascent red giant.
156:
157: \cite{le90} identified HD 100764 as a potential
158: silicate/carbon star because of its red \iras\ [12]$-$[25]
159: color as measured by the {\it Infrared Astronomy Satellite}
160: (\iras). As a consequence, it was observed twice using
161: ground-based mid-infrared spectrometers over a decade ago.
162: \cite{lev92} obtained an 8--14~\mum\ spectrum at the
163: Wyoming Infrared Observatory (WIRO) with a resolution
164: ($\lambda/\Delta\lambda$) of $\sim$50 and a signal/noise
165: (S/N) ratio of $\sim$5. While they could rule out the
166: presence of silicate dust emission at 10~\mum\ in the
167: spectrum, they could say little more. \cite{ski94} obtained
168: a higher quality spectrum with CGS3 at the United Kingdom
169: Infrared Telescope (UKIRT), also saw no spectral features
170: from dust, and concluded that the infrared emission was
171: dominated by amorphous carbon dust in a circumstellar disk.
172: The disk explains why the strong infrared excess does not
173: appreciably redden the optical spectrum.
174:
175: Although uncertain, it is plausible that this disk formed
176: when HD 100764 became a red giant and engulfed a companion.
177: The luminosity of HD 100764 is consistent with other R
178: stars with measured parallaxes, which \cite{alk98} have
179: determined are first-ascent red giants, not AGB stars.
180: \cite{mcc97} observed that R stars do not have companions
181: and suggested that their carbon-rich nature and the lack of
182: a companion could both be explained by coalescence of an
183: expanding giant and its companion.
184:
185:
186: \section{The infrared spectra} % Sec. 2.0
187:
188: \subsection{Observations and analysis} % Sec. 2.1
189:
190: We observed HD 100764 with both the Short-Low (SL) and
191: Long-Low (LL) modules of the IRS in standard staring mode on
192: 2006 January 14. Because the source is bright for the IRS,
193: we used the shortest possible ramps in both modules, 6-second
194: ramps which provide only four samples. This source was
195: observed independently with the Short-High (SH) and Long-High
196: (LH) modules in {\it Spitzer} program 278 (AOR key 19481344),
197: and we include those data here with permission of the P.I.,
198: M. Werner. % 3235
199:
200: We followed the standard calibration method used at Cornell.
201: We started with the S14 pipeline output from the {\it
202: Spitzer} Science Center (SSC) and subtracted a sky image from
203: each image before extracting a spectrum. The high-resolution
204: observations include separate sky images obtained close to
205: the target. For SL, the sky image for one spectral aperture
206: is obtained when the source is in the other aperture (i.e.
207: aperture differerences: SL2$-$SL1 and SL1$-$SL2, where
208: ``SL2'' means ``SL Order 2''). For LL, we simply differenced
209: the images with the source in the same aperture, but in the
210: other nod position. For a source as bright as HD 100764, the
211: primary benefit of background removal is the subtraction of
212: most of the rogue pixels. These pixels have temporarily
213: increased dark currents and are the primary source of noise
214: in images with bright sources. We applied {\rm
215: imclean.pro}\footnote{Available from the SSC as {\rm
216: irsclean.pro}.} to replace remaining rogue and bad pixels.
217:
218: Spectra were extracted from the individual images using
219: the SSC-defined apertures and the routines {\rm profile},
220: {\rm ridge}, and {\rm extract}, which are available with the
221: {\rm SPICE} software package ({\it Spitzer} IRS Custom
222: Extraction). To calibrate to flux-density
223: units, we used a spectral correction generated from IRS
224: observations of standard stars, HR 6348 (K0 III) for SL, and
225: HR 6348, HD 166780 (K4 III) and HD 173511 (K5 III) for LL
226: \citep[see ][ for more details]{slo07}. The high-resolution
227: data were calibrated using $\xi$ Dra (K2 III). Error bars
228: are based on the standard deviation of the spectrum in the
229: two separate nods in each aperture. The resulting spectrum
230: has a S/N ratio which is typically between 200 and 400.
231:
232: We applied scalar multiplicative corrections to the segments
233: to remove discontinuities and align them upwards to the
234: presumably best-centered spectral segment, in this case LL2.
235: This step required corrections of 9\% to SL2, 2\% to SL1, and
236: 1\% to LL1. These corrections indicate the accuracy of the
237: pointing of the telescope and are consistent with typical
238: observations. Finally, we combined the bonus order with
239: valid data in the overlapping orders and removed all data
240: outside the ranges of trustworthy signal. Table 1 gives the
241: wavelength ranges used for each low-resolution order.
242:
243: % Table 1 goes here
244:
245: \begin{deluxetable}{ccc} % Table 1
246: \tablecolumns{3}
247: \tablewidth{0pt}
248: \tablenum{1}
249: \tablecaption{Low-resolution wavelength ranges}
250: \tablehead{
251: \colhead{order} & \colhead{SL (\mum)} & \colhead{LL (\mum)} }
252: \startdata
253: second & 5.10--7.59 & 14.20--21.23 \\
254: bonus & 7.73--8.39 & 19.28--21.23 \\
255: first & 7.59--14.33 & 20.46--37.00 \\
256: \enddata
257: \end{deluxetable}
258:
259: \begin{figure} % Fig. 1
260: \includegraphics[width=3.5in]{f1c.eps}
261: \caption{The spectrum of HD 100764 with the low-resolution
262: modules (blue or black) and with the high-resolution
263: modules (red or gray).}
264: \end{figure}
265:
266: The flux density from HD 100764 in the 5--37~\mum\ spectral
267: region ranges between 5 and 11 Jy, and we have therefore
268: assessed the saturation and non-linearities in the response
269: function, especially in LL. The S14 pipeline has a greatly
270: improved correction for these problems, and it produces much
271: better spectra compared to previous pipeline versions.
272: Figure 1 presents the full spectrum of HD 100764, both our
273: low-resolution data and also the high-resolution data
274: obtained by M. Werner et al. A comparison of the two spectra
275: reveals no evidence for any residual artifacts from the
276: saturation and linearity corrections in our low-resolution
277: spectrum. One artifact that does remain is the fringing
278: from the LL1 filter apparent between 21 and 25~\mum. We
279: do not attempt a correction because the analysis in this
280: paper concentrates on the features at shorter wavelengths.
281: For this paper, we focus on the
282: low-resolution spectrum from 5 to 14~\mum.
283:
284: Superimposed on the continuum produced by the circumstellar
285: disk are emission features at wavelengths near those
286: associated with PAHs and a broad emission feature centered
287: at 10.6~\mum. To isolate the PAH-related features we
288: subtracted a spline-fitted continuum, as Figure 2 shows.
289: This spline passes through and includes the broad feature
290: peaking at 10.63~\mum. We examine this feature separately
291: in \S 2.5. The spectrum of HD 100764 also shows a narrow
292: absorption band from acetylene (C$_2$H$_2$) at 13.7~\mum.
293: When this absorption band appears with PAH emission features,
294: it is only in the rare class C PAH spectra \citep{kra06}.
295:
296: The low-contrast features in the 8--14~\mum\ range escaped
297: previous detection. The 8~\mum\ feature has a contrast of
298: 5\% but lies at the edge of the ground-based window, and the
299: feature near 11.3~\mum\ has a contrast of only 3\%, too small
300: to be seen even in the spectrum by \cite{ski94}, which has a
301: S/N ratio of $\sim$15 at those wavelengths.
302:
303: Figure 2 ({\it top}) plots the spectra from the two nod
304: positions separately. Systematic errors in the spectra have
305: their greatest impact on low-contrast features, and they
306: often show up as differences between the nods. Some detailed
307: differences in the PAH features are apparent, most notably at
308: $\sim$ 8.5~\mum, but these differences are not large enough
309: to have a significant quantitative effect on our conclusions.
310: Figure 2 ({\it bottom}) presents the continuum-subtracted
311: spectrum from HD 100764, along with line segments used to
312: extract the strength and position of each PAH emission
313: feature, as described in \S 2.3.
314:
315: % KK - can we quantify here, e.g. lamba_c?
316:
317: \begin{figure} % Fig. 2
318: \includegraphics[width=3.5in]{f2c.eps}
319: \caption{The spectrum of HD 100764. The top panel shows
320: the coadded spectrum and the spectra from the individual nod
321: positions (offset by 1 and 2 Jy, respectively). The thin
322: solid curve is a spline fit to the data at wavelengths marked
323: with diamonds. These points lie outside of the PAH features
324: and C$_2$H$_2$ absorption band at 13.7~\mum. The bottom panel
325: shows the resulting continuum-subtracted spectrum, along with
326: the error bars and the line segments fit to extract the
327: strengths and centers of the spectroscopic features. The
328: line segments are thick in the wavelength regions used to fit
329: the continuum and thin where the feature is integrated. The
330: equivalent width of the 13.7~\mum\ acetylene band is measured
331: before any continuum subtraction.}
332: \end{figure}
333:
334: \subsection{The comparison sample} % Sec. 2.2
335:
336: \begin{deluxetable*}{llrllll} % Table 2
337: \tablecolumns{7}
338: \tablewidth{0pt}
339: \tablenum{2}
340: \tablecaption{HD 100764 and the comparison sample}
341: \tablehead{
342: \colhead{ } & \colhead{ } & \colhead{ } & \colhead{ } &
343: \colhead{Spectral} & \colhead{$T_{eff}$} & \colhead{PAH} \\
344: \colhead{Target} & \colhead{Instrument} & \colhead{AOR key or TDT} &
345: \colhead{Object type\tablenotemark{a}} & \colhead{type\tablenotemark{a}} &
346: \colhead{(K)\tablenotemark{a}} & \colhead{class} }
347: \startdata
348: HD 100764 & IRS & 16262656 & red giant &
349: C1,1 & 4850 & C \\
350: IRAS 13416-6243 & SWS & 62803904 & post-AGB &
351: G1 I & 5440 & C \\
352: AFGL 2688 & SWS & 33800604 35102563 & post-AGB &
353: F5 Ia & 6520 & C \\
354: MSX SMC 029 & IRS & 10656256 & post-AGB &
355: \nodata & \nodata & C \\
356: HD 233517 & IRS & 3586048 & red giant &
357: K2 III & 4475 & C \\
358: SU Aur & IRS & 3533824 & T Tauri &
359: G1 & 5945 & C \\
360: HD 135344 & IRS & 3580672 & Herbig AeBe &
361: F4 Ve & 6590 & B/C \\
362: HD 44179 & SWS & 70201801 & post-AGB &
363: A0 III & 9520 & B \\
364: NGC 1333 SVS 3 & SWS & 65902719 & reflection neb. &
365: B6 & 14000 & A \\
366: \enddata
367: \tablenotetext{a}{See \S 3.1 for details and references.}
368: \end{deluxetable*}
369:
370: \begin{figure} % Fig. 3
371: \includegraphics[width=3.5in] {f3c.eps}
372: \caption{Infrared spectra of several sources showing
373: class C PAH features, along with spectra of HD 44179
374: (class B) and NGC 1333 SVS 3 (class A). The spectra of
375: IRAS 13416, AFGL 2688, NGC 1333 SVS 3, and HD 44179 are
376: from the \iso/SWS database \citep[as processed
377: by][]{slo03}; the remaining spectra are from the IRS.
378: The thin lines show the continua fit to the spectra, based
379: on a spline through the wavelengths marked with diamonds.
380: The resulting continuum-subtracted PAH spectra appear
381: in Fig. 4.
382: %The letters in parentheses give the class
383: %of PAH emission, as defined by \cite{pee02}
384: }
385: \end{figure}
386:
387: \begin{figure} % Fig. 4
388: \includegraphics[width=3.5in]{f4c.eps}
389: \caption{The continuum-subtracted spectrum of HD 100764
390: along with several comparison spectra (also
391: continuum-subtracted). The name of each source is followed
392: by the classification of its PAH spectrum. The vertical
393: lines are at the centers of the PAH features for a class B
394: spectrum: 6.26, 7.90, 11.26, and 12.67~\mum. The majority
395: of the class C spectra show features shifted to the red of
396: these lines. The dashed lines at 6.85 and 7.25 mark the
397: positions of aliphatic emission features. The bottom two
398: spectra are the prototypical class A and class B spectra from
399: the \iso/SWS database. The remainder are the sample of known
400: class C PAH spectra (or in the case of HD 135344, nearly
401: class C PAH spectrum). The extractions of the PAH features
402: at 12.0 and 12.7~\mum\ in AFGL 2688 are particularly
403: untrustworthy due to their extremely low contrast and
404: resultant sensitivity to the location of the spline points
405: for the continuum. In the spectrum of AFGL 2688, the bottom
406: of the 13.7~\mum\ feature has been truncated to prevent it
407: from overrunning the spectra below.}
408: \end{figure}
409:
410: To place the class C PAH spectrum from HD 100764 in context,
411: we have also examined several other PAH spectra. These
412: comparison spectra include the two class C PAH sources from
413: the SWS database, AFGL 2688 and IRAS 13416$-$6243, along with
414: SWS spectra of NGC 1333 SVS 3 and HD 44179 (the Red
415: Rectangle). These sources are prototypical examples of class
416: A and B PAH spectra, respectively. All four spectra are from
417: the atlas of SWS spectra produced by \cite{slo03}, and they
418: have been regridded to a lower spectral resolution. In the
419: case of AFGL 2688, the spectrum is an average of two
420: observations. The comparison sample also includes the four
421: sources observed by the IRS which are currently known to have
422: PAH spectra either in or near class C, including the K giant
423: HD 233517 \citep{jur06}, the post-AGB source MSX SMC 029
424: \citep{kra06}, the HAeBe source HD 135344 \citep{slo05},
425: and the intermediate-mass T Tauri star SU Aur \citep{fur06}.
426:
427: Table 2 presents the comparison sample, including their
428: spectral classes and effective temperatures, which are
429: described in \S 3.1.
430:
431: % Table 2 goes here.
432:
433: \subsection{Extracting the PAH features} % Sec. 2.3
434:
435: \begin{deluxetable}{ccccc} % Table 3
436: \tablecolumns{5}
437: \tablewidth{0pt}
438: \tablenum{3}
439: \tablecaption{Wavelength intervals used to extract spectral features}
440: \tablehead{
441: \colhead{} & \multicolumn{2}{c}{For class C sources} &
442: \multicolumn{2}{c}{For class A and B sources} \\
443: \colhead{Feature (\mum)} &
444: \colhead{$\lambda_{blue}$ (\mum)} & \colhead{$\lambda_{red}$ (\mum)} &
445: \colhead{$\lambda_{blue}$ (\mum)} & \colhead{$\lambda_{red}$ (\mum)} }
446: \startdata
447: %6.0 & 5.89--5.95 & 6.07--6.13 & \\
448: 6.2 & 5.80--5.95 & 6.65--6.80 & as class C & 6.54--6.69 \\
449: 7.9 & 7.30--7.60 & 9.00--9.30 & 7.10--7.40 & 8.92--9.17 \\
450: 8.6 & 8.32--8.44 & 8.86--8.98 & as class C & as class C \\
451: 11.3 & 10.80--11.00 & 11.85--11.95 & 10.68--10.86 & 11.72--11.90 \\
452: 12.0 & 11.85--11.95 & 12.35--12.60 & 11.72--11.90 & 12.13--12.25 \\
453: 12.7 & 12.35--12.60 & 13.25--13.40 & 12.07--12.19 & 12.98--13.10 \\
454: 13.7 & 13.25--13.55 & 13.83--14.13 & as class C & as class C \\
455: \enddata
456: \end{deluxetable}
457:
458: \begin{center}
459: \begin{deluxetable*}{lccccccc} % Table 4
460: %\rotate
461: \tablecolumns{8}
462: \tablewidth{0pt}
463: \tablenum{4}
464: \tablecaption{Central wavelengths of the PAH and C$_2$H$_2$ features}
465: \tablehead{
466: \colhead{ } & \multicolumn{6}{c}{$\lambda_{c}$ (\mum)} \\
467: \colhead{Target} & \colhead{6.2~\mum\ PAH} & \colhead{7.7--8.2~\mum\ PAH} &
468: \colhead{8.6~\mum\ PAH} & \colhead{11.3~\mum\ PAH} &
469: \colhead{12.0~\mum\ PAH} & \colhead{12.7~\mum\ PAH} &
470: \colhead{13.7~\mum\ C$_2$H$_2$} }
471: \startdata
472: HD 100764 & 6.33$\pm$0.01 & 8.15$\pm$0.06 & \nodata &
473: 11.47$\pm$0.07 & 12.14$\pm$0.15\tablenotemark{a} &
474: 12.83$\pm$0.27\tablenotemark{a} & 13.70$\pm$0.02 \\
475: IRAS 13416 & 6.31$\pm$0.01 & 8.22$\pm$0.02 & 8.71$\pm$0.02 &
476: 11.42$\pm$0.03 & 12.25$\pm$0.07 & 12.87$\pm$0.10 &
477: 13.70$\pm$0.00 \\
478: AFGL 2688 & 6.29$\pm$0.01 & 8.20$\pm$0.01 & 8.68$\pm$0.03 &
479: 11.36$\pm$0.03 & 12.13$\pm$0.03 & 12.93$\pm$0.03 &
480: 13.71$\pm$0.01 \\
481: MSX SMC 029 & 6.25$\pm$0.04 & 8.12$\pm$0.10 & 8.68$\pm$0.05 &
482: 11.32$\pm$0.07 & \nodata & \nodata &
483: 13.67$\pm$0.02 \\
484: HD 233517 & 6.28$\pm$0.03 & 8.26$\pm$0.03 & 8.72$\pm$0.07 &
485: 11.35$\pm$0.02 & \nodata & 12.75$\pm$0.09 & \nodata \\
486: SU Aur & 6.26$\pm$0.01 & 8.19$\pm$0.03 &
487: 8.67$\pm$0.18\tablenotemark{a} & 11.33$\pm$0.01 &
488: 12.02$\pm$0.03\tablenotemark{b} & 12.78$\pm$0.08 & \nodata \\
489: HD 135344 & 6.28$\pm$0.03 & 8.08$\pm$0.04 & 8.64$\pm$0.07 &
490: 11.35$\pm$0.01 & \nodata & 12.75$\pm$0.08 & \nodata \\
491: HD 44179 & 6.26$\pm$0.00 & 7.84$\pm$0.06 & 8.66$\pm$0.01 &
492: 11.27$\pm$0.00 & 12.00$\pm$0.04 & 12.71$\pm$0.02 & \nodata\\
493: NGC 1333 SVS 3 & 6.23$\pm$0.00 & 7.68$\pm$0.01 & 8.61$\pm$0.01 &
494: 11.26$\pm$0.01 & 12.00$\pm$0.02 & 12.70$\pm$0.01 & \nodata\\
495: \enddata
496: \tablenotetext{a}{S/N of extracted feature $<$ 2.}
497: \tablenotetext{b}{S/N of extracted feature $<$ 3.}
498: \end{deluxetable*}
499: \end{center}
500:
501: \begin{center}
502: \begin{deluxetable*}{lccccccc} % Table 5
503: %\rotate
504: \tablecolumns{8}
505: \tablewidth{0pt}
506: \tablenum{5}
507: \tablecaption{Extracted strengths of the PAH and C$_2$H$_2$ features}
508: \tablehead{
509: \colhead{ } & \multicolumn{6}{c}{$F$ (10$^{-15}$ W m$^2$)} &
510: \colhead{$W_{\lambda}$ (10$^{-3}$ \mum) \tablenotemark{a}} \\
511: \colhead{Target} & \colhead{6.2~\mum} & \colhead{7.7--8.2~\mum} &
512: \colhead{8.6~~\mum} & \colhead{11.3~\mum} & \colhead{12.0~\mum} &
513: \colhead{12.7~\mum} & \colhead{13.7~\mum} }
514: \startdata
515: HD 100764 & 4.61$\pm$0.24 & 9.15$\pm$0.82 & \nodata &
516: 2.27$\pm$0.28 & 0.32$\pm$0.17 & 0.16$\pm$0.13 &
517: 3.18$\pm$0.64 \\
518: IRAS 13416 & 57.3$\pm$2.4 & 225$\pm$5 & 1.73$\pm$0.51 &
519: 22.9 $\pm$1.5 & 7.39$\pm$1.66 & 7.71$\pm$1.54 &
520: 5.10$\pm$0.48 \\
521: AFGL 2688 & 111$\pm$4 & 860$\pm$10 & 18.6$\pm$1.6 &
522: 147$\pm$15 & 76.5$\pm$7.4 & 204$\pm$14 &
523: 6.23$\pm$0.57 \\
524: MSX SMC 029 & 0.16$\pm$0.03 & 0.29$\pm$0.03 & 0.051$\pm$0.007 &
525: 0.068$\pm$0.012 & 0.005$\pm$0.021 & 0.001$\pm$0.015 &
526: 14.84$\pm$2.96 \\
527: HD 233517 & 1.46$\pm$0.15 & 1.75$\pm$0.08 & 0.11$\pm$0.03 &
528: 0.66$\pm$0.04 & \nodata & 0.091$\pm$0.037 &
529: 1.22$\pm$3.09 \\
530: SU Aur & 6.08$\pm$0.35 & 6.64$\pm$0.35 & 0.14$\pm$0.12 &
531: 3.77$\pm$0.13 & 0.080$\pm$0.037 & 0.31$\pm$0.08 &
532: \nodata \\
533: HD 135344 & 5.44$\pm$0.54 & 9.42$\pm$0.46 & 0.43$\pm$0.12 &
534: 2.34$\pm$0.06 & \nodata & 0.14$\pm$0.04 &
535: \nodata \\
536: HD 44179 & 2969$\pm$23 & 5731$\pm$677 & 960$\pm$19 &
537: 1182$\pm$19 & 48.3$\pm$10.6 & 239$\pm$14 &
538: \nodata \\
539: NGC 1333 SVS 3 & 241$\pm$3 & 280$\pm$7 & 69.9$\pm$1.8 &
540: 172$\pm$5 & 3.52$\pm$0.63 & 57.2$\pm$1.2 &
541: \nodata \\
542: \enddata
543: \tablenotetext{a}{Equivalent width of the acetylene absorption band.}
544: \end{deluxetable*}
545: \end{center}
546:
547: For each source, we follow the algorithm described for
548: HD 100764 by spline-fitting and removing a continuum,
549: as Figure 3 illustrates. It has proven necessary to shift
550: the spline points from one spectrum to the next to avoid
551: some of the spectral structure which only appears in
552: individual spectra. Care must be taken in the case of
553: IRAS 13416 and AFGL 2688 because the PAH features have such
554: low contrast with respect to the continuum. In the case of
555: AFGL 2688, the features at 12.0 and 12.7~\mum\ must be
556: treated with caution because their apparent strength and
557: position shift substantially with the choice of spline
558: points. The spline fit to SU Aur removes the silicate
559: emission feature; this method has been tested for several
560: similar sources showing both PAH and silicate emission by
561: \cite{kel07}. Two of the spectra have been smoothed:
562: MSX SMC 029 with a 3-pixel boxcar, and HD 233517 with a
563: 5-pixel boxcar. Figure 4 presents the continuum-subtracted
564: PAH spectra for HD 100764 and the comparison sample.
565:
566: Fitting and removing a spline removes most, but not all, of
567: the continuum spectrum. Because we have not forced the fitted
568: spline to pass precisely through the continuum on either side
569: of each feature, small residual tilts remain. While these
570: would have little impact on the extracted strengths of the
571: features, they would shift the measured center. We therefore
572: continue to use the method applied to a sample of HAeBe
573: stars showing PAH emission by \cite{slo05}. As they did, we
574: fit line segments to the continuum on either side of each PAH
575: feature and integrate the flux above this estimated continuum
576: to measure the strength of the feature. We determine the
577: wavelength with half the emitted flux to either side, which
578: for the remainder of this paper, we call the central
579: wavelength.
580:
581: Other authors have analyzed the position of the peak
582: wavelength, but this result differs from the central
583: wavelength for two reasons. First, PAH features are usually
584: asymmetric, so the peak will lie slightly to the blue of the
585: center. Second, most of the features are blends of multiple
586: transitions. The feature peaking at $\sim$7.7--7.9~\mum\
587: can be analyzed as a combination of features at 7.65 and
588: 7.85~\mum\ \citep[e.g.][]{pee02,bt05}. As the 7.85~\mum\
589: component increases with respect to the 7.65~\mum\ component,
590: the central wavelength will move steadily to the red, but the
591: peak wavelength will not move significantly until the red
592: component outshines the blue component. Analyzing the
593: central wavelength provides better insight about the relative
594: strengths of the various components of each PAH feature.
595:
596: % Table 3 goes here.
597:
598: Table 3 gives the wavelength ranges used to fit the line
599: segments to each feature; these have changed some from the
600: ranges used by \cite{slo05}. We use the class C
601: wavelengths, for all of the sources except HD 44179 and
602: NGC 1333 SVS 3, which require shifted wavelengths to extract
603: the features. All of the spectra except HD 100764 and SU Aur
604: have a feature at 8.6~\mum\ from the C--H in-plane bending
605: mode on the red shoulder of the C--C feature peaking between
606: 7.7 and 8.2~\mum. To eliminate the influence of the
607: 8.6~\mum\ feature on the position and strength of the broader
608: feature, we fit a line segment underneath it and include only
609: the flux below that line in our measurement of the
610: 7.7--8.2~\mum\ feature.
611:
612: % Table 4 goes here.
613: % Table 5 goes here.
614:
615: Table 4 presents the extracted central wavelengths, while
616: Table 5 gives the equivalent fluxes (i.e., integrated flux
617: densities), and for the acetylene band at 13.7~\mum, the
618: equivalent width. In cases where no feature is apparent
619: or the strength of the extracted feature has a S/N ratio
620: less than one, Table 4 does not quote a central wavelength.
621: Table 4 includes notes indicating those wavelengths for
622: features with S/N ratios less than 2 or 3. Results for
623: some of the comparison spectra have been published
624: recently, but the results presented here represent newer
625: S14 pipeline output and reflect modifications to the
626: continuum fitting and extraction wavelengths.
627:
628:
629: \subsection{The PAH spectra} % Sec. 2.4
630:
631: Figures 3 and 4 include the spectra of our class A and B
632: prototypes, NGC 1333 SVS 3 and HD 44179. Using these and
633: other SWS data, we find that the C--C modes produce features
634: in class A spectra with typical central wavelengths of 6.23
635: and 7.7~\mum, while class B spectra have features centered at
636: 6.26 and 7.9~\mum\ \citep[in essential agreement
637: with][]{pee02}. In the two class C spectra in the SWS
638: database, these features are shifted to 6.30 and 8.2~\mum,
639: respectively. In HD 100764, they are centered at 6.33 and
640: 8.15~\mum. In the other class C IRS sources, these features
641: appear in the 6.25--6.28 and 8.09--8.29~\mum\ ranges.
642:
643: The features beyond 10~\mum\ arise from out-of-plane C--H
644: bending modes. The wavelength of these modes depends on the
645: number of adjacent hydrogen atoms on a single aromatic ring
646: \citep[e.g.][]{atb89}. Single H atoms produce the solo mode,
647: which class A and B spectra show between 11.21 and
648: 11.30~\mum\ with a mean at 11.26~\mum. Rings with two
649: adjacent H atoms produce the duo mode, which normally appears
650: at 12.00~\mum. Three adjacent H atoms produce the trio mode
651: which appears at 12.70~\mum\ in the class A and B spectra.
652:
653: In all of the class C sources, the solo out-of-plane bending
654: mode has shifted to longer wavelengths. In the comparison
655: class C PAH spectra observed by the IRS, the features have
656: shifted from the nominal 11.26~\mum\ position to between 11.32
657: and 11.36~\mum. In the two class C spectra in the SWS database,
658: the shifts are difficult to measure due to possible effects from
659: molecular absorption and artifacts. Our best estimate places the
660: band centers in the 11.36--11.42~\mum\ range. In HD 100764 this
661: feature is centered further to the red, at 11.47~\mum.
662:
663: The duo and trio modes also appear to shift in the class C
664: spectra, but they are fainter and more difficult to measure.
665: A shift is apparent in both features in the SWS spectra of
666: AFGL 2688 and IRAS 13416, from 12.0 to $\sim$12.1--12.2~\mum\
667: for the duo mode and from 12.7 to $\sim$12.9~\mum\ for the
668: trio mode, but these results should be treated with
669: reservation. The problem is that the contrast of these
670: features is small, and their apparent strength and position
671: depend on the details of how we fit a spline to the
672: continuum. Of the IRS comparison spectra, SU Aur shows the
673: clearest duo-mode feature, but the S/N ratio is only $\sim$2
674: and the shift is minimal. The spectrum of HD 100764 shows a
675: more significant shift, but again, the S/N ratio is only
676: $\sim$2. The situation with the trio mode is similar in the
677: IRS spectra. A shift is apparent, but the uncertainties in
678: central wavelength are large.
679:
680: In summary, the positions of the PAH features in the spectrum
681: of HD 100764 are fully consistent with a class C PAH spectrum.
682: Two of the features, at 6.33 and 11.47~\mum, represent
683: extreme positions for our sample. The spectrum is definitely
684: not class A or B.
685:
686: \subsection{Other spectral features} % Sec. 2.5
687:
688: In Figures 2 and 4, the spectrum of HD 100764 shows structure
689: between the PAH features at 6.3 and 8.1~\mum\ reminiscent
690: of the features observed in emission at 6.85 and 7.25~\mum\
691: in the spectra of the HAeBe stars HD 34282 and HD 169142 by
692: \cite{slo05}. These features are most obvious in the
693: spectrum of AFGL 2688 (where they can be seen in both scan
694: directions). The carriers of the 6.85 and 7.25~\mum\
695: features have been identified as aliphatic hydrocarbons
696: \citep{chi00} and/or hydrogenated amorphous carbon
697: \citep[HAC;][]{fur99}. In HD 100764, the features are faint
698: and close to our uncertainty level. The 7.25~\mum\ feature
699: is stronger, which is a little unusual. As a consequence,
700: our identification of these features in HD 100764 is only
701: tentative. Other class C spectra also show possible spectral
702: structure in this area but with some variations. For
703: example, IRAS 13416 shows an extra feature (all three appear
704: in both scan directions). The class A and B prototypes do
705: not show the 6.85 and 7.25~\mum\ features.
706:
707: Excluding the emission features from PAHs and related
708: molecules, the remaining spectrum from HD 100764 consists of
709: a cool dust continuum, absorption due to acetylene at
710: 13.7~\mum, and a broad emission feature centered at
711: $\sim$10.6~\mum.
712:
713: The acetylene band is centered at 13.7~\mum, which is
714: typical for a carbon star in the Galactic sample, and it has
715: an equivalent width of only 0.0032 $\pm$ 0.0006~\mum, about
716: a factor of 10--20 times weaker than seen in the SWS sample
717: of Galactic carbon stars \citep{slo06}. The acetylene bands
718: are apparent in sources with optically thick dust shells,
719: indicating that the absorbing molecules are not in the
720: stellar photosphere, but instead intermixed with or above the
721: emitting dust \citep[][ and references within]{slo06}. In the
722: case of HD 100764, it is similarly likely that the acetylene
723: absorption is not from the stellar photosphere. Instead,
724: the acetylene is probably distributed in and/or above the
725: disk.
726:
727: The broad emission feature to the blue of the 11.47~\mum\
728: PAH feature can be fit reasonably well with a Gaussian
729: centered at 10.63~\mum\ with a full width at half maximum
730: of 1.37~\mum. As \cite{spe05} have explained, typical SiC
731: dust grains emit at $\sim$11.3~\mum, but larger SiC grains
732: emit predominantly at 10.8~\mum\ because the contribution
733: from the longitudinal optic at 10.8~\mum\ increases with
734: respect to the transverse optic at 11.5~\mum\ as the grain
735: size grows. \cite{slo06} may have observed this effect in
736: two carbon stars in the SMC, but they were trying to explain
737: a shift from 11.3 to 11.0~\mum. A shift past 10.8~\mum\ to
738: 10.6~\mum\ seems far less likely. We conclude that this
739: broad emission feature at 10.6~\mum\ is not likely to arise
740: from SiC; it remains unidentified.
741:
742:
743: \section{Discussion} % Sec. 3.0
744:
745: \subsection{Dependence of the PAH emission on excitation temperature} % Sec. 3.1
746:
747: \begin{figure} % Fig. 5
748: \includegraphics[width=3.5in]{f5c.eps}
749: \caption{The correlation between the central wavelength
750: (defined in \S 2.3) of the two strongest PAH features and the
751: effective temperature of the exciting star. The top panel
752: plots the position of the 7.7--8.2~\mum\ PAH complex, and the
753: bottom panel plots the position of the 11.3~\mum\ feature.
754: This figure contains three Herbig AeBe stars not included
755: in Tables 2, 4 or 5. The IRS data for these sources,
756: HD 34282, HD 141569, and HD 169142, appear elsewhere
757: \citep{slo05,kel07}. HD 135344 is the right-most square.
758: The two prototypes are NGC 1333 SVS 3 (far left) and HD 44179
759: (second to left).}
760: \end{figure}
761:
762: Table 2 gives the spectral types and effective temperatures
763: of our PAH sample. HD 100764 has been classified as R2 or
764: C1,1 \citep{san44,yam72} and has an effective temperature of
765: 4850 K \citep{dom84}. The two class C sources in the SWS
766: database appear to be post-AGB objects evolving into
767: planetary nebulae (PNe). The central star in AFGL 2688 is
768: classified as F5~Ia, and the surrounding nebulosity shows no
769: strong emission lines \citep{cra75}. IRAS 13416$-$6243 has
770: a spectral type of G1~I \citep{hu93} and also shows no
771: ionized emission \citep{kau93}\footnote{\cite{vds00} actually
772: detected Br$\gamma$ {\it absorption} at 2.17~\mum.}.
773: \cite{van89} describe it as in transition from the AGB to a
774: PN. We have determined temperatures from the spectral
775: classes for these two objects using the relation calibrated
776: by \cite{mcw91}.
777:
778: The PAH spectrum of MSX SMC 029 is best described as class C.
779: While the 6.2~\mum\ feature has not shifted much from the
780: position seen in class B, the 7--9~\mum\ PAH complex and
781: 11.3~\mum\ feature are shifted to the red. Like the post-AGB
782: objects AFGL 2688 and IRAS 13416, MSX SMC 029 shows an
783: absorption band from acetylene at 13.7~\mum. \cite{kra06}
784: argue that it is one of the few known post-AGB objects in the
785: SMC. It is unfortunate that there are no optical data to help
786: classify the spectrum of the central source.
787:
788: \cite{slo05} presented the spectra of four HAeBe stars, three
789: classified as early to mid A dwarfs, and one, HD 135344, as
790: F4 Ve \citep{dmr97}, which corresponds to an effective
791: temperature of 6590 K \citep[using the calibration of][Table
792: A5]{kh95}. The PAHs around the A dwarfs resemble class B
793: spectra, except that the 7.85~\mum\ feature is shifted
794: to 7.9--8.0~\mum, and in the F dwarf HD 135344, this feature
795: is shifted even further, to 8.08~\mum, making it intermediate
796: between class B and C. \cite{kel07} have re-examined these
797: four spectra as part of a larger sample of 18 HAeBe stars and
798: four related stars, and they confirm these previous results.
799: As a group, the HAeBe stars exhibit PAH spectra which differ
800: from the typical class B PAH spectra, with more redshifted
801: features. The coolest stars in the sample have spectra which
802: are even closer to class C. One source examined by
803: \cite{kel07} is the intermediate-mass T Tauri star SU Aur,
804: which has a spectral class of G1 and an effective temperature
805: of 5945 K \citep{cal04}. \cite{fur06} noted that while
806: silicate emission dominates its infrared spectrum, emission
807: from PAHs is apparent at 6.2~\mum\ and on the wings of the
808: 10~\mum\ silicate feature at 8 and 11.3~\mum. This source is
809: the coolest star in the sample of \cite{kel07}, and it is
810: their one source with an unambigious class C PAH spectrum.
811:
812: HD 233517 has a spectral type of K2~III \citep{fek96}, an
813: effective temperature of 4475 K \citep{bal00}, and in the
814: infrared, a class C PAH spectrum. It is the coolest object
815: in our comparison sample, and the center of its 7--9~\mum\
816: PAH complex is also at the longest wavelength observed.
817:
818: By comparison, the class A and B prototypes are warmer.
819: NGC 1333 SVS 3 has a spectral class of B6 \citep{hwj84},
820: which corresponds to an effective temperature of 14000 K
821: \citep{kh95}. HD 44179 has a spectral type of A0 III
822: \citep{coh75}, corresponding to 9520 K \citep{kh95}. While
823: a range of temperatures have been used to model the Red
824: Rectangle, we adopt 9520 K as most consistent with the
825: optical spectral class. %\cite{vih06} use a value of 8250 K.
826:
827: Figure 5 plots the positions of the PAH features as a function
828: of the effective temperature of the exciting source. In
829: addition to the comparison sample in Tables 2, 4, and 5,
830: the figure also includes the HAeBe stars HD 34282, HD 141569,
831: and HD 169142. \cite{slo05} first published the IRS spectra
832: of these sources, and the results presented here are from the
833: more recent analysis by \cite{kel07}. The correlation of
834: the position of the 7.7--8.2~\mum\ PAH complex with
835: effective temperature is impressive. While the 11.3~\mum\
836: PAH feature also tends to shift to longer wavelength as the
837: temperature decreases, the trend is not so clear, with little
838: difference between the class A and B sources and more
839: scatter in the class C sources.
840:
841: \subsection{Spatial dependence of the PAHs in extended sources} % Sec. 3.2
842:
843: In the original PAH model, ultraviolet radiation was required
844: to excite the UIR emission features \citep[e.g.][]{atb89}.
845: Observations by \citet[][ 2000]{uch98} first observed PAH
846: emission in cooler radiation fields, with effective
847: temperatures as low as 6800 K in the case of the reflection
848: nebula vdB 133. While these observations initially cast some
849: doubt on the PAH model, \cite{ld02} showed that the absorption
850: of visible photons by large or ionized PAHs can produce the
851: observed UIR features.
852:
853: Since PAH emission often arises in a photo-dissociation
854: region (PDR), where a front is eating its way into a denser
855: region and destroying the PAHs in the process, one might
856: expect a change in the nature of the PAH spectrum as the
857: temperature of the exciting radiation field varies.
858: \cite{uch00} did not observe variation in the relative
859: strengths of the features in their sample, but they did
860: observe a change in the shape of the 7--9~\mum\ PAH complex.
861:
862: \cite{bt05} analyzed the shape of the 7--9~\mum\ complex as
863: a function of position within the reflection nebulae vdB 133,
864: NGC 1333 SVS 3, and vdB 17 (also within NGC 1333). They
865: found that closer to the exciting star, the strength of the
866: 7.65~\mum\ component increases relative to the 7.85~\mum\
867: component, thus shifting the measured center of the
868: 7.7--7.9~\mum\ PAH feature to the blue. They also found that
869: this complex grows stronger relative to the C--H modes at
870: longer wavelengths near the exciting sources, and suggested
871: that the wavelength shift at 7.7--7.9~\mum\ might be related
872: either to the ionization fraction of the PAHs or to PAH
873: processing by the radiation field, as previously proposed
874: by \cite{hon01}.
875:
876: %KK - raise distinction between UV hardness and UV intensity
877:
878: \subsection{The possible role of aliphatics} % Sec. 3.3
879:
880: Hydrocarbons can exist in both aromatic or aliphatic
881: forms. Aromatic hydrocarbons are dominated by sp$^2$ bonds
882: which produce the polycyclic ring structure that define
883: PAHs. Aliphatics include sp$^1$ bonds as seen in acetylene
884: and sp$^3$ bonds as seen in methane and longer alkane chains.
885: The sp$^2$ bonds efficiently spread the energy absorbed from
886: a photon over the entire molecule before it can disrupt a
887: single bond, making the aromatic carbon structure in PAHs
888: more stable than aliphatic bonding structures. Thus, when a
889: mixture of aliphatic and amorphous hydrocarbons is exposed to
890: a harsh radiation environment, we expect the aliphatic bonds
891: to be broken first. We propose that the class C spectra
892: arise from mixtures of aromatic and aliphatic material that
893: have not yet been subjected to intense ultraviolet radiation,
894: allowing the more fragile aliphatic bonds to survive.
895:
896: Consider the class C spectrum of MSX SMC 029. This source
897: also shows a strong absorption band from acetylene
898: (C$_2$H$_2$) at 13.7~\mum\ centered within a broader
899: absorption band in the 12--16~\mum\ region \citep[see][Fig.
900: 4]{kra06}. \cite{kra06} argue that this broader band
901: is due to other aliphatic molecules seen in a similar
902: spectrum at higher spectral resolution in SMP LMC 11, a
903: source in Large Magellanic Cloud in transition to the early
904: planetary nebula stage \citep[][Fig. 1]{jbs06}. Acetylene
905: appears in other class C PAH spectra, including AFGL 2688,
906: IRAS 13146, and our spectrum of HD 100764\footnote{It is
907: missing from HD 233517, which is an oxygen-rich source, and
908: the disks around HD 135344 and SU Aur.}. The association of
909: the acetylene absorption band at 13.7~\mum\ and the broader
910: 12--16~\mum\ absorption with class C PAH emission is
911: consistent with our proposal that the class C spectra arise
912: from mixtures of PAHs and aliphatics.
913:
914: The ground-based mid-infrared spectrum of HD 56126
915: (IRAS 07134+1005) shows red-shifted PAH features similar to
916: our IRS spectrum of HD 100764, with emission both in a
917: plateau at 8.0--8.2~\mum\ and from out-of-plane bending modes
918: at 11.4 and 12.2~\mum\ \citep{jus96}. Although not as
919: pronounced, the infrared spectra of IRAS 04296+3429 and
920: IRAS 05341+0852 display similar unusual characteristics.
921: All three of these sources are post-AGB objects. HD 56126
922: is classified as F5 I \citep{nas65}, while IRAS 05341 and
923: IRAS 04296 are F4 Iab: and G0 Ia, respectively. These
924: sources also show unusual spectra in the 3~\mum\ range, which
925: is dominated by C--H stretching modes. IRAS 05341 shows a
926: feature at 3.40~\mum\ that dominates the normally stronger
927: feature at 3.29~\mum\ \citep{gv90}, while IRAS 04296 also
928: shows an unusually strong 3.40~\mum\ component
929: \citep{geb92}. The 3.29~\mum\ feature arises from an
930: aromatic C--H stretching mode \citep[e.g.][]{dw81,atb89},
931: while the 3.4~\mum\ feature arises from a similar mode in
932: aliphatic C--H bonds \citep{dw81,jm90,geb94}.
933:
934: In the Orion Bar, \cite{geb89} observed an increase in the
935: ratio of the aliphatic 3.4~\mum\ feature to the aromatic
936: 3.29~\mum\ feature in the shielded molecular zone compared
937: with the ionized zone. \cite{slo97} verified these
938: observations with long-slit 3~\mum\ spectroscopy and showed
939: that the 3.4~\mum\ feature actually arises from multiple
940: aliphatic components. \cite{job96} obtained spatially
941: resolved 3~\mum\ spectroscopy in the reflection nebulae
942: NGC 1333 and NGC 2023 and found that where the ultraviolet
943: radiation field was less intense, the 3.4~\mum\ feature is
944: stronger compared to the 3.29~\mum\ feature. All of these
945: authors argued that the radiation field is altering an
946: initial mix of aliphatic and aromatic bonds by destroying the
947: more fragile aliphatic bonds.
948:
949: %(HD 56126 and IRAS 04296 also show a strong 21~\mum\ feature.)
950:
951: \subsection{Hydrogenated amorphous carbon} % Sec. 3.4
952:
953: \begin{figure} % Fig. 6
954: \includegraphics[width=3.5in]{f6c.eps}
955: \caption{A laboratory spectrum of hydrogenated amorphous
956: carbon heated to 800 K\citep{sco97}. The two portions of
957: the spectrum separated by the vertical hatched line at
958: 7.5~\mum\ were obtained separately and have been arbitrarily
959: normalized here to the same vertical range. The apparent
960: relative strengths of the two halves are not meaningful. The
961: positions of the bands, however, are a good indication of
962: how the wavelengths of the various modes responsible
963: for the observed PAH features may shift as aliphatic bonds
964: are attached to the aromatic hydrocarbons that form the
965: basis of free PAH molecules. Specifically, the two strongest
966: features at 6.32 and 11.45~\mum\ have shifted from 6.23 and
967: 11.26~\mum\ in more normal PAH spectra. The vertical lines
968: mark the positions of the 6.85 and 7.25~\mum\ features
969: seen in spectra of cooler HAC samples.}
970: \end{figure}
971:
972: Hydrogenated amorphous carbon (HAC) is a generic name for a
973: mixture of aliphatic and aromatic carbon, consisting of
974: PAH clusters embedded within a matrix of aliphatically bonded
975: material \citep[see ][ and references therein]{jdw90}. This
976: description is similar to the material we are proposing to
977: explain the class C PAH spectra.
978:
979: Compared to previously obtained class C PAH spectra,
980: HD 100764 represents an extreme case because its features are
981: more consistently red-shifted and its exciting radiation field
982: is one of the coolest known. The PAHs around this source must
983: be relatively unprocessed by energetic photons, making this
984: source an excellent candidate for the presence of HAC-like
985: structures.
986:
987: Figure 6 shows two representative laboratory spectra of a HAC
988: sample at $\sim$ 800 K \citep{sco97}. HAC films with a
989: thickness of $\sim$1~\mum\ were prepared by ablating graphite
990: in a hydrogen atmosphere with an excimer laser as reported
991: previously \citep{sd96,sdj97}. Films were deposited on a
992: stainless steel substrate, placed in a vacuum chamber, and
993: heated by conduction to $\sim$800 K. Infrared emission
994: spectra were obtained with a % Bomem MB-100
995: Fourier-transform spectrometer at a resolution of 4 cm$^{-1}$
996: over a spectra range of 500--6000 cm$^{-1}$ (1.7--20~\mum).
997: The spectra were calibrated by taking the ratio of the
998: emission from HAC to that of an uncoated stainless steel
999: substrate at the same temperatures and making a cubic
1000: polynomial baseline correction. The two spectral segments
1001: from 5.5 to 8.0 and 7.5 to 14~\mum\ in Figure 6 were obtained
1002: separately and their relative intensities are unknown. We
1003: have simply scaled both segments to a maximum of 1.0
1004: arbitrarily in the figure.
1005:
1006: While the relative band strengths in Figure 6 are not well
1007: determined, the positions are more clear. The emission
1008: features have shifted to the red, with the nominal 6.23 and
1009: 11.26~\mum\ features appearing at 6.32 and 11.45~\mum,
1010: respectively. If the features in the 12--13~\mum\ range can
1011: be attributed to the duo and trio C--H out-of-plane bending
1012: modes, then they have shifted from 11.99 and 12.67~\mum\ to
1013: 12.39 and 13.43~\mum. The feature centered at 8.53~\mum\
1014: could be a red-shifted C--C mode, or it could simply be the
1015: C--H in-plane bending mode. This laboratory HAC spectrum
1016: is consistent with the wavelength shifts we have observed in
1017: class C PAH sources.
1018:
1019: \subsection{PAHs, HAC, and the class C spectrum} % Sec. 3.5.
1020:
1021: \begin{figure} % Fig. 7
1022: \includegraphics[width=3.5in]{f7c.eps}
1023: \caption{Laboratory spectra of two simple PAHs: naphthalene
1024: and benzene with two adjacent methyl side groups
1025: \citep[from][]{cob05}. The subsitution of aliphatic
1026: sidegroups on benzene adds a second C--H stretching mode
1027: at 3.4~\mum, produces a strong absorption at 6.8~\mum,
1028: shifts the quartet out-of-plane C--H bending mode from
1029: 12.8 to 13.5~\mum, and produces more spectral structure
1030: in the vicinity of the observed 6.85 and 7.25~\mum\
1031: aliphatic features (indicated with solid vertical lines).}
1032: \end{figure}
1033:
1034: Bonds in aromatic and aliphatic species have resonances at
1035: different wavelengths \citep[see][ and the many references
1036: therein]{bel78}. In the case of the C--H stretching
1037: fundamental, the shift from aromatic to aliphatic is always
1038: to the red, from 3.29 to 3.40~\mum, but for other vibrational
1039: modes, the shifts can be in either direction, or both,
1040: depending on the molecules in question. We hypothesize that
1041: at longer wavelengths, the substitution of aliphatic
1042: sidegroups on the edges of large PAH molecules shifts the
1043: out-of-plane aromatic bending modes to the red. While
1044: laboratory data of large PAHs with aliphatic substitutions
1045: are lacking, data for some of the simplest PAHs are
1046: available, and as Figure 7 shows, are consistent with our
1047: hypothesis.
1048:
1049: Using data from the NIST Chemistry WebBook, maintained by the
1050: National Institute for Standards and Technology \footnote{At
1051: http://webbook.nist.gov/chemistry/}, we show in Figure 7 the
1052: spectra of naphthalene and 1,2-dimethylbenzene, which is
1053: benzene with two adjacent subsitutions of methyl sidegroups.
1054: The two spectra in Figure 7 were obtained from vapor samples
1055: using a Fourier-transform infrared spectrometer at a
1056: resolution of 4 cm$^{-1}$ \citep{cob05}. The napthalene
1057: was at a temperature of 518 K, while the 1,2-dimethylbenzene
1058: was at 423 K. Since both molecules have four adjacent H
1059: atoms on each ring, the only out-of-plane C--H bending mode
1060: they show in the 11--14~\mum\ region is the quartet mode.
1061: This mode has shifted from 12.8~\mum\ in naphthalene to
1062: 13.5~\mum\ in the simpler benzene molecule with the methyl
1063: sidegroups, consistent with the anticipated effect of the %%% REFERENCE?
1064: substitution of a methyl sidegroup. However, this spectral
1065: difference may also result from the absence of the second
1066: ring in naphthalene, making further analysis of larger
1067: molecules highly desirable.
1068:
1069: We also note that the presence of aliphatic C--H stretching
1070: modes in the methyl sidegroups on the benzene molecule has
1071: added emission at 3.4~\mum\ not present in the naphthalene.
1072: Furthermore, in the 6--8~\mum\ region, the strongest emisson
1073: feature in naphthalene is at 6.6~\mum, but a stronger feature
1074: at 6.8~\mum\ is apparent in the methyl-substituted benzene.
1075: As described by \cite{bel78} the carbon skeletal breathing
1076: modes in aromatics cluster in the 6.2 to 6.9~\mum\ range
1077: while similar modes from methyl (CH$_3$) and methylene
1078: (CH$_2$) groups cluster in the 6.8--7.5~\mum\ region. As
1079: noted in \S2.4, we may have detected these methyl and
1080: methylene features in emission in some of the class C
1081: PAH spectra, including HD 100764.
1082:
1083: Laboratory HAC spectra by \cite{fur99} clearly show emission
1084: features at 6.85 and 7.25~\mum. The HAC spectrum in Figure 6
1085: only shows a single emission feature at 7.0~\mum\ at about
1086: half the strength of the 6.3~\mum\ feature. The differences
1087: in the spectra probably arise in how the samples were treated
1088: and measured. \cite{fur99} obtained absorption spectra from
1089: samples at 300 K, while the HAC spectrum in Figure 6 was
1090: observed in emission at $\sim$800 K. This higher temperature
1091: has probably modified the simple groups responsible for the
1092: 6.85 and 7.25~\mum\ features, and it has also enhanced the
1093: C$-$C modes at 6.2~\mum.
1094:
1095: % AL suggests we give the H/C ratio
1096:
1097: HAC samples have a number of degrees of freedom, including
1098: the ratio of aliphatic and aromatic bonds and the size
1099: distribution and structure of the embedded PAHs among others,
1100: so it is not surprising that no HAC sample matches the
1101: observed astrophysical spectra in detail. It is worth
1102: recalling that no laboratory PAH spectrum provides a precise
1103: match to astrophysical PAH spectra either. Available data
1104: are consistent with the hypothesis that increasing the ratio
1105: of aliphatic to aromatic bonds in a hydrocarbon mixture
1106: explains the differences between class B and class C PAH
1107: spectra.
1108:
1109: We propose that complex astrophysical hydrocarbons are
1110: originally synthesized as some form of HAC. When this
1111: material is exposed to harsh radiation fields, the aliphatic
1112: bonds are destroyed and only free PAHs remain. \cite{sdp97}
1113: provide evidence that this process could occur. They exposed
1114: HAC mixtures to UV radiation and found that the dissolution
1115: of the HAC led to the production of large PAH molecules with
1116: attached aliphatic sidegroups. \cite{hu06} have recently
1117: shown that these mixtures of aromatic and aliphatic bonds
1118: have the potential for reproducing the observed features
1119: in the 6--9~\mum\ range. These modified PAHs have less than
1120: a few hundred atoms and still respond to the absorption of
1121: single photons like more typical free PAHs do.
1122:
1123: Two separate processes are responsible for the PAH spectra
1124: we observe. First, the PAHs must be freed from the aliphatic
1125: matrix in which they are initially embedded. Second, the
1126: features must be excited. This latter step requires less
1127: energy than that needed to completely strip the PAHs of all
1128: aliphatic side-chains. The positions of the observed PAH
1129: features depend on how completely the PAHs have been freed
1130: from the underlying matrix. In the class C PAH sources, the
1131: aliphatic side groups have only been partially destroyed.
1132:
1133: The sample of isolated HAeBe stars represent a stage in the
1134: evolution of PAHs between class C and class B. The
1135: 7.85~\mum\ feature is shifted measurably to 7.9--8.0~\mum\ or
1136: beyond \citep{slo05,kel07}. Here again, the PAHs may not be
1137: entirely stripped from the underlying aliphatic matrix, since
1138: the A and F stars exciting the PAH spectrum may not produce
1139: enough photons with sufficient energy to break all of the
1140: aliphatic bonds.
1141:
1142: \subsection{The problem of the reflection nebulae} % Sec. 3.6
1143:
1144: RNe typically do not show class C PAH spectra, even though
1145: the exciting source can be as cool as 6800 K \citep{uch98}.
1146: The two RNe in the sample examined by \cite{pee02} are both
1147: class A, as are the three spectra presented by \cite{uch00}.
1148: The objects studied by \cite{bt05} include one from
1149: Uchida et al., and all three showed variations in the
1150: position of the 7.7--7.9~\mum\ feature with radiation
1151: field, but not enough to move them even as far as a true
1152: class B spectrum.
1153:
1154: We suggest that while the PAHs in these complex, evolving
1155: environments are now subject only to cool radiation fields,
1156: they may have been exposed in the recent past to a large
1157: dose of more intense ultraviolet radiation. RNe are
1158: typically diffuse and are associated with complicated
1159: star-forming environments. This diffuse nature means that
1160: the PAHs are poorly shielded from both current and past
1161: radiation fields. Furthermore, PAHs in a diffuse environment
1162: are not able to regenerate any broken aliphatic bands.
1163:
1164: %While reflection nebulae may be the strongest example of
1165: %the interplay of the processing and excitation mechanisms
1166: %necessary for PAH emission, it is unlikely that they are the
1167: %only example.
1168: The typical PAH emission source is a PDR in a star formation
1169: region, and the emitting materials in these environments must
1170: have a complicated history of UV irradiation. This history
1171: blurs the link between the current PAH composition and the
1172: current radiation field, which is probably why the
1173: correlation illustrated in Fig. 5 has not been noticed
1174: before. Only in more isolated sources such as those examined
1175: here is the link clear.
1176:
1177:
1178: \section{Conclusions} % Sec. 4.0
1179:
1180: The PAH spectrum of HD 100764 adds to the small, but growing
1181: sample of class C PAH spectra, as defined by \cite{pee02}.
1182: It has one of the coolest exciting stars and some of the
1183: most redshifted features in the class. Since all
1184: seven of the known class C spectra are excited by relatively
1185: cool stars of spectral class F or later, we argue that the
1186: hydrocarbons in these systems are unusual because they have
1187: not been exposed to much ultraviolet radiation.
1188:
1189: We hypothesize that carbonaceous materials are synthesized as
1190: large HAC conglomerates, and that aliphatic bonds are
1191: subsequently broken in harsh radiation fields. We suggest
1192: that PAH spectra evolve over time; the hydrocarbons in
1193: class C objects are relatively protected and unprocessed
1194: while class B and A PAHs have been exposed to more energetic
1195: photons and are more processed.
1196:
1197:
1198: \acknowledgments
1199:
1200: We are grateful to the referee, whose careful reading and
1201: thoughtful comments led to considerable improvements in the
1202: manuscript. We would also like to thank T. Geballe and
1203: P. Roche for useful comments and suggestions and M. Werner
1204: for generously providing us with his high-resolution spectra
1205: of HD 100764. These observations were made with the {\it
1206: Spitzer Space Telescope}, which is operated by JPL, California
1207: Institute of Technology, under NASA contract 1407 and
1208: supported by NASA through JPL (contract 1257184). Support for
1209: this work was provided by NASA through contract 960803 issued
1210: by JPL/Caltech. WMD is supported by a grant from the NSERC
1211: of Canada. AL is supported in part by the NASA/{\it Spitzer}
1212: theory program. This research has made use of the SIMBAD
1213: database and VizieR tool for catalog access, operated at the
1214: Centre de Données astronomiques de Strasbourg.
1215:
1216:
1217: \begin{thebibliography}{}
1218:
1219: \bibitem[Alksnis et al.(1998)]{alk98} Alksnis, A., Balklavs, A.,
1220: Dzervitis, U., \& Eglitis, I. 1998, \aap, 338, 209
1221: \bibitem[Allamandola et al.(1999)]{ahs99} Allamandola, L.~J., Hudgins,
1222: D.~M., \& Sandford, S.~A. 1999, \apj, L115
1223: \bibitem[Allamandola et al.(1985)]{atb85} Allamandola, L.~J., Tielens,
1224: A.~G.~G.~M., \& Barker, J.~R. 1985, \apj, 290, L25
1225: \bibitem[Allamandola et al.(1989)]{atb89} Allamandola, L.~J., Tielens,
1226: A.~G.~G.~M., \& Barker, J.~R. 1989, \apjs, 71, 733
1227: \bibitem[Balachandran et al.(2000)]{bal00} Balachandran, S.~C., Fekel, F.~C.,
1228: Henry, G.~W., \& Uitenbroek, H. 2000, ApJ, 542, 978
1229: \bibitem[Bellamy(1978)]{bel78} Bellamy, L.~J. 1978, The Infra-Red Spectra
1230: of Complex Molecules (London: Chapman \& Hall)
1231: \bibitem[Bernard-Salas et al.(2006)]{jbs06} Bernard-Salas, J., Peeters, E.,
1232: Sloan, G.~C., Cami, J., \& Houck, J.~R. 2006, \apj, 652, L29
1233: \bibitem[Bouwman et al.(2001)]{bou01} Bouwman, J., Meeus, G., de Koter, A.,
1234: Hony, S., Dominik, C., \& Waters, L.~B.~F.~M. 2001, \aap, 375, 950
1235: \bibitem[Bregman \& Temi(2005)]{bt05} Bregman, J. \& Temi, P. 2005,
1236: \apj, 621, 831
1237: \bibitem[Calvet et al.(2004)]{cal04} Calvet, N., Muzerolle, J.; Brice\~{n}o,
1238: C., Hern\'{a}ndez, J., Hartmann, L., Saucedo, J.~L., \& Gordon, K.~D.
1239: 2004, \aj, 128, 1294
1240: \bibitem[Chiar et al.(2000)]{chi00} Chiar, J.~E., Tielens, A.~G.~G.~M.,
1241: Whittet, D.~C.~B., Schutte, W.~A., Boogert, A.~C.~A., Lutz, D., van
1242: Dishoeck, E.~F., \& Bernstein, M.~P. 2000, \apj, 537, 749
1243: \bibitem[Coblentz Society, Inc.(2005)]{cob05} Coblentz Society, Inc. 2005,
1244: in NIST Chemistry WebBook, NIST Standard Reference Database Number 69,
1245: ed. P.~J. Linstrom \& W.~G. Mallard, (Gaithersburg, MD: National
1246: Institute of Standards and Technology, http://webbook.nist.gov)
1247: \bibitem[Cohen et al.(1975)]{coh75} Cohen, M., et al. 1975, \apj, 196, 179
1248: \bibitem[Crampton et al.(1975)]{cra75} Crampton, D., Cowley, A.~P.,
1249: \& Humphreys, R.~M. 1975, \apj, 198, L135
1250: \bibitem[Dominy(1984)]{dom84} Dominy, J.~F. 1984, \apjs, 55, 27
1251: \bibitem[Duley \& Williams(1981)]{dw81} Duley, W.~W. \& Williams, D.~A.
1252: 1981, \mnras, 196, 269
1253: \bibitem[Dunkin et al.(1997)]{dmr97} Dunkin, S.~K., Barlow, M.~J., \&
1254: Ryan, S.~G. 1997, \mnras, 286, 604
1255: %\bibitem[Engelke(1992)]{eng92} Engelke, C.~W. 1992, \aj, 104, 1248
1256: \bibitem[Fekel et al.(1996)]{fek96} Fekel, F.~C., Webb, R.~A., White,
1257: R.~J., \& Zuckerman, B. 1996, \apj, 462, L95
1258: \bibitem[Furlan et al.(2006)]{fur06} Furlan, E., Hartmann, L., Calvet, N.,
1259: D'Alessio, P., Franco-Hern\'{a}ndez, R., Forrest, W.~J., Watson, D.~M.,
1260: Uchida, K.~I.; Sargent, B., Green, J.~D., Keller, L.~D., \& Herter, T.~L.
1261: 2006, \apjs, 165, 568
1262: \bibitem[Furton et al.(1999)]{fur99} Furton, D.~G., Laiho, J.~W., \&
1263: Witt, A.~N. 1999, \apj, 526, 752
1264: \bibitem[Geballe et al.(1994)]{geb94} Geballe, T.~R., Joblin, C.,
1265: d'Hendecourt, L.~B., Jourdain de Muizon, M., Tielens, A.~G.~G.~M.,
1266: \& Leger, A. 1994, \apj, 434, L15
1267: \bibitem[Geballe et al.(1989)]{geb89} Geballe, T.~R., Tielens, A.~G.~G.~M.,
1268: Allamandola, L.~J., Moorhouse, A., \& Brand, P.~W.~J.~L. 1989, \apj, 341, 278
1269: \bibitem[Geballe et al.(1992)]{geb92} Geballe, T.~R., Tielens, A.~G.~G.~M.,
1270: Kwok, S., \& Hrivnak, B.~J. 1992, ApJ, 387, L89
1271: \bibitem[Geballe \& van der Veen(1990)]{gv90} Geballe, T.~R. \& van der Veen,
1272: W.~E.~C.~J. 1990, \aap, 235, 9
1273: \bibitem[Gillett et al.(1973)]{gfm73} Gillett, F.~C., Forrest, W.~J., \&
1274: Merrill, K.~M. 1973, \apj, 183, 87
1275: \bibitem[Harvey et al.(1984)]{hwj84} Harvey, P.~M., Wilking, B.~A., \& Joy, M.
1276: 1984, \apj, 278, 156
1277: \bibitem[Hony et al.(2001)]{hon01} Hony, S., Van Kerckhoven, C.,
1278: Peeters, E., Tielens, A.~G.~G.~M., \& Allamandola, L.~J. 2001, \aap,
1279: 370, 1030
1280: \bibitem[Houck et al.(2004)]{hou04} Houck, J.~R., et al. 2004, \apjs,
1281: 154, 18
1282: \bibitem[Hu et al.(1993)]{hu93} Hu, J.~Y., Slijkhuis, S., de Jong, T., \&
1283: Jiang, B.~W. 1993, \aaps, 100, 413
1284: \bibitem[Hu et al.(2006)]{hu06} Hu, A., Alkhesho, I., \& Duley, W.~W. 2006,
1285: \apj, 653, L157
1286: %\bibitem[Jaschek \& Jaschek(1987)]{jj87} Jaschek, C. \& Jaschek, M.
1287: % 1987, The Classification of Stars (Cambridge: Univ. of Cambridge Press)
1288: \bibitem[Joblin et al.(1996)]{job96} Joblin, C., Tielens, A.~G.~G.~M.,
1289: Allamandola, L.~J., \& Geballe, T.~R. 1996, \apj, 458, 610
1290: \bibitem[Jones et al.(1990)]{jdw90} Jones, A.~P., Duley, W.~W., \&
1291: Williams, D.~A. 1990, QJRAS, 31, 567
1292: \bibitem[Jourdain de Muizon et al.(1990)]{jm90} Jourdain de Muizon, M.,
1293: d'Hendecourt, L.~B., \& Geballe, T.~R. 1990, \aap, 235, 367
1294: \bibitem[Jura(2003)]{jur03} Jura, M. 2003, \apj, 582, 1032
1295: %\bibitem[Jura(2003b)]{jur03b} Jura, M. 2003b, \apj, 584, L91
1296: \bibitem[Jura et al.(2006)]{jur06} Jura, M., Bohac, C.~J., Forrest, W.~J.,
1297: Green, J., Watson, D.~M., Sloan, G.~C., Markwick-Kemper, F., \&
1298: Najita, J. 2006, \apj, 637, L45
1299: %\bibitem[Jura et al.(2002)]{jur02} Jura, M., Chen, C., \& Plavchan, P.
1300: % 2002, \apj, 574, 963
1301: \bibitem[Justtanont et al.(1996)]{jus96} Justtanont, K., Barlow, M.~J.,
1302: Skinner, C.~J., Roche, P.~F, Aitken, D.~K., \& Smith, C.H. 1996, \aap,
1303: 309, 612
1304: \bibitem[K\"{a}ufl et al.(1993)]{kau93} K\"{a}ufl, H.~U., Renzini, A., \&
1305: Stanghellini, L. 1993, \apj, 410, 251
1306: \bibitem[Keller et al.(2007)]{kel07} Keller, L.~D., et al. 2007, \apj,
1307: almost submitted (really)
1308: \bibitem[Kenyon \& Hartmann(1995)]{kh95} Kenyon, S.~J. \& Hartmann, L. 1995,
1309: \apjs, 101, 117
1310: \bibitem[Kraemer et al.(2006)]{kra06} Kraemer, K.~E., Sloan, G.~C.,
1311: Bernard-Salas, J., Price, S.~D., Egan, M.~P., \& Wood, P.~R. 2006,
1312: \apj, 652, L25
1313: \bibitem[Leger \& Puget(1984)]{lp84} Leger, A. \& Puget, J.~L. 1984, \aap,
1314: 137, L5
1315: \bibitem[Li \& Draine(2002)]{ld02} Li, A. \& Draine, B.~T. 2002, \apj, 572, 232
1316: \bibitem[Lloyd Evans(1990)]{le90} Lloyd Evans, T. 1990, \mnras, 342, 336
1317: \bibitem[LeVan et al.(1992)]{lev92} LeVan, P.~D., Sloan, G.~C.,
1318: Little-Marenin, I.~R., \& Grasdalen, G.~L. 1992, \apj, 392, 702
1319: \bibitem[McClure(1997)]{mcc97} McClure, R.~D. 1997, \pasp, 109, 256
1320: \bibitem[McWilliam(1991)]{mcw91} McWilliam, A. 1991, \aj, 101, 1065
1321: \bibitem[Nassau et al.(1965)]{nas65} Nassau, J.~J., Stephenson, C.~B.,
1322: \& MacConnell, D.~J. 1965, in Luminous Stars in the Northern Milky Way 6
1323: (Hamburg: Hamburg Sternwarte and Warner and Swasey Observatory)
1324: %\bibitem[NIST(2005)]{nist05} National Institute of Standards and Technology
1325: % 2005, NIST Chemistry WebBook: NIST Standard Reference Database No. 69
1326: % (available at http://webbook.nist.gov/chemistry/)
1327: \bibitem[Parthasarathy(1991)]{par91} Parthasarathy, M. 1991, \aap, 247, 429
1328: \bibitem[Peeters et al.(2002)]{pee02} Peeters, E., Hony, S., Van
1329: Kerckhoven, C., Tielens, A.~G.~G.~M., Allamandola, L.~J.; Hudgins,
1330: D.~M., \& Bauschlicher, C.~W. 2002, \aap, 390, 1089
1331: %\bibitem[Pendleton \& Allamandola(2002)]{pa02} Pendleton, Y.~J. \&
1332: % Allamandola, L.~J. 2002, \apjs, 138, 75
1333: %\bibitem[Perryman et al.(1997)]{hip97} Perryman, M.~A.~C. et al. 1997,
1334: % \aap, 323, L49
1335: %\bibitem[Ridgway et al.(1980)]{ri80} Ridgway, S.~T., Joyce, R.~R., White,
1336: % N.~M., \& Wing, R.~F. 1980, \apj, 235, 126
1337: \bibitem[Sanford(1944)]{san44} Sanford, R.~F. 1944, \apj, 99, 145
1338: \bibitem[Scott(1997)]{sco97} Scott, A. 1997, Ph.D. Thesis, Univ. Waterloo,
1339: Walterloo, Ontario
1340: \bibitem[Scott \& Duley(1996)]{sd96} Scott, A. \& Duley, W.~W. 1996, \apj,
1341: 472, L123
1342: \bibitem[Scott et al.(1997a)]{sdp97} Scott, A., Duley, W.~W., \& Pinho,
1343: G.~P. 1997a, \apj, 489, L189
1344: \bibitem[Scott et al.(1997b)]{sdj97} Scott, A., Duley, W.~W., \& Jahani,
1345: H.~R. 1997b, \apj, 490, L175
1346: %\bibitem[Seahra \& Duley(2000)]{sd00} Seahra, S.~S. \& Duley, W.~W. 2000,
1347: % \apj, 542, 898
1348: \bibitem[Skinner(1994)]{ski94} Skinner, C.~J. 1994, \mnras, 271, 300
1349: \bibitem[Sloan et al.(1997)]{slo97} Sloan, G.~C., Bregman, J.~D., Geballe,
1350: T.~R., Allamandola, L.~J., \& Woodward, C.~E. 1997, \apj, 474, 735
1351: \bibitem[Sloan et al.(2003)]{slo03} Sloan, G.~C., Kraemer, K.~E.,
1352: Price, S.~D., \& Shipman, R.~F. 2003, \apjs, 147, 379
1353: \bibitem[Sloan et al.(2005)]{slo05} Sloan, G.~C., et al. 2005,
1354: \apj, 632, 956
1355: \bibitem[Sloan et al.(2006)]{slo06} Sloan, G.~C., Kraemer, K.~E., Matsuura,
1356: M., Wood, P.~R., Price, S.~D., \& Egan, M.~P. 2006, \apj, 645, 1118
1357: \bibitem[Sloan et al.(2007)]{slo07} Sloan, G.~C., et al. 2007,
1358: almost submitted
1359: \bibitem[Speck et al.(2005)]{spe05} Speck, A.~K., Thompson, G.~D., \&
1360: Hofmeister, A.~M. 2005, \apj, 634, 426
1361: \bibitem[Uchida et al.(1998)]{uch98} Uchida, K.~I., Sellgren, K., \& Werner,
1362: M. 1998, \apj, 493, 109
1363: \bibitem[Uchida et al.(2000)]{uch00} Uchida, K.~I., Sellgren, K.,
1364: Werner, M.~W., \& Houdashelt, M.~L. 2000, \apj, 530, 817
1365: \bibitem[van der Veen et al.(1989)]{van89} van der Veen, W.~E.~C.~J.,
1366: Habing, H.~J., \& Geballe, T.~R. 1989, \aap, 226, 108
1367: \bibitem[Van de Steene et al.(2000)]{vds00} Van de Steene, G.~C., van Hoof,
1368: P.~A.~M., \& Wood, P.~R. 2000, \aap, 362, 984
1369: %\bibitem[Vijh et al.(2006)]{vij06} Vijh, U.~P., Witt, A.~N., York, D.~G.,
1370: % Dwarkadas, V.~V., Woodgate, B.~E., \& Palunas, P. 2006, \apj, 653, 1336
1371: \bibitem[Werner et al.(2004)]{wer04} Werner, M.~W., et al. 2004,
1372: \apjs, 154, 1
1373: \bibitem[Yamashita(1972)]{yam72} Yamashita, Y. 1972, Ann. Tokyo. Astr. Obs.,
1374: 13, 169 % or 1975, 15, 47
1375: \end{thebibliography}
1376:
1377: \end{document}
1378: