1: % file: dustygals.tex
2: %
3: %
4: %************************AASTEX v5.0***********************
5: %
6: %
7: % AASTEX v5.0 commands:
8: % DOCUMENT STYLE COMMANDS
9: %
10: % GENERAL ARTICLE STYLE with emulateapj5 option:
11: %\documentclass[preprint]{aastex}
12: %\documentclass{emulateapj}
13: %\usepackage{emulateapj5}
14: %
15: %
16: % TWO-COLUMN PREPRINT SUBSTYLE
17: %\documentclass[preprint2]{aastex}
18: %
19: % GENERAL ARTICLE STYLE
20: %\documentclass[preprint]{aastex}
21: %
22: %
23: % WORKING MANUSCRIPT STYLE (text extends over the full page)
24: % AND STYLE FOR ELECTRONIC SUBMISSION
25: % don't use this: \documentclass[manuscript]{aastex}
26: %***
27: %\documentclass[12pt,preprint]{aastex}
28: \documentclass{emulateapj}
29: %***
30: %
31: % APJ PREPRINT STYLE (text is split into two half pages)
32: %\documentstyle[aaspp4]{article}
33:
34: %************ added to help zippy get the margins right
35: %\setlength{\oddsidemargin}{.0in}
36: %\setlength{\evensidemargin}{.0in}
37: %\setlength{\topmargin}{.40in}
38: %\setlength{\topmargin}{.5in}
39: %\setlength{\topmargin}{.75in}
40: %\setlength{\textwidth}{6.5in}
41: %\setlength{\textheight}{8.in}
42: %************
43:
44:
45: % set up some macros (based on ``TEX by Example'' page 131):
46: \def\stacksymbols #1#2#3#4{\def\theguybelow{#2}
47: \def\verticalposition{\lower#3pt}
48: \def\spacingwithinsymbol{\baselineskip0pt\lineskip#4pt}
49: \mathrel{\mathpalette\intermediary#1}}
50: \def\intermediary #1#2{\verticalposition\vbox{\spacingwithinsymbol
51: \everycr={}\tabskip0pt
52: \halign{$\mathsurround0pt#1\hfil##\hfil$\crcr#2\crcr
53: \theguybelow\crcr}}}
54: \def\lta{\stacksymbols{<}{\sim}{2.5}{.2}}
55: \def\gta{\stacksymbols{>}{\sim}{3}{.5}}
56: \def\approxprop{\stacksymbols{\propto}{\sim}{3}{.5}}
57:
58:
59:
60:
61: \shorttitle{Extended Dust in Elliptical Galaxies}
62: \shortauthors{Temi, Brighenti \& Mathews}
63:
64: \begin{document}
65:
66: %\title{EXTENDED, HIGHLY TRANSIENT DUSTY PLUMES IN TWO
67: %ELLIPTICAL GALAXIES}
68: \title{{\it SPITZER} OBSERVATIONS OF TRANSIENT,
69: EXTENDED DUST IN TWO
70: ELLIPTICAL GALAXIES: NEW EVIDENCE OF RECENT
71: FEEDBACK ENERGY RELEASE IN GALACTIC CORES}
72: %OF NGC 5044 AND 4636}
73:
74:
75: \author{Pasquale Temi\altaffilmark{1,2},
76: Fabrizio Brighenti\altaffilmark{3,4}, William
77: G. Mathews\altaffilmark{3} }
78: %\email{ptemi@mail.arc.nasa.gov}
79: %\email{mathews@ucolick.org}
80: %\email{fabrizio.brighenti@unibo.it}
81:
82: \altaffiltext{1}{Astrophysics Branch, NASA/Ames Research Center, MS
83: 245-6,
84: Moffett Field, CA 94035.}
85: \altaffiltext{2}{SETI Institute, Mountain View, CA 94043;
86: and Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Western
87: Ontario,
88: London, ON N6A 3K7, Canada. ptemi@mail.arc.nasa.gov}
89: \altaffiltext{3}{University of California Observatories/Lick
90: Observatory,
91: Board of Studies in Astronomy and Astrophysics,
92: University of California, Santa Cruz, CA 95064
93: mathews@ucolick.org}
94: \altaffiltext{4}{Dipartimento di Astronomia,
95: Universit\`a di Bologna, via Ranzani 1, Bologna 40127, Italy
96: fabrizio.brighenti@unibo.it}
97:
98:
99: \begin{abstract}
100: {\it Spitzer}
101: observations of extended dust in two optically normal
102: elliptical galaxies provide a new confirmation of buoyant feedback
103: outflow in the hot gas atmospheres around these galaxies. AGN
104: feedback energy is required to prevent wholesale cooling and star
105: formation in these group-centered galaxies. In NGC 5044 we observe
106: interstellar (presumably PAH) emission at 8 $\mu$m out to about 5
107: kpc. Both NGC 5044 and 4636 have extended 70 $\mu$m emission from cold
108: dust exceeding that expected from stellar mass loss. The sputtering
109: lifetime of this extended dust in the $\sim1$keV interstellar gas,
110: $\sim10^7$ yrs, establishes the time when the dust first entered the
111: hot gas. Evidently the extended dust originated in dusty disks or
112: clouds, commonly observed in elliptical galaxy cores, that were
113: disrupted, heated and buoyantly transported outward. The surviving
114: central dust in NGC 5044 and 4636 has been disrupted into many small
115: filaments. It is remarkable that the asymmetrically extended 8 $\mu$m
116: emission in NGC 5044 is spatially coincident with Halpha+[NII]
117: emission from warm gas. A calculation shows that dust-assisted cooling
118: in buoyant hot gas moving out from the galactic core can cool within a
119: few kpc in about $\sim10^7$ yrs, explaining the optical line emission
120: observed. The X-ray images of both galaxies are disturbed. All
121: timescales for transient activity -- restoration of equilibrium and
122: buoyant transport in the hot gas, dynamics of surviving dust
123: fragments, and dust sputtering -- are consistent with a central
124: release of feedback energy in both galaxies about $10^7$ yrs ago.
125:
126:
127: \end{abstract}
128:
129:
130: \keywords{galaxies: elliptical and lenticular; galaxies: ISM;
131: infrared: galaxies; infrared: ISM}
132:
133:
134: \section{Introduction}
135:
136: In a recent survey of elliptical galaxies observed with
137: the {\it Spitzer} telescope
138: we found spatially extended cold interstellar dust emitting at
139: 70 $\mu$m in a significant fraction of our sample
140: (Temi, Brighenti \& Mathews 2007).
141: A few unusual galaxies in our sample, having
142: atypically large and massive dust lanes
143: that often dominate the optical image,
144: probably acquired their dust and cold gas from a merger.
145: However, some optically normal elliptical galaxies also
146: contain extended cold dust, such as the two galaxies we
147: discuss here, NGC 5044 and 4636.
148: Evidently, the source of this dust is internal, not from mergers.
149: Since this dust is thought to be in direct contact with
150: the hot, virialized interstellar gas ($kT \sim 1$ keV),
151: it has a short lifetime ($\sim 10^7$ yrs)
152: to sputtering destruction by thermal ions.
153: Consequently, this dust is a spatial tracer of extremely transient
154: events that recently occurred on kpc scales.
155: %Here we present images and a detailed
156: %analysis of two nearby elliptical galaxies with extended dust,
157: %NGC 5044 and NGC 4636.
158: Both galaxies are extended at 70 $\mu$m, but NGC 5044
159: is also extended at 8 $\mu$m in a manner similar to the
160: highly asymmetric optical line emission from warm gas
161: in this galaxy.
162: The temperature of the warm gas is maintained by photoionization
163: by UV radiation from hot post-asymptotic giant branch (AGB)
164: stars and radiation
165: of optical line emission; the dust is heated by starlight and
166: hot thermal electrons and cooled by infrared emission.
167:
168: As we proposed in Temi, Brighenti \& Mathews (2007),
169: current evidence is consistent with an internal origin for this dust,
170: and we hypothesize that dust has been buoyantly transported from the
171: galactic cores out to several kpc following a feedback heating
172: event.
173: In both galaxies
174: small, disorganized fragments of optically absorbing dusty gas
175: are visible within the central $\sim$100 parsecs,
176: further evidence of a recent central energy release.
177: In addition, {\it Chandra} X-ray images reveal that
178: the extended hot interstellar gas in
179: both galaxies is undergoing short-term gasdynamical activity.
180: All this information converges to confirm the
181: transient state of affairs in these galaxies.
182: In particular, the association of interstellar PAH emission
183: (from polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon molecules) and warm gas
184: ($T \sim 10^4$ K) in NGC 5044 indicates that we may be
185: viewing this galaxy at a rare moment immediately following
186: a release of energy near the central black hole.
187: This type of central feedback
188: energy release, thought to be caused by
189: the accretion of a small mass of gas into the
190: central black hole, has been
191: proposed as a likely solution of
192: the so-called cooling flow problem.
193: In the following we adopt distances of 15 Mpc
194: ($1^{\prime} = 4.36$ kpc) for NGC 4636
195: and 33 Mpc ($1^{\prime} = 9.60$ kpc) for NGC 5044
196: (Tonry et al. 2001).
197:
198: \section{Images of NGC 5044 and NGC 4636}
199:
200: Figures 1 and 2 show {\it Spitzer} images of NCC 5044
201: and NGC 4636 at
202: 160, 70, 24, and 8 $\mu$m.
203: The 8-4.5 $\mu$m images are
204: differences of {\it Spitzer} images at 8.0 and 4.5 $\mu$m.
205: Details of the acquisition and reduction of far-infrared
206: data at 24, 70 and 160 $\mu$m are described in
207: Temi, Brighenti \& Mathews (2007).
208: These data were obtained with the Multiband Imager Photometer (MIPS)
209: (Rieke et al. 2004) on the {\it Spitzer} Space Telescope.
210: Both NGC 5044 and 4636 are detected at 160 $\mu$m, but neither
211: image can be distinguished from a point source.
212: However, as we illustrate in Figure 10 of
213: Temi, Brighenti \& Mathews (2007), at
214: 70 $\mu$m both NGC 5044 and 4636 are
215: clearly extended beyond the MIPS point response function.
216:
217: Mid-infrared data at 3.6, 4.5, 5.8 and 8.0 $\mu$m
218: for NGC 4636 were obtained using the Infrared Array
219: Camera (IRAC) onboard {\it Spitzer}
220: under the guaranteed time program (PID 69)
221: led by PI G. Fazio (Fazio et al. 2004).
222: NGC 4636 was observed for 60 seconds on each of the
223: four IRAC wavelength channels.
224: NGC 5044 was observed during an IRAC calibration program
225: (PID 1160, PI: W. T. Reach).
226: Images of NGC 5044 at each of the four IRAC bandpasses were
227: recorded at 5 different positions slightly
228: offset from the galaxy center.
229: Observations at each position were acquired using
230: a five position gaussian dither parameter with an integration time
231: of 12 seconds per frame.
232: Thus, the total on target integration time
233: at IRAC wavelengths was 300 seconds.
234: For all wavelengths and with both MIPS and IRAC, full coverage
235: imaging was obtained for all observations with additional sky
236: coverage to properly evaluate the background emission.
237: We used the Basic Calibrated
238: Data (BCD) products from the Spitzer
239: Science pipeline (version 13.2) to construct mosaic
240: images when necessary.
241: Pipeline reduction and post-BCD processing
242: using the MOPEX software package provide all necessary steps
243: to process individual frames: dark subtraction,
244: flat-fielding, mux-bleed correction, flux calibration, correction
245: of focal plane geometrical distortion, and cosmic ray rejection.
246:
247: Also shown in Figures 1 and 2 are
248: images of the H$\alpha$+[NII] emission
249: from the warm gas in NGC 5044 (isophotes)
250: and 4636 (gray scale).
251: The panels at the lower right in both figures illustrate
252: isophotes of the X-ray images of
253: the same central regions of both
254: galaxies, produced from data in the {\it Chandra}
255: archives, superimposed on optical images from the
256: Digital Sky Survey.
257:
258: The H$\alpha$+[NII] image of NGC 5044 is quite unusual,
259: with extensions
260: toward the East, North and (especially) to the South.
261: These warm gas features are obviously
262: unrelated to the underlying stellar distribution.
263: The H$\alpha$+[NII] image in NGC 4636 is more
264: compact, but nevertheless
265: exhibits irregularities in the outer regions.
266: The radial velocities of the warm gas
267: in both galaxies determined
268: from slit spectra show highly irregular
269: activity of $\pm \sim 150$ km s$^{-1}$ on scales of
270: $\sim 1$ kpc that are unrelated to the bulk motion of
271: the stars
272: (Caon et al. 2000).
273: These quasi-random velocities are consistent with
274: the disordered spatial appearance of the warm gas.
275:
276: \section{Excess Dust in NGC 5044 and 4636 and its Origin}
277:
278: Recent studies of mid-infrared {\it Spitzer} IRS spectra
279: of elliptical galaxies indicate that most of the emission
280: shortward of 8 $\mu$m is photospheric, while emission
281: in the 8-20 $\mu$m region is from circumstellar dust around
282: mass-losing red giant stars
283: (Bregman, Temi \& Bregman 2006; Bressan et al. 2006).
284: In addition,
285: Temi, Brighenti \& Mathews (2007) find a tight correlation
286: between fluxes at 24 $\mu$m from {\it Spitzer} MIPS data
287: and optical B-band fluxes,
288: suggesting that circumstellar dust also dominates at this
289: wavelength.
290: But MIPS fluxes from elliptical galaxies
291: at 70 and 160 $\mu$m are uncorrelated with optical fluxes from
292: starlight, so we regard this colder dust as truly
293: interstellar.
294: It is remarkable that the
295: fluxes at 70 and 160 $\mu$m vary by factors of 30-100
296: among galaxies with similar optical fluxes.
297: Some elliptical galaxies with large
298: 70 and 160 $\mu$m fluxes contain very extended, multi-kpc
299: disks of cold, dusty gas consistent with
300: the strength and spatial extent of the 70 $\mu$m image.
301: Evidently, these galaxies have experienced an unusual major
302: merger with a gas-rich spiral.
303: However, a few optically normal elliptical galaxies,
304: including NGC 5044 and 4636,
305: also show unexpected large 70 and 160 $\mu$m fluxes with
306: 70 $\mu$m emission extended
307: well beyond the MIPS point response function.
308:
309: Because the 8-24 $\mu$m spectrum of elliptical galaxies is
310: dominated by circumstellar dust in outflowing stellar
311: winds, some internally produced dust is expected when
312: this dust moves into the interstellar environment,
313: where it is heated by diffuse starlight
314: to much lower temperatures
315: and radiates in the far-infrared.
316: In Temi, Brighenti \& Mathews (2007) we describe a
317: simple steady state model in which interstellar dust
318: is continuously produced by normal mass loss from
319: a single population of evolving stars and continuously
320: destroyed by ion sputtering.
321: A far-infrared spectral energy distribution (SED) can
322: be calculated assuming a power-law initial
323: grain size distribution
324: $\propto a^{-3.5}$ in $0 < a < a_{max}$.
325: This grain size distribution is normalized so
326: that $\delta = (1/150)z(r)$ is the ratio of dust to
327: gas mass in the circumstellar outflows where
328: $z(r) \approx (r/R_e)^{-0.207}$ is a typical
329: radial variation of the metal abundance (in solar units)
330: in elliptical galaxies (Arimoto et al. 1997).
331: We assume amorphous silicate grains and compute the
332: temperature of each dust grain.
333: The grain production rate is proportional to the local
334: stellar density and the specific stellar mass loss rate
335: for an old stellar population
336: $\alpha_* = {\dot M}_*/M_*
337: = 4.7 \times 10^{-20}$ s$^{-1}$ (Mathews 1989).
338: The sputtering rate of the grains is determined by the local
339: density and temperature in the hot gas as determined
340: from X-ray observations.
341: The total galactic SED is found by integrating the dust emission over
342: the steady state dust size distribution and galactic radius.
343: We show in Figure 11
344: of Temi, Brighenti \& Mathews (2007) that the
345: far-infrared SED at 70 and 160 $\mu$m observed in at least a
346: few galaxies -- such as NGC 1399, 1404 and 4472 --
347: can be fully explained by this type of normal stellar mass loss.
348: Elliptical galaxies that agree with our steady state
349: dust model are among those with the lowest
350: 70 and 160 $\mu$m luminosities.
351:
352: However, as illustrated in Figure 3,
353: the 70 and 160 $\mu$m fluxes of both NGC 5044 and 4636
354: are far in excess of our predicted steady state SED.
355: (The 24 $\mu$m flux shown in Figure 3 is circumstellar
356: and is unrelated to our SED model.)
357: The mass and spatial extent
358: of the ``excess'' interstellar dust in these
359: galaxies can be estimated using our steady state model
360: but artificially increasing the stellar
361: mass loss rate $\alpha_*$ within radius $r_{ex}$.
362: Increasing $\alpha_*$ by some factor $f_{\alpha}$
363: increases the mass of interstellar
364: dust and $r_{ex}$ can be adjusted until
365: the mean grain temperature approximately fits
366: the 70 $\mu$m/160 $\mu$m flux ratio observed in each galaxy.
367: Interstellar dust is heated by starlight and
368: by inelastic collisions with thermal electrons.
369: Since the mean intensity of starlight and the
370: electron density both decrease
371: with galactic radius, the dust temperature
372: $T_d$ also decreases, so $r_{ex}$ can be adjusted to change
373: mean dust grain temperature $\langle T_d \rangle$
374: and therefore the 70 $\mu$m/160 $\mu$m flux ratio.
375: These values of $f_{\alpha}$, $r_{ex}$ and the
376: excess dust mass estimated from them are only approximations,
377: since it is unlikely that the radial distribution of the
378: excess non-stellar dust exactly follows the stellar density
379: profile, but with a sharp truncation at $r_{ex}$.
380:
381: Each panel of Figure 3 shows three combinations of
382: $f_{\alpha}$ and $r_{ex}$, holding $a_{max} = 0.3 \mu$m constant.
383: The best-fitting SED for the extra dust in NGC 5044 and
384: 4636, shown by dotted lines in both panels, corresponds
385: respectively to a mass of excess dust of
386: $1.5 \times 10^5$ and $1.1 \times 10^5$ $M_{\odot}$.
387: The physical size of this dust, $r_{ex} \sim 4-5$ kpc,
388: is comparable to or
389: exceeds the 70 $\mu$m point response function for both galaxies.
390: We propose below that $r_{ex}$ is limited by the sputtering time
391: in buoyant dusty gas flowing from galaxy cores.
392:
393: We argue in Temi, Brighenti \& Mathews (2007) that the
394: incidence of (otherwise normal) elliptical galaxies with
395: excess dust emission at $70 \mu$m
396: exceeds the fraction of ellipticals that are likely
397: to have experienced
398: mergers with dusty gas-rich (dwarf) galaxies within
399: a typical dust sputtering time $t_{sput} \approx 10^7$ yrs,
400: evaluated a few kiloparsecs from the galactic center.
401: In addition,
402: since $t_{sput}$ is somewhat less than the typical
403: free fall time from several effective radii,
404: if the extended dust were a result of merging,
405: ellipticals having far-infrared excesses should contain
406: evidence of the merging galaxies within their
407: optical images, but this is not observed.
408: The mean stellar ages of elliptical galaxies can be
409: measured from the strength of Balmer line absorption features.
410: Annibali et al. (2006) find a stellar age of
411: 13.5 $\pm$ 3.6 Gyrs for NGC 4636 but the age for
412: NGC 5044 (14.2 $\pm$ 10. Gyrs) is indeterminate because
413: the Balmer absorption is masked by the much stronger
414: interstellar Balmer emission in this galaxy.
415: The optical colors of both galaxies also seem
416: normal, $B-V \approx 0.97-1.06$ (Poulain 1988;
417: Poulain \& Nieto 1994).
418: Finally, the stellar velocity dispersion and rotation are largely
419: normal for both galaxies{\footnotemark[1]}
420: \footnotetext[1]{
421: NGC 4636 does have a few minor peculiarities.
422: Slit spectra of
423: Caon, Macchetto \& Pastoriza (2000) indicate that the
424: mean stellar radial velocity
425: has a broad central {\it minimum} at position angle 117$^o$, but not
426: in other directions.
427: Also, for its luminosity and central stellar velocity dispersion
428: NCC 4636 has an unusually low near-IR stellar surface brightness,
429: causing it to deviate from the fundamental plane for galaxy cores
430: (Ravindranath, et al. 2001).
431: }
432: , with no
433: kinematical indication of
434: an alien merging stellar system
435: (Caon, Macchetto, \& Pastoriza, 2000).
436: We conclude there is no optical evidence in either galaxy of
437: a merger event during the previous $\sim 10^8$ yrs.
438:
439: In Temi et al. (2003) we first discovered
440: excess dust at 60, 90 and 180 $\mu$m in NGC 4636
441: from observations with the {\it Infrared Space
442: Observatory} (ISO) and proposed that the short-lived
443: dust resulted from a recent merger.
444: However, now that the age of the stars in
445: NGC 4636 has been found to
446: be very old and the dust is known to be extended,
447: our earlier merger explanation is untenable.
448: Instead, as discussed in Temi, Brighenti \& Mathews
449: (2007), we now propose that the extended excess
450: dust seen in both NGC 4636 and 5044 and other similar
451: galaxies has been buoyantly
452: transported from the galactic core to several kpc
453: following a heating event near the central black hole.
454:
455: Galactic cores are a natural source of dust.
456: Mathews \& Brighenti (2003) showed that
457: the $\sim100-300$kpc-sized nuclear disks
458: that are often observed in the nuclei of elliptical galaxies
459: (e.g. Lauer et al. 2005)
460: can result from stellar mass loss within
461: the innermost $\sim$1 kpc
462: at a rate ${\dot M}_1 \approx \alpha_* M_1
463: \approx 0.1$ $M_{\odot}$ yr$^{-1}$,
464: where $M_1 \sim 5 \times 10^{10}$ $M_{\odot}$ is the
465: stellar mass in the central kpc.
466:
467: In the Appendix of Temi et al. (2007) we showed that the excess
468: far-infrared emission at 70 and 160 $\mu$m
469: cannot arise from these small nuclear dust disks/clouds but must
470: come from dust distributed 5-10 kpc into the hot
471: gas.{\footnotemark[2]}
472: \footnotetext[2]{
473: Cold dust inside dense, optically thick nuclear disks/clouds is
474: self-shielded and cannot be heated by the diffuse stellar UV radiation
475: from hot post-AGB stars.
476: The apparent longevity of these optically thick
477: clouds ($\sim 10^7$ yrs)
478: suggests that heating by thermal electrons in the
479: adjacent hot gas is also suppressed.
480: Evidently magnetic fields
481: (tangent to the surface of the spinning disks) are sufficient to
482: restrict thermal conduction.
483: However, when the dusty gas is heated
484: and dispersed by an AGN explosion, some of the dust is directly
485: exposed to diffuse galactic UV and hot thermal electrons that heat the
486: dust to radiate much more efficiently at infrared wavelengths.
487: But when the same mass of
488: dust is contained in dense, self-shielding central disks, its infrared
489: luminosity is unobservably low.}
490: We hypothesized that the spatially extended
491: dust has its origin in the nuclear disks/clouds that
492: are disrupted and buoyantly transported to large radii
493: in the hot gas as a result of intermittent AGN-type heating
494: in the galactic core.
495: The mass of excess extended dust, $\sim 10^5$ $M_{\odot}$,
496: is consistent with this.
497: %New dusty disks form after the older ones are destroyed.
498:
499: Consider for example the time $t_{disk}$ required to
500: form an optically obscuring dusty disk of radius
501: $r \sim 300$ pc.
502: To block starlight, the column density
503: in the disk must exceed about
504: $N \sim 10^{21}N_{21}$ cm$^{-2}$, assuming solar abundance.
505: So the total mass of an optically dark disk of radius $r$
506: is at least $M_{disk} \approx [5\mu/(2+\mu)] m_p N \pi r^2
507: \approx 3 \times 10^7 N_{21} r_{300}^2$ $M_{\odot}$ where
508: $r_{300}$ is the disk radius in units of 300 parsecs
509: and $\mu = 0.61$ is the mean molecular weight.
510: [This disk mass is consistent with the upper limit to the
511: HI mass in NGC 4636 of $1.1 \times 10^8$ $M_{\odot}$
512: established by Krishna Kumar \& Thonnard (1983).]
513: The time for stellar mass loss
514: (within the central kpc) to form such an obscuring disk,
515: $t_{disk} \approx M_{disk}/{\dot M}_1$,
516: is only $t_{disk} \approx 3 \times 10^7 N_{21} r_{300}^2$ yrs,
517: similar to the buoyant rise time in the hot gas.
518: For a dust to gas mass ratio $\delta \sim 0.01$, these disks
519: should contain about
520: $3 \times 10^5$ $M_{\odot}$ of dust, which is very similar
521: to the dust we observe in NGC 5044 and 4636
522: in excess of our steady state model.
523:
524: To support this hypothesis further,
525: we show in Figure 4 {\it Hubble Space Telescope} images
526: of the central $\sim 1-2$ kpc in NGC 5044 and 4636.
527: Small, chaotically arranged dusty fragments are visible
528: against the stellar background in both galaxies.
529: The dense gas in these fragments is clearly in a highly
530: transient state, dynamically
531: orbiting in the galactic potential out to a few kpc
532: where the freefall time is $\sim 10^7$ years.
533: It is very unlikely that
534: these relatively large optically obscuring clouds
535: can be interpreted as infalling dust just
536: after being ejected from stars.
537: The radius of individual optically dark fragments in Figure 4 is about
538: 10 parsecs, which translates to
539: a dust mass $\sim 3 \times 10^4$ $M_{\odot}$
540: far in excess of that from a single star
541: or from a hypothetical agglomeration of several stellar outflows
542: during the short freefall time.
543: We propose instead that these dusty regions are fragments of
544: a central, more organized disk-like structure that was disrupted
545: about $10^7$ yrs ago by an AGN-related energy release.
546: While it may seem unlikely that dense fragments can
547: result from an AGN energy release and be
548: accelerated outwards in this quasi-coherent manner,
549: we appeal to studies of Seyfert galaxies where similar large
550: and dense clouds are accelerated in just
551: this manner by non-thermal, radio-emitting outflows
552: (e.g. Whittle, et al. 2005).
553:
554: As soon as a dusty disks are destroyed by a significant release of
555: AGN energy, another disk begins to form.
556: The fragments visible in Figure 4 indicate that
557: some fraction of the disk received kinetic energy but
558: was not irreversibly heated by the explosive AGN event.
559: Therefore the next generation disks in these galaxies will
560: be formed out of these denser remnants of the previous disk
561: and new dust that is continuously ejected from red giant stars
562: in the galactic core.
563: At present it is impossible to know what fraction of
564: disk material is heated to supervirial (buoyant) temperatures and
565: what fraction remains in the fragments visible in
566: Figure 4.
567: Nor is it clear at present what limits the maximum
568: amount of dusty cold gas that resides in central disks/clouds.
569:
570: The only signs of current nuclear activity in NGC 5044 and 4636 are
571: small, weak non-thermal GHz nuclear radio sources.
572: There is no
573: evidence of disk or Bondi type accretion.
574: For example, from Chandra
575: observations of NGC 4636
576: Loewenstein et al. (2001) determined that the accretion
577: onto the $8 \times 10^7$ $M_{\odot}$ central massive black hole
578: in this galaxy
579: is less than $3 \times 10^{-8}L_{edd}$ and less than $6 \times
580: 10^{-4}$ of the spherical Bondi accretion rate.
581: The general absence
582: of mass accretion in supermassive nucelear black holes in elliptical
583: galaxies is consistent
584: with models in which most of their mass was acquired during a
585: short-lived early evolutionary phase (e.g. Hopkins, Narayan, \&
586: Hernquist 2006).
587: The AGN-type energy releases in NGC 5044 and 4636
588: required in our interpretation must also be sufficiently short-lived
589: or radiatively unremarkable.
590:
591:
592: \section{PAH Emission from NGC 5044}
593:
594: Perhaps the most dramatic illustration of extended
595: dust in NGC 5044 is the difference image between IRAC wavelengths
596: 8 and 4.5 $\mu$m shown in Figure 1 and its
597: striking similarity to that of the warm gas emission
598: in H$\alpha$+[NII].
599: The 8-4.5 $\mu$m difference image is constructed by
600: subtracting a properly normalized 4.5 $\mu$m image
601: from the 8 $\mu$m image.
602: Emission at 4.5 $\mu$m is due largely to stellar photospheres
603: while both photospheric and circumstellar emission
604: contribute at 8 $\mu$m --
605: but the 8 $\mu$m image may also contain interstellar emission
606: from hot dust emission or the strong 7.7 $\mu$m
607: PAH emission feature.
608: When the two images are subtracted, both the
609: stellar and circumstellar emission are canceled,
610: and only emission from the faint interstellar dust emission remains.
611: Our subtraction process in NGC 5044 was based on visual examination
612: of the surface brightness $\Sigma$ in the difference image
613: $\Sigma_{8.0} - F \Sigma_{4.5}$ where the subscripts refer
614: to the IRAC wavelengths and $F$ is a variable parameter.
615: As $F$ was varied, the stellar surface brightness of the difference
616: image of the stellar emission passes through a cancellation when
617: $F = \Sigma_{8.0}/\Sigma_{4.5}$.
618: In this process
619: particular attention was paid to the
620: residual stellar brightness in the
621: region along the H$\alpha$ plume about 3-5 kpc south of
622: the galactic center.
623: The value of $F$ at which the stellar contributions at
624: 8.0 and 4.5 microns outside the plume region
625: are equalized depends on the galactic radius in NGC 5044.
626: The 8-4.5 $\mu$m image of NGC 5044 shown in Figure 1 corresponds to
627: $F \approx 0.52$ where the stellar emission near the plume
628: canceled and the faint residual interstellar features
629: are revealed.
630: Our value of $F$ is almost identical to $F = 0.526$ which is
631: the flux ratio
632: $F_{8.0}/F_{4.5}$ of a 10 Gyr old solar abundance
633: single stellar population estimated by Piovan et al. (2003),
634: who include both photospheric and circumstellar infrared emission.
635: In our difference image of NGC 5044
636: the interstellar emission exhibits the
637: same extended features toward the north and south that are so
638: prominent in the H$\alpha$+[NII] isophotes.
639: We estimate that the total luminosity of the 8 $\mu$m
640: component is about 4 percent of the total interstellar
641: far-infrared luminosity longward of 24 $\mu$m,
642: this is similar
643: to the PAH emission fraction observed in Milky Way sources.
644:
645: The residual interstellar feature in NGC 5044 could be due
646: to the strong PAH
647: emission band at 7.7 $\mu$m or to hot dust emission from small,
648: stochastically heated dust grains, in some proportion.
649: Dust with temperatures approaching $10^3$ K could
650: be heated by an intense beam of optical-UV radiation from
651: the galactic center along the direction of the plume.
652: However, to our knowledge normal elliptical galaxies
653: with abnormally UV-bright nuclei, when viewed along such
654: beams, are not commonly observed.
655: In principle, thermal excursions of
656: small grains recently heated by individual photons or electrons could
657: explain the diffuse 8 $\mu$m emission.
658: For example, this process is thought to explain the
659: diffuse near-infrared dust emission often observed in
660: planetary nebulae (e.g. Phillips \& Ramos-Larios 2006).
661: During the short-lived
662: stages as the dusty hot gas in the southerly
663: plume of NGC 5044 cools, the
664: electron density increases and stochastic
665: heating of small grains by electron encounters may increase.
666: However, in
667: situations where stochastically heated dust emission dominates,
668: the infrared continuum generally increases from 8 toward
669: longer wavelengths since a larger fraction of small grains can
670: be momentarily heated to lower temperatures that radiate
671: at longer wavelengths
672: (e.g. Draine \& Anderson 1985).
673: But this increase is not observed in spectra
674: of normal elliptical galaxies taken
675: with the {\it Spitzer} Infrared Spectrograph
676: (IRS) (e.g. Bregman, Temi \& Bregman 2006).
677: Our 24 $\mu$m image of NGC 5044
678: (not shown in Figure 1) shows no evidence
679: of asymmetrically extended emission similar to the optical
680: line emission.
681:
682: If the extended 8-4.5 $\mu$m feature
683: visible to the south in Figure 1 were due
684: to transient thermal excursions of small grains,
685: this feature would be even more
686: pronounced in a 24-4.5 $\mu$m difference image.
687: To explore this possibility, we spatially
688: degraded the 4.5 $\mu$m image
689: to the PSF of the 24 $\mu$m image and varied the flux ratio
690: to cancel the stellar and circumstellar emission
691: at both wavelengths.
692: We see no non-stellar residual interstellar enhancement
693: in the 24-4.5 $\mu$m image of NGC 5044
694: that is geometrically similar to the plume extension visible
695: in optical emission and the 8.0-4.5 $\mu$ difference image.
696: The absence of extended emission in the 24-4.5 $\mu$m image
697: of NGC 5044
698: is therefore a strong argument for PAH emission at 8 $\mu$m
699: and for the relative unimportance of thermal excursions
700: in the mid-infrared dust SED in this galaxy.
701: An IRS spectrum of NGC 5044 has been taken but it is not
702: currently available in the {\it Spitzer} archive,
703: although the extended interstellar emission in Figure 1
704: may be too faint to be
705: easily visible as PAH emission features in the spectrum.
706:
707: In the following discussion we adopt a PAH interpretation of
708: the 8 $\mu$m interstellar features in NGC 5044, but the
709: precise identification of this dust-related interstellar emission
710: is not central to our main arguments.
711: It is unclear if the PAH is located in the warm gas or is
712: in the hot interstellar gas where its expected lifetime
713: is short but its modes of excitation
714: and emission might be more easily excited.
715:
716: Evidence of PAH emission in {\it Spitzer} IRS spectra
717: of elliptical or other early type galaxies is rare and
718: has only been found in a few unusual early-type galaxies
719: that have starburst activity in massive cold disks:
720: NGC 4550, NGC 4435 (Bressan et al. 2006;
721: both are SB0 galaxies) and
722: NGC 4697 (Bregman, Bregman \& Temi 2006;
723: an E6 galaxy with a dust lane that may be an S0).
724:
725: It is unclear at present if the extended
726: 70 $\mu$m emission also shows the same feature to the
727: south of NGC 5044.
728: When the 8-4.5 $\mu$m feature is convolved
729: with the PRF of the 70 $\mu$ filter, this southern
730: extension largely disappears.
731:
732: The very elongated H$\alpha$+[NII] image in NGC 5044
733: is unusual -- perhaps the only other elliptical galaxy
734: that is known to have a similar feature
735: (unrelated to large disks of cold gas)
736: is NGC 5813 (Goudfrooij et al. 1994).
737: In normal galaxies without extended dust or warm gas
738: features, all the warm gas is expected to result from
739: stellar mass loss and is generally visible only
740: within the central kpc.
741: Gas ejected from evolving stars at a rate $\alpha_*M_*$
742: (where $\alpha_* = 4.7 \times 10^{-20}$ s$^{-1}$)
743: cannot accumulate in
744: the warm gas phase indefinitely
745: since otherwise after
746: $\sim 10^5$ yrs the H$\alpha$+[NII]
747: flux would exceed values commonly observed in most
748: elliptical galaxies.
749: We conclude therefore that the warm line-emitting
750: gas thermally merges
751: with the hot ($T \sim 10^7$ K)
752: interstellar gas in this time
753: (Mathews \& Brighenti 1999).
754: Therefore the extended warm gas observed in NGC 5044
755: is very transitory, although the PAHs and warm gas
756: may be continuously supplied for
757: a longer time $\sim 10^7$ years
758: as gas cools in the buoyant dusty plume.
759:
760: \section{Buoyant Dust Outflow in NGC 5044}
761:
762: Two questions come to mind about buoyant dust transport.
763: Can dust grains survive sputtering destruction during
764: their buoyant journey out to $\sim 5$ kpc, the approximate
765: extent of the H$\alpha$+[NII] and PAH emission features
766: in NGC 5044?
767: Can the dust also cool (some of) the buoyant gas to create the
768: warm gas that emits H$\alpha$+[NII]?
769: To answer these questions we consider a simple model
770: in which gas is assumed to be heated
771: at some small radius $r_0$ in NGC 5044 and
772: remains in hydrostatic equilibrium as it
773: moves buoyantly out at velocity $v$.
774: For simplicity we assume $v$ is constant since
775: the buoyant velocity depends on
776: the size of the buoyant region and other uncertain parameters.
777: After the gas is heated at radius $r_0$ it has an electron density
778: $n$ that is lower
779: by a factor $\Delta < 1$ than the local ambient density
780: of the hot gas, i.e. $n(r_0) = \Delta {\hat n}(r_0)$.
781: In this Section variables with hats refer to the (unheated) ambient
782: hot gas in NGC 5044.
783: The density and temperature profiles in NGC 5044,
784: found from X-ray observations (i.e. Buote et al.
785: 2003), can be approximated with the following
786: expressions:
787: \begin{equation}
788: {\hat n} = {0.065 \over r_{kpc}^{1/2}[1 + (r_{kpc}/9.5)^{1.05}]}
789: + {0.002 \over [1 + (r_{kpc}/30.5)^{3/2}]}~~~{\rm cm}^{-3}
790: \end{equation}
791: and
792: \begin{displaymath}
793: {\hat T} = {10^7 \over
794: [F(r_{kpc})^{-3} + G(r_{kpc})^{-3}]^{1/3} }
795: \end{displaymath}
796: \begin{equation}
797: ~~~~- 0.12 e^{-(r_{kpc}/1.5)} + 3 \times 10^6~~{\rm K}
798: \end{equation}
799: where
800: \begin{equation}
801: F(r_{kpc}) = 0.85 + 0.95(r_{kpc}/30)^2
802: \end{equation}
803: and
804: \begin{equation}
805: G(r_{kpc}) = 1.64 (r_{kpc}/30)^{-0.10}.
806: \end{equation}
807:
808: For simplicity we assume that the grains have a single
809: initial radius $a(r_0)$ and, as they move buoyantly outward,
810: are sputtered at a rate given by
811: \begin{equation}
812: {da \over dr} = - { 3.2 \times 10^{-18} n_p \over v}
813: \left[ 1 + \left( {2 \times 10^6{\rm K} \over T}\right)^{2.5}
814: \right]^{-1} ~~~ {\rm cm~cm}^{-1}
815: \end{equation}
816: (Tsai \& Mathews 1995)
817: where $n_p = 0.83n_e$ is the proton density.
818: As the buoyant gas flows out in local pressure equilibrium,
819: $P = {\hat P}$,
820: its temperature follows an adiabat
821: ($T \propto P^{(\gamma - 1)/\gamma}$ with $\gamma = 5/3$)
822: modified by radiative losses,
823: \begin{equation}
824: {dT \over dr} = {2T \over 5{\hat P}}
825: \left[ {d {\hat P} \over dr}
826: - {1 \over v}
827: \left({\mu {\hat P} \over k T} \right)^2 (\Lambda_{gas}
828: + \Lambda_{dust})\right].
829: \end{equation}
830: The first term in square brackets describes the
831: adiabatic cooling of the buoyant gas as it expands,
832: continuously
833: adjusting to the decreasing ambient pressure as it moves out
834: in the hot gas atmosphere of NGC 5044.
835: %Local pressure equilibrium is assumed, $nT = {\hat n}{\hat T}$.
836: The second term is the intrinsic cooling that occurs
837: in the buoyant gas due to standard radiative losses
838: with coefficient $\Lambda_{gas}(T)$
839: (e.g. Sutherland \& Dopita 1993) and due to the
840: absorption of thermal electrons by inelastic collisions
841: with the grains,
842: \begin{equation}
843: \Lambda_{dust} = {9 \over 8} { (2+\mu) \over 5 \mu}
844: {\delta m_p \over \rho_g}
845: \left( 8 \over \pi m_e \right)^{1/2} { (kT)^{3/2} \over a}
846: ~~~{\rm ergs}~{\rm cm}^3~{\rm s}^{-1}
847: \end{equation}
848: (Mathews \& Brighenti 2003).
849: We assume a uniform
850: dust mass to gas mass ratio of $\delta = 0.015$ in the initial gas,
851: similar to that in Milky Way gas.
852: The mass density of the grain material $\rho_g = 3.3$ g cm$^{-3}$
853: is appropriate for amorphous silicates.
854:
855: The solution to these equations shown in Figure 5
856: corresponds to the following (somewhat arbitrary) parameters:
857: $r_0 = 200$ pc, $\Delta = 0.15$, $a(r_0) = 1\mu$m,
858: and $v = 400$ km s$^{-1}$.
859: The upper panel of Figure 5 shows Chandra observations of
860: the hot and cold temperature phases in NGC 5044
861: (Buote et al. 2003).
862: The solid lines in the upper two panels
863: show the temperature and density profiles of
864: the cooler, dense phase ${\hat T} \equiv T_c(r)$ and the
865: long-dashed lines show the buoyant evolution of dust-free
866: gas heated by a factor $\Delta^{-1}$ at $r_0$.
867: The short-dashed lines in Figure 5 show the trajectory
868: of the same heated gas but with a uniform admixture of dust
869: at a fraction $\delta = 0.015$ of the gas mass.
870: It is seen that the buoyant gas does in fact cool
871: to low temperatures ($T \ll {\hat T}$)
872: at $r \approx 5$ kpc similar
873: to the extent of the southern warm gas feature observed in
874: NGC 5044.
875: The dust-assisted cooling occurs in $\sim 10^7$ yrs even
876: though the buoyant gas was initially hotter than the ambient
877: gas ${\hat T}$; the bottom panel in Figure 5 shows that
878: dust cooling dominates at every radius in the dusty buoyant gas.
879: Evidently, the PAH emission observed comes from residual
880: dust fragments diminished by sputtering.
881: Perhaps the least satisfactory aspect of this approximate
882: calculation is the rather high value of the
883: buoyant velocity required to reach $\sim 5$ kpc
884: in $\sim 10^7$ yrs,
885: $v = 400$ km s$^{-1}$,
886: which nearly approaches the
887: sound speed $c_s = (\gamma k {\hat T} / \mu m_p)^{1/2}
888: = 480 ({\hat T}/10^7~{\rm K})^{1/2}$ km s$^{-1}$.
889: This suggests that the buoyantly heated gas may have received
890: momentum from a jet emerging from the central black hole.
891:
892: Considering the many uncertainties
893: involved, it seems plausible from Figure 5 that the peculiar
894: asymmetric extensions of warm gas in NGC 5044 can be formed
895: by dust-assisted cooling of buoyant flow.
896: Buoyant gas that was heated less at $r_0$
897: (i.e. $\Delta > 0.15$) or which contains a locally higher
898: dust density will cool
899: at smaller radius, explaining the full extent of
900: the warm gas feature in NGC 5044.
901: The enhanced soft X-ray emission extending southward in
902: the general direction of the plume (Figure 1)
903: could be due to enhanced emission from cooling
904: (and therefore denser) hot gas.
905: Indeed, we note that the cooling in Figure 5 occurs on a timescale
906: $\sim 10^7$ yrs consistent with other transient
907: events in the hot gas in
908: both NGC 5044 and 4636 which we discuss below.
909:
910: \section{Central Optical and X-ray Cavity in NGC 4636}
911:
912: Optical line emission from warm gas in the central
913: $\sim1$ kpc of NGC 4636 and thermal
914: X-ray emission from the hot gas both have a
915: small cavity slightly displaced from the galactic center
916: {\footnotemark[3]} (Figure 6).
917: \footnotetext[3]{
918: The cavity is less visible in the emission line image
919: shown in Figure 2 probably because of
920: the gray-scale intensities adopted by Caon et al. (2000).
921: }
922: Demoulin-Ulrich et al. (1984), Buson et al. (1994) and
923: Zeilinger et al. (1996), all noticed
924: a nearly circular hole of radius
925: $r_{hole} = 1.7^{\prime\prime} = 120$ parsecs
926: in the H$\alpha$+[NII] image that is clearly visible in Figure 6 just
927: NE of the galactic center.
928: At the right in Figure 6 is an X-ray
929: image taken from the {\it Chandra} archives.
930: Superimposed on the X-ray image are approximate contours showing
931: the radio jets as observed
932: at 1.4 GHz by Stanger \& Warwick (1986)
933: and at 5 GHz by Birkinshaw \& Davies (1985).
934: The (steep spectrum) double radio jets are about 1 kpc long,
935: oriented at position angle $\sim45^o$.
936: It is remarkable that the circular hole
937: seen by the optical observers is also
938: visible in the {\it Chandra} image.
939: While the X-ray emitting gas (paradoxically) appears to have
940: been disturbed very little by the radio lobes,
941: the energy source that created the circular cavity to the
942: NE has does not contain a significant
943: non-thermal radio source of its own.
944:
945: Assuming that the circular feature is formed by a point explosion,
946: the energy required to form a hole of radius $r_{hole}$
947: in the hot gas
948: is $E \approx (3P/2\rho)\cdot \rho V_{hole} = 2 \pi r_{hole}^3 P$,
949: where $P = 1.9nkT$ is the local gas pressure.
950: Using central values of the hot gas density $n$
951: and temperature $T$ from
952: Allen et al. (2006), we estimate that the local gas pressure
953: near the circular cavity
954: is $P \approx 6.14 \times 10^{-10}$ dynes cm$^{-2}$.
955: The energy required to form this hole is therefore
956: $E \approx 200 \times 10^{51}$ ergs.
957: This energy far exceeds that of a
958: single supernova, so the cavity was probably formed with energy
959: released near the central black hole.
960: Since the chaotic warm gas velocities observed
961: by Caon, Macchetto \& Pastoriza (2000) near the hole are
962: $v \sim \pm 50-100$ km s$^{-1}$, the age of the hole cannot exceed
963: $t_{hole} \approx 2r_{hole}/v \approx 2 \times 10^6/v_{100}$ yrs
964: where $v_{100}$ is the
965: local warm gas velocity in units of 100 km s$^{-1}$.
966: Evidently, the central AGN-black hole
967: in NGC 4636 has been active during the last few million years.
968:
969: \section{Transient Activity in the Hot Gas}
970:
971: Unlike most other similar galaxy/groups,
972: {\it XMM} X-ray spectra of the hot gas in the NGC 5044 group
973: show that the hot gas within about 30 kpc
974: from the central galaxy
975: does not have a uniform temperature at each radius
976: (Figure 5; Buote et al. 2003).
977: In most galaxy groups and clusters
978: the hot gas temperature rises from the center and peaks at
979: about 0.1 of the virial radius, then decreases further out.
980: The emission-weighted (single) temperature profile
981: in NGC 5044 has a similar thermal structure.
982: However, {\it XMM} spectra reveal that
983: NGC 5044 contains an additional component
984: of hotter gas in which the temperature
985: {\it decreases} outward from the
986: center (Buote et al. 2003)
987: as shown by the long-dashed line in the top panel of Figure 5.
988: Since this hotter (and therefore less dense) gas
989: in NGC 5044 must be buoyant, it is natural to associate
990: it with the dust-transporting regions discussed in
991: the previous section.
992: The ``multi-phase'' character of the X-ray spectrum
993: of NGC 5044 is also evident from the hot gas density
994: irregularities visible in the {\it Chandra} image
995: (Fig. 1 of Buote et al. 2003)
996: with isophotes shown in our Figure 1.
997: It appears that the X-ray feature toward the
998: south in NGC 5044 is roughly coincident with
999: the H$\alpha$+[NII] and PAH extensions in that same region.
1000: The enhanced X-ray emission in this region may
1001: result from slightly denser gas that is undergoing
1002: dust-assisted cooling in the buoyant plume.
1003: Overall, observations indicate many dusty plumes
1004: in NGC 5044, but only the plume toward the south is currently
1005: producing warm gas out to $\sim 5$ kpc.
1006:
1007: X-ray spectra and images of NGC 4636 also reveal evidence
1008: of recent, possibly somewhat more violent activity in
1009: this galaxy/group.
1010: {\it Chandra} observations presented by Jones et al. (2002)
1011: show a symmetric
1012: X-shaped parabolic pattern of enhanced emission,
1013: presumably caused by shock waves, that enclose
1014: cavities several kpc to the east and west of the galactic center.
1015: Jones el al. interpret this as the result of two
1016: symmetric and nearly simultaneous
1017: point explosions ($\sim 10^{57}$ ergs)
1018: offset from the galactic center
1019: that occurred about $3 \times 10^6$ yrs ago.
1020: No radio emission has been observed in
1021: these cavities which are somewhat misaligned from
1022: the current radio jets shown in Figure 6
1023: (Birkinshaw \& Davies 1985; Stanger \& Warwick 1986).
1024:
1025: The X-ray observations of NGC 4636
1026: and their explanation do not necessarily require a
1027: (buoyant) mass
1028: outflow that could create the extended
1029: dust emission observed at 70$\mu$m.
1030: However, strong evidence for outflows in NGC 4636 is provided
1031: by the {\it XMM} spectra
1032: and images shown by O'Sullivan, Vrtilek and Kempner (2005).
1033: Their abundance map of NGC 4636 shows a patch
1034: of gas with high abundance about 25-30 kpc toward the
1035: southwest of the galactic core.
1036: O'Sullivan et al. interpret this as evidence of an older
1037: (collimated, plume-like) gas outflow
1038: that transported gas from the galactic center that was
1039: enriched by Type Ia supernovae.
1040: Consequently,
1041: there is now good X-ray evidence that the same kind of transient
1042: collimated outflow has occurred in both of these galaxies
1043: having extended far-infrared emission.
1044:
1045: \section{Final Remarks}
1046:
1047: We discuss two optically normal elliptical
1048: galaxies, NGC 5044 and NGC 4636, in which we
1049: discovered spatially extended interstellar
1050: dust at 70$\mu$m.
1051: In NGC 5044
1052: we observe asymmetrically extended interstellar
1053: 8$\mu$m PAH emission associated with warm gas and
1054: extending about 5 kpc from the center of the galaxy.
1055: In view of the short sputtering lifetime for extended dust,
1056: $\sim 10^7$ yrs, and the commonplace optical appearance
1057: of both galaxies,
1058: we conclude that the extended dust observed
1059: cannot result from a recent merger with a gas-rich galaxy.
1060: The stellar morphologies, spectra, colors and old ages
1061: of these two galaxies
1062: appear to be normal with no evidence of an
1063: additional merger component.
1064: Instead, we propose that the extended excess
1065: dust is created by stellar mass loss
1066: in the central $\sim1$ kpc and stored
1067: in small disks or clouds in the galactic cores.
1068: These disks are intermittently disrupted and
1069: heated by energy released by accretion onto the
1070: central black holes (AGN feedback).
1071: Finally, the heated dusty gas is buoyantly
1072: transported out to several kpc where it is observed.
1073: The physical extent of the extended dust is governed by the
1074: buoyant velocity and either the grain sputtering time
1075: or the dust-assisted cooling time, whichever is shorter.
1076:
1077: X-ray observations of both NGC 5044 and 4636 show unusual,
1078: transient features consistent with recent
1079: energy releases in or near the galactic cores.
1080: Both galaxies show disorganized, highly fragmented
1081: optically visible dust clouds
1082: in the central 100-200 parsecs that are also highly transient.
1083: Finally, the timescales for all these processes are comparable
1084: to the sputtering lifetime of the extended dust,
1085: about $10^7$ yrs.
1086:
1087: We are particularly privileged to view NGC 5044 during
1088: a brief interval when asymmetric,
1089: radially extended 8$\mu$m PAH and H$\alpha$+[NII] emission
1090: is present in the outflowing gas.
1091: We explain this remarkable observation as a result of
1092: dust-assisted cooling in
1093: a buoyant plume of hot dusty gas.
1094: We show with a simple calculation that dust can cool
1095: buoyant gas to $\sim 10^4$ K which emits the optical
1096: emission lines observed.
1097: The warm gas phase is maintained in
1098: thermal equilibrium near $\sim 10^4$ K
1099: by radiative losses and UV heating from post-AGB stars.
1100: Based on the collective Balmer line luminosities of
1101: normal elliptical galaxies, we conclude that
1102: this warm gas can only last for $\sim 10^5$ yrs
1103: before it thermally melts into the dominant hot
1104: interstellar phase.
1105: %and this accounts for the rarity of extended warm gas
1106: %features as in NGC 5044.
1107: Finally, the buoyant outflow described here is
1108: an essential feature of flows that
1109: successfully resolve the cooling flow problem
1110: with the outward transport of both mass and energy
1111: from the galactic core to large radii, i.e. a
1112: circulation flow (Mathews, Brighenti \& Buote 2004).
1113:
1114: \vskip.1in
1115: \acknowledgements
1116: This work is based on observations made with the Spitzer Space
1117: Telescope, which is operated by the Jet Propulsion Laboratory,
1118: California Institute of Technology, under NASA contract 1407.
1119: Support for this work was provided by NASA through Spitzer
1120: Guest Observer grant RSA 1276023.
1121: Studies of the evolution of hot gas in elliptical galaxies
1122: at UC Santa Cruz are supported by
1123: NASA grants NAG 5-8409 \& ATP02-0122-0079 and NSF grant
1124: AST-0098351 for which we are very grateful.
1125:
1126: \begin{references}
1127:
1128: \reference{} Allen, S. W., Dunn, R. H., Fabian, A. C.,
1129: Taylor, G. B. \& Reynolds, C. S. 2006, MNRAS, 272, 21
1130:
1131: \reference{} Annibali, F., Bressan, A., Rampazzo, R.,
1132: Zeilinger, W. W. \& Danese, L. 2006, A\&A (in press)
1133: (astro-ph/0609175)
1134:
1135: \reference{} Arimoto, N., Matsushita, K., Ishimaru, Y.,
1136: Ohashi, T. \& Renzini, A. 1997, ApJ, 477, 128
1137:
1138: \reference{} Birkinshaw, M. \& Davies, R. 1985,
1139: ApJ, 291, 32
1140:
1141: %ages of E gals from IR spectra
1142: \reference{} Bregman, J. N., Temi, P. \&
1143: Bregman, J. D. 2006, ApJ, 647, 265
1144:
1145: %unusual PAH emission from NGC 4697
1146: \reference{} Bregman, J. D., Bregman, J. N. \& Temi, P. 2006,
1147: to appear in {\it The Spitzer Science Center 2005
1148: Conference: Infrared Diagnostics of Galaxy Evolution},
1149: (astro-ph/0604369)
1150:
1151: %\reference{} Bressan, A. et al. to appear in
1152: %{\it The Spitzer Science Center 2005
1153: %Conference: Infrared Diagnostics of Galaxy Evolution},
1154: %(astro-ph/0604068)
1155:
1156: %Spitzer IRS spectra of Virgo early-type galaxies; silicate em.
1157: \reference{} Bressan, A. et al. 2006, ApJ, 639, L55
1158:
1159: \reference{} Buote, D. A., Lewis, A. D., Brighenti, F. \&
1160: Mathews, W. G. 2003, ApJ, 594, 741
1161:
1162: \reference{} Buson, L. M. et al. 1993, A\&A, 280, 409
1163:
1164: \reference{} Caon, N., Macchetto, D. \& Pastoriza, M. 2000,
1165: ApJS, 127, 39
1166:
1167: \reference{} Demoulin-Ulrich, M. H., Butcher, H. R. \&
1168: Boksenberg, A. 1984, ApJ, 285, 527
1169:
1170: \reference{} Draine, B. T. \& Anderson, N. 1985,
1171: ApJ, 292, 494
1172:
1173: \reference{} Fazio, G. G. et al. 2004, ApJS, 154, 10
1174:
1175: \reference{} Goudfrooij, P., Hansen, L, Jorgensen, H. E.,
1176: \& Norgaard-Nielsen, H. U. 1994, A\&AS, 105, 341
1177:
1178: \reference{} Hopkins, P. F., Narayan, R., Hernquist, L.,
1179: 2006, ApJ, 643, 641
1180:
1181: \reference{} Jones, C., Forman, W., Vikhlinin, A.,
1182: Markevitch, M., David, L., Warmflash, A., Murray, S.,
1183: \& Nulsen, P. E. J. 202, ApJ, 567, L115
1184:
1185: \reference{} Krishna Kumar, D. \& Thonnard, N.
1186: 1983, AJ, 88, 260
1187:
1188: \reference{} Lauer, T., R. et al. 2005, AJ, 129, 2138
1189:
1190: \reference{} Loewenstein, M., et al. 2001, ApJ, 555, L21
1191:
1192: \reference{} O'Sullivan, E., Vrtilk, J. M. \& Kempner,
1193: J. C. 2005, ApJ, 624, L77
1194:
1195:
1196: \reference{} Mathews, W. G. 1989, AJ, 97, 42
1197:
1198: \reference{} Mathews, W. G. \& Brighenti, F. 2003,
1199: ApJ, 590, L5
1200:
1201: %formation of low mass stars in CFs
1202: \reference{} Mathews, W. G. \& Brighenti, F. 1999,
1203: ApJ, 526, 114
1204:
1205: %time-dept circulation flows
1206: \reference{} Mathews, W. G., Brighenti, F. \&
1207: Buote, D. A. 2004, ApJ, 615, 662
1208:
1209: %\reference{} Nagar, N. M., Falcke, H., Wilson, A. S. \&
1210: %Ho, L. C. 2000, ApJ, 542, 186
1211:
1212: \reference{} Phillips, J. P. \& Ramos-Larios, G. 2006,
1213: MNRAS, 368, 1773
1214:
1215: \reference{} Piovan, L, Tantalo, R.,\& Chiosi, C. 2003,
1216: A\&A, 408, 559
1217:
1218: \reference{} Poulain, P. 1988, A\&AS, 72, 215
1219: \reference{} Poulain, P. \& Nieto, J.-L. 1994, A\&AS, 103, 573
1220:
1221: \reference{} Ravindranath, S. et al. 2001, AJ, 122, 653
1222:
1223: \reference{} Stanger, V. \& Warwick, R. 1986, MNRAS, 220, 363
1224:
1225: \reference{} Sutherland, R. S. \& Dopita, M. A. 1993,
1226: ApJS, 88, 253
1227:
1228: \reference{} Temi, P., Brighenti, F., \& Mathews, W. G. 2007,
1229: ApJ (in press) (astro-ph/0701431)
1230:
1231: \reference{} Temi, P., Mathews, W. G., Brighenti, F., \&
1232: Bregman, J. D. 2003, ApJ, 585, L121
1233:
1234: \reference{} Tonry, J. et al. 2001, ApJ, 546, 681
1235:
1236: %\reference{} Tsai, J. C. \& Mathews, W. G. 1996, ApJ,
1237: %468, 571
1238:
1239: \reference{} Tsai, J. C. \& Mathews, W. G. 1995, ApJ,
1240: 448, 84
1241:
1242: \reference{} Whittle, M., Rosario, D. J., Silverman, J. D.,
1243: Nelson, C. H. \& Wilson, A. S. 2005, ApJ, 129, 104
1244:
1245: \reference{} Zeilinger, W. W. et al. 1996, A\&AS, 120, 257
1246:
1247: \end{references}
1248:
1249:
1250: \clearpage
1251: \begin{figure}%1
1252: \figurenum{1}
1253: \centering
1254: \vskip2.in
1255: %%\includegraphics[bb=90 216 522 569,scale=0.9,angle= 270]
1256: %\includegraphics[bb=90 166 522 519,scale=1.0,angle= 0]
1257: \includegraphics[bb=50 166 422 619,scale=0.8,angle=90]{f1.ps}
1258: %\vskip.7in
1259: \caption{Comparison of optical, infrared and X-ray emission
1260: from NGC 5044.
1261: The physical scale is 160 parsecs/${\prime\prime}$.
1262: The top three panels from left to right
1263: show {\it Spitzer} images
1264: at (1) 160 $\mu$m, (2) 70 $\mu$m,
1265: and (3) 8 $\mu$m.
1266: A small source about
1267: 20$^{\prime\prime}$ to the East of the center of NGC 5044,
1268: is revealed in the 8 $\mu$m image. This source is
1269: coincident with a point-like source in the $B-I$ image of
1270: Goudfrooij et al. (1994) and appears as a background galaxy
1271: in the HST image.
1272: The second row of panels from left to right shows:
1273: (1) the difference image 8-4.5 $\mu$m,
1274: (2) isophotes of H$\alpha$+[NII] emission
1275: from warm gas in NGC 5044 taken from Goudfrooij et al. (1994) and
1276: (3) isophotes from the {\it Chandra}
1277: X-ray images superimposed on an optical image from the
1278: Digital Sky Survey.
1279: Surface brightness values in the color bars are presented in units
1280: of $\mu Jy/arcsec^2$.
1281: }
1282: \label{f1}
1283: \end{figure}
1284:
1285: \clearpage
1286: \begin{figure}%2
1287: \figurenum{2}
1288: \centering
1289: \vskip2.in
1290: %%\includegraphics[bb=90 216 522 569,scale=0.9,angle= 270]
1291: %\includegraphics[bb=90 166 522 519,scale=1.0,angle= 0]
1292: \includegraphics[bb=50 166 422 619,scale=0.8,angle=90]{f2.ps}
1293: %\vskip.7in
1294: \caption{Comparison of optical, infrared and X-ray emission
1295: from NGC 4636.
1296: The physical scale is 73 parsecs/${\prime\prime}$.
1297: The top three panels from left to right show {\it Spitzer} images
1298: at (1) 160 $\mu$m, (2) 70 $\mu$m,
1299: and (3) the difference image 8-4.5 $\mu$m.
1300: Surface brightness values in the color bars are presented in units
1301: of $\mu Jy/arcsec^2$.
1302: The second row of panels from left to right
1303: shows: (1) isophotes of H$\alpha$+[NII] emission
1304: from warm gas in NGC 4636 taken from Caon et al. (2000) and
1305: (2) isophotes from the {\it Chandra}
1306: X-ray images superimposed on an optical image from the
1307: Digital Sky Survey.
1308: }
1309: \label{f2}
1310: \end{figure}
1311:
1312:
1313:
1314: \clearpage
1315: \begin{figure}%3
1316: \figurenum{3}
1317: \centering
1318: %\vskip2.in
1319: %%\includegraphics[bb=90 216 522 569,scale=0.9,angle= 270]
1320: %\includegraphics[bb=90 166 522 519,scale=1.0,angle= 0]
1321: \includegraphics[bb=50 236 422 669]{f3.ps}
1322: %\vskip.7in
1323: \caption{
1324: Solid circles show {\it Spitzer} MIPS flux observations
1325: for NGC 5044 and 4638 at 24, 70 and 160 $\mu$m.
1326: The lower two thin curves show the far-infrared
1327: steady state dust SED expected
1328: from normal stellar mass loss balanced
1329: by sputtering destruction in the hot gas.
1330: The short-dashed and solid lines show the
1331: SED based on initial grain size distributions with maxima
1332: at $a_{max} = 1$ and 0.3 $\mu$m respectively.
1333: These models are clearly insufficient to explain the
1334: observations of either galaxy -- an additional source
1335: of extended dust is required.
1336: Each panel shows several models of the dust SED with extra dust,
1337: designed to fit the interstellar 70 and 160 $\mu$m
1338: fluxes (but not 24 $\mu$m which is circumstellar).
1339: As explained in the text, these models are characterized
1340: by two parameters $(f_{\alpha},r_{ex})$ which have the
1341: following values:
1342: {\it Upper panel:} (300,5kpc) ({\it dotted line}),
1343: (165,10kpc) ({\it long-dashed line}),
1344: (800,2kpc) ({\it dash-dotted line});
1345: {\it Lower panel:} (60,4kpc) ({\it dotted line}),
1346: (26,10kpc) ({\it long-dashed line}),
1347: (133,2kpc) ({\it dash-dotted line}).
1348: }
1349: \label{f3}
1350: \end{figure}
1351:
1352: \clearpage
1353: \begin{figure}%4
1354: \figurenum{4}
1355: \centering
1356: \vskip2.in
1357: %%\includegraphics[bb=90 216 522 569,scale=0.9,angle= 270]
1358: %\includegraphics[bb=90 166 522 519,scale=1.0,angle= 0]
1359: \includegraphics{f4.ps}
1360: %\vskip.7in
1361: \caption{ {\it Hubble Space Telescope} images of the
1362: central $\sim 1-2$ kpc in NGC 5044 (left panel)
1363: and 4636 (right panel).
1364: The optical dust maps were generated from archival HST data
1365: recorded with the Wide Field and Planetary
1366: Camera 2 (WFPC2) using the broad-band filters F791W and F547M.
1367: We first modeled the stellar contribution, recorded in the
1368: broad--band image, with elliptical isophotes using a two pass
1369: procedure to properly mask out and remove bad pixels and
1370: background/foreground objects.
1371: The dust map
1372: was then generated from the ratio of the continuum image over
1373: its purely stellar isophotal model.
1374: Dust absorption features are evident as
1375: dark filamentary structures in the maps.
1376: }
1377: \label{f4}
1378: \end{figure}
1379:
1380:
1381: \clearpage
1382: \begin{figure}[ht]%5
1383: \figurenum{5}
1384: \centering
1385: %\vskip2.in
1386: %%\includegraphics[bb=90 216 522 569,scale=0.9,angle= 270]
1387: %\includegraphics[bb=90 166 522 519,scale=1.0,angle= 0]
1388: \vskip2.in
1389: %orig bb is BoundingBox: 22 16 596 784
1390: %\includegraphics[bb=70 166 422 669,angle=-90]
1391: %\includegraphics[bb=192 236 536 554,angle=-90,scale=0.8]
1392: %\includegraphics[bb=62 256 526 554,angle=-90]
1393: \includegraphics[bb=62 256 526 554,angle=-90]
1394: %[bb=50 236 422 669]22 236 596 554
1395: {f5.ps}
1396: \vskip.7in
1397: \caption{
1398: Approximate radial evolution of dust cooling in the
1399: constant-velocity buoyant outflow in NGC 5044.
1400: {\it Top panel:} temperature (K) of a dust-free buoyant element
1401: (long-dashed line) and dust-filled buoyant element
1402: (short-dashed line) compared to that of the ambient gas (solid line),
1403: {\it Second panel:} electron density (cm$^{-3}$) of the buoyant element
1404: (long-dashed line) compared to that of the ambient gas (solid line)
1405: and that in dusty buoyant gas (short-dashed line),
1406: {\it Third panel:} time $t_7$ in $10^7$ yrs for the buoyant element
1407: to reach each radius (short-dashed line),
1408: radius $a_{\mu}$ of the grains in microns (short-dashed line),
1409: {\it Bottom panel:} radiative cooling coefficient
1410: $\Lambda_{gas}$ (lower short-dashed line)
1411: and dust-assisted cooling coefficient
1412: $\Lambda_{dust}$ (upper short-dashed line), both in erg cm$^{3}$ s$^{-1}$.
1413: }
1414: \label{f5}
1415: \end{figure}
1416:
1417:
1418: \clearpage
1419: \begin{figure}%6
1420: \figurenum{6}
1421: \centering
1422: \vskip2.in
1423: %%\includegraphics[bb=90 216 522 569,scale=0.9,angle= 270]
1424: %\includegraphics[bb=90 166 522 519,scale=1.0,angle= 0]
1425: \includegraphics[angle=0]
1426: {f6.ps}
1427: %\vskip.7in
1428: \caption{
1429: {\it Left Panel:} An H$\alpha$+[NII] image of NGC 4636
1430: from Zeilinger et al. (1996) also showing the orientation
1431: of their slit spectra. These authors note that the slits
1432: are centered about 1.5$^{\prime\prime}$ from the galactic center.
1433: {\it Right Panel:}
1434: {\it Chandra} X-ray image from the {\it Chandra}
1435: archives with approximate radio contours of the double jet
1436: based on Birkinshaw \& Davies (1985) and Stanger \& Warwick (1986).
1437: The contours are symmetric about
1438: the green cross that shows the position of the galactic center
1439: based on a compromise between images from the Digital Sky Survey
1440: and the centroid of the HST stellar image.
1441: }
1442: \label{f6}
1443: \end{figure}
1444:
1445:
1446: \end{document}
1447: