1: \documentclass[12pt,preprint]{aastex}
2: %\usepackage{natbib}
3: %\citestyle{aa}
4: \slugcomment{Draft Version Jun 22, 2007}
5:
6: % revise version (last update2007.05.07.)
7:
8: \shorttitle{Triggering Mechanism for a Filament Eruption}
9:
10: \begin{document}
11:
12:
13: \title{Triggering Mechanism for the Filament Eruption
14: on 2005 September 13
15: in Active Region NOAA 10808}
16:
17: \author{Kaori Nagashima\altaffilmark{1,2},
18: Hiroaki Isobe\altaffilmark{3},
19: Takaaki Yokoyama\altaffilmark{3},
20: Takako T. Ishii\altaffilmark{2},
21: Takenori J. Okamoto\altaffilmark{2},
22: and Kazunari Shibata\altaffilmark{2}}
23:
24: \altaffiltext{1}{Department of Astronomy, Kyoto University,
25: Sakyo-ku, Kyoto 606-8502, Japan; kaorin@kwasan.kyoto-u.ac.jp}
26: \altaffiltext{2}{Kwasan and Hida Observatories, Kyoto University,
27: Yamashina-ku, Kyoto 607-8471, Japan}
28: \altaffiltext{3}{Department of Earth and Planetary Science, University of Tokyo, Hongo, Bunkyo-ku, Tokyo 113-0033, Japan}
29:
30: \begin{abstract}
31: On 2005 September 13
32: a filament eruption accompanied by a halo CME
33: occurred in
34: the most flare-productive active region NOAA 10808
35: in Solar Cycle 23.
36: Using multi-wavelength observations
37: before the filament eruption on Sep.~13th,
38: we investigate the processes leading to the catastrophic eruption.
39: We find that the
40: filament slowly ascended at a speed of $0.1 {\rm km \ s^{-1}}$
41: over two days before the eruption.
42: During slow ascending,
43: many small flares were observed
44: close to the footpoints of the filament,
45: where new magnetic elements were emerging.
46: On the basis of the observational facts
47: we discuss the triggering mechanism leading to the
48: filament eruption.
49: %We suggest that
50: We suggest the process toward the eruption as follows:
51: First, a series of small flares played a role in changing the
52: topology of the loops overlying the filament.
53: Second, the small flares gradually changed the
54: equilibrium state of the filament
55: and caused the filament to ascend slowly over two days.
56: Finally, a C2.9 flare that
57: occurred when the filament was close to
58: the critical point for loss
59: of equilibrium directly led to the catastrophic filament
60: eruption right after itself.
61: \end{abstract}
62:
63: \keywords{Sun: coronal mass ejections (CMEs) ---
64: Sun: filaments --- Sun: flares}
65:
66: %%%%
67:
68:
69: \section{Introduction}
70: Investigating the triggering mechanism of filament eruption
71: is one of the most important subjects in the field of space
72: weather, because
73: such ejections of plasma and magnetic fields from the sun
74: lead to a significant disturbance
75: of the magnetosphere and affect human life.
76: %%% Yurchyshyn et al. 2001 ApJ
77: It is widely accepted that
78: flares, filament eruptions and coronal mass ejections (CMEs) are
79: %attributed to the magnetic energy release
80: different aspects of the same physical process
81: including plasma ejection and magnetic energy release
82: (see \citealt{1995ApJ...451L..83S};
83: \citealt{2000JGR...10523153F}).
84: Several precursor signatures were reported
85: \citep{1980SoPh...68..217M}.
86: However, what directly
87: triggers such catastrophic eruptive events is not yet understood.
88: Many theoretical models were proposed so far
89: (e.g., \citealt{1992LNP...399...69M},
90: \citealt{1999ApJ...510..485A})
91: %\citealt{2001ApJ...552..833M}).
92: As a catastrophe model for CMEs,
93: \citet{1990JGR....9511919F} and \citet{1991ApJ...373..294F}
94: proposed the loss of equilibrium.
95: Using a two-dimensional numerical simulation,
96: \citet{1990JGR....9511919F}
97: confirmed that when the filament current exceeds a
98: critical value, the stable configuration containing the filament
99: loses equilibrium.
100: When equilibrium is lost, the filament is magnetically driven
101: upward and may evolve into a CME.
102: \citet{2000ApJ...545..524C} and \citet{2001JGR...10625053L}
103: proposed the emerging flux triggering mechanism for filament
104: eruptions and CMEs, motivated by the observed correlation
105: between reconnection-favored emerging flux and CMEs
106: (e.g. \citealt{1995JGR...100.3355F},
107: \citealt{1999ApJ...510L.157W}).
108:
109: From the observational point of view, however,
110: conclusions reported in literatures have not converged yet
111: in that which model is the best as the triggering mechanism of
112: eruptive events.
113: Therefore, accumulation of detailed analyses of
114: individual events is still necessary to understand
115: the physical mechanisms of solar
116: eruptions as well as to construct empirical models toward
117: space weather forecast.
118: In order to extract the essential physics and to compare with the
119: existing theories, those events whose magnetic configuration
120: is as simple as possible may be suitable.
121: On the other hand, flare-productive active regions usually have
122: very complex magnetic structures.
123: From the viewpoint of space weather, we wish to understand
124: and predict the eruptions from such complex active regions.
125:
126: Therefore, in this paper we focus on the eruptive events
127: in active region NOAA 10808
128: which appeared in September 2005 and showed the
129: most furious flare activity during
130: the current solar cycle (cycle 23).
131: To have a clear view of the mechanism of the filament eruption
132: in this region,
133: we examined extensively the observational signatures
134: that may lead to the filament eruption
135: using various available data.
136: We find several interesting features
137: that might help to understand
138: the physical mechanism of the eruption.
139: One of those is that the filament
140: that erupted on Sep.~13th gradually deviated from the
141: magnetic neutral line
142: over two days.
143: The speed of this ascending motion is approximately
144: $0.1 {\rm km \ s^{-1}}$.
145: Another feature is the sites where C- and M-class flares occurred
146: during the period of ascending motion.
147: In these sites magnetic elements emerged and moved markedly.
148: %In this paper,
149: We discuss a plausible triggering mechanism of the eruption,
150: considering these features as the clues.
151: Independent analyses of this filament eruption
152: were carried out by
153: \citet{2007Chifor} and \citet{2007Wang}.
154:
155: In \S \ref{sec:NOAA10808}, we give
156: an overview of active region NOAA 10808.
157: We describe the observations of
158: a filament eruption that occurred on 2005 September 13
159: in \S \ref{sec:20050913X15}
160: and the long-time evolution of the filament in
161: \S \ref{sec:filament_evolution}.
162: Discussions and conclusions are given in
163: \S \S \ref{sec:10808Discussion} and
164: \ref{sec:10808conclusion}, respectively.
165:
166:
167: \section{Overview of the active region}
168: \label{sec:NOAA10808}
169: In September 2005, a flare-productive
170: active region appeared on the solar disk.
171: Active Region NOAA 10808 appeared over
172: the east limb on
173: 2005 September 7 and produced at least 10 X-class
174: and 25 M-class flares until it disappeared behind the disk.
175: Figure \ref{fig:GOES_lc} shows the {\it GOES} soft X-ray
176: lightcurve of the period when this active region was on the disk.
177: Since no other strong active region was on the disk
178: during this period,
179: almost all the flares shown in this figure were attributed
180: to this active region. This is the most intense flare
181: activity during Solar Cycle 23
182: despite in the declining phase of the cycle.
183: After crossing the meridian the active region seemed to
184: decay remarkably and most of the X-class flares occurred
185: in the eastern hemisphere.
186: Some flares were accompanied by CMEs;
187: however, they were not so geoeffective.
188: (See \citealt{2006ApJ...646..625W}.)
189:
190:
191: It should be noted that
192: this active region was the return of active region NOAA 10798
193: of the previous month.
194: The active region NOAA 10798 emerged into a coronal hole
195: near the disk center
196: and formed a sea-anemone-type active region
197: \citep{1994ApJ...431L..51S}.
198: By the time it rotated over the limb,
199: two M-class flares accompanied with halo CMEs occurred and
200: caused a large geomagnetic storm with the minimum Dst
201: index of $-216 {\rm nT}$ \citep{2006IAUJD...3E..72A}.
202: %(Asai et al. private communication).
203:
204: In Figure \ref{fig:AR_evolution},
205: four sets of images show
206: the evolution of the active region.
207: Each set has white-light image, photospheric magnetogram,
208: and H$\alpha$ image co-aligned with each other.
209: The white-light images were taken by
210: {\it Transition Region And Coronal Explorer}
211: ({\it TRACE}; \citealt{1999SoPh..187..229H}).
212: The magnetograms are those from
213: Michelson Doppler Imager
214: (MDI; \citealt{1995SoPh..162..129S}) onboard
215: the {\it Solar and Heliospheric Observatory} ({\it SOHO}).
216: The H$\alpha$ images were clipped
217: from the full-disk images obtained by
218: Solar Magnetic Activity Research Telescope (SMART;
219: %\citealt{2004SPIE.5492..958U})
220: \citealt{2004ASPC..325..319U})
221: at Hida Observatory, Kyoto University.
222:
223:
224:
225: At the center of the active region there was
226: a delta-type sunspot which has two umbrae with
227: different magnetic polarities packed tightly
228: within a single penumbra.
229: It showed a
230: counter-clockwise rotational motion.
231: The direction of the motion was such that
232: the orientation of the two polarities of the delta-type spot
233: approaches the so-called
234: %toward that fits to so-called
235: ``Hale's polarity law'' \citep{1919ApJ....49..153H}.
236: According to Hale's law, in southern hemisphere
237: the leading and following spots have
238: negative and positive polarities, respectively,
239: during Solar Cycle 23.
240: The delta-type spot is surrounded by more diffuse magnetic field
241: that satisfies Hale's law.
242: Running through the delta-type sunspot,
243: there was an S-shaped neutral line in this active region
244: (see Figure \ref{fig:AR_evolution};
245: details are given in \S \ref{sec:20050913X15}).
246: Along the neutral line dark filaments were seen in H$\alpha$ images
247: in Figure \ref{fig:AR_evolution}.
248: We find that when halo CMEs occurred on Sep.~9th, 11th, and 13th,
249: the east part of the filaments erupted.
250: Although the other halo CME occurred on Sep.~10th,
251: we cannot identify the source region of the CME due to lack of
252: EUV and H$\alpha$ data.
253: Among these events, we focus on the filament eruption
254: that occurred on Sep.~13th to understand the
255: mechanism of flares and
256: their relationship to the processes of eruptive events
257: in this active region.
258:
259:
260:
261: \section{Filament eruption on 2005 September 13}
262: \label{sec:20050913X15}
263:
264: On 2005 September 13, an X1.5 class flare occurred
265: near the disk center in the super active region NOAA 10808.
266: This flare was accompanied by filament eruptions and
267: a halo CME.
268: % ref. Zhang et al. 2001 APJL
269: A chronological description of the event is
270: summarized in Table \ref{tab:050913X15}.
271: % ref. Chifor et al. 2006
272: Hereafter, this event is referred as ``the X1.5 event''.
273:
274:
275:
276:
277: Figure \ref{fig:GOES_lc_0913} shows
278: {\it GOES} soft X-ray light curves during this event.
279: The {\it GOES} 1-8\AA \ flux began to increase
280: at 19:19 and attained its peak at 19:27.
281: % ref. Yurchysyn et al. 2006 SoPh
282: At the time of {\it GOES} flux peak,
283: two filaments erupted:
284: the inner one (hereafter referred as filament 2)
285: brightened and erupted,
286: the outer one (referred as filament 1)
287: remained dark and seemed to ascend following filament 2.
288: Figure \ref{fig:TRACE195_0913X15} describes the
289: motion of the filaments as they appeared
290: in 195 \AA \ images
291: % ref. Chifor et al. 2006 A&A
292: taken by {\it TRACE}.
293:
294:
295: Figure \ref{fig:timeslice_filerup} shows the height-time
296: profile for the erupting filaments along the slit shown in
297: Figure \ref{fig:0913X15event}b %\ref{fig:timeslice_slit}
298: as observed from {\it TRACE} 195 \AA \ images.
299: This height-time profile shows
300: filament 2 brightened and rapidly erupted
301: at a velocity of $1.5 \times 10^2 \ \rm{km \ s^{-1}}$
302: (white dot-dashed line).
303: Filament 1 remained dark and seemed
304: to follow bright filament 2 at a speed of
305: $5.8 \times 10 \ {\rm km \ s^{-1}}$ (black dashed line);
306: the upward velocity increased up to
307: $2.5 \times 10^2 \ \rm{km \ s^{-1}}$ (white dashed line).
308: Such motions of the filaments are also recognizable in
309: Figure \ref{fig:TRACE195_0913X15}.
310:
311:
312: Figure \ref{fig:0913X15event} explains the magnetic structure of
313: the active region and the locations of the filaments and the
314: flares.
315: Figure \ref{fig:0913X15event}a %\ref{fig:TRACE195_mag_0913X15}
316: shows the {\it SOHO} MDI magnetogram overlaid on the
317: {\it TRACE} 195 \AA \ image before the eruption.
318: In this region,
319: there was an S-shaped neutral line %in this active region
320: running through the delta-type sunspot as shown in
321: Figure \ref{fig:0913X15event}d.
322: The filament eruption
323: occurred along all the southeast part of this neutral line.
324: At the same time of the eruption the flare core brightened in EUV
325: on the east side of the delta-type sunspot
326: along the neutral line; this region is labeled as region C
327: (see Figure \ref{fig:0913X15event}d).
328: Region C is characterized by
329: several small negative-polarity magnetic elements moving
330: one after another
331: from the negative-polarity umbra in the delta-type spot
332: (see Figure \ref{fig:MDI_preflare}
333: and \S \ref{section:regionC} for detail).
334: Another characteristic site in the magnetograms
335: is on the opposite side of the neutral line from region C.
336: In this region, hereafter referred as region T, many
337: magnetic elements flowed out near the neutral line
338: (See Figure \ref{fig:MDI_preflare} and \S \ref{section:regionT}
339: for detail).
340: As discussed in \S \ref{sec:preflare},
341: many small (C- and M-class) flares
342: occurred in regions C
343: and T before the X1.5 event.
344: These characteristic magnetic regions
345: are summarized in Figure \ref{fig:0913X15event}f
346: with their characteristic motions
347: indicated by arrows.
348: In this panel, filaments are indicated by gray lines:
349: Filament 1 (F1) originally appeared above the S-shaped neutral line
350: and gradually deviated southeastward, while filament 2 (F2)
351: appeared above the neutral line by the time the X1.~5
352: event occurred.
353:
354:
355: Although the initiation of the filament eruption was unclear
356: in EUV because {\it TRACE} satellite
357: was in the South Atlantic Anomaly (SAA) during the period,
358: the first flare brightening in H$\alpha$ blue wing
359: (H$\alpha -0.6$ \AA)
360: was observed right before the eruption of filaments 1 and 2.
361: Figure \ref{fig:0913X15event}c
362: shows an H$\alpha$ wing (H$\alpha -0.6$ \AA) image
363: taken at the Big Bear Solar Observatory (BBSO).
364: The brightening began from region C as shown in Figure
365: \ref{fig:0913X15event}c,
366: and expanded southeastward along the S-shaped neutral line.
367: After the filament eruption,
368: flare ribbons formed along the
369: S-shaped neutral line which are shown in {\it TRACE} 1600
370: \AA \ images
371: in Figure \ref{fig:0913X15event}e. %\ref{fig:TR1600_ribbon}.
372:
373: After the filament eruption mentioned above,
374: a more faint eruptive event occurred in the south part
375: of the active region at around 20:00 UT, i.e., at the second peak
376: of {\it GOES} flux.
377: Footpoints of this erupting filament were located
378: on the west of the delta-type sunspot and
379: close to the post flare loops in the southeast of
380: the active region.
381:
382:
383:
384: These erupting events
385: seemed to evolve into a white-light halo CME.
386: According to CME
387: catalogue\footnote{http://cdaw.gsfc.nsa.gov/CME\_list}
388: \citep{2004JGRA..10907105Y},
389: this event is recognized as a halo CME
390: with the projected speed of $1866 {\rm km\ s^{-1}}$.
391: In {\it SOHO} LASCO C2 images, two blobs were observed;
392: the second bright core is thought to be related to the
393: second eruption at 20:00 UT,
394: because its launch time is estimated at around
395: that time on the basis of the linear extrapolation of its track.
396:
397: \section{Long-time evolution of filaments}
398: \label{sec:filament_evolution}
399:
400:
401: Before Sep.~13th eruption (the X1.5 event),
402: we can see two filaments
403: in the southeast part of the active region:
404: The outer one (filament 1)
405: and the inner one (filament 2).
406: They formed after another filament eruption on Sep.~11th.
407: We concentrate on the evolution of these filaments
408: after the eruption on Sep.~11th.
409: We find that filament 1 continuously deviated from the neutral
410: line from 11th to 13th.
411: Figure \ref{fig:long_timeslice} shows the time evolution of
412: EUV intensity along the slit shown in Figure
413: \ref{fig:0913X15event}b.
414: Asterisked line indicates the position of the magnetic
415: neutral line.
416: This figure shows that the filament seemed to
417: separate from the neutral line at a
418: nearly constant speed of $0.12 {\rm km \ s^{-1}}$
419: over more than
420: 40 hours, while the filament accelerated to
421: $200 - 300 {\rm km \ s^{-1}}$ when it erupted
422: as mentioned in \S \ref{sec:20050913X15}.
423: Although we see only the plane-of-sky motion of the
424: filament separating from the neutral line,
425: we can interpret it as an ascending motion
426: by taking into account the projection effect.
427: Such a slow and long-lasting ascending motion is
428: %not the motion during so-called slow-rise phase of
429: probably different from
430: so-called slow-rise phase of the erupting filaments,
431: such as those reported by \citet{1997PASJ...49..249O}
432: (see also
433: \citealt{1988ApJ...328..824K},
434: \citealt{1990HvaOB..14...37R},
435: \citealt{2001ApJ...559..452Z},
436: \citealt{2004ApJ...613.1221S}).
437: \citet{2006A&A...458..965C} reported the early evolution of
438: a prominence eruption observed on 2005 July 27.
439: Slow-rise at a speed of $4.8 {\rm km \ s^{-1}}$ was observed
440: over 30 minutes prior to the fast-rise phase during which
441: the filament accelerated up to $300 {\rm km \ s^{-1}}$.
442: Since the slow ascending motion continues much longer than
443: those in the previously reported events,
444: we believe the physical mechanism is different.
445: \citet{2006A&A...449L..17I} and
446: \citet{2007preprint...Isobe} reported
447: an observation of slow rising motion ($1 {\rm km s^{-1}}$)
448: of a polar crown filament that last for more than 10 hours
449: before it finally erupted.
450: They found a large amplitude oscillation of the filament
451: during the slow rising, and hence concluded that
452: the filament retained a stable equilibrium and
453: the rising motion is a quasi-static evolution.
454: This may be the same phenomenon as our long-lasting
455: slow rise.
456: Existence of such long-term slow rise has been
457: also pointed out by S. Martin (private communication).
458:
459:
460:
461: It should be noted that
462: filament 1 showed active motion along its axis
463: in {\it TRACE} EUV images and SMART H$\alpha$ images
464: during its slowly ascending, i.e., over two days
465: (e.g., \citealt{1980SoPh...68..217M}).
466:
467:
468:
469:
470: \section{Preflare brightenings on Sep.~12th and 13th}
471: \label{sec:preflare}
472: \sectionmark{Preflare brightenings}
473:
474: \subsection{All M- and C-class flares}
475:
476: During the slow rise of the filament,
477: several M- and C-class flares and small brightenings in EUV
478: occurred in this active region.
479: As shown between the dashed lines in Figure \ref{fig:GOES_lc},
480: 5 M-class and 18 C-class flares occurred since 00:00 UT on
481: Sep.~12th until the X1.5 flare on Sep.~13th.
482: All of these flares are listed in Table \ref{tab:MCclassflares}
483: and the locations on the magnetogram %of them are shown
484: are shown in Figure \ref{fig:MCflares_ichi}.
485: These flares can be categorized into four groups:
486: (I) eruptive events along the S-shaped neutral line
487: (the X1.5 event),
488: (II) brightenings around filaments
489: on the east side of the delta-type spot (region C),
490: (III) local events in the emerging flux region (region T),
491: (IV) small jets in the northeast
492: part of the active region.
493: Since small jets (group IV) were localized events and
494: were not attributed to the S-shaped neutral line,
495: we consider that these events
496: did not have direct influence on the X1.5 event.
497: {\it TRACE} 195 \AA \ images of groups II, III, and IV
498: are shown in Figure \ref{fig:MCflares}.
499:
500:
501:
502:
503:
504: Group I is the filament eruption
505: during the X1.5 event on Sep.~13th itself.
506: We consider the other smaller events (groups II and III)
507: which occurred along the S-shaped neutral line
508: as a key to find out the triggering mechanism of the X1.5 event.
509: First, we focus on the events occurred in region C (group II)
510: to consider the eruptive process of the X1.5 event.
511: Next, we consider the last local event (group III) right before the
512: X1.5 event to consider the direct triggering mechanism of the
513: X1.5 event.
514:
515:
516: \subsection{Filaments in region C and M1.5 and M6.1 flares on Sep.~12th}
517: \label{section:regionC}
518:
519: One of the puzzling points in the X1.5 event is that
520: although the flare ribbon extended throughout the S-shaped
521: neutral line, the filament was visible
522: only in the southeast part of the neutral line.
523: We suggest that an eruptive process did occur in region C
524: as well, even though we did not observe an filament during
525: the X1.5 event. The magnetic topology may be either
526: a flux rope (e.g., \citealt{1989ApJ...344.1010P};
527: \citealt{1996SoPh..167..217L})
528: or a sheared arcade (e.g., \citealt{1994ApJ...420L..41A}).
529:
530: A filament was actually visible in region C sometimes
531: during Sep.~12th and 13th.
532: An M1.5 flare occurred in region C at 5:05 UT on 12th.
533: An EUV brightening seemed to be
534: located under a dark filament in region C.
535: Neither eruption nor a CME was
536: observed during this event.
537: Some loops overlying the dark filament
538: brightened after the main phase.
539: Four hours after the M1.5 flare,
540: an M6.1 class flare occurred at 9:03 UT.
541: Figure \ref{fig:regionCfil} shows
542: {\it TRACE} 195 \AA \ images of this event.
543: In this event, brightening in EUV started from region C.
544: A thin dark filament in region C
545: was lifted up %by the brightening loop
546: and seemed to erupt at 8:46 UT, i.e.,
547: the first peak of the GOES soft X-ray flux.
548: The thin dark filament twined around the brightening loop.
549: When the brightening loop expanded the dark filament
550: erupted.
551: Although the dark filament could not be identified clearly after
552: its eruption, according to CME catalog
553: \citep{2004JGRA..10907105Y},
554: a narrow CME was observed by {\it SOHO} LASCO
555: right after this event.
556: A little thin lump of bright coronal emission
557: first appeared in LASCO/C2 field of view at 9:12 UT
558: % Zhou et al. 2006 p.1241
559: and was recognized as a CME with the projected speed
560: of $511 \rm{km \ s^{-1}}$,
561: which is consistent with the assumption
562: that the filament erupted at around 8:46 UT and evolved into a CME.
563:
564: After these flares, a
565: dark filament existed in region C.
566: This filament could be seen in SMART H$\alpha$ wing
567: (H$\alpha \pm 0.5 {\rm \AA}$)
568: images taken at around 3:00 UT on 13th. %by SMART T1. %;
569: We observed ceaseless mass flow along the filament
570: in region C.
571: This is similar to the active motion of the filament 1 along
572: its axis that is mentioned in \S \ref{sec:filament_evolution}.
573:
574:
575: On the basis of the observational features of
576: the small dark filament in region C,
577: we speculate that there was a flux rope
578: or sheared field in region C.
579: Owing to the nonsteady mass flow along the filament
580: in region C, the filament itself was sometimes
581: visible and, another time, was invisible.
582: However, the magnetic field that supported the filament
583: should have existed all the time.
584: Considering the fact that during the X1.5 event
585: the brightening in H$\alpha$ started
586: from region C and extended to the southeast part,
587: we suppose that
588: this eruptive process in region C
589: was the initiation of the X1.5 event
590: even though the filament in region C was invisible
591: at the time of the event.
592: Those observations described in this section
593: support that a flux rope (or whatever plays the role of a filament)
594: did exist in region C even at the time of the X1.5 event on 13th.
595:
596: \subsection{Possible direct trigger for
597: the X1.5 event: C2.9 flare on Sep.~13th}
598: \label{section:regionT}
599: A small brightening in EUV close to the footpoint of
600: filament 2 was observed
601: 40 minutes before the filament eruption.
602: It was recorded as a {\it GOES} C2.9 class flare at 19:05 UT
603: (see Figure \ref{fig:GOES_lc_0913}).
604: We consider this event as the final trigger of the X1.5 event.
605:
606:
607: At the site of the C2.9 flare,
608: successive appearances of small magnetic elements were seen
609: in magnetograms.
610: Figure \ref{fig:miniflare_mag195} shows a series of
611: {\it TRACE} 195 \AA \ images during this event.
612: {\it SOHO} MDI magnetogram contours are overlaid;
613: red and blue contours indicate $\pm 100 {\rm G}$.
614: At around the center of each panel, a small brightening in EUV
615: appeared and jet-like features pointed by the white arrow
616: were observed to the east of the
617: bright loops.
618: These dark jet-like features are also
619: seen in BBSO H$\alpha$ wing (H$\alpha - 0.6{\rm \AA}$) images.
620: These jets and loops moved eastward gradually and
621: the jets also showed a whip-like motion.
622: Moreover, on the left side of bright jet-like features,
623: dark backward flows were observed when we check
624: a {\it TRACE} 195 \AA \ movie of this event
625: (see mpeg animation of Figure \ref{fig:TRACE195_0913X15}).
626: Figure \ref{fig:MDI_preflare} shows a series of
627: MDI magnetograms
628: mainly taken on September 12th and 13th.
629: From the tail part of the S-shaped neutral line,
630: lots of small magnetic elements were flowing out.
631: Although region T was dominated by the negative polarity,
632: patchy magnetic elements with both polarities were emerging.
633: Over the two days before the filament eruption,
634: similar small brightenings in EUV which were identified as
635: C- or sub-C-class flares by {\it GOES}
636: occurred in the similar locations (Figure \ref{fig:MCflares_ichi});
637: C-class events were listed in Table \ref{tab:MCclassflares}.
638: Taking a closer look at the sites of small brightenings,
639: they slightly moved southward with time, but
640: corresponded to the source region of
641: the emerging mixed polarities.
642:
643: It is noteworthy that an element of negative polarity
644: which first appeared in the frame taken at 19:15 UT on Sep 12th
645: (see the second panel in the first row in
646: Figure \ref{fig:MDI_preflare})
647: moved southwestward along the neutral line.
648: It weakened the positive region
649: so that the positive region divided into parts
650: after the X1.5 event (see the magnetogram
651: image taken at 14:27 on Sep.~14th in
652: Figure \ref{fig:MDI_preflare}).
653: This negative element was located at the footpoint of the
654: brightening loop during the C2.9 event at 19:05 UT on Sep.~13th.
655: We examine the motion of the negative element and
656: it yields valuable clues to understand the triggering mechanism
657: of the X1.5 event
658: (see \S \ref{sec:10808Discussion}).
659:
660:
661: It should be noted that
662: small brightenings in EUV 195 \AA \ were also found
663: just before the X1.5 event on the west side of the delta-type spot.
664: In H$\alpha$ wing (H$\alpha-0.6 {\rm \AA}$)
665: images taken at BBSO, the only data taken
666: simultaneously during this period,
667: we cannot identify corresponding brightenings.
668: Although this event occurred in the
669: same period as the C2.9 event
670: we consider that this west-part event did not have
671: a direct influence in triggering the X1.5 event.
672: The reasons are as follows:
673: (1)In this region similar brightenings in EUV were also observed
674: one hour before this event.
675: (2)The dark filament in this region seemed not to be
676: affected by the X1.5 event, and remained as it were
677: after the X1.5 event.
678: (3)Although it located close to the footpoint of the second
679: eruption at around 20:00 UT, the magnetic field lines
680: in this region did not seem to directly connect with
681: those which were involved in the X1.5 event.
682: Another brightening was observed to the northeast
683: of the tail of the S-shaped neutral line
684: (See the center panel in the first row of
685: Figure \ref{fig:TRACE195_0913X15}).
686: We consider that this event was not directly related to
687: the X1.5 event because of similar reasons. %in a similar way.
688:
689:
690: \section{Discussion: Triggering Mechanism of the X1.5 Event}
691: \label{sec:10808Discussion}
692:
693:
694: On the basis of the multi-wavelength observations,
695: we discuss the triggering mechanism of the X1.5 event.
696: As mentioned in the previous section,
697: we considered M- and C-class flares on Sep.~12th and 13th
698: as a key to find out the triggering mechanism of the X1.5 event.
699:
700: % filament formation (2)
701: A filament eruption occurred at 13:12 on Sep.~11th
702: accompanying an M3.0 flare.
703: At least ten hours after this filament eruption,
704: another filament was re-formed along the S-shaped neutral line.
705: After that several M- and C-class flares and
706: small brightenings in EUV occurred in region C and region T.
707: We consider that these small flares played a role in
708: lengthening the magnetic arcades overlying the filaments.
709:
710: %region C flares
711: In region C, the negative elements
712: flowed out from the negative part of
713: the delta-type spot during 12th and 13th.
714: When small flares occurred in region C,
715: such as the M1.5 flare at 05:05 UT on Sep.~12th
716: and the M6.1 flare at 09:03 UT on Sep.~12th,
717: the magnetic field lines connecting to these
718: negative elements reconnected to
719: the loops overlying the filaments in region C;
720: a schematic illustration is shown in
721: Figure \ref{fig:regionC_structure}.
722: Note that the positive element on the left side of the pointed
723: negative element shown in Figures
724: \ref{fig:regionC_structure}b, c, and d
725: was not on line AB shown in Figures
726: \ref{fig:regionC_structure}a in reality;
727: we consider that it was located in the positive side
728: of the delta-type spot.
729: During the events in region C,
730: bright loops crossing over the dark filament were observed.
731: It is the evidence that the loops overlying the filament
732: were involved in the reconnection process as shown in
733: Figure \ref{fig:regionC_structure}.
734: As mentioned in \S \ref{section:regionC},
735: no eruption was observed during all but
736: the M6.1 flare at 09:03 on Sep.~12th;
737: the M6.1 flare was associated with
738: a small filament eruption in region C which
739: appeared to evolve into a CME.
740: We consider that
741: most events only changed the equilibrium state of the filament
742: in region C, while
743: the perturbation at the time of the M6.1 flare was
744: strong enough to trigger the eruption of the filament.
745: However, we consider that
746: all these flares in region C (group II events)
747: occurred in essentially the same way as the mechanism shown in
748: Figure \ref{fig:regionC_structure}.
749:
750: % C & T (in the same way)
751: As for the flares in region T (group III events),
752: we interpret also in a similar way.
753: Although group II and group III were apparently independent events,
754: they were located along a single magnetic neutral line
755: (the S-shaped neutral line; see Figure \ref{fig:0913X15event}f)
756: in the active region.
757: Moreover, during the X1.5 event,
758: throughout the east part of the S-shaped neutral line
759: flare ribbons were observed.
760: Therefore, we suppose that these filaments were
761: different parts of one flux rope or sheared field
762: along the S-shaped neutral line,
763: and similar mechanisms for small flares along the neutral line
764: (group II and III events) are suggested.
765:
766:
767: % slow-rise + C2.9
768: As the reconnection associated with these small flares
769: lengthened overlying loops,
770: the filaments changed its equilibrium state and
771: appeared to deviate from the neutral line.
772: Finally, the filaments erupted after the C2.9 flare
773: that occurred at 19:05 UT on Sep.~13th in region T.
774: We suppose that this small flare was a direct trigger of
775: the filament eruption (the X1.5 event).
776: At that time the filaments were probably
777: very close to the critical point for loss of equilibrium,
778: and were caused by the C2.9 flare to erupt.
779: Magnetic configuration of the C2.9 flare on Sep.~13th
780: is shown in Figure \ref{fig:regionT_structure}.
781: The emerging flux whose footpoint located on the
782: flowing negative element interacted with the loops
783: overlying filament 2. The reconnected loop brightened
784: and a jet-like feature crossing over the filament was observed.
785: This jet-like feature showed a whip-like motion
786: as the magnetic reconnection proceeded.
787:
788:
789: The characteristic features observed during Sep.~12th and 13th
790: are summarized as follows:
791: (1) Filament 1 continuously ascended slowly.
792: (2) Lots of M- and C-class flares occurred at around the footpoints
793: of filaments; however, no eruption was observed during all but the
794: M6.1 flare in region C on Sep.~12th.
795: (3) Although the C2.9 flare on 13th showed the
796: similar magnetic structure to
797: the preceding M- and C-class events and was not
798: a strong event in particular,
799: it seemed to trigger the catastrophic eruption (the X1.5 event).
800: We suggest that a series of
801: small flares triggered the filament eruption
802: through the process of lengthening the overlying arcade
803: by magnetic reconnection.
804: This is consistent with the emerging flux
805: triggering mechanism suggested by \citet{2000ApJ...545..524C}
806: in that magnetic reconnection that occurred
807: in a filament channel triggers a filament eruption.
808: Note that \citet{1993SoPh..143..119W} also suggested
809: two-step magnetic reconnection:
810: The first step of reconnection is a slow reconnection in the lower
811: atmosphere that is observed as flux cancellation, while
812: the flare energy release comes directly from the second step
813: reconnection that is the fast reconnection higher in the corona.
814: However,
815: the fact that lots of small flares occurred around the
816: footpoints of filaments but no eruption was observed except
817: the M6.1 flare on Sep.~12th (feature (2) described above)
818: indicates that
819: magnetic reconnection at the footpoints of filaments is not a
820: sufficient condition for the eruption.
821: In order to trigger the eruption,
822: such reconnection must occur when the filament is
823: close to the critical point for loss of equilibrium; that is
824: why the relatively small (C2.9)
825: flare could trigger the eruption.
826: Since in the initial condition of the
827: simulation of \citet{2000ApJ...545..524C},
828: the flux rope was already set
829: in an equilibrium state very close to instability or
830: loss of equilibrium, once magnetic flux emerges
831: the flux rope can erupt immediately.
832: A loss of equilibrium model was proposed
833: by \citet{1990JGR....9511919F} and \citet{1991ApJ...373..294F}.
834: \citet{1990JGR....9511919F} confirmed
835: by a numerical simulation
836: that when the filament current exceeds a
837: critical value, the stable
838: configuration containing the filament
839: loses equilibrium and the filament may erupt.
840: We suggest the slow and long-lasting
841: ascending motion of the filament
842: presented in this paper corresponds
843: to the change of the equilibrium height of
844: the filament; the filament approaches to the critical point from
845: initially stable
846: equilibrium, as described in the loss of equilibrium model.
847: For our X1.5 event, such change was due to
848: the series of small flares involving the
849: overlying arcade of the filament.
850:
851:
852: It has to be mentioned that
853: we can interpret these processes in another way.
854: In Figure \ref{fig:C29_structure},
855: we show the structure of the C2.9 flare that
856: occurred right before the X1.5 event.
857: In this scenario, we consider the moving magnetic elements played
858: the key role in triggering the filament eruption;
859: at the footpoint of the flux rope labeled as filament 2
860: reconnection occurred and it made
861: the flux rope itself lengthen directly.
862: Then filament 2 erupted and filament 1 that was already
863: approaching certain critical point
864: also erupted in a consequence of eruption of filament 2.
865:
866:
867: Another interesting feature to be noted here is
868: a rising motion of bright structure during the slow rise of
869: the filament indicated by an arrow in the time slice shown
870: in Figure \ref{fig:long_timeslice}.
871: This rising structure corresponds to an apparently swelling loop
872: in {\it TRACE} image. This may be related to `bugle',
873: which was reported by \citet{1993JGR....9813177H}.
874: Bugles were observed as
875: brightening and swelling of the bright belt of coronal
876: streamers several days before a CME, and
877: they suddenly disappeared as the CMEs occurred.
878: They were named so because the shape looks like a bugle
879: on synoptic maps at a given height in the corona.
880: The timescale of bugles is the same order as
881: the slow swelling motion in the corona found in our event,
882: although the size of bugle is much larger.
883: Perhaps the swelling motion is the lower coronal counterpart of a
884: bugle.
885: One of the bugles reported by \citet{1993JGR....9813177H}
886: was investigated by \citet{1995JGR...100.3355F}.
887: During the development of the bugle,
888: a new magnetic flux was observed to emerge below the
889: large-scale arcades.
890: As \citet{2000ApJ...545..524C} suggested,
891: an emerging flux can trigger filament eruptions
892: through the reconnection with the magnetic field lines
893: around the filament.
894: In our event, we found systematic motions of magnetic elements
895: below the filament. Such moving magnetic elements may or may not
896: be related to newly emerging fluxes, but they also can induce the
897: magnetic reconnection that changes the equilibrium state of the
898: filament and triggers its eruption.
899: Therefore, we suggest that (1) both emerging fluxes
900: and moving magnetic elements in the vicinity of filament
901: neutral line can lead a filament to
902: approach the loss of equilibrium, and
903: (2) both the bugles in the high corona and the swelling loops in
904: the low corona are the manifestations of the evolution of coronal
905: field that is approaching to the loss of equilibrium (eruption).
906:
907:
908: Using multi-wavelength data of these events,
909: such as {\it TRACE} EUV 195 \AA \ and 1600 \AA \ data,
910: MDI magnetograms, and BBSO and SMART H$\alpha$ data,
911: we tried to investigate extensively
912: what happened in the active region
913: before the filament eruption.
914: Although we find several interesting features,
915: we cannot find definitive conclusion of what directly triggers
916: such flares in the active region,
917: since the magnetic structure of flares were extremely complex
918: in this region.
919: It is not clear whether
920: one can know the equilibrium properties of a filament
921: (flux rope) from a ``snap shot" of the active region
922: by, e.g., non-linear force free extrapolation of
923: a photospheric magnetogram. Such approaches may work,
924: but possibly one needs the evolutionary
925: history of the active region
926: for an accurate diagnostics.
927: Comparison of coronal observations and the numerical
928: models of coronal field calculated from observed magnetograms have
929: been done extensively (e.g.,\citealt{1997SoPh..174...65Y}).
930: We stress the
931: importance of studying the long-term (namely more than a few days)
932: temporal evolution of the photospheric and coronal magnetic field
933: that eventually produces an eruption.
934: The Solar Optical Telescope onboard Hinode satellite obtains
935: accurate vector magnetograms with uninterrupted observation, and
936: therefore will provide ideal data sets for this purpose.
937:
938:
939:
940: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
941: \section{Conclusion}
942: \label{sec:10808conclusion}
943: Active region NOAA 10808
944: appeared in September 2005 and exhibited extraordinary
945: flare activity which was the most active in Solar Cycle 23.
946: Using EUV, H$\alpha$, and magnetogram data
947: taken before and during eruptive events accompanied
948: by an X1.5 flare (the X1.5 event),
949: we investigate the processes leading to the catastrophic eruption.
950: We find several interesting features to
951: understand the physical mechanism of the X1.5 event.
952: The main points are as follows:
953: \begin{itemize}
954: \item
955: The filament which erupted during the X1.5 event
956: slowly ascended over two days before its eruption.
957: The speed of the ascending motion is approximately
958: $0.1 {\rm km \ s^{-1}}$.
959:
960: \item
961: While the filament was ascending slowly,
962: lots of M- and C-class flares were observed close to
963: the footpoints of the filament.
964: At the sites where the flares frequently occurred,
965: magnetic elements emerged and moved distinctively.
966: \end{itemize}
967:
968: On the basis of these observational facts,
969: we discuss the triggering mechanism of the
970: filament eruption on 2005 September 13.
971: We suggest that many small flares that occurred
972: in the vicinity of the filament
973: played a role in %loosening the magnetic lines
974: changing the topology of the magnetic field lines
975: overlying the filament through small scale reconnection.
976: Over two days,
977: they changed its equilibrium state gradually
978: and allowed the filament to ascend slowly.
979: In the end, a C2.9 flare that occurred just before
980: the X1.5 event was considered to lead to
981: the catastrophic filament eruption directly.
982:
983:
984:
985:
986: \acknowledgments
987: This work is supported by the Grant-in-Aid for
988: the 21st Century COE ``Center for Diversity and
989: Universality in Physics" from the Ministry of
990: Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology (MEXT) of Japan,
991: and by the Grant-in-Aid for Creative
992: Scientific Research ``The Basic Study of Space Weather Prediction''
993: (17GS0208, Head Investigator: K. Shibata) from MEXT.
994: K.N., H.I., and T.J.O. are supported by the Research Fellowship
995: from the Japan Society for the Promotion of Science for
996: Young Scientists.
997: %% Isobe & Tripathi 2006 A&A
998: {\itshape TRACE} is a NASA Small Explorer mission.
999: %%% Chifor et al. 2006
1000: {\itshape SOHO} is a project operated by
1001: the European Space Agency and
1002: the US National Aeronautics and Space Administration.
1003: %%% reconnection rate.
1004: We thank the Big Bear Solar Observatory (BBSO) for providing access
1005: to H$\alpha$ data.
1006: Data analysis was carried out on the computer system
1007: at the Nobeyama Solar Radio Observatory of the National
1008: Astronomical Observatory of Japan.
1009:
1010:
1011: %\bibliographystyle{apj}
1012: \bibliography{apj-jour,fil_erup,instrument}
1013: %\input{./ver7_bbl.tex}
1014: \input{./bbl.tex}
1015:
1016: \clearpage
1017: %%% TABLE
1018:
1019: \begin{deluxetable}{cc}
1020: \tabletypesize{\scriptsize}
1021: \tablecaption{Time-line summary of
1022: the 2005 September 13 X1.5 event\label{tab:050913X15}}
1023: \tablecolumns{2}
1024: \tablewidth{0pt}
1025: \tablehead{
1026: \colhead{Time(UT)} &
1027: \colhead{Event} }
1028: \startdata
1029: 18:40 & Brightening in region T begins. (195 \AA) \\
1030: 19:05 & {\it GOES} Soft X-Ray flux peak at C2.9\tablenotemark{a} \\
1031: 19:22 & Brightening in region C (H$\alpha-0.6$\AA)\\
1032: 19:24 & Filament 1 begins to rise (H$\alpha-0.6$ \AA)\\
1033: 19:24 & Filament 2 begins to brighten and rise (195 \AA)\\
1034: 19:27 & {\it GOES} Soft X-Ray flux first peak at X1.5\\
1035: 20:00 & {\it GOES} second peak, faint eruption (195 \AA) \\
1036: 20:00 & Halo CME with the speed of $1866 \rm{km \ s^{-1}}$
1037: (LASCO C2)\\
1038: \enddata
1039: \tablenotetext{a}{We consider this event as a direct trigger of
1040: the filament eruption; see text.}
1041: \end{deluxetable}
1042:
1043: \clearpage
1044: \begin{deluxetable}{ccccccc}
1045: \tabletypesize{\scriptsize}
1046: \tablecaption{X-, M-, and C-class flares on
1047: Sep.~12th and 13th \label{tab:MCclassflares}}
1048: \tablecolumns{7}
1049: \tablewidth{0pt}
1050: \tablehead{
1051: \colhead{} &
1052: \multicolumn{3}{c}{time\tablenotemark{a}} & \colhead{} &\colhead{} &\colhead{} \\
1053: \cline{2-4} \\
1054: \colhead{date} &
1055: \colhead{start} &
1056: \colhead{peak} &
1057: \colhead{end} &
1058: \colhead{GOES class} &
1059: \colhead{CME} &
1060: \colhead{location [group]}}
1061: \startdata
1062: Sep.~12th& 00:45 & 00:49 & 00:53 & C3.3 & None& region C
1063: [group II] \\
1064: & 02:42 &02:48 &02:53 & C2.0 & None& region C [group II]\\
1065: & 04:49 &05:05& 05:27 & M1.5 & None& region C [group II]\\
1066: & 06:56 &07:01& 07:05& M1.3& None& region T (failed eruption) [group III]\\
1067: & 08:37& 09:03& 09:20 & M6.1& CME & region C (eruption) [group II]\\
1068: & 15:33& 15:37& 15:42 & C1.1& None& region C [group II]\\
1069: & 16:29& 16:33& 16:35& C1.1& None& region T [group III]\\
1070: & 16:35& 16:38& 16:40& C1.2& None& region T [group III]\\
1071: & 19:28& 19:40& 19:42& C3.2& None& jet [group IV]\\
1072: & 20:05& 20:09& 20:11& M1.5& None& region T [group III]\\
1073: & 22:07& 22:25& 22:42& C7.2& None& region C [group II]\\
1074: & 22:57& 23:01& 23:03& C5.6& None& to the southwest of delta-type spot\\
1075: & 23:12& 23:17& 23:23& C5.5& None& region T [group III]\\
1076: Sep.~13th& 00:53& 00:58& 01:02& C4.3& None& region T [group III]\\
1077: & 03:21& 03:27& 03:31& C3.4& None& region T [group III]\\
1078: & 03:57& 04:00& 04:02& C1.5 & None& jet [group IV]\\
1079: & 04:15& 04:18& 04:20& C1.9& None& region T [group III]\\
1080: & 04:37& 04:45& 04:54& C5.1& None®ion T [group III]\\
1081: & 06:31& 06:35& 06:37& C1.2& None& region T [group III]\\
1082: & 08:24& 08:28& 08:31& C1.8& None& region T? [group III?]\\
1083: & 10:41& 11:21& 11:24& M1.3& None& region C [group II]\\
1084: & 13:11& 13:43& 13:53& C4.5& None& region C [group II]\\
1085: & 18:49& 19:05& 19:15& C2.9& None®ion T [group III]\\
1086: & 19:19& 19:27& 20:57& X1.5& halo CME&
1087: filament eruption along NL [group I]\\
1088: & 23:15& 23:22& 23:30& X1.7\tablenotemark{b}& CME & above the delta-type spot\\
1089: \enddata
1090: \tablenotetext{a}{The timescale of flares are based on the data
1091: of {\it GOES} X-ray flux.
1092: See http://www.ngdc.noaa.gov/stp/SOLAR/ftpsolarflares.html}
1093: \tablenotetext{b}{In this study, we do not refer to this event.}
1094: \end{deluxetable}
1095:
1096: \clearpage
1097: %%%% FIGURE
1098:
1099: %%section{overview of the AR}
1100:
1101:
1102: \begin{figure}[htpb]
1103: %\plotone{./GOES_lc_0907_17_1213waku.eps}
1104: \plotone{./f1.eps}
1105: \caption[{\it GOES} lightcurve from 7th to 17th in September 2005.]
1106: {Soft X-Ray fluxes in the {\it GOES} 0.5-4 \AA \ (lower)
1107: and 1-8 \AA \ (upper) channels from 7th to 17th in September 2005.
1108: The data was obtained by {\it GOES} 10.
1109: In \S \ref{sec:preflare}, we focus on the M- and C-class flares
1110: that occurred during the period between the dashed lines (12th and 13th).}
1111: \label{fig:GOES_lc}
1112: \end{figure}
1113:
1114:
1115: \begin{figure}[htpb]
1116: \begin{tabular}{ccc}
1117: %\includegraphics[scale=0.75]{../ForRevise_images/ARev_sizeadjust_Apr24/WL_02.eps} &
1118: %\includegraphics[scale=0.75]{../ForRevise_images/ARev_sizeadjust_Apr24/mag_02.eps}&
1119: %\includegraphics[scale=0.75]{../ForRevise_images/ARev_sizeadjust_Apr24/Ha_02.eps}\\
1120: \includegraphics[scale=0.75]{./f2a.eps} &
1121: \includegraphics[scale=0.75]{./f2b.eps}&
1122: \includegraphics[scale=0.75]{./f2c.eps}\\
1123: %\includegraphics[scale=0.75]{../ForRevise_images/ARev_sizeadjust_Apr24/WL_05.eps} &
1124: %\includegraphics[scale=0.75]{../ForRevise_images/ARev_sizeadjust_Apr24/mag_05.eps}&
1125: %\includegraphics[scale=0.75]{../ForRevise_images/ARev_sizeadjust_Apr24/Ha_05.eps}\\
1126: \includegraphics[scale=0.75]{./f2d.eps} &
1127: \includegraphics[scale=0.75]{./f2e.eps}&
1128: \includegraphics[scale=0.75]{./f2f.eps}\\
1129: %\includegraphics[scale=0.75]{../ForRevise_images/ARev_sizeadjust_Apr24/WL_07.eps} &
1130: %\includegraphics[scale=0.75]{../ForRevise_images/ARev_sizeadjust_Apr24/mag_07.eps}&
1131: %\includegraphics[scale=0.75]{../ForRevise_images/ARev_sizeadjust_Apr24/Ha_07.eps}\\
1132: \includegraphics[scale=0.75]{./f2g.eps} &
1133: \includegraphics[scale=0.75]{./f2h.eps}&
1134: \includegraphics[scale=0.75]{./f2i.eps}\\
1135: %\includegraphics[scale=0.75]{../ForRevise_images/ARev_sizeadjust_Apr24/WL_09.eps} &
1136: %\includegraphics[scale=0.75]{../ForRevise_images/ARev_sizeadjust_Apr24/mag_09.eps}&
1137: %\includegraphics[scale=0.75]{../ForRevise_images/ARev_sizeadjust_Apr24/Ha_09.eps}\\
1138: \includegraphics[scale=0.75]{./f2j.eps} &
1139: \includegraphics[scale=0.75]{./f2k.eps}&
1140: \includegraphics[scale=0.75]{./f2l.eps}\\
1141: \end{tabular}
1142: \caption[Evolution of the active region NOAA 10808.]
1143: {Evolution of the active region NOAA 10808.
1144: {\it TRACE} white-light images, {\it SOHO} MDI magnetograms, and
1145: SMART H$\alpha$ images are shown in the first, second,
1146: and third columns, respectively.
1147: In magnetograms, white and black indicate positive and
1148: negative polarities, respectively, and
1149: solid lines indicate the solar limb.
1150: The field of view of these images is $450'' \times 400''$.
1151: North is to the top, and west is to the right in these and
1152: other solar images in this paper.% Sterling & Moore 2005 ApJ Fig.1
1153: }
1154: \label{fig:AR_evolution}
1155: \end{figure}
1156:
1157:
1158:
1159: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
1160: %%section{09.13 X1.5}
1161: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
1162: \begin{figure}[htpb]
1163: %\plotone{./ForRevise_images/GOES_lc_0913.eps}
1164: \plotone{./f3.eps}
1165: \caption[{\it GOES} lightcurve on 2005 September 13.]
1166: {Soft X-Ray fluxes in the {\it GOES}
1167: 0.5-4 \AA \ (lower) and 1-8 \AA \
1168: (upper) channels on 2005 September 13.}
1169: \label{fig:GOES_lc_0913}
1170: \end{figure}
1171:
1172:
1173:
1174: \begin{figure}[htpb]
1175: \begin{tabular}{ccc}
1176: %\includegraphics[width=0.3\textwidth]{./ForRevise_images/X15gaiyou5_Apr25/fil1_2_0913_181540.eps}&
1177: % \includegraphics[width=0.3\textwidth]{./ForRevise_images/X15gaiyou5_Apr25/0913_185357.eps}&
1178: %\includegraphics[width=0.3\textwidth]{./ForRevise_images/X15gaiyou5_Apr25/0913_192412.eps} \\
1179: \includegraphics[width=0.3\textwidth]{./f4a.eps}&
1180: \includegraphics[width=0.3\textwidth]{./f4b.eps}&
1181: \includegraphics[width=0.3\textwidth]{./f4c.eps} \\
1182: % \includegraphics[width=0.3\textwidth]{./ForRevise_images/X15gaiyou5_Apr25/0913_192612.eps}&
1183: %\includegraphics[width=0.3\textwidth]{./ForRevise_images/X15gaiyou5_Apr25/fil1_2_0913_192842.eps} &
1184: % \includegraphics[width=0.3\textwidth]{./ForRevise_images/X15gaiyou5_Apr25/0913_193557.eps} \\
1185: \includegraphics[width=0.3\textwidth]{./f4d.eps}&
1186: \includegraphics[width=0.3\textwidth]{./f4e.eps} &
1187: \includegraphics[width=0.3\textwidth]{./f4f.eps} \\
1188: % \includegraphics[width=0.3\textwidth]{./ForRevise_images/X15gaiyou5_Apr25/0913_194529.eps} &
1189: % \includegraphics[width=0.3\textwidth]{./ForRevise_images/X15gaiyou5_Apr25/0913_201608.eps} &
1190: % \includegraphics[width=0.3\textwidth]{./ForRevise_images/X15gaiyou5_Apr25/0913_203038.eps}\\
1191: \includegraphics[width=0.3\textwidth]{./f4g.eps} &
1192: \includegraphics[width=0.3\textwidth]{./f4h.eps} &
1193: \includegraphics[width=0.3\textwidth]{./f4i.eps}\\
1194: \end{tabular}
1195: \caption[EUV images of active region NOAA 10808 on Sep.~13th.]
1196: {{\it TRACE} 195 \AA \ images of active region NOAA 10808
1197: before and during the X1.5 event on 2005 September 13.
1198: F1 and F2 indicate filament 1 and 2,
1199: respectively (see text).
1200: The field of view is $450'' \times 400''$,
1201: the same as that of Fig.~\ref{fig:AR_evolution}
1202: and the ticks correspond to $10''$.
1203: This figure is also available as an
1204: mpeg animation in the electronic edition
1205: of the {\it Astrophysical Journal}.}
1206: % Mandrini et al. 2006 SoPh Fig.1}
1207: \label{fig:TRACE195_0913X15}
1208: \end{figure}
1209:
1210: \begin{figure}[htpb]
1211: %\plotone{./ForRevise_images/eruption_ht_line_2.eps}
1212: \plotone{./f5.eps}
1213: \caption[Time slice showing the filament eruption.]{Time slice for slit shown in Figure
1214: \ref{fig:0913X15event}b.
1215: The spatial slices are
1216: laid adjacent from left to right in the diagram.
1217: The distance is measured from
1218: the northwestern end of the slit.
1219: %Isobe & Tripathi 2006 A&A Fig.2}
1220: Arrows labeled as F1 and F2 point to filaments 1 and 2.
1221: White dot-dashed line, white dashed line, and
1222: black dashed line indicate
1223: $1.5 \times 10^2 \ {\rm km \ s^{-1}}$,
1224: $2.5 \times 10^2 \ {\rm km \ s^{-1}}$,
1225: and $5.8 \times 10 \ {\rm km \ s^{-1}}$, respectively.}
1226: \label{fig:timeslice_filerup}
1227: \end{figure}
1228:
1229: \begin{figure}[htpb]
1230: \begin{center}
1231: \begin{tabular}{ccc}
1232: \includegraphics[width=5.0cm]{./f6a.eps} &
1233: \includegraphics[width=5.0cm]{./f6b.eps} &
1234: \includegraphics[width=5.0cm]{./f6c.eps} \\
1235: \includegraphics[width=5.0cm]{./f6d.eps} &
1236: \includegraphics[width=5.0cm]{./f6e.eps} &
1237: \includegraphics[width=5.0cm]{./f6f.eps} \\
1238: %\includegraphics[width=5.0cm]{./ForRevise_images/0913X15events/TR195_mag_wb_rb.eps} &
1239: %\includegraphics[width=5.0cm]{./ForRevise_images/0913X15events/slit_ichi_plus_mag_motion.eps} &
1240: %\includegraphics[width=5.0cm]{./ForRevise_images/0913X15events/0913X15_BBSO_050913192229_8.eps} \\
1241: %\includegraphics[width=5.0cm]{./ForRevise_images/0913X15events/region_setsumei.eps} &
1242: %\includegraphics[width=5.0cm]{./ForRevise_images/0913X15events/0913X15_ribbon_1600_S.eps} &
1243: %\includegraphics[width=5.0cm]{./ForRevise_images/0913X15events/AR_setsumei.eps} \\
1244: \end{tabular}
1245: \end{center}
1246: \caption[Figures showing
1247: magnetic structure of the active region
1248: NOAA 10808.]
1249: {Magnetic structure of active region
1250: NOAA 10808. The field of view of these images except
1251: Fig.~\ref{fig:0913X15event}f is $450'' \times 400''$,
1252: the same as that of Fig.~\ref{fig:AR_evolution}.
1253: A $100''$-long-scale that corresponds to about
1254: $7\times10^{4} {\rm km}$ on the solar surface
1255: is shown in Fig.~\ref{fig:0913X15event}d.
1256: (a){\it SOHO} MDI magnetogram contours superimposed on
1257: {\it TRACE} 195 \AA \ image.
1258: {\it TRACE} 195 \AA \ image was taken at 19:00:12 UT
1259: and the magnetogram was taken at 19:11:03 UT.
1260: Displacement between these images due to difference in time and
1261: pointing is corrected. Red and blue contours represent
1262: $\pm 100 {\rm G}$.
1263: (b){\it TRACE} 195 \AA \ image. The solid line indicates the slit
1264: position of time slice shown in
1265: Figs.~\ref{fig:timeslice_filerup} and \ref{fig:long_timeslice}.
1266: %%Isobe & Tripathi 2006 A&A}
1267: %The box with solid lines indicates the field of view
1268: %of a series of images in Fig.~\ref{fig:miniflare_mag195}.
1269: The box written by dashed lines indicates the field of view
1270: %the area covered by
1271: of a series of {\it TRACE} 195 \AA \ images
1272: in Fig.~\ref{fig:miniflare_mag195} and of
1273: a series of magnetic maps shown in Fig.~\ref{fig:MDI_preflare}.
1274: (c)BBSO H$\alpha$ wing (H$\alpha -0.6$ \AA) image of the active
1275: region before the X1.5 event.
1276: %Brightening in EUV also began in region C at this time.
1277: %%Yurchyshyn et al. 2006SoPh Fig.1
1278: (d){\it SOHO} MDI magnetogram. A green box indicates
1279: the delta-type sunspot and a pink dashed line
1280: indicates the S-shaped neutral line. Region C in the red box and
1281: region T in the blue box are the sites where small flares
1282: occurred frequently.
1283: (e){\it TRACE} 1600 \AA \ image taken at 19:37:34 UT.
1284: A pink dashed line indicates the S-shaped neutral line.
1285: Flare ribbons appeared along the S-shaped neutral line.
1286: (f)Schematic illustration of this active region.
1287: In this panel,
1288: the central part of the active region is enlarged.
1289: White and black circles indicate positive and
1290: negative polarity regions, respectively. The meaning of
1291: pink dashed line is the same as in Fig.~\ref{fig:0913X15event}d.
1292: Gray lines indicate filaments.}
1293: \label{fig:0913X15event}
1294: \end{figure}
1295:
1296:
1297: %%section{long-time evolution of filament}
1298:
1299:
1300: \begin{figure}
1301: %\plotone{./slowrise_ht_slitNL2.eps}
1302: %plotone{./ForRevise_images/slowrise_ht_slitNL_arrow.eps}
1303: \plotone{./f7.eps}
1304: \caption[Time slice showing slow ascending of the filament.]
1305: {Time slice for slit shown
1306: in Fig.~\ref{fig:0913X15event}b.
1307: The distance is measured from the northwestern end of the slit.
1308: Asterisked line indicates the position of the
1309: magnetic neutral line.
1310: Asterisks are the data points.
1311: The error of the neutral line position is roughly 10 arcsecs.
1312: F1 and F2 indicate dark filaments 1 and 2, respectively.
1313: The black arrow indicates the rising motion of a bright structure
1314: (see \S \ref{sec:10808Discussion}).}
1315: \label{fig:long_timeslice}
1316: \end{figure}
1317:
1318:
1319:
1320: \begin{figure}[htpb]
1321: \plotone{./f8.eps}
1322: %\plotone{./MCflares_ichi.eps}
1323: \caption[Location of the M- and C-class flares on 2005 Sep.~12th and 13th.]
1324: {Location of the M- and C-class flares that occurred on
1325: 2005 September 12 and 13 showing on
1326: {\it SOHO} MDI magnetogram.
1327: White and black indicate positive and negative polarities in the
1328: magnetogram, respectively.
1329: Diamonds and crosses indicate M-class and C-class, respectively.
1330: FOV is the same as that of Fig.~\ref{fig:AR_evolution}.}
1331: \label{fig:MCflares_ichi}
1332: \end{figure}
1333:
1334:
1335: \begin{figure}[htpb]
1336: \begin{tabular}{ccc}
1337: %M1.5 (region C[group II]) &
1338: %M1.3 (region T[group III]) &
1339: %C1.5 (jet[group IV])\\
1340: \includegraphics[width=0.3\textwidth]{./f9a.eps} &
1341: \includegraphics[width=0.3\textwidth]{./f9b.eps} &
1342: \includegraphics[width=0.3\textwidth]{./f9c.eps} \\
1343: %\includegraphics[width=0.3\textwidth]{./ForRevise_images/fig9/TR195_12_03_1.eps} &
1344: %\includegraphics[width=0.3\textwidth]{./ForRevise_images/fig9/TR195_12_04_1.eps} &
1345: %\includegraphics[width=0.3\textwidth]{./ForRevise_images/fig9/scale_TR195_13_03.eps} \\
1346: \end{tabular}
1347: \caption[EUV images of M- and C-class events.]
1348: {{\it TRACE} 195 \AA \
1349: images showing representative events of group II, III, and IV
1350: on 2005 September 12 and 13.
1351: Arrows indicate the sites of brightening.
1352: FOV is the same as that of Fig.~\ref{fig:AR_evolution}.}
1353: \label{fig:MCflares}
1354: \end{figure}
1355:
1356:
1357: \begin{figure}[htpb]
1358: \begin{tabular}{ccc}
1359: \includegraphics[scale=1.1]{./f10a.eps}
1360: \includegraphics[scale=1.1]{./f10b.eps} &
1361: \includegraphics[scale=1.1]{./f10c.eps} \\
1362: \\
1363: %\includegraphics[scale=1.1]{./regionCfil/arrowscale_0912_084246.eps}
1364: %\includegraphics[scale=1.1]{./regionCfil/0912_084603.eps} &
1365: %\includegraphics[scale=1.1]{./regionCfil/0912_093722.eps} \\
1366: \\
1367: \end{tabular}
1368: \caption[EUV images showing the filament
1369: eruption in region C.]
1370: {
1371: {\it TRACE} 195 \AA \ images
1372: showing the filament eruption in region C.
1373: During the M6.1 class flare at 9:03 UT on 12th,
1374: the thin dark filament (arrow in the left panel)
1375: in region C appears to be lifted up by
1376: a brightening loop and erupted.
1377: FOV of these images is the same
1378: as that of Fig.~\ref{fig:AR_evolution}.
1379: }
1380: \label{fig:regionCfil}
1381: \end{figure}
1382:
1383:
1384: \clearpage
1385:
1386: \begin{figure}[htpb]
1387: \begin{tabular}{ccc}
1388: \includegraphics[scale=0.8]{./f11a.eps} &
1389: \includegraphics[scale=0.8]{./f11b.eps}&
1390: \includegraphics[scale=0.8]{./f11c.eps} \\
1391: \includegraphics[scale=0.8]{./f11d.eps} &
1392: \includegraphics[scale=0.8]{./f11e.eps}&
1393: \includegraphics[scale=0.8]{./f11f.eps} \\
1394: \includegraphics[scale=0.8]{./f11g.eps} &
1395: \includegraphics[scale=0.8]{./f11h.eps}&
1396: \includegraphics[scale=0.8]{./f11i.eps} \\
1397: %\includegraphics[scale=0.8]{./miniflare_mag195_May01/kakudai150_0913_184233.eps} &
1398: %\includegraphics[scale=0.8]{./miniflare_mag195_May01/kakudai150_0913_184618.eps}&
1399: %\includegraphics[scale=0.8]{./miniflare_mag195_May01/kakudai150_0913_185018.eps} \\
1400: %\includegraphics[scale=0.8]{./miniflare_mag195_May01/kakudai150_0913_185234.eps} &
1401: %\includegraphics[scale=0.8]{./miniflare_mag195_May01/kakudai150_0913_185442.eps}&
1402: %\includegraphics[scale=0.8]{./miniflare_mag195_May01/kakudai150_0913_185612.eps} \\
1403: %\includegraphics[scale=0.8]{./miniflare_mag195_May01/kakudai150_0913_190012.eps} &
1404: %\includegraphics[scale=0.8]{./miniflare_mag195_May01/kakudai150_0913_190457.eps}&
1405: %\includegraphics[scale=0.8]{./miniflare_mag195_May01/kakudai150_0913_192612.eps} \\
1406: \end{tabular}
1407: \caption[MDI magnetogram and {\it TRACE} 195 \AA \ images of the C2.9 flare.]
1408: {{\it SOHO} MDI magnetogram contours overlaid on
1409: {\it TRACE} 195 \AA \ images showing the C2.9 flare
1410: considered as a trigger of the X1.5 event.
1411: The white arrow in the center panel indicates the jet-like feature.
1412: The last panel shows the filament eruption
1413: during the X1.5 event (see Fig.~\ref{fig:TRACE195_0913X15})
1414: to indicate the relative position against the C2.9 flare.
1415: Red and blue contours indicate $+100 {\rm G}$ and $-100 {\rm G}$,
1416: respectively.
1417: The field of view of these images is shown in
1418: Fig.~\ref{fig:0913X15event}b
1419: as a box with dashed lines and is $150''$ square.
1420: }
1421: \label{fig:miniflare_mag195}
1422: \end{figure}
1423:
1424: \clearpage
1425: \begin{figure}[htpb]
1426: \begin{tabular}{cccc}
1427:
1428: \includegraphics[scale=1.0]{./f12a.eps}&
1429: \includegraphics[scale=1.0]{./f12b.eps}&
1430: \includegraphics[scale=1.0]{./f12c.eps} &
1431: \includegraphics[scale=1.0]{./f12d.eps} \\
1432: \includegraphics[scale=1.0]{./f12e.eps}&
1433: \includegraphics[scale=1.0]{./f12f.eps} &
1434: \includegraphics[scale=1.0]{./f12g.eps} &
1435: \includegraphics[scale=1.0]{./f12h.eps}\\
1436: %\includegraphics[scale=1.0]{../ForRevise_images/mag_motion2/mag_ef_arrow_C_2_0_01.eps}&
1437: %\includegraphics[scale=1.0]{../ForRevise_images/mag_motion2/mag_ef_arrow_T_2_0_10.eps}&
1438: %\includegraphics[scale=1.0]{../ForRevise_images/mag_motion2/mag_ef_arrow_C_2_1_12.eps} &
1439: %\includegraphics[scale=1.0]{../ForRevise_images/mag_motion2/mag_ef_arrow_T_2_1_13.eps} \\
1440: %\includegraphics[scale=1.0]{../ForRevise_images/mag_motion2/mag_ef_arrow_C_2_2_18.eps}&
1441: %\includegraphics[scale=1.0]{../ForRevise_images/mag_motion2/mag_ef_arrow_T_2_2_19.eps} &
1442: %\includegraphics[scale=1.0]{../ForRevise_images/mag_motion2/mag_ef_arrow_C_2_3_22.eps} &
1443: %\includegraphics[scale=1.0]{../ForRevise_images/mag_motion2/mag_ef_arrow_T_2_3_23.eps}\\
1444: \end{tabular}
1445: \caption[Evolution of the
1446: magnetic field around the S-shaped neutral line.]
1447: {{\it SOHO} MDI magnetic maps showing the evolution of the
1448: magnetic field around the S-shaped neutral line.
1449: The area covered by each image is 150 arcsecs square
1450: which corresponds to the square drawn in
1451: Figs.~\ref{fig:0913X15event}b.
1452: Dotted lines are drawn every 25 arcsecs
1453: ($1.8\times 10^4 {\rm km}$).
1454: Black arrows %in the first column
1455: indicate the negative elements in region C
1456: flowing out from the negative umbra in the delta-type spot,
1457: while white arrows % in the second column
1458: indicate the negative elements emerging into
1459: region T and moving toward the footpoint of the loop
1460: that brightened along with the C2.9 flare at around 19:00 UT
1461: on Sep.~13th. }
1462: %Mandrini et al. 2006, Fig.1
1463: \label{fig:MDI_preflare}
1464: \end{figure}
1465:
1466:
1467:
1468:
1469: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
1470: %%section{discussion}
1471: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
1472:
1473: \begin{figure}[htpb]
1474: \begin{tabular}{ccc}
1475: \includegraphics[width=0.32\textwidth]{./f13a.eps} &&\\
1476: \includegraphics[width=0.32\textwidth]{./f13b.eps} &
1477: \includegraphics[width=0.32\textwidth]{./f13c.eps} &
1478: \includegraphics[width=0.32\textwidth]{./f13d.eps} \\
1479: %\includegraphics[width=0.32\textwidth]{./discussion2/regionCa_mono.eps} &&\\
1480: %\includegraphics[width=0.32\textwidth]{./discussion2/regionCb_mono.eps} &
1481: %\includegraphics[width=0.32\textwidth]{./discussion2/regionCc_mono.eps} &
1482: %\includegraphics[width=0.32\textwidth]{./discussion2/regionCd_mono.eps} \\
1483: \end{tabular}
1484: \caption[Evolution of magnetic structure in region C. (the M6.1 flare)]
1485: {Schematic illustration of the
1486: evolution of magnetic structure
1487: at the time of flares in region C
1488: (group II, see Fig.~\ref{fig:0913X15event}d).
1489: This figure is based on the data of the M6.1 flare on 12th as a
1490: representative of the flares in region C.
1491: However, we believe that all the flares in region C
1492: occurred in a similar way.
1493: (a) Simple sketch of magnetic structure in the active region
1494: when the flare occurred. White and black indicate
1495: positive and negative polarities.
1496: The dashed line indicates the S-shaped neutral line and
1497: the gray curve on the neutral line indicates the filament in
1498: region C.
1499: (b) A cross section of magnetic structure along line AB
1500: shown in Fig. \ref{fig:regionC_structure}a.
1501: Solid lines are magnetic field lines and
1502: hatched area indicates the filament.
1503: The negative element pointed by an arrow is considered to be
1504: the key of this event. Between the field line
1505: connected to the element
1506: and the loops overlying the filament a current sheet
1507: forms (dotted line).
1508: Note that the positive element on the left side of the pointed
1509: negative element was not on line AB in reality;
1510: we consider that it was located in the positive side
1511: of the delta-type spot.
1512: (c) In the current sheet, magnetic reconnection occurred
1513: and the loops overlying the filament
1514: brightened and were lengthened.
1515: The bright loop is indicated by the thick curve.
1516: The gray arrow indicates an ascending motion of the filament.
1517: (d) As the reconnection proceeds,
1518: arcades with increasing height allow the filament to ascend.
1519: }
1520: \label{fig:regionC_structure}
1521: \end{figure}
1522:
1523:
1524: \begin{figure}[htpb]
1525: \begin{tabular}{cccc}
1526: \includegraphics[width=0.18\textwidth]{./f14a.eps} & %&&\\
1527: \includegraphics[width=0.25\textwidth]{./f14b.eps} &
1528: \includegraphics[width=0.25\textwidth]{./f14c.eps} &
1529: \includegraphics[width=0.25\textwidth]{./f14d.eps} \\
1530: &
1531: \includegraphics[width=0.25\textwidth]{./f14e.eps} &
1532: \includegraphics[width=0.25\textwidth]{./f14f.eps} &
1533: \includegraphics[width=0.25\textwidth]{./f14g.eps} \\
1534: %\includegraphics[width=0.32\textwidth]{./discussion2/regionTa.eps} &&\\
1535: %\includegraphics[width=0.32\textwidth]{./discussion2/regionTb.eps} &
1536: %\includegraphics[width=0.32\textwidth]{./discussion2/regionTc.eps} &
1537: %\includegraphics[width=0.32\textwidth]{./discussion2/regionTd.eps} \\
1538: %\includegraphics[width=0.32\textwidth]{./discussion2/regionTb_p.eps} &
1539: %\includegraphics[width=0.32\textwidth]{./discussion2/regionTc_p.eps} &
1540: %\includegraphics[width=0.32\textwidth]{./discussion2/regionTd_p.eps} \\
1541: \end{tabular}
1542: \caption[Evolution of magnetic structure in region T. (the C2.9 flare)]
1543: {Schematic illustration of the evolution of magnetic structure
1544: at the time of flares in region T (group III, see Fig.~\ref{fig:0913X15event}d).
1545: This figure is based on the data of the C2.9 flare on Sep.~13th
1546: as a representative of the flares in region T.
1547: (a) Simple sketch of magnetic structure in the active region
1548: when the flare occurred.
1549: White and black indicate positive and negative polarities.
1550: The dashed line indicates the S-shaped neutral line.
1551: (b) A cross section of magnetic structure along curve
1552: DE shown in Fig.~\ref{fig:regionT_structure}a.
1553: In Figs.~\ref{fig:regionT_structure}b, c, and d,
1554: curve DE is unbent in a straight line.
1555: The negative element pointed out by an arrow is
1556: considered to be the key to this event.
1557: This element emerged into region T and moved toward southwest.
1558: Hatched area indicates filament 2.
1559: Between the overlying loops and the emerging flux
1560: a current sheet formed (red dotted line).
1561: (c) In the current sheet, magnetic reconnection occurred.
1562: A small bright loop (thin orange curve)
1563: appeared as the left footpoint put on
1564: the negative element. The overlying arcade was lengthened and
1565: the filament anchored by the arcade ascended as indicated by
1566: a gray arrow.
1567: A bright jet-like feature indicated by orange arrow
1568: showed a whip-like motion as the loop stretched.
1569: An outlined arrow indicates this whip-like motion.
1570: (d) As the reconnection proceeded, jets with whip-like motion
1571: gradually moved eastward
1572: and the filament continued to move upward.
1573: (b')Three-dimensional schematics of the magnetic structure
1574: along curve DE. Green lines indicate loops overlying
1575: filament 2 indicated by a gray cylinder.
1576: (c')This panel shows the same phase as
1577: Fig.~\ref{fig:regionT_structure}c.
1578: (d')This panel shows the same phase as
1579: Fig.~\ref{fig:regionT_structure}d.
1580: }
1581: \label{fig:regionT_structure}
1582: \end{figure}
1583:
1584:
1585:
1586: \begin{figure}[htpb]
1587: %\plottwo{./discussion/C29_structure_before_wb.eps}
1588: %{./discussion/C29_structure_after_wb.eps}
1589: \plottwo{./f15a.eps}{./f15b.eps}
1590: \caption[Alternative view of the C2.9 flare.]
1591: {Alternative interpretation of the C2.9 flare at 19:05 UT
1592: on September 13.
1593: White and black indicate positive and negative polarities.
1594: The dashed line indicates the S-shaped neutral line.
1595: In the left panel,
1596: two magnetic lines crossed each other;
1597: this is the view before the small flare.
1598: As the negative polarity elements moved westward,
1599: the light gray magnetic line was pressed against
1600: the dark gray line
1601: and finally they reconnected (see the right panel).
1602: This dark gray line indicates filament 2 and
1603: owing to the reconnection it became longer.
1604: Therefore, filament 2 could not be held
1605: and it erupted with filament 1.}
1606: \label{fig:C29_structure}
1607: \end{figure}
1608:
1609:
1610:
1611:
1612: \end{document}
1613: