1: %\documentstyle[11pt]
2: %\documentclass[emulateapj]{emulateapj}
3: \documentclass[12pt, preprint]{aastex}
4: %\pagestyle{myheadings}
5: %\nofiles
6:
7: % Some definitions I use in these instructions.
8:
9: %\def\emphasize#1{{\sl#1\/}}
10: %\def\arg#1{{\it#1\/}}
11: %\let\prog=\arg
12:
13: %\def\edcomment#1{\iffalse\marginpar{\raggedright\sl#1\/}\else\relax\fi}
14: %\marginparwidth 1.25in
15: %\marginparsep .125in
16: %\marginparpush .25in
17: %\reversemarginpar
18: \begin{document}
19: %\shorttitle{Possible Planet Formation in h \& $\chi$ Persei }
20: \shorttitle{Evolution of Debris Disks}
21: \shortauthors{Currie, T. et al.}
22: %\setcounter{page}{1}
23: %\title{MIPS Observations of h \& $\chi$ Persei: Evidence for an Inside-Out Evolution of Protoplanetary Debris
24: %Disks}
25: %\title{MIPS Observations of h \& $\chi$ Persei: Constraints on the Early Stages of Debris Disk Evolution}
26: \title{The Rise and Fall of Debris Disks: MIPS Observations of h and $\chi$ Persei and the Evolution of Mid-IR
27: Emission from Planet Formation}
28: \author{Thayne Currie\altaffilmark{1,5}, Scott J. Kenyon\altaffilmark{1,6},
29: Zoltan Balog\altaffilmark{2,7},George Rieke\altaffilmark{2}, Ann Bragg\altaffilmark{3,6}, \&
30: Benjamin Bromley\altaffilmark{4}}
31: \altaffiltext{1}{Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics, 60 Garden St. Cambridge, MA 02140}
32: \altaffiltext{2}{Steward Observatory, University of Arizona, 933 N. Cherry Av. Tucson, AZ 85721}
33: \altaffiltext{3}{Department of Physics, Bowling Green State University, Bowling Green, OH}
34: \altaffiltext{4}{Department of Physics, University of Utah, 201 JFB, Salt Lake City, UT 84112}
35: \altaffiltext{5}{Department of Physics \& Astronomy, University of California-Los Angeles, Los Angeles,
36: CA, 90095}
37: \altaffiltext{6}{Visiting Astronomer, Kitt Peak National Observatory, National Optical Astronomy
38: Observatory, which is operated by the Association of Universities for Research
39: in Astronomy, Inc., under cooperative agreement with the National Science
40: Foundation.}
41: \altaffiltext{7}{on leave from Dept. of Optics and Quantum Electronics, University of Szeged, H-6720, Szeged, Hungary}
42: \email{tcurrie@cfa.harvard.edu}
43: \begin{abstract}
44: We describe Spitzer/MIPS observations of the double cluster, h and $\chi$ Persei,
45: covering a $\sim$ 0.6 square-degree area surrounding the cores of both clusters.
46: The data are combined with IRAC and 2MASS data to investigate $\sim$ 616 sources
47: from 1.25-24 $\mu m$. We use the long-baseline
48: $K_{s}$-[24] color to identify two populations with IR excess indicative of circumstellar
49: material: Be stars with 24 $\mu m$ excess from
50: optically-thin free free emission and 17 fainter sources (J$\sim$ 14-15)
51: with [24] excess consistent with a circumstellar disk.
52: The frequency of IR excess for the fainter sources increases
53: from 4.5 $\mu m$ through 24 $\mu m$. The IR excess is likely due to debris from the planet
54: formation process. The wavelength-dependent behavior is consistent with an inside-out clearing of circumstellar disks.
55: A comparison of the 24 $\mu m$ excess population in h and $\chi$ Per sources with results for
56: other clusters shows that 24 $\mu m$ emission from debris disks 'rises' from 5 to 10 Myr, peaks
57: at $\sim$ 10-15 Myr, and then 'falls' from $\sim$ 15/20 Myr to 1 Gyr.
58: \end{abstract}
59: \keywords{Galaxy: Open Clusters and Associations: Individual: NGC Number: NGC 869, Galaxy: Open Clusters and Associations: Individual: NGC Number: NGC 884, Stars: Circumstellar Matter, Infrared: Stars, planetary systems: formation planetary systems: protoplanetary disks}
60: \section{Introduction}
61: Most 1-2 Myr-old stars are surrounded by massive (M$_{disk}$ $\sim$ 0.01-0.1 M$_{\star}$)
62: optically-thick accretion disks of gas and dust. The disk
63: produces near-to-mid infrared (IR) emission comparable in brightness to the stellar photosphere (L$_{disk}$
64: $\sim$ L$_{\star}$) (e.g. Kenyon \& Hartmann 1995, Hillenbrand 1997).
65: The evolution of these 'primordial' disks has been studied extensively (e.g. Haisch, Lada, \& Lada 2001;
66: Lada et al. 2006; Dahm \& Hillenbrand 2007).
67: By 5-10 Myr, primordial disks disappear and less massive (M$_{disk}$ $\lesssim$ 1 M$_{\oplus}$)
68: gas-poor, optically-thin 'debris disks'
69: with weaker emission (L$_{disk}$ $\lesssim$ 10$^{-3}$ L$_{\star}$) emerge
70: (e.g. Hernandez et al. 2006). By $\sim$ 10-20 Myr, primordial disks are extremely
71: rare: almost all disks are debris disks (Currie et al. 2007a, hereafter C07a; Gorlova et al. 2007;
72: Sicilia-Aguilar et al. 2006).
73:
74: Debris disks older than $\sim$ 20Myr are well studied. Rieke et al. (2005; hereafter
75: R05) showed that the 24 $\mu m$ emission declines with time as t$^{-1}$ (see also
76: Kalas 1998; Habing et al. 2001; Decin et al. 2003). This decay
77: agrees with expectations for the gradual depletion of the reservoir of small planetesimals. With fewer
78: parent bodies to initiate the collisional cascades that yield the infrared-emitting dust, the infrared excesses
79: drop systematically with time (Kenyon \& Bromley 2002; Dominik \& Decin 2003; R05; Wyatt et al. 2007a). R05 also found a large range in the
80: amount of infrared excess emission at each age, even for very young systems. Wyatt et al. (2007a) demonstrate that the
81: first-order cause of this range is probably the large variation in protostellar disk masses and hence in the
82: mass available to form planetesimals.
83:
84: Because the R05 sample and other studies of individual stars (e.g.,
85: Chen et al. 2005a) include few stars younger than 20Myr, they do not probe the 5-20 Myr
86: transitional period from primordial to debris disks well. This transition marks an important phase for planet
87: formation and other physical processes in disks.
88: Gas accretion onto most young stars ceases by $\approx$ 10 Myr (Sicilia-Aguilar
89: et al. 2005). Planets acquire most of their mass
90: by $\approx$ 5-20 Myr (Kenyon \& Bromley 2006; Chambers 2001; Wetherill \& Stewart 1993).
91:
92: With an age of 13 $\pm$ 1 Myr and with over $\sim$ 5000 members (C07a), the double cluster, h and $\chi$ Persei
93: (d=2.34 kpc, A$_{V}$$\sim$ 1.62; Slesnick et al. 2002, Bragg \& Kenyon
94: 2005), provides an ideal laboratory to study disk evolution during this critical age.
95: Recent observations of h and $\chi$ Per with the
96: Spitzer Space Telescope have demonstrated the utility of using the double cluster to investigate
97: disk evolution after the primordial stage. C07a used 3.6-8$\mu m$ Spitzer data to show that
98: disks last longer around less massive stars and
99: at greater distances from the star. C07b analyzed a well-constrained subsample of h and $\chi$ Per
100: sources and showed that at least some of the disk emission in them comes from warm dust
101: in the terrestrial zones of disks as a byproduct of terrestrial planet formation.
102:
103: In this paper, we use data obtained with the Multiband Imaging Photometer for Spitzer (MIPS) to extend
104: the study of h and $\chi$ Per to 24$\mu$m. This band allows us to search for high levels of mid-IR excess
105: associated with cool dust that orbits in a disk at $\sim$ 2-50 AU from the central star. Our survey
106: covers a region containing $\sim$ 600 intermediate-to-high mass cluster members.
107: In \S 2 we describe the MIPS observations, data reduction, and sample selection.
108: We analyze the 24$\mu$m photometry in \S 3. The main results are: 1) there are two IR-excess
109: populations, Be stars with optically thin free-free emission and intermediate mass stars likely harboring
110: disks; 2) debris disk excesses are more common at 24$\mu$m than at shorter wavelengths; and 3) there
111: are several extreme disks similar to the nearby young debris disks around $\beta$ Pic, HR 4796A, and
112: 49 Cet. Finally, in \S 4 we place h and $\chi$ Per in the context of results for other open
113: clusters/associations with optically-thin debris disk candidates.
114: The flux from debris disks rises from $\sim$ 5 Myr (when they first emerge),
115: peaks at $\sim$ 10-15 Myr, and then falls as t$^{-1}$ as described by R05. We conclude
116: with a summary of our findings and discuss future observations that may place even stronger
117: constraints on debris disk evolution by accounting for wide range of IR excesses at
118: 10-15 Myr.
119: %We discuss the possible reasons for this trend in debris disk evolution and for the peak
120: %in IR excess at 10-15 Myr, noting that accretion around most
121: %sources ceases by $\sim$ 10 Myr and the final stages of planet formation, during
122: %which mergers/ejection of lunar mass or larger bodies occurs, also commences
123: %by 10-20 Myr. Future observations of h \& $\chi$ Persei and other
124: %$\sim$ 10-15 Myr clusters will yield larger ensembles of evolved disks and
125: %thus will help to more strongly constrain this evolution.
126: %\section{MIPS Data for h \& $\chi$ Persei}
127: \section{Observations}
128: \subsection{MIPS and Ground-Based Spectroscopic Data}
129: We acquired MIPS 24 $\mu m$ data using 80-second exposures in
130: scan mode, covering two 0.3 square-degree regions centered on the two clusters.
131: The frames were processed using the MIPS Data Analysis Tool
132: (Gordon et al. 2005). PSF fitting in the IRAF/DAOPHOT package was used to
133: obtain photometry using a 7.3 Jy zero-point for the 24 $\mu$m magnitude
134: scale. The typical errors for the MIPS sources are 0.2 mag ($\sim$ 5$\sigma$) at
135: a 24$\mu m$ magnitude of [24] $\sim$ 10.5-11. The number counts for the
136: MIPS data peak at [24] $\sim$
137: 10.5 and decline to zero by [24]$\sim$ 11.5 (Figure 1a).
138: We detect 2,493 potential h and $\chi$ Per sources.
139:
140: We combined the MIPS photometry with the 2MASS/IRAC catalogue of h and $\chi$
141: Persei from C07a.
142: To minimize potential contamination of stellar sources by background
143: PAH-emission galaxies and AGN, we used a small 1.25" matching radius (about half of a MIPS pixel; r$_{M}$)
144: to merge the 2MASS/IRAC and the MIPS catalogues. Although the MIPS beam is 6
145: arcsec in diameter, the instrument delivers positions good to one arcsec even for faint sources in crowded
146: fields (Bai et al. 2007). This procedure yielded 616 sources (N$_{MIPS}$) with high-quality 1--24 $\mu m$ photometry.
147: Table 1 shows the 2MASS/IRAC + MIPS catalogue. Optical UBV photometry from Slesnick et al. (2002) is
148: included where available.
149:
150: To [24]=10.5, the probability of chance alignments between
151: distant PAH-emission galaxies/AGN and our sources is low. Using the galaxy number counts from
152: Papovich et al. (2004), N$_{G}$ $\sim$ 3.5$\times$10$^{6}$/sr,
153: we derive a probability of $\sim$ 24.8\% that one of our 616 sources is contaminated
154: ($\pi$r$_{M}$$^{2}$$\times$N$_{G}$$\times$N$_{MIPS}$/(3282.8$\times$3600$^{2}$)). The likelihood
155: that many of our sources are contaminated is then much smaller.
156:
157: To estimate the completeness of the MIPS sample, we compare the
158: fraction of J band sources detected with MIPS within either cluster.
159: Figure 1b shows that $\gtrsim$ 90\% of the 2MASS sources brighter than J=10.5
160: are also detected in MIPS. The completeness falls to $\sim$ 50\% by J=11
161: and to $\sim$ 10\% by J=12. The dip at J$\sim$8-9 occurs because many sources in this range
162: are near the cluster centers, where the high density of even brighter sources (J $\sim$ 6-8)
163: masks the presence of fainter objects.
164:
165:
166: To provide additional constraints on the 24$\mu m$ excess sources,
167: we also obtained Hectospec (Fabricant et al. 2005) and FAST (Fabricant et al. 1998) spectra of selected
168: MIPS sources on the 6.5m MMT and 1.5m Tillinghast telescopes at F. L. Whipple Observatory
169: during September-November 2006. Spectra for bright sources (J $\le$ 13) were also cross referenced with
170: the FAST archive. The FAST spectroscopy, described in detail by
171: Bragg \& Kenyon (2002), typically had $\sim$ 10 minute integrations using
172: a 300 g mm$^{-1}$ grating blazed at 4750 $\AA$ and
173: a 3$\arcsec$ slit. These spectra cover 3700--7500 \AA\ at 6 \AA\ resolution.
174: The typical signal-to-noise ratios were $\gtrsim$ 25-30 at 4000 \AA.
175: For each Hectospec source, we took three, 10-minute exposures
176: using the 270/mm grating. This configuration yields spectra at
177: 4000-9000$\dot{A}$ with 3$\dot{A}$ resolution. The data were
178: processed using standard FAST and Hectospec reduction pipelines (e.g. Fabricant et al. 2005).
179:
180: We acquired additional spectra of h and $\chi$ Per sources with
181: the Hydra multifiber spectrograph (Barden et al. 1993) on the WIYN 3.5 m telescope at the Kitt Peak National
182: Observatory. Hydra spectra were obtained during two observing runs in November 2000 and October 2001
183: and include stars brighter than V=17.0. We used the 400 g mm$^{-1}$ setting blazed at 42 degrees, with
184: a resolution of 7 \AA\ and a coverage of 3600-6700 \AA.
185: The standard IRAF task \textit{dohydra} was
186: used to reduce the spectra. These spectra had high signal-to-noise with
187: $\gtrsim$ 1000 counts over most of the wavelength coverage.
188:
189: \subsection{Spatial Distribution of MIPS sources}
190: To investigate the spatial distribution of the MIPS sources and the likelihood that they are cluster members,
191: we compare the projected sky surface
192: densities derived from MIPS and 2MASS. C07a showed that $\sim$ 47\% of stars within 15' of the cluster
193: centers are cluster members. Between 15' and 25', $\sim$ 40\% of the 2MASS sources are in a halo
194: population with roughly the same age as bona fide cluster stars. Because the MIPS coverage is complete only
195: out to $\sim$ 15' away from each cluster center, we cannot identify MIPS sources with this halo
196: population. We compare the spatial distribution of MIPS sources to those in 2MASS from C07a by calculating the
197: number density of sources in 5'-wide half-annuli facing away from the midpoint of the two clusters.
198:
199: Through 15' away from either cluster center,
200: the number counts of sources detected with both MIPS and 2MASS fall off about as steeply or slightly more steeply than the
201: counts for 2MASS alone from C07a (Figure \ref{dens}). Near the center of the clusters the
202: density of MIPS sources is $\sim$ 0.4/sq. arc-minute, or about an order of magnitude lower than from 2MASS.
203: For h Persei and $\chi$ Persei, respectively, this density falls off by 4 \% and 25 \% from 0-5' to 5'-10' away
204: from the cluster centers and 22\%-41\% from 0-5' to '10-15' away from the centers. The low counts
205: through 5' and more shallow drop in number density for $\chi$ Persei is due to crowding in the inner
206: $\sim$ 1-2' of the $\chi$ Persei core; the slope of the MIPS number density in $\chi$ Persei shown in
207: Figure \ref{dens} is most likely a lower limit. In contrast, the
208: number counts for the 2MASS data from C07a fall off by 10\% (20\%) and 30\% (32\%) for h ($\chi$) Persei
209: over the same 5' intervals (the values in Figure \ref{dens} are slightly different due to the larger annuli used here).
210: The MIPS source counts appear to be about as centrally concentrated as the
211: 2MASS counts.
212: % and, by extension, are about as likely to be in the cluster.
213:
214: \subsection{General nature of the 24 $\mu m$ sources}
215:
216: Figure \ref{k24dist} shows the histogram of K$_{s}$-[24] colors for the MIPS detections with
217: 2MASS counterparts. The histogram has a main peak at K$_{s}$-[24]$\sim$0-1 and two
218: groups with K$_{s}$-[24] $\sim$1-2 and K$_{s}$-[24]$\sim$2-6.
219: The sources with very red K$_{s}$-[24] colors ($\ge$ 2) are
220: in two main groups (Figure \ref{kexc}). A bright group of very red sources
221: has K$_{s}$$\sim$9-11; a fainter population of red sources
222: stretches from K$_{s}$$\sim$13.5-15.
223: A population of 13 Myr-old stars in h \& $\chi$ Per with
224: spectral types later than B9 (M$\le$3.0 $M_{\odot}$)
225: should have J, $K_{s}$ magnitudes $\gtrsim$ 13.3 (Siess et al. 2000).
226: Thus, some of these fainter sources with red K$_{s}$-[24]
227: colors are possibly pre-main sequence stars.
228:
229: Some of the sources are very faint in the near infrared. To examine the nature of the
230: MIPS sources without J counterparts, we first compared
231: the MIPS mosaic and the 2MASS J mosaic by eye. Many sources appear scattered throughout the MIPS mosaic
232: but do not appear in 2MASS, even at very high contrast. These sources are likely
233: cluster stars with J $\gtrsim$ 16-17 and very red J-[24] colors or background galaxies with
234: negligible near-IR emission. Using the number density
235: of galaxies in the MIPS 24 $\mu m$ filter from Papovich et al. (2004), we expect
236: $\gtrsim$ 600-700 galaxies in the 0.6 square-degree coverage area brighter than
237: [24] $\sim$ 10.5. Thus, many of the sources without 2MASS counterparts are likely not
238: h \& $\chi$ Per members. From the C07a survey, there are $\sim$ 4700
239: stars with J $\sim$ 10-15.5 within either cluster or the surrounding halo population of comparable age.
240: For a reasonable IMF (e.g. Miller \& Scalo 1979),
241: we expect $\sim$ 2800 ($\sim$ 8900) cluster/halo stars with J$\sim$16-17
242: (17-18). If $\sim$ 10\%-20\% of these stars have large 24$\mu m$ excesses, as predicted
243: from an extrapolation of the C07a results to fainter J magnitudes, we expect 1170-2340 cluster/halo
244: stars with MIPS detections and no 2MASS counterparts. Together with the 600-700 background
245: galaxies, this population yields the observed number of MIPS detections without 2MASS
246: counterparts.
247:
248: \section{A [24] IR excess population in h and $\chi$ Persei}
249: \subsection{Groups in the J, J-H Color-Magnitude Diagram}
250: To identify the nature of the 24$\mu m$ emission in sources with red K$_{s}$-[24] colors in Figure 2,
251: we refer to previous MIPS observations of very 'red' sources and consider possible contaminants.
252: MIPS observations of the Pleiades (Gorlova et al. 2006) guide our analysis of $K_{s}$-[24] colors
253: for IR excess disk/envelope sources. While the stellar density in h and $\chi$ Per is larger than
254: in the Pleiades, other possible contaminants are less important.
255: The level of galactic cirrus for h and $\chi$ Persei is much lower than for the Pleiades: 17-27 MJy/sr versus
256: 36-63 MJy/sr. Gorlova et al. found that disk-bearing candidate sources have dereddened
257: $K_{s}$-[24] colors $\gtrsim$ 0.25. Because h \& $\chi$ Persei has a low, uniform extinction of $A_{V}\sim 1.62$,
258: E(B-V)$\sim$0.52 (Bragg \& Kenyon 2005), we convert the dereddened $K_{s}$-[24] excess
259: criterion into a reddened $K_{s}$-[24] criterion
260: using the reddening laws from Indebetouw et al. (2005) and Mathis (1990). For
261: $A_{V}$$\sim$1.62, 24$\mu m$ excess sources should have $K_{s}$-[24]$\gtrsim$0.45.
262: Because the MIPS data have $\sigma$ $\lesssim$ 0.2, we round this limit up to $K_{s}$-[24] $\gtrsim$ 0.65.
263:
264: Figure \ref{jjh} shows the distribution of sources with and without $K_{s}$-[24] excess in J/J-H color-magnitude space.
265: The IR excess population is clustered into two main groups.
266: Asterisks (diamonds) denote sources brighter (fainter) than J=13.
267: Larger asterisks/diamonds correspond to sources with
268: $K_{s}$-[24] $\ge$ 2, while smaller asterisks identify sources with $K_{s}$-[24]=0.65-2 and J $\le$ 13.
269: %Small asterisks (diamonds) denote sources brighter (fainter) than
270: %J=13 with $K_{s}$-[24]=0.65-2 (small excess). The large asterisks and diamonds
271: %denote sources with $K_{s}$-[24]$\ge$2 (large excess), and the small squares denote photospheric sources.
272: The excess sources with J$\le$13 typically have J-H colors $\sim$ 0.2 mag redder than
273: a typical stellar photosphere. Many sources with weak excess lie well
274: off the 14 Myr isochrone and may be consistent with foreground M stars or supergiants.
275: About 17 out of 21 stars with 24$\mu m$ excess fainter than J=13 fall
276: along the 14 Myr isochrone with J$\approx$ 14-15.
277: At 14 Myr and a distance of 2.4 kpc, this J magnitude range corresponds to stars with masses $\sim$ 2.2-1.4 $M_{\odot}$
278: (B9/A0-G2) stars (Siess et al. 2000). We inspected each faint excess source on the MIPS mosaic for
279: extended emission (indicative of galaxies) or 'excess' due to source confusion/crowding. We found no evidence
280: issues such as as large extended emission or source confusion that could compromise the photometry of any of the faint excess sources.
281: \subsection{Two Populations of IR-Excess Sources: Be stars with Circumstellar Envelopes and Faint Pre-Main Sequence
282: Stars with Disks}
283: There are three main possibilities for the source of 24$\mu m$ excess emission around h and $\chi$ Per stars.
284: Red giants or supergiants not associated with the clusters or the halo produce IR excesses in massive stellar winds,
285: and should have J-H $\gtrsim$ 0.5. Two such stars have large 24 $\mu m$ excesses
286: and are not considered further. Be stars in the clusters/halo population have IR excesses from optically-thin
287: free-free emission and should have J $\lesssim$ 13-13.5 and J-H $\lesssim$ 0.4. Many potential Be stars have $K_{s}$ -[24] $\sim$ 2
288: (Figure \ref{jjh}; large asterisks) and clearly are an important part of the cluster population. Aside from Be stars,
289: circumstellar disks around lower-mass cluster/halo stars can produce excess emission. Figure 5 shows a significant
290: population of fainter stars (all with J $\gtrsim$ 13.5) on the 14 Myr isochrone with large K$_{s}$ -[24] excesses.
291: To identify the nature of the 24$\mu m$ excess sources, we analyze the near-IR colors and selected spectra
292: of the excess population. We begin with Be star candidates and then discuss the fainter population.
293:
294: Be stars are massive and are evolving off the main sequence (McSwain and Gies 2005). The IR-excess emission from Be
295: stars arises from an optically-thin, flattened, circumstellar shell of ionized gas ejected from the star (Woolf, Stein, and
296: Strittmatter 1970; Dachs et al. 1988). We find 57 candidates -- J $\lesssim$ 13.5 and J-H $\le$ 0.4 --
297: with 24 $\mu m$ excess (K$_{s}$-[24] $\gtrsim$ 0.65). Twenty of these stars have been previously identified
298: as Be stars by Bragg and Kenyon (2002), all with Oosterhoff (1937) numbers, and have spectral types
299: from Strom and Wolff (2005) and Bragg and Kenyon (2002). Table 2 lists the properties of these 57 candidates.
300:
301: We can estimate the ratio of Be stars to B stars over a narrow range of spectral types (earlier than B4).
302: In our MIPS survey, there are $\sim$ 175 stars that are likely B type stars (J=8-13.5; J-H $\le$ 0.2) without excess.
303: All of these stars are probably earlier than B4 based on their 2MASS J band photometry (J $\lesssim$ 11.75).
304: There are 57 Be star candidates with 24$\mu m$ excess (K$_{s}$-[24]$\gtrsim$0.65): 51 of these stars probably
305: have spectral types earlier than B4 based on their J-band photometry. The ratio of Be star
306: candidates to main sequence B-type stars earlier than B4 in the MIPS survey is then $\sim$ 0.29.
307: This estimate is larger than the ratio derived from optical and near-IR data ($\sim$ 0.14, Bragg \& Kenyon 2002).
308: We explored this difference as follows.
309:
310: First, we analyze the Be star candidate population in high-density regions close to the cluster centers
311: where spectroscopic data on bright stars in h and $\chi$ Per is complete.
312: Our candidates were cross correlated with spectroscopically identified Be stars from Bragg and Kenyon within
313: 5' of the cluster centers.. Ten known Be stars and two candidate
314: stars from the MIPS survey are in this region.
315: These two candidate stars with 24 $\mu m$ excesses are not Be stars.
316: One is a 5th magnitude B3 supergiant cluster member
317: identified by Slesnick et al. (2002) and the other is a G1 star, lying well off the isochrone with J=11.67 and J-H=0.39.
318:
319: Because our spectroscopic sample of Be stars is spatially limited, we turn to near-IR colors from 2MASS to
320: investigate the nature of the bright MIPS excess sources.
321: Dougherty et al. (1991, 1994) showed that Be stars follow a distinct locus in JHK$_{s}$ colors.
322: This locus is characteristic of free-free emission from optically-thin ionized gas and is well separated
323: from main sequence colors and the near-IR colors produced by warm dust.
324: Thus, the J-H/H-K$_{s}$ color-color diagram (Figure 6) provides a clear way to distinguish Be stars from
325: lower mass stars with circumstellar dust emission.
326: From Figure 6, it is clear that the bright sources with K$_{s}$-[24]$\ge$2
327: follow a locus (dotted line) in J-H/H-$K_{s}$ from
328: (0,0) to (0.3,0.4), a range consistent with known Be star colors
329: (Dougherty et al. 1991, 1994). The bright sources with weaker excess (small asterisks) also appear to
330: lie along the Be star locus or are clumped close to the red giant locus at J-H $\sim$ 0.6-0.8,
331: H-$K_{s}$$\sim$ 0.2-0.3. The observed distribution of IR colors
332: suggests $\approx$ 15 Be stars and $\approx$ 25 giants/supergiants.
333: If this ratio is confirmed by optical spectroscopy, then the fraction of Be stars among
334: all B-type stars is similar to the 14\% derived by Bragg \& Kenyon (2002).
335:
336: Finally, we search the FAST archive at the Telescope Data Center at the Smithsonian Astrophysical
337: Observatory and the Slesnick et al. catalogue for additional spectra of the 35 Be star candidates in lower-density regions.
338: The FAST archive contains additional data for four candidates; we find one additional source from Slesnick et al.
339: The Slesnick et al. source is a confirmed Be star (B1Ie). The FAST sources contain an A2, F7, G2, and B4 star. The first
340: three of these are bright and likely either foreground or giants associated with the halo population of h and $\chi$ Per.
341: Thus, the spectra support our conclusion from the color-color diagram (Figure 6) that
342: many of the candidate Be stars are not true identifications. If none of the remaining candidate stars are true
343: Be stars, then the ratio of Be stars to B stars is $\sim$ 0.12, close to the Bragg and Kenyon value.
344:
345: Interestingly, the B4 star identified by Bragg \& Kenyon (2002), has 24 $\mu m$ excess
346: \textit{and} has a J magnitude and J-H colors marginally consistent with an early B star in h and $\chi$ Per.
347: The $K_{s}$-[24] excess for this source is $\sim$ 1.05, though unlike Be stars it lacks clear IR excess at JHK$_{s}$ and
348: in the IRAC bands. We show its spectrum compared with that of a known Be star (Oosterhoff number 517) in Figure 7.
349: This star is the earliest, highest mass star+circumstellar disk source known so far in h \& $\chi$ Per.
350:
351: Based on their near-IR colors and optical spectra, the faint excess sources in our survey are clearly
352: distinguishable from Be stars. The near-IR colors of the faint excess sources are
353: evenly distributed between J-H = 0.1-0.6 and H-$K_{s}$=0-0.2
354: (Figure 6, diamonds). The lack of very red H-K$_{s}$ colors for a typical faint excess
355: source is consistent with a lack of warm (T$\sim$ 1000 K) circumstellar envelope emission.
356: Nearly all (17/21) faint sources are photometrically consistent with h \& $\chi$ Per membership, though
357: high-quality spectroscopic data are currently limited to 8 sources (2 from Hydra, 6 from Hectospec).
358: Figure 8 shows the spectra.
359: Seven of the eight faint excess sources have spectra consistent
360: with h and $\chi$ Per membership. The one non-member source in Figure 8
361: is an F5 star with J=15.9, beyond the 2MASS
362: completeness limit and below the isochrone by $\sim$ 1.0 magnitude, and thus
363: is one of the four faint sources that is also photometrically inconsistent with cluster
364: membership.
365: The spectral types for the 7 sources consistent with cluster membership
366: range from A2 to F9. None show strong H$_{\alpha}$ emission which is a
367: signature of accretion (e.g. White \& Basri 2003) and thus a reservoir of
368: circumstellar gas. These stars are therefore
369: very similar to the nearby young (8-12 Myr old)
370: debris disks $\beta$ Pic, HR 4796A, and 49 Cet in that they have comparable
371: spectral types, have 24 $\mu m$ excess, and lack any signatures of gas accretion.
372: The 13 sources without known spectral types are either unobserved (12) or had too low
373: signal-to-noise to derive spectral types (1, this source is well off the isochrone).
374:
375: Many of the fainter 24$\mu m$ sources have high-quality IRAC photometry.
376: Of the 17 MIPS excess sources fainter than J=13.5
377: on the isochrone, 14 (12, 11) also have IRAC
378: measurements at [4.5] ([5.8], [8]). We summarize the observed properties of
379: the faint MIPS excess sources in Table 3. In the following two sections, we focus
380: on these sources, comparing the MIPS photometry to IRAC/2MASS photometry from C07a and
381: modeling the sources' emission from 2.2 $\mu m$ through 24$\mu m$.
382: \subsection{Nature of the Disk Population in Faint Pre-Main Sequence Stars}
383: \subsubsection{Mid-IR colors and the Wavelength-Dependent Frequency of Disks}
384: %To better constrain the circumstellar environment of our 16 disk candidates, we compare $K_{s}$-[24] colors with two IRAC colors,
385: To constrain the nature of the 17 faint MIPS excess sources that are (photometrically)
386: consistent with cluster membership, we compare the K$_{s}$/$K_{s}$-[24] CMD with CMDs using three IRAC colors,
387: $K_{s}$-[4.5], K$_{s}$-[5.8], and $K_{s}$-[8] in Figure \ref{cmdirac} (diamonds). For reference,
388: we also show the colors for bright MIPS sources without 24$\mu m$ excess (squares).
389: Following C07a, we identify sources with $K_{s}$-[IRAC] colors $\ge$ 0.4 as
390: IR excess sources; sources with $K_{s}$-[24]$\ge$0.65 are 24$\mu m$ excess
391: sources. A vertical line in Figure \ref{cmdirac} shows the division between excess and non excess sources.
392:
393: The frequency of IR excess varies with wavelength.
394: Only 1/14 faint 24$\mu m$ excess sources also have excess at [4.5]. The fraction of sources with
395: [5.8] excess is 3/12. The 8$\mu m$ excess population has a larger fraction of
396: excess sources, 5/11. While some of the 'photospheric' sources, $K_{s}$-[4.5, 5.8, 8] $\le$ 0.4,
397: may have weak excesses, many sources have $K_{s}$-[IRAC] $\le$ 0.2 (observed) and $\lesssim$ 0.1 (dereddened).
398: These sources are unlikely to have any dust emission at [4.5], [5.8], or [8].
399: While the small sample of 24$\mu m$ excess sources precludes a strong statistical significance for any trend
400: of IR excess emission, the wavelength-dependent frequency of excess emission is consistent with
401: results from larger surveys (e.g. C07a; Su et al. 2006).
402: \subsubsection{Temperature and Location of Circumstellar Dust}
403: Analyzing the strength of IR excess emission at multiple bands
404: places constraints on the temperature and location of the dust.
405: Just over half of the faint 24$\mu m$ excess sources have no
406: excess emission in the IRAC bands, so these sources
407: lack circumstellar material with temperatures $\gtrsim$ 400K.
408: Because a blackbody that peaks at 24$\mu m$ has T $\sim$ 120 - 125 K, the dust
409: temperature in most of the faint 24$\mu m$ excess sources is probably $\lesssim$ 100-200 K.
410: %For stars with a spectral type of A0 (F5), dust with an equilibrium temperature of
411: %$\sim$ 100-200K lies at distances $\sim$ ( )AU.
412:
413: We can put more quantitative constraints on the dust temperature with
414: a flux ratio diagram. Flux ratio diagrams have been an important
415: tool in analyzing accretion disks in unresolved cataclysmic
416: variable systems (e.g. Berriman et al. 1985; Mauche et al. 1997). In this
417: method, the ratio of fluxes (in this case, $\lambda$F$_{\lambda}$) at different wavelengths
418: such as $\lambda_{4.5}$F$_{4.5}$/$\lambda_{8}$F$_{8}$ and $\lambda_{24}$F$_{24}$/$\lambda_{8}$F$_{8}$ is computed. The ratios
419: for blackbody emission follow a curve in flux ratio space. Because disk-bearing sources should
420: be, to first order, the sum of two blackbodies (a hot stellar component and a cooler circumstellar
421: component), their positions in flux ratio space should lie on a line between the circumstellar dust temperature
422: and the stellar temperature.
423:
424: Figure \ref{fr} shows the flux ratio diagram for our sample, and Table 4 lists the derived
425: disk temperatures (labeled as T$_{D}$ FR).
426: We restrict our sample to 10 sources with 5$\sigma$ detections from 4.5 through
427: 24 $\mu m$\footnote{The first source in Table 3, with J=13.84, has a
428: [8] flux that has a negative K$_{s}$-[8] color and thus is unphysically faint.
429: An unphysically large ratio of the [4.5] to [8] flux cannot be interpreted with
430: a flux-ratio diagram.}.
431: Five of these sources have [8] excess; one has [4.5] excess.
432: For 13-14 Myr-old sources, the range of spectral types with J=14-15.5 is
433: $\sim$ A0 to G8 (Siess et al. 2000).
434: The flux ratios for blackbody emission from 10 K to 10000 K follow the solid line with
435: the temperatures characteristic of disks ($\sim$ 10-1000 K) on the vertical part of the line
436: and those for stellar photospheres on the horizontal part.
437: Loci showing the locations for a stellar photosphere+disk of a given temperature are shown
438: ranging from T$_{disk}$= 300 K to 100 K assuming a stellar temperature of
439: $T_{e,\star}$$\sim$ 7250 K (about F0 spectral type). The sources without (with) IRAC excess emission,
440: K$_{s}$-[IRAC] $\lesssim$ 0.4, are shown as diamonds (thick diamonds). The further away
441: from the origin point of the loci a given source is, the more the disk contributes to the total flux. The
442: derived dust temperatures are only weakly sensitive to $T_{e,\star}$ as
443: flux ratios for 5250-10000 K ($\sim$ G9-B8) blackbodies occupy roughly
444: the same place at $\lambda_{4.5}$F$_{4.5}$/$\lambda_{8}$F$_{8}$ ($\sim$ 5$\pm$0.15)
445: and $\lambda_{24}$F$_{24}$/$\lambda_{8}$F$_{8}$ ($\sim$ 0).
446: The line for the ice sublimation temperature is shown in bold.
447: The source (diamond at $\sim$ 2, 0.5) with a disk
448: component of $\approx$ 300 K has a strong [8] excess and was
449: previously identified as having $\sim$ 300-350 K dust (Source 5 in C07b) using a
450: single blackbody $\chi$$^{2}$ fit to the disk SED.
451: Four other sources, also with 8 $\mu m$ emission, have dust temperatures between 230 K and 250 K.
452: All the sources with 8$\mu m$ excess then have dust temperatures $\ge$ 230 K.
453: While these sources may have cooler dust components, some of the dust emission must
454: come from warmer disk regions closer to their parent stars.
455:
456: The dust temperatures of sources without 8$\mu m$ excess, characteristic of a slight majority
457: in our sample, are significantly lower.
458: Three sources have slightly cooler temperatures of
459: $\sim$ 170-185 K, comparable to the water ice sublimation temperature (Hayashi 1981).
460: The remaining sources have much cooler dust temperatures ($\sim$ 100-150 K).
461: This diagram demonstrates that many sources
462: must have cold dust with temperatures of T$_{dust}$ $\lesssim$ 200K.
463:
464: For sources with photospheric IRAC emission, using a single-temperature
465: blackbody - calculated by matching the 24 $\mu m$ excess while not producing significant excess in the IRAC bands - should
466: match the observed disk emission well. However, many sources also have IRAC excess, and modeling the disk emission as coming
467: from two sources (e.g. warm \textit{and} cold dust) may yield a significantly better fit (e.g.
468: Augereau et al. 1999). As an alternate way to constrain the disk temperature(s) and
469: estimate the disk luminosity and location of the dust, we now consider blackbody fits to the dereddened SEDs.
470: For sources with IRAC excess we add sources of hot and cold dust emission with temperatures of 50-250 K and 250-700 K, respectively,
471: to the stellar photosphere. Sources without IRAC excess are modeled by a stellar photosphere + single-temperature disk.
472: For the stellar blackbody, we use the conversion from spectral type to effective temperature from Kenyon and Hartmann (1995).
473: If the star has no spectral type, we use the dereddened J band flux as a proxy for spectral type as in C07a, assuming
474: A$_{J}$ $\sim$ 0.45 and using the Kenyon and Hartmann (1995) conversion table, and add a question mark after the spectral type
475: in Tables 3 and 4. We use the stellar luminosity, L$_{\star}$, for 13-14 Myr old stars of a given spectral type from Siess et al. (2000).
476: A $\chi$$^{2}$ fit to the 3.6-24 $\mu m$ fluxes is performed to find the best-fit one or
477: two dust blackbody + stellar blackbody model following Augereau et al. (1999).
478: Following Habing et al. (2001), we derive the disk luminosity from blackbody fits.
479: The integrated fluxes for each dust population of a given temperature are added and then divided by
480: the stellar flux to obtain the fractional disk luminosity, L$_{D}$/L$_{\star}$. Finally, we estimate the location of the dust
481: populations from simple radiative equilibrium:
482: \begin{equation}
483: R(AU) \approx (T_{disk}/{280})^{-2}({L_{\star}}/{L_{\odot}})^{0.5}.
484: \end {equation}
485:
486: The sources without IRAC excess have nearly identical disk temperatures to those derived from the
487: flux-ratio diagram (Table 3), ranging from $\sim$ 90 K to 185 K, and are similar to equilibrium temperatures
488: just beyond the terrestrial zone into the gas giant regions of the solar system. These sources have $\chi$$^{2}$
489: values slightly less than or comparable to the number of observations ($\sim$ 1-6). The fractional disk luminosities range from
490: $\sim$ 5.5$\times$10$^{-4}$ to 3.5$\times$10$^{-3}$, which is similar to dust luminosities for young stars surrounded by optically-thin
491: debris disks (e.g. Meyer et al. 2007). Dust in these systems is probably confined to disk regions
492: of $\sim$ 8-40 AU.
493:
494: Sources with both IRAC and MIPS excess emission have disk temperatures substantially different from
495: those inferred from the flux-ratio diagram and show evidence of terrestrial zone dust emission and colder dust.
496: %While the $\chi$$^{2}$ parameter of several IRAC+MIPS excess sources is larger
497: %than any for MIPS-only excess sources,
498: The two dust population fits for the IRAC+MIPS excess sources show evidence
499: for a wide range of dust temperatures with warm terrestrial dust emission and cold dust
500: emission similar to that from sources without IRAC excess. For instance,
501: the SED of the A6 star with IRAC and MIPS excess is best fit ($\chi$$^{2}$ $\sim$ 7.6) by a hot dust component of 375 K coming from
502: 1.8 AU and a cold component of 85 K at $\sim$ 37 AU. The faint F9 star, identified previously as 'Source 5',
503: is extremely well fit ($\chi$$^{2}$ $\sim$ 0.5) by dust populations of 240 and 330 K at 1.8 and 3.4 AU, respectively.
504: Because these sources have both warm and cold dust, it is not surprising that
505: their fractional disk luminosities are typically higher. The fractional luminosity of Source 5 ($\sim$ 6$\times$10$^{-3}$) is
506: comparable to the most massive debris disks (e.g. HR 4796A), and in general the luminosity of the disk population is
507: consistent with values for massive debris disks. The most luminous disk source
508: (L$_{D}$/L$_{\star}$ $\sim$ 1.5$\times$10$^{-2}$) is the lone exception and
509: has a luminosity halfway in between values expected for luminous debris disks ($\sim$ several$\times$10$^{-3}$) and long-lived T Tauri
510: disks with inner holes (e.g. TW Hya; Low et al. 2005). We analyze this system further in \S 3.3.3.
511:
512: In summary, the faint MIPS excess sources have dust with a range of temperatures and luminosities.
513: Sources without IRAC excess are well fit by single-temperature blackbodies and have cold dust components with temperatures
514: $\sim$ 90-185 K. Sources with IRAC excess are better fit by two dust components, a hotter, terrestrial zone component
515: and a cooler component. The disks in h and $\chi$ Persei then show evidence of having inner regions of varying
516: sizes cleared of dust. All but one source has a fractional disk luminosity $\lesssim$ 10$^{-2}$, consistent with optically-thin
517: debris disks. In the next section, we investigate the evolutionary state of the faint MIPS excess population further
518: by comparing their properties to other predicted properties for massive debris disks and T Tauri disks.
519: \subsubsection{Evolutionary State of the MIPS Disk Candidates: A Population of Luminous $\sim$ 13-14 Myr-old Debris Disks}
520: We now consider the evolutionary state of the dust in the 24$\mu m$ excess sources.
521: Although the relative luminosities (L$_{d}$/L$_{\star}$
522: $\sim$ 10$^{-3}$) and lack of accretion signatures suggest these h and $\chi$ Per sources are debris disks, some T Tauri stars (e.g.
523: 'transition' T Tauri stars; Kenyon \& Hartmann 1995) may also have inner regions cleared of gas and dust.
524: Thus, it is important to compare their disk properties to models of debris disks and T Tauri disks.
525:
526: We first examine the nature of the h and $\chi$ Per disk population
527: as a whole. Because our smallest disk luminosities,
528: $\sim 5 \times 10^{-4}$, are larger than more than half of
529: known $\gtrsim$ 10 Myr-old disks (e.g. Meyer et al. 2007), our MIPS
530: sample probably misses lower luminosity sources with
531: $L_d/L_{\star} \lesssim 10^{-4}$. Similarly, our lack of
532: 70 $\mu$m detections limits our ability to detect and to
533: evaluate disk emission from cooler dust -- such as is observed in
534: $\beta$ Pic and HR 4796A -- with SEDs that peak at 40--100 $\mu$m.
535: For example, the nearby, luminous disk around 49 Cet (spectral type A1V, 8 Myr old;
536: \citealt{Wa07}) has a 24$\mu$m excess of $\sim$ 2.5 magnitudes.
537: We detect only one faint (J $\ge$ 13) MIPS excess sources with K$_{s}$-[24] $\le$ 2.5. Therefore, it is possible that
538: there are additional very luminous young disks in h and $\chi$ Per just below our detection limit.
539:
540: These limits and the rich nature of the Double Cluster allow
541: us to estimate the prevalence of massive, luminous disks.
542: The total number of A0 to early F stars (F2) in h and $\chi$ Per is $\approx$ 1000 (Currie et al. 2007
543: in prep.; cf. Currie et al. 2007a). Assuming that the disk fraction is
544: $\sim$ 20\%\footnote{disk fractions quoted by Chen et al. (2005b) range from
545: 9\% to 46\%}, we detect 17/200, or $\approx$ 10\% of all disks with strong emission at
546: 24$\mu$m. Thus, this population
547: is extreme and yields a better understanding of the evolutionary
548: state of the most luminous disks in a populous star cluster.
549:
550: To constrain the evolutionary state of the disks, we
551: compare the near-to-mid infrared disk colors to those expected for two disk models:
552: a flat, optically-thick disk around a Classical T Tauri star
553: ($T_{disk}$$\sim$$r^{-0.75}$; Kenyon \& Hartmann 1987)
554: %, an optically-thick disk+inner hole
555: %model for Class II/III 'transition' T Tauri stars (e.g. Kenyon \& Hartmann 1995),
556: and an optically-thin disk
557: model from Kenyon \& Bromley (2004a) for debris emission produced by planet formation.
558: Because only one of our sources has [4.5] excess emission and less than half
559: have [8] excess emission, we match the data to models of planet formation not in the
560: terrestrial zone (Kenyon \& Bromley 2004a) but at 30-150 AU from a 2.0 $M_{\odot}$
561: primary star (Kenyon \& Bromley 2004b). For a $\sim$ 2.0 $M_{\odot}$, 20 L$_{\odot}$ star, the temperature range from 30 to 150 AU
562: is comparable to the outer gas/ice giant region in our solar system ($\sim$ 6.7-34 AU).
563: We adopt a $\Sigma \propto$ $r^{-1.5}$ profile for the initial column density
564: of planetesimals and an initial disk mass of 3$\times$ a scaled Minimum Mass Solar Nebula (Hayashi 1981):
565: 3$\times$ 0.01 M$_{\star}/M_{\odot}$ (where M$_{\star}$ = 2 M$_{\odot}$).
566: Emission from planetesimal collisions is tracked for $\sim$ 10$^{8}$ yr. Model predictions are reddened
567: to values for h and $\chi$ Persei (reddening laws in the IRAC/MIPS bands are described in C07b).
568:
569: Figure \ref{colcol} shows the K$_{s}$-[4.5, 5.8]/K$_{s}$-[24] color-color diagrams for bright photospheric
570: sources and the faint 24$\mu m$ excess sources.
571: The debris disk locus is overplotted as a thin black line. Debris from planet formation
572: produces a peak excess emission at $K_{s}$-[24] $\sim$ 3.6 at $\sim$ 10$^{7}$ years; the $K_{s}$-[4.5]
573: and $K_{s}$-[8] colors peak at $\sim$ 0.4 at earlier times ($\sim$ 10$^{6}$ years). The debris disk locus tracks the colors
574: for most of the sources in $K_{s}$-[4.5]/$K_{s}$-[24] space very well
575: (Figure \ref{colcol}a). While the locus underpredicts the [8] excess for about half of the
576: sources (Figure \ref{colcol}b), warmer regions of a debris disk
577: not modeled here may produce this excess (e.g. KB04a). C07b showed that planet formation in the
578: terrestrial zone can produce strong [8] emission characteristic of some h and $\chi$ Per
579: sources at $\sim$ 10-15 Myr. Indeed, the source with $K_{s}$-[8]$\sim$ 1.3,
580: $K_{s}$-[24]$\sim$ 4.4 is Source 5 from C07b which was one of eight modeled as having terrestrial zone
581: debris disk emission. The warm dust temperature ($\sim$ 300 K) derived for this
582: source in \S 4.2 is consistent with terrestrial zone emission.
583:
584: Disk models corresponding to earlier evolutionary states fare worse in matching the observed mid-IR colors.
585: The optically-thick flat disk model (the triangle in both plots)
586: predicts $K_{s}$-[5.8] ([8]) $\sim$ 1.5 (2.9) and $K_{s}$-[24]$\sim$6, consistently 1-2 magnitudes redder
587: than the data. To match the observed [24] excess, any
588: optically-thick disk with an inner hole (cf. C07b) must be cleared of dust out to the distances probed
589: by the MIPS bands: $\sim$ 25 AU for a 20 $L_{\odot}$ primary star. While inner hole models may be
590: constructed to fit the SEDs of sources with only 24 $\mu m$ excess, these models predict nearly zero
591: IRAC color even though about half of the sample has excess at [8]. Lack of gas accretion signatures,
592: low fractional disk luminosities, and SED modeling then suggest that at least many faint h and $\chi$
593: Per sources with 24 $\mu m$ excess are stars surrounded by optically-thin debris disks.
594: More sensitive spectroscopic observations are needed to verify the lack of gas in these
595: systems.
596:
597: Despite the general success of the debris disk models, at least one h and $\chi$ Per source may
598: harbor a disk at an earlier evolutionary state.
599: This source has a K$_{s}$-[24] color of $\sim$ 6, which is $\sim$ 1 mag redder than HR 4796A,
600: the strongest 24$\mu m$ excess source in R05. This color is close to the optically-thick disk predictions,
601: is extremely difficult to produce with a debris disk model, and is more similar to the level of excesses in
602: older T Tauri stars like HD 152404 and TW Hya (Chen et al. 2005b; Low et al. 2005).
603:
604: To explore this possibility, we
605: overplot the K$_{s}$-[4.5], K$_{s}$-[8], and K$_{s}$-[24] colors of TW Hya from Hartmann et al. (2005) and
606: Low et al. (2005) in Figure \ref{colcol} (large cross, reddened to h and $\chi$ Per). The mid-IR colors of our brightest source are
607: similar to the colors of TW Hya. While TW Hya's disk has an optically-thin inner region
608: where the early stages of planet formation may be commencing (Eisner et al. 2006), the disk is probably optically-thick
609: at 24$\mu m$ (Low et al. 2005). TW Hya also has strong H$_{\alpha}$ emission which
610: indicates accretion. On the other hand, the fractional disk luminosity in h and $\chi$ Per sources
611: is much lower than that of TW Hya ($\sim$ 0.27, Low et al. 2005) and in between values for debris disks
612: and transition disks. Thus, some lines of evidence suggest that this extreme h and $\chi$ Per source
613: is at an evolutionary state earlier than the debris disk phase while others are more ambiguous.
614: Obtaining optical spectra of this source, to search for accretion signatures, may allow us to make a better
615: comparison between it and older T Tauri stars like TW Hya.
616: %This discrepancy may be resolved by noting that
617: %TW Hya is a K8 star while the 'TW Hya'-like source in h \& $\chi$ Per is likely much earlier and thus
618: %more luminous: L$_{\star, TW Hya}$/L$_{\star, source}$ $\approx$ 0.035. Dividing the disk luminosity by
619: %this ratio brings the h \& $\chi$ Per source luminosity to within a factor of 3 of TW Hya's.
620:
621: The spectral energy distributions (SEDs) of the faint MIPS excess sources show
622: evidence for a range of dust temperature distributions, which may be connected to a range
623: of evolutionary states (Figure \ref{sed4}). We select four sources, three with spectra and
624: one without, that are representative of the range of mid-IR colors from our sample.
625: The first three sources of Figure \ref{sed4}, dereddened to A$_{V}$=1.62 (E(B-V)=0.52),
626: have been spectroscopically confirmed as
627: F9 (source 1), F9 (source 2), and A6 (source 3) stars, respectively; the second source was mentioned in the previous
628: paragraph (with K$_{s}$-[24]$\sim$ 4.4). The SEDs
629: for the bottom left source was also dereddened to A$_{V}$=1.62, and a spectral type
630: of A2 was chosen based on the conversion from absolute magnitude to spectral type
631: for 14 Myr-old sources (from Siess et al. 2000; Kenyon \& Hartmann (1995) color conversions).
632: The source with photospheric emission at $\lambda$ $<$24$\mu m$ (source 4) has
633: IRAC colors representative of just over half of the faint MIPS-excess sources in
634: Figure \ref{colcol}. The debris disk model accurately predicts the SEDs of the source with photospheric
635: 8$\mu m$ emission and two sources with weak 8$\mu m$ excess emission. The remaining source is not
636: fit well by the disk model and shows clear evidence for a large warm dust population (see C07b).
637: The evolutionary states for the sources shown in Figure \ref{sed4} and
638: the 9 sources with complete IRAC and MIPS photometry are listed Table 2.
639:
640: Thus, we conclude that emission from at least half of the 24$\mu m$ excess sources around pre-main sequence stars
641: in h and $\chi$ Per is best explained by debris from
642: planet formation at locations comparable to the gas/ice giant regions in the solar nebula. Some of the other
643: pre-main sequence stars with 24 $\mu m$ excess may also have ongoing planet formation in the
644: inner, terrestrial zone regions as indicated by their 8 $\mu m$ excesses. One of our sources
645: may be a T Tauri star at a slightly earlier evolutionary state than the debris disk sources
646: in our sample.
647:
648: If most of the disk population is then interpreted as an early debris disk population
649: (not a Class II/III transition T Tauri disk population), the wavelength-dependent frequency
650: of IRAC/MIPS disk excess identified in \S3.3.1 implies a location-dependent evolution of
651: debris disks, specifically a clearing of warm dust from inner disk regions.
652: This behavior is consistent with standard models of planet formation (KB04a),
653: which predict that dust emission from the planet formation process disappears at shorter
654: wavelengths (e.g. IRAC bands) faster than at longer wavelengths (e.g. MIPS bands).
655: This result is expected if planet formation runs to completion in the innermost regions
656: of protoplanetary disks before planets are formed in the outer disk.
657:
658: \section{Evidence for a Rise and Fall of Debris Disk Emission}
659: To place our results in context, we now compare the excesses observed
660: in h and $\chi$ Per sources with measurements of other stars with roughly similar masses. We follow
661: R05 and consider the magnitude of the 24$\mu m$ excess, [24]$_{obs}$-[24]$_{\star}$, as a function of time.
662: Using a sample of early (A) type stars with ages $\gtrsim$ 5 Myr, R05 showed that stars have a wide range of
663: excesses at all ages and that sources with the largest excesses define an envelope that decays slowly with
664: time (Figure \ref{excvagegr}). Although this envelope is consistent with a power-law decay,
665: [24]$_{obs}$-[24]$_{\star}$ $\propto$ t$^{-1}$, the R05 sample has relatively few stars with ages
666: $\sim$ 5-20 Myr where debris disk models predict large excesses. The sources with the largest
667: excesses, HR 4796A and $\beta$ Pic, fall within this age range at 8 and 12
668: Myr\footnote{While $\beta$ Pictoris was given an age of 20 Myr in R05, derived from Barrado y Navasceus et al. (1999),
669: recent work suggests a slightly younger age of $\sim$ 12 Myr (e.g. Zuckerman et al. 2001; Ortega et al. 2002).}, respectively.
670:
671: Together with our results for h and $\chi$ Per, several recent surveys in young clusters and associations
672: identify debris disks with ages of $\sim$ 5-20 Myr (Chen et al. 2005b; Hernandez et al. 2006;
673: Sicilia-Aguilar et al. 2006). As in R05, these surveys show a large range of 24 $\mu m$ excesses
674: at each age. In the well-sampled Sco-Cen Association, for example, Chen et al. (2005b) identify many stars
675: with photospheric emission (no excess) at 24$\mu m$ and several stars with excesses considerably
676: larger than the typical excess observed in the R05 sample. Although our h and $\chi$ Per data
677: do not provide any measure of the number of stars with photospheric emission at 24 $\mu m$,
678: the survey yields a good sample of stars with excesses much larger than the typical R05 source.
679:
680: We now combine our results with those from R05 and from more recent surveys of debris disks in young clusters.
681: Specifically, we add data from Tr 37 (4 Myr) and NGC 7160 (11.8 Myr) (in Cepheus; Sicilia-Aguilar et al. 2006),
682: Orion OB1a (10 Myr) and Orion OB1b (5 Myr; both from Hernandez et al. 2006), and Sco-Cen ($\sim$ 5, 16, and 17 Myr
683: for Upper Sco, Lower Centaurus Crux, and Upper Centaurus Lupus, respectively; Chen et al.
684: 2005b). For h and $\chi$ Per and Cepheus sources, we include only the IR-excess sources. The sensitivity of the
685: Sco-Cen observations allows more precise determinations of the photospheric flux levels farther down the initial mass function of
686: the cluster, so we include data for all sources earlier than G0 with or without excess in this cluster.
687: For sources with no published estimate of the photospheric flux, we assume that K$_{s}$-[24]$_{\star}$ $\sim$ 0 (dereddened),
688: which is valid for our sample of A and F stars.
689:
690: \subsection{Observed Mid-IR Emission vs. Age}
691: When data from h and $\chi$ Persei and other young clusters are added to R05,
692: the evolution of 24 $\mu m$ excess with age shows an important new trend. \textit{From $\sim$ 5-10 Myr,
693: there is a clear rise in the magnitude of excess followed by a peak at $\sim$ 10-15 Myr, and a slow t$^{-1}$
694: decay after $\sim$ 15-20 Myr} (Figure \ref{excvage}). All sources with very large
695: ($\gtrsim$ 3 mag) excesses have ages between 8 and 16 Myr. The 24 $\mu m$ excess
696: emission peaks at $\sim$ 12-16 Myr as indicated by strong excess sources in h and
697: $\chi$ Persei (diamonds), NGC 7160 (squares), and Sco-Cen (asterisks).
698: Data from 5 Myr-old Orion OB1b and Upper Sco to 10 Myr-old Orion OB1a to 12-17 Myr-old NGC 7160, h and $\chi$ Per,
699: and the two older Sco-Cen subgroups shows a
700: sequential rise in the median 24 $\mu m$ excess \footnote{The debris disk
701: candidates in Tr 37 have larger excesses than those in Orion OB1a. However, the strong excess may be explained by
702: differences in stellar properties: 2/3 of the debris disk systems in Tr 37 are B3/B5 and B7 stars, which are
703: far more massive than 10 Myr-old A/F stars ($\sim$ 3.5-6 M$_{\odot}$ vs. 1.5-2.5 M$_{\odot}$; cf. Siess et al. 2000). If typical disk
704: masses scale with the stellar mass, then these much more massive stars should have more massive, more strongly emitting disks.
705: The disk mass-dependent amplitude of excess is discussed in \S 4.3.}. A peak in the 24 $\mu m$ excess emission at $\sim$ 10 Myr is
706: also visible in a plot from Hernandez et al. (2006), albeit at a lower statistical significance.
707: The addition of several $\lesssim$ 20 Myr-old clusters
708: more strongly constrains the time when debris emission peaks and maps out its evolution from 5-20 Myr
709: in more detail.
710:
711: Removing possible TW Hya-like sources from this diagram does not modify the trends.
712: The 'TW Hya-like' source in h and $\chi$ Per ([24] excess $\sim$ 5.5) and the strongest excess source
713: in Sco-Cen ([24] excess $\sim$ 5.75) have the largest 24$\mu m$ excesses and may be at an evolutionary state
714: prior to the debris disk phase. However, many sources in
715: the 10-15 Myr age range have $\sim$ 2-3.5 magnitude excesses, including HR 4796A and many
716: h and $\chi$ Per sources, which have disk luminosities and mid-IR colors inconsistent with an optically-thick disk.
717: The second most luminous source in Sco-Cen, HD 113766A (F3 spectral type) with a 24 $\mu m$ excess of $\sim$ 4.7 magnitudes,
718: has a fractional disk luminosity characteristic of a massive debris disk (Chen et al. 2005b).
719: Sources with [24]$_{observed}$-[24]$_{\star}$ $\ge$ 2-3 are more common at $\sim$ 10-15 Myr than at much younger
720: ($\sim$ 5 Myr) or older ($\gtrsim$ 20 Myr) ages.
721:
722: \subsection{Statistical Verification of a Peak in 24 $\mu m$ Emission at 10-15 Myr}
723: The peak at 10-15 Myr is statistically robust. To test it, we adopted the underlying approach that Wyatt et
724: al. (2007a) demonstrate gives a good first-order description of debris disk behavior: debris disks all evolve
725: in a similar fashion, with the variations among them arising primarily from differences in initial mass. This
726: result has two important implications for us: 1.) it validates deducing evolution with time from the upper
727: envelope of the infrared excesses, since similar high-mass disks of different ages define this envelope; and
728: 2.) it allows us to estimate the distribution of excesses at any time by scaling the excesses at another time
729: according to $t^{-1}$ (by one over the ratio of the source ages), the general time dependence of disk decay (R05). We use the second of these results
730: to predict the distribution of excesses at 5Myr from measurements of the distribution at 10 - 30 Myr, where
731: enough systems have been measured to define the distribution well. We use three samples (Sco-Cen, Orion Ob1, and
732: R05), each of which includes the complete range of [24]$_{obs}$-[24]$_*$ down to zero, i.e.,
733: photospheric colors. If the scaled colors for sources predict much larger excesses than the 5Myr old
734: Orion Ob1b excesses, then we can conclude that the mid-IR colors of our samples from 5 to 15 Myr do not
735: follow a $t^{-1}$ decline.
736:
737: Figure \ref{scaled} shows the scaled Sco-Cen and Rieke et al. excesses compared to the observed 5 Myr excesses in Orion Ob1b
738: normalized to the total number of sources in each sample.
739: Many scaled excess sources ($\sim$ 20\% of the total population) are $\gtrsim$ 1-3 mags redder than any in Orion Ob1b.
740: The Kolmogorov-Smirnov test shows that the scaled Sco-Cen (Rieke et al.) sources
741: have a probability of 0.07 (0.06) of being drawn from the same population as Orion Ob1b with a $\gtrsim$ 0.75 mag excess.
742: If we instead compare the scaled sources to Orion Ob1b sources with a $\gtrsim$ 0.5 mag excess, where Orion and the
743: other two populations begin to overlap in Figure \ref{scaled}, the probability is even lower:
744: 2.3$\times$10$^{-5}$ (3.5$\times$10$^{-8}$) for the Sco-Cen (Rieke et al.) sample. Thus, the evolution of 24 $\mu m$
745: emission from Orion Ob1b, Sco-Cen, and Rieke et al. sources is not consistent with a t$^{-1}$ decay.
746:
747: There are two main alternatives to the t$^{-1}$ decay of IR excess with time for the youngest debris disks.
748: The IR excess could be constant for $\sim$ 20 Myr and then follow a t$^{-1}$ decay law. The IR excess could also
749: increase with time to some peak value and then follow a t$^{-1}$ decay law. To test the constant emission
750: possibility, we use the Wilcoxon Rank-Sum test. The Rank-Sum test allows us to
751: evaluate whether or not the populations have the same mean value or have
752: intrinsically larger/smaller excesses than another sample (Z parameter).
753: The test also measures the probability that two samples are drawn from
754: the same parent population by the Prob(RS) parameter (as in the K-S test).
755:
756: Table 5 summarizes our results.
757: Statistical tests show that the [24]$_{obs}$-[24]$_{\star}$ excesses cannot be constant with time and verify that
758: emission rises from 5 to 10 Myr (Table 3). Sco-Cen has the largest mean excess ratio ($\sim$ 1.25) and has
759: the widest range of colors with a [24]-[24]$_{\star}$ standard deviation of $\sim$ 1.4 compared
760: to $\sim$ 0.6-0.8 for the Orion subgroups. The Wilcoxan Rank-Sum test reveals that Sco-Cen has $\lesssim$ 5\% probability of being drawn
761: from the same population as Orion Ob1b and has a statistically significant larger peak (Z $\sim$ -1.65). Orion Ob1a also
762: has a significant larger peak than Orion Ob1b (Z $\sim$ -2.8, Prob (RS) $\sim$ 0.002), and Sco-Cen's peak is marginally larger
763: than Orion Ob1a's (Z $\sim$ -0.05).
764:
765: These results lead us to conclude that \textit{\textbf{the evolution of mid-IR excess emission from planet formation
766: in debris disks is best characterized as a rise in excess
767: from $\sim$ 5-10 Myr, a peak at $\sim$ 10-15 Myr, and a fall in excess from $\sim$ 15/20 Myr-1 Gyr}}.
768: The rise to maximum excess from 5 to 10 Myr is steep: typical excesses increase from $\sim$ 1 mag to $\sim$ 3 mag by 11.8 Myr.
769: The peak in excess amplitude is $\sim$ 5-10 Myr broad because
770: the excesses in NGC 7160, h and $\chi$ Per, and Sco-Cen are all comparable. By $\sim$ 25 Myr the typical excesses decline
771: with age as suggested by R05.
772:
773: \subsection{Comparison with Models of Emission from Planet Formation}
774: To investigate how the 'rise and fall' trend of debris emission may be connected with physical processes producing
775: the emission, we overplot the debris disk evolution tracks (dotted lines) from \S 3.3.3 and debris disk tracks for a low-mass disk
776: (1/3$\times$MMSN$_{scaled}$). The KB04 calculations start at t=0 with an ensemble of $\sim$ km-sized planetesimals.
777: To bracket the likely timescale for km-sized planetesimals to form at 30-150 AU (e.g. Dominik \& Dullemond 2005; Weidenschilling 1997),
778: we include a second locus shifted by 2 Myr (solid lines). The range in debris disk masses
779: is about a factor of 10, comparable to the range of disk masses inferred from submillimeter observations of young stars
780: %(Natta et al. 2004; Andrews and Williams 2005).
781: \citep{Aw05}.
782:
783: The debris disk models from \S 3.3.3 show a steep
784: increase in debris emission from 5-10 Myr, a plateau for the following $\sim$ 20 Myr, and then a shallow decline in debris emission.
785: The massive disk locus (dotted line) yields a peak in emission at $\sim$ 7-8 Myr, or very close to the age of HR 4796A.
786: The locus started at 2 Myr (solid line) peaks at $\sim$ 9-10 Myr, close to the ages of h and $\chi$ Persei and NGC 7160,
787: and yields substantial emission through 20 Myr before emission declines. The lower-mass disk loci
788: peak later at $\sim$ 40 Myr with excesses comparable to the majority of those in R05. Caution should be taken to avoid
789: overinterpreting these similarities: the exact time of the debris disk emission peak as
790: well as the amplitude of the peak depend on
791: %the initial disk mass as well as other
792: input parameters such as planetesimal disruption energy.
793: %For example, the massive debris disk
794: %locus assumes an initial disk mass of 3$\times$ a scaled Minimum Mass Solar
795: %Nebula ($\approx$ 0.1 $M_{disk}$/$M_{\star}$). While the mass of this disk is within
796: %the range of measured $M_{disk}$/$M_{\star}$ ratios (Natta et al. 2004; Andrews and Williams 2005),
797: %lower mass, MMSN disks produce weaker excess emission ($\sim$ 2-3 magnitudes).
798: Nevertheless, the massive debris disk model yields the same
799: general trend in the maximum 24 $\mu m$ excess amplitude with time;
800: the low-mass disk model reproduces the 24 $\mu m$ excesses of many $\gtrsim$ 30 Myr-old sources.
801: The observed behavior of 24 $\mu m$ excess with time is then at least qualitatively
802: consistent with our understanding of the processes associated with planet formation.
803: \section{Discussion}
804: \subsection{Summary of Results}
805: Our analysis of MIPS data for the 13-14 Myr-old double cluster,
806: h and $\chi$ Persei, shows two significant 24 $\mu m$ excess populations.
807: Bright Be stars with J$\lesssim$ 12-13 have 1-2 mag excesses
808: at 24 $\mu m$ and follow a clear Be star locus in the J-H/H-K$_{s}$ color-color diagram. Optical
809: spectra confirm the Be star status for just under half of the candidates from the color-color diagram.
810: We also detect a B4 star with a clear 24 $\mu m$ excess but without H$_{\alpha}$ emission
811: or evidence for near-IR excess.
812:
813: Fainter stars with J $\sim$ 14-15 fall on the 14 Myr isochrone in a J/J-H color-magnitude diagram.
814: Optical spectra confirm that many of these stars have late A-type or F-type spectra, consistent with cluster
815: membership. The IRAC and MIPS colors of these sources suggest that the frequency of excess
816: at wavelengths which probe IR excess emission increases with increasing wavelength. The wavelength-dependent
817: frequency of excess is consistent with the presence of inner holes devoid of dust.
818:
819: Our analysis of the dust temperatures in the fainter excess sources suggest two groups.
820: A smaller group of stars has emission from warmer dust with T $\sim$ 200-300 K. A larger
821: group has emission from colder dust, T $\lesssim$ 200 K. In both groups, the dust luminosity is
822: a small fraction of the stellar luminosity, L$_{d}$/L$_{\star}$ $\sim$ 10$^{-4}$-10$^{-3}$, typical
823: of debris disks like HR 4796A (Low et al. 2005). The IR colors and spectral energy distributions of the latter
824: group are consistent with predictions from cold debris disk models; sources with warmer dust
825: may have terrestrial zone debris emission (see also C07b).
826:
827: The MIPS data from h \& $\chi$ Persei and other recently surveyed clusters yield a large sample
828: of disks at 5-20 Myr, an age range critically
829: important for understanding debris disk evolution and planet formation.
830: This sample shows that debris disk emission rises from 5 Myr to $\sim$ 10 Myr, peaks at $\sim$ 10-15 Myr,
831: and then fades on a $\sim$ 150 Myr timescale as t$^{-1}$ (R05). Numerous statistical tests verify
832: the observed trend.
833: Debris production from ongoing planet formation explains the general time evolution of this emission
834: (e.g. KB04).
835:
836: \subsection{Future Modeling Work: Explaining the Range of MIPS Excesses}
837: The debris disk models from Kenyon \& Bromley (2004a) generally explain the peak excesses
838: for sources in h \& $\chi$ Per and other $\sim$ 10-15 Myr-old clusters.
839: However, at a given age stars have a wide spread of IR excesses above and below the debris disk
840: model predictions. The IR excesses far weaker than the model predictions have several tenable explanations. Low-mass disks
841: modeled in \S 4 have weaker excesses.
842: Disks in systems with binary companions close to the disk radius are probably disrupted quickly, although
843: binaries with wider separations should have little effect, and very close separations may actually enhance
844: infrared excesses (Bouwman et al. 2006; Trilling et al. 2007). Gas giant planets may also remove IR-emitting dust.
845:
846: Reproducing the larger IR excesses (K$_{s}$-[24] $\gtrsim$ 4-5) is more difficult.
847: The debris disk model used in this paper yields a
848: peak K$_{s}$-[24] $\sim$ 3.5 (unreddened), but HR 4796A and several sources in h and $\chi$ Per and Sco-Cen
849: have stronger excesses.
850: More massive disks should yield stronger 24$\mu m$ excesses, but the disk mass cannot be increased indefinitely.
851: A disk with mass M$_{d}$ $\gtrsim$ 0.1-0.15 M$_{\star}$ would have been initially gravitationally
852: unstable and would form a low-mass companion.
853: %Submillimeter observations also define a maximum inferred disk mass of
854: %$\approx$ 0.1 M$_{\star}$ (e.g. Andrews and Williams 2005).
855: However, the debris disk status of one of these extreme cases, HR 4796A with K$_{s}$-[24] $\approx$ 5,
856: has been confirmed by extensive disk SED modeling (e.g. \citealt{Au99, Cu03, Wa05})
857: %(e.g. Augereau et al. 1999; Currie et al. 2003 )
858: and strict gas mass upper limits of $\lesssim$ 1 M$_{Jupiter}$ \citep{Ck04}.
859: There are several ways to account for these larger excesses.
860: %First,
861: %due to the likelihood of grain growth and other processes unique to the disk environment (Dominik et al. 2007),
862: %the optical constants of the emitting grains are uncertain, so the mapping of excess to disk mass may be
863: %incorrect. Second,
864: For example, dynamical processes that allow small grains to be retained (which produce
865: larger opacity) in rings like that observed for HR 4796A may explain the large-amplitude excesses in some debris disks
866: (e.g. Klahr and Lin 2005; Takeuchi and Artymowicz 2001).
867: Whether or not the strong excess sources in h and $\chi$ Per can be explained by such grain confinement
868: mechanisms is the subject of future work.
869: \subsection{Comparison with Previous Spitzer Observations and Analysis of h and $\chi$ Persei
870: from \citet{Cu07a} and \citet{Cu07b}}
871: This paper completes the first study of the circumstellar disk population of pre-main sequence
872: stars in the massive double cluster, h and $\chi$ Persei. Together with
873: Cu07a and Cu07b, this work provides new constraints on the frequency, lifetimes,
874: and evolutionary states of circumstellar disks in 10-15 Myr old stars.
875: Here we summarize the main results and conclusion of these studies.
876:
877: Spitzer data for h and $\chi$ Per provide clear
878: evidence that the frequency of IR excess emission
879: depends on wavelength and on the mass of the star
880: (C07a; this paper, \S 3). Stars in both clusters
881: have a higher frequency of IR excess at longer
882: wavelengths. Lower mass (1.4-2 M$_{\odot}$) stars have IR excesses more
883: often than more massive ($\gtrsim$ 2 M$_{\odot}$) stars. Su et al. (2006)
884: and \citet{Gr07} derive similar results
885: for other clusters. Taken together, these results
886: are consistent with an inside-out clearing of
887: dust from young circumstellar disks, as expected
888: from theoretical models of planet formation (e.g. \citealt{KB04b}).
889:
890: To compare the completeness level of the MIPS sample with
891: the IRAC sample from C07a, we derive the fraction of IRAC
892: sources with MIPS detections at each IRAC band. The IRAC
893: survey has 90\% completeness levels of $\sim$ 14.5 at
894: [4.5] and $\sim$ 13.75 at [8]. The
895: MIPS sample includes 87\% (3\%) of the IRAC sources with
896: [3.6] $<$ 10 ([3.6] $<$ 14.5) and 88\% (11\%) of the IRAC sources
897: with [8] $<$ 10 ([8] $<$ 13.75) within 25' of either cluster center.
898: Because the MIPS survey detects
899: such a small percentage of the IRAC sources in C07a, we
900: cannot analyze a statistically significant population of
901: IRAC IR excess sources with MIPS detections. However, the
902: MIPS sources yield interesting constraints on the Be star
903: population in h and $\chi$ Per (\S 3.2) and demonstrate a
904: clear peak in the time evolution of the 24 $\mu$m excess of
905: debris disks (\S 4.).
906:
907: Detailed analyses of the IRAC/MIPS colors and the
908: broadband SEDs demonstrate that warm dust (T $\sim$
909: 240--400 K) is visible in 11 cluster stars (C07b;
910: this paper, \S 3). The dust luminosities of ten of these
911: sources ($\sim$ 10$^{-4}$-6$\times$10$^{-3}$ L$_{\star}$) suggest this emission arises
912: from optically thin dust in a debris disk. The
913: IR excesses of these sources -- which comprise the
914: majority of known warm debris disks (see Hines et al. 2006, Wyatt et al. 2007b,
915: and \citealt{Gr07} for others) -- are
916: consistent with detailed calculations of terrestrial
917: planet formation around $\sim$ 2 $M_{\odot}$ stars \citep{KB04a}.
918:
919: Most of the IRAC/MIPS IR excess sources show evidence for
920: cooler dust with T $\sim$ 100--200 K (this paper; \S 3, 4).
921: Although the lack of 70 $\mu$m detections prevents
922: us from deriving precise limits on the dust temperatures
923: and luminosities, the Spitzer data suggest that most
924: (perhaps all) of these sources are debris disks with
925: SEDs similar to those observed in Sco-Cen,
926: the TW Hya Association and other young clusters. (\citealt{Ch05b, Lo05}).
927: When combined with data from the literature, these
928: data provide clear evidence for a rise in the magnitude
929: of the IR excesses from debris disks from $\sim$ 5 Myr
930: to $\sim$ 10--15 Myr followed by a fall from $\sim$
931: 20 Myr onward.
932:
933: Although theory provides a reasonably good first-order
934: explanation for the time evolution of the IR excesses in
935: $\gtrsim$ 1.4 M$_{\odot}$ stars,
936: some aspects of the observations remain challenging.
937: A large range of initial disk masses and binary companions
938: can probably explain the large range in IR excesses at
939: a given stellar age, but these explanations require
940: further testing.
941: Current theory does not explain the largest IR excesses
942: observed in the 10--20 Myr old stars in h and $\chi$ Persei,
943: Sco-Cen, and the TW Hya Association (specifically HR 4796A).
944: Dynamical, radiative, and stochastic processes not included
945: in the numerical calculations are possible solutions to
946: this failure. Increasing the sample size of this extreme
947: population would provide better constraints on these
948: processes.
949:
950: Finally, this survey has provided us with several interesting
951: sources that warrant more detailed investigation.
952: %As in $\beta$ Pic and HR 4796A, the luminous debris disks in h
953: %and chi Per (e.g., 'Source 5') appear to have a wide range of
954: %dust temperatures suggesting that the material orbits in
955: %a broad torus instead of a narrow ring. -- describe observations
956: %that might help to udnerstand this system
957: For instance,
958: 'Source 5' -- discussed here and in \citet{Cu07b} -- is probably an extremely massive debris disk.
959: With a fractional disk luminosity of $\sim$ 6$\times$ 10$^{-3}$, its emission rivals that of
960: HR 4796A, $\beta$ Pic and other massive, nearby debris disks. However, this source differs from these other
961: sources in at least two important ways.
962: First, its spectral type is later (F9) than most stars with massive debris disks. Second, it harbors far warmer
963: dust (T$_{d}$ $\sim$ 240-330 K) than most massive debris disks like HR 4796A (T$_{d}$ $\sim$ 110 K; \citealt{Lo05}). This
964: feature may make it more similar to the warm debris disk of HD 113766A in Sco-Cen, the second most
965: luminous source in Sco-Cen shown in Figure \ref{excvage} \citep{Ch05b}, than to HR 4796A and $\beta$ Pic.
966: %'Source 5' may be a rather unique system, a massive warm debris disk around a late F star, or it may be
967: %the brightest of a largely-unseen population of massive debris disks around F and later-type stars in h and $\chi$ Per.
968: Longer wavelength observations of this h and $\chi$ Per source (e.g. 30-100 $\mu m$) will better constrain its SED and thus
969: its dust population(s). Mid-IR spectroscopy of this source may also provide clues to the chemical composition of its
970: circumstellar dust to compare with models of cometary and asteroidal material.
971: \subsection{Future Observations}
972: Future observations of h and $\chi$ Persei will provide stronger constraints on debris disk evolution and
973: the possibilities for producing the wide range of debris disk emission. A deeper MIPS survey (approved for Spitzer cycle 4)
974: of the double cluster will identify $\gtrsim$ 1000-2000 cluster sources with [24] $\lesssim$ 12.25,
975: the brightness of an 1.3 M$_{\odot}$ G9 (1.7 M$_{\odot}$ A8) star with a 3 (2) magnitude excess.
976: This $\sim$ 2 magnitude increase in sensitivity ($\sim$ 2260 seconds/pixel integration)
977: should yield a larger sample of 24 $\mu m$ excess sources which will better map out the
978: distribution of mid-IR excesses during the primordial-to-debris disk transition.
979: If the correlation of massive, high fractional luminosity-disks with early A stars is purely a selection
980: effect, then this deeper survey of h and $\chi$ Persei should reveal many massive debris disks around
981: slightly later-type stars like 'Source 5'. This survey will be complemented by a deeper IRAC survey (also approved for cycle 4)
982: of the double cluster, which will identify h and $\chi$ Per sources with [5.8] ([8]) $\lesssim$ 15.9 (15.2), the
983: brightess of a $\sim$ 0.8 M$_{\odot}$ M0 (1.0 M$_{\odot}$ K6) photosphere. The $\sim$ 1.5-2 magnitude increase in sensitivity
984: ($\sim$ 120 seconds/pixel integration vs. 20.8 seconds/pixel from the C07a observations) will likely result in photometry for
985: $\gtrsim$ 10,000-15,000 cluster stars through [8], assuming a typical cluster initial mass function (e.g. Miller and Scalo 1979).
986: These two surveys will likely detect hundreds of debris disk (and perhaps transition disk) candidates
987: and yield extremely strong constraints on evolution of dust in circumstellar disks
988: from warm, inner regions (IRAC) to cooler regions (MIPS) at a critical age for planet formation.
989: %Finally, mid-IR spectroscopy of this source and other terrestrial zone debris disks in h and $\chi$ Persei
990: %may reveal insight into the grain properties of terrestrial planet-forming systems at an age where
991: %such formation may be entering its final stages.
992:
993: Ground-based surveys of h and $\chi$ Persei may also provide important clues about the evolution of
994: disks around young stars. For instance, the ability of binary companions to
995: affect the mid-IR excesses from disks can also be tested. At $\sim$ 2.34 kpc, a binary system with separation of
996: $\sim$ 100 AU (and thus able to truncate debris disks) has an angular separation of $\approx$ 0.04". Such systems
997: can be resolved by long-baseline interferometers such as the Keck Interferometer. Comparing the IR excesses from
998: single and binary systems can then determine if weaker IR excess sources are binaries.
999: A large-scale spectroscopic survey of all sources in h \& $\chi$ Per brighter than V $\sim$ 21 ($\gtrsim$ 10,000)
1000: is underway (Currie et al. 2007, in prep.). This survey will identify sources most likely to be h \& $\chi$ Per members
1001: as well as those with strong H$_{\alpha}$ emission indicate of gas accretion. Preliminary work indicates that
1002: the population of accreting h and $\chi$ Per sources is non negligible ($\gtrsim$ 20-30; \citealt{Cu07c}). Comparing the IR excesses
1003: of accreting sources with those that are not accreting may examine the role of residual circumstellar gas in
1004: affecting the mid-IR excesses from disks.
1005: \acknowledgements
1006: We thank the referee for a thorough review and suggestions which improved this manuscript.
1007: We also thank Michael Meyer, John Carpenter, Christine Chen, and Nadya Gorlova for useful discussions regarding debris disks
1008: in other clusters; Matt Ashby, Rob Gutermuth, and Anil Seth provided
1009: valuable advice regarding galaxy contamination. We acknowledge from the
1010: NASA Astrophysics Theory Program grant NAG5-13278, TPF Grant NNG06GH25G, and the Spitzer GO program (Proposal 20132).
1011: T.C. is supported by a SAO predoctoral fellowship; Z.B. received support from Hungarian OTKA Grants
1012: TS049872 and T049082. This work was partially supported by contract 1255094, issued by JPL/Caltech to the University
1013: of Arizona.
1014: \begin{thebibliography}{}
1015: \bibitem[Andrews and Williams(2005)]{Aw05} Andrews, S., Williams, J., 2005, \apj, 631, 1134
1016: \bibitem[Augereau et al.(1999)]{Au99} Augereau, J. C., et al., 1999, A\&A, 348, 557
1017: %\bibitem[Au (1984)]{Au84} Aumann, H., et al., 1984, ApJL, 278, 23
1018: %\bibitem[Al (2001)]{Al01} Allen, C. W., 2001, Allen's Astrophysical Quantities, Fourth Ed., Arthur N. Cox (ed.), Springer-Verlag
1019: %\bibitem[Be (1988)]{Be88} Bessell, M., Brett, J., 1988, PASP, 100, 1134
1020: \bibitem[Bai et al.(2007)]{Ba07} Bai, L., et al., 2007, \apj, in press, arXiv:0704.0953
1021: \bibitem[Barden et al.(1993)]{Ba93} Barden, S., et al., 1993, \pasp, 37, Fiber Optics in Astronomy II,
1022: ed. P. M. Gray (San Francisco: ASP), 185
1023: \bibitem[Ba (1999)]{Ba99} Barrado y Navascues, D., et al., 1999, \apjl, 520, 123
1024: \bibitem[Be (1985)]{Be85} Berriman, G., et al., 1985, MNRAS, 217, 327
1025: %\bibitem[Be (2007)]{Be07} Besla, G., Wu, Y., 2007, \apj, 655, 528
1026: \bibitem[BK (2002)]{BK02} Bragg, A., \& Kenyon, S., 2002, \aj, 124, 3289
1027: \bibitem[BK (2005)]{BK05} Bragg, A. \& Kenyon, S., 2005, ApJ, 130, 134
1028: \bibitem[Ch (2001)]{Ch01} Chambers, J., 2001, Icarus, 152, 205
1029: %\bibitem[Co (2003)]{Co03} Cohen, M., et al., 2003, AJ, 126, 1090
1030: \bibitem[Chen and Kamp(2004)]{Ck04} Chen, C., Kamp, I., 2004, \apj, 602, 985
1031: \bibitem[Chen et al.(2005b)]{Ch05b} Chen, C., et al., 2005, \apj, 623, 493
1032: \bibitem[Chen et al.(2005a)]{Ch05a} Chen, C., et al., 2005, \apj, 634, 1372
1033: \bibitem[Currie et al.(2003)]{Cu03} Currie, T., et al., 2003, in ASP Conf. Ser. 294, Scientific Frontiers in Research on Extrasolar Planets,
1034: ed. D. Deming \& S. Seager (San Francisco: ASP), 265
1035: %\bibitem[Currie et al.(2007a)]{Cu07a} Currie, T., et al., 2007(a), \apj, 659, 599
1036: %\bibitem[Currie et al.(2007b)]{Cu07b} Currie, T., et al., 2007(b), \apj, 663, 105L
1037: \bibitem[Currie et al.(2007a)]{Cu07a} Currie, T., et al., 2007(a),\apj, 659, 599
1038: \bibitem[Currie et al.(2007b)]{Cu07b} Currie, T., et al., 2007(b), \apj, 663, 105L
1039: \bibitem[Currie et al. (2007c)]{Cu07c} Currie, T., et al., 2007(c), ApJL accepted, arXiv:0709.1847
1040: \bibitem[Da (1988)]{Da88} Dachs, J., Kiehling, R., Engels, D., 1988, A\&A, 194, 167
1041: \bibitem[Da (2007)]{Da07} Dahm, S., Hillenbrand, L., 2007, \aj, 133, 2072
1042: \bibitem[De (2003)]{De03} Decin, L., et al., 2003, A\&A, 598, 636
1043: \bibitem[Dd (2003)]{Dd03} Dominik, C., Decin, G., 2003, \apj, 598, 626
1044: \bibitem[Do (2005)]{Do05} Dominik, C., Dullemond, C., 2005, A\&A, 434, 971
1045: \bibitem[Do (2007)]{Do07} Dominik, C., et al., 2007, in "Protostars and Planets V", ed.
1046: B. Reipurth, D. Jewitt, \& K. Keil, (University of Arizona: Tucson, AZ), pp 783--800
1047: \bibitem[Do (1991)]{Do91} Dougherty, S., et al., 1991, \aj, 102, 1753
1048: \bibitem[Do (1994)]{Do94} Dougherty, S., et al., 1994, A\&A, 290, 609
1049: \bibitem[Ei (2006)]{Ei06} Eisner, J., et al., 2006, \apj, 637, 133
1050: \bibitem[Fa (1998)]{fab98} Fabricant, D., et al., 1998, \pasp, 110, 79
1051: \bibitem[Fa (2005)]{Fa05} Fabricant, D., et al., 2005, \pasp, 117, 1411
1052: %\bibitem[FC (2007)]{Fc07} Ford, E., Chiang, E., 2007, \apj, 661, 602
1053: %\bibitem[Go (2004)]{Go04} Goldreich, P., et al., 2004, ARA\&A, 42, 549
1054: \bibitem[Go (2005)]{Go05} Gordon, K. D., et al., 2005, \pasp, 117, 503
1055: \bibitem[Gr (2006)]{Gr06} Gorlova, N., et al., 2006, \apj, 649, 1028
1056: \bibitem[Gorlova et al.(2007)]{Gr07} Gorlova, N., et al., 2007, \apj, submitted
1057: %\bibitem[Ha (2005)]{Ha05} Hartmann, L., et al., 2005, ApJ, 629, 881
1058: \bibitem[Habing et al. (2001)]{hab01} Habing, H. J., et al. 2001, A\&A, 365, 545
1059: \bibitem[Ha (2001)]{Ha01} Haisch, K., Lada, E., \& Lada, C., 2001, ApJL, 553, 153
1060: \bibitem[Ha (1981)]{Ha81} Hayashi, C.,1981, Prog. Theor. Phys. Suppl., 70, 35
1061: \bibitem[He (2006)]{He06} Hernandez, J., et al., 2006, ApJ, 652, 472
1062: %\bibitem[Hi (2005)]{Hi05} Hillenbrand, L., et al., 2005, astro-ph/0511083
1063: \bibitem[Hi (2006)]{Hi06} Hines, D., et al., 2006, \apj, 638, 1070
1064: %\bibitem[Jo (2007)]{Jo07} Johnson, J., et al., 2007, astro-ph/0704.2455
1065: \bibitem[Kalas (1998)]{kal98} Kalas, P. 1998, Earth, Moon, \& Planets, 81, 27
1066: \bibitem[Ke (2001)]{Ke01} Keller, S.C., et al., 2001, AJ, 122, 248
1067: \bibitem[Ke (1999)]{Ke99} Kenyon, S, et al., 1999, ApJL, 526, 465
1068: \bibitem[KB (2002)]{Kb02} Kenyon, S., Bromley, B., 2002, ApJL, 577, 35
1069: \bibitem[Kenyon and Bromley(2004a)]{KB04a} Kenyon, S., Bromley, B., 2004a, ApJL, 602, 133
1070: \bibitem[Kenyon and Bromley(2004b)]{KB04b} Kenyon, S., Bromley, B., 2004b, \aj, 127, 513
1071: %\bibitem[KB (2005)]{Kb05} Kenyon, S., Bromley, B., 2005, AJ, 130, 269
1072: \bibitem[KB (2006)]{Kb06} Kenyon, S., Bromley, B., 2006, AJ, 131, 1837
1073: \bibitem[KH (1987)]{Kh87} Kenyon, S., Hartmann, L., 1987, ApJ, 323, 714
1074: \bibitem[KH (1995)]{Kh95} Kenyon, S., Hartmann, L., 1995, ApJS, 101, 117
1075: \bibitem[Kl (2005)]{Kl05} Klahr, H., Lin, D. N. C., 2005, \apj, 632, 1113
1076: \bibitem[La (2006)]{La06} Lada, C., et al., 2006, \aj, 131, 1574
1077: \bibitem[Low et al. (2005)]{Lo05} Low, F., et al., 2005, \apj, 631, 1170
1078: \bibitem[In (2005)]{In05} Indebetouw, R., et al., 2005, ApJ, 619, 931
1079: \bibitem[Ma (2005)]{Ma05} Mathis, J., 1990, ARA\&A, 28, 37
1080: \bibitem[Me (2007)]{Me07} Meyer, M., et al., 2006, in Protostars and Planets V, ed. B. Reipurth and D. Jewitt,
1081: (Tucson: University of Arizona Press)
1082: \bibitem[Ma (1997)]{Ma97} Mauche, C., et al., 1997, \apj, 477, 832
1083: \bibitem[Mc (2005)]{Mc05} McSwain, M., Gies, D., 2005, \apjs, 161, 118
1084: \bibitem[MS (1979)]{Ms79} Miller, G., \& Scalo, J., 1979, \apjs, 41, 513
1085: \bibitem[Na (2004)]{Na04} Natta, A., et al., 2004, in ASP Conf. Ser. 324,
1086: Debris Disks and the Formation of Planets: A Symposium in Memory of Fred Gillett, ed. L. Caroff, et al.,
1087: (San Francisco: ASP), p.20
1088: %\bibitem[Mi (2007)]{Mi07} Meyer, M., et al., 2006, astro-ph/0606399
1089: %\bibitem[Oc (1973)]{Oc73} O'Connell, R., 1973, \aj, 78, 1074
1090: %\bibitem[La (2006)]{La06} Lada, C.J., et al., 2006, AJ, 131, 1574
1091: \bibitem[Or (2002)]{Or02} Ortega, V. G., et al., 2002, \apjl, 575, 75
1092: \bibitem[Pa (2004)]{Pa04} Papovich, C., et al., 2004, ApJS, 154, 70
1093: %\bibitem[Pa (2006)]{Pa06} Pascucci, I., et al., 2006, ApJ, 651, 1177
1094: %\bibitem[Ri (2002)]{Ri02} Richter, M., et al., 2002, ApJL, 572, 161
1095: \bibitem[Ri (2005)]{R05} Rieke, G., et al., 2005, ApJ, 620, 1010
1096: \bibitem[Si (2000)]{Si00} Siess, L., et al., 2000, A\&A, 358, 593
1097: \bibitem[Si (2005)]{Si05}Sicilia-Aguilar, A., et al., 2005, \aj, 130, 188
1098: \bibitem[Si (2006)]{Si06}Sicilia-Aguilar, A., et al., 2006, \apj, 638, 897
1099: %\bibitem[Si (2007)]{Si07} Sicilia-Aguilar, A., et al., 2007, astro-ph/0701321
1100: %\bibitem[Si (2006)]{Si06} Silverstone, M., et al., 2006, 639, 1138
1101: \bibitem[Sl (2002)]{Sl02} Slesnick, C., et al., 2002, \apj, 576, 880
1102: \bibitem[Su (2006)]{Su06} Su, K., et al., 2006, \apj, 653, 675
1103: \bibitem[Ta (2001)]{Ta01} Takuechi, T., Artymowicz, P., 2001, \apj, 557, 990
1104: \bibitem[Tr (2007)]{Tr07} Trilling, D., et al., 2007, \apj, 658, 1289
1105: %\bibitem[Zo (1997)]{Zo97} Zorec, J., Briot, D., 1997, A\&A, 318, 443
1106: \bibitem[Wahhaj et al.(2005)]{Wa05} Wahhaj, Z., et al., 2006, \apj, 618, 385
1107: \bibitem[Wahhaj, Koerner and Sargent (2007)]{Wa07} Wahhaj, Z., Koerner, D. W., \& Sargent, A. I., 2007, \apj, 661, 368
1108: \bibitem[Weidenschilling (1997)]{We97} Weidenschilling, S. J., 1997, Icarus, 127, 290
1109: \bibitem[Wetherill and Stewart(1993)]{WS93} Wetherill, G., Stewart, G., 1993, Icarus, 106, 190
1110: \bibitem[White and Basri(2003)]{Wb03} White, R., Basri, G., 2003, \apj, 582, 1109
1111: \bibitem[Woolf, Stein, and Strittmatter (1970)]{Wo70} Woolf, N. J., Stein, W. A., Strittmatter, P. A., 1970, A\&A, 9, 252
1112: \bibitem[Wyatt et al. (2007a)]{Wy07a} Wyatt, M., et al., 2007,\apj\ accepted, astro-ph/0703608
1113: \bibitem[Wyatt et al.(2007b)]{Wy07b} Wyatt, M., et al., 2007, \apj, 658, 569
1114: %\bibitem[Zu (1995)]{Zu05} Zuckerman, B., et al., 1995, Nature, 373, 494
1115: \bibitem[Zu (2001)]{Zu01} Zuckerman, B., et al., 2001, \apjl, 562, 87
1116: %\bibitem[Wi (2007)]{Wi07} Winston, E., et al., 2007,in prep.
1117: %\bibitem[Yin (2002)]{Yi02} Yin, Q., et al., 2002, Nature, 418, 949
1118: \end{thebibliography}
1119:
1120: \clearpage
1121: \input{tab1.tex}
1122: \input{tab2.tex}
1123: \input{tab3.tex}
1124: \input{tab4.tex}
1125: \input{tab5.tex}
1126: %\input{Upp_Sco.tex}
1127: \clearpage
1128: \begin{figure}
1129: \epsscale{1.}
1130: \plottwo{f1a.eps}{f1b.eps}
1131: %\plotone{mips_j.ps}
1132: \caption{(left) Distribution of [24] magnitudes
1133: for sources detected at the 5$\sigma$ level with MIPS that have 2MASS/IRAC detections.
1134: The number counts peak at [24] $\sim$ 10.5. (right) The completeness profile as a function
1135: of 2MASS J magnitude. Through J=10.5, $\gtrsim$ 90\% of all the 2MASS sources are detected
1136: with MIPS. Only about half of the 2MASS sources between J=10.5-11 are detected with MIPS.}
1137: \end{figure}
1138: \begin{figure}
1139: \plotone{f2.eps}
1140: \caption{The number density distribution of MIPS-detected sources as a function of distance from h Persei (diamonds; dashed line) and
1141: $\chi$ Persei (triangles; solid line). The error bars are based on Poisson statistics. The number counts decline through $\sim$ 20' away from
1142: both cluster centers, though because of the small area coverage it is unclear exactly where the
1143: true background lies. For reference, we show the number density of 2MASS sources (J $\le$ 15.5) as a function of distance away from
1144: h Persei (diamonds; dotted line) and $\chi$ Persei (triangles; dot-dashed line) divided by 5. The peak number density of MIPS sources is about an order of magnitude smaller than for
1145: 2MASS J band as found by C07a.}
1146: \label{dens}
1147: \end{figure}
1148:
1149: \begin{figure}
1150: %\plotone{dist.ps}
1151: \plotone{f3.eps}
1152: \caption{Distribution of $K_{s}$-[24] colors for the 2MASS/MIPS detections. The distribution
1153: is peaked at $K_{s}$-[24] $\sim$ 0-0.5 and has a long positive tail stretching to $K_{s}$-[24] $\sim$ 6.}
1154: \label{k24dist}
1155: \end{figure}
1156:
1157: \begin{figure}
1158: \plotone{f4.eps}
1159: \caption{Distribution of K$_{s}$ magnitudes with strong IR excess in the MIPS bands (K$_{s}$-[24]$\ge$2).
1160: There appear to be two populations of strong MIPS excess sources: a bright distribution from
1161: K$_{s}$=9-11 and a faint distribution from K$_{s}$=13.5-15.}
1162: \label{kexc}
1163: \end{figure}
1164:
1165:
1166: \begin{figure}
1167: \plotone{f5.eps}
1168: \caption{Distribution of photospheric (small squares), marginal [24] excess (small asterisks for
1169: sources brighter than J=13), and
1170: strong [24] excess (large asterisks for J$\le$13; diamonds for J$\ge 13$) sources. 'Marginal'
1171: and 'strong' excesses are defined as sources
1172: with $K_{s}$-[24]=0.65-2 and $K_{s}$-[24]$\ge$2, respectively. The 14 Myr Siess et al. (2000) isochrone
1173: (solid line), reddened to A$_{V}$ = 1.62 (reddening vector shown as arrow), is plotted with a 0.3 magnitude lower bound (dot-dashed line) for photometric errors and a 0.75 magnitude upper bound (dashed line) for binarity. There are two
1174: sources at J $\sim$ 14.66, J-H $\sim$ 0.36 that are not distinguishable on this plot.}
1175: \label{jjh}
1176: \end{figure}
1177: \begin{figure}
1178: \plotone{f6.eps}
1179: \caption{Distribution of 24 $\mu m$ excess sources in observed J-H/H-K$_{s}$ color-color space. The symbols are the same as in
1180: the previous figure. The reddening band is overplotted as two straight dash-dotted lines.
1181: Only the faint sources lying along the 14 Myr isochrone are
1182: included. The bright sources with K$_{s}$ $\ge$ 2 follow a clear Be star locus (dotted line) from zero color
1183: to J-H=0.2, H-$K_{s}$=0.3; bright sources with weaker excess (K$_{s}$-[24] $\sim$ 0.65-2) appear either
1184: along the Be star locus or close to the giant locus (curved dashed line).
1185: The faint excess sources appear to be evenly distributed across the photospheric track (solid line).
1186: The IR-excess population is probably comprised of two
1187: main groups: bright Be stars with optically-thin free-free emission and fainter
1188: (J $\le$ 13.5) pre-main sequence A-F stars that likely harbor protoplanetary disks.}
1189: \end{figure}
1190: \begin{figure}
1191: \plottwo{f7a.eps}{f7b.eps}
1192: \caption{Sample spectra of bright (J $\le$ 13) 24 $\mu m$ excess sources in the MIPS field. The source on the left
1193: was identified as a Be star from Bragg \& Kenyon (2002) and has IR-excess emission from a circumstellar envelope.
1194: The source on the right has a spectral type of B4 and appears to be consistent with cluster membership.}
1195: \end{figure}
1196: \clearpage
1197: \thispagestyle{empty}
1198: \setlength{\voffset}{-18mm}
1199: \begin{figure}
1200: \plottwo{f8a.eps}{f8b.eps}
1201: \plottwo{f8c.eps}{f8d.eps}
1202: \plottwo{f8e.eps}{f8f.eps}
1203: \plottwo{f8g.eps}{f8h.eps}
1204: \caption{Spectra for 8 faint (J $\ge$ 13) stars with 24 $\mu m$ excess observed with
1205: Hydra (top two) and Hectospec (bottom six). The coordinates and spectral types for each
1206: source are listed on the top of each plot.
1207: The A6 star observed with Hydra has some image artifacts (spikes in count level well above the continuum level) at
1208: $\sim$ 0.44 and 0.56 \AA\ due to bad sky subtraction, though this did not impact the spectral type determination as
1209: we use other spectral indices that were not contaminated.
1210: The F5 star lies about one magnitude fainter than the 14 Myr isochrone
1211: for h and $\chi$ Persei (J$\sim$ 15.9) and is thus both photometrically and spectroscopically
1212: inconsistent with cluster membership. The other stars are both photometrically and spectroscopically consistent
1213: with being $\sim$ 13-14 Myr old at a distance of 2.34 kpc.
1214: Thus, 7 of the 17 faint MIPS-excess sources
1215: lying on the J/J-H isochrone for h and $\chi$ Per are spectroscopically confirmed members.}
1216: \end{figure}
1217: \clearpage
1218: \setlength{\voffset}{0mm}
1219:
1220: \begin{figure}
1221: \plotone{f9.eps}
1222: \caption{K$_{s}$ vs. K$_{s}$-[4.5], K$_{s}$-[5.8], K$_{s}$-[8], and K$_{s}$-[24]
1223: color-magnitude diagrams for bright, photospheric sources and 24 $\mu m$ excess sources.
1224: Of the 24 $\mu m$ excess sources, 1/14 have excess at [4.5], 3/12 have excess at [5.8], and
1225: 5/11 have excess at [8].}
1226: \label{cmdirac}
1227: \end{figure}
1228: \begin{figure}
1229: \plotone{f10.eps}
1230: \caption{Flux ratio diagram for sources with 5$\sigma$ detections at 4.5 through 24 $\mu m$ with
1231: errors in the flux ratios overplotted.
1232: The flux ratios for single temperature blackbodies are shown as a solid line. Dotted lines show
1233: loci of dust temperatures assuming a stellar blackbody temperature of 7250 K. Sources
1234: with 8 $\mu m$ excess are shown in bold. The five sources
1235: with 8 $\mu m$ excess typically have warmer dust temperatures (T $\sim$ 200-300 K)
1236: indicative of terrestrial zone emission. The sources without 8 $\mu m$ excess have
1237: colder dust temperatures.
1238: Two sources probably have some dust at temperatures comparable
1239: to the water ice sublimation point (170 K). Two sources probably have dust grains
1240: that are colder and icy ($\sim$ 100-150 K). Typical errors for sources with only MIPS excess
1241: are $\sim$ 50 K, while errors for sources with IRAC and MIPS excess were smaller ($\sim$ 20 K).}
1242: \label{fr}
1243: \end{figure}
1244:
1245: \clearpage
1246: \thispagestyle{empty}
1247: \setlength{\voffset}{-18mm}
1248: \begin{figure}
1249: \epsscale{0.85}
1250: \plotone{f11a.eps}
1251: \plotone{f11b.eps}
1252: \caption{The (top)$K_{s}$-[3.6]/$K_{s}$-[24] and (bottom) $K_{s}$-[8]/$K_{s}$-[24] color-color
1253: diagrams. Sources below the horizontal line have photospheric [4.5] emission; those to the left of the
1254: vertical line have photospheric [24] emission. The source with $K_{s}$-[8]$\sim$1.3 and $K_{s}$-[24]$\sim$4.5
1255: is source 5 in C07b and is labeled 'S5'. One source appears to
1256: have mid-IR colors strongly resembling TW Hya (shown as a large cross; reddened to h and $\chi$ Per). All sources have
1257: colors inconsistent with an optically-thick primordial disk (large triangle). The debris disk
1258: locus is overplotted as a dark solid line with reddened K$_{s}$-[24] colors at 1 Myr ($\sim$ 0.9) and 10 Myr ($\sim$ 3.2) labeled.
1259: Debris from planet formation at 30-150 AU accurately reproduces the $K_{s}$-[4.5]/$K_{s}$-[24] diagram colors and
1260: is able to reproduce the $K_{s}$-[8] colors for sources with weaker [8] excess.}
1261: %Overall, $\lesssim$ 50 of the [24] excess sources have IR excess at [8] and
1262: %only one has IR excess at [4.5].
1263: \label{colcol}
1264: \end{figure}
1265: \clearpage
1266: \setlength{\voffset}{0mm}
1267:
1268: \begin{figure}
1269: \plotone{f12.eps}
1270: \caption{Spectral energy distributions for selected MIPS-excess sources.
1271: The J2000 coordinates of the sources (in degrees) are 35.3215, 57.2030 (1); 34.7824, 57.2347 (2);
1272: 34.6889, 57.2731 (3); and 35.3783, 57.2056 (4). The spectral types of the
1273: sources are (clockwise from the top) F9, F9, A6, and A2. The photospheric model (dash-dot) and
1274: cold debris disk model (dash-three dots) from Kenyon \& Bromley (2004) are overplotted.
1275: The top-right F9 source was modeled as having terrestrial zone emission, though
1276: the disk may extend to more distant, cooler regions.
1277: Two sources (top-left F9 and A6) exhibit weak 8$\mu m$ emission, whereas the A2 source, typical
1278: of the majority of faint MIPS-excess sources, has no excess emission at 8$\mu m$.}
1279: \label{sed4}
1280: \end{figure}
1281:
1282: \begin{figure}
1283: \epsscale{0.75}
1284: \plotone{f13.eps}
1285: \caption{(top) Color-excess of sources from the R05 sample assuming that the photospheric $K_{s}$-[24] color
1286: is $\sim$ 0. The strongest excess sources in this sample are HR 4796A (8 Myr) and $\beta$ Pictoris (12 Myr).
1287: There is a clear trend of decreasing color excess vs. age beyond $\sim$ 20 Myr.}
1288: \label{excvagegr}
1289: \end{figure}
1290: \clearpage
1291: \begin{figure}
1292: \plotone{f14.eps}
1293: \caption{Color-excess of sources from R05 as well as $\sim$ 13 Myr-old h and $\chi$ Persei (diamonds);
1294: Sco-Cen subgroups at 5, 16, and 17 Myr old (asterisks; Chen et al. 2005b); 4 and
1295: 11.8 Myr-old Cepheus subgroups Tr 37 and NGC 7160 (squares; Sicilia-Aguilar et al. 2006); and 5 and 10 Myr-old
1296: Orion Ob1b and Ob1a (Hernandez et al. 2006). We include the B4 star in h and $\chi$ Per with
1297: MIPS excess. HR 4796A is again clearly visible while $\beta$ Pic is obscured by the Cepheus data.
1298: Upper Sco data (5 Myr old) is also obscured by Orion Ob1b and has 24$\mu m$ excess $\sim$ 0-0.3.
1299: Overplotted are debris disk evolution tracks from
1300: Kenyon \& Bromley (2004) for a 3$\times$ and 1/3$\times$ (scaled) MMSN disk assuming that primordial disk
1301: grains grow to planetesimal sizes by 0 (dotted line) and 2 Myr (solid line). There is a clear trend of increasing
1302: color excess at 24 $\mu m$ from $\sim$ 5-10 Myr, a peak at $\sim$ 10-15 Myr, and a steady decline
1303: afterwards through 1 Gyr. The trend is clear even if the strongest excess sources in
1304: h and $\chi$ Per and Sco-Cen ([24]$_{obs}$ -[24]$_{\star}$ $\gtrsim$ 4-5) were excluded due to their uncertain evolutionary states.}
1305: \label{excvage}
1306: \end{figure}
1307:
1308: \begin{figure}
1309: \plotone{f15.eps}
1310: \caption{[24]-[24]$_{\star}$ excesses for Orion Ob1b (solid line) compared to the 'scaled' 5 Myr Sco-Cen (dotted line)
1311: and Rieke et al. colors (dashed line), assuming that
1312: excess emission declines as t$^{-1}$ for t$\gtrsim$ 5 Myr. We normalize the total number of sources in each bin by the total
1313: number of sources in all bins. The excesses from many Sco-Cen and Rieke et al. sources are
1314: far redder than any Orion sources ($\gtrsim$ 4 magnitudes). Thus, the evolution of 24 $\mu m$ emission from disks is not consistent
1315: with a t$^{-1}$ power law. Further statistical tests, described in \S 4.2, verify that the emission rises from 5 to 10 Myr.}
1316: \label{scaled}
1317: \end{figure}
1318: %\begin{figure}
1319: %debris disk SED, see it works!
1320: %\end{figure}
1321: \end{document}
1322: