1: \documentclass[usegraphicx,useAMS]{mn2e}
2: \usepackage{graphics}
3: \usepackage{times}
4:
5:
6: \title[Radio observations of NGC 4254]
7: {Low radio frequency signatures of ram pressure stripping in Virgo spiral NGC 4254 \\}
8: \author[N. G. Kantharia et al.]{N. G. Kantharia$^1$, A. Pramesh Rao$^2$, S. K. Sirothia$^3$ \\
9: National Centre for Radio Astrophysics, Tata Institute of Fundamental
10: Research, \\ Post Bag 3, Ganeshkhind, Pune-411007, India \\
11: $^1$ ngk@ncra.tifr.res.in \\
12: $^2$ pramesh@ncra.tifr.res.in \\
13: $^3$ sirothia@ncra.tifr.res.in \\
14: }
15:
16:
17: \begin{document}
18:
19: %\date{Received May 8 2007/Accepted September 27 2007}
20: \date{Accepted 2007 September 27. Received 2007 September 26; in original form 2007 May 8}
21:
22: \maketitle
23:
24: \begin{abstract}
25: We report the detection of extended low radio frequency continuum emission
26: beyond the optical disk of the spiral galaxy NGC 4254
27: using the Giant Metrewave Radio Telescope.
28: NGC 4254, which has an almost face-on orientation, is located in the outskirts of the Virgo cluster.
29: Since such extended emission is uncommon in low inclination galaxies,
30: we believe it is a signature of magnetised plasma pushed out of the
31: disk by ram pressure of the intracluster medium as NGC 4254 falls into
32: the Virgo cluster. The detailed spectral index distribution across
33: NGC 4254 shows that the steepest spectrum
34: $\alpha < -1$ ($S \propto \nu^{\alpha}$) arises in the gas beyond the
35: optical disk. This lends support to the ram pressure scenario
36: by indicating that the extended emission is not from the disk gas
37: but from matter which has been stripped by ram pressure. The steeper spectrum of
38: the extended emission is reminiscent of haloes in edge-on galaxies. The sharp fall in intensity
39: and enhanced polarization in the south of the galaxy, in addition to enhanced star formation
40: reported by others provide evidence towards the efficacy of ram pressure on this galaxy.
41: HI 21cm observations show that the gas in the north lags in rotation and hence
42: is likely the atomic gas which is carried along with the wind.
43: NGC 4254 is a particularly strong radio emitter with a power of
44: $7\times10^{22}$ Watts-Hz$^{-1}$ at 240 MHz. We find that the integrated spectrum of the galaxy
45: flattens at lower frequencies
46: and is well explained by an injection spectrum with $\alpha_0=-0.45\pm0.12$.
47: We end by comparing published simulation results with our data and
48: conclude that ram pressure stripping is likely to be a significant contributor to
49: evolution of galaxies residing in X-ray poor groups and cluster outskirts.
50: \end{abstract}
51:
52: \section{Introduction}
53: Galaxy mergers (Toomre \nocite{toomre} 1977), galaxy harassment (Moore et al. \nocite{moore} 1996),
54: ram pressure (Gunn \& Gott \nocite{gunn} 1972), viscous stripping (Nulsen 1982 \nocite{nulsen})
55: and dynamical friction (Lecar \nocite{lecar} 1975, Chandrasekhar \nocite{chandrasekhar} 1943)
56: are believed to play a role in the evolution of galaxies
57: in a cluster enviroment and have explained numerous observational results. Different physical
58: mechanisms dominate in different environments. While ram pressure effects are
59: believed to be dominant in the dense inner regions of clusters, tidal interactions
60: are believed to dominate the evolution in the cluster outskirts and in groups of galaxies.
61: However, this picture has been undergoing a gradual paradigm shift as demonstrated
62: by observations, especially at radio frequencies, and simulations
63: of groups and outskirts of clusters (e.g. Virgo) conducted by
64: various authors.
65:
66: The Virgo cluster galaxies have
67: been extensively studied in radio and other wavebands e.g. in HI 21cm
68: by Davies, et al. \nocite{davies} (2004), Cayatte et al. \nocite{cayatte} (1990),
69: Warmels \nocite{warmels} (1988), Huchtmeier \& Richter \nocite{hucht} (1986) and in
70: radio continuum by Vollmer et al. \nocite{vollmer2} (2004). Chung et al. \nocite{chung} (2007)
71: have recently reported HI tails for several Virgo galaxies which they conclude is ram pressure
72: stripped gas from the galaxy. Vollmer et al. \nocite{vollmer3} (2007)
73: have studied the polarisation properties of several Virgo spirals and
74: inferred that the interaction of the galaxy with the intracluster medium (ICM)
75: has resulted in peculiar polarisation properties of the cluster spirals.
76: Wezgoweic et al. \nocite{wezgoweic} (2007)
77: find distorted magnetic fields in several Virgo cluster members which
78: they attribute to ram pressure of the ICM.
79:
80: NGC 4254 is an interesting almost face-on SA(s)c spiral, located in the outskirts of the Virgo cluster,
81: with one dominant spiral arm. This galaxy
82: has been studied extensively in the HI line (Cayatte et al. \nocite{cayatte}
83: 1990, \nocite{cayatte1} 1994, Phookun et al. \nocite{phookun} 1993),
84: in high frequency radio continuum and polarization (Urbanik et al.
85: \nocite{urbanik} 1986, Soida et al. \nocite{soida} 1996, Urbanik \nocite{urbanik1} 2004
86: Chyzy et al. \nocite{chyzy} 2006),
87: in X-rays (Chyzy et al. 2006 \nocite{chyzy}, Soria \& Wong 2006 \nocite{soria})
88: and via simulations involving tidal interaction and ram pressure
89: stripping (Vollmer et al 2005 \nocite{vollmer}).
90: NGC 4254 is both optically and radio bright and lies about $4^{\circ}$ ($\sim 1.2$ Mpc
91: using a distance of 17 Mpc to Virgo cluster) to the north-west of M87.
92: Phookun et al. \nocite{phookun}(1993), from their deep HI observations, separate
93: the disk and non-disk emission from the galaxy and find that the latter forms a tail of clouds that
94: extend to $\sim 11'$ from the galaxy.
95: They conclude that there is an infall of a disintegrating cloud of gas onto NGC 4254
96: and that the one-armed structure is a result of the tidal
97: interaction with the infalling gas.
98: Vollmer et al \nocite{vollmer}(2005) have modelled NGC 4254 after
99: including a tidal encounter and ram pressure stripping. They find that the one-armed
100: structure can be explained by a rapid and close encounter $\sim 2.8\times10^8$ years ago
101: with another massive galaxy ($\sim 10^{11} M_\odot$). They note that most of the observed
102: HI morphology is reproduced by including ongoing ram pressure effects in the
103: simulation and only two main HI features remain unexplained namely
104: 1) the shape of the extended tail of HI emission in the north-west,
105: 2) a low surface density HI blob observed to the south of the main disk.
106: Davies et al. \nocite{davies} (2004) and Minchin et al. \nocite{minchin} (2005) have
107: reported the detection of a massive ($\sim 10^{11} M_{\odot}$)
108: HI cloud VIRGOHI 21 in the Virgo cluster. This cloud lies to the north of NGC 4254 and
109: connects both spatially and kinematically to NGC 4254
110: (Minchin et al. \nocite{minchin1} (2005). Recently Haynes et al.
111: \nocite{haynes} (2007) have presented the HI map of this entire region made using the Arecibo
112: telescope. They detect a long HI tail which starts from NGC 4254, includes
113: VirgoHI 21 and extends northwards to a total distance of 250 kpc.
114: Earlier observations had only detected parts of this long HI tail.
115: Haynes et al. \nocite{haynes} (2007) attribute this long HI tail
116: to galaxy harrassment (Moore et al. \nocite{moore} 1996) which the galaxy is undergoing as
117: it enters the Virgo cluster.
118:
119: Soida et al. \nocite{soida} (1996), from their
120: radio continuum observations near 5 and 10 GHz, have reported enhanced polarisation
121: in the southern ridge which they attribute to interaction of the disk gas with the ICM.
122: Chyzy et al. \nocite{chyzy} \nocite{chyzy1} (2006,2007) detect an extended polarized envelope at 1.4 GHz.
123: Excess blue emission is observed along the southern ridge (Knapen et al. \nocite{knapen} 2004)
124: which indicates the presence of a large population of young blue stars (Wray \nocite{wray} 1988).
125: The trigger for the enhanced star formation in this region
126: is possibly compression by the ram pressure of the ICM.
127: From high resolution CO data, Sofue et al. \nocite{sofue} (2003) note that the
128: inner spiral arms of NGC 4254 are asymmetric. They reason that the ram pressure of the ICM
129: has distorted the inter-arm low density regions leading to the
130: asymmetric spiral arms.
131: This galaxy has also been observed in the near and far ultraviolet by
132: GALEX (Gil de Paz et al. \nocite{gil} 2007). The UV
133: morphology of the galaxy is similar to the DSS optical with several young
134: star forming regions visible in the GALEX images.
135:
136: In light of all these interesting results, we present new low
137: frequency radio continuum and HI 21cm observations of NGC 4254 using the Giant Metrewave
138: Radio Telescope (GMRT) near Pune in India. The continuum observations were conducted
139: at four frequencies between 240 and 1280 MHz. We detected extended
140: continuum emission surrounding the optical disk of NGC 4254.
141: We discuss the integrated spectrum of the galaxy and
142: the environmental effects on this galaxy located at the periphery of the cluster.
143: We adopt a distance of 17 Mpc to the Virgo Cluster following Vollmer et al.
144: \nocite{vollmer} (2005). In Table \ref{tab1}, we summarize the physical properties
145: of NGC 4254 and the empirical data from wavebands ranging from
146: X-rays to radio.
147:
148: \begin{table}
149: \caption{Properties of NGC 4254}
150: \begin{tabular}{lcc}
151: \hline\hline
152: {\bf Parameter} & {\bf Value/Property} & {\bf Reference} \\
153: $\alpha(2000)$ & $\rm 12^h 18^m49.6^s$ & RC3 \\
154: $\delta(2000)$ & $14^\circ24'59''$ & RC3 \\
155: Morphological type & Sc & RC3 \\
156: Optical diameter D$_{25}$ & $5.4'$ & RC3 \\
157: B$^0_T$ & 10.44 & RC3 \\
158: Heliocentric velocity & $2407\pm3$ kms$^{-1}$ & RC3 \\
159: Distance & $ 17$ Mpc & Vollmer et al. (2005) \\
160: Distance to cluster centre & $\sim 1.2$ Mpc & \\
161: \hline
162: \multicolumn{3}{l}{\bf From HI} \\
163: Morphology & distorted & Cayatte et al. (1990) \\
164: V (rotation) & 150 kms$^{-1}$ & Phookun et al. (1993) \\
165: Inclination angle & $42^{\circ}$ & Phookun et al. (1993) \\
166: Non-disk emission & $2.3\times10^8 M_\odot$ & Phookun et al. (1993) \\
167: HI deficiency & $0.17\pm0.2$ & Cayatte et al. (1994) \\
168: ICM ram pressure &$0.9\times10^{-12}$ dyn-cm$^{-2}$ & Cayatte et al. (1994)\\
169: Grav pull & $1.6\times10^{-12}$ dyn-cm$^{-2}$ & Cayatte et al. (1994)\\
170: %Tidal debris & $11'$ away & Phookun et al. (1993) \\
171: Galaxy Harrassment & 250 kpc tail & Haynes et al. (2007) \\
172: \multicolumn{3}{l}{\bf From radio continuum} \\
173: Radio spectrum (0.4-10 GHz) & $-0.83\pm0.04 $ & Soida et al. (1996) \\
174: Polarised emission & excess in south & Soida et al. (1996) \\
175: Polarised envelope & yes & Chyzy et al. (2007) \\
176: \multicolumn{3}{l}{\bf From Optical (DSS), NIR (2MASS), NUV,FUV (GALEX) } \\
177: Structure & One-arm morphology & ...\\
178: Star formation & Vigorous & ...\\
179: Blue stars & Forms a ridge in south & Wray (1988) \\
180: B Band & Excess in south & Knapen et al. (2004) \\
181: \multicolumn{3}{l}{\bf From CO} \\
182: Inner arms & asymmetric & Sofue et al. (2003)\\
183: Possible Reason & ICM ram pressure & Sofue et al. (2003)\\
184: \multicolumn{3}{l}{\bf From X-ray} \\
185: Galaxy & Intense emitter & Fabbiano et al. (1992) \\
186: Discrete source & ULX in south & Soria \& Wong (2006)\\
187: \multicolumn{3}{l}{\bf From simulations} \\
188: One arm & Tidal & Vollmer et al. (2005) \\
189: Obs. HI structure & tidal+ram press & Vollmer et al. (2005) \\
190: Stripping angle & $70^{\circ}$ & Vollmer et al. (2005) \\
191: \hline\hline
192: \end{tabular}
193: \label{tab1}
194: \end{table}
195:
196: \section{Observations and Results}
197: NGC 4254 was observed at 240 MHz, 325 MHz, 610 MHz and 1280 MHz
198: in the radio continuum and in the 21 cm emission line of HI
199: using the GMRT (Swarup et al. \nocite{swarup}1991,
200: Ananthakrishnan \& Rao \nocite{ananth} 2002).
201: GMRT consists of thirty 45-m diameter parabolic dish antennas spread
202: over a 25 km region and operates at five frequency bands below 1.5 GHz.
203: Details of our observations are listed in Table \ref{tab2}.
204:
205: \begin{table*}
206: \caption{Details of radio observations. The integrated flux density of NGC 4254
207: is given in the last row. }
208: \begin{tabular}{lccccc}
209: \hline\hline
210: Obs Freq (MHz) & 240 & 325 & 610 & 1280 & 21 cm HI\\
211: Obs Dates & 20/02/06 & 24/04/04 & 20/02/06 & 23/10/00 & 16/11/00 \\
212: Working antennas & 23 & 26 & 23 & 18 & 22 \\
213: Bandwidth(MHz) & 5 & 9 & 13 & 12 & 0.0625$^1$ \\
214: {\bf Robust=0} &&& & & \\
215: Synthesized Beam & $17.7''\times11.4''$ & $27''\times10.3''$ & $9.9''\times 5.3''$
216: & $23'' \times 20''$$^2$ & $7.5'' \times 4.9''$ \\
217: Position angle & $-81^{\circ}$ & $-47^{\circ}$ & $-87^{\circ}$ & $-44^{\circ}$ & $31^{\circ}$ \\
218: RMS noise (mJy/beam) & 1.1 & 1.0 & 0.2 & 0.1 & 2.3$^3$ \\
219: {\bf Robust=5} && & & & \\
220: Synthesized Beam & $24''\times21''$ & $34''\times20''$ & $17''\times 16''$ & $19'' \times 17''$ &
221: - \\
222: Position angle & $-31^{\circ}$ & $-6^{\circ}$ & $24^{\circ}$ & $54^{\circ}$ & - \\
223: RMS noise (mJy/beam) & 0.9 & 2 & 0.2 & 0.15 & - \\
224: \hline
225: S (Jy) & 1.96 & 1.6 & 1.08 & 0.377 & - \\
226: \hline\hline
227: \end{tabular}
228:
229: $^1$ 128 channels over the 8 MHz bandwidth resulted in this channel width
230: (i.e. $12.5$ kms$^{-1}$).
231:
232: $^2$ using data on baselines upto $\rm 14 k\lambda$.
233:
234: $^3$ rms is for a channel of width 12.5 kms$^{-1}$.
235:
236: \label{tab2}
237: \end{table*}
238:
239: \subsection{Radio continuum}
240:
241: The visibility data obtained at GMRT in `lta' format were converted to FITS and
242: imported to AIPS\footnote{AIPS is distributed by NRAO
243: which is a facility of the NSF operated under cooperative agreement by Associated Universities, Inc. }.
244: The analysis was carried out using standard tasks in AIPS.
245: Since the field-of-view at 610, 325 and 240 MHz is large, the images were generated
246: using multiple facets.
247: The final images were generated using robust weighting (Briggs \nocite{briggs} 1995) of
248: the visibilities. We made the images using
249: robust=0 (between pure uniform weighting i.e. robust$=-5$ and pure
250: natural weighting i.e. robust$=5$) and robust=5.
251:
252: \begin{figure*}
253: %\includegraphics[width=6cm]{fig1a.ps}
254: %\includegraphics[width=6cm]{fig1b.ps}
255: %\includegraphics[width=6cm]{fig1c.ps}
256: %\includegraphics[width=6cm]{fig1d.ps}
257: \caption{ Maps of NGC 4254 made using Briggs robust=0. The contours are plotted
258: at 3, 6, 12, 24, 48 and 96 times the rms noise $\sigma$.
259: The crosses mark the position of the optical centre of NGC 4254 and the three background point
260: sources in the field.
261: (a) Top left panel. The image at 240 MHz with a beamsize $17.7'' \times 11.4''$,
262: PA$= -81^{\circ}$
263: The rms noise is $\sigma = 1.1$ mJy/beam. The highest contour is $35\sigma$.
264: (b) Top right panel. The image at 325 MHz. The angular resolution is
265: $ 27'' \times 10.3''$, PA$= -46.8^{\circ}$. The rms noise is
266: $\sigma = 1$ mJy/beam and the highest contour is $35\sigma$.
267: (c) Bottom left panel. The image at 610 MHz has a resolution of
268: $9.9''\times 5.3''$, PA$= -87^{\circ}$. The rms noise is
269: $\sigma=0.2$ mJy/beam and the highest contour is $24\sigma$.
270: (d) Bottom right panel. Image at 1280 MHz, obtained with a uvtaper of $14 k\lambda$
271: along both axes (u,v) and convolved to an angular resolution of
272: $23'' \times 20''$, PA$= -44^{\circ}$ to highlight
273: the extended emission in the north-west.
274: The rms noise is $\sigma = 0.1$ mJy/beam and the highest contour is 140$\sigma$. }
275: \label{fig1}
276: \end{figure*}
277:
278: In Fig. \ref{fig1}, we show the images made using robust=0.
279: A sharp cutoff to the radio emission is observed to the south/south-east (see the 325 and
280: 1280 MHz images in Fig. \ref{fig1}).
281: A radio continuum minimum is detected in the
282: north-west at all frequencies although the extent and shape varies.
283: Part of this difference is likely due to the different spatial frequency coverage
284: of the multi-frequency observations. This minimum is accentuated in the naturally
285: weighted maps with it being most prominent at 240 MHz (see Fig. \ref{fig3}b).
286: The 1280 MHz image (robust=0) was made using a maximum baseline of 14 k$\lambda$
287: to highlight the extended features.
288: In Fig. \ref{fig2}, the 610 MHz image has been superposed on the DSS optical image
289: to show the envelope of radio emission around the optical disk.
290: We note that our images at 240 MHz and 610 MHz made using robust=5
291: are by far the most sensitive low frequency images of this galaxy with rms noise
292: of 0.9 mJy/beam and 0.2 mJy/beam respectively, for the beamsizes listed in Table \ref{tab2}.
293: The signal-to-noise ratio on the robust=5 image is higher
294: than on the robust=0 image by a factor of about 3.
295: In Fig. \ref{fig3}, the robust=0 and robust=5 images at 240 MHz are shown for comparison.
296: The correlation between the images is good as seen from the radio emission which extends outwards
297: of the optical disk in the north-west, south-east and south-west and is present in both the maps.
298: For rest of the discussion, we use the naturally weighted images at 240 and 610 MHz
299: unless stated.
300:
301: The integrated flux density of NGC 4254 at different frequencies are
302: listed in Table \ref{tab2}.
303: Visibility data corresponding to the three confusing sources (marked in
304: Fig. \ref{fig3}) which are engulfed by the radio emission from NGC 4254 were removed
305: before generating the images used for constructing the spectral index maps.
306:
307: \begin{figure}
308: %\includegraphics[width=8cm]{fig2.ps}
309: \caption{The 610 MHz Briggs robust=0 map (in contours) is superposed
310: on the DSS grey scale map. Note the radio envelope around the optical disk.
311: The crosses mark the position of the optical centre of the galaxy and the three background point sources.}
312: \label{fig2}
313: \end{figure}
314:
315: \subsection{21 cm HI}
316:
317: An 8 MHz bandwidth spread over 128 channels and centred at 2407 kms$^{-1}$
318: resulted in a channel width of 62.5 KHz $\approx$ 12.5 kms$^{-1}$ for our HI observations.
319: 3C147 and 1120+143 were used as the flux and phase calibrators respectively.
320: The HI data were analysed in AIPS++ ver 1.9 (build 1460).
321: The continuum was estimated by fitting a first order baseline to the
322: line-free channels and subtracted from the data. A spectral line
323: cube was then generated from this database.
324: The moment maps shown in Fig. \ref{fig4} were obtained using a rms noise cutoff of
325: $1.5 \sigma$ in the channel maps. The full resolution maps had an angular resolution of
326: about $7.5''\times4.9''$ with a position angle of $31^{\circ}$.
327:
328: The HI distribution (Fig. \ref{fig4}) across NGC 4254 shows emission detected
329: from the disk but little HI is coincident with the
330: radio continuum extensions in the south-east, the north-west and the
331: south-west. The lowest column density is $3.4\times 10^{19}$ cm$^{-2}$.
332: The velocity field (Fig. \ref{fig4}b) shows that the north-east is the
333: receding side of the disk. A slight lopsidedness is visible
334: in the velocity field with the north-east showing lower rotation
335: ($ < 100$ kms$^{-1}$) velocities compared to the south-west ($ < -100$ kms$^{-1}$)
336: wrt to the systemic velocity ($2407$ kms$^{-1}$) of the galaxy.
337: Fig. \ref{fig4}c shows the velocity dispersion across the galaxy. Widest spectral lines
338: are seen near the centre whereas rest of the disk shows line widths of $10-15$ kms$^{-1}$.
339: The disk has a smooth boundary to the south, south-east whereas the northern boundary
340: is jagged as if this part of HI is being `blown' off. Interestingly, this is
341: also the region where Phookun et al. \nocite{phookun} (1993) detect the largest
342: non-disk HI cloud.
343: We do not detect the non-disk HI clouds (Phookun et al. 1993) or the long HI tail
344: (Haynes et al. \nocite{haynes} 2007) associated with NGC 4254 likely due to
345: lack of short spatial frequencies resulting in lower sensitivity to such extended faint features.
346:
347: \begin{figure*}
348: \includegraphics[width=8cm]{fig3a.ps}
349: \includegraphics[width=8cm]{fig3b.ps}
350: \caption{240 MHz image.
351: Notice the envelope of radio continuum emission
352: at 240 MHz which surrounds the DSS map in the left panel. The
353: contours are plotted at 3, 6, 12, 24, 48 times the rms noise ($\sigma$).
354: (a) The 240 MHz map made with robust=0 superposed on the DSS optical
355: map. Angular resolution is
356: $17.7'' \times 11.4''$, PA$= -81^{\circ}$. The rms noise is
357: 1.1 mJy/beam. The highest contour is $35\sigma$.
358: (b) The naturally weighted (robust=5) 240 MHz map. The angular
359: resolution is $24'' \times 21 ''$,
360: PA$= -30^{\circ}$. The rms noise is 0.9 mJy/beam. The
361: highest contour is $72\sigma$. The grey scale runs from 0.9 to 80 mJy/beam.}
362: \label{fig3}
363: \end{figure*}
364:
365:
366: \begin{figure}
367: %\includegraphics[width=9cm,clip]{fig4a.ps}
368: %\includegraphics[width=9cm,clip]{fig4b.ps}
369: %\includegraphics[width=9cm,clip]{fig4c.ps}
370: \caption{ The HI moment maps are superposed on the 240 MHz
371: grey scale image. (a) Top panel. HI Moment 0 map.
372: The lowest contour level is $3.4\times 10^{19}$ cm$^{-2}$.
373: Contours levels are $(20.4 + 2.43n)\times 10^{19}$ cm$^{-2}$
374: where n runs from -7 to 7. (b)Middle panel. HI Moment 1 map. The systemic velocity
375: of the galaxy is 2407 kms$^{-1}$. The solid lines indicate recession
376: while the dashed lines identifies the approaching side. (c) Bottom
377: panel. HI Moment 2 map. }
378: \label{fig4}
379: \end{figure}
380:
381: \section{The Radio Morphology}
382: We enumerate below the interesting morphological features
383: detected in the radio continuum emission (Figs. \ref{fig1}, \ref{fig2}, \ref{fig3}) and
384: the HI (Fig. \ref{fig4}) from NGC 4254.
385: \begin{enumerate}
386: \item Radio continuum emission and HI are detected from the optical disk.
387: \item Bright abrupt cutoff in the radio emission to the south of the galaxy which outlines the
388: optical disk.
389: \item Low surface brightness emission enveloping the disk emission
390: is detected at all frequencies. These features
391: are prominent at 240 MHz (see Fig. \ref{fig3}).
392: Most notable features are the extension to the north-west,
393: south-east and the finger-like extensions in the south-west which
394: is likely the gas blown out by the ICM pressure.
395: No R band or H$\alpha$ emission is detected from these regions.
396: \item A minimum in the radio continuum is detected in the north-west at all
397: the frequencies. This minimum is most extended and prominent at 240 MHz.
398: Chyzy et al. \nocite{chyzy} (2006,2007) report low polarization in the region which appears to be
399: partially coincident with the minimum at 240 MHz. Thus the minimum could likely be due
400: to a decrease in the magnetic field in that region.
401: \item About 15\% of the total emission at 240 MHz arises in the emission which surrounds
402: the optical disk.
403: \item The HI disk is extended in the north-east (see Fig. \ref{fig4}).
404: \item The HI velocity field is lopsided. Lower recessional velocities are recorded
405: in the north-east and the same region also shows lower column densities.
406: Moreover, the velocity field in the north appears to lag.
407: \item The HI has a jagged border in the north, north-west (see Fig. \ref{fig4})
408: suggesting that the atomic gas is being progressively `blown' off.
409: A smooth boundary is seen in the south, south-east.
410: Moreover the HI shows a vertical edge in the north-east and the
411: west as if gas has been stripped off.
412: \item HI is not found to be coincident with the radio continuum envelope
413: around NGC 4254 (see Fig. \ref{fig4}).
414: \end{enumerate}
415:
416: \begin{figure}
417: \includegraphics[width=6cm,angle=-90]{fig5.ps}
418: \caption{Integrated spectrum of NGC 4254 including the
419: data from Soida et al. (1996) \& Chyzy et al. (2007). The best single power law fit to
420: the data has an index $\alpha=-0.848$ and is shown by the dashed line.
421: The dotted line shows the best fit to the data if electron energy losses
422: are included. It has an injection spectrum of $-0.45$ and has
423: lower $\chi^2$ than the single power law fit. Data at frequencies $\le 100$ MHz are required to
424: confirm the break in the spectrum. }
425: \label{fig5}
426: \end{figure}
427:
428: We compare the radio continuum envelope to the HI low resolution map in
429: Phookun et al. \nocite{phookun}(1993) who detected
430: disk and non-disk HI components. Phookun et al. \nocite{phookun} (1993)
431: inferred that the non-disk HI clouds around NGC 4254 were an infalling population.
432: A similar conclusion can be drawn from the HI velocity field of
433: the non-disk clouds which are likely to be located between us and the galaxy.
434: The HI blob (Fig 5 in Phookun
435: et al. 1993) to the south of NGC 4254 is coincident with part of southern extension we
436: detect at 240 MHz. Moreover, some of the northern HI clouds are
437: coincident with the northern radio continuum extension (see Fig \ref{fig3}).
438: However, it is not clear if these are physically associated or
439: coincident in projection. The HI velocity field is distorted in the north of the galaxy
440: (Fig 4 (b) in Phookun et al. \nocite{phookun} 1993).
441:
442: \section{The Radio Spectrum}
443: We estimate a global spectral index between 240 and 610 MHz of $-0.65$.
444: However, fitting a single power law using
445: the least squares method to all the available data ranging from 408 MHz to
446: 10 GHz (Soida et al. \nocite{soida} 1996, Chyzy et al. \nocite{chyzy1} 2007) and
447: including our data (excluding the 1280 MHz point) resulted in the best fit spectrum
448: %with an index of $-0.82 \pm 0.02$ (see Fig \ref{fig5}). This is in
449: with an index of $-0.848 \pm 0.016$ (see Fig \ref{fig5}). This is in
450: good agreement with the value ($-0.83\pm0.04$) that Soida et al. \nocite{soida} (1996)
451: quote. However $\alpha=-0.65$ obtained from our low frequency data
452: suggests that the spectrum might be flattening at the lower frequencies.
453: Since the galaxy is face-on, absorption by foreground thermal gas is expected to be
454: negligible. Thus, the break could possibly be due to propagation effects of
455: relativistic electrons and subsequent energy losses as explained by
456: Pohl et al. \nocite{pohl} (1991) \& Hummel \nocite{hummel} (1991).
457:
458: To check this, we fitted the observed integrated spectrum of NGC 4254 using the heuristic model given by
459: Hummel \nocite{hummel} (1991) which describes the radio spectrum as
460: \begin{equation}
461: S(\nu)= K \frac{\nu^{\alpha_0}}{1+ (\nu/\nu_b)^{1/2}}
462: \end{equation}
463: The spectral index of the injection spectrum, $\alpha_0$ and
464: the break frequency, $\nu_b$ are estimated
465: by fitting the observed spectrum with the above function.
466: The best fit which has $\alpha_0=-0.45\pm 0.12$ is shown in Fig. \ref{fig5}.
467: This spectrum gives a lower $\chi^2$ compared to the single power law
468: fit (also in Fig. \ref{fig5}) and hence, we believe, is a better fit to the
469: observed data between 240 MHz and 10 GHz. However the fit fails to constrain the break frequency
470: since we do not have data points below 240 MHz.
471: From the above, it is reasonable to conclude that the integrated spectrum of NGC 4254
472: has a break at lower frequencies which is typical of spiral galaxies
473: (Pohl et al. \nocite{pohl} 1991, Hummel \nocite{hummel} 1991).
474: % which is well explained by electron propagation effects
475: %as discussed by Pohl et al. (\nocite{pohl} 1991) and Hummel \nocite{hummel} (1991).
476: We also note that lower frequency data ($\nu\le100$ MHz) are required to confirm the break.
477:
478: A spectral index map of NGC 4254 was constructed between 240 and 610 MHz
479: (Fig. \ref{fig6}). Images at both the frequencies were made
480: with a maximum baseline of 15 k$\lambda$ and then convolved to
481: an angular resolution of $27''\times21''$ at a position angle of $-24^{\circ}$.
482: A cutoff of $2\sigma$ was used for both the images.
483: While the spectral index across the disk is typically between $\alpha = -1~$ and $~ -0.4$
484: with few regions showing $\alpha<-1$, the
485: emission outside the optical disk typically has a spectral index steeper than $-1$
486: (see Fig. \ref{fig6}).
487: The spectral index of the envelope is reminiscent of the halo emission in
488: edge-on galaxies.
489: Chyzy et al \nocite{chyzy} (2006,2007) report the detection of a
490: sharp bright magnetized ridge at 1.43 GHz in the south and present
491: their image at 4.8 GHz. They do not detect the southern feature
492: at 4.8 GHz which implies a spectral index steeper than $-1.5$
493: when combined with our 240 MHz data. This is consistent with our data at 610 MHz.
494: The spectral index near the centre of the galaxy is comparable to the disk ruling
495: out the presence of an AGN at the centre.
496:
497: From the above discussion, we conclude that there are two components to the radio continuum
498: emission from NGC 4254, namely the intense disk component which has
499: $\alpha \ge -1$ and the extended component which has
500: $\alpha \le -1$. The two components are difficult to distinguish
501: morphologically.
502:
503: \begin{figure*}
504: \includegraphics[width=8cm]{fig6a.ps}
505: \includegraphics[width=8cm]{fig6b.ps}
506: \caption{ Spectral index maps of NGC 4254.
507: The maps were were convolved to a resolution of $27.4''\times21.1''$,
508: PA$=-24^{\circ}$ and a flux cutoff of $2\sigma$ was used.
509: The spectral index contours are superposed on the DSS optical image.
510: The solid lines outline regions which are blanked or show positive spectral index
511: whereas the dashed line indicate the negative spectral index distribution. The
512: crosses mark the position of the centre of the galaxy and three background
513: sources which have been removed from the images.
514: (a) Left panel shows contours for $\alpha=-2,-1$ which is typical
515: of the gas beyond the optical disk.
516: (b) Right panel shows contours for $\alpha=-0.8,-0.4$ which is typical
517: of the disk gas. }
518: \label{fig6}
519: \end{figure*}
520:
521: \section{Discussion}
522: The radio power at 1.4 GHz of most normal spiral galaxies lie
523: between $1.6\times10^{19}$ Watts-Hz$^{-1}$
524: and $10^{22}$ Watts-Hz$^{-1}$ (Hummel \nocite{hummel1} 1981)
525: and absolute blue magnitudes lie between $-18$ to $-21$ (Hummel \nocite{hummel1} 1981).
526: NGC 4254 has a power of $1.5 \times 10^{22}$ Watts-Hz$^{-1}$ at 1.4 GHz.
527: The RC3 (de Vaucouleurs et al. \nocite{vaucouleurs} 1991)
528: 25 magnitude size of NGC 4254 is $322''\times281''$ and its total blue apparent magnitude
529: is 10.44 yielding an absolute magnitude of $-21.05$.
530: NGC 4254 is thus, both optically and radio bright.
531: High star formation rates (Schweizer \nocite{schweizer} 1976) of
532: $\sim 10 M_\odot$yr$^{-1}$ (Soria \& Wong \nocite{soria} 2006) have been reported for NGC 4254.
533: Cayatte et al. \nocite{cayatte} (1990) suggested that the sharp cutoff in HI in
534: the south-east could be due to compression by the ICM which
535: could then explain the bright disk.
536: Simulations by Vollmer et al. \nocite{vollmer} (2005) suggest that ram pressure
537: needs to be invoked to explain the observed HI morphology.
538: More recently, Chyzy et al. \nocite{chyzy} (2006,2007) have
539: detected a large polarized envelope of emission at 1.43 GHz around the
540: optical disk and also a bright ridge
541: of polarised emission in the south which they suggest is due to field compression
542: by ram pressure. This, they suggest, could be enhanced by the non-disk HI clouds
543: detected by Phookun et al. \nocite{phookun} (1993) falling back on the disk.
544: All the above indicate that ram pressure due to interstellar
545: medium (ISM)-ICM interaction is active in this system.
546:
547: On the other hand, ample evidence that this galaxy was involved in a tidal
548: encounter has been found - the single dominant spiral arm, the presence of
549: non-disk HI clouds (Phookun et al. \nocite{phookun} 1993) and
550: the presence of a large HI tail which extends northwards from NGC 4254 to a distance
551: of 250 kpc (Haynes et al. \nocite{haynes} 2007). Haynes et al. \nocite{haynes} (2007)
552: attribute this long tail to gas stripped from NGC 4254 by
553: the process of galaxy harrassment (Moore et al.
554: \nocite{moore} 1996) as it enters the Virgo cluster at high speed.
555: The presence of the large HI cloud VIRGOHI21 (Davis et al. \nocite{davies} 2004)
556: which connects spatially and kinematically (Haynes et al. \nocite{haynes},
557: Minchin et al. \nocite{minchin} 2005) to NGC 4254
558: resembles the results of the simulations by Bekki et al. \nocite{bekki} (2005).
559: %Thus, this galaxy has certainly been
560: %subjected to tidal forces.
561:
562: The X-ray emission detected from this galaxy (Chyzy et al. \nocite{chyzy1} 2007,
563: Soria \& Wong \nocite{soria} 2006) is confined to the optical
564: disk. This indicates the absence of hot gas
565: around NGC 4254 which is as expected since it is located on
566: the periphery of the Virgo cluster at a projected distance of 1.2 Mpc from M87.
567: Soria \& Wong \nocite{soria} (2006) suggest that the ultraluminous X-ray (ULX)
568: source they detect due south of the optical disk of NGC 4254 has been triggered
569: by the impact of the infalling HI cloud (Phookun et al. \nocite{phookun} 1993)
570: on the disk.
571:
572: \subsection{Origin of the extended radio continuum emission}
573: Edge-on galaxies commonly show the presence of halo emission extending along the
574: minor axis which is widely studied at low radio frequencies owing to their
575: steep spectra.
576: We examined the DSS maps of a few low inclination galaxies (e.g. NGC 5236,
577: NGC 2997, NGC 6946)
578: taken from the atlas by Condon et al. \nocite{condon1}
579: (1987) and find that the radio and optical disks have similar extents.
580: Hence we find the radio continunum envelope detected around NGC 4254
581: interesting and in this section we try to understand the
582: origin of the extended component (Fig. \ref{fig3}).
583: We believe one of the following scenarios can account for this extended
584: radio continuum component.
585:
586: \subsubsection{Extension of spiral arms}
587: If we examine Fig \ref{fig3}b closely, it appears that the radio emission extends
588: further along the spiral arms of the galaxy especially in the north-west and south-east.
589: Thus, one possibility is that the spiral arms extend further out in the radio than in the optical.
590: We examine the plausibility of this as follows.
591: The typical synchrotron lifetimes of relativistic electrons diffusing
592: out from supernovae in the galaxy would be $4\times10^8$ years at 240 MHz if the
593: magnetic field was 3 $\mu$G. Since we observe
594: radio continuum emission from the envelope, this suggests that the relativistic electron
595: population was generated less than $4\times10^8$ years ago. If this was the case,
596: then at least the low mass stars (lifetimes $> 4\times10^8$ years)
597: from the progenitor stellar population should be surviving even if the
598: OB associations have disappeared (lifetimes $\sim 10^6$ years) during
599: the synchrotron lifetime of the electrons. However no optical emission in the DSS R band
600: is observed to be coincident with the extended features.
601: We also examined the NIR emission in the J, H and K bands from the
602: 2MASS maps which trace emission from low mass stars.
603: The NIR morphology of the galaxy is similar to the DSS optical
604: and no emission coincident with the extended features is detected.
605: This indicates that the extended features are unlikely to be
606: extensions of the galactic spiral arms but are a result of
607: some other physical processes.
608:
609: \subsubsection{Emission from ram-pressure stripped gas}
610: The extended emission could be from the magnetized electron gas which has been
611: removed from the disk due
612: to external influences like tidal, ram pressure or turbulent viscous stripping. This would
613: lead to the ICM being enriched in magnetic field and matter.
614: \begin{figure*}
615: \includegraphics[width=8cm]{fig7.ps}
616: \caption{Schematic explaining the origin of the extended emission around NGC 4254
617: observed in radio continuum at 240 MHz. The 240 MHz map in contours alongwith the optical
618: DSS map are shown. The arrows (white with black stripes) indicate the expanding envelope
619: around NGC 4254 whereas the black arrow shows that the galaxy is moving southwards and
620: into the page.
621: The schematic is not to scale.
622: The envelope of expanding gas is between us and the galaxy as the galaxy recedes
623: with a velocity of 1300 kms$^{-1}$ towards the cluster centre.}
624: \label{fig7}
625: \end{figure*}
626:
627: Our multi-frequency radio study of NGC 4254 gives interesting results.
628: We detect radio continuum emission from regions surrounding the optical
629: disk (see Fig \ref{fig3}).
630: The spectrum of this emission is steeper ($\alpha \le -1$) compared to the disk emission
631: ($\alpha \ge -1$). Moreover,
632: the extended emission does not form a uniform halo around the optical disk (see Fig. \ref{fig1}).
633: While it could be partially attributed to sensitivity and spatial frequency coverage,
634: most of this feature indicates real
635: asymmetry in the extended emission. At 240 MHz, about 15\% of the total emission arises
636: in this extended component.
637: In our HI velocity map, we notice a lagging rotation field in the atomic gas located to the
638: north of the galaxy. It is likely that this part is being
639: stripped and the gas is slowly losing rotation.
640:
641: From the above, we suggest that the extended radio
642: continuum emission which has a steeper spectral index and the atomic gas in the north of
643: the galaxy are likely not part of
644: the disk emission and probably do not lie in the plane of NGC 4254.
645: This might be gas which has been pushed out of the galaxy by ISM-ICM interaction.
646: Below we summarize the morphological features that we believe can be
647: explained by ram pressure caused by the ISM-ICM interaction:
648: \begin{itemize}
649: \item A sharp cutoff is present in both the radio continuum and HI to the south/south-east.
650: The galaxy is ploughing into the ICM at an angle of $70^{\circ}$
651: (Vollmer et al. \nocite{vollmer} 2005) which is close to face-on
652: and the south is the leading edge
653: encountering the ICM wind. The swept-up gas would, thus, give rise to such a smooth boundary.
654: \item The enhanced star formation rates across the entire galaxy.
655: The wind encounters the entire disk and hence
656: star formation would have been triggered throughout the disk explaining the
657: enhanced star formation rates ($\sim 10 M_\odot$yr$^{-1}$, Soria \& Wong \nocite{soria} 2006)
658: \item Intense radio emission. This would be a direct result of enhanced star formation
659: and presence of young massive stars in this galaxy.
660: \item Extended radio continuum around the optical disk. This emission is from the
661: relativistic electron gas which has been influenced by ram pressure and which is
662: subsequently diffusing beyond the galaxy as the latter rushes
663: towards the cluster centre (see Fig. \ref{fig7}) through the ICM. The extended emission arises
664: in gas which is not co-planar with the disk of the galaxy but follows the galaxy.
665: The HI Tully-Fisher relation gives a distance of 16.8 Mpc to NGC 4254
666: (Schoniger \& Sofue \nocite{schoniger} 1997) whereas the mean
667: distance to the Virgo cluster is $20.7\pm 2.4$ Mpc
668: (Federspiel et al. \nocite{federspiel} 1998). Thus, NGC 4254 is
669: closer to us compared to M87 and hence it is reasonable to consider it to be receding and
670: falling in towards the centre of the cluster. The matter giving rise to the extended
671: radio continuum, then, lies between us and the galaxy.
672: \item Steep spectrum of the extended continuum. The extended emission is similar
673: to the halo emission observed in edge-on disk galaxies which is also found to
674: have a steeper spectrum compared to disk emission. We believe a similar explanation
675: holds for the emission around NGC 4254.
676: \item Extended polarized envelope at 1.4 GHz detected around the
677: optical disk by Chyzy et al. \nocite{chyzy}\nocite{chyzy1} (2006,2007).
678: \item Minor HI deficiency of 0.17 quoted by Cayatte et al. (1994).
679: \end{itemize}
680:
681: Based on the above, we believe that the extended radio continuum emission detected
682: outside the optical disk is mainly because of a ram pressure event as the galaxy moves
683: in the ICM. The point we would like to stress is that ram pressure is effective
684: even though the galaxy is located in the low ICM density
685: environs in the outskirts of the Virgo cluster.
686:
687: Using equipartition and minimum energy arguments, we find that the equipartition
688: magnetic field in NGC 4254 is
689: about 3$\mu$G and the magnetic pressure is $4\times10^{-13}$ ergs-cm$^{-3}$.
690: The ram pressure acting on the galaxy, which lies about
691: $3.7^{\circ}$ from the centre of the cluster
692: was estimated to be $9\times10^{-13}$ ergs-cm$^{-3}$ (Cayatte et al.\nocite{cayatte1} 1994).
693: They estimate the gravitational pull for this galaxy to be $16\times10^{-13}$ ergs-cm$^{-3}$.
694: Thus, the ram pressure acting on the galaxy leading to gas stripping
695: is slightly larger than the magnetic pressure holding back the relativistic electrons
696: from escaping and about half of the gravitational pressure
697: of the galaxy. Since this galaxy has undergone a tidal encounter,
698: the tidal debris could increase the ICM densities or the tidal
699: interaction could have reduced the surface density of gas in the outer parts of the
700: galaxy leading to an enhancement in the ability of ram pressure to
701: influence the ISM of NGC 4254. Similar mechanism has been suggested for
702: other Virgo galaxies (e.g. Vollmer \nocite{vollmer4} 2003,
703: Chung et al. \nocite{chung} 2007) and poor groups
704: (e.g. Kantharia et al. \nocite{kantharia} 2005).
705: Moreover the high star formation rate of the galaxy would lead to intense
706: stellar winds and supernova explosions which would further facilitate
707: the ISM-ICM interaction.
708: Thus, we believe that our radio observations support the earlier results
709: of Vollmer et al. \nocite{vollmer} (2005) and Chyzy et al. \nocite{chyzy} (2006) where
710: both tidal interactions and ram pressure were put forward to explain the observed morphology
711: of the HI and the radio continuum at 1.4 and 4.8 GHz of NGC 4254.
712: We also suggest a possible way to determine whether
713: a low inclination galaxy has undergone a ram pressure
714: event by examining its low radio frequency morphology and the distribution of
715: the spectral index across it.
716:
717: \subsection{Comparison with published simulation results}
718: Several authors have studied ram pressure stripping in a variety
719: of environs and with a variety of
720: initial conditions in clusters and groups (e.g. Schulz \& Struck \nocite{schulz} 2001,
721: Vollmer \nocite{vollmer1} 2001, Roediger \& Hensler \nocite{roediger1} 2005,
722: Roediger \& Bruggen \nocite{roediger} 2006, Hester \nocite{hester} 2006).
723: We examine these in light of our new low frequency radio observations of NGC 4254.
724: The angle between the disk of NGC 4254 and its orbital plane in Virgo cluster is
725: $70^{\circ}$ (Vollmer et al. \nocite{vollmer} 2005) and the stripping is close to, but
726: not entirely, face-on
727: as the galaxy moves within the cluster. Roediger \& Bruggen \nocite{roediger} (2006),
728: in their simulations of ram pressure stripping
729: in disk galaxies, have shown that for face-on stripping, the stripped gas will expand and
730: form a tail behind the galaxy. For a low inclination galaxy,
731: the stripped gas will form a halo around it over a few hundred
732: million years and would be detectable depending on its emissivity.
733: Vollmer et al. (2005) performed simulations to explain the observed HI morphology
734: (Phookun et al. \nocite{phookun} 1993) of NGC 4254. They could explain
735: most of the morphological
736: features only if ram pressure is invoked alongwith a tidal encounter
737: which would have occurred about 300 Myrs ago.
738: Their results indicated that ram pressure would only succceed in
739: distorting gas with hydrogen column densities $< 10^{20}$ cm$^{-2}$.
740: Roediger \& Hensler \nocite{roediger1} (2005) and Roediger \& Bruggen (2006),
741: from their simulations on the influence of
742: the ICM on the cluster members, infer that galaxies undergo
743: ram pressure stripping in three stages. The first stage, they describe as
744: the instantaneous stripping phase
745: wherein the outer gas disk expands without becoming unbound from the galaxy. It can
746: lead to truncation of the gas disk without much mass loss.
747: This phase is likely to affect galaxies on the
748: outskirts of clusters and in groups and is short-lived,
749: lasting only for 20 to 200 Myr. In the intermediate, much longer-lived phase, some of
750: the expanded gas actually evaporates while some of it falls back on the disk.
751: In the final third phase, the galaxy loses mass at a stable rate of 1 M$_\odot$yr$^{-1}$ due
752: to turbulent viscous stripping (Nulsen 1982).
753:
754: Comparing this simulation result with our radio continuum data on NGC 4254, it appears that
755: gas stripping in NGC 4254 is in the first phase of evolution.
756: The extended features which surround the optical disk of NGC 4254 (see Fig. \ref{fig3})
757: are probably due to the relativistic gas which has diffused out from the
758: disk but has not yet evaporated.
759: The same argument also probably holds for the HI gas.
760: The gas is being stripped as seen from the jagged morphology of
761: HI that we detect especially in the north and along the vertical edge
762: in the east. The smooth boundary to the south is the leading edge and
763: is caused by the wind blowing across it. Some of the gas in the north which
764: shows a lagging rotation field might be due to stripped gas which is slowly losing
765: rotation.
766: We also tried to understand the non-disk HI clouds that Phookun et al.
767: \nocite{phookun}(1993)
768: have detected surrounding the galaxy and not following galaxy rotation. Phookun et al.
769: \nocite{phookun} (1993) conclude that these clouds form an
770: infalling population. While the tidal origin put forward by Phookun et al.
771: \nocite{phookun} (1993) is the most plausible especially since
772: these form part of the long HI tail which Haynes et al. \nocite{haynes} (2007) attribute
773: to galaxy harrassment, we examined it in relation to the
774: three stages of ram pressure stripping inferred by Roediger \& Hensler \nocite{roediger1} (2005)
775: and explained in brief above. If we hypothesize that the infalling clouds were
776: stripped from the galaxy due to ram pressure then the HI gas in
777: this galaxy might have just entered into the second phase of evolution
778: (Roediger \& Hensler \nocite{roediger1} 2005).
779: In this phase, part of the HI falls back whereas part of the gas is lost from the
780: system. Some of the far non-disk HI clouds that Phookun et al. \nocite{phookun}
781: (1993) detect could also possibly be part of this population.
782: Since the galaxy is receding towards south/south-east,
783: the tail of clouds extending northwards
784: appears to be in the expected direction.
785: However, we also note that Roediger \& Bruggen \nocite{roediger} (2006)
786: demonstrate in their simulations that the
787: direction of motion of the galaxy cannot always be surmised
788: from the tail of stripped gas. It may be mentioned, however,
789: that our explanation of the infalling clouds (Phookun et al. \nocite{phookun} 1993)
790: is more speculative and requires further evidence from simulations.
791:
792: Since NGC 4254 is located in a relatively low density environment in the outskirts
793: of the Virgo cluster, the ram pressure stripping event is
794: relatively young and was begun
795: at most 200 Myrs ago (Roediger \& Hensler \nocite{roediger1} 2005).
796: Recall that the simulation by Vollmer et al. \nocite{vollmer} (2005)
797: indicated that a tidal interaction involving NGC 4254 occurred $\approx 300$ Myrs ago.
798: These timescales support the hypothesis that the tidal encounter
799: boosted the potential of ISM-ICM interaction making it more effective then it would
800: have otherwise been. The schematic in Fig. \ref{fig7} summarizes the scenario for
801: NGC 4254 as discussed above.
802:
803: \section{Summary \& Conclusions}
804: In this paper, we have presented multifrequency radio continuum observations
805: made with the GMRT of the spiral galaxy NGC 4254 located in the north-west outskirts of the
806: Virgo cluster. NGC 4254 is a luminous galaxy with a radio power of
807: $7\times10^{22}$ Watts-Hz$^{-1}$ at 240 MHz.
808: We report the detection of extended, structured, low surface brightness radio continuum
809: emission at 240 MHz surrounding the optical disk.
810: We note that Chyzy et al. \nocite{chyzy} (2006,2007) have reported detection
811: of an extended polarized envelope around the optical disk at 1.4 GHz.
812:
813: Combining our data with existing spectral data (Soida et al. \nocite{soida} 1996, Chyzy et al.
814: \nocite{chyzy1} 2007),
815: we find that the best fit to the global spectrum is given by a spectral index of
816: $-0.848 \pm 0.016$ which is close to the value Soida et al. \nocite{soida} (1996) quote.
817: However from our data at 240, 325 and 610 MHz, we deduce that the spectrum
818: flattens at the lower frequencies. A heuristic model which includes electron
819: propogation effects (Hummel \nocite{hummel} 1991) gives
820: a better fit to the data. The injection spectrum has an index $\alpha_0=-0.45\pm0.12$.
821:
822: From a detailed spectral index mapping between 240 and 610 MHz, we find that the
823: spectral index of the extended emission is steeper with $\alpha \le -1$ compared to
824: that of the radio emission coincident with the optical disk ($\alpha \ge -1$).
825: We hypothesize that the extended emission is not associated
826: with the optical disk but has been pushed out due to ram pressure of the ICM acting
827: on the ISM of the galaxy. The atomic material in the north lags in rotation wrt
828: rest of the disk and this we believe is part of the gas mass which is being influenced by
829: ram pressure.
830: NGC 4254 is moving away from us and the stripped material lies between us and
831: the galaxy as shown in the schematic of Fig. \ref{fig7}.
832:
833: From the above, we conclude the following:
834: \begin{itemize}
835: \item We believe that we have detected a clear signature of ram pressure stripping in
836: NGC 4254, a spiral galaxy in the outskirts of the Virgo cluster, in the form of
837: an extended envelope of emission surrounding the optical disk at 240 MHz.
838: This emission exhibits a steep spectral index as compared to the disk emission.
839: We suggest that these might be common signatures of ISM-ICM interaction
840: which have not been noticed due to a dearth of such low frequency high
841: sensitivity data on low inclination galaxies in cluster/group environments.
842:
843: \item We suggest that low frequency ($\le 300$ MHz) high sensitivity survey of
844: a sample of face-on galaxies in low density groups and clusters will help generate significant
845: information on the radio frequency signatures of ISM-ICM interactions.
846: Signatures such as a steep spectrum and extended emission around low inclination
847: galaxies can be studied for a larger sample.
848:
849: \item ISM-ICM interactions are likely to be more common in lower density, lower
850: velocity dispersion environments than is presently believed. There are already
851: several examples (e.g Solanes et al. \nocite{solanes} 2001,
852: Kantharia et al. \nocite{kantharia} 2005, Levy et al.
853: \nocite{levy} 2007) which suggest that ram pressure events are active in
854: X-ray poor groups and in the outskirts of clusters. Simulations
855: by several groups (e.g. Roediger \& Bruggen 2006, Vollmer et al. 2005, Hester 2006 )
856: show that this is possible. Ram pressure in many of these cases
857: is aided by other physical phenomena such as tidal interaction and supernova
858: explosions. The stripped gas would help enhance the ICM densities further.
859: Systematic low frequency observations of several galaxies in the outskirts of
860: clusters and in poor groups are required for further understanding.
861:
862: \end{itemize}
863:
864: \section{Acknowledgements}
865: We thank the anonymous referee for a detailed report and
866: for giving several helpful suggestions on the manuscript.
867: We thank the staff of the GMRT that made these observations possible.
868: GMRT is run by the National Centre for Radio Astrophysics of the Tata Institute of
869: Fundamental Research.
870: This research has made use of the NASA/IPAC Extragalactic Database (NED) and NASA/ IPAC
871: Infrared Science Archive
872: which is operated by the Jet Propulsion Laboratory, California Institute of Technology,
873: under contract with the National Aeronautics and Space Administration.
874: This research has made use of NASA's Astrophysics Data System.
875: NGK thanks Prof. T. P. Prabhu for useful discussions.
876:
877:
878: \begin{thebibliography}{}
879:
880: \bibitem[2002]{ananth}Ananthakrishnan, S., \& Rao, A. P. 2002, in Multicolour Universe,
881: International conference on Multi Colour Universe, ed. R. Manchanda \& B. Paul, 233
882:
883: \bibitem[2005]{bekki} Bekki, K., Koribalski, B., Kilborn, V., 2005, 2005, MNRAS, 363, L21
884:
885: \bibitem[1995]{briggs} Briggs, D., 'High Fidelity Deconvolution of Moderately Resolved
886: Sources', PhD thesis, 1995.
887:
888: \bibitem[1990]{cayatte} Cayatte, V., van Gorkom, J. H., Balkowski, C., Kotanyi, C., 1990, AJ, 100, 604
889:
890: \bibitem[1994]{cayatte1} Cayatte, V., Kotanyi, C., Balkowski, C.,
891: van Gorkom, J. H., 1994, AJ, 107, 1003
892:
893: \bibitem[1943]{chandrasekhar} Chandrasekhar, S., 1943, ApJ., 97, 255
894:
895: \bibitem[2006]{chyzy} Chyzy, K.T., Ehle, M., Beck, R., 2006, Astronomische Nachrichten, 327, 501
896:
897: \bibitem[2007]{chyzy1} Chyzy, K.T., Ehle, M., Beck, R., 2007 (arXiv:0708.1533)
898:
899: \bibitem[1987]{condon1} Condon, J.J., 1987, ApJS, 65, 485
900:
901: \bibitem[1992]{condon} Condon, J.J., 1992, ARA\&A, 30,575
902:
903: \bibitem[2007]{chung} Chung, A, van Gorkom, J. H., Kenney, J. D. P., Vollmer, B., 2007,
904: ApJ, 659, L115
905:
906: \bibitem[2004]{davies} Davies, J., Minchin, R., Sabatini, S., et al., 2004, MNRAS, 349, 922
907:
908: \bibitem[1991]{vaucouleurs} de Vaucouleurs, G., de Vaucouleurs, A.,
909: Corwin, H. G., et al., 1991, Third Reference Catalogue
910: of Bright Galaxies, (New York; Springer) (RC3)
911:
912: \bibitem[1992]{fabbiano} Fabbiano, G., Kim, D.-W., Trinchieri, G., 1992, ApJS, 80, 531
913:
914: \bibitem[1998]{federspiel} Federspiel, M., Tammann, G. A., Sandage, A.,
915: 1998, ApJ, 495, 115
916:
917: \bibitem[2007]{gil} Gil de Paz, A., Boissier, S., Madore, B. F.,
918: et al., to appear in ApJS (astro-ph/0606440)
919:
920: \bibitem[2007]{haynes} Haynes, M. P., Giovanelli, R., Kent, B. R., 2007, ApJ, 665, L19
921:
922: \bibitem[2006]{hester} Hester, J. A., 2006, ApJ, 647, 910
923:
924: \bibitem[1981]{hummel1} Hummel, E., 1981, A\&A, 93, 93
925:
926: \bibitem[1991]{hummel} Hummel, E., 1991, A\&A, 251, 442
927:
928: \bibitem[1972]{gunn}Gunn, J. E., \& Gott III, J. R. 1972, ApJ, 176,1
929:
930: \bibitem[1986]{hucht} Huchtmeier, W. K., Richter, O.-G., 1986, A\&AS, 64, 111
931:
932: \bibitem[2005]{kantharia} Kantharia, N. G., Ananthakrishnan, S., Nityananda, R.,
933: Hota, A., 2005, A\&A, 435, 483
934:
935: \bibitem[2004]{knapen} Knapen, J. H., Stedman, S., Bramich, D. M., Folkes, S. L., Bradley, T. R.,
936: 2004, A\&A, 426,1135
937:
938: \bibitem[1975]{lecar} Lecar, M., 1975, in
939: Dynamics of Stellar Systems: Proceedings from IAU Symposium no. 69,
940: Ed. Avram Hayli, Dordrecht; Boston: D. Reidel Pub. Co., p.161
941:
942: \bibitem[2007]{levy} Levy, L., Rose, J. A., van Gorkom, J. H., Chaboyer, B.,
943: 2007, AJ, 133, 1104
944:
945: \bibitem[2005]{minchin} Minchin, R. F., Davies, J.I., Disney, M. J., et al., 2005, ApJ, 622, L21
946:
947: \bibitem[2007]{minchin1} Minchin R. F., Davies, J. I., Disney, M. J. et al., 2007,
948: to appear in ApJ (astro-ph/0706.1586)
949:
950: \bibitem[1996]{moore} Moore, B., Katz, N., Lake, G., Dressler, A., Oemler, A., Jr.,
951: 1996, Nature, 379, 613
952:
953: \bibitem[1982]{nulsen}Nulsen, P. E. J., 1982, MNRAS, 198, 1007
954:
955: \bibitem[1993]{phookun}Phookun, B., Vogel, Stuart N., Mundy, Lee G., 1993, ApJ, 418, 113
956:
957: \bibitem[1991]{pohl}Pohl, M., Schlickeiser, R., Hummel, E., 1991, A\&A 250, 302
958:
959: \bibitem[2006]{roediger} Roediger, E., Brüggen, M., 2006, MNRAS, 369, 567
960:
961: \bibitem[2005]{roediger1}Roediger, E., Hensler, G., 2005, A\&A, 433, 875
962:
963: \bibitem[1997]{schoniger} Schoniger, F., Sofue, Y., 1997, A\&A, 323, 14
964:
965: \bibitem[2001]{schulz} Schulz, S., Struck, C., 2001, MNRAS, 328, 185
966:
967: \bibitem[2006]{soria} Soria, R., Wong, D. S., 2006, MNRAS, 372, 1531
968:
969: \bibitem[1996]{soida} Soida, M., Urbanik, M., Beck, R., 1996, A\&A, 312, 409
970:
971: \bibitem[2003]{sofue} Sofue, Y., Koda, J., Nakanishi, H., Hidaka, M., 2003, PASJ, 55, 75
972:
973: \bibitem[1991]{swarup}Swarup, G., Ananthakrishnan, S., Kapahi, V., et al. 1991,
974: Current Science, 60, 95
975:
976: \bibitem[1976]{schweizer} Schweizer, F., 1976, ApJS, 31, 313
977:
978: \bibitem[2001]{solanes} Solanes, J. M., Manrique, A., Garcia-Gomez, C., et al.
979: 2001, 548, 97
980:
981: \bibitem[1977]{toomre} Toomre, A., 1977, ARA\&A, 15, 437
982:
983: \bibitem[1986]{urbanik} Urbanik, M., Klein, U., Graeve, R., 1986, A\&A, 166, 107
984:
985: \bibitem[2004]{urbanik1} Urbanik, M., in Proceedings of 'The Magnetized Plasma
986: in Galaxy Evolution', 2004, p201, Ed: Chyzy, K. T., et al.
987:
988: \bibitem[2001]{vollmer1} Vollmer, B., Cayatte, V., Balkowski, C., Duschl, W. J.,
989: 2001, ApJ, 561, 708
990:
991: \bibitem[2003]{vollmer4} Vollmer, B., 2003, A\&A, 398, 525
992:
993: \bibitem[2004]{vollmer2} Vollmer, B., Thierbach, M., Wielebinski, R., 2004, A\&A, 418, 1
994:
995: \bibitem[2005]{vollmer} Vollmer, B., Huchtmeier, W., van Driel, W., 2005, A\&A, 439, 921
996:
997: \bibitem[2007]{vollmer3} Vollmer, B., Soida, M., Beck, R., et al., 2007, A\&A, 464, L37
998:
999: \bibitem[1988]{warmels} Warmels, R. H. 1988, A\&AS, 72, 57
1000:
1001: \bibitem[2007]{wezgoweic} Wezgoweic, M., Urbanik, M., Vollmer, B., et al.,
1002: 2007, A\&A, 471, 93
1003:
1004: \bibitem[1988]{wray} Wray, J. D., in 'The Colour Atlas of Galaxies', 1988, Cambridge Univeristy Press.
1005:
1006:
1007: \end{thebibliography}{}
1008:
1009:
1010: \end{document}
1011: