1: %\documentclass{aastex}
2: \documentclass[12pt,preprint]{aastex}
3: %\documentclass[12pt,manuscript]{aastex}
4: \usepackage{graphicx}
5: \begin{document}
6: \def\la{\mathrel{\hbox{\rlap{\hbox{\lower4pt\hbox{$\sim$}}}\hbox{$<$}}}}
7: \def\ga{\mathrel{\hbox{\rlap{\hbox{\lower4pt\hbox{$\sim$}}}\hbox{$>$}}}}
8: \def\lam{$\lambda$}
9: \def\kms{km~s$^{-1}$}
10: \def\vphot{$v_{\rm phot}$}
11: \def\ang{~\AA}
12: \def\syn{SYNOW}
13: \def\dm15{{$\Delta$}$m_{15}$}
14: \def\rsi{$R$(Si~II)}
15: \def\v10{$V_{10}$(Si~II)}
16: \def\wsi{$W_lambda$(Si~II)}
17: \def\vdot{\.v(Si~II)}
18: \def\W575{$W(5750)$}
19: \def\W610{$W(6100)$}
20: \def\6100{the 6100~\AA\ absorption}
21: \def\tex{$T_{\rm exc}$}
22: \def\ve{$v_{\rm e}$}
23:
24: \title {Comparative Direct Analysis of Type~Ia Supernova Spectra.
25: IV. Postmaximum}
26:
27: \author {David Branch\altaffilmark{1},
28: David~J. Jeffery\altaffilmark{1,2}, Jerod Parrent\altaffilmark{1,3},
29: E.~Baron\altaffilmark{1}, M.~A. Troxel\altaffilmark{1},
30: V.~Stanishev\altaffilmark{4}, Melissa Keithley\altaffilmark{1},
31: Joshua Harrison\altaffilmark{1}, and Christopher
32: Bruner\altaffilmark{1,5}}
33:
34: \altaffiltext{1} {Homer L. Dodge Department of Physics and Astronomy,
35: University of Oklahoma, Norman,~OK; branch@nhn.ou.edu}
36:
37: \altaffiltext{2} {Department of Physics, University of Idaho,
38: Moscow,~ID}
39:
40: \altaffiltext{3} {Department of Physics and Astronomy, Dartmouth
41: College, Hanover,~NH}
42:
43: \altaffiltext{4} {Department of Physics, Stockholm University,
44: Stockholm, Sweden}
45:
46: \altaffiltext{5} {Department of Physics, Worcester Polytechnic
47: Institute, Worcester,~MA}
48:
49: \begin{abstract}
50:
51: A comparative study of optical spectra of Type~Ia supernovae (SNe~Ia)
52: obtained near 1 week, 3 weeks, and 3 months after maximum light is
53: presented. Most members of the four groups that were defined on the
54: basis of maximum light spectra in Paper~II (core normal, broad line,
55: cool, and shallow silicon) develop highly homogeneous postmaximum
56: spectra, although there are interesting exceptions. Comparisons with
57: SYNOW synthetic spectra show that most of the spectral features can be
58: accounted for in a plausible way. The fits show that 3 months after
59: maximum light, when SN~Ia spectra are often said to be in the nebular
60: phase and to consist of forbidden emission lines, the spectra actually
61: remain dominated by resonance scattering features of permitted lines,
62: primarily those of Fe~II. Even in SN~1991bg, which is said to have
63: made a very early transition to the nebular phase, there is no need to
64: appeal to forbidden lines at 3 weeks postmaximum, and at 3 months
65: postmaximum the only clear identification of a forbidden line is
66: [Ca~II] \lam\lam7291, 7324. Recent studies of SN~Ia rates indicate
67: that most of the SNe~Ia that have ever occurred have been ``prompt''
68: SNe~Ia, produced by young ($\sim 10^8$ yr) stellar populations, while
69: most of the SNe~Ia that occur at low redshift today are ``tardy'',
70: produced by an older (several Gyrs) population. We suggest that the
71: shallow silicon SNe~Ia tend to be the prompt ones.
72:
73: \end{abstract}
74:
75: \keywords{Supernovae}
76:
77: \section{INTRODUCTION}
78:
79: This is the fourth in a series of papers on a comparative direct
80: analysis of the optical spectra of Type~Ia supernovae (SNe~Ia).
81: Paper~I (Branch et~al. 2005) was concerned with a time series of
82: spectra of the spectroscopically normal SN~1994D, Paper~II (Branch
83: et~al. 2006) was devoted to spectra obtained near maximum light, and
84: Paper~III (Branch et~al. 2007) concentrated on premaximum spectra.
85: This paper is about postmaximum spectra, which form in the deeper,
86: lower velocity ejecta.
87:
88: In Paper~II we divided the maximum-light ($B$ maximum) spectra into
89: four groups: core normal, broad line, cool, and shallow silicon
90: (denoted CN, BL, CL, and SS, respectively, in this paper). The group
91: assignments were made on the basis of measurements of the (pseudo)
92: equivalent widths of absorption features near 5750 and 6100\ang, as
93: well as on the appearance (depth, width, and shape) of the 6100\ang\
94: absorption, which is produced by the Si~II \lam6355 transition.
95: Although we framed the presentation and discussion in terms of the
96: four groups, in the end we concluded that for the most part the
97: spectra appeared to have a continuous distribution of properties,
98: rather than consisting of discrete subtypes (the extreme SS
99: SN~2002cx--likes being an apparent exception, and the extreme CL
100: SN~1991bg--likes being a possible exception). In Paper~III we found
101: that to a large extent the premaximum spectra exhibited the defining
102: characteristics of the four groups.
103:
104: In this paper, as in the previous ones, we confine our attention to
105: optical spectra, from the Ca~II H and K feature in the blue
106: ($\sim3700$\ang) to the Ca~II infrared triplet (Ca~II IR3) in the red
107: ($\sim9000$\ang). All spectra have been corrected for the redshifts
108: of the host galaxies, and mild smoothing has been applied to some of
109: the spectra. All spectra have been flattened according to the local
110: normalization procedure of Jeffery et~al. (2007), which eliminates all
111: significant broad band continuum variations, including those caused by
112: interstellar reddening and observational error. Thus the locally
113: normalized spectra allow valid comparisons of intrinsic line features.
114: But note that a locally normalized spectrum is not a unique
115: representation of the line spectrum. It depends on the exact
116: prescription of the local normalization procedure. We use exactly the
117: same procedure for all spectra of this paper.
118:
119:
120: We examined all of the SN~Ia postmaximum spectra available to us and
121: selected three samples: a ``1 week postmax'' sample, consisting of one
122: spectrum each of 21 SNe~Ia observed between day~+6 and day~+8 with
123: respect to the time of maximum brightness in the $B$ band; a ``3 week
124: postmax'' sample of 19 SNe~Ia observed between day~+19 and day~+23;
125: and a ``3 months postmax'' sample of 15 SNe~Ia observed between
126: day~+81 and day~+98 (an interval of day~+80 to day~+100 yielded no
127: additional spectra). The SNe~Ia and the epochs of the selected
128: spectra are listed in Table~1. Many comparisons of subsets of these
129: spectra have appeared in the literature. Our goal is to provide a
130: more systematic and comprehensive comparison.
131:
132: Spectra of four of the SNe~Ia of Table~1 were not available for
133: previous papers of this series. Sadakane et~al. (1996) published
134: spectra of SN~1995D obtained shortly after maximum light, but it is
135: difficult to decide from their Figure~3 whether SN~1995D should be
136: assigned to the CNs or the SSs. On the basis of the report by Benetti
137: \& Mendes de Oliveira (1995) that in a 1 week premax spectrum the
138: 5750~\AA\ absorption was unusually weak if present at all, we
139: tentatively assign SN~1995D to the SS group. Pastorello et~al. (2007)
140: referred to SN~2004eo as a transitional SN~Ia because its properties
141: placed it between the three groups (faint, low velocity gradient, and
142: high velocity gradient) of Benetti et~al. (2005). In our
143: classification, the maximum light spectrum of SN~2004eo is not quite
144: CN; it resembles that of SN~1989B (Paper~II), and like SN~1989B it is
145: placed in the CL group although it does not contain the blue ``Ti~II
146: trough'' of the more extreme members of the CL group. The maximum
147: light spectrum of SN~2006X (Wang et~al. 2007) is that of an extreme BL
148: SN~Ia, such as SN~1984A. Hicken et~al. (2007) showed that an early
149: spectrum of SN~2006gz had the strongest C~II \lam6580\ absorption yet
150: seen in a SN~Ia, and argued that super--Chandrasekhar mass ejection is
151: required. Although no spectrum was obtained within three days of
152: maximum light, at earlier epochs SN~2006gz showed characteristics of a
153: SS event, and we tentatively classify it as such.
154:
155: \section{CALCULATIONS}
156:
157: Continuing our attempt to provide an internally consistent
158: quantification of SN~Ia spectra, we have used the parameterized
159: resonance--scattering synthetic--spectrum code, SYNOW, to fit the
160: spectra of Table~1. The excitation temperature is fixed at a nominal
161: value of 7000~K, as was done for the postmaximum SN~1994D spectra of
162: Paper~I. A change of procedure from our previous work with SYNOW on
163: postmaximum spectra, including that of Paper~I, is that instead of
164: using exponential (Paper~I) or power--law radial optical depth
165: distributions, we use a flat distribution with an imposed maximum
166: velocity, $v_{\rm max}$, for every ion. In the outer layers of the
167: ejected matter, a decreasing density is dictated by hydrodynamical
168: models (and by mass conservation: the density must start decreasing
169: somewhere), but in the deeper layers the density gradient is less
170: steep. Since the optical depth distribution depends also on
171: composition, excitation, and ionization gradients, a flat optical
172: depth distribution is not unreasonable. For further economy of
173: parameters, for a given spectrum we use the same value of $v_{\rm
174: max}$ for all singly ionized members of the iron group, from Sc~II to
175: Ni~II (with the exception of the 1 week postmax spectrum of SN~2000cx;
176: \S~3.) The price to be paid is that the fits are not optimized, but
177: the fitting procedure becomes more efficient (there is no need to vary
178: the $v_{\rm e}$ parameter) and the parameters become easier to
179: compare: for each ion we have just a reference--line optical depth and
180: the velocity interval in which the lines of the ion are forming in the
181: synthetic spectrum, the minimum velocity being either the velocity at
182: the photosphere $v_{\rm phot}$ or a higher detachment velocity (i.e.,
183: detached from the photosphere). Since we use only one optical depth
184: component for each ion, in this paper it is not necessary to use the
185: HV (high velocity) and PV (photospheric velocity) terminology of
186: previous papers of this series.
187:
188: Consider the effects, when switching from an exponential to a flat
189: optical depth distribution, on the relative importance of lines of the
190: same ion but of different strengths. In the flat case, the optical
191: depths of the strongest lines need to be smaller than in the
192: exponential case, since they maintain the same optical depths all the
193: way to $v_{\rm max}$. Lines that are somewhat weaker, but whose
194: optical depths still remain above unity in the flat case, become
195: relatively more important, because they now form over just as large a
196: velocity interval as the strongest lines. Lines whose optical depths
197: are reduced from above unity in the exponential case to well below
198: unity in the flat case no longer conspicuously affect the spectrum.
199:
200: As an example, Figure~1 compares synthetic spectra for Fe~II, with
201: flat and exponential optical depth distributions. The flat case has
202: the parameters that we use in \S~4 for the day~+22 spectrum of the CN
203: SN~1996X: $\tau$(Fe~II)=12, $v_{\rm phot} = 6000$ \kms, and $v_{\rm
204: max}=13,000$ \kms. The exponential case has the parameters that we
205: used in Paper~I for the day~+24 spectrum of the CN SN~1994D:
206: $\tau$(Fe~II)=200, $v_{\rm phot} = 9000$ \kms, and exponential
207: $e$--folding velocity $v_e = 1000$ \kms. Note that the flat case
208: requires a lower value of $v_{\rm phot}$ than the exponential case.
209: While the two synthetic spectra are similar, there are some
210: significant differences, such as the near disappearance in the flat
211: case of the absorption that appears near 5380~\AA\ in the exponential
212: case, and the higher flux peak near 4660~\AA\ in the flat case.
213:
214: \section{ONE WEEK POSTMAX}
215:
216: One week postmax is in the middle of what we referred to in Paper~I as
217: the postmaximum ``Si~II phase'' (from two to 12 days past maximum, for
218: SN~1994D), because the 6100~\AA\ absorption is deep and apparently
219: unblended, at least in its core. At 1 week postmax the spectra are
220: not radically different from at maximum light.
221:
222: Figure~2 shows the 1 week postmax spectra of the CNs. The spectra are
223: very similar. A log plot such as Figure~2 is convenient for comparing
224: multiple spectra at once, but since the spectra are displaced from
225: each other, it can be difficult to appreciate the degree of the
226: homogeneity. Figure~3 directly compares the spectra of SN~1998bu and
227: SN~1996X, to show how strikingly similar these two spectra are. Even
228: the difference at the red end of the SN~1998bu spectrum is not
229: necessarily real, because observed spectra sometimes have problems at
230: their ends, and also because the local normalization technique can
231: mildly warp the ends of the spectra (Jeffery et~al. 2007).
232:
233: An example SYNOW fit is shown in Figure~4. The fit is to the spectrum
234: of the CN SN~1996X (selected because it is the best spectrum of
235: Figure~2, not because it is the best fit). The fitting parameters for
236: SN~1996X (and other selected spectra of Figure~2) are in Table~2.
237: Apart from the flat optical depth distribution, the fit of Figure~4 is
238: a conventional one. The ions are the same as were used for the 1 week
239: postmax spectrum of SN~1994D in Paper~I, except that here Cr~II also
240: is included. Lines of O~I, Si~II, S~II, Ca~II, and Fe~II produce most
241: of the features in the synthetic spectrum, and we are confident that
242: these ions are present in the observed spectrum. The presence in the
243: observed spectrum of Na~I, Mg~II, Cr~II, Fe~III, and Co~II is not
244: definite, but we use them in the synthetic spectrum because they are
245: plausible and they improve the fit.
246:
247: The three main discrepancies in Figure~4 are familiar problems with
248: SYNOW fits. First, for Ca~II we choose parameters to fit the observed
249: IR3 feature, because it is less blended and more sensitive to optical
250: depth than the H and K feature; in this case, this causes the
251: synthetic H and K absorption to be too strong. Second, the flux
252: minimum from about 6900 to 7100~\AA\ has no counterpart in the
253: synthetic spectrum. The only identification that we can suggest is
254: [O~II] \lam\lam7320,7330, which was discussed in the context of
255: SN~1991T by Fisher et~al. (1999) and of the Type~Ic SN~1994I by
256: Millard et~al. (1999). However, at later epochs this discrepancy
257: becomes stronger, and invoking [O~II] to solve it would imply
258: excessive mass and kinetic energy of oxygen (at least for an exploding
259: white dwarf). More likely, what we are seeing in Figure~4 is an
260: early, mild manifestation of a discrepancy that is due to our
261: simplifying assumption of resonant scattering. Third, the synthetic
262: spectrum lacks absorption from about 7600 to 7800~\AA. The observed
263: absorption in this region presumably is due to Mg~II \lam7890, blended
264: with O~I \lam7772, but in SYNOW spectra the synthetic absorption
265: usually is too blue, even when Mg~II is undetached, as it is here.
266:
267: Most of the spectra of Figure~2 are so similar that it is not worth
268: reporting fitting parameters for every spectrum. The exception is
269: SN~2004S, which has much stronger high velocity Ca~II absorption than
270: the others. Krisciunas et~al. (2007) termed SN~2004S a clone of
271: SN~2001el, another CN with exceptionally strong high velocity Ca~II
272: features (Wang et~al. 2003; Kasen et~al. 2003; Mattila et~al. 2005;
273: Paper~II). Krisciunas et~al. noted that at maximum light SN~2004S had
274: an unusually low Si~II absorption blueshift for a spectrum containing
275: the usual SN~Ia features, and that the blueshift decreased more
276: rapidly than in SN~2001el. We find that at 1 week postmax, all
277: absorptions other than those of Ca~II are less blueshifted than in the
278: other spectra of Figure~2; consequently our fit for SN~2004S has a low
279: value of $v_{\rm phot}= 7000$ \kms\ (Table~2), instead of 11,000 \kms\ as
280: used for the others of Figure~2.
281:
282: Figure~5 shows the 1 week postmax spectra of the BLs (plus the
283: spectrum of the CN SN~1996X for comparison). At this epoch the
284: spectrum of SN~2002er is like that of a CN. SN~1992A retains some of
285: its BL characteristics and remains mildly different from CN. The
286: spectra of SN~2002bf, SN~2006X, and SN~1984A are obviously different
287: from CN, but similar to each other. Their 6100~\AA\ absorptions are
288: deeper, broader, and more blueshifted, and they have deep absorptions
289: from about 4700 to 5100~\AA. A fit to SN~2002bf is shown in Figure~6.
290: The 6100~\AA\ absorption and the deep absorption from 4700 to
291: 5100~\AA\ are matched by using a high $v_{\rm max}$ of 21,000 \kms\
292: for Si~II and Fe~II, compared to a typical value of 15,000 \kms\ for
293: the CNs at 1 week postmax. The Fe~II features of SN~2005bf are so
294: prominent that it is difficult to determine whether lines of Mg~II,
295: Fe~III, and Co~II are present.
296:
297: The 1 week postmax spectra of the CLs are shown in Figure~7. At this
298: epoch SN~1989B is like that of a CN and SN~2004eo is only mildly
299: different. The spectrum of the extreme CL SN~1999by, a
300: SN~1991bg--like (Garnavich et~al. 2004), is more highly evolved than
301: the others of the 1 week postmax sample, in fact it has more in common
302: with the 3 week postmax spectra of the CNs than with their 1 week
303: postmax spectra. A fit for SN~1999by is shown in Figure~8. The
304: presence of Si~II, Ca~II, Ti~II, and Fe~II is definite, while Mg~I,
305: Sc~II, and Cr~II are plausible and improve the fit. There are three
306: main discrepancies. First, the synthetic absorption near 5340~\AA,
307: produced by Cr~II, is not deep enough, even though Cr~II is too strong
308: in several other places. (A corresponding feature in the CNs of the 3
309: week postmax sample is discussed in \S~4.) Second, the observed
310: absorption near 5820~\AA\ has practically no counterpart in the
311: synthetic spectrum. The only identification we can offer is Si~II
312: \lam5972, but it hardly appears in the synthetic spectrum even though
313: the absorption feature of the \lam 6355 Si~II reference line is too
314: strong. Third, the synthetic flux peaks near 4000 and 4600~\AA\ are
315: too high; this may be a consequence of the flat optical depth
316: distribution (see the 4600~\AA\ peak in Figure~1.) Our present SYNOW
317: fit differs from the one presented in Garnavich et~al. in that we do
318: not use Ca~I, Ti~II makes no significant contribution to the synthetic
319: spectrum at wavelengths longer than 5300~\AA, and we do invoke Mg~I,
320: Sc~II, and Cr~II.
321:
322: Figure~9 shows the 1 week postmax spectra of the SSs. SN~2006gz is
323: intermediate between the CN SN~1996X and the SS SN~1999aa, which has
324: weaker Si~II, S~II, and Ca~II absorptions. Hicken et~al. (2007)
325: identified C~II in spectra of SN~2006gz obtained 10 or more days
326: before maximum light, after which the feature was not identifiable,
327: consistent with the lack of evidence for C~II in the spectrum shown in
328: Figure~9. The direct comparison of SN~1999ac and SN~1996X in
329: Figure~10 is interesting. SN~1999ac has Si~II and S~II absorptions
330: that are less blueshifted than in SN~1996X, but Fe~II features from
331: 4700 to 5100~\AA\ that are more blueshifted. A fit for SN~1999ac is
332: shown in Figure~11. The presence of O~I, Si~II, S~II, Ca~II, and
333: Fe~II in SN~1999ac is definite; Na~I, Mg~II and Fe~III are plausible.
334: To account for the above mentioned peculiarity, we use a low
335: photospheric velocity of 6000 \kms\ and a higher $v_{\rm max}$ for
336: Fe~II (15,000 \kms) than for most of the other ions (see Table~2).
337: The spectra of SN~1999ac have been discussed extensively by Garavini
338: et~al. (2005). They emphasized the unusually low Si~II blueshift,
339: consistent with our use of a low photospheric velocity. They also
340: concluded that Fe~II lines formed at unusually low velocities, but our
341: $v_{\rm max}$ of 15,000 \kms\ is the same as we use for the CN
342: SN~1996X.
343:
344: The Ca~II IR3 feature of SN~2000cx obviously differs from the others
345: of Figure~9. Otherwise, the closest match to SN~2000cx is SN~1999aa,
346: but there are conspicuous differences. The fit for SN~2000cx shown in
347: Figure~12 is unusual because, as in Paper~II, we resort to detached
348: high--velocity Ti~II, Cr~II, and Fe~II. In fact, in the synthetic
349: spectrum most of the photospheric features are at least mildly
350: detached (Table~2). Still, the fit is not very good. Although the
351: synthetic Ca~II H and K absorption is much too strong, the IR3 does
352: not appear. The observed multicomponent absorption of the IR3 has
353: been discussed by Li et~al. (2001), Wang et~al. (2003), Kasen
354: et~al. (2003), and Thomas et~al. (2004), and is known to have involved
355: asymmetrical structures at high velocity.
356:
357: \section{THREE WEEKS POSTMAX}
358:
359: Three weeks postmax is in the middle of what we referred to in Paper~I
360: as the ``Si~II--to--Fe~II transition phase'' (from 14 to 28 days past
361: maximum, for SN~1994D) because the core of the 6100~\AA\ absorption is
362: present but flanked by strengthening Fe~II features. The 3 week
363: postmax spectra are very different from the 1 week postmax spectra.
364:
365: Figure~13 shows the 3 week postmax spectra of the CNs, and a fit for
366: SN~1996X is shown in Figure~14. The ions are the same as were used
367: for SN~1994D at comparable epochs in Paper~I. Apart from the Ca~II
368: and Na~I features, the dominant ion is Fe~II, but Si~II, Cr~II, and to
369: a lesser extent Co~II are also needed. Fitting parameters for
370: SN~1996X and other selected spectra of the 3 week postmax sample are
371: given in Table~3.
372:
373: The degree of homogeneity in Figure~13 is very high, except in two
374: respects. First, SN~2001el and SN~2004S still have strong high
375: velocity Ca~II H and K absorptions (and most of the absorption
376: features of SN~2004S continue to be somewhat less blueshifted than in
377: the others). Second, the relative heights of the flux peaks that
378: flank the 5350~\AA\ absorption are not all the same. The relative
379: heights of these two peaks were discussed in Paper~I: in SN~1994D the
380: ratio of the peak on the right of the 5350~\AA\ absorption to the peak
381: on the left increased steadily from day~+15, when the peaks were
382: roughly equally high, to day~+28, when the peak on the right was much
383: higher. Our fits accounted nicely for this evolution, in terms of
384: strengthening Fe~II and Cr~II lines. In this respect, some of the
385: spectra of Figure~13 appear to be spectroscopically ``earlier'' than
386: some of the others. For example, the day~+21 spectrum of SN~1998aq
387: (Fig.~13) has equally high peaks, like the day~+15 spectrum of
388: SN~1994D (Paper~I), and closely resembles that spectrum in other
389: respects also. Even CN spectra can get mildly out of phase, with
390: respect to the time of B--band maximum.
391:
392: The 3 week postmax spectra of the BLs are shown in Figure~15. At this
393: epoch SN~1981B is like CN and so is SN~2002er, apart from its deep
394: high velocity Ca~II H and K absorption (which is not matched by the
395: appearance of the IR3 absorption). Even the extreme BL SN~1984A
396: appears to differ only mildly from CN, although the limited wavelength
397: coverage does not allow us to see how the Ca~II lines are behaving.
398:
399: Figure~16 shows the 3 week postmax spectra of the CLs. At this epoch
400: SN~1989B and SN~2004eo are like CN. SN~1986G remains mildly
401: different, e.g., its 5750~\AA\ absorption is shallow, and the ratio of
402: the flux peaks flanking the 5350~\AA\ absorption is very large.
403: SN~1991bg continues to show obvious differences. A fit for SN~1991bg
404: is shown in Figure~17. All 7 ions used in the synthetic spectrum are
405: considered to be definite. In the blue the synthetic spectrum is a
406: complex blend of Ti~II, Cr~II, and Fe~II. Not only does SN~1991bg
407: have Ti~II while CNs do not, but also Cr~II plays a more important
408: role than it does in the CNs.
409:
410: The 3 week postmax spectra of the SSs are shown in Figure~18.
411: SN~1999ee is similar to CN, although with a strong high velocity Ca~II
412: H and K absorption. SN~1999aa also is similar to CN except for the
413: spectroscopically ``early'' ratio of the flux peaks flanking the
414: 5350~\AA\ absorption. In this respect, as in others, the day~+19
415: spectrum of SN~1999aa in Figure~18 is a good match to the day~+14
416: spectrum of SN~1994D (Paper~I).
417:
418: As shown in previous papers (Chornock et~al. 2006; Phillips
419: et~al. 2007; Stanishev et~al. 2007), at multiple epochs the spectra of
420: SN~2002cx and SN~2005hk are very similar. In Figure~18, the spectra
421: of both have been artifically blueshifted by 5000 \kms, to
422: approximately align their absorption features with those of the other
423: SSs. The direct comparison in Figure~19 of SN~2005hk and the CN
424: SN~1996X shows that although the features of SN~2005hk are narrower,
425: when the spectrum of SN~2005hk is artificially blueshifted, the
426: features of the two spectra show a strong correspondence. Not only
427: the absorptions but also the flux peaks match up well. If the flux
428: peaks of SN~2005hk were true emission peaks, at the rest wavelengths
429: of the lines that produce them, then after the blueshifting, the peaks
430: would be bluer than those of SN~1996X. This is in accord with the
431: maxim that in heavily blended resonance--scattering spectra,
432: ``absorptions trump emissions'', i.e., flux peaks do not necessarily
433: occur at the rest wavelengths of the strongest lines, because they are
434: strongly influenced by absorption components of mainly redward lines.
435: Figure~20 shows a fit to the (not artificially blueshifted) spectrum
436: of SN~2005hk. The ions used are the same ones as used for the 3 week
437: postmax spectrum of the CN SN~1996X, except that Si~II is not needed
438: for SN~2005hk. Note that it is not $v_{\rm phot}$, but $v_{\rm max}$
439: for Cr~II, Fe~II, and Co~II that differs by 5000 \kms\ from that of
440: SN~1996X (Table~2). Apart from the two Ca~II features and the one
441: Na~I feature, the synthetic spectrum is a complex blend of Fe~II,
442: Cr~II, and Co~II, just as it is for SN~1996X.
443:
444: As can be seen in Figure~18, at this epoch SN~2000cx remains different
445: from CN in several ways, e.g., the peaks that appear near 4800 and
446: 4920~\AA\ in SN~1996X are smeared out in SN~2000cx. In this respect,
447: SN~2000cx resembles the BL SN~2002bf of the 1 week premax sample
448: (\S~2). To fit the spectrum of SN~2000cx we use a high maximum
449: velocity of 18,000 \kms\ for Fe~II and Cr~II (Table~2). A discussion
450: of SYNOW fits to day +15 and +32 spectra, which have better wavelength
451: coverage, can be found in Branch et~al. (2004).
452:
453: \section{THREE MONTHS POSTMAX}
454:
455: Three months postmax is within what we referred to in Paper~I as the
456: ``Fe~II phase'' (from 50 to 115 days after maximum for SN~1994D, with
457: these particular limiting epochs being determined by the availability
458: of spectra) because the 6100~\AA\ absorption is nearly gone at 50 days
459: and the spectrum is mainly shaped by Fe~II lines. The 3 months
460: postmax spectra are quite different from the 3 weeks postmax spectra.
461: The spectra of the five CNs (Fig.~21) are very much alike. It is
462: often assumed that at this epoch the spectrum is composed of optically
463: thin, collisionally excited forbidden lines, but the SYNOW fit for
464: SN~2003du in Figure~22 is good enough to firmly establish that
465: whatever the underlying source of the emission, permitted lines of
466: Na~I, Ca~II, and Fe~II are mainly responsible for shaping the spectrum
467: (see also the discussion in Paper~I). However, our fit is very poor
468: from 6600 to 7800~\AA. It may be that the broad flux minimum near
469: 6750~\AA\ is not an absorption feature, and that the flux peaks from
470: 7270 to 7700 are produced by strong net emission. Bowers
471: et~al. (1997) modeled the day~+95 optical spectrum (along with the
472: day~92 infrared spectrum) of SN~1995D assuming that the spectrum
473: consists only of forbidden--line emissions. Their identifications of
474: the flux peaks are shown in Figure~22 (SN~1995D and SN~2003du have the
475: same peaks, and for some of the peaks Bowers et~al. did not suggest
476: identifications). In the blue, the Bowers et~al. fit was not
477: successful. However, our poor fit from 6600 to 7800~\AA\ may signal
478: that in this wavelength range forbidden emission lines are emerging
479: without strong modification by permitted--line scattering. On the
480: other hand, if we make the Fe~II lines stronger, thereby making our
481: fit worse in the blue, we do begin to obtain a better fit in the 6600
482: to 7800~\AA\ interval. This could be a consequence of a wavelength
483: dependent variation in the depth of the photosphere. At present, line
484: identifications in this wavelength range are uncertain.
485:
486: At this epoch the four BL events of the 3 months postmax sample
487: (Fig.~23), including the extreme BL SN~2006X, are similar to CN.
488:
489: Among the CLs (Fig.~24), SN~1989B is like CN, SN~1986G differs mildly,
490: and the extreme CL SN~1991bg remains distinctly different. The fit
491: for SN~1991bg in Figure~25 shows that permitted--line scattering,
492: mainly by Fe~II, shapes the spectrum in the blue, but the fit fails
493: from 6000 to 8000~\AA. The only clear evidence for forbidden lines is
494: the strong emission near 7250~\AA, due to [Ca~II] (Filippenko
495: et~al. 1992a).
496:
497: At this epoch the probable SS SN~1995D and the extreme SS SN~1991T
498: (Fig.~26) are like CN, and even the maverick SN~2000cx is only mildly
499: different.
500:
501: \section{DISCUSSION}
502:
503: The spectra that appear in this series of papers are simply the good
504: spectra that are available to us, so the samples are affected not only
505: by observational bias in favor of supernovae that are bright and have
506: slowly declining light curves, but also by the observer bias in favor
507: of obtaining and publishing spectra of unusual events. Nevertheless,
508: these samples clearly indicate a trend toward increasing spectroscopic
509: conformity at later epochs. Among the 24 SNe~Ia of the maximum light
510: sample (Paper~II), only 7 were admitted to the (by construction)
511: highly homogeneous CN group. By contrast, of the 12 SNe~Ia of the 3
512: months postmax sample, only SN~1991bg is distinctly different from the
513: CNs. (SN~2002cx--likes would be different too, if they were in the
514: sample.) This spectroscopic convergence suggests that although the
515: outer layers of SNe~Ia are diverse in various ways, the deep layers of
516: most SNe~Ia are fundamentally the same.
517:
518: In this paper, the line identifications for the CNs are much like they
519: were in Paper~I for SN~1994D, although the fitting parameters are
520: different because of our present use of flat optical depth
521: distributions. The conclusion that permitted lines strongly affect
522: the spectrum as late as 3 months postmax leads to a caveat to the
523: statement above that the deep layers of most SNe~Ia are fundamentally
524: the same: at three months postmax the strongest permitted lines are
525: strong, which entails line profile saturation and a limited
526: sensitivity of the spectra to physical differences in the ejecta. If
527: the spectra of the 3 months postmax sample consisted simply of
528: optically thin forbidden emission lines, saturation would not be an
529: issue and the observed spectroscopic homogeneity would imply a
530: startling (unbelievable?) degree of physical homogeneity. The degree
531: of diversity should increase at still later times as the permitted
532: lines weaken and the forbidden lines emerge unscathed. The transition
533: from resonance--scattering to forbidden--line dominated spectra will
534: be the subject of a future paper.
535:
536: As in previous papers of this series, we find that the BL SNe~Ia have
537: essentially the same line identifications as the CNs, but with more
538: line optical depth at high velocities. The distinct characteristics
539: of the extreme BL events SN~1984A, SN~2002bf, and SN~2006X at 1 week
540: postmax raises the issue of whether they are a discrete subgroup, but
541: only in terms of the properties of their outer layers. There is no
542: evidence that their deep layers are unusual: by 3 months postmax,
543: SN~2006X was like a CN.
544:
545: The spectrum of the extreme CL SN~1991bg has been thought to have
546: undergone an early transition to the nebular phase (Filippenko
547: et~al. 1992a; Leibundgut et~al. 1993; Turatto et~al. 1996; Mazzali
548: et~al. 1997). According to our interpretation (Fig.~17) there is no
549: need to appeal to forbidden lines in the 3 week postmax spectrum
550: (Fig. 17), and even in the 3 month postmax spectrum the only obvious
551: one is [Ca~II] \lam\lam7291, 7324. In spite of its peculiarities, the
552: spectrum of SN~1991bg does increasingly resemble the spectra of other
553: SNe~Ia after maximum light, and in all respects SN~1986G appears to be
554: a link between SN~1991bg--likes and normal SNe~Ia. As discussed in
555: Paper~I, the spectroscopic peculiarities of SN~1991bg--likes may
556: largely (but not entirely) reflect a temperature threshold below which
557: key ionization ratios change abruptly. The issue of whether
558: SN~1991bg--likes are a distinct subgroup remains open.
559:
560: The 1 week and 3 week postmax spectra of the SS SN~2000cx are unique
561: among SNe~Ia observed so far. Our identifications of high velocity
562: Ti~II and especially Cr~II are not definite, but for nonstandard
563: spectra, nonstandard identifications are to be expected, and no
564: alternative identifications have been suggested. The resemblance of
565: the 3 months postmax spectrum of SN~2000cx to CNs suggests, though,
566: that its deeper layers are like those of other SNe~Ia. The
567: SN~2002cx-likes, on the other hand, appear to be radically different
568: from other SNe~Ia, even in their deeper layers. Pending the discovery
569: of SNe~Ia having less mild SN~2002cx--like properties, the
570: SN~2002cx--likes appear to be a discrete subgroup. Yet the
571: resemblance of their spectra, when artificially blueshifted, to other
572: SNe~Ia (Fig.~19) suggests kinship.\footnote{An anonymous referee
573: points out that another possible discrete subgroup could be SNe~Ia
574: that have very slow light curve decline rates, such as SN~2001ay
575: (Howell \& Nugent 2004), SN~2003fg (Howell et~al. 2006), and SN~2006gz
576: (Hicken et~al. 2007). Subclassifying SNe~Ia by means of photometric
577: characteristics is beyond the scope of this paper, but we note that in
578: our spectroscopic classification scheme, SN~2001ay is broad line
579: (Paper~II) while SN~2003fg (Paper~III) and SN~2006gz (this paper) are
580: shallow silicon.}
581:
582: Although this series of papers is confined to spectroscopy, it is
583: worth emphasizing that the spectroscopic diversity is bound to
584: contribute to the photometric diversity. Branch et~al. (2004)
585: discussed the effects of the putative high velocity Ti~II of SN~2000cx
586: on the evolution its $B-V$ color. Another good example is the 1 week
587: postmax spectra of the extreme BLs SN~2002bf, SN~1984A, and SN~2006X
588: (Figures 5 and 6). The deep Fe~II absorption from 4700 to 5100~\AA,
589: near the interesection of the B and V bands, throws flux right into
590: the peak of the V band (thus obscuring the S~II absorptions) and is
591: bound to affect the B-V color evolution, with implications for
592: attempts to estimate the interstellar extinction on the basis of broad
593: band photometry (e.g., Wang et~al. 2007 for SN~2006X).
594:
595: In recent years it has been shown (Mannucci et~al. 2005, 2006;
596: Scannapieco \& Bildsten 2005; Sullivan et~al. 2006) that some SNe~Ia,
597: called prompt, are produced by a young ($\sim 10^8$ yr) stellar
598: population while others, called tardy, are produced by an older
599: population (several Gyr). Most the SNe~Ia that have ever occurred
600: were prompt, but at the present epoch most of the SNe~Ia at low
601: redshift are tardy. This raises the question of which of our
602: spectroscopic groups are prompt and which are tardy. Since the
603: extreme CL events such as SN~1991bg tend to occur in old populations
604: and the extreme SS events such as SN~1991T tend to occur in young
605: populations (Sullivan et~al. 2006 and references therein), if we are
606: to break our groups into a minority of prompts and a majority of
607: tardies, then the members of the SS group should tend to be prompts
608: and the members of the other three groups tend to be tardies. Yet
609: there is no obvious spectroscopic separation between the SS group and
610: the CN group. The CN group was defined to emphasize the strong
611: spectroscopic homogeneity of its members, but several of the SSs
612: (e.g., SN~1999ee, SN~1999ac, SN~1999aa) are not very different from
613: CN. As discussed in Paper~II, it may be that there are two
614: evolutionary paths to SNe~Ia that require different amounts of time
615: but produce two families of SNe~Ia that have overlapping distributions
616: of their properties.
617:
618: That being said, Quimby et~al. (2007) suggested that even among normal
619: SNe~Ia (in the broad sense of the term) there may be two distinct
620: classes of events: those that have a smoothly declining density
621: distribution in their outer layers and therefore show a blueshift of
622: the 6100~\AA\ absorption that decreases smoothly with time, and those
623: in which silicon is largely confined to a shell--like density
624: structure and therefore have a more constant blueshift of the
625: 6100~\AA\ absorption. The smooth density structure is characteristic
626: of deflagration and delayed detonation models, while a shell is
627: characteristic of pulsating delayed detonation and tamped detonation
628: models. The suggestion of Quimby et~al. was motivated by a prolonged
629: period of nearly constant blueshift in SN~2005hj, but they point out
630: that some other SNe~Ia such as SN~1999aa and SN~2000cx are similar in
631: this respect. In our classification, these three events are SS. More
632: well observed SS and CN SNe~Ia are needed to determine whether SS and
633: CN SNe~Ia are distinctly different in this respect.
634:
635: SYNOW is useful for establishing line identifications and information
636: on the velocity intervals in which the lines are forming, but it is no
637: substitute for detailed calculations of spectra of hydrodynamical
638: models. At present no 1D explosion model has been to shown to account
639: well for the observed spectral evolution, not even for the CNs (Baron
640: et~al. 2006). Spectropolarimetry and explosion modeling tells us that
641: asymmetries are present, but the spectra of 3D explosion models cannot
642: yet even be calculated in full detail (although a start has been made
643: by calculating the spectra of 3D models for angle averaged
644: compositions; Baron et~al. 2007). The homogeneity of the CNs shows
645: that there is a standard, repeatable SN~Ia explosion model that does
646: not have large compositional inhomogeneities near or below the maximum
647: photospheric velocity of about 12,000 \kms\ --- but what is this
648: model? And there are many additional questions, such as: what
649: variation on the CN model is responsible for the extra high velocity
650: matter in the BLs, and the putative bizarre high velocity features of
651: SN~2000cx, and the distinctive properties of the SN~2002cx--likes? We
652: have hardly begun on the path toward understanding the various
653: manifestions of spectroscopic diversity of SNe~Ia.
654:
655: We are grateful to all observers who have provided spectra. This work
656: has been supported by NSF grants AST 0506028 and AST 0707704, NASA
657: LTSA grant NNG04GD36G, and DOE grant DEFG02-07ER41517.
658:
659: \clearpage
660:
661: \begin{references}
662:
663: %\reference{} Anupama, G. C, Sahu, D. K., \& Jose, J. 2005, A\&A, 429, 667
664:
665: \reference{} Barbon, R., Iijima, T., \& Rosino, L. 1989, A\&A, 220, 83
666:
667: \reference{} Baron, E., Bongard, S., Branch, D., \&
668: Hauschildt,~P.~H. 2006, ApJ, 645, 480
669:
670: \reference{} Baron, E., Jeffery, D. J, \& Branch, D., Bravo,~E.,
671: Garcia--Senz,~D., \& Hauschildt,~P.~H., 2007, ApJ, in press
672: (arXiv:0709.4177)
673:
674: %\reference{} Baron, E., Lentz, E. J., \& Hauschildt, P. H. 2003, ApJ,
675: %588, L29
676:
677: \reference{} Benetti, S., \& Mendes de Oliveira, C. 1995, IAU
678: Circ. No.~6135
679:
680: \reference{} Benetti, S., et al. 2004, MNRAS, 348, 261
681:
682: \reference{} Benetti, S., et al. 2005, ApJ, 623, 1011
683:
684: %\reference{} Blondin, S., et al. 2006, ApJ, 131, 1648
685:
686: \reference{} Bowers, E., et al. 1997, MNRAS, 290, 663
687:
688: %\reference{} Branch, D. 1987, ApJ, 316, L81
689:
690: \reference{} Branch, D., et~al. 1983, ApJ, 270, 123
691:
692: \reference{} Branch, D., Baron, E., Hall,~N., Melakayil,~M., \&
693: Parrent,~J. 2005, PASP, 117, 545 (Paper~I)
694:
695: %\reference{} Branch, D., Lacy, M. L., McCall, M. L.,
696: %Sutherland,~P.~G., Uomoto,~A., Wheeler,~J.~C., \& Wills,~B.~J. 1983,
697: %ApJ, 270, 123
698:
699: %\reference{} Branch, D., \& van den Bergh, S. 1993, AJ, 105, 2231
700:
701: \reference{} Branch, D., et al. 2003, AJ, 126, 1489
702:
703: %\reference{} -----. 2004a, ApJ, 606, 413
704:
705: \reference{} -----. 2004, PASP, 116, 903
706:
707: \reference{} -----. 2006, PASP, 118, 560 (Paper~II)
708:
709: \reference{} -----. 2007, PASP, 119, 709 (Paper~III)
710:
711: %\reference{} Bravo, E., \& Garcia--Senz, D. 2006, ApJ, 642, L157
712:
713: \reference{} Chornock, D., Filippenko, A. V., Branch, D.,
714: Foley,~R.~J., Jha,~S., \& Li,~W. 2006, PASP, 118, 722
715:
716: %\reference{} Chugai, N. N. 1988, Sov. Astron. Lett., 14(5), 334
717:
718: \reference{} Cristiani, S., et al. 1992, A\&A, 259, 63
719:
720: %\reference{} Dessart, L., \& Hillier, D. J. 2005, A\&A, 437, 667
721:
722: \reference{} Elias--Rosa, N., et al. 2006, MNRAS, 369, 1880
723:
724: \reference{} Filippenko, A. V., et al. 1992a, AJ, 104, 1543
725:
726: %\reference{} -----. 1992b, ApJ, 384, L15
727:
728: \reference{} Filippenko, A. V. 1997, in Proc. NATO Advanced Study
729: Institute, Thermonuclear Supernovae, ed. P.~Ruiz--Lapuente, R.~Canal,
730: \& J.~Isern (Dordrecht: Kluwer), 1
731:
732: \reference{} Fisher, A., Branch, D., Hatano, K., \& Baron,~E. 1999,
733: MNRAS, 304, 67
734:
735: %\reference{} Fisher, A., Branch, D., Nugent, P., \& Baron,~E. 1997,
736: %ApJ, 481, L89
737:
738: %\reference{} Follatelli et~al. 200?
739:
740: %\reference{} Gallagher, J. S., Garnavich, P. M., Berlind, P.,
741: %Challis,~P., Jha,~S., \& Kirshner,~R.~P. 2005, ApJ, in press
742:
743: \reference{} Garavini, G., et al. 2004, AJ, 128, 387
744:
745: \reference{} -----. 2005, AJ, 130, 2278
746:
747: %\reference{} -----. 2007, A\&A, in press
748:
749: \reference{} Garnavich, P. M., et al. 2004, ApJ, 613, 1120
750:
751: %\reference{} Gerardy, C., et al. 2004, ApJ, 607, 391
752:
753: %\reference{} Gomez, G., Lopez, R., \& Sanchez, F. 1996, AJ, 112, 2094
754:
755: \reference{} Gomez, G., \& Lopez, R. 1998, AJ, 115, 1096
756:
757: \reference{} Hamuy, M., et al. 2002, AJ, 124, 417
758:
759: %\reference{} -----. 2003, Nature, 424, 651
760:
761: %\reference{} Hatano, K., Branch, D., Fisher, A., Baron,~E., \&
762: %Filippenko,~A.~V. 1999b, ApJ, 525, 881
763:
764: %\reference{} Hatano, K., Branch, D., Fisher, A., Millard,~J., \&
765: %Baron,~E. 1999a, ApJS, 121, 233
766:
767: %\reference{} Hatano, K., Branch, D., Qiu, Y. L., Baron,~E.,
768: %Thielemann,~F.-K., \& Fisher, A. 2002, New Astr., 7, 441
769:
770: %\reference{} Hernandez, M., et al. 2000, MNRAS, 319, 223
771:
772: \reference{} Hicken, M., Garnavich, P. M., Prieto, J. L., Blondin,~S.,
773: DePoy,~D.~L., Kirshner,~R.~P., \& Parrent,~J., ApJ, 669, 17
774:
775: %\reference{} Hillebrandt, W., Sim, S. A., \& R\"opke,~F.~K. 2007,
776: %A\&A, in press
777:
778: %\reference{} H\"oflich, P., Gerardy, C. L., Fesen, R. A., \&
779: %Sakai,~S. 2002, ApJ, 568, 791
780:
781: %\reference{} H\"oflich, P., Wheeler, J. C., \& Thielemann,~F.-K. 1998,
782: %ApJ, 495, 617
783:
784: %\reference{} Howell, D. A. 2001, ApJ, 554, L193
785:
786: %\reference{} Howell, D. A., H\"oflich, P., Wang, L., \&
787: %Wheeler,~J.~C. 2001, ApJ, 556, 302
788:
789: \reference{} Howell, D. A., \& Nugent, P. 2004, in Cosmic Explosions
790: in Three Dimensions, eds. P.~H\"oflich, P.~Kumar, \& J.~C.~Wheeler
791: (Cambridge, CUP), p. 151
792:
793: \reference{} Howell, D. A., et~al. 2006, Nature, 443, 308
794:
795: %\reference{} Jeffery, D. J. \& Branch, D. 1990, in Supernovae,
796: %eds. J.~C.~Wheeler, T.~Piran, \& S.~Weinberg (Singapore: World
797: %Scientific), 149
798:
799: %\reference{} Jeffery, D. J., Branch, D., \& Baron, E. 2007a, ApJ,
800: %submitted; astro--ph/0609804
801:
802: \reference{} Jeffery, D. J., Ketchum, W., Branch, D., Baron,~E.,
803: Elmhamdi,~A., \& Danziger,~I.~J. 2007, ApJS, 171, 493
804:
805: %\reference{} Jeffery, D. J., Leibundgut, B., Kirshner, R. P.,
806: %Benetti,~S., Branch,~D., \& Sonneborn,~G. 1992, ApJ, 397, 304
807:
808: \reference{} Jha, S., et~al. 1999, ApJS, 125, 73
809:
810: %\reference{} Jha, S., et~al. 2006, AJ, 132, 189
811:
812: %\reference{} Kasen, D., \& Plewa, T. 2005, ApJ, 622, L41
813:
814: %\reference{} Kasen, D., \& Woosley, S. E. 2007, ApJ, 656, 661
815:
816: \reference{} Kasen, D., et al. 2003, ApJ, 593, 788
817:
818: \reference{} Kirshner, R. P., et al. 1993, 415, 589
819:
820: \reference{} Kotak, R., et al. 2006, A\&A, 436, 1021
821:
822: %\reference{} Kozma, C., et~al. 2005, A\&A, 437, 983
823:
824: \reference{} Krisciunas, K., et al. 2007, AJ, 133, 58
825:
826: %\reference{} Kurucz, R. L. 1993, CD-ROM 1, Atomic Data for Opacity
827: %Calculations (Cambridge: SAO)
828:
829: %\reference{} Lentz, E. J., Baron, E., Branch, D., \&
830: %Hauschildt,~P.~H. 2001a, ApJ, 547, 402
831:
832: %\reference{} Lentz, E. J., Baron, E., Branch, D., \&
833: %Hauschildt,~P.~H. 2001b, ApJ, 557, 266
834:
835: %\reference{} Leibundgut, B., Kirshner, R. P., Filippenko, A. V.,
836: %Shields,~J.~S, Foltz,~C.~B., Phillips,~M.~M., \& Sonneborn,~S. 1991,
837: %ApJ, 371, L23
838:
839: \reference{} Leibundgut, B., et al. 1993, AJ, 105, 301
840:
841: \reference{} Leonard, D. C., Li, W., Filippenko, A. V., Foley,~R.~J.,
842: \& Chornock,~R. 2005, ApJ, 632, 450
843:
844: \reference{} Li, W., et al. 1999, AJ, 117, 2709
845:
846: \reference{} -----. 2001, PASP, 113, 1178
847:
848: \reference{} -----. 2003, PASP, 115, 453
849:
850: \reference{} Mannucci, F., Della Valle, M., \& Panagia, N. 2006,
851: MNRAS, 370, 773
852:
853: \reference{} Mannucci, F., et al. 2005, A\&A, 433, 807
854:
855: %\reference{} Marion, G. H., H\"oflich, P., Wheeler,~J.~C.,
856: %Robinson,~E.~L., Gerardy,~C.~L., \& Vacca,~W.~D. 2006, ApJ, 645, 1392
857:
858: \reference{} Mattila, S., et~al. 2005, A\&A, 443, 649
859:
860: %\reference{} Mazzali, P. A. 2000, A\&A, 363, 705
861:
862: %\reference{} Mazzali, P. A. 2001, MNRAS, 321, 341
863:
864: %\reference{} Mazzali, P. A., Benetti, S., \& Hillebrandt, W. 2007,
865: %Science, in press
866:
867: %\reference{} Mazzali, P. A., Danziger, I. J., \& Turatto, M. 1995,
868: %A\&A 297, 509
869:
870: %\reference{} Mazzali, P. A., Lucy, L. B., Danziger, I. J.,
871: %Gouiffes,~C., Cappellaro,~E., \& Turatto,~M. 1993,
872: %A\&A 269, 423
873:
874: \reference{} Mazzali, P. A., et~al. 1997, MNRAS, 284, 151
875:
876: %\reference{} Mazzali, P. A., et~al. 2005a, MNRAS, 357, 200
877:
878: %\reference{} Mazzali, P. A., et~al. 2005b, ApJ, 623, L37
879:
880: %\reference{} McCall, M. L., Reid, N., Bessell, M. S., \&
881: %Wickramasinghe,~D. 1984, MNRAS, 210, 839
882:
883: %\reference{} Meikle, W. P. S., et al. 1996, MNRAS, 281, 263
884:
885: \reference{} Millard, J., et al. 1999, ApJ, 527, 746
886:
887: %\reference{} Nugent, P., Phillips, M. M., Baron, E., Branch,~D., \&
888: %Hauschildt,~P.~H. 1995, ApJ, 455, L147
889:
890: %\reference{} Parrent, J., et al. 2007, PASP, 119, 135
891:
892: \reference{} Pastorello et~al. 2007, MNRAS, 377, 1531
893:
894: \reference{} Patat, F., et~al. 1996, MNRAS, 278, 111
895:
896: %\reference{} Phillips, M. M. 1979, ApJS, 39, 377
897:
898: %\reference{} Phillips, M. M., Lira, P., Suntzeff, N. B.,
899: %Schommer,~R.~A., Hamuy,~M., \& Maza,~J. 1999, AJ,
900: %118, 1766
901:
902: %\reference{} Phillips, M. M., Wells, L. A., Suntzeff, N. B.,
903: %Hamuy,~M., Leibundgut,~B., Kirshner,~R.~P., \& Foltz,~C.~B. 1992, AJ,
904: %103, 1632
905:
906: %\reference{} Phillips, M. M. 1993, ApJ, 413, L105
907:
908: \reference{} Phillips, M. M., et al. 2007, PASP, 119, 360
909:
910: %\reference{} Plewa, T., Calder, A. C., \& Lamb, D. Q. 2004, ApJ, 612,
911: %L37
912:
913: %\reference{} Quimby, R., et al. 2006, ApJ, 636, 400
914:
915: \reference{} Quimby, R., H\"oflich, P., \& Wheeler, J.~C., ApJ, 666,
916: 1083
917:
918: %\reference{} Riess, A. G., et al. 1999, AJ, 118, 2675
919:
920: %\reference{} Ruiz--Lapuente, P., Cappellaro, E., Turatto, M.,
921: %Gouiffes,~C., Danziger,~I.~J., Della Valle, M., \& Lucy,~L.~B. 1992,
922: %ApJ, 387, L33
923:
924: \reference{} Sadakane, K., et al. 1996, PASJ, 48, 51
925:
926: \reference{} Salvo, M. E., Cappellaro, E., Mazzali, P. A.,
927: Benetti,~S., Danziger,~I.~J., Pata,~F., \& Turatto,~M. 2001, MNRAS,
928: 321, 254
929:
930: \reference{} Scannapieco, E., \& Bildsten, L. 2005, ApJ, 629, L85
931:
932: \reference{} Stanishev, V., et al. 2007, in preparation
933:
934: %\reference{} Stehle, M., Mazzali, P. A., Benetti, S., \&
935: %Hillebrandt,~W. 2005, MNRAS, 360, 1231
936:
937: \reference{} Sullivan, M., et al. 2006, ApJ, 648, 868
938:
939: %\reference{} Tanaka, M., Mazzali, P. A., Maeda, K., \&
940: %Nomoto,~K. 2006, ApJ, 645, 470
941:
942: \reference{} Thomas, R. C., Branch, D., Baron, E., Nomoto,~K., Li,~W., \&
943: Filippenko,~A.~V. 2004, ApJ, 601, 1019
944:
945: %\reference{} Thomas, R. C., et~al. 2007, ApJ, 654, L53
946:
947: \reference{} Turatto, M., et al. 1996, MNRAS, 283, 1
948:
949: %\reference{} Turatto, M., Piemonte, A., Benetti, S., Cappellaro,~E.,
950: %Mazzali,~P.~A., Danziger,~I.~J., \& Patat,~F. 1998, ApJ, 116, 2431
951:
952: %\reference{} Valentini, G., et al. 2003, 595, 779
953:
954: %\reference{} Wang, L., Howell, D. A., H\"oflich, P, \&
955: %Wheeler,~J.~C. 2001, ApJ, 550, 1030
956:
957: \reference{} Wang, L., et al. 2003, ApJ, 591, 1110
958:
959: \reference{} Wang, X., et al. 2007, ApJ, in press (arXiv:0708.0140)
960:
961: %\reference{} Wegner, G., \& McMahan, R. K. 1987, AJ, 92, 287
962:
963: \reference{} Wells, L. A., et al. 1994, AJ, 108, 2233
964:
965: %\reference{} Wood--Vasey, W. M., et~al. 2004, New Astr. Rev., 48, 637
966:
967: \end{references}
968:
969: \clearpage
970:
971: \begin{figure}
972: \includegraphics[width=.8\textwidth,angle=270]{f1.eps}
973: \caption{Synthetic spectra for Fe~II with flat ({\sl solid line}) and
974: exponential ({\sl dashed line}) optical depth distributions are
975: compared. The parameters for the flat case are $\tau$(Fe~II)=12,
976: $v_{\rm phot} = 6000$ \kms, and $v_{\rm max}=13,000$ \kms. For the
977: exponential case they are $\tau$(Fe~II)=200, $v_{\rm phot} = 9000$ \kms,
978: and $v_e = 1000$ \kms.}
979: \end{figure}
980:
981: \begin{figure}
982: \includegraphics[width=.8\textwidth,angle=0]{f2.eps}
983: \caption{Spectra of the eight CNs of the 1 week postmax
984: sample. The spectra have been flattened according to the local
985: normalization technique of Jeffery et~al. (2007). Vertical
986: displacements are arbitrary and narrow absorptions near 7600\ang\ and
987: 6900\ang\ are telluric. Vertical dashed lines refer to Ca~II
988: \lam3945, Fe~II \lam5018, Si~II \lam6355, and Ca~II \lam8579,
989: blueshifted by 11,000 \kms.}
990: \end{figure}
991:
992: \begin{figure}
993: \includegraphics[width=.8\textwidth,angle=270]{f3.eps}
994: \caption{ The 1 week--postmax spectra of the CN SN~1998bu ({\sl solid
995: line}) from Jha et~al. (1999) and the CN SN~1996X ({\sl dashed
996: line}) from Salvo et~al. (2001) are compared.}
997: \end{figure}
998:
999: \begin{figure}
1000: \includegraphics[width=.8\textwidth,angle=270]{f4.eps}
1001: \caption{The 1 week postmax spectrum of the CN SN~1996X ({\sl
1002: solid line}) from Salvo et~al. (2001) compared with a synthetic
1003: spectrum ({\sl dashed line}).}
1004: \end{figure}
1005:
1006: %\begin{figure}
1007: %\includegraphics[width=.8\textwidth,angle=0]{f5.eps}
1008: %\caption{Comparison of spectra of SN~1996X from Salvo et~al. (2001) in
1009: %the region of Fe~II multiplet 42: \lam\lam4924, 5018, and 5169.
1010: %Vertical lines at the top represent the Fe~II lines blueshifted by
1011: %17,000 \kms\ and Si~II \lam5051 blueshifted by 13,000 \kms. Vertical
1012: %lines at the bottom represent the Fe~II lines and Si~II \lam5051 all
1013: %blueshifted by 11,000 \kms. }
1014: %\end{figure}
1015:
1016: \begin{figure}
1017: \includegraphics[width=.8\textwidth,angle=0]{f5.eps}
1018: \caption{Like Fig.~2 but for one CN (for comparison) and
1019: the five BLs of the 1 week postmax sample.}
1020: \end{figure}
1021:
1022: \begin{figure}
1023: \includegraphics[width=.8\textwidth,angle=270]{f6.eps}
1024: \caption{The 1 week postmax spectrum of the BL SN~2002bf ({\sl solid
1025: line}) from Leonard et~al. (2005) compared with a synthetic spectrum
1026: ({\sl dashed line}). Unlabelled absorption features in the
1027: synthetic spectrum are produced by Fe~II.}
1028: \end{figure}
1029:
1030: \begin{figure}
1031: \includegraphics[width=.8\textwidth,angle=0]{f7.eps}
1032: \caption{Like Fig.~2 but for one CN and the three CLs of the
1033: 1 week postmax sample.}
1034: \end{figure}
1035:
1036: \begin{figure}
1037: \includegraphics[width=.8\textwidth,angle=270]{f8.eps}
1038: \caption{The 1 week--postmax spectrum of the CL SN~1999by ({\sl
1039: solid line}) from Garnavich et~al. (2004) compared with a synthetic
1040: spectrum ({\sl dashed line}).}
1041: \end{figure}
1042:
1043: \begin{figure}
1044: \includegraphics[width=.8\textwidth,angle=0]{f9.eps}
1045: \caption{Like Fig.~2 but for one CN and the five SSs of the 1 week
1046: postmax sample.}
1047: \end{figure}
1048:
1049: \begin{figure}
1050: \includegraphics[width=.8\textwidth,angle=270]{f10.eps}
1051: \caption{ The 1 week postmax spectra of the SS SN~1999ac
1052: ({\sl solid line}) from Garavini et~al. (2005) and the CN
1053: SN~1996X ({\sl dashed line}) from Salvo et~al. (2001) are compared.
1054: The arrows point to the lower blueshifts of Si~II and S~II and the
1055: higher blueshifts of Fe~II, in SN~1999ac.}
1056: \end{figure}
1057:
1058: \begin{figure}
1059: \includegraphics[width=.8\textwidth,angle=270]{f11.eps}
1060: \caption{The 1 week postmax spectrum of the SS SN~1999ac
1061: ({\sl solid line}) from Garavini et~al. (2005) compared with a
1062: synthetic spectrum ({\sl dashed line}).}
1063: \end{figure}
1064:
1065: %\begin{figure}
1066: %\includegraphics[width=.8\textwidth,angle=270]{x.eps}
1067: %\caption{ The 1 week postmax spectra of the SSs SN~2000cx
1068: % ({\sl solid line}) from Li et~al. (2001) and SN~1999aa ({\sl dashed
1069: % line}) from Garavini et~al. (2004) are compared.}
1070: %\end{figure}
1071:
1072: \begin{figure}
1073: \includegraphics[width=.8\textwidth,angle=270]{f12.eps}
1074: \caption{The 1 week postmax spectrum of the SS SN~2000cx ({\sl solid
1075: line}) from Li et~al. (2001) compared with a synthetic spectrum
1076: ({\sl dashed line}). The synthetic absorption near 8000~\AA\ is
1077: produced by O~I \lam8446 but the neighboring observed absorptions
1078: are produced by the Ca~II IR3.}
1079: \end{figure}
1080:
1081: \begin{figure}
1082: \includegraphics[width=.8\textwidth,angle=0]{f13.eps}
1083: \caption{Like Fig.~2 but for the seven CNs of the 3 week
1084: postmax sample, with an additional dashed line at 5350~\AA.}
1085: \end{figure}
1086:
1087: %\begin{figure}
1088: %\includegraphics[width=.8\textwidth,angle=270]{x94D96X+21.eps}
1089: %\caption{ The 3 week--postmax spectra of the CNs SN~1994D
1090: % ({\sl solid line}) from Patat et~al. (1996) and SN~1996X ({\sl
1091: % dashed line}) from Salvo et~al. (2001), are compared.}
1092: %\end{figure}
1093:
1094: \begin{figure}
1095: \includegraphics[width=.8\textwidth,angle=270]{f14.eps}
1096: \caption{The 3 week--postmax spectrum of the CN SN~1996X
1097: ({\sl solid line}) from Salvo et~al. (2001) compared with a
1098: synthetic spectrum ({\sl dashed line}).}
1099: \end{figure}
1100:
1101: \begin{figure}
1102: \includegraphics[width=.8\textwidth,angle=0]{f15.eps}
1103: \caption{Like Fig.~2 but for one CN and the three BLs
1104: of the 3 week postmax sample, with an additional dashed line at
1105: 5350~\AA.}
1106: \end{figure}
1107:
1108: \clearpage
1109:
1110: \begin{figure}
1111: \includegraphics[width=.8\textwidth,angle=0]{f16.eps}
1112: \caption{Like Fig.~2 but for one CN and the four CLs of the
1113: 3 week postmax sample, with an additional dashed line at 5350~\AA.}
1114: \end{figure}
1115:
1116: %\begin{figure}
1117: %\includegraphics[width=.8\textwidth,angle=270]{x91bg96X+21.eps}
1118: %\caption{ The 3 week--postmax spectra of the CL SN~1991bg ({\sl
1119: % solid line}) from Filippenko et~al. (1992a) and the CN
1120: % SN~1996X ({\sl dashed line}) from Salvo et~al. (2001) are compared.}
1121: %\end{figure}
1122:
1123: \clearpage
1124:
1125: \begin{figure}
1126: \includegraphics[width=.8\textwidth,angle=270]{f17.eps}
1127: \caption{The 3 week--postmax spectrum of the CL SN~1991bg({\sl solid
1128: line}) from Filippenko et~al. (1992a) compared with a synthetic
1129: spectrum ({\sl dashed line}).}
1130: \end{figure}
1131:
1132: \clearpage
1133:
1134: \begin{figure}
1135: \includegraphics[width=.8\textwidth,angle=0]{f18.eps}
1136: \caption{Like Fig.~2 but for one CN and the five SSs of the 3 week
1137: postmax sample, with an additional dashed line at 5350~\AA. The
1138: spectra of SN~2002cx and SN~2005hk have been artificially blueshifted
1139: by 5000 \kms.}
1140: \end{figure}
1141:
1142: \clearpage
1143:
1144: \begin{figure}
1145: \includegraphics[width=.8\textwidth,angle=270]{f19.eps}
1146: \caption{ The 3 week--postmax spectra of the SS SN~2005hk ({\sl solid
1147: line}) from Stanishev et~al. (2007) but artificially blueshifted by
1148: 5000 \kms, and the CN SN~1996X ({\sl dashed line}) from Salvo
1149: et~al. (2001) are compared.}
1150: \end{figure}
1151:
1152: \begin{figure}
1153: \includegraphics[width=.8\textwidth,angle=270]{f20.eps}
1154: \caption{The 3 week--postmax spectrum of the SS SN~2005hk ({\sl solid
1155: line}) from Stanishev et~al. (2007) compared with a synthetic
1156: spectrum ({\sl dashed line}). Unlabelled absorption features in the
1157: synthetic spectrum are produced by Fe~II.}
1158: \end{figure}
1159:
1160: \begin{figure}
1161: \includegraphics[width=.8\textwidth,angle=0]{f21.eps}
1162: \caption{Like Fig.~2 but for the five CNs of the 3 month
1163: postmax sample.}
1164: \end{figure}
1165:
1166: \begin{figure}
1167: \includegraphics[width=.8\textwidth,angle=270]{f22.eps}
1168: \caption{The 3 month--postmax spectrum of the CN SN~2003du ({\sl solid
1169: line}) from Stanishev et~al. (2007) compared with a synthetic
1170: spectrum ({\sl dashed line}). The forbidden--line identifications
1171: that appear above some of the flux peaks are from Bowers
1172: et~al. (1997) but these are not used in the SYNOW synthetic
1173: spectrum. Unlabelled absorption features in the synthetic spectrum
1174: are produced by Fe~II.}
1175: \end{figure}
1176:
1177: \begin{figure}
1178: \includegraphics[width=.8\textwidth,angle=0]{f23.eps}
1179: \caption{Like Fig.~2 but for one CN and the four
1180: BLs of the 3 month postmax sample.}
1181: \end{figure}
1182:
1183: \begin{figure}
1184: \includegraphics[width=.8\textwidth,angle=0]{f24.eps}
1185: \caption{Like Fig.~2 but for one CN and the three
1186: CLs of the 3 month postmax sample.}
1187: \end{figure}
1188:
1189: \begin{figure}
1190: \includegraphics[width=.8\textwidth,angle=270]{f25.eps}
1191: \caption{The 3 month--postmax spectrum of the CL SN~1991bg ({\sl
1192: solid line}) from Filippenko et~al. (1992a) compared with a synthetic
1193: spectrum ({\sl dashed line}).}
1194: \end{figure}
1195:
1196: \begin{figure}
1197: \includegraphics[width=.8\textwidth,angle=0]{f26.eps}
1198: \caption{Like Fig.~2 but for one CN and the three
1199: SSs of the 3 month postmax sample.}
1200: \end{figure}
1201:
1202: %\begin{figure}
1203: %\includegraphics[width=.8\textwidth,angle=270]{x91M03du+90.eps}
1204: %\caption{ The 3 month postmax spectra of the BL SN~1991M ({\sl
1205: % solid line}) from Gomez \& Lopez (1998) and the CN
1206: % SN~2003du ({\sl dashed line}) from Anupama et~al. (2005) are
1207: % compared.}
1208: %\end{figure}
1209:
1210:
1211: \clearpage
1212:
1213: \begin{deluxetable}{lcll}
1214: %\tabletypesize{\scriptsize}
1215: %\rotate
1216: \tablenum{1}
1217:
1218: %\tablewidth{1000pt}
1219: \setlength{\tabcolsep}{4pt}
1220:
1221: \tablecaption{The SN~Ia Sample}
1222:
1223: \tablehead{\colhead{SN} & \colhead{Epochs} & \colhead{Galaxy} &
1224: \colhead{References} \\
1225:
1226: \colhead{} & \colhead{(days)} & \colhead{} & \colhead{} }
1227:
1228: \startdata
1229:
1230: 1981B BL & 22, 93 & NGC 4526 & Branch et al. 1983\\
1231:
1232: 1984A BL & 8, 19 & NGC 4419 & Barbon et al. 1989\\
1233:
1234: 1986G CL & 21, 90 & NGC 5128 & Cristiani et al. 1992\\
1235:
1236: 1989B CL & 8, 19, 92 & NGC 3627 & Wells et al. 1994\\
1237:
1238: 1990N CN & 7, 21 & NGC 4639 & 7: Leibundgut et al. 1991; 21:
1239: Filippenko et~al. 1992b\\
1240:
1241: 1991M BL & 81 & IC 1151 & Gomez \& Lopez 1998\\
1242:
1243: 1991T SS & 83 & NGC 4527 & A. V. Filippenko, unpublished\\
1244:
1245: 1991bg CL & 19, 91 & NGC 4374 & Filippenko et al. 1992a\\
1246:
1247: 1992A BL & 6 & NGC 1380 & Kirshner et al. 1993\\
1248:
1249: 1994D CN & 7, 19, 87 & NGC 4526 & 7, 19: Patat et al. 1996; 87:
1250: Filippenko 1997\\
1251:
1252: 1994ae CN & 89 & NGC 3370 & Bowers et~al. 1997\\
1253:
1254: 1995D SS & 96 & NGC 2962 & Bowers et~al. 1997\\
1255:
1256: 1996X CN & 7, 22, 87 & NGC 5061 & Salvo et al. 2001\\
1257:
1258: 1997br SS & 8 & ESO 576-G40 & Li et~al. 1999\\
1259:
1260: 1998aq CN & 7, 21, 91 & NGC 3982 & Branch et al. 2003\\
1261:
1262: 1998bu CN & 8 & NGC 3368 & Jha et al. 1999\\
1263:
1264: 1999aa SS & 6, 19 & NGC 4469 & Garavini et~al. 2004\\
1265:
1266: 1999ac SS & 8 & NGC 2848 & Garavini et~al. 2005\\
1267:
1268: 1999by CL & 7 & NGC 2841 & Garnavich et al. 2004\\
1269:
1270: 1999ee SS & 22 & IC 5179 & Hamuy et al. 2002\\
1271:
1272: 2000cx SS & 7, 20, 89 & NGC 524 & Li et~al. 2001\\
1273:
1274: 2001el CN & 20 & NGC 1448 & Wang et al. 2003\\
1275:
1276: 2002bf BL & 7 & \nodata & Leonard et al. 2005\\
1277:
1278: 2002bo BL & 82 & NGC 3190 & Benetti et al. 2004\\
1279:
1280: 2002cx SS & 21 & \nodata & Li et~al. 2003\\
1281:
1282: 2002er BL & 6, 20 & UGC 10743 & Kotak et al. 2006\\
1283:
1284: 2003cg CN & 7, 23 & NGC 3169 & Elias--Rosa et al. 2006\\
1285:
1286: 2003du CN & 7, 84 & UGC 9391 & Stanishev et al. 2007\\
1287:
1288: 2004S CN & 8, 19 & \nodata & Krisciunas et~al. 2007\\
1289:
1290: 2004eo CL & 7, 21 & NGC 6928 & Pastorello et~al. 2007\\
1291:
1292: 2005hk SS & 21 & UGC 272 & Stanishev et~al. 2007\\
1293:
1294: 2006X BL & 6, 98 & NGC 4321 & Wang et~al. 2007\\
1295:
1296: 2006gz SS &7 & IC 1277 & Hicken et~al. 2007\\
1297:
1298: \enddata
1299: \end{deluxetable}
1300:
1301: %\end{document}
1302:
1303: \clearpage
1304:
1305: \begin{deluxetable}{lccccccc}
1306: %\tabletypesize{\scriptsize}
1307: \rotate
1308: \tablenum{2}
1309: %\tablewidth{1000pt}
1310: \setlength{\tabcolsep}{4pt}
1311:
1312: \tablecaption{Fitting Parameters for Selected Spectra of the 1 Week
1313: Postmax Sample}
1314:
1315: \tablehead{\colhead{Parameter} & \colhead{SN~1996X} &
1316: \colhead{SN~2004S} & \colhead{SN~2002bf} &
1317: \colhead{SN~1999by} & \colhead{SN~1999ac} & \colhead{SN~2000cx} \\
1318:
1319: \colhead{} & \colhead{CN} & \colhead{CN} & \colhead{BL} &
1320: \colhead{CL} & \colhead{SS} & \colhead{SS} }
1321:
1322: \startdata
1323:
1324: \vphot\ (\kms) & 11,000 & 7000 & 11,000 & 6000 & 6000 &
1325: 11,000 \\
1326:
1327: $\tau$(O~I) & 0.25/[17] & 0.2/[16] & 0.2/[15] & 0.3/[14] &
1328: 0.1/[16] & 0.2/[17] \\
1329:
1330: $\tau$(Na~I) & 0.3/[15] & 0.3/[12] & 0.5/[14] & \nodata & 0.1/[14]
1331: & 0.2/[13] \\
1332:
1333: $\tau$(Mg~I) & \nodata & \nodata & \nodata & 1/[13] & \nodata &
1334: \nodata \\
1335:
1336: $\tau$(Mg~II) & 0.6/[15] & 0.2/[13] & \nodata & \nodata & 0.5/[14] &
1337: \nodata \\
1338:
1339: $\tau$(Si~II) & 2/[15] & 0.5/[13] & 3/[21] & 1.2/[12] & 0.5/[14]
1340: & 1/13[15] \\
1341:
1342: $\tau$(S~II) & 0.8/[13] & 0.3/[11] & 0.2/[15] & \nodata & 0.3/[10] &
1343: 0.3/13[15]\\
1344:
1345: $\tau$(Ca~II) & 30/[17] & 15/[24] & 30/[23] & 100/[14] &
1346: 25/[20] & 2/[23] \\
1347:
1348: $\tau$(Sc~II) & \nodata & \nodata & \nodata & 2/[11] & \nodata &
1349: \nodata \\
1350:
1351: $\tau$(Ti~II) & \nodata & \nodata & \nodata & 0.8/[11] & \nodata &
1352: 0.2/23[25] \\
1353:
1354: $\tau$(Cr~II) & \nodata & \nodata & \nodata & 2/[11] & \nodata &
1355: 0.3/21[23] \\
1356:
1357: $\tau$(Fe~II) & 1/[15] & 0.8/[13] & 1.5/[21] & 7/[11] & 0.8/[15] &
1358: 0.3/19[22] \\
1359:
1360: $\tau$(Fe~III) & 0.3/[15] & 0.3/[13] & \nodata & \nodata & \nodata &
1361: 0.3/13[15] \\
1362:
1363: $\tau$(Co~II) & 0.6/[15] & 0.6/[13] & \nodata & \nodata & \nodata
1364: & \nodata \\
1365:
1366: $\tau$(Ni~II) & \nodata & \nodata & \nodata & \nodata & \nodata &
1367: 0.1/13[15] \\
1368:
1369:
1370: \enddata
1371:
1372: \tablenotetext{a}{NOTE.---For each ion, the optical depth $\tau$ is
1373: the optical depth at the photosphere or detachment velocity of the
1374: ion's reference line (ordinarily the ion's strongest line in the
1375: optical spectrum). Minimum and maximum velocities (in units of
1376: 1000~\kms) are preceded by a forward slash, with maximum velocities in
1377: square brackets.}
1378:
1379: \end{deluxetable}
1380:
1381: \begin{deluxetable}{lcccc}
1382: %\tabletypesize{\scriptsize}
1383: \rotate
1384: \tablenum{3}
1385: %\tablewidth{1000pt}
1386: \setlength{\tabcolsep}{4pt}
1387:
1388: \tablecaption{Fitting Parameters for Selected Spectra of the
1389: 3 Weeks Postmax Sample}
1390:
1391: \tablehead{\colhead{Parameter} & \colhead{SN~1996X} &
1392: \colhead{SN~1991bg} & \colhead{SN~2005hk} & \colhead{SN~2000cx} \\
1393:
1394: \colhead{} & \colhead{CN} & \colhead{CL} & \colhead{SS} & \colhead{SS} }
1395:
1396: \startdata
1397:
1398: \vphot\ (\kms) & 6000 & 6000 & 4000 &7000\\
1399:
1400: $\tau$(O~I) & \nodata & 0.6/8[13] & \nodata & \nodata \\
1401:
1402: $\tau$(Na~I) & 0.4/7[17] & 0.6/10[13] & 0.2/6[9] & 0.6/[18] \\
1403:
1404: $\tau$(Si~II) & 0.7/8[13] & 1.2/7[11] & \nodata & 0.7/9[16] \\
1405:
1406: $\tau$(Ca~II) & 50/[16] & 500/9[14] & 50/[9]
1407: & \nodata \\
1408:
1409: $\tau$(Ti~II) & \nodata & 3/[11] & \nodata & \nodata \\
1410:
1411: $\tau$(Cr~II) & 6/[13] & 10/[11] & 10/[8] & 0.3/[18] \\
1412:
1413: $\tau$(Fe~II) & 12/[13] & 10/[11] & 30/[8] & 0.8/[18] \\
1414:
1415: $\tau$(Fe~III) & \nodata & \nodata & \nodata & 0.5/[15] \\
1416:
1417: $\tau$(Co~II) & 6/[13] & \nodata & 10/[8] & \nodata \\
1418:
1419: \enddata
1420:
1421: \tablenotetext{a}{NOTE.---For column descriptions, see the note to Table~2.}
1422:
1423: \end{deluxetable}
1424:
1425: %\end{document}
1426:
1427: \begin{deluxetable}{lcc}
1428: %\tabletypesize{\scriptsize}
1429: \rotate
1430: \tablenum{4}
1431: %\tablewidth{1000pt}
1432: \setlength{\tabcolsep}{4pt}
1433:
1434: \tablecaption{Fitting Parameters for Selected Spectra of the 3 Months
1435: Postmax Sample}
1436:
1437: \tablehead{\colhead{Parameter} & \colhead{SN~2003du} &
1438: \colhead{SN~1991bg} \\
1439:
1440: \colhead{}& \colhead{CN} & \colhead{CL} }
1441:
1442: \startdata
1443:
1444: \vphot\ (\kms) & 7000 & 3000\\
1445:
1446: $\tau$(Na~I) & 4/[15] & 4/[15]\\
1447:
1448: $\tau$(Ca~II) & 10,000/[14] & 1000/[12] \\
1449:
1450: $\tau$(Fe~II) & 8/[12] & 2/[10] \\
1451:
1452: $\tau$(Cr~II) & \nodata & 0.5/[10] \\
1453:
1454: \enddata
1455: \tablenotetext{a}{NOTE.---For column descriptions, see the note to Table~2.}
1456: \end{deluxetable}
1457:
1458: \end{document}
1459: