1: \documentclass[preprint,12pt]{aastex}
2: % Revised
3:
4: \begin{document}
5:
6: \title{X-ray Emitting Ejecta in Puppis A Observed with Suzaku}
7: \author{Una Hwang, Robert Petre, \& Kathryn A. Flanagan}
8:
9: \begin{abstract}
10:
11: We report the detection and localization of X-ray emitting ejecta in
12: the middle-aged Galactic supernova remnant Puppis A using five
13: observations with the Suzaku X-ray Imaging Spectrometer to survey the
14: eastern and middle portions of the remnant. A roughly $3'\times 5'$,
15: double-peaked region in the north center is found to be highly
16: enriched in Si and other elements relative to the rest of the remnant.
17: The X-ray fitted abundances are otherwise well below the solar values.
18: While the ejecta-enhanced regions show some variation of relative
19: element abundances, there is little evidence for a very strong
20: enhancement of one element over the others in the imaged portion of
21: the remnant, except possibly for a region of O and Ne enhancement in
22: the remnant's south center. There is no spatial correlation between
23: the compact [O III] emitting ejecta knots seen optically and the
24: abundance enhancements seen in X-rays, although they are located in
25: the same vicinity. The map of fitted column density shows strong
26: variations across the remnant that echo earlier X-ray spectral
27: hardness maps. The ionization age (as fitted for single temperature
28: models) is sharply higher in a ridge behind the northeast-east
29: boundary of the remnant, and is probably related to the strong
30: molecular cloud interaction along that boundary. The temperature map,
31: by comparison, shows relatively weak variations.
32:
33: \end{abstract}
34:
35: \keywords{ISM:supernova remnants, X-rays:ISM, X-rays:individual (Puppis A)}
36:
37: \section{Introduction}
38:
39: In recent years, X-ray spectral imaging has revealed X-ray emitting
40: ejecta even in a number of very old ($\sim$10,000 yr) remnants where
41: most of the X-ray emission is from shock-heated interstellar or
42: circumstellar matter (e.g, Hughes et al. 2003, Park et al. 2003,
43: Hendrick et al. 2003, 2005, Borkowski et al. 2006). Puppis A is a
44: middle-aged supernova remnant whose X-ray emission is dominated by
45: shock-heated interstellar material. It resides in a very complex
46: interstellar environment including large atomic and molecular clouds
47: (Dubner \& Arnal 1988, Reynoso et al. 1995) and a large-scale
48: interstellar density gradient (Petre et al. 1982). It is, however,
49: one of a handful of remnants in which fast-moving ($\sim 1500$ km/s)
50: ejecta knots enriched in oxygen have been identified optically
51: (Winkler \& Kirshner 1985), and is thus a promising target for the
52: identification of hot, X-ray emitting ejecta. The goal of the Suzaku
53: observations reported here is to search for and to localize X-ray
54: emitting ejecta in Puppis A.
55:
56: The presence of O-enriched ejecta in Puppis A clearly indicates that
57: the progenitor was a massive star that synthesized the oxygen
58: hydrostatically, a conclusion that is further confirmed by the
59: presence of an X-ray emitting compact central source, believed to be a
60: neutron star (Petre et al. 1996, Winkler \& Petre 2007). The
61: optically emitting oxygen knots are found in the central and eastern
62: regions of Puppis (Winkler \& Kirshner 1985). More global oxgyen
63: ejecta enrichment had been indicated by high-spectral resolution X-ray
64: observations with the Focal Plane Crystal Spectrometer (FPCS) on the
65: Einstein Observatory (Canizares \& Winkler 1981). The O enrichment
66: suggested by the Einstein FPCS could not be localized by it, however,
67: as the spectra were accumulated over rather large regions of the
68: remnant ($3'\times 30'$ and $6'$ diameter). The identification and
69: localization of gas with enriched element abundances requires adequate
70: spectral imaging. Einstein Solid-State Spectrometer observations with
71: a 6$'$ aperature did not find evidence for ejecta enrichment
72: (Szymkowiak 1985 PhD thesis), but a later survey by the ASCA
73: Observatory (Tamura 1995 PhD thesis) did produce evidence for
74: localized ejecta enrichment, mostly of Ne in the west and northwest.
75: Chandra observation of a small $8'$ square field at the eastern edge
76: of the remnant, where the shock is interacting with molecular and
77: interstellar clouds, hinted at small pockets of gas enriched with
78: ejecta (Hwang, Flanagan, \& Petre 2005).
79:
80: In this paper, we present a partial X-ray imaging and spectral survey
81: of the Puppis A supernova remnant with the CCD detectors on the Suzaku
82: Observatory. Five observations cover about two-thirds of this large
83: 50$'$ diameter remnant to the east and center, including the locations
84: of the optically emitting O ejecta knots. Compared to ASCA, Suzaku
85: has only slightly improved angular resolution, but much better
86: sensitivity and spectral resolution, particularly at low energies.
87: The Suzaku XIS also surpasses the Chandra CCDs for sensitivity and
88: spectral resolution at low energies, a feature that is particularly
89: important for studying the X-ray emitting O and Ne ejecta.
90:
91: \section{Observations and Analysis}
92:
93: Five observations of Puppis A were performed with the CCD-based X-ray
94: Imaging Spectrometer (XIS) at the beginning of the AO1 guest observing
95: phase of the Suzaku Observatory. The XIS features four separate
96: imagers, one illuminated from the back (XIS1), the other three from
97: the front (XIS0, XIS2, subsequently defunct, and XIS3). Details can
98: be found in Mitsuda et al. (2007).
99:
100: The exposure times were optimized for observation of the oxygen
101: emission lines (O VII resonance at 574 eV, the dominant component of
102: the He-like O triplet in Puppis A, and O VIII Ly$\alpha$ at 653 eV;
103: see Winkler et al. 1981). The observations, which are summarized in
104: Table 1, cover most of the bright eastern and central portions of the
105: remnant, but not the west. Given the very soft spectrum of the source
106: and the overall high count rates of the Bright Eastern Knot (BEK),
107: Northeast (NE) and Interior (I) fields, data from the Hard X-ray
108: Detector on Suzaku were not telemetered, in favor of data from the
109: XIS. Additionally for these three observations, 4s burst mode was
110: used for the FI chips in order to further reduce the telemetry load
111: (in this mode, the detector does not collect data for 4 s out of the
112: normal 8 s data cycle). Shorter exposures also reduce the impact of
113: pulse pile-up in the detector, which is likely to be an issue at the
114: 10\% level in the bright regions of the remnant. The observations
115: were carried out without the use of charge injection to moderate the
116: effects of radiation damage on the CCDs. We use the initial release
117: version 0.7 of the data, after performing the data screening
118: recommended in the Suzaku Data Reduction
119: Guide\footnote{http://heasarc.gsfc.nasa.gov/docs/suzaku/analysis/abc}.
120: \begin{deluxetable}{lccccc}
121: \tabletypesize{\footnotesize}
122: \tablecaption{AO1 Suzaku XIS Observations of Puppis A}
123: \tablewidth{0pt}
124: \tablehead{
125: \colhead{Field}&\colhead{Obs ID}&\colhead{Date}&\colhead{Coordinates}&\colhead{Exposure Time (ks)}&\colhead{FI Burst Mode}}
126: \startdata
127: Bright Eastern Knot (BEK) & 501086010 & 2006 Apr 17 & 125.9422, -42.9626 & 16.8 & 4s \\
128: Northeast (NE) & 501087010 & 2006 Apr 17-18 & 125.7579, -42.7332 & 20.7 & 4s \\
129: Interior (Int) & 501088010 & 2006 Apr 17 & 125.5915, -42.9172 & 20.3 & 4s \\
130: Southeast (SE) & 501089010 & 2006 Apr 18 & 126.0121, -43.2023 & 29.8 & 4s, none \\
131: South (S) & 501090010 & 2006 Apr 18-19 & 125.6826, -43.1664 & 31.2 & none \\
132: \enddata
133: \end{deluxetable}
134: \subsection{Imaging Analysis and Results}
135:
136: For all five fields, the full-CCD spectra are qualitatively similar.
137: They fall off rapidly above energies of 3-4 keV, with no evidence for
138: harder emission, and have numerous strong emission line features.
139: These are the He$\alpha$ blends of O (dominated by the resonance
140: line), Ne, Mg, Si, and S, plus weak Fe L features near 827 eV
141: corresponding to Fe XVII (cf. Winkler et al. 1981). Figure 1 shows
142: the BI illuminated XIS1 spectrum for the South field as an example,
143: with the prominent emission lines and blends labelled. In this and all
144: other spectra considered here, the channels are binned to provide at
145: least 25 counts per channel.
146:
147: \begin{figure}
148: \centerline{\includegraphics[scale=0.40,angle=-90]{f1.eps}}
149: \figcaption{The XIS1 spectrum for the South field of Puppis A with
150: the prominent emission lines and blends labelled.}
151: \end{figure}
152:
153: \begin{deluxetable}{llll}
154: \tabletypesize{\footnotesize}
155: \tablecaption{Image Pulse Height and Energy Cuts}
156: \tablewidth{0pt}
157: \tablehead{
158: \colhead{Image}&\colhead{Pulse Heights}&\colhead{Energies (keV)$^*$}&\colhead{Total Counts ($10^4$)}}
159: \startdata
160: Cont 0 & 100-125 & 0.36-0.46 & 18\\
161: C He$\alpha$ & 125-145 & 0.46-0.53 & 51\\
162: O VII He$\alpha$ (Res) & 145-164 & 0.53-0.60 & 87\\
163: O VIII Ly$\alpha$ & 164-192 & 0.60-0.70 & 266\\
164: Cont 1 & 192-216 & 0.70-0.79 & 259\\
165: Fe L (Fe XVII) & 216-236 & 0.79-0.86 & 313\\
166: Ne IX He$\alpha$ & 236-268 & 0.86-0.98 & 573\\
167: Ne X Ly$\alpha$ & 268-300 & 0.98-1.09 & 322\\
168: Cont 2 & 312-348 & 1.14-1.27 & 166\\
169: Mg XI He$\alpha$ & 348-390 & 1.27-1.42 & 175\\
170: Cont 3 & 390-420 & 1.42-1.53 & 42\\
171: Si XIII He$\alpha$& 475-538 & 1.74-1.96 & 63\\
172: Si XIII He$\beta$ & 563-633 & 2.05-2.31 & 15\\
173: S XV He$\alpha$ & 633-710 & 2.31-2.59 & 12\\
174: Cont 4 & 710-860 & 2.59-3.13 & 7.4\\
175: %Cont 4a & 710-740 & 2.59-2.70 & 1.8\\
176: \enddata
177: \tablenotetext{*}{The energies are computed for a gain of 3.65 eV per pulse height channel.}
178: \end{deluxetable}
179:
180: We produced energy-selected images of all the notable line features in
181: the integrated spectrum, as well as regions of continuum emission, as
182: summarized in Table 2. We perform a simple correction for the
183: detector exposure by making the individual line images for each
184: detector for each observation, then trimming several pixels at all
185: four edges and dividing by the average exposure time; i.e., we do not
186: correct for vignetting. No attempt was made to subtract background as
187: the images are all bright. The final mosaicked images have 8.4$''$
188: pixels and are scaled to a fiducial exposure time, taken to be the
189: 16.8 ks exposure time for observation 50108600. The Si He$\beta$ and
190: S He$\alpha$ images have the fewest photons and so were binned by a
191: further factor of four in each dimension to improve signal-to-noise.
192:
193: The combined mosaicked line images for all four XIS detectors are
194: shown in Figure 2; the images mosaicked separately for the BI and FI
195: detectors are not shown but are similar to those in the Figure. The
196: continuum images are also not shown, but are similar to the line
197: images in general morphology. Spatial variations in the line emission
198: are further highlighted by difference images, five of which are shown
199: in Figure 3. These difference images are line images with the
200: broadband image normalized to it and subtracted. While we refer to
201: the images in Figure 2 and 3 as ``line images'', they are in reality
202: simply energy-selected images that include any emission in the
203: relevant energy range, whether from line or continuum. In Figure 2,
204: the O VII image is overlaid with surface brightness contours of the
205: ROSAT High Resolution Imager mosaic of the entire remnant (Petre et
206: al. 1996) and the J2000 coordinates. Coordinates are also given for
207: the images in Figure 3 to facilitate identification of morphological
208: features discussed below.
209:
210: The so-called Bright Eastern Knot (BEK), located just inside the
211: bottom of the straight eastern shock front, is prominent in all the
212: images. Its brightness peaks at roughly (J2000) $\alpha$=126.04,
213: $\delta$=-42.97 (see Figures 2 and 3). It is known to be a
214: complicated interaction between the supernova remnant shock and
215: multiple interstellar clouds (Petre et al. 1982, Hwang et al. 2005).
216: Given that the eastern part of the BEK has lower temperature and
217: ionization age conducive to stronger O line emission (Hwang et
218: al. 2005), it is not surprising that O emission is seen to be
219: relatively prominent at the easternmost edge of the BEK, and Ne and Fe
220: L emission is strong in a larger region extending towards the remnant
221: interior (Figure 3). We also point out some of the other
222: morphological features that we will later discuss in more detail.
223: These include the elongated region extending southward from the BEK
224: region (SE Arm, roughly $\alpha$=126.05, $\delta$=-43.15), and the low
225: surface brightness region that is just west of it (SE Low SB).
226: Extending north by northwest from the BEK is the northeast shock
227: front (NE SF); seen by Suzaku, it is bright in the images of Ne, Mg,
228: Si, S, but not of O.
229: %The entire northeastern edge of the remnant is interacting with a large complex of molecular clouds.
230: The relative prominence of lines of higher energy as opposed to oxygen
231: lines is consistent with the harder spectra seen interior to the NE SF
232: in ROSAT observations (Aschenbach et al. 1994, Hwang et al. 2005).
233: The remnant's interior is populated with additional patchy clumps of
234: emission. The most striking of these is seen most prominently in the
235: Si images, just inside the northernmost apex of the remnant in the Si
236: images (it is also seen clearly in Ne, Mg, and S emission; we call
237: this the ``Si Knot'' ($\alpha$=125.70, $\delta$=-42.76).
238: Incidentally, the neutron star in Puppis A is visible in Si and S, and
239: in negative in the Ne IX difference image, at the lower right of the
240: image mosaics (i.e., in the lower center of the remnant at
241: $\alpha$=125.48, $\delta$=-43.01).
242:
243: \begin{figure}
244: \centerline{\includegraphics[scale=0.8]{f2.eps}}
245: \vskip -1.5 in
246: \caption{Energy selected line image mosaics of all four XIS detectors
247: combined. From left to right: (top) O VII Res, O VIII Ly$\alpha$, Fe
248: L (Fe XVII) (middle) Ne IX He$\alpha$, Ne X Ly$\alpha$, Mg XI
249: He$\alpha$ (bottom) Si XIII He$\alpha$, Si XIII He$\beta$, S XV
250: He$\alpha$. The final two images have been binned further by a factor
251: of four to improve the signal-to-noise level. The O VII image is
252: labelled with J2000 coordinates and overlaid with surface brightness
253: contours of the ROSAT HRI mosaic (Petre et al. 1996) to indicate the
254: full extent of the remnant. The neutron star can be seen in the
255: images in the bottom row.}
256: \end{figure}
257:
258: \begin{figure}
259: \centerline{\includegraphics[scale=0.8]{f3.eps}}
260: \vskip -1.5 in
261: \caption{Selected line images from Figure 2, with scaled broadband
262: image subtracted. White indicates excess emission compared to
263: broadband; black indicates a deficit of emission. For reference, the
264: spectral regions presented in Figure 6 are shown in the panels for Ne
265: IX (top: O Knot Center and bottom: Ne Knot South) and Si XIII
266: (counterclockwise from top: Si Knot North, NE SF, BEK, SE Arm and SE
267: Low SB)}
268: \end{figure}
269:
270: Line-to-continuum ratio images (``line equivalent width'' or EQW) can
271: be used to make a quick assessment of whether enhancements in the
272: images are particularly due to enhanced line emission. The continuum
273: underlying the line emission is first estimated (either by
274: interpolation or extrapolation from the continuum in nearby energy
275: regions,
276: %(Cont 0 and 1 for O VIII, Cont 2 and 3 for Mg, Cont 3 and 4a for Si)
277: or by extrapolating from a single adjacent continuum region),
278: %(Cont 2, subdivided twice, for Ne)
279: then it is subtracted from the ``line'' image before taking the ratio
280: (the procedure is essentially that used by Hwang et al. 2000). We
281: examined EQW images for O VIII Ly$\alpha$, Ne He$\alpha$, Mg
282: He$\alpha$ and Si XIII He$\alpha$ with particular reference to the
283: emission enhancements at the BEK, the northeastern shock front, and
284: the various interior knots.
285: %The images are binned by a factor of four relative to the line images in Figure 2.
286: None of the EQW images is bright at the BEK, which is in line with our
287: understanding that the BEK is associated with shocked interstellar
288: clouds. The northeast shock front is also absent from the EQW images
289: for the same reason. Of all the features seen in the EQW images, the
290: strongest by far is the roughly $3'\times 5'$ Si Knot seen in the Si,
291: Ne, Mg, and S images. It completely dominates the Si EQW image which
292: is shown in Figure 4. (This image is binned by a factor of four
293: relative to the Si He$\alpha$ line image in Figure 2.) We do not show
294: the O, Ne, or Mg images here, in favor of the abundance maps from
295: spectral fitting to be discussed below, but note that O and Ne EQW
296: also appear high in a few regions, particularly in the southern
297: portion of the Si Knot and in the SE Low SB region adjacent to the SE
298: Arm.
299:
300: \begin{figure}
301: \centerline{\includegraphics[scale=0.8]{f4.eps}}
302: \vskip -2.5 in
303: \caption{Left: Line-to-continuum, or ``equivalent width'' image for
304: Si XIII He$\alpha$.
305: Right: Line ratio image for O VII Res/O VIII Ly$\alpha$.}
306: \end{figure}
307:
308: Element abundances aside, we also briefly consider the O VII Res/O
309: VIII Ly$\alpha$ ratio image as an example of a single-element
310: line-ratio image that can be used to diagnose conditions in the X-ray
311: emitting plasma (Figure 4; the analogous image for Ne is similar and
312: not shown). Ideally the ratio should be for line
313: emission only, but we have taken the ratio without subtracting the
314: continuum; the true continuum level is difficult to determine at this
315: spectral resolution, and the O VII line in particular is rather weak.
316: The image highlights the SE Low SB region that extends southward from
317: the BEK, as well as the eastern edge of the BEK, but cannot tell us to
318: what extent the O VII enhancement is caused by temperature, ionization
319: age, or column density differences. Imaging spectral observations
320: with Chandra indicate that the BEK is composed of at least two
321: physical components, with the easternmost of these at lower
322: temperature, lower ionization, and higher column density (Hwang et
323: al. 2005). Except for the higher column density, these would
324: contribute to the observed enhancement of O VII/O VIII at the eastern
325: edge of the BEK. Likewise for the low surface brightness region,
326: further constraints from spectral analysis are needed to understand
327: the enhancement observed.
328:
329: \section{Spectral Analysis}
330:
331: While the EQW images provide an easily accessible overview of where in
332: the remnant the line emission is enhanced, a quantitative
333: interpretation is not possible from these images alone. First, it
334: must be known how temperature, ionization, and element abundances
335: affect the line strengths relative to the continuum, and this depends
336: on the underlying spectral model assumed. Moreover, the parameters of
337: any model are not expected to be uniform throughout the remnant.
338: Second, the continuum estimation can be accurate only if the
339: ``continuum'' regions are truly line-free to start with, but this is
340: not usually a safe assumption for lines such as those of O or Ne that
341: lie at energies where the spectra are dense with line emission.
342: Finally, a two-point interpolation is the only feasible method to
343: estimate and subtract the continuum here, but it lacks sophistication
344: and probably accuracy. EQW images are thus most likely to be useful
345: if the line emission is very strong and well-isolated; for example, in
346: tracing the qualitative large-scale morphology of known, strong ejecta
347: enhancements as in Cas A (Hwang et al. 2000). They are less reliable
348: when searching for relatively modest ejecta enhancements. To support
349: the conclusions of the imaging analysis, it is thus necessary to turn
350: to the X-ray spectra, as we do next.
351:
352: We extracted spectra across the portion of the remnant imaged by
353: Suzaku in a grid following the procedure used by Hwang et al. (2005)
354: for Chandra observations of the BEK. Spectra were extracted for 259
355: square and rectangular regions of angular size 100-200$''$, with each
356: spectrum containing at least 10,000 counts. We focus on the spectral
357: results for the BI chip.
358:
359: The spectra were binned to 25 counts per channel and were fitted using
360: XSPEC with nonequilibrium ionization (NEI) models for a plane parallel
361: shock, modified by interstellar absorption using cross sections from
362: Morrison \& McCammon (1983). The models are characterized by the
363: temperature and the limiting ionization ages; we take the lower limit
364: for the ionization age to be fixed at $n_et = 0$ cm$^{-3}$~s and have
365: fitted only for the upper limit. Element abundances were varied for
366: O, Ne, Mg, Si (with S, Ar, and Ca linked to Si), and Fe (with Ni
367: linked to Fe).
368: %Most fits were improved by an adjustment of the instrument gain, with 0.7-0.9 percent being the most common adjustments.
369:
370: The spectral models must be converted to pulse-height spectra for
371: comparison to the data. This conversion is carried out with an
372: effective area file giving the total efficiency to detect a photon of
373: a given energy, and a response matrix for the distribution of photon
374: energy with pulse height. Both of these responses can vary depending
375: on the region of the detector used and the specific observation
376: conditions. An important time-dependent effect is the reduction in
377: XIS low energy efficiency caused by the build-up of contaminants on
378: the optical blocking filter (Koyama et al. 2007). This effect is
379: included in the effective area calculation (Ishisaki et al. 2007).
380: CCDs are also damaged by radiation with the passing of time causing
381: degradation in the energy resolution and gain. While this effect is
382: now ameliorated by charge injection, charge injection was not used for
383: these early observations. We compensate by fitting the spectrum with
384: an overall scaling factor for the gain (usually 0.993 to 0.996).
385:
386: The observations were spread out over only two days, and there was no
387: discernable change in the response matrices computed for the various
388: observations. We use the matrix appropriate for an observation using
389: the entire CCD chip because the current matrices do not reproduce
390: differences in response across the detector.
391:
392: The effective areas are another story. Ideally, the effective area
393: should be computed for the specific region on the detector used for a
394: given spectrum, but this requires time-consuming ray-tracing
395: simulations for each spectrum. This was impractical for us given
396: limitations in computer power and the large number of spectral regions
397: involved. The good signal-to-noise level of our data allowed us to
398: use relatively small spectral regions, but this makes the effective
399: area compuations even more time-consuming. We therefore compared the
400: results of spectral fits using several ray-tracing simulations of the
401: effective area: five for relatively large regions ($3'$ radius) on the
402: detector (center, top and bottom to the left and to the right) and
403: also a smaller 2$'$ grid region. Using the same spectrum and response
404: matrix, but different effective area files, we find that the
405: temperatures remain very consistent; abundances and ionization ages
406: vary from a few to 10 percent, and the column density variation by
407: less than twenty percent. For all the fits presented in this paper we
408: used the simulation for a $3'$ radius region on the center of the
409: detector, which amounts to neglecting the energy- and
410: spatial-dependent effects of vignetting and the contaminant on the
411: optical blocking filter. The vignetting removes photons from the edge
412: of the detector and is more severe at high energies, while the
413: contamination removes photons from the center of the detector and is
414: more severe at low energies (see Ishisaki et al. 2007). The two
415: effects tend to compensate, but the overall effect is
416: complicated. Since the spectrum of Puppis A peaks at around 1 keV,
417: neither effect should be too severe. Given that the variation in the
418: spectral parameters across the remnant is significantly larger than
419: the spread in spectral parameters that we find from using different
420: effective area computations, we consider this to be an acceptable
421: simplification. The biggest limitation imposed by the lack of fully
422: correct effective area calculations throughout the remnant is that we
423: are not able to obtain accurate model emission measures.
424:
425: Given the uncertainties in the spectral response described above, we
426: do not give numerical values of the spectral parameters obtained for
427: the entire grid. Rather we present an overview of the fitted
428: temperatures, ionization ages, column densities, and abundances in
429: Figure 5, with the smoothed Suzaku broadband mosaic image contours
430: overlaid for reference. The fitted parameters are represented for
431: each region by the color scale. Spectra and the fitted model
432: parameters are shown in Figure 6 and Table 3 for a small sample of
433: interesting spectral regions.
434:
435: \begin{figure}
436: \centerline{\includegraphics[scale=0.8]{f5.eps}}
437: \vskip -1.5 in
438: \caption{Maps of the fitted parameters for plane-parallel shock
439: models, overlaid with smoothed contours of the Suzaku broadband image
440: mosaic: $\chi^2/d.o.f$, column density $N_H$ ($10^{22}$ cm$^{-2}$),
441: temperature kT (keV), ionization age $n_et$ (cm$^{-3}$ s), and element
442: abundances of O, Ne, Mg, Si, S, and Fe by number relative to
443: solar. The Si abundance map has the explosion center inferred by
444: Winkler et al. 1985 marked as ``E''.}
445: \end{figure}
446:
447: Figure 5 shows that the quality of the fits is generally fair, with
448: all but a few values of the $\chi^2$ per degree of freedom falling
449: below 2. While not formally acceptable in a statistical sense, we
450: consider it acceptable given that the model is simple and many of the
451: spectra a few tens of thousands of counts or more. Column densities
452: are distributed mostly between about 0.13 to 0.35 $\times 10^{22}$
453: cm$^{-2}$, and are at the higher end of this range in the north and
454: center, away from BEK. The regions of high absorption generally
455: correspond to the spectrally harder regions in the ROSAT images
456: (Aschenbach 1994). The upper ionization age is typically
457: $0.5-2.5\times 10^{11}$ cm$^{-3}$s, but is particularly high along a
458: relatively narrow ridge behind the straight portion of the NE SF on to
459: the inside of the BEK. Since the gas near the shock front should have
460: been shocked relatively recently, these high ionization ages (which
461: exceed $3\times 10^{11}$ cm$^{-3}$s) are consistent with high gas
462: densities. The lowest ionization ages occur in the SE Low SB region,
463: as might be expected since the low surface brightness indicates low
464: gas densities. The temperature map is somewhat patchy, but more
465: uniform than the others, with temperatures distributed fairly
466: uniformly between 0.5-0.8 keV.
467:
468: The abundance maps all show a prominent double peak at the Si Knot in
469: the north central region. Two strong peaks are seen in Mg, Si and Fe,
470: but the southernmost of these is more prominent in O and Ne. All the
471: fitted element abundances have their peak values in this region; these
472: are all above solar, except for Fe. Ne and Si have higher peak
473: abundance values than the other elements, but Ne abundances are skewed
474: higher than the other elements throughout the remnant. In most of the
475: remnant, O, Mg, Si, and Fe abundances are generally between 0.3 to
476: 0.6-0.7 solar, but the Ne abundances fall mostly between 0.55-0.85
477: solar. Ne and Mg lines are blended with Fe L emission, so their
478: abundances are somewhat more model-dependent than those of elements
479: with cleaner line emission, such as Si. It should also be noted here
480: that sub-solar abundances are the norm in Puppis A when the spectra
481: are fitted with single-component models. For example, Tamura (1995)
482: typically required abundances from 0.1 to 0.6 solar for the ASCA
483: spectra.
484:
485: The O and Ne abundance maps are patchier than the others. The fitted
486: abundances are lowest in the SE Low SB region, and highest in the
487: southern peak of the Si Knot; we refer to this as the O Knot Center in
488: Table 3 ($\alpha$=125.67 $\delta$=-42.84). The absence of this
489: feature in the O EQW image (not shown here) underlines the difficulty
490: of identifying O ejecta from the X-ray images alone; the imaging
491: analysis is particularly difficult for lines like those of O that lie
492: in crowded spectral regions. Only by examining the spectra could we
493: learn that the O abundance is high at the Si Knot. Ne shows another
494: relative enhancement in an extended region just south of the broadband
495: contours that is also echoed more faintly by O. This region is
496: clearly visible in the Ne difference image in Figure 3, so we refer to
497: it as Ne Knot South in Table 3 ($\alpha$=125.66, $\delta$=-43.12).
498: For Mg, Si and Fe, the Si Knot is the only region with a definite
499: element enhancement.
500:
501: We take a closer look at a few spectra selected for their interest, in
502: Figure 6. The top panel compares the spectrum of a region in the
503: northern peak of the Si Knot with one in the NE SF. Both have strong
504: Si line emission in the Si line image in Figure 2, but only the Si
505: Knot knot has enhanced EQW (Figure 4) and enhanced Si abundance from
506: spectral fitting. The Si He-like blend is indeed stronger at the
507: knot. From Table 3, we see that the column densities and temperatures
508: are similar for the two fits, whereas the NE SF has a somewhat higher
509: ionization age. All the fitted element abundances are higher by at
510: least a factor of two at the Si Knot compared to the NE SF, with Si
511: being higher by a factor of four. Given that the statistical errors
512: are quite tight, the Si Knot is clearly enriched with ejecta.
513:
514: The second panel shows two spectra with O and Ne enhancements---those
515: of the O Knot Center (the southern peak of the Si Knot) and the Ne
516: Knot South. While the O Knot Center also has higher-than-average
517: abundances for all the elements except perhaps Fe, the Ne Knot South
518: does not really show evidence for significant enhancement of elements
519: other than Ne, which is especially prominent; O is only slightly
520: higher than average.
521:
522: In the bottom panel of Figure 6, we compare regions without
523: significant abundance enhancements---the SE Arm extending south from
524: the BEK, the SE Low SB region, and the eastern edge of the BEK. The
525: latter two are prominent in the O VII/O VIII ratio image, and the SE
526: Low SB region also appears in the O VIII Ly$\alpha$ EQW image.
527: Enhanced O VII/O VIII in the SE Low SB region and the BEK is affirmed
528: by the spectra, as the O VII line is clearly stronger in these regions
529: than in the SE arm, whereas O VIII emission is comparably strong in
530: all three regions. Enhanced O EQW in the SE Low SB region is not
531: affirmed by the fitted O abundance, however. The explanation would
532: appear to be that the ``continuum band'' used to subtract the
533: continuum contribution (``Cont 1'' at 0.70-0.79 keV from Table 2) is
534: relatively weaker here (due in part to lower Fe abundance), which
535: artificially enhances the O EQW. The spectral parameters given in
536: Table 3 show that these three regions have similar columns,
537: temperatures, and abundances. The primary difference is a lower
538: ionization age for the SE Low SB region, which is enough to shift the
539: ion balance in favor of He-like O and to enhance the O VII/O VIII line
540: intensity ratio. Compared to other regions in the remnant, the SE Low
541: SB region also has very low column density and relatively low
542: temperature, which combines with the low ionization age to enhance O
543: VII relative to O VIII.
544:
545: %A few other regions (including, for example, the O knot) show some
546: %enhancement of the O VII/O VIII ratio. They tend to have a relatively
547: %low ionization age compared to other regions, which would tend to
548: %enhance the ratio by producing more O VII emission relative to O VIII.
549: \begin{figure}
550: \centerline{\includegraphics[scale=0.8]{f6.eps}}
551: \vskip -2.0 in
552: \caption{(Top) Spectra comparing strong Si line emission at the NE SF
553: (left) and the northern peak of the Si Knot (right). (Middle)
554: Spectrum of the O Knot Center (the southern peak of the Si Knot) (left) and the Ne Knot South (right).
555: (Bottom) Spectra from SE Arm with low O VII/O VIII and O VIII EQW
556: (left) and the SE Low SB region with high O VII/O VIII and O VIII EQW
557: (middle) and the eastern edge of the BEK (right). Fitted parameters
558: are given in Table 3.}
559: \end{figure}
560: \begin{deluxetable}{lllllllll}
561: \tabletypesize{\scriptsize}
562: \rotate
563: \tablecaption{Spectral Fits}
564: \tablewidth{0pt}
565: \tablehead{\colhead{Region}&\colhead{$\chi^2, \chi^2/dof$}&\colhead{N$_{\rm H}^*$}&\colhead{kT}&\colhead{$n_et$}&\colhead{O}&\colhead{Ne}&\colhead{Si}&\colhead{Fe}\\
566: \colhead{J2000 RA, DEC}&\colhead{}&\colhead{$10^{22}$ cm$^{-2}$}&\colhead{(keV)}&\colhead{$10^{11}$cm$^{-3}$s}&\colhead{$\odot$}&\colhead{$\odot$}&\colhead{$\odot$}&\colhead{$\odot$}}
567: \startdata
568: % reg 166
569: % first row: no gain adjustment
570: %NE SF & 617.2, 1.48 & 0.34$\pm0.02$ & 0.71 (0.69-0.74) & 2.7e11 (2.2-3.4e11) & 0.54 (0.48-0.61) & 0.63 (0.58-0.70) & 0.41 (0.36-0.46) & 0.46 (0.42-0.51) \\
571: NE SF & 587.4, 1.41 & 0.345$\pm0.005$ & 0.708 (0.707-0.727) & 2.63e11 (2.56-2.72e11) & 0.53 (0.51-0.56) & 0.64 (0.63-0.67) & 0.41 (0.38-0.43) & 0.45 (0.44-0.47) \\
572: 125.89, -42.79 &&&&&&&&\\
573: % reg 233 north part of Si knot; mistakenly I had entered 195 here and 233 for O Knot
574: %Si Knot & 457.1, 1.36 & 0.28$\pm0.02$ & 0.83 (0.77-0.90) & 7.5e10 (6.6-8.9e10) & 1.1 (0.97-1.3) & 1.5 (1.3-1.7) & 1.7 (1.5-2.0) & 0.98 (0.82-1.2)\\
575: Si Knot & 558.6, 1.56 & 0.33$\pm0.01$ & 0.88 (0.87-0.91) & 6.5e10 (6.3-6.9e10) & 0.86 (0.84-0.89) & 1.27 (1.24-1.33) & 1.5 (1.4-1.6) & 0.94 (0.90-0.97) \\
576: 125.70, -42.76 &&&&&&&&\\
577: %reg 186 (replaces 195) south part of Si knot
578: O Knot Center & 510.7, 1.49 & 0.35 (0.33-0.36) & 0.77 (0.73-0.86) &
579: 7.1e10 (6.2-7.2e10) & 1.3 (1.1-1.4) & 1.8 (1.7-2.0) & 1.3 (1.2-1.3)
580: & 0.57 (0.54-0.65) \\
581: 125.67, -42.84 &&&&&&&&\\
582: % reg 27
583: %Ne Knot South & 389.5, 1.64 & 0.24 (0.21-0.26) & 0.75 (0.66-0.84) & 5.3e10 (4.4-6.3e10) & 0.74$\pm0.09$ & 1.5 (1.3-1.7) & 0.53 (0.40-0.69) & 0.57 (0.46-0.69) \\
584: Ne Knot South & 271.0, 1.14 & 0.30$\pm 0.01$ & 0.66 (0.64-0.68) & 5.30e10 (5.28-5.30e10) & 0.73 (0.70-0.75) & 1.41 (1.35-1.46) & 0.48 (0.39-0.54) & 0.41 (0.38-0.44) \\
585: 125.66, -43.12 &&&&&&&&\\
586: % reg 8
587: %SE Arm & 529.3, 1.59 & 0.20 (0.19-0.22) & 0.53 (0.50-0.54) & 1.9e11 (1.6e11-2.2e11) & 0.44 (0.41-0.47) & 0.65 (0.61-0.71) & 0.47 (0.40-0.54) & 0.54 (0.50-0.60) \\
588: SE Arm & 479.2, 1.45 & 0.22$\pm0.01$ & 0.50 (0.48-0.52) & 1.95e11 (1.62-2.03e11) & 0.42 (0.41-0.45) & 0.67 (0.63-0.70) & 0.47 (0.43-0.51) & 0.50 (0.45-0.54) \\
589: 126.05, -43.15 &&&&&&&&\\
590: % reg 19
591: %SE Low SB & 648.0, 1.87 & 0.15$\pm0.01$ & 0.66 (0.63-0.70) & 8.8e10 (7.8e10-9.9e10) & 0.34 (0.33-0.36) & 0.57 (0.53-0.60) & 0.41 (0.36-0.41) & 0.42 (0.39-0.46) \\
592: SE Low SB & 489.8, 1.42 & 0.173 (0.166-0.183) & 0.64 (0.61-0.68) & 8.2e10 (7.4-9.0e10) & 0.35 (0.32-0.37) & 0.61 (0.59-0.63) & 0.43 ( 0.37-0.47) & 0.39 (0.36-0.42) \\
593: 125.91, -43.14 &&&&&&&&\\
594: % reg 82
595: %BEK, east edge & 398.9, 1.35 & 0.14 (0.11-0.16) & 0.57 (0.55-0.60) & 1.1e11 (1.0-1.4e11) & 0.38 (0.35-0.40) & 0.68 (0.63-0.74) & 0.42$\pm0.08$ & 0.44 (0.40-0.49) \\
596: BEK, east edge & 363.7, 1.23 & 0.15 (0.14-0.17) & 0.58 (0.52-0.59) & 1.1e11 (1.0-1.3e11) & 0.38 (0.35-0.40) & 0.69 (0.64-0.74) & 0.40 (0.34-0.49) & 0.43 (0.38-0.47) \\
597: 126.08, -42.98 &&&&&&&&\\
598: \enddata
599:
600: \tablenotetext{*}{Error ranges given are 90\% confidence for a single interesting parameter.}
601: \end{deluxetable}
602:
603: \section{Discussion}
604:
605: To summarize the observational results, Suzaku clearly detects X-ray
606: emitting ejecta in Puppis A, and shows where it is
607: located. The most striking feature of the spectral maps is the
608: spatial correlation of the element abundances, especially at the
609: location of the Si Knot. All the elements are found to be
610: particularly enriched this region, with Si appearing to show the most
611: enrichment relative to other regions. Ne, and to a lesser extent O (
612: but not other elements), is also enriched in the south center of the
613: remnant.
614:
615: The two peaks of the Si Knot are both regions with somewhat
616: higher-than-average temperatures, but even a forced temperature of 0.6
617: keV closer to the remnant average requires clearly enhanced element
618: abundances (Si=1.3 and O=0.65 for the weaker northern peak of the
619: knot). We consider it more likely that the temperature difference is
620: real and is associated with the different composition of the knot
621: compared to its surroundings.
622:
623: The spectral parameters also show strong patterns. The high column
624: density to the north (combined with relatively uniform temperature)
625: echoes the patterns seen in spectral hardness by ROSAT. There is some
626: hint that the fitted column densities may be correlated with detector
627: position in the two northernmost fields (covering the northern peak
628: and the interior southwest of it), with the center of the detector
629: giving higher values. The other fields do not give the same
630: impression, however, and the large-scale differences in column density
631: are certainly robust. The ridge of high ionization age that follows
632: the boundary of the northeast shock front is qualitatively consistent
633: with the strong interaction of the blast wave seen in that region.
634: Radio HI observations show a very large molecular cloud whose straight
635: edge fits against the X-ray boundary of the remnant (Reynoso et
636: al. 1995). The blast wave will be strongly decelerated as it
637: propagates through the dense cloud, but the reflected shock will be
638: associated with higher temperature gas (cf. Levenson et al. 2002).
639: The difference in ionization age is a factor of several on the ridge
640: compared to the region behind it, and implies a comparable density
641: difference assuming that the shock times are roughly the same. Higher
642: angular resolution observations would be useful to make more reliable
643: quantitative estimates, but in any case, the relative narrowness of
644: the ridge seems to suggest that there was a sudden increase in the
645: ambient gas density, which presumably occured at the boundary of the
646: molecular cloud.
647:
648: The Chandra study of the BEK region in Puppis A showed that there are
649: significant spectral differences even within the BEK. The eastern
650: 0.5$'$ of the region is a compact knot having different spectral
651: parameters from the portion of the BEK to the interior. These
652: differences are unfortunately not accessible to this study, being on
653: too small an angular scale compared to the angular resolution of the
654: spectral grid. Nevertheless, it is encouraging to see that other,
655: somewhat larger scale spectral features seen in the BEK region by
656: Chandra are also seen by Suzaku. For example, there is a clump of
657: high ionization age gas inside the main part of the BEK which
658: corresponds well with the bottom end of the ``ridge'' of high
659: ionization age in the Suzaku map. The increase in temperature just
660: north of the BEK is also reproduced by the Suzaku analysis. The only
661: sufficiently large angular-scale spectral feature that we did not see
662: reproduced in the Suzaku spectral images is the higher column density
663: gas, not only at the eastern edge of the BEK, but also at the eastern
664: boundary above and below it. We do not have a complete explanation
665: for this, but it may be related in part to the contaminants that build
666: up on CCDs, since these reduce low energy sensitivity and can be
667: masked as increased absorption column densities; this is relevant for
668: both the Suzaku and Chandra CCDs.
669:
670: The overall subsolar element abundances also require some comment. As
671: noted earlier, similarly low abundances had been obtained by Tamura
672: (1995) in his analysis of ASCA X-ray spectra, but there are otherwise
673: no indications that the interstellar medium around Puppis A has
674: depleted element abundances. Dust depletion is a possibility, given
675: the brightness of the remnant at infrared wavelengths, and the
676: excellent correlation of infrared and X-ray morphologies (Arendt et
677: al. 1990). Dust is clearly present in the remnant and is apparently
678: collisionally heated. The signature of dust depletion in the X-ray
679: emission would be higher Ne abundance to that of O, Mg, Si, and Fe,
680: since Ne is not depleted onto dust grains as are these other elements.
681: The Ne abundance does have a tendency to be slightly higher than that
682: of O in Puppis A, but so is the Si abundance. Moreover, the Ne
683: abundance in CCD-resolution spectra is subject to additional
684: uncertainty because the Ne lines are blended with the complicated Fe L
685: line emission. In the south-central Ne knot of Puppis A, the fitted
686: Ne abundance is near the solar value and significantly enhanced
687: relative to the other elements; perhaps this is a region where dust
688: depletion is important. The Ne abundance is nevertheless generally
689: fitted at subsolar values, however, so it would appear that the
690: overall abundances are indeed subsolar, independent of any depletion
691: of some of the elements onto dust grains.
692:
693: Element abundances obtained from an overly simple spectral model may
694: be inaccurate, but there are no definite indications of additional
695: components in Puppis A that would, if present and unaccounted for,
696: result in artifically lower element abundances. Neither is Puppis A
697: an isolated incidence of low abundances inferred for the ISM-phase of
698: a supernova remnant. The Cygnus Loop in particular has yielded
699: extremely low ISM-phase abundances of 0.1-0.2 solar to analysis using
700: data from ASCA (Miyata et al. 1994), Chandra (Levenson et al. 2002,
701: Leahy et al. 2004), XMM-Newton (Tsunemi et al. 2007) and Suzaku
702: (Miyata et al. 2007). Finally, the interstellar medium in the
703: Magellanic Clouds is known to have subsolar abundances that are in
704: fact reproduced by Sedov models fitted to the entire remnant spectrum
705: (Hughes et al. 1998)\footnote{Plane-parallel shocks should provide a
706: good approximation to Sedov models (Borkowski et al. 2001).}.
707:
708: \subsection{Lack of Widespread O Enrichment}
709:
710: The modest O ejecta enrichment seen with Suzaku is at odds with the
711: significant enrichment of O and Ne relative to Fe that was reported by
712: Canizares \& Winkler (1981; hereafter CW81). In most regions of
713: Puppis A, we do not see O significantly enhanced relative to Fe, even
714: where O is enhanced above its average value. This echoes earlier
715: spectral studies of Puppis A with the Einstein Solid-State
716: Spectrometer (Szymkowiak 1985) and the ASCA Solid-State Imaging
717: Spectrometer (Tamura 1995), neither of which found a significant O/Fe
718: enrichment anywhere in Puppis A. The FPCS has also reported
719: enrichments of O relative to Fe for other sources, including
720: M87 and the supernova remnant N132D. For M87, XMM-Newton Reflection
721: Grating Spectrometer observations indicated a O/Fe abundance ratio of
722: 0.5 (Sakelliou et al. 2002), compared to the factor of 3-5 enrichment
723: reported by the FPCS (Canizares et al. 1982). For N132D, ASCA finds that
724: O/Fe is roughly solar (Hughes, Hayashi, \& Koyama 1998), in contrast
725: to values of twice solar or higher as deduced from Einstein
726: observations (Hwang et al. 1993).
727:
728: The Einstein FPCS observations were the first high-resolution X-ray
729: spectra ever obtained of non-solar cosmic sources---and the FPCS
730: observation of Puppis A was the very first of these. The FPCS used a
731: number of different crystals to scan limited energy ranges around a
732: feature of interest. The calibration was thus challenging, and not
733: fully optimal because the calibration data files taken just prior to
734: launch were unusable. The final calibration was based on extensive,
735: earlier laboratory measurements\footnote{Mark Schattenburg, private
736: communication}. For M87, the relative abundance estimate was based on
737: the O VIII Ly $\alpha$ line at 654 eV and the Fe XVII line at 826 eV,
738: for which two different crystals were required to scan the separate
739: lines, adding to the calibration uncertainties. This uncertainty is
740: eliminated for the observations of Puppis A and N132D since a single
741: crystal was used to scan the O VIII Ly $\gamma$ (816 eV) and Fe XVII
742: lines for the relative abundance determination. There is added
743: uncertainty, however, in that this is a crowded spectral region, and
744: the relatively weak Ly $\gamma$ line had to be modelled carefully.
745:
746: For Puppis A, the assumptions made by CW81 to interpret their spectra
747: were reasonable enough at the time, but updated X-ray observations and
748: atomic physics show some possible pitfalls. These can be summarized
749: as arising from (1) the assumption of a single-component (i.e., single
750: temperature, single ionization age) plasma within the large FPCS
751: apertures (2) comparison to a solar coronal spectrum with a
752: temperature distribution that turns out not to be appropriate for most
753: of Puppis A (3) the assumption that Fe XVII is always the dominant Fe
754: ion species when O VII and O VIII ions coexist. (1) Spectral maps of
755: Puppis A, including the one in this work, clearly show a wide variety
756: of temperatures, column densities, and ionization timescales
757: throughout the remnant. (2) From the same maps, we see that
758: temperatures in Puppis A are relatively high, averaging near 0.6 keV.
759: By contrast the solar coronal spectrum used to calibrate the FPCS
760: observations peaked at roughly 0.2 keV (3) Evaluation of the ion
761: populations using the NEI models in XSPEC show that O VII, O VIII, and
762: Fe XVII do not necessarily coexist as assumed, particularly at
763: temperatures below kT=0.2 keV and, more pertinently for this
764: discussion, at temperatures above kT=0.6-0.7 keV. The same evaluation
765: of ion populations show that they can vary by factors of at least 3-5
766: in the optically thin NEI models, particularly when ionization effects
767: are also taken into account.
768:
769: Given the foregoing, we believe that the current Suzaku abundance
770: results are more accurate, the high spectral resolution of the FPCS
771: notwithstanding.
772:
773: \subsection{Spatial Correlations}
774:
775: Although the peak abundances for the different elements vary from
776: subsolar (Fe) to nearly twice solar (Ne and Si), the abundance maps
777: all have the same general appearance, with the double-peaked Si Knot
778: being the most prominent feature throughout. At the southern peak,
779: all the elements with line emission have element abundances that are
780: significantly higher than average, and reach their highest values (in
781: this survey). The northern peak of this knot is relatively weaker for
782: O, Ne, and Mg compared to Si, but when the errors on the fitted
783: abundances are considered (Table 3), there is no significant
784: difference in the Si/O abundance ratio at the northern vs the southern
785: peak. The presence of Si ejecta at a radius comparable to that of O
786: ejecta is certainly interesting, because supernova ejecta may be
787: either hydrostatic or explosive in origin; O is synthesized completely
788: hydrostatically by the progenitor before the explosion, and Si in the
789: inner layers of the exploding star. Thus Si originates close to the
790: center of the explosion, but has been propelled outward in the
791: northern region of Puppis A and mixed with O and Ne ejecta.
792:
793: Most of the fast optically emitting ejecta [O III] knots reported by
794: Winkler et al. (1985) are in the eastern half of Puppis A observed
795: with Suzaku. The bulk of them lie 25 to 90 degrees east of north, at
796: 5$'$ to 9$'$ from the explosion center determined from their proper
797: motions (this center is indicated in the Si map subpanel of Figure 5).
798: Many of the optical knots are part of a large (roughly $8'\times 4'$)
799: tangle of [O III] filaments lying to the south and east of the
800: southern peak of the X-ray Si Knot. A smaller clump of optical knots
801: touches the X-ray knot at its southeastern boundary. Thus, while the
802: optically emitting O ejecta are in the general vinicity of the O
803: element abundances identified through the X-ray spectral fits, there
804: is no close physical correspondence between the optical and X-ray
805: emitting ejecta. On the whole, the X-ray and optically emitting O
806: ejecta appear to be spatially disjoint.
807:
808: %\begin{figure}
809: %\centerline{\includegraphics[scale=0.40]{figures/osi_ovlay.eps}}
810: %\caption{Two-color overlay of the O and Si EQW image mosaics showing
811: %the relative orientations of the O and Si enhanced regions in the
812: %north. The Si ejecta are at a larger radius. Also shown are the
813: %expansion center determined for the optically emitting O ejecta by
814: %Winkler \& Kirshner (1985) and the position of the neutron star
815: %discovered by Petre et al. (1996).}
816: %\end{figure}
817:
818: It is clear from the Suzaku observations that the Si knot is the only
819: example of significant Si ejecta enhancement in the eastern half of
820: Puppis A. In a result simultaneous with the preparation of this
821: paper, Katsuda et al. 2007 (in preparation) independently confirm the
822: Si enhancement here using XMM-Newton data, which provides
823: complementary coverage to Suzaku of the western half of the remnant.
824: They survey a larger fraction of the remnant, but do not find other
825: regions with substantial Si ejecta enrichment. If we allow that the
826: average interstellar element abundances near Puppis A are below the
827: solar value, it would appear that Fe is enhanced at the Si Knot as
828: well, since the fitted Fe abundances are higher here than elsewhere in
829: the remnant. The Si Knot is thus the only recognizable structure that
830: contains significant amounts of any explosively synthesized ejecta,
831: whether Si or Fe. Unlike the case in Cas A, where there is evidence
832: for physical separation of the Si and Fe ejecta (Hughes et al. 2000),
833: Puppis shows Si and Fe ejecta that appear to be coincident with each
834: other, as well as being mixed with lower Z elements.
835:
836: \subsection{Knot Ejecta Mass Ratios}
837:
838: The north central knot being the cleanest sample of ejecta in the
839: remnant, we consider how its element abundances compare to the
840: predictions of nucleosynthesis models. We convert the fitted
841: element abundances in Table 3, which are by number relative to the
842: solar values of Anders \& Grevesse (1989), to the ratio of the element
843: mass relative to that of Si. The observed mass ratios are compared to
844: various calculations of core-collapse supernova nucleosynthesis by
845: Woosley \& Weaver (1994), Thielemann et al. (1996), Rauscher et
846: al. (2002) and Limongi \& Chieffi (2003).
847:
848: Nucleosynthesis calculations are complex, and are sensitive to the
849: treatment of the stellar and nuclear physics, some of which is not yet
850: fully understood. For these reasons, models have yet to converge in
851: detail on what the element mass ratios should be for a progenitor of
852: given mass. The models we consider predict that a Type II explosion
853: for a 25 M$_\odot$ progenitor should produce 0.1-0.3 M$_\odot$ Si
854: ejecta, with the models of Thielemann et al. giving Si masses at the
855: low end of this range. Considering the various model calculations for
856: abundances of O, Ne, Mg, and Fe relative to Si, we do not find perfect
857: agreement with the observed mass ratios, but progenitors between 15
858: and 25 M$_\odot$ appear to be generally indicated. In no case do we
859: find a plausible model for a progenitor more massive than 30
860: M$_\odot$, whereas models are seldom computed for masses below about
861: 15 M$_\odot$.
862:
863: %we find the closest match to the
864: %element mass ratios for a progenitor of mass about 15 M$_\odot$ in the
865: %models of Thielemann et al. (1996), although the measured O/Si, and to
866: %a less extent Ne/Si, are somewhat too high. The match is rather poor
867: %for 20-30 M$-\odot$ progenitors in these models. Compared to the
868: %calculations of Woosley \& Weaver, our measured Fe/Si is always higher
869: %than predicted. Otherwise, either 18 or 25 M$_\odot$ models seem in
870: %fair agreement, but not the models with masses in between.
871: %Progenitors above 30 M$_\odot$ are very inconsistent with the
872: %abundances in the north central knot. In the various Limongi \&
873: %Chieffi models, a 20 M$_\odot$ progenitor matches quite well, but
874: %generally predict somewhat lower O/Si than observed. For the Rauscher
875: %et al. models, a fair match is found at 15 M$_\odot$, though 19 and 25
876: %M$_\odot$ may also be viable, but not the progenitor masses in
877: %between.
878: Of course, this particular knot need not even be a representative
879: sample of the global ejecta abundances, but at the least it is
880: reassuring that the high abundances of O, Ne and Mg relative to Si
881: require a core-collapse rather than a thermonuclear explosion.
882:
883: It is challenging to put tight constraints on the progenitor of Puppis
884: A from the X-ray observations because the remnant is relatively old
885: and most of the X-ray emission is dominated by interstellar material,
886: some of which is highly structured as dense clouds. Even where ejecta
887: are present, they are mixed with ISM, but complex models cannot always
888: be reliably constrained using moderate-resolution X-ray spectra. We
889: have only considered simple one-component models. Technically, the
890: presence of a second component could skew the derived ejecta, but this
891: should tend to increase the element abundances. We found that if we
892: did attempt to add a second thermal component representing emission
893: behind the blast wave (hence with the blast wave abundances fixed at
894: 0.4 solar), the fitted ejecta abundances increased overall by a factor
895: of two or so; the temperature and ionization age for the Si Knot did
896: not change much, increasing by no more than 10-20\%. We chose not to
897: use two-component fits throughout because the spectra generally cut
898: off above 2-3 keV, and we considered it difficult to put believable
899: constraints on a second component. In any case, this is a
900: conservative assumption for identifying ejecta enhancements, as we
901: have pointed out.
902:
903: In spite of the remnant's advanced age, the ejecta in this mature
904: remnant are tantalizing to pursue for the hints it may give to the
905: explosion that formed it. Ideally, better angular resolution is
906: desirable since Chandra observations (Hwang et al. 2005) have hinted
907: at relatively small localized regions with abundance enhancements.
908: These may contribute to the patchy, low-level enhancements seen with
909: Suzaku. Aside from the X-ray emitting Si Knot, the remaining Si may
910: either already be shocked and cooled, shocked and diluated, or still
911: unshocked. If the former, we might hope to see it in optical
912: emission, but optical [S II] emission in Puppis A resembles H$\alpha$
913: emission rather than the X-ray Si emission, and appears more likely to
914: be associated with blast wave emission (P. F. Winkler, private
915: communication). Shocked and diluted Si will be difficult to detect
916: with the significant dilution by the ISM expected for Puppis A after
917: 4000 years. Roughly 0.1 M$_\odot$ of Si is present in a few hundred
918: solar masses of interstellar material at 0.4 solar abundances.
919: Unshocked ejecta might be revealed by infrared observations, but the
920: available data are unfortunately insufficient for identifying ejecta
921: (Arendt et al. 1990). We hope that future observations will shed
922: interesting light on the ejecta in Puppis A.
923:
924: %The mass of the Si, assuming an ellipsoidal volume ($3'\times 2'
925: %\times 2'$) with the fitted Si abundance and a density inferred from
926: %the fitted X-ray emission measure ($1.26\times 10^{12}$ cm$^{-5}$) for
927: %region 5, is only on the order of $10^{-3}$ M$_\odot$ for a distance
928: %of 2.2 kpc (but this number is wildly wrong because it uses the
929: %generic effective area). This represents a small
930: %fraction of the few tenths M$_\odot$ or so Si ejecta that is expected
931: %to be produced in
932:
933: \acknowledgments
934:
935: We have benefitted from scientific discussions with Satoru Katsuda and
936: other collaborators on the XMM-Newton observation, and from a careful
937: reading by an anonymous referee. We are grateful to Hideyuki Mori for
938: expert help in configuring the observations, Mark Schattenburg, Dale
939: Graessle, and Claude Canizares for discussion of the FPCS observations
940: and calibration, Takashi Okajima for discussion of the Suzaku
941: mirrors, and Frank Winkler for sharing his optical images.
942:
943: \begin{thebibliography}{}
944: \bibitem[]{andersgrevesse89}Anders, E., \& Grevesse, N. 1989, Geo. et Cosmo. Acta, 53, 197
945: \bibitem[Arendt et al. (1990)]{arendt90}Arendt, R. G., Dwek, E.,
946: Petre, R., Dickel, J. R., Roger, R. S.,Milne, D. K., \& Kesteven,
947: M. J. 1990, \apj, 350, 266
948: \bibitem[Aschenbach (1994)]{aschenbach94}Aschenbach, B. 1994,
949: New Horizon of X-ray Astronomy, ed. F. Makino \& T. Ohashi, 103
950: \bibitem[]{984} Borkowski, K. J., Hendrick, S. P., \& Reynolds, S. P. 2006,
951: \apj, 652, 1259
952: \bibitem[]{} Borkowski, K. J., Lyerly, W. J., \& Reynolds, S. P. 2001, ApJ, 548, 820
953: \bibitem[]{986}Canizares, C. R., \& Winkler, P. F. 1981, ApJ, 246, L33
954: \bibitem[]{987} Dubner, G. M, \& Arnal, E. M. 1988, A\&AS, 75,363
955: \bibitem[]{988} Fesen, R. A., et al. 2006, ApJ, 636, 859
956: \bibitem[]{989} Hendrick, S. P., Borkowski, K. J., \& Reynolds, S. P. 2003,
957: \apj, 593, 370
958: \bibitem[]{991} Hendrick, S. P., Reynolds, S. P., \& Borkowski, K. J. 2005,
959: \apjl, 622, L117
960: \bibitem[]{993} Hughes, J. P., Ghavamian, P., Rakowski, C. E., \& Slane,
961: P. O. 2003, \apjl, 582, L95
962: \bibitem[]{995} Hughes, J. P., Hayashi, I., \& Koyama, K. 1998, ApJ, 505, 732
963: \bibitem[]{996} Hwang, U., Flanagan, K. A., \& Petre, R. 2005, \apj, 635, 355
964: \bibitem[]{997} Hwang, U., Holt, S. S., \& Petre, R. 2000, \apjl, 537, L119
965: \bibitem[]{998} Hwang, U., Hughes, J. P., Canizares, C. R., \& Markert, T. H. 1993, ApJ, 414, 219
966: \bibitem[]{999} Ishisaki, Y., et al. 2007, PASJ, 59, S113
967: \bibitem[]{1000} Koyama, K., et al. 2007, PASJ, 59S, 23
968: \bibitem[]{} Leahy, D. 2004, MNRAS, 351, 385
969: \bibitem[]{1001} Levenson, N. A., Graham, J. R., \& Walters, J. L. 2002, ApJ, 576, 798
970: \bibitem[]{1002} Limongi, M., \& Chieffi, A. 2003, ApJ, 592, 433
971: \bibitem[]{1003} Mitsuda, K. et al. 2007, PASJ, 59, 1
972: \bibitem[]{} Miyata, E., et al. 1994, PASJ, 46, L101
973: \bibitem[]{} Miyata, E., et al. 2007, PASJ, 59, S163
974: \bibitem[]{1004} Morrison, R., \& McCammon, D. 1983, ApJ, 270, 119
975: \bibitem[]{1005} Park, S., Hughes, J. P., Burrows, D. N., Slane, P. O., Nousek,
976: J. A., Garmire, G. P., 2003, \apjl, 598, L95
977: \bibitem[]{1007}Petre, R., Canizares, C. R., Kriss, G. A., \& Winkler, P. F. 1982, ApJ, 258, 22
978: \bibitem[Petre et al. (1996)]{petre96}Petre, R., Becker, C. M., \&
979: Winkler, P. F. 1996, ApJL, 465, L43
980: \bibitem[]{1010}Rauscher, T., Heger, A., Hoffman, R. D., \& Woosley, S. E. 2002, ApJ, 576, 323
981: \bibitem[]{1011}Reynoso, E. M., Dubner, G. G., Goss, W. M., \& Arnal, E. M. 1995, AJ 110, 318
982: \bibitem[]{1012}Sakelliou, I., et al. 2002, A\&A, 391, 903
983: \bibitem[]{1013}Szymkowiak, E. 1985, University of Maryland PhD Thesis
984: \bibitem[]{1014}Tamura, K. 1995, Osaka University PhD Thesis
985: \bibitem[]{1015}Teske, R. G., \& Petre, R. 1987, ApJ, 314, 673
986: \bibitem[]{1016}Thielemann, F.-K., Nomoto, K., \& Hashimoto, M. 1996, ApJ, 460, 408
987: \bibitem[]{} Tsunemi, H., et al. 2007, ApJ, in press, arXi:0710.1135
988: \bibitem[]{1017}Winkler, P. F., et al. 1981, ApJ, 246, L27
989: \bibitem[]{1018}Winkler, P. F., \& Kirshner, R. P. 1985, ApJ, 299, 981
990: \bibitem[]{1019}Winkler, P. F., \& Petre, R., 2007, ApJ, 670, 635
991: \bibitem[]{1020}Woosley, S. E., \& Weaver, T. A. 1994, ApJS, 101, 181
992:
993: \end{thebibliography}
994:
995: \end{document}
996: