1: %\documentclass[12pt,preprint]{aastex}
2: \documentclass[apj]{emulateapj} %for emulateapj style: *ONLY* put \begin{deluxetable}, \begin{figure*}
3: % *IF* YOU WANT TO GO OVER TWO COLUMNS~~~
4: %\usepackage{natbib}
5: \slugcomment{Accepted by the Astrophysical Journal Letters}
6:
7:
8:
9: \newcommand{\ergs}{$~{\rm erg~s^{\scriptscriptstyle -1}}$}
10: \newcommand{\snjc}{SN~2006jc}
11: \newcommand{\snbf}{SN~2005bf}
12:
13: % Lines:
14: \newcommand{\OxySeven}{\ion{O}{1}~$\lambda$7774}
15: \newcommand{\MgOne}{[\ion{Mg}{1}~$\lambda4571$}
16: \newcommand{\Oxy}{[\ion{O}{1}]}
17: \newcommand{\Ca}{[\ion{Ca}{2}]}
18: \newcommand{\OxyOne}{[\ion{O}{1}]~$\lambda\lambda$6300,6363}
19: \newcommand{\OxyTwo}{[\ion{O}{2}] $\lambda\lambda$7319,7330}
20: \newcommand{\OxyThree}{[\ion{O}{3}]~$\lambda$5007}
21: \newcommand{\OxyOneone}{[\ion{O}{1}]~$\lambda$6300}
22: \newcommand{\OxyOnetwo}{[\ion{O}{1}]~$\lambda$6363}
23: %\newcommand{\CaTwo}{[\ion{Ca}{2}]~$\lambda\lambda$7319,7324}
24: \newcommand{\CaTwo}{[\ion{Ca}{2}]~$\lambda\lambda$7291,7324}
25: \newcommand{\CaTwoone}{[\ion{Ca}{2}]~$\lambda$7291}
26: \newcommand{\CaTwotwo}{[\ion{Ca}{2}]~$\lambda$7324}
27: \newcommand{\synCo}{$^{56}$\rm{Co}}
28: \newcommand{\synNi}{$^{56}$\rm{Ni}}
29: \newcommand{\cmg}{\ensuremath{{\rm cm^{-2}g~^{-1}}}}
30: \newcommand{\cms}{$~{\rm cm~s^{\scriptscriptstyle -1}}$}
31: \newcommand{\cmsq}{$~{\rm cm^{\scriptscriptstyle -2}}$}
32: \newcommand{\sm}{M$_{\odot}$}
33: \newcommand{\smy}{M$_{\odot}{\rm yr^{\scriptscriptstyle -1}}$}
34: \newcommand{\sz}{Z$_{\odot}$}
35: \newcommand{\kms}{\ensuremath{{\rm km~s}^{-1}}}
36: \newcommand{\ergcm}{$~{\rm erg~cm^{\scriptscriptstyle -2}}$}
37: \newcommand{\ergscm}{$~{\rm erg~s^{\scriptscriptstyle -1}~cm^{\scriptscriptstyle -2}}$}
38: \newcommand{\ergscmA}{$~{\rm erg~s^{\scriptscriptstyle -1}~cm^{\scriptscriptstyle -1}~\AA^{\scriptscriptstyle -1}}$}
39: \newcommand{\ergcms}{\ensuremath{{\rm{erg~cm}}^{\scriptscriptstyle -2}{\rm{s}}^{\scriptscriptstyle -1}}}
40: \newcommand{\kmsMpc}{${\rm km~s^{\scriptscriptstyle -1}~Mpc^{\scriptscriptstyle -1}}$}
41: \newcommand{\grb}{GRB~060218}
42: \newcommand{\sn}{SN~2006aj}
43: \newcommand{\snbw}{GRB~980425/SN~1998bw}
44: \newcommand{\sndh}{GRB~030329/SN~2003dh}
45: \newcommand{\snaj}{GRB~060218/SN~2006aj}
46: \newcommand{\othree}{[\ion{O}{3}]~$\lambda\lambda4959,5007$}
47: \newcommand{\othreeweak}{[\ion{O}{3}]~$\lambda4363$}
48: \newcommand{\otwo}{[\ion{O}{2}]~$\lambda3727$}
49: \newcommand{\ntwo}{[\ion{N}{2}]~$\lambda6584$}
50: \newcommand{\sitwo}{\ion{Si}{2}~$\lambda6355$}
51: \newcommand{\SiSix}{\ion{Si}{2}~$\lambda$6355}
52: \newcommand{\stwo}{\ion{S}{2}~$\lambda6717$}
53: \newcommand{\stwol}{\ion{S}{2}~$\lambda6731$}
54: \newcommand{\snr}{SNR~1E0102.2$-$7219}
55:
56: \newcommand{\nsn}{8}
57:
58:
59:
60: \begin{document}
61: \title{Double-peaked Oxygen Lines Are not Rare in Nebular Spectra of Core-Collapse Supernovae}
62:
63: \author{M.~Modjaz\altaffilmark{1,2,3},
64: R.~P.~Kirshner\altaffilmark{2},
65: S.~Blondin\altaffilmark{2},
66: P.~Challis\altaffilmark{2},
67: T.~Matheson\altaffilmark{4}
68: }
69:
70: \altaffiltext{1}{University of California, Berkeley, 601 Campbell Hall, Berkeley, CA 94720; mmodjaz@astro.berkeley.edu}
71: \altaffiltext{2}{Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics,
72: 60 Garden Street, Cambridge, MA, 02138; kirshner,sblondin,pchallis@cfa.harvard.edu.}
73: \altaffiltext{3}{Miller Research Fellow}
74: \altaffiltext{4}{National Optical Astronomy Observatory, 950 N. Cherry Avenue, Tucson, AZ 85719-4933; matheson@noao.edu.}
75:
76:
77: \begin{abstract}
78:
79:
80: Double-peaked oxygen lines in the nebular spectra of two peculiar
81: Type Ib/c Supernovae (SN Ib/c) have been interpreted as off-axis
82: views of a GRB-jet or unipolar blob ejections. Here we present
83: late-time spectra of \nsn\ SN IIb, Ib and Ic and show that this
84: phenomenon is common and should not be so firmly linked to
85: extraordinary explosion physics. The line profiles are most likely
86: caused by ejecta expanding with a torus- or disk-like geometry.
87: Double-peaked oxygen profiles are not necessarily the indicator of a
88: mis-directed GRB jet.
89:
90:
91: \end{abstract}
92:
93: \keywords{gamma-ray burst: general supernovae: general}% \\ }
94:
95: \section{INTRODUCTION}\label{intro_sec}
96:
97:
98: To understand the connection between long-duration Gamma Ray Bursts
99: (GRBs) and the supernovae (SNe) associated with them, it would be
100: significant to detect the effects of jets that are produced in the
101: explosion even when the observer is not in the relativistic
102: beam \citep{woosley06_rev}). In the broad-lined Type Ic, SN 2003jd, an
103: off-axis GRB jet was proposed as the cause for the double-peaked
104: oxygen profile observed in its nebular spectrum
105: \citep{mazzali05_03jd,valenti08}. A similar double-peaked oxygen
106: profile, with a large blueshift, was detected in the peculiar Type Ib,
107: SN 2005bf \citep{maeda07,modjaz07_thesis}, where it was interpreted as
108: coming from a unipolar blob or jet \citep{maeda07}.
109:
110: If the double-peaked oxygen shape were exclusively caused by highly
111: relativistic jets, then we might expect only broad-lined SN Ic, whose line
112: widths approach 30,000 \kms , and which are the only subtype of
113: stripped-envelope SN seen at the sites of GRBs to exhibit
114: them. However, if we see double-peaked profiles in a range of
115: supernova types, we might conclude that asphericities are present in
116: more typical core-collapse events.
117:
118: We set out to obtain a set of nebular spectra for supernovae of
119: various subtypes to measure the emission line profiles with adequate
120: resolution and signal to detect signs of these double-peaked profiles
121: in nebular spectra of supernovae. As the supernova turns optically
122: thin a few months after maximum light, the emission line shapes can
123: provide information on the velocity distribution of the ejecta
124: \citep{matheson01,foley03,maeda06}. Structure in emission line
125: profiles have been reported in SN II \citep{spyromilio91}, SN IIb
126: \citep{spyromilio94_93j,matheson00_93jdetail} and SN Ib
127: \citep{sollerman98,elmhamdi04}, and interpreted as clumping of oxygen
128: in the ejecta.
129:
130:
131: In \S~\ref{obs_sec} we describe the observational sample. In
132: \S~\ref{doubleOxy_sec} we discuss the line profiles and show that the
133: double-peaked line profiles are unlikely to be caused by optical depth
134: effects. We speculate on the implications of our results in
135: \S~\ref{interpretation_sec} and summarize in \S~\ref{conclusion_sec}.
136:
137: \section{Observations and Analysis}\label{obs_sec}
138:
139: Spectra were obtained with the 6.5 m Clay Telescope of the Magellan
140: Observatory located at Las Campanas Observatory, the 8.1 m
141: Gemini-North telescope via queue-scheduled observations (GN-2005B-Q-11,
142: GN-2006B-Q-16 PI: Modjaz), the 6.5 m Multiple Mirror Telescope
143: (MMT) and the 1.5 m Tillinghast telescope at the Fred Lawrence Whipple
144: Observatory (FLWO). The spectrographs utilized were the LDSS-3
145: (Mulchaey \& Gladders 2005) at Magellan, the GMOS-North \citep{hook03}
146: at Gemini, the Blue Channel \citep{schmidt89} at the MMT, and FAST
147: \citep{fabricant98} at the FLWO 1.5 m telescope. All optical spectra
148: were reduced and calibrated employing standard techniques in
149: IRAF\footnote{IRAF is distributed by the National Optical Astronomy
150: Observatory, which is operated by the Association of Universities
151: for Research in Astronomy, Inc., under cooperative agreement with
152: the National Science Foundation.} and our own IDL routines for flux
153: calibration (see e.g., \citealt{matheson08}).
154:
155:
156: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
157: \begin{figure}[!ht]
158: \includegraphics[scale=0.55,angle=0]{f1.ps}% -- manuscript
159: \singlespace \caption{Selection of nebular spectra of SN IIb, SN Ib
160: and SN Ic in their respective rest frames. SN name, type and phase
161: of spectrum (with respect to maximum light, except for \snaj\ which
162: is referenced to time of GRB burst) are marked. For clarity we show
163: only the latest spectrum of each SN (except for SN~2004ao), even
164: though we obtained several for some SN. Also the main nebular
165: emission lines of \MgOne, \OxyOne , \CaTwo\ and \OxySeven\ are
166: marked at the very top. }
167: \label{nebmont_fig}
168: \end{figure}
169: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
170:
171: In Figure~\ref{nebmont_fig}, we present the observed nebular spectra
172: of \nsn\ new SN IIb, SN Ib and SN Ic. For clarity we show only the
173: latest spectrum of each SN (except for SN~2004ao). We double the
174: number of unambiguous SN Ib with late-time data from four historical
175: cases (SNe 1983N, 1984L, 1990I, and 1996N) to a total of eight (now
176: including SNe~2004ao, 2004dk, 2004gq, 2004gv), not counting SN~2005bf
177: (see also \citealt{maeda08}). We determined the phase with respect to
178: maximum from our own photometry (\citealt{modjaz07_thesis}, M.
179: Modjaz, in prep.). In addition, we show our data of the peculiar SN Ib
180: 2005bf, independently observed and analyzed by \citet{maeda07}, and of
181: SN~2006aj, the broad-lined SN Ic connected with GRB~060218
182: \citep{modjaz06}, independently observed and analyzed by
183: \citet{mazzali07_06aj}.
184:
185:
186: All spectra display the hallmark features of nebular SN Ib/c spectra:
187: strong forbidden emission lines of intermediate-mass elements such as
188: \OxyOne\ and \CaTwo, similar to spectra of SN~II. In the absence of
189: hydrogen, oxygen is the primary coolant in the ejecta of
190: stripped-envelope SN at late epochs when the gas is neutral or at most
191: singly ionized \citep{uomoto86,fransson87}. SN~2005bf is the only SN
192: discussed here that exhibits broad H$\alpha$ (see also
193: \citealt{maeda07}).
194:
195:
196:
197: \section{Detection of Double-peaked Oxygen Lines }\label{doubleOxy_sec}
198:
199: In the optically-thin case, the late-time emission line profile is
200: dictated, in principle, by the geometry and distribution of the emitting
201: material \citep{fransson87,schlegel89}. A radially expanding spherical
202: shell of gas produces a square-topped profile, while a filled uniform
203: sphere produces a parabolic profile. In contrast, a cylindrical ring,
204: or torus, that expands in the equatorial plane gives rise to a
205: ``double-horned'' profile as there is very little low-velocity
206: emission in the system, while the bulk of the emitting gas is located
207: at $\pm v_t$, where $v_t$ is the projected expansion velocity at the
208: torus.
209:
210:
211: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
212: \begin{figure}
213: \includegraphics[scale=0.55,angle=0]{f2.eps}
214: %\includegraphics[scale=0.58,angle=0]{Mont_OI_double.vel.6300.eps}
215: % \plotone{Mont_OI_double.vel.6300.eps}
216: \singlespace \caption{Montage of SN with double-peaked oxygen profiles
217: in velocity space. SN name, type and phase of spectrum (with respect
218: to maximum light). SN~1984L, a SN Ib is from \citet{schlegel89}.
219: SN~1994I \citep{filippenko95} that exhibits a simple parabolic
220: oxygen line profile is plotted for comparison at the bottom. The
221: dashed line marks zero velocity with respect to 6300 \AA\ . For
222: SN~2004ao, we plot the scaled profiles of \OxySeven\ (in blue) and
223: \MgOne\ (in red), which are not doublets, but also exhibit the two
224: peaks. As discussed in the text (\S~\ref{optdepth_subsec}), the two
225: horns are unlikely to be due to the doublet nature of \OxyOne. Note
226: the large blueshift in \snbf\ compared to the other SN which we do
227: not explain here.}
228: \label{doubleOxy_fig}
229: \end{figure}
230: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
231: Figure~\ref{nebmont_fig} shows that SNe 2004ao, 2004gt, 2006T show
232: conspicuous double-peaked lines of \OxyOne . We plot the oxygen line
233: profiles in velocity space for these objects in
234: Figure~\ref{doubleOxy_fig}. A literature search of published SN IIb,
235: Ib, and Ic spectra reveals that SN Ib 1984L, the prototype of the SN
236: Ib class, also shows a clear double-peaked profile that went
237: unremarked in the original publication \citep{schlegel89}. We plot
238: the spectrum with the highest S/N in Figure~\ref{doubleOxy_fig}. Finally,
239: we also include our data on SN~2005bf, the peculiar SN Ib with
240: extraordinary early-time light curves and spectra
241: \citep{tominaga05,folatelli06}, that showed highly blue-shifted (by
242: $\sim$ 2000 \kms) oxygen and calcium lines
243: \citep{maeda07,modjaz07_thesis}.
244:
245: This double-peaked line profile is visible in the oxygen line and not
246: in calcium. For SN~2004ao, the only SN for which we have a
247: sufficiently high S/N spectra, the double-horned feature is present in
248: the permitted line of oxygen, \OxySeven , and in \MgOne\ (see
249: Fig.~\ref{doubleOxy_fig}). Our late-time spectral follow-up for some
250: SN \citep{modjaz07_thesis} shows that SN \emph{without} double-peaked
251: profiles (SNe 2004gk, 2004gq) do not exhibit them at any epoch, while
252: SN \emph{with} double peaks (SNe~2004ao, 2004gt) retain them over the
253: full observed period.
254:
255:
256: The two horns are roughly symmetrically offset by $\sim$1000$-$2000
257: \kms\ around the trough. For most SN in our sample, the trough between
258: the two ``horns'' is located at nearly zero velocity for [\ion{O}{1}]
259: 6300\AA. SN~2004ao shows an apparent blueshift and SN~1984L shows a
260: redshift in the trough. A velocity shift of $\pm$ 200 \kms\ (as seen for
261: SN 2004gt) could be due to rotation of the host galaxy. We discuss other
262: possible causes for these shifts in \S~\ref{interpretation_sec}.
263:
264:
265: \subsection{Optical Depth Effects causing the Double Peaks? }\label{optdepth_subsec}
266:
267: Could the observed double-peaked profile be due to optical depth
268: effects? The \OxyOne\ doublet has a velocity separation of 3000 \kms
269: (with respect to 6300 \AA) and an intensity ratio of 3:1 in the
270: optically thin limit. Optical depth effects for \OxyOne\ have been
271: discussed in the supernova context by \citet{leibundgut91},
272: \citet{spyromilio91} and \citet{li92}. In these models, the ratio of
273: \OxyOneone\ to \OxyOnetwo\ evolves from $\sim$1 to $\sim$3 from early
274: times to late times as the supernova expands and the lines become
275: optically thin, as was observed for SNe 1987A
276: \citep{spyromilio91_87a,li92} and 1988A \citep{spyromilio91}. In
277: Figure~\ref{sn04aoratio_fig}, we plot the measured ratio of the blue
278: to the red horn for SN 2004ao, the supernova in our sample with the
279: longest time span of observations. The ratio of line intensity
280: decreases over time for SN~2004ao. In contrast, this ratio would
281: increase with time if the two horns were due to \OxyOneone\ and
282: \OxyOnetwo , as seen in SN 1987A (\citealt{li92}, overplotted in
283: Fig.~\ref{sn04aoratio_fig}).
284:
285: In SN 2004ao, where we have sufficiently high S/N- data, we also see a
286: similar double-peaked profile in the permitted \OxySeven\ line and in
287: \MgOne\, which are not doublets, as shown in Fig.~\ref{doubleOxy_fig}.
288: This suggests that the line shapes really do provide a guide to the
289: distribution of oxygen and magnesium in the ejecta. Optical depth is
290: not the probable cause for seeing two equal peaks in the \OxyOne\ line
291: profile.
292:
293:
294: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
295: \begin{figure}[!ht]
296: %\includegraphics[scale=0.37,angle=90]{LineRatio_DoubleOxy.ps}
297: \includegraphics[scale=0.37,angle=90]{f3.ps}
298: \singlespace \caption{Evolution of the intensity ratio of the blue to
299: the red horn ( I(Blue Horn)/I(Red Horn) ) as a function of time for
300: SN~2004ao (filled circles, this work). The intensity ratio decreases
301: over time. In contrast, if the blue and red horns corresponded to
302: \OxyOneone\ and \OxyOnetwo\, the intensity ratio would increase over
303: time, as observed in SN~1987A (empty circles, from \citealt{li92})
304: and 1988A \citep{spyromilio91}. }
305: \label{sn04aoratio_fig}
306: \end{figure}
307: %%%%% Made with /indirect/virgo4/mmodjaz/Ibc/sn2004ao/spec/Neb_analysis/plot_LineRatio_DoubleOxy.pro --> LineRatio_DoubleOxy.ps
308: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
309: % \newpage
310: \section{Interpretation}\label{interpretation_sec}
311:
312: We suggest a torus-like structure for either the oxygen distribution
313: or for the radioactive energy source that excites the oxygen lines,
314: \synCo\ \citep{fransson89}. If the distribution of the energy source
315: were most important, we would expect to see a double-peaked profile
316: for all the emission lines, including calcium. Since the
317: double-peaked lines are seen only for oxygen and magnesium, the
318: evidence favors the view that we are seeing the effects of the
319: distribution of those elements in velocity space.
320:
321: Models of the line shape that results from an expanding disk are
322: worked out by, e.g., \citet{gerardy00}, and \citet{fransson05}.
323: Comprehensive modeling of the line profiles needs to take into account
324: viewing angle effects and the thickness of the line-emitting and
325: expanding region. We leave that as a topic for future work.
326:
327: Here we do not attempt to explain the extreme blueshift ($\sim$ 2000
328: \kms) seen in \snbf\ at epochs later than 200 days. The less extreme
329: blueshifts seen in spectra obtained at $t \la$ 200 days for one of our
330: SN (SN~2004ao) might be caused by the same mechanism that is
331: responsible for the observed blueshifts in SN that show a single-peak
332: line of \OxyOne . S. Taubenberger at al. (in preparation) observe in a
333: large set of late-time spectra of 34 SN Ib and SN Ic that the oxygen
334: line centroids are found to be blueshifted for spectra taken at $t
335: \la$ 200 days. These blueshifts range up to $\sim$1500 \kms\ for
336: spectra at $t\sim$90 days and go to zero with increasing time.
337: Taubenberger et al. exclude dust formation, contamination from oth er
338: lines and geometric effects as potential causes and invoke residual
339: opacity effects as the most likely reason. The observed
340: blueshift-values in our sample agree with those seen in Taubenberger
341: et al. for similar epochs; thus, the same mechanism might be causing
342: the blueshifts in both single- and double-peaked \OxyOne . We
343: encourage future detailed modeling of the radiative transfer of
344: \OxyOne\ to elucidate the exact reason for the blueshift. We do not
345: have a simple explanation for the redshift seen in the trough of the
346: double-peaked \OxyOne\ of SN~1984L.
347:
348: We conclude that the most probable explanation for the double-horned
349: oxygen profiles is a torus like, or at least flattened, distribution
350: of oxygen, that may be a relic of the explosion physics. Energy
351: deposition and radiation transport modeling of late-time emission in
352: SN Ib (\citealt{fransson89}) predicts that material contributing to
353: \OxyOne\ (and to \MgOne) emission is situated further out in the
354: ejecta than material emitting in \CaTwo\ (see their Fig. 8). We
355: speculate that the mechanism causing the asphericities has to affect
356: the outer layers of the SN debris more than the inner ones. The
357: anisotropies we observe in the oxygen lines suggest large-scale plumes
358: of mixing rather than the small-scale inhomogeneities invoked to
359: explain sub-structure of the oxygen lines as reported for SNe II
360: 1979C, 1980K (\citealt{fesen99} and references therein), in SN IIb
361: 1993J \citep{matheson00_93jdetail} and in SN Ib/c~1985F
362: \citep{filippenko86}. In the case of our observed SN, the anisotropies
363: may be of global nature in order to give rise to such a clear
364: double-peaked line profiles. Alternatively, in case the supernova
365: progenitors are part of binaries, binary interaction or merger might
366: be modulating the geometry of the supernova ejecta \citep{morris07}.
367:
368:
369: Such a clear signature of a pure double-peaked oxygen profile has not
370: been found in other SN Ib/c \citep{matheson01}, except in SN~2003jd
371: \citep{mazzali05_03jd} and in SN~2005bf. SN~2003jd was a broad-lined
372: SN Ic without an observed GRB and showed the same double-peaked oxygen
373: profile \citep{mazzali05_03jd} as SN~2004ao (compare their Fig. 2 with
374: our Fig.~\ref{doubleOxy_fig}). \citet{mazzali05_03jd} interpret their
375: observations as indicating an aspherical axisymmetric explosion viewed
376: from near the equatorial plane, and suggest that this asphericity was
377: caused by an off-axis GRB jet. They conclude that only special SN,
378: those with high expansion velocities and possibly connected with GRBs,
379: are aspherical, and use SN~2003jd as a link between the normal,
380: spherical SN Ic and those highly aspherical ones connected with GRBs.
381: In our sample, however, the SN showing these line profiles are normal
382: SN Ib and even SN IIb, i.e. SN from stars with intact helium and
383: partial H envelopes before explosion, and have normal early-time
384: expansion velocities. Thus, it appears that asphericities are
385: prevalent in normal core-collapse events.
386:
387: Indeed, complex and ring-like velocity structures of oxygen have been
388: observed in SN remnants (SNRs), most prominently in the oxygen-rich
389: \snr\ in the Small Magellanic Cloud \citep{tuohy83}. \citet{tuohy83}
390: and subsequent papers fit a twisted ring model to the spatial and
391: velocity extent of the filaments that extents to velocities ranging
392: between $-$2500 to $+$ 4000 \kms. It is conceivable that the stellar
393: death leading to \snr\ had a geometry for the ejecta that was similar
394: to the events we observe. Asphericities may be common in in
395: core-collapse events, be they neutrino-driven \citep{scheck06},
396: acoustic \citep{burrows06}, or magneto driven
397: \citep{burrows07,dessart08}, as indicated by polarization, neutron
398: star kick velocities and the morphologies of young remnants.
399: Recently, \citet{maeda08} also reported that double-peaked line
400: profiles are not rare in stripped core-collapse SN. They suggested
401: that the observed fraction of double-peaked profiles ($\sim40\pm10$\%)
402: is consistent with the hypothesis that all of these core-collapse
403: events are mildly aspherical. Although their inferences are based on
404: the results of bipolar jet models \citep{maeda06}, \citet{maeda08}
405: suggest that a wide variety of geometries, similar to those suggested
406: here, may be present.
407:
408:
409:
410: \section{Conclusions}\label{conclusion_sec}
411:
412: In summary, we detect clear double-peaked line profiles of \OxyOne\ in
413: three SN IIb and SN Ib/c out of our observed sample of \nsn\ and
414: additionally, in one out of four published SN Ib. Our sample does not
415: include broad-lined SN Ic or peculiar objects. These line profiles
416: are probably not caused by optical depth effects, and suggest global
417: anisotropies in the ejecta. Prior to this work, double-peaked oxygen
418: lines had only been reported in two peculiar SN Ib/c and interpreted
419: as off-axis GRB-jet or unipolar blob ejections. It seems more likely
420: that asphericities are present in a wide variety of core-collapse
421: events and they are not strictly confined to the supernovae associated
422: with GRB jets. Although special models have been proposed to account
423: for the line profiles in peculiar supernovae, our investigation
424: suggests that double-peaked profiles, and underlying disks, are not
425: unusual. These ordinary SN from our sample have a variety of subtypes,
426: reflecting the diversity of mass loss prior to the explosion.
427:
428: We recommend a meta-analysis of available nebular spectra of all
429: core-collapse SN, spanning the full range from SN II to IIb, Ib, Ic
430: and finally, to broad-lined SN Ic, in order to quantify the kinematics
431: and geometry of the ejecta and to seek trends as a function of SN
432: type. Further high-SN/N multi-epoch observations of a sample of SN
433: II/IIb/Ib/Ic coupled with radiative transfer models should help to
434: elucidate the observed blue- and redshifts of the line profiles.
435:
436: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
437:
438: \acknowledgements M. M. would like to especially thank R. Fesen for
439: very helpful suggestions and for reading a draft of this manuscript,
440: and in addition C. Fransson, R. Narayan, D. Sasselov, B. Leibundgut
441: and J. Spyromilio for insightful discussions. We thank and FLWO 1.5m
442: observers for obtaining service-spectroscopy, and the referee, Alex
443: Conley, for constructive comments. M. M. acknowledges support from the
444: Miller Institute for Basic Research during the time in which part of
445: this work was completed. Observations reported here were obtained at
446: the MMT Observatory, a joint facility of the Smithsonian Institution
447: and the University of Arizona, at the 6.5 meter Magellan Telescopes
448: located at Las Campanas Observatory, Chile, at the F.L Whipple
449: Observatory, which is operated by the Smithsonian Astrophysical
450: Observatory, and at the Gemini Observatory, which is operated by the
451: Association of Universities for Research in Astronomy, Inc., under a
452: cooperative agreement with the NSF on behalf of the Gemini
453: partnership. Supernova research at Harvard University has been
454: supported in part by the National Science Foundation grant AST06-06772
455: and R.P.K. in part by the Kavli Institute for Theoretical Physics NSF
456: grant PHY99-07949.
457:
458: {\it Facilities:} \facility{MMT (Blue Channel spectrograph)}, \facility{FLWO:1.5m (FAST)}, \facility{Magellan:Baade(LDSS3)}, \facility{Gemini:Gillett (GMOS-N)}
459:
460:
461: \begin{thebibliography}{46}
462: \expandafter\ifx\csname natexlab\endcsname\relax\def\natexlab#1{#1}\fi
463:
464: \bibitem[{{Burrows} {et~al.}(2006){Burrows}, {Livne}, {Dessart}, {Ott}, \&
465: {Murphy}}]{burrows06}
466: {Burrows}, A., {Livne}, E., {Dessart}, L., {Ott}, C.~D., \& {Murphy}, J. 2006,
467: \apj, 640, 878
468:
469:
470: \bibitem[{{Burrows} {et~al.}(2007){Burrows}, {Dessart}, {Livne}, {Ott}, \&
471: {Murphy}}]{burrows07}
472: {Burrows}, A., {Dessart}, L., {Livne}, E., {Ott}, C.~D., \& {Murphy}, J. 2007,
473: \apj, 664, 416
474:
475: \bibitem[{{Dessart} {et~al.}(2008){Dessart}, {Burrows}, {Livne}, \&
476: {Ott}}]{dessart08}
477: {Dessart}, L., {Burrows}, A., {Livne}, E., \& {Ott}, C.~D. 2008, \apjl, 673,
478: L43
479:
480: \bibitem[{{Elmhamdi} {et~al.}(2004){Elmhamdi}, {Danziger}, {Cappellaro}, {Della
481: Valle}, {Gouiffes}, {Phillips}, \& {Turatto}}]{elmhamdi04}
482: {Elmhamdi}, A., {Danziger}, I.~J., {Cappellaro}, E., {Della Valle}, M.,
483: {Gouiffes}, C., {Phillips}, M.~M., \& {Turatto}, M. 2004, \aap, 426, 963
484:
485: \bibitem[{{Fabricant} {et~al.}(1998){Fabricant}, {Cheimets}, {Caldwell}, \&
486: {Geary}}]{fabricant98}
487: {Fabricant}, D., {Cheimets}, P., {Caldwell}, N., \& {Geary}, J. 1998, \pasp,
488: 110, 79
489:
490: \bibitem[{{Fesen} {et~al.}(1999){Fesen}, {Gerardy}, {Filippenko}, {Matheson},
491: {Chevalier}, {Kirshner}, {Schmidt}, {Challis}, {Fransson}, {Leibundgut}, \&
492: {van Dyk}}]{fesen99}
493: {Fesen}, R.~A., et~al.\ 1999, \aj, 117, 725
494:
495: %\bibitem[{{Fesen} {et~al.}(2006){Fesen}, {Hammell}, {Morse}, {Chevalier},
496: % {Borkowski}, {Dopita}, {Gerardy}, {Lawrence}, {Raymond}, \& {van den
497: % Bergh}}]{fesen06_casabi}
498: %{Fesen}, R.~A., et~al.\ 2006, \apj, 645, 283
499:
500: \bibitem[{{Filippenko} \& {Sargent}(1986)}]{filippenko86}
501: {Filippenko}, A.~V. \& {Sargent}, W.~L.~W. 1986, \aj, 91, 691
502:
503: \bibitem[{{Filippenko} {et~al.}(1995)}]{filippenko95}
504: {Filippenko}, A.~V. {et~al.} 1995, \apjl, 450, L11
505:
506: \bibitem[{{Folatelli} {et~al.}(2006){Folatelli}, {Contreras}, {Phillips},
507: {Woosley}, {Blinnikov}, {Morrell}, {Suntzeff}, {Lee}, {Hamuy},
508: {Gonz{\'a}lez}, {Krzeminski}, {Roth}, {Li}, {Filippenko}, {Foley},
509: {Freedman}, {Madore}, {Persson}, {Murphy}, {Boissier}, {Galaz},
510: {Gonz{\'a}lez}, {McCarthy}, {McWilliam}, \& {Pych}}]{folatelli06}
511: {Folatelli}, G., et~al.\ 2006, \apj, 641, 1039
512:
513: \bibitem[{{Foley} {et~al.}(2003){Foley}, {Papenkova}, {Swift}, {Filippenko},
514: {Li}, {Mazzali}, {Chornock}, {Leonard}, \& {Van Dyk}}]{foley03}
515: {Foley}, R.~J., et~al.\ 2003, \pasp, 115, 1220
516:
517:
518: \bibitem[{{Fransson} {et~al.}(2005){Fransson}, {Challis}, {Chevalier},
519: {Filippenko}, {Kirshner}, {Kozma}, {Leonard}, {Matheson}, {Baron},
520: {Garnavich}, {Jha}, {Leibundgut}, {Lundqvist}, {Pun}, {Wang}, \&
521: {Wheeler}}]{fransson05}
522: {Fransson}, C., et~al.\ 2005, \apj, 622, 991
523:
524: \bibitem[{{Fransson} \& {Chevalier}(1987)}]{fransson87}
525: {Fransson}, C. \& {Chevalier}, R.~A. 1987, \apjl, 322, L15
526:
527: \bibitem[{{Fransson} \& {Chevalier}(1989)}]{fransson89}
528: ---. 1989, \apj, 343, 323
529:
530: \bibitem[{{Gerardy} {et~al.}(2000){Gerardy}, {Fesen}, {H{\"o}flich}, \&
531: {Wheeler}}]{gerardy00}
532: {Gerardy}, C.~L., {Fesen}, R.~A., {H{\"o}flich}, P., \& {Wheeler}, J.~C. 2000,
533: \aj, 119, 2968
534:
535: \bibitem[{{Hook} {et~al.}(2003){Hook}, {Allington-Smith}, {Beard}, {Crampton},
536: {Davies}, {Dickson}, {Ebbers}, {Fletcher}, {Jorgensen}, {Jean}, {Juneau},
537: {Murowinski}, {Nolan}, {Laidlaw}, {Leckie}, {Marshall}, {Purkins},
538: {Richardson}, {Roberts}, {Simons}, {Smith}, {Stilburn}, {Szeto}, {Tierney},
539: {Wolff}, \& {Wooff}}]{hook03}
540: {Hook}, I., et~al.\ 2003, in Proceedings of the SPIE., ed. M.~{Iye} \& A.~F.~M. {Moorwood}, Vol. 4841, 1645--1656
541:
542: \bibitem[{{Leibundgut} {et~al.}(1991){Leibundgut}, {Kirshner}, {Pinto},
543: {Rupen}, {Smith}, {Gunn}, \& {Schneider}}]{leibundgut91}
544: {Leibundgut}, B., {Kirshner}, R.~P., {Pinto}, P.~A., {Rupen}, M.~P., {Smith},
545: R.~C., {Gunn}, J.~E., \& {Schneider}, D.~P. 1991, \apj, 372, 531
546:
547: %\bibitem[{{Leonard} \& {Filippenko}(2005)}]{leonard05}
548: %{Leonard}, D.~C. \& {Filippenko}, A.~V. 2005, in ASP Conf. Ser. 342: 1604-2004:
549: % Supernovae as Cosmological Lighthouses, ed. M.~{Turatto}, S.~{Benetti},
550: % L.~{Zampieri}, \& W.~{Shea}, 330
551:
552:
553: \bibitem[{{Li} \& {McCray}(1992)}]{li92}
554: {Li}, H. \& {McCray}, R. 1992, \apj, 387, 309
555:
556: \bibitem[{{Maeda} {et~al.}(2008){Maeda}, {Kawabata}, {Mazzali}, {Tanaka},
557: {Valenti}, {Nomoto}, {Hattori}, {Deng}, {Pian}, {Taubenberger}, {Iye},
558: {Matheson}, {Filippenko}, {Aoki}, {Kosugi}, {Ohyama}, {Sasaki}, \&
559: {Takata}}]{maeda08}
560: {Maeda}, K., et~al.\ 2008, Science, 319, 1220
561:
562: \bibitem[{{Maeda} {et~al.}(2006){Maeda}, {Nomoto}, {Mazzali}, \&
563: {Deng}}]{maeda06}
564: {Maeda}, K., {Nomoto}, K., {Mazzali}, P.~A., \& {Deng}, J. 2006, \apj, 640, 854
565:
566: \bibitem[{{Maeda} {et~al.}(2007){Maeda}, {Tanaka}, {Nomoto}, {Tominaga},
567: {Kawabata}, {Mazzali}, {Umeda}, {Suzuki}, \& {Hattori}}]{maeda07}
568: {Maeda}, K., et~al.\ 2007, \apj, 666, 1069
569:
570: \bibitem[{{Matheson} {et~al.}(2000){Matheson}, {Filippenko}, {Ho}, {Barth}, \&
571: {Leonard}}]{matheson00_93jdetail}
572: {Matheson}, T., {Filippenko}, A.~V., {Ho}, L.~C., {Barth}, A.~J., \& {Leonard},
573: D.~C. 2000, \aj, 120, 1499
574:
575: \bibitem[{{Matheson} {et~al.}(2001){Matheson}, {Filippenko}, {Li}, {Leonard},
576: \& {Shields}}]{matheson01}
577: {Matheson}, T., {Filippenko}, A.~V., {Li}, W., {Leonard}, D.~C., \& {Shields},
578: J.~C. 2001, \aj, 121, 1648
579:
580: \bibitem[{{Matheson} {et~al.}(2008){Matheson}, {Kirshner}, {Challis}, {Jha},
581: {Garnavich}, {Berlind}, {Calkins}, {Blondin}, {Balog}, {Bragg}, {Caldwell},
582: {Dendy Concannon}, {Falco}, {Graves}, {Huchra}, {Kuraszkiewicz}, {Mader},
583: {Mahdavi}, {Phelps}, {Rines}, {Song}, \& {Wilkes}}]{matheson08}
584: {Matheson}, T., et~al.\ 2008, \aj, 135, 1598
585:
586: \bibitem[{{Mazzali} {et~al.}(2007){Mazzali}, {Foley}, {Deng}, {Patat}, {Pian},
587: {Baade}, {Bloom}, {Filippenko}, {Perley}, {Valenti}, {Wang}, {Kawabata},
588: {Maeda}, \& {Nomoto}}]{mazzali07_06aj}
589: {Mazzali}, P.~A., et~al.\ 2007, \apj, 661, 892
590:
591: \bibitem[{{Mazzali} {et~al.}(2005){Mazzali}, {Kawabata}, {Maeda}, {Nomoto},
592: {Filippenko}, {Ramirez-Ruiz}, {Benetti}, {Pian}, {Deng}, {Tominaga},
593: {Ohyama}, {Iye}, {Foley}, {Matheson}, {Wang}, \& {Gal-Yam}}]{mazzali05_03jd}
594: {Mazzali}, P.~A., et~al.\ 2005, Science, 308, 1284
595:
596: \bibitem[{{Modjaz}(2007)}]{modjaz07_thesis}
597: {Modjaz}, M. 2007, PhD thesis, Harvard University
598:
599: \bibitem[{{Modjaz} {et~al.}(2006){Modjaz}, {Stanek}, {Garnavich}, {Berlind},
600: {Blondin}, {Brown}, {Calkins}, {Challis}, {Diamond-Stanic}, {Hao}, {Hicken},
601: {Kirshner}, \& {Prieto}}]{modjaz06}
602: {Modjaz}, M., et~al.\ 2006, \apjl, 645, L21
603:
604: \bibitem[{{Morris} \& {Podsiadlowski}(2007)}]{morris07}
605: {Morris}, T. \& {Podsiadlowski}, P. 2007, Science, 315, 1103
606:
607: \bibitem[{{Scheck} {et~al.}(2006){Scheck}, {Kifonidis}, {Janka}, \&
608: {M{\"u}ller}}]{scheck06}
609: {Scheck}, L., {Kifonidis}, K., {Janka}, H.-T., \& {M{\"u}ller}, E. 2006, \aap,
610: 457, 963
611:
612: \bibitem[{{Schlegel} \& {Kirshner}(1989)}]{schlegel89}
613: {Schlegel}, E.~M. \& {Kirshner}, R.~P. 1989, \aj, 98, 577
614:
615: \bibitem[{{Schmidt} {et~al.}(1989){Schmidt}, {Weymann}, \& {Foltz}}]{schmidt89}
616: {Schmidt}, G.~D., {Weymann}, R.~J., \& {Foltz}, C.~B. 1989, \pasp, 101, 713
617:
618: \bibitem[{{Sollerman} {et~al.}(1998){Sollerman}, {Leibundgut}, \&
619: {Spyromilio}}]{sollerman98}
620: {Sollerman}, J., {Leibundgut}, B., \& {Spyromilio}, J. 1998, \aap, 337, 207
621:
622: \bibitem[{{Spyromilio}(1991)}]{spyromilio91}
623: {Spyromilio}, J. 1991, \mnras, 253, 25P
624:
625: \bibitem[{{Spyromilio}(1994)}]{spyromilio94_93j}
626: ---. 1994, \mnras, 266, L61
627:
628: \bibitem[{{Spyromilio} {et~al.}(1991){Spyromilio}, {Stathakis}, {Cannon},
629: {Waterman}, {Couch}, \& {Dopita}}]{spyromilio91_87a}
630: {Spyromilio}, J., {Stathakis}, R.~A., {Cannon}, R.~D., {Waterman}, L., {Couch},
631: W.~J., \& {Dopita}, M.~A. 1991, \mnras, 248, 465
632:
633: \bibitem[{{Tominaga} {et~al.}(2005)}]{tominaga05}
634: {Tominaga}, N. {et~al.} 2005, \apjl, 633, L97
635:
636: \bibitem[{{Tuohy} \& {Dopita}(1983)}]{tuohy83}
637: {Tuohy}, I.~R. \& {Dopita}, M.~A. 1983, \apjl, 268, L11
638:
639: \bibitem[{{Uomoto} \& {Kirshner}(1986)}]{uomoto86}
640: {Uomoto}, A. \& {Kirshner}, R.~P. 1986, \apj, 308, 685
641:
642: \bibitem[{{Valenti} {et~al.}(2008){Valenti}, {Benetti}, {Cappellaro}, {Patat},
643: {Mazzali}, {Turatto}, {Hurley}, {Maeda}, {Gal-Yam}, {Foley}, {Filippenko},
644: {Pastorello}, {Challis}, {Frontera}, {Harutyunyan}, {Iye}, {Kawabata},
645: {Kirshner}, {Li}, {Lipkin}, {Matheson}, {Nomoto}, {Ofek}, {Ohyama}, {Pian},
646: {Salvo}, {Sauer}, {Schmidt}, {Soderberg}, \& {Zampieri}}]{valenti08}
647: {Valenti}, S., et~al.\ 2008, \mnras, 383, 1485
648:
649: %\bibitem[{{Wang} {et~al.}(2006){Wang}, {Lai}, \& {Han}}]{wang06_nskicks}
650: %Wang}, C., {Lai}, D., \& {Han}, J.~L. 2006, \apj, 639, 1007
651:
652: \bibitem[{{Woosley} \& {Bloom}(2006)}]{woosley06_rev}
653: {Woosley}, S.~E. \& {Bloom}, J.~S. 2006, \araa, 44, 507
654:
655:
656: \end{thebibliography}
657:
658:
659:
660:
661:
662:
663: \end{document}
664: