1: % INJ
2:
3: \documentclass[12pt]{article}
4: \usepackage{graphicx}
5: \usepackage[latin1]{inputenc}
6: \usepackage{amsfonts}
7: \usepackage{epsfig}
8: \usepackage{amsmath}
9:
10: \advance\textwidth by 3truecm
11: \advance\oddsidemargin by -1.5truecm
12:
13:
14: \begin{document}
15:
16: \title{\normalsize\bf LETTER\\[\baselineskip]
17: Statistical correlations of an anyon liquid at low temperatures}
18: \author{\normalsize F. M. D. Pellegrino$^1$,
19: G. G. N. Angilella$^2$\footnote{Corresponding author.
20: E-mail: {\tt giuseppe.angilella@ct.infn.it}}, N. H. March$^{3,4}$, R. Pucci$^2$\\
21: \normalsize\emph{$^1$Scuola Superiore di Catania, Universit\`a di
22: Catania,}\\
23: \normalsize\emph{Via S. Nullo, 5/i, I-95123 Catania, Italy,}\\
24: \normalsize\emph{and INFN, Sez. Catania, Via S. Sofia, 64, I-95123 Catania, Italy}\\
25: \normalsize\emph{$^2$Dipartimento di Fisica e Astronomia, Universit\`a di
26: Catania,}\\
27: \normalsize\emph{and CNISM, UdR Catania, and INFN, Sez. Catania,}\\
28: \normalsize\emph{Via S. Sofia, 64, I-95123 Catania, Italy}\\
29: \normalsize\emph{$^3$Oxford University, Oxford, UK}\\
30: \normalsize\emph{$^4$Department of Physics, University of Antwerp,}\\
31: \normalsize\emph{Groenenborgerlaan 171, B-2020 Antwerp, Belgium}}
32:
33:
34: \date{\normalsize (Received on 8 February 2008, in final form)}
35:
36: \maketitle
37:
38: \abstract{%
39: Using a proposed generalization of the pair distribution function for a gas of
40: non-interacting particles obeying fractional exclusion statistics in arbitrary
41: dimensionality, we derive the statistical correlations in the asymptotic limit
42: of vanishing or low temperature. While Friedel-like oscillations are present in
43: nearly all non-bosonic cases at $T=0$, they are characterized by exponential
44: damping at low temperature. We discuss the dependence of these features on
45: dimensionality and on the value of the statistical parameter
46: $\alpha$.\\[0.5\baselineskip]
47: {\sl Keywords:} Electron liquid; Quantum Hall effect; Fractional statistics;
48: Pair correlation function.\\[0.5\baselineskip]
49: {\sl Running head:} {\bf Low-temperature correlations of anyon liquids.}
50: }
51:
52: \newpage
53:
54:
55: Fractional statistics has been introduced to describe the fractional quantum
56: Hall effect in low-dimensional, correlated electron quantum liquids.
57: \cite{Leinaas:77,Wilczek:82,Wilczek:82a,Laughlin:83,Laughlin:83a,Laughlin:88}
58: The elementary excitations of such systems, usually dubbed anyons, can be
59: characterized either through the phase factor $e^{i\alpha\pi}$ ($0\leq \alpha
60: \leq1$) picked up by the overall wave-function upon exchange of two particles,
61: of by the variation of size $\Delta D$ of the available Hilbert space
62: corresponding to a variation $\Delta N$ of the number of particles, through the
63: ratio $g=-\Delta D/\Delta N$ ($0\leq g \leq1$). The limiting cases $\alpha=0$,
64: $g=0$ [$\alpha=1$, $g=1$] correspond to boson [fermion] statistics,
65: respectively. While the former characterization, corresponding to
66: \emph{exchange} fractional statistics, applies to dimensions $d \leq 2$ only,
67: the latter characterization, corresponding to \emph{exclusion} statistics, does
68: not suffer from such a restriction, and has been considered for arbitrary
69: dimensionality. The relation between the two definitions of fractional
70: statistics is not completely settled, to date \cite{Speliotopoulos:97}.
71:
72: In this context, it has been recently proposed that topological excitations such
73: as vortex rings (anyonic loops) in the three-dimensional chiral spin liquids may
74: obey fractional non-Abelian statistics \cite{Si:07}. For the sake of simplicity,
75: and in order to avoid confusion with the pair correlation function to be defined
76: below, in the following we shall use the symbol $\alpha$ for the statistical
77: parameter in both contexts.
78:
79: Recently, the statistical correlations of an ideal gas of particles obeying
80: fractional exchange statistics have been addressed, in arbitrary dimensionality,
81: as a function of density, temperature, and statistical parameter $\alpha$,
82: partly analytically and partly numerically, through the study of the pair
83: correlation function $g(\textbf{r})$ \cite{Pellegrino:07}. This function
84: represents the probability of simultaneously finding two anyons at positions
85: $\textbf{r}$ and $\textbf{r}=0$, respectively. A general result, applying to all
86: non-bosonic values of the fractional parameter ($0 < \alpha \leq1$), is that the
87: pair correlation function is characterized by Friedel-like oscillations, which
88: become more pronounced for increasing $\alpha$ or density, or for decreasing
89: $T$. A somewhat related study \cite{Sen:07} considered the two-particle kernel
90: in the lowest Landau level of a quantum Hall system, but now in $d=2$ and within
91: the context of exchange fractional statistics.
92:
93: In this Letter, we study some asymptotic properties of the pair correlation
94: function at zero temperature as a function of density.
95:
96: In the formalism of second quantization, the pair correlation function introduced above can be defined as:
97: \begin{equation}
98: g(\textbf{r}) = \frac{\langle \Psi^\dag (\textbf{r}) \Psi^\dag (0) \Psi (0)
99: \Psi(\textbf{r})\rangle}{n(\textbf{r}) n(0)},
100: \label{eq:gr}
101: \end{equation}
102: where $\Psi^\dag (\textbf{r})$ [$\Psi(\textbf{r})$] is a creation [annihilation] quantum field operator at position $\textbf{r}$, $n(\textbf{r})=\langle \Psi^\dag(\textbf{r}) \Psi(\textbf{r})\rangle$ is the single-particle probability density at position $\textbf{r}$, and $\langle ...\rangle$ denotes a quantum statistical average associated with the equilibrium distribution of the identical particle assembly under analysis.
103:
104: In Ref.~\cite{Pellegrino:07}, we introduce a particular generalization of the
105: commutation relations for the $\Psi$-fields, interpolating between boson and
106: fermion statistics for $0\leq\alpha\leq1$ and arbitrary dimensionality $d$.
107: These are reminiscent of the graded commutation relations of Greenberg
108: \cite{Greenberg:91}, weakly violating conventional quantum statistics.
109:
110: In this way, the pair correlation function for a translationally system of
111: anyons obeying exclusion statistics can be written as:
112:
113: \begin{eqnarray}
114: g (r ) &=& 1+\cos(\alpha\pi) \frac{|\langle \Psi^\dag (r ) \Psi (0 ) \rangle|^2}{n^2 (0)} \nonumber\\
115: &=& 1+\cos(\alpha\pi) \left| \frac{\tilde{n} (r)}{\tilde{n} (0)} \right|^2 ,
116: \label{eq:galpha}
117: \end{eqnarray}
118: where
119: \begin{equation}
120: \tilde{n}(r) = \int \frac{d^d \textbf{k}}{(2\pi)^d} e^{-i\textbf{k}\cdot \textbf{r}} n(\textbf{k})
121: \label{eq:gnFourier1}
122: \end{equation}
123: is the Fourier trasform in $d$ dimensions of the distribution function
124: $n(\textbf{k})$ for exclusion anyons at equilibrium. While alternative
125: derivations of the latter have been proposed by Ouvry \emph{et al.}
126: \cite{DasnieresdeVeigy:94,DasnieresdeVeigy:95}, as well as viable approximations
127: within the chemical collision model by March \emph{et al.}
128: \cite{March:93c,March:93b,March:97b}, in the following we shall use Wu's
129: definition \cite{Wu:95}:
130: \begin{equation}
131: n(\textbf{k})=\frac{1}{w(\zeta)+\alpha},
132: \label{eq:distrib_wu}
133: \end{equation}
134: where $\zeta=\zeta(\textbf{k})$, and $w(\zeta)$ satisfies the functional relation:
135: \begin{equation}
136: w^\alpha (1+w)^{1-\alpha}=\zeta.
137: \end{equation}
138:
139: In this Letter we treat the case of an ideal gas of anyons obeying exclusion exclusion statistics, and for their dispersion relation we assume the usual one as for a non-relativistic free particle:
140: \begin{equation} \label{eq:disp_rel}
141: \epsilon(\textbf{k}) = \frac {\hbar^2k^2}{2m}.
142: \end{equation}
143:
144: At $T=0$ and for each non-zero value of the statistical parameter $\alpha$
145: ($0<\alpha \leq1$), Wu's distribution function Eq.~(\ref{eq:distrib_wu}) becomes
146: a step function, as in Fermi statistics. In particular, it assumes the following
147: limiting form:
148: \begin{equation} \label{eqn:scalinoanioni}
149: n(\epsilon)=
150: \left \{
151: \begin{array}{rl}
152: 1/\alpha, & \epsilon \leq \epsilon_{f,\alpha}, \\
153: 0, & \epsilon > \epsilon_{f,\alpha},
154: \end{array}
155: \right.
156: \end{equation}
157: where $\epsilon_{f,\alpha}$ is a generalized Fermi energy, that can be defined in arbitrary dimension as the highest level occupied by $N$ particles at $T=0$.
158: It is appropriate at this point to remind that under the same conditions in the bosonic case ($\alpha=0$) the distribution function behaves like a Dirac delta function, $n(\epsilon)=N\delta(\epsilon)$.
159:
160:
161: Therefore, inserting Eq.~(\ref{eqn:scalinoanioni}) into
162: Eq.~(\ref{eq:gnFourier1}) allows us to derive the analytical expression of the
163: anyon pair correlation function in arbitrary dimension $d$ at $T=0$ as:
164: \begin{equation} \label{eq:g_zero}
165: g(r) = 1+\cos(\alpha \pi) \Gamma\left(\frac{d}{2}\right) \left( \frac{2}{k_{f,\alpha} r}\right)^d J^2_{d/2}(k_{f,\alpha} r),
166: \end{equation}
167: where $J_{d/2}(z)$ is a Bessel function of first kind of order $d/2$ \cite{GR}. $k_{f,\alpha}$ represents the wavevector implicitly defined by:
168: \begin{equation}
169: C_d \left(\frac{k_{f,\alpha}}{2\pi}\right)^d =\alpha \frac{N}{V},
170: \label{eq:Wu_Kfermi}
171: \end{equation}
172: where $C_d =\frac{\pi^{d/2}}{\Gamma(d/2)}$ denotes the volume of
173: the unit sphere in $d$ dimensions.
174: In the fermion case ($\alpha=1$), $\hbar k_{f,\alpha}$ represents the Fermi momentum.
175:
176: In order to compare the cases with different values of the statistical parameter $\alpha$, we write the pair correlation function as:
177: \begin{equation} \label{eq:g_zero2}
178: g(y) = 1+\cos(\alpha \pi) \Gamma\left(\frac{d}{2}\right) \frac{2^d}{\alpha y^d} J^2_{d/2}(\alpha^{1/d}y),
179: \end{equation}
180: where $y=k_f r$ is a dimensionless variable, with $k_f$ the Fermi wavevector,
181: which agrees with Eq.~(\ref{eq:Wu_Kfermi}) when $\alpha=1$. For $0<\alpha\leq1$,
182: $g(y)$ has the same functional form of the fermionic limit, the differences
183: being the factor $\cos(\alpha \pi)/\alpha$ and the dependence of $k_{f,\alpha}$
184: on the statistical parameter $\alpha$.
185:
186:
187:
188:
189: \begin{figure}[t]
190: \begin{center}
191: %
192: \begin{minipage}[c]{0.49\textwidth}
193: \begin{center}
194: \includegraphics[width=\textwidth]{fig1a.ps}
195: \end{center}
196: \end{minipage}
197: %\\[0.1truecm]
198: \begin{minipage}[c]{0.49\textwidth}
199: \begin{center}
200: \includegraphics[width=\textwidth]{fig1b.ps}
201: \end{center}
202: \end{minipage}
203: %
204: \end{center}
205: \caption{{\sl (Left)} Pair correlation function $g(y)$ (in scaled units),
206: Eq.~(\ref{eq:g_zero2}), in $d=2$ for $\alpha=0-1$ ($\alpha$ increases from top to
207: bottom). {\sl (Right)} The figure shows Friedel-like oscillations of the pair
208: correlation function, which are present in each case with $\alpha \neq
209: 0,\frac{1}{2}$.}
210: \label{fig:tzero}
211: \end{figure}
212:
213: Figure~\ref{fig:tzero}, on the left hand side, shows the pair correlation
214: function $g(y)$ at $T=0$ in $d=2$ for $\alpha=0-1$. In the fermionic regime
215: ($\frac{1}{2} <\alpha\leq 1$), the pair correlation function exhibits a
216: \emph{hole} centred at $y=0$, whose depth decreases with decreasing $\alpha$
217: until it disappears at $\alpha=\frac{1}{2}$. For $0<\alpha<\frac{1}{2}$ $g(y)$
218: shows a \emph{hill} centred at $y=0$, whose height decreases with increasing
219: $\alpha$. In the bosonic limit ($\alpha=0$), the pair correlation function
220: $g(y)$ is a constant, $g(y)=2$, which is a known result. Figure \ref{fig:tzero},
221: on the right hand side, allows us to appreciate the damped Friedel-like
222: oscillations of the pair correlation function for each non-zero value of the
223: statistical parameter $\alpha$, except for the case $\alpha=\frac{1}{2}$.
224:
225: Making use of Eq.~(\ref{eq:g_zero}) and of the asymptotic properties of the Bessel function $J_\nu(z)$, in the limit $z\gg1$, the wavelength $R$ of the Friedel-like oscillations in the pair correlation function can be derived as:
226: \begin{equation} \label{eq:periodo_zero}
227: R=\frac{2\pi}{k_{f,\alpha}}=\sqrt{\pi} \left(\alpha \Gamma\left(d/2\right) \frac{N}{V}\right)^{-\frac{1}{d}}.
228: \end{equation}
229: For each dimensionality $d$, at $T=0$ and at fixed density $N/V$, the wavelength $R$ depends explicitly on the statistical parameter $\alpha$. Indeed, $R$ increases with decreasing $\alpha$, and in the bosonic limit ($\alpha=0$) the wavelength becomes infinity ($R=\infty$).
230:
231:
232:
233: On the basis of Eq.~(\ref{eq:periodo_zero}), one would find a finite wavelength
234: $R$ also for $\alpha=\frac{1}{2}$. Therefore, the absence of Friedel-like
235: oscillations in the pair correlation function (cf. Fig.~\ref{fig:tzero}, right
236: panel, for $T=0$, and Ref.~\cite{Pellegrino:07} for finite temperature) can only
237: be related to the presence of the vanishing factor $\cos(\alpha\pi)$ in the
238: original definition of the pair correlation function, Eq.~(\ref{eq:gr}). Indeed,
239: in this case the factor $\cos(\alpha\pi)$ cancels every deviation of
240: $g(\textbf{r})$ from unity. In other words, the absence of Friedel-like
241: oscillations in the pair correlation function in the so-called semionic case
242: ($\alpha=\frac{1}{2}$) is not a consequence of the exclusion statistics in
243: momentum space, but of the exchange properties implied in our \emph{ad hoc}
244: generalization of the commutation relations for anyons obeying exclusion
245: statistics \cite{Pellegrino:07}. Qualitatively similar results (not shown here)
246: are obtained in $d=1$ and $d=3$.
247:
248: Generally, Friedel oscillations in the many-body properties of fermion
249: assemblies arise from the presence of a discontinuity in the Fermi distribution
250: function at the Fermi level. This behaviour is characteristic of Wu's
251: distribution function when $\alpha$ is non-zero. In the literature, it is known
252: that at low but finite temperature the Friedel oscillations in the charge
253: density around a screened impurity are exponentially damped with a
254: characteristic decay length $\lambda^2 k_f$, where $\lambda=\hbar \sqrt{2\pi/(m
255: k_B T)}$ is the thermal wavelength. Since at low temperature the behaviour of
256: Wu's distribution function for non-zero $\alpha$ is equivalent to the
257: Fermi-Dirac distribution, we find that the Friedel oscillations are exponentially
258: damped with a characteristic decay length $\lambda^2 k_{f,\alpha}$.
259:
260: Making use of these remarks, we can derive an approximate form of the pair
261: correlation function at finite temperature. The idea consists in weakly
262: modifying the function $g(r)$, Eq.~(\ref{eq:galpha}), which is exact at $T=0$.
263: We multiply it by a damping factor which has a characteristic decay length:
264: \begin{equation} \label{eq:decay_l}
265: L=\lambda^2 k_{f,\alpha}.
266: \end{equation}
267: In this way the approximate correlation function can be defined as:
268: \begin{equation} \label{eq:g_approx}
269: g(r) = 1+\exp \left( {-\frac{r}{L}} \right) \cos(\alpha \pi) \Gamma\left(\frac{d}{2}\right) \left( \frac{2}{k_{f,\alpha} r}\right)^d J^2_{d/2}(k_{f,\alpha} r).
270: \end{equation}
271:
272: Analogously, at $T=0$ we can rewrite the pair correlation function by means of a change of variable, and we obtain:
273: \begin{equation} \label{eq:g_zero2approx}
274: g(y) = 1+\exp \left( {-\frac{y}{Y}} \right)\cos(\alpha \pi) \Gamma\left(\frac{d}{2}\right) \frac{2^d}{\alpha y^d} J^2_{d/2}(\alpha^{1/d}y),
275: \end{equation}
276: where the dimensionless quantity $Y$ acts as a characteristic decay length, and is defined as:
277: \begin{equation} \label{eq:decay_Y}
278: Y=\alpha^{\frac{1}{d}} \lambda^2 k_f^2.
279: \end{equation}
280:
281: \begin{figure}[t]
282: \begin{center}
283: %
284: \begin{minipage}[c]{0.49\textwidth}
285: \begin{center}
286: \includegraphics[width=\textwidth]{fig2a.ps}
287: \end{center}
288: \end{minipage}
289: %\\[0.1truecm]
290: \begin{minipage}[c]{0.49\textwidth}
291: \begin{center}
292: \includegraphics[width=\textwidth]{fig2b.ps}
293: \end{center}
294: \end{minipage}
295: %
296: \end{center}
297: \caption{{\sl (Left)} Approximate pair correlation function $g(y)$ (in scaled
298: units), Eq. (\ref{eq:g_zero2}), in $d=2$ and with $\lambda^d N/V=1/15$, for $0<
299: \alpha \leq 1$ ($\alpha$ increases from top to bottom). {\sl (Right)} Showing
300: Friedel-like oscillations in $g(y)$.}
301: \label{fig:approx}
302: \end{figure}
303:
304: Figure~\ref{fig:approx} shows the approximate pair correlation function in $d=2$
305: for $\lambda^d N/V=1/15$. This value of the scaled density is still far from the
306: classical limit, since the average distance between two particles is comparable
307: to the thermal wavelength. Likewise, the approximate pair correlation function
308: at $T=0$ shows a hill centred at $y=0$ when the statistical parameter $\alpha$
309: is close to the bosonic limit, $0\leq\alpha<\frac{1}{2}$, and shows instead a
310: hole near the fermionic limit, $\frac{1}{2}<\alpha\leq1$.
311:
312: Moroever, Figure~\ref{fig:approx} shows that the oscillations are absent only
313: for $\alpha=0$ and $\frac{1}{2}$. For the cases which are close to the bosonic
314: limit ($0\leq\alpha<\frac{1}{2}$) the damping term extinguishes completely the
315: Friedel-like oscillations. On the other hand, for the cases which are close to
316: the fermionic limit ($\frac{1}{2}<\alpha\leq1$), under the same conditions, the
317: oscillations suffer from a heavy attenuation but are still visible. It is clear
318: from Eq.~(\ref{eq:decay_Y}) that under the same conditions (\emph{i.e.}
319: temperature, density, dimensionality), the damping of the Friedel-like
320: oscillations depends explicitly on the parameter $\alpha$. Indeed, the value of
321: the scaling variable $Y$ increases with increasing $\alpha$. Near the bosonic
322: limit, the characteristic decay length is so short that the oscillations are
323: completely damped out, whereas close to the fermionic limit the characteristic
324: decay length is so large that the first Friedel-like oscillations survive.
325: Pictorially, we can state that the ideal anyonic liquids losing Friedel-like
326: oscillations in their pair correlation function at low $T$, are those which have
327: smaller volume within the generalized Fermi surface.
328:
329: Summarizing, following a proposed generalization of the pair correlation
330: function $g(\textbf{r})$ for a gas of non-interacting anyons obeying exclusion
331: fractional statistics in arbitrary dimensions, we have studied the asymptotic
332: statistical correlations between anyons at $T=0$ and in the limit of low
333: temperature. We find Friedel-like oscillations in $g(\textbf{r})$ in all
334: quasi-fermionic cases at $T=0$, except for the value $\alpha=\frac{1}{2}$ of the
335: statistical parameter. At low temperature, such oscillations are damped
336: exponentially, with a characteristic decay length which increases with
337: decreasing density and increasing dimensionality.
338:
339: \subsection*{Acknowledgements}
340:
341: This paper was brought to completion during a visit of GGNA and NHM to the
342: Department of Physics, University of Antwerp. Thanks are due to Professors C.
343: Van~Alsenoy and D. Lamoen for their warm hospitality. NHM was partially
344: supported by FWO-Vlaanderen under Project No. G.0425.05.
345:
346:
347:
348: \begin{small}
349: \bibliographystyle{pcl}
350: \bibliography{a,b,c,d,e,f,g,h,i,j,k,l,m,n,o,p,q,r,s,t,u,v,w,x,y,z,zzproceedings,Angilella}
351: \end{small}
352:
353:
354:
355:
356: \end{document}
357:
358:
359:
360:
361:
362:
363:
364:
365:
366:
367:
368:
369:
370:
371: