1: \documentclass[12pt,preprint]{aastex}
2: \usepackage{emulateapj5}
3: \begin {document}
4:
5: \title{High Spatial Resolution Mid-IR Imaging of V838 Monocerotis: Evidence of New Circumstellar Dust Creation}
6:
7: \author{John P. Wisniewski\altaffilmark{1}, Mark Clampin \altaffilmark{1},
8: Karen S. Bjorkman\altaffilmark{2}, Richard K. Barry\altaffilmark{1}}
9:
10: \altaffiltext{1}{NASA GSFC Exoplanets and Stellar Astrophysics Lab Code 667,
11: Greenbelt, MD 20771, John.P.Wisniewski@gmail.com, Mark.Clampin@nasa.gov, Richard.K.Barry@nasa.gov}
12: %\altaffiltext{2}{Current Affiliation: NSF Astronomy and Astrophysics Postdoctoral Fellow,
13: %Department of Astronomy, University of Washington,
14: %Box 351580, Seattle, WA 98195, }
15: \altaffiltext{2}{Ritter Observatory, MS \#113, Department of Physics
16: and Astronomy, University of Toledo, Toledo, OH 43606, Karen.Bjorkman@utoledo.edu}
17:
18:
19: \begin{abstract}
20:
21: We report high spatial resolution 11.2 and 18.1 $\mu$m imaging of V838 Monocerotis obtained
22: with Gemini Observatory's Michelle instrument in 2007 March. Strong emission is observed from the unresolved
23: stellar core of V838 Mon in our Gemini imagery, and is confirmed by Spitzer MIPS 24 $\mu$m imaging
24: obtained in 2007 April. The 2007 flux density of the unresolved
25: mid-infrared emission component is $\sim$2 times brighter than that observed in 2004. No clear change
26: in the net amount of 24$\mu$m extended emission is observed between the 2004 and 2007 epoch Spitzer
27: imagery.
28: We interpret these data as evidence that V838 Mon has experienced a new circumstellar dust creation event.
29: We suggest that this newly created dust has condensed from the expanding ejecta produced from V838 Mon's
30: 2002 outburst events, and is most likely clumpy. We speculate that one (or more) of these
31: clumps might have passed through the line-of-sight in late 2006, producing the brief multi-wavelength photometric
32: event reported by \citet{bon06} and \citet{mu07b}. We detect no evidence of extended emission above a level of
33: $\sim$1 mJy at 11.2 $\mu$m and $\sim$7 mJy at 18.1 $\mu$m over radial distances of 1860 - 93000 AU
34: (0$\farcs$3-15$\farcs$0) from the central source. Using the simple assumption that ejecta material expands at
35: a constant velocity of 300-500 km s$^{-1}$, this gap of thermal emission suggests that no significant prior
36: circumstellar dust production events have occurred within the past $\sim$900-1500 years.
37:
38: \end{abstract}
39:
40: \keywords{circumstellar matter ---
41: stars: individual (V838 Monocerotis) ---}
42:
43: \section{Introduction} \label{introduction}
44:
45: V838 Monocerotis experienced three photometric outbursts in
46: early 2002, beginning with an initial event on 2002 January 6.6 \citep{bro02} and continuing with
47: events in 2002 February and 2002 March \citep{kim02,mun05}. The
48: star's spectrum cooled through the F, G, and K spectral types throughout
49: February \citep{mun07}, transitioned to a late M-type giant by 2002 April 16 \citep{rau02}, and had
50: cooled to a L-type supergiant appearance by 2002 October \citep{eva03}. The circumstellar ejecta from the
51: outburst events was not spherically symmetric, as revealed by the intrinsic polarization detected until
52: 2002 February 13 \citep{wi03a,des04}; \citet{wis07} estimated that
53: ejecta located interior to the region producing H$\alpha$ and Ca II emission was flattened by a
54: \textit{minimum} of 10\% from a spheroidal shell. A renewed intrinsic
55: polarization component observed on 2002 October 22 might be attributable to
56: a new source of asymmetrical scatterers in V838 Mon's circumstellar envelope or to a change in the
57: opacity of the existing envelope \citep{wi03b}.
58:
59: V838 Mon produced a spectacular light echo first detected on 2002 February 17
60: by \citet{hen02}, which evolved dramatically over time \citep{bon03}.
61: \citet{ban06} imaged V838 Mon with the \textit{Spitzer Space Telescope}
62: at 24, 70, and 160$\mu$m, and attributed the observed excess of thermal infrared (IR) emission from the
63: unresolved central source as evidence of the formation of circumstellar dust produced by the 2002
64: outbursts. An IR excess was also observed from the spatially resolved light echo, and \citet{ban06}
65: concluded that the source of this emitting dust could have both interstellar and circumstellar components.
66:
67: V838 Mon resides in a young open cluster \citep{afs07} at a distance of
68: 6.2 $\pm$1.2 kpc \citep{spa08}. It has a known, albeit unresolved, B3V binary companion
69: \citep{mun05}. The nature of V838 Mon prior to outburst is a subject of active
70: debate (c.f. \citealt{mun05, tyl05}); a wide variety of mechanisms
71: have been proposed to explain the eruptive events in V838 Mon, including
72: a shell thermonuclear event \citep{mun05}, a born-again star which experienced an accretion
73: event \citep{law05}, a stellar merger \citep{tyl06}, and a star which engulfed several planets
74: \citep{ret06}. Determining the amount and spatial distribution of dust within the V838 Mon line of sight, and
75: quantifying how much is circumstellar versus interstellar in nature, would help constrain whether its outburst
76: mechanism was a variant of a repeatable phenomenon, like a thermonuclear
77: runaway or nova-like explosion, or more likely a singular event, like a stellar merger.
78:
79:
80: \section{Observations} \label{obs}
81:
82: We obtained N$^{'}$ (11.2$\mu$m) and Q$_{a}$ (18.1$\mu$m) imaging of V838 Mon on
83: 2007 March 21-22 using Gemini Obervatory's Michelle imager. Michelle is a 320 x 240 pixel array
84: which has a 32$\farcs$0 x 24$\farcs$0 field of view (0$\farcs$1 per pixel).
85: All observations were obtained using a standard chop-nod mode with the same instrument configuration: a
86: detector position angle of 110$^{\circ}$ east of north, a chop angle of 130$^{\circ}$ east of north,
87: and the maximum chop throw of 15$\farcs$0. The weather and seeing conditions during our observing
88: runs were stable,
89: with FWHM values of individual chop-nod pairs deviating from the average values quoted in
90: Table \ref{obstable} by less than 0$\farcs02$ on 2007 March 21, 0$\farcs$05 on 2007 March 22,
91: 0$\farcs$04 on 2007 August 6, and 0$\farcs$01 on 2007 August 9.
92:
93: The data, summarized in Table 1, were reduced with procedures similar to those prescribed in Gemini's \textit{midir} package. Following
94: combination of individual chop-nod pairs, known image artifacts such as vertical and horizontal ``staircases''
95: were characterized by sampling 15 pixel-wide regions along column and row borders, and removed
96: via custom IDL routines. Cleaned images were registered to a common position and examined
97: for evidence of anomalous elongation along the chop direction, which is known to characterize a
98: fraction of all Michelle data since early 2007. Our final combined images were flux calibrated using
99: observations of Cohen standards \citep{coh99} HD 66141 and HD 60522
100: obtained immediately following our V838 Mon observations. Figure \ref{rawfig} provides a 15$\farcs$0 x
101: 15$\farcs$0 view of our reduced V838 Mon and PSF-star data, plotted on a linear scale in units of mJy.
102:
103: V838 Mon was also imaged with the Multiband Imaging Photometer for Spitzer (MIPS; \citealt{rie04}) on
104: 2007 April 10 by program 30472 (PI K. Su). These data were reduced using version 16.1.0 of the Spitzer pipeline.
105: Earlier epoch MIPS imaging from 2004 October 14 (24$\mu$m) and 2005 April 2 (70$\mu$m) have been
106: previously presented in \citet{ban06}.
107:
108:
109: \section{Analysis} \label{results}
110: \subsection{Photometry of the Unresolved Point Source} \label{phot}
111:
112: We used simple aperture photometry to extract flux densities for the unresolved V838 Mon point source in our
113: Gemini data. We explored the use of 5 circular apertures having radii ranging in size from 0$\farcs$6-3$\farcs$0 for our
114: N$^{'}$ data and from 0$\farcs$7-3$\farcs$0 for our Q$_{a}$ data, and found consistent results from each.
115: The mean flux density values from these apertures, 29.54$\pm$0.14 Jy at 11.2$\mu$m and 36.43$\pm$0.82 Jy
116: at 18.1$\mu$m, are cited in Table \ref{obstable}. The quoted errors are the
117: standard deviations from our different apertures, and provide an estimate of the internal uncertainty in our
118: measurements ($\sim$1\%). Additional uncertainties in the absolute flux calibration, owing to the internal
119: accuracy of the Cohen flux standards and changes in the atmospheric conditions between our observations,
120: are expected to be of order several percent for bright sources observed in stable conditions (K. Volk 2008,
121: personal communication).
122:
123: Spitzer's MIPS observed V838 Mon in 2007, $\sim$2 weeks after our Gemini data were obtained. The 24$\mu$m
124: imagery was heavily saturated at the core. \citet{ban06} reported similar saturation effects in their 2004 24$\mu$m
125: MIPS data. These authors fit a scaled PSF-star to match the brightness of
126: V838 Mon's first airy ring, and replaced the saturated V838 Mon core by the core of this scaled PSF-star to recover
127: a flux density measurement of the unresolved V838 Mon central source (Table \ref{obstable}).
128: To extract similar measurements for the 2007 24$\mu$m MIPS data, we simply scaled and registered the
129: 2004 and 2007 V838 Mon data to match their unsaturated PSF wing regions. The optimal scaling factor
130: yielded a 24$\mu$m flux density of 29.69$\pm$ $^{1.95}_{1.91}$ Jy (Table \ref{obstable}). Note that the quoted
131: error represents the uncertainty we estimated for our image scaling ($\sim$1.5\%) along with the 5\% absolute flux
132: uncertainty of the 2004 Spitzer flux densities reported by \citet{ban06}. Using simple aperture
133: photometry, we also
134: extracted a flux density for the 2007 April Spitzer MIPS 70$\mu$m observation of 7.34$\pm$0.73 Jy
135: (Table \ref{obstable}).
136:
137: The 2007 March Gemini 18.1$\mu$m flux density is consistent with the 2007 April Spitzer 24$\mu$m flux
138: density at the 3$\sigma$ level; these flux densities are a factor of two stronger than that observed
139: in 2004 October observations. Similarly, the 2007 April Spitzer 70$\mu$m flux density is $\sim$2 times stronger than
140: that observed in 2005 April. The amount of excess IR emission associated with the unresolved central source
141: of V838 Mon has clearly increased between 2004/2005 and 2007.
142:
143: \subsection{Extended Emission} \label{ee}
144:
145: Gemini's Michelle provides a 10-fold improvement in spatial resolution compared to Spitzer's MIPS; hence, our data
146: provide us the unique opportunity to search for mid-IR extended emission interior to that probed by \citet{ban06}.
147: Comparison of median azimuthally averaged radial profiles of our 11.2$\mu$m and 18.1$\mu$m imagery of
148: V838 Mon with a similar color PSF-star observation (HD 52666; M2 III), obtained immediately before our V838 Mon
149: data, reveal no convincing evidence of extended emission nearby the stellar core. Measured median FWHM values
150: of V838 Mon and
151: our PSF-star are the same at 11.2 and 18.1 $\mu$m (Table \ref{obstable}) to within the maximum
152: observed deviation amongst chop-nod pairs ($<$0$\farcs$02 at 11.2 $\mu$m and $<$0$\farcs$05 at
153: 18.1 $\mu$m), which quantitatively supports this conclusion.
154:
155: To search for extended emission outside of the immediate vicinity of the stellar core, we used both
156: contemporaneously observed PSF-star observations (HD 52666; Table \ref{obstable})
157: and longer integrations of a PSF-star obtained several months after our V838 Mon observations (HD 168723;
158: Table \ref{obstable}) to model and subtract the PSF from our V838 Mon imagery. The deeper PSF-star
159: observations exhibit marginally different FWHM values as compared to V838 Mon, likely attributable to minor
160: differences in atmospheric conditions, but provide a lower average detector noise
161: background which is better suited to identify faint extended emission far from the V838 Mon stellar core.
162: Figure \ref{psffig} illustrates
163: our V838 Mon imagery following subtraction of optimally scaled and registered PSF-star observations, plotted
164: on a linear stretch in units of mJy, and smoothed by a second-order Gaussian function. We have masked the
165: region inside a radial distance of 0$\farcs$8 (8-pixels), which is dominated by PSF-subtraction residuals, along
166: with a diagonal strip in our N$^{'}$ imagery which exhibited a commonly observed detector artifact which arises when
167: Michelle images bright sources.
168:
169: We detect no convincing evidence of extended emission above a level of $\sim$1 mJy at 11.2 $\mu$m
170: and above a level of $\sim$7 mJy at 18.1 $\mu$m. Applying additional binning
171: or alternate smoothing functions to the data presented in Figure \ref{psffig} yielded no evidence of extended
172: emission above the observed residual detector noise background.
173:
174: As described in Section \ref{phot}, we shifted and scaled the archival 2004 Spitzer MIPS 24$\mu$m data to extract
175: point source photometry for the 2007 Spitzer 24$\mu$m data. The scaling factor we applied to the 2004 data
176: (1.97) led to an optimal cancellation of the PSF wings
177: of the 2007 data in the subtraction process, but produced a large region of over-subtracted flux exterior to the
178: stellar core, whose morphology corresponded to the extended emission reported by \citet{ban06}. Using a
179: circular aperture of radius 80$\farcs$0 and masking the central PSF-core region, we determined the net
180: 24$\mu$m flux density of this oversubtraction region was -0.88 Jy. This is exactly the flux density one would
181: expect to see if the extended emission component did not vary between 2004 and 2007,
182: given the reported 2004 extended emission flux of 0.91 Jy \citep{ban06} and our use of a scaling factor of 1.97, i.e.
183: \begin{displaymath}
184: 24\mu m_{2007} - (1.97 \times 24\mu m_{2004}) = 24\mu m_{net}
185: \end{displaymath}
186: \begin{displaymath}
187: 0.91 Jy - (1.97 \times 0.91 Jy) = -0.88 Jy
188: \end{displaymath}
189: While a comprehensive comparative analysis of the 2004 and 2007 Spitzer MIPS data is outside of
190: the scope of this Letter, our simple analysis suggests a) the amount of 24$\mu$m and 70$\mu$m emission in
191: the unresolved V838 Mon stellar core has increased by a factor of $\sim$2 from 2004 to 2007; and b) the
192: net amount of 24$\mu$m extended emission appears unchanged from 2004 to 2007.
193:
194: \section{Discussion} \label{disc}
195:
196: We detect no
197: evidence of extended 18.1 $\mu$m emission above a level of $\sim$7 mJy from radial distances of
198: 1860 AU (0$\farcs$3) to 93000 AU (15$\farcs$0), assuming a distance of 6.2 kpc \citep{spa08}. Making
199: the simple assumption that V838 Mon's circumstellar ejecta expands at a constant velocity, this gap of thermal IR
200: emission suggests no circumstellar dust producing events have occurred within the past
201: $\sim$900 (if v$_{ejecta}$ $\sim$300 km s$^{-1}$; \citealt{wi03a}) to $\sim$1500 years (if
202: v$_{ejecta}$ $\sim$500 km s$^{-1}$; \citealt{mun02}). Our analysis of 2007 imagery of V838 Mon from
203: both Gemini's Michelle and Spitzer's MIPS
204: indicates the presence of significantly enhanced 10-70$\mu$m emission in the unresolved central stellar core
205: in 2007 as compared to 2004. We interpret our 2007 data as evidence that a \textit{new}
206: circumstellar dust production event has occurred since 2004.
207:
208: Spectroscopic evidence of V838 Mon's binary companion disappeared and H$\alpha$ returned to emission
209: in late 2006, corresponding with a temporary multi-color photometric fading \citep{bon06,mu07b}.
210: \citet{mu07b} attributed
211: these events to either a) an eclipse between the primary and secondary; or b) a dust cloud characterized by
212: E$_{B-V}$ = 0.55 and R$_{V}$ = 3.1, gravitationally
213: bound to the binary system, which eclipsed the B3V secondary. We suggest alternate interpretations are possible
214: if these photometric and spectroscopic events are correlated to the new mid-IR behavior we have
215: found in data from early 2007. A gravitationally bound dust cloud would radiate a constant amount of thermal
216: IR emission throughout its orbit except during the brief time that it is occulted by the secondary; thus, \textit{unless
217: it was only recently formed}, such a cloud could not be singularly responsible for producing the observed enhanced
218: mid-IR emission. A simple eclipse between the primary and secondary also
219: would not lead to enhanced thermal IR emission.
220:
221: \citet{bon06} suggested that the photometric and
222: spectroscopic events of late 2006 were indicative of the 2002 ejecta interacting with and overtaking the B3V
223: binary. More recent observations indicate that V838 Mon is experiencing a prolonged
224: period of reduced photometric brightness (H. Bond 2008, personal communication), further supporting this
225: interpretation. While the temporal resolution of our data do not allow us to quantitatively determine
226: whether this proposed encounter is related to the new circumstellar dust creation event we report, we suggest
227: that such a correlation is plausible.
228:
229: We suggest that the expanding ejecta from the 2002 outbursts has condensed to form \textit{new} circumstellar dust,
230: producing the enhanced IR excess observed inside a radial distance of 1860 AU. The dust condensation radius
231: of $\sim$3.5 AU for the B3V companion, which assumes T$_{cond}$ $\sim$1000K, $R_{cond} \sim\frac{R_{star}}{2} (\frac{T_{star}}{T_{cond}})^{2} $ \citep{ire05}, and the estimated primary-secondary separation of $\sim$34 AU
232: derived from interferometry \citep{lan05}, indicates that dust can survive within the radial distance constraint
233: of $<$1860 AU implied by our observations. This type of event is not altogether unexpected, as \citet{lyn04} previously
234: reported the detection of an expanding region of molecular gas which they noted was likely dust precursor
235: material. The enhanced flux at 18.1, 24, and 70 $\mu$m we observed in 2007
236: suggests that the equally strong (2007 epoch) 11.2 $\mu$m
237: flux might not represent an additional enhancement of gas-phase molecular emission above that suggested by
238: \citet{lyn04}, but rather represents a warm thermal dust emission component.
239:
240: Early post-outburst polarimetric observations \citep{wi03a,des04} indicated this ejecta was
241: asymmetric; hence, we
242: suggest that it is likely that dust which condenses from this ejecta will be spatially non-uniform and/or
243: clumpy. We speculate
244: that it is possible that one or more of these clumps eclipsed the line of sight in late 2006, producing the attenuation
245: event reported by \citet{bon06} and \citet{mu07b}. Unlike the dust cloud eclipse event invoked by \citet{mu07b},
246: we believe that any eclipsing dust blob is more likely to located in the expanding ejecta which is condensing to form
247: new dust. Followup interferometric observations might reveal differences in the angular size of the system
248: from that found in 2004 epoch observations by \citet{lan05} if this ejecta has indeed recently reached the location
249: of the B3V secondary star.
250:
251:
252: \acknowledgments
253:
254: We thank H. Bond, B. Bonev, M. Perrin, A. Roberge, and K. Volk for helpful
255: discussions about our data, and our annonymous referee for providing
256: feedback which helped to improve this paper. Support for this project was provided by a
257: NASA NPP fellowship to JPW (NNH06CC03B).
258:
259:
260: \begin{thebibliography}{}
261:
262: \bibitem[Afsar \& Bond(2007)]{afs07} Afsar, M. \& Bond, H.E. 2007, AJ, 133, 387
263: \bibitem[Banerjee et al.(2006)]{ban06} Banerjee, D.P.K., Su, K.Y.L., Misselt, K.A., \& Ashok, N.M. 2006, ApJL, 644, 57
264: \bibitem[Bond et al.(2003)]{bon03} Bond, H.E. 2003, Nature, 422, 405
265: \bibitem[Bond(2006)]{bon06} Bond, H.E. 2006, ATel, 966
266: \bibitem[Brown et al.(2002)]{bro02} Brown, N.J. et al. 2002, IAU Circ. 7785
267: \bibitem[Cohen et al.(1999)]{coh99} Cohen, M., Walker, R.G., Carter, B., Hammersley, P., Kidger, M.,
268: \& Noguchi, K. 1999, AJ, 117, 1864
269: \bibitem[Desidera \& Munari(2002)]{des02} Desidera, S. \& Munari, U. 2002, IAU Circ. 7982
270: \bibitem[Desidera et al.(2004)]{des04} Desidera, S. et al. 2004, A\&A, 414, 591
271: \bibitem[Evans et al.(2003)]{eva03} Evans, A., Geballe, T.R., Rushton, M.T., Smalley, B., van Loon, J. Th.,
272: Eyres, S.P.S., \& Thne, V.H. 2003, MNRAS, 343, 1054
273: \bibitem[Henden et al.(2002)]{hen02} Henden, A., Munari, U., \& Schwartz, M. 2002, IAU Circ. 7859
274: \bibitem[Ireland et al.(2005)]{ire05} Ireland, M.J., Tuthill, P.G., Davis, J., \& Tango, W. 2005, MNRAS, 361, 337
275: \bibitem[Kimeswenger et al.(2002)]{kim02} Kimeswenger, S., Lederie, C., Schmeja, S., \& Armsdorfer, B.
276: 2002, MNRAS, 336, L43
277: \bibitem[Lanet et al.(2005)]{lan05} Lane, B.F., Retter, A., Thompson, R.R., \& Eisner, J.A. 2005, ApJL, 622, 137
278: \bibitem[Lawlor(2005)]{law05} Lawlor, T.M. 2005, MNRAS, 361, 695
279: \bibitem[Lynch et al.(2004)]{lyn04} Lynch, D.K. et al. 2004, ApJ, 607, 460
280: \bibitem[Munari et al.(2002)]{mun02} Munari, U. et al. 2002, A\&A, 389, 51
281: \bibitem[Munari et al.(2005)]{mun05} Munari, U. et al. 2005, A\&A, 434, 1107
282: \bibitem[Munari et al.(2007a)]{mun07} Munari, U., Navasardyan, H., \& Villanova, S. 2007a, in The Nature of V838 Mon and Its Light Echo, ed. R.L.M. Corradi \& U. Munari, ASP Conf. Ser., 363, 13
283: \bibitem[Munari et al.(2007b)]{mu07b} Munari, U. et al. 2007, A\&A, 474, 585
284: \bibitem[Rauch et al.(2002)]{rau02} Rauch, T., Kerber, F., \& Van Wyk, F. 2002, IAU Circ. 7886
285: \bibitem[Retter et al.(2006)]{ret06} Retter, A., Zhang, B., Siess, L., \& Levinson, A. 2006, MNRAS, 370, 1573
286: \bibitem[Rieke et al.(2004)]{rie04} Rieke, G.H. et al. 2004, ApJS, 154, 25
287: \bibitem[Rushton et al.(2005)]{rus05} Rushton, M.T. et al. 2005, MNRAS, 360, 1281
288: \bibitem[Sparks et al.(2008)]{spa08} Sparks, W.B. 2008, AJ, 135, 605
289: \bibitem[Tylenda et al.(2005)]{tyl05} Tylenda, R., Soker, N., \& Szczerba, R. 2005, A\&A, 441, 1099
290: \bibitem[Tylenda \& Soker(2006)]{tyl06} Tylenda, R. \& Soker, N. 2006, A\&A, 451, 223
291: \bibitem[Wisniewski et al.(2003a)]{wi03a} Wisniewski, J.P. et al. 2003a, ApJ, 588, 486
292: \bibitem[Wisniewski et al.(2003b)]{wi03b} Wisniewski, J.P., Bjorkman, K.S., \& Magalhaes, A.M. 2003b, ApJL, 598, 43
293: \bibitem[Wisniewski(2007)]{wis07} Wisniewski, J.P. 2007, in The Nature of V838 Mon and Its Light Echo, ed. R.L.M.
294: Corradi \& U. Munari, ASP Conf. Ser., 363, 73
295:
296: \end{thebibliography}
297:
298:
299: \clearpage
300: \newpage
301: \begin{table}
302: \begin{center}
303: \footnotesize
304: \caption{Summary of Observations and Flux Densities\label{obstable}}
305: \begin{tabular}{lccccccc}
306: Target & UT Date & Observatory & $\lambda_{central}$ & $\delta\lambda$ & FWHM & Flux Density & Comment \\
307: & & & ($\mu$m) & ($\mu$m) & (arcsec) & (mJy) & \\
308: \tableline
309: V838 Mon & 2004 October 14$^{1}$ & Spitzer & 23.7 & 4.7 & 6$\farcs$0 & 15.06$\pm$0.75$^{2}$ & \citet{ban06} \\
310: V838 Mon & 2005 April 1$^{1}$ & Spitzer & 71.42 & 19 & 18$\farcs$0 & 3.82$\pm$0.38$^{2}$ & \citet{ban06} \\
311: HD 52666 & 2007 March 21 & Gemini & 11.2 & 2.4 & 0$\farcs$40 & \nodata & PSF-star obs \\
312: HD 66141 & 2007 March 21 & Gemini & 11.2 & 2.4 & 0$\farcs$43 & \nodata & flux std \\
313: V838 Mon & 2007 March 21 & Gemini & 11.2 & 2.4 & 0$\farcs$40 & 29.54$\pm$0.14$^{3}$ & \nodata \\
314: V838 Mon & 2007 March 22 & Gemini & 18.1 & 1.9 & 0$\farcs$61 & 36.43$\pm$0.82$^{3}$ & \nodata \\
315: HD 52666 & 2007 March 22 & Gemini & 18.1 & 1.9 & 0$\farcs$57 & \nodata & PSF-star \\
316: HD 60522 & 2007 March 22 & Gemini & 18.1 & 1.9 & 0$\farcs$59 & \nodata & flux std \\
317: V838 Mon & 2007 April 10 & Spitzer & 23.7 & 4.7 & 6$\farcs$0 & 29.67$\pm$$^{1.95}_{1.91}$$^{2}$ & AOR-21475072 \\
318: V838 Mon & 2007 April 10 & Spitzer & 71.42 & 19 & 18$\farcs$0 & 7.34$\pm$0.73$^{2}$ & AOR-21475072 \\
319: HD 168723 & 2007 August 6 & Gemini & 18.1 & 1.9 & 0$\farcs$44 & \nodata & deep PSF-star obs \\
320: HD 168723 & 2007 August 9 & Gemini & 11.2 & 2.4 & 0$\farcs$54 & \nodata & deep PSF-star obs \\
321: \tableline
322: \tablecomments{$^{1}$ 2004/2005 Spitzer flux density measurements were adopted from Table 2 of \citet{ban06}.
323: $^{2}$ The uncertainties quoted for Spitzer flux density measurements, 5\% for 24$\mu$m and 10\% for 70$\mu$m,
324: represent the estimated absolute flux uncertainty. $^{3}$ Gemini flux density error estimates represent the internal
325: uncertainties of the measurements; additional absolute flux scaling uncertainties are expected to be of order several percent for bright sources observed in stable conditions (K Volk 2008,
326: personal communication).}
327: \end{tabular}
328: \end{center}
329: \end{table}
330:
331:
332: \clearpage
333: \newpage
334: \begin{figure}
335: \includegraphics[scale=0.25]{f1.eps}
336: \figcaption[f1.eps]{Reduced imagery spanning a 15$\farcs$0 x 15$\farcs$0 field of view and plotted on a linear
337: scale in units of mJy. The displayed panels include (a) N$^{'}$-band V838 Mon; (b) N$^{'}$-band HD 52666
338: (PSF-star); (c) N$^{'}$-band HD 168723 (deep PSF-star); (d) Qa-band V838 Mon; (e) Qa-band HD 52666
339: (PSF-star); and (f) Qa-band HD 168723 (deep PSF-star) imagery. The diagonal dark lanes seen prominently in
340: panels a-d are known detector artifacts which arise when Gemini's Michelle observes bright sources. \label{rawfig}}
341: \end{figure}
342:
343:
344: \clearpage
345: \newpage
346: \begin{figure}
347: \includegraphics[scale=0.6]{f2.eps}
348: \figcaption[f2.eps]{SED of the unresolved point source flux of V838 Mon, based on the flux densities listed
349: in Table \ref{obstable}. The 2007 Gemini and Spitzer data, obtained $\sim$2 weeks apart, are consistent
350: to within 3$\sigma$ of the total error budget of each observation. The IR excess emission at $\sim$20$\mu$m
351: and 70$\mu$m has clearly increased between 2004 and 2007. We interpret this as evidence that a
352: circumstellar dust production event has recently occurred. \label{sedfig}}
353: \end{figure}
354:
355: \clearpage
356: \newpage
357: \begin{figure}
358: \includegraphics[scale=0.3]{f3.eps}
359: \figcaption[f3.eps]{PSF-subtracted V838 Mon imagery plotted on different linear scales in units of mJy. The field of
360: view, 15$\farcs$0 x 15$\farcs$0, lies entirely inside of region of extended emission detected by Spitzer's
361: MIPS in 2004 \citep{ban06}. The displayed panels include (a) N$^{'}$-band imagery using
362: HD 52666 as the PSF-star; (b) N$^{'}$-band imagery using HD 168723 as the PSF-star; (c) Qa-band
363: imagery using HD 52666 as the PSF-star; and (d) Qa-band imagery using HD 168723 as the PSF-star. Regions
364: inside a radial distance of 0$\farcs$8 (8-pixels) were contaminated by PSF subtraction residuals and are
365: therefore masked in the displayed imagery. We detect no clear evidence of excess extended emission in
366: these data. \label{psffig}}
367: \end{figure}
368:
369:
370:
371:
372:
373:
374: \end{document}
375: