1: \documentclass[12pt,preprint]{aastex}
2: %\documentclass[preprint]{aastex}
3: %\documentstyle[emulateapj]{article}
4:
5: \shortauthors{Matthews \& Uson}
6: \shorttitle{Disk Corrugations in IC~2233}
7:
8: \begin{document}
9:
10: \newcommand{\ang}{\rm \AA}
11: \newcommand{\msun}{M$_\odot$}
12: \newcommand{\lsun}{L$_\odot$}
13: \newcommand{\days}{$d$}
14: \newcommand{\degree}{$^\circ$}
15: \newcommand{\ud}{{\rm d}}
16: \newcommand{\as}[2]{$#1''\,\hspace{-1.7mm}.\hspace{.0mm}#2$}
17: \newcommand{\am}[2]{$#1'\,\hspace{-1.7mm}.\hspace{.0mm}#2$}
18: \newcommand{\ad}[2]{$#1^{\circ}\,\hspace{-1.7mm}.\hspace{.0mm}#2$}
19: \newcommand{\lsim}{~\rlap{$<$}{\lower 1.0ex\hbox{$\sim$}}}
20: \newcommand{\gsim}{~\rlap{$>$}{\lower 1.0ex\hbox{$\sim$}}}
21: \newcommand{\HA}{H$\alpha$}
22: \newcommand{\HII}{\mbox{H\,{\sc ii}}}
23: \newcommand{\NII}{\mbox{N\,{\sc ii}}}
24: \newcommand{\kms}{\mbox{km s$^{-1}$}}
25: \newcommand{\HI}{\mbox{H\,{\sc i}}}
26: \newcommand{\KI}{\mbox{K\,{\sc i}}}
27: \newcommand{\popI}{\mbox{Population\,{\sc i}}}
28: \newcommand{\nan}{Nan\c{c}ay}
29: \newcommand{\galex}{{\it GALEX}}
30: \newcommand{\jks}{Jy~km~s$^{-1}$}
31:
32:
33: \title{Corrugations in the Disk of the Edge-On Spiral
34: Galaxy IC~2233}
35: \author{L. D. Matthews\altaffilmark{1} \& Juan M. Uson\altaffilmark{2}}
36:
37: \altaffiltext{1}{Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics,
38: 60 Garden Street, Cambridge, MA, USA 02138}
39: \altaffiltext{2}{National Radio Astronomy Observatory, 520 Edgemont
40: Road, Charlottesville, VA USA 22903}
41:
42: \begin{abstract}
43: %
44: We recently reported the discovery of a
45: regular corrugation pattern in the \HI\ disk of
46: the isolated, edge-on spiral galaxy IC~2233. Here we present
47: measurements of the vertical structure of this galaxy at several
48: additional wavelengths, ranging from the far ultraviolet to the far
49: infrared. We find that undular patterns with amplitude $\lsim 5''$
50: ($\lsim$250~pc) are
51: visible in a variety of \popI\ tracers in IC~2233, including the
52: young-to-intermediate age stars, the \HII\ regions, and the dust.
53: However, the
54: vertical excursions become less pronounced in the older stellar populations
55: traced by the
56: mid-infrared light. This suggests that the process leading to the
57: vertical displacements may be linked with the regulation of star
58: formation in the galaxy. We have also identified
59: a relationship between the locations
60: of the density corrugations and small-amplitude ($\lsim$5~\kms)
61: velocity undulations in the \HI\
62: rotation curve. We are able to exclude several possible mechanisms
63: for the origin of the observed corrugations, including tidal
64: interaction from a companion, Parker instabilities, or a galactic bore.
65: Global gravitational instabilities appear to be the most
66: likely explanation, although
67: local perturbations may also be important.
68: \end{abstract}
69:
70:
71: \keywords{galaxies: spiral -- galaxies: Individual (IC~2233) --
72: galaxies: structure -- ISM: structure -- instabilities}
73:
74:
75: \section{Introduction}
76: %
77: It is well known that the disks of late-type galaxies are
78: not completely
79: flat. Warping of the outer gas disk into an
80: ``integral sign''
81: shape is a nearly ubiquitous feature of
82: spiral galaxies, even those that appear to be quite isolated
83: (Garc\'\i a-Ruiz et al. 2002). A significant fraction of
84: galaxies also have warped stellar disks
85: (S\'anchez-Saavedra et al. 1990; Reshetnikov \& Combes 1998).
86: For several decades it has been recognized that the \HI\ disk and other
87: \popI\ components of the Milky Way
88: exhibit an additional type of vertical structure in the form of
89: systematic displacements from the mean plane known as
90: ``corrugations''
91: (e.g., Gum et al. 1960; Quiroga 1974,1977; Lockman 1977; Sanders et
92: al. 1984). These
93: corrugations are present along both radial and azimuthal directions
94: and have scales ranging from $\sim$50 to 350~pc in amplitude and from
95: one to several kiloparsecs in wavelength (Spicker \& Feitzinger
96: 1986).
97:
98: Despite
99: predictions that corrugations may be a common phenomenon in disk galaxies,
100: systematic searches for these features have been limited, and
101: consequently, little has
102: been known about their true frequency of occurrence in external galaxies.
103: To date, evidence of corrugations has been reported
104: for only a handful of cases outside the Milky Way: in
105: the emission nebulae of M31 (Arp 1964), in the
106: stellar (optical) light of three edge-on, late-type
107: galaxies (Florido et al. 1991,1992), and in the velocity structure of
108: the face-on spiral NGC~5427 (Alfaro et al. 2001).
109:
110: The origin of disk corrugations is a matter of longstanding debate
111: given the small number of galaxies in which they have so far been detected
112: (see the reviews by
113: Alfaro \& Efremov 1996 and
114: Alfaro 2003). Suggestions have included:
115: gravitational instabilities (e.g., Nelson 1976); tidal interactions (Edelsohn
116: \& Elmegreen 1997), collisions of high-velocity clouds with the disk
117: (Franco et al. 1988;
118: Santill\'an et al. 1999); interaction of spiral waves with the gaseous
119: disk (Alfaro et al. 2001); and the undular mode of the Parker
120: instability (Franco et al. 2002).
121: Depending on their origin, the presence or absence of corrugations
122: can provide important
123: clues into the role of magnetic fields on galaxy disk
124: structure (e.g., Spicker \&
125: Feitzinger 1986; Santill\'an et al. 2000; Franco et al. 2002),
126: the formation of
127: molecular clouds (e.g., Nelson \& Matsuda 1980),
128: the degree of self-gravity of galaxy disks (e.g.,
129: Revaz \& Pfenniger 2004), or the timescales of recent interactions
130: (e.g., Edelsohn \& Elmegreen 1997). Moreover,
131: current evidence suggests that whatever the physical
132: process(es) responsible for corrugations, they are
133: closely linked to the mechanisms responsible
134: for the formation of the dense gas condensations and therefore with the
135: regulation of star formation
136: (e.g., Nelson \& Matsuda 1980; Alfaro et al. 1992;
137: Alfaro \& Efremov 1996; Alfaro 2003).
138:
139: In a recent paper (Matthews \& Uson 2008; hereafter MU08),
140: we presented optical and \HI\
141: imaging observations of the nearby, edge-on spiral galaxy IC~2233.
142: There we reported the discovery of a
143: corrugated pattern in the \HI\ disk of this galaxy---i.e., we found that
144: the \HI\ layer of IC~2233 exhibits a remarkably regular pattern of
145: positive and negative vertical displacements from the kinematically-defined
146: midplane. This pattern has a wavelength of $\sim150''$
147: (7~kpc) and an amplitude that increases with distance from the center
148: of the galaxy, reaching a maximum of $\sim3''$
149: ($\sim$150~pc).\footnote[3]{Throughout this paper we assume a distance to
150: IC~2233 of 10~Mpc (see MU08).} [For comparison, the
151: FWHM thickness of the \HI\ layer ranges from $\sim$\as{10}{4} near the
152: disk center to $\sim$\as{20}{3} toward the outer disk (MU08)].
153: Subsequently, we have explored the vertical
154: structure of IC~2233 using a variety of additional tracers of the
155: stellar and interstellar components of its disk. We have also examined
156: the relationship between the peaks of the vertical \HI\ excursions
157: with both \HI\ density enhancements along the disk and with
158: velocity perturbations in the disk rotation curve. Here
159: we report the discovery of undular patterns in several additional
160: \popI\ tracers in IC~2233.
161: In contrast, we find the vertical
162: displacements are minimal in the old stars. We also report the discovery of a
163: link between the locations of the peak excursions from the
164: midplane in \HI\ with features in the \HI\ rotation curve.
165: In \S~\ref{discussion} we discuss the implications of these findings
166: for understanding the origin of the disk corrugations seen in
167: IC~2233 and other galaxies.
168:
169:
170: \section{A Multiwavelength Analysis of the Vertical Structure of
171: IC~2233}
172: %
173: IC~2233 is a bulgeless Sd galaxy located at a
174: distance of $\sim$10~Mpc. It has a moderately low surface brightness,
175: ``superthin'' disk structure (Goad
176: \& Roberts 1981) and a low current star formation rate
177: ($\lsim0.05~M_{\odot}$~yr$^{-1}$; MU08).
178: The transparency and structural simplicity
179: of IC~2233 make it well-suited to a detailed
180: vertical structure analysis. IC~2233 also appears to be
181: a very isolated system (MU08), implying that its disk structure should
182: be minimally affected by external perturbations.
183:
184: \subsection{The Data\protect\label{data}}
185: %
186: To investigate the vertical structure of the \HI\ disk of IC~2233, MU08
187: extracted a series of \HI\ intensity profiles perpendicular to the disk,
188: spaced at regular intervals. These profiles were derived from an
189: \HI\ total intensity image with a spatial resolution of
190: $\sim16''$. The position angle for the galaxy was taken to be
191: 172$^{\circ}$, and the adopted center of the galaxy, ($x,z$)=(0,0),
192: was the kinematic center established by
193: MU08: $\alpha_{J2000}=08^{h}~13^{m}~58.9^{s}$,
194: $\delta_{J2000}=+45^{\circ}~44'~$~\as{27}{0}.
195: (Here $x$ is the distance along the galaxy
196: major axis, with values increasing toward
197: the north, and $z$ is taken as the
198: distance above the midplane, with positive values to the east.)
199: MU08 fitted a single Gaussian to each intensity
200: slice and plotted the displacement of the computed centroid from the
201: midplane ($z$=0)
202: as a function of distance along the major axis. The resulting
203: ``corrugation curve'' for the \HI\ data is reproduced in the upper
204: left panel of Figure~\ref{fig:corplots}.
205:
206: The arrows on the upper left panel
207: of Figure~\ref{fig:corplots} indicate the
208: extent of the stellar disk of
209: IC~2233, as determined from the 25 magnitude
210: arcsec$^{-2}$ $B$-band isophote. It can be seen that
211: near the edge of the stellar disk, the \HI\ layer
212: twists to form an ``integral sign'' warp. On the side of the disk
213: where the \HI\ layer is more extended, the layer bends back
214: toward the midplane at larger radii. However, at small and
215: intermediate projected radii, regular
216: undulations are clearly visible across the disk of the galaxy.
217: Furthermore, it can be seen that a portion of the galaxy near $x=0$
218: is displaced
219: from the kinematically-defined
220: center-of-mass. One possible explanation is that
221: this is linked with the presence of an inner bar.
222:
223: To insure that our derived \HI\ corrugation curve is not significantly
224: impacted by optical depth effects,
225: we have compared \HI\ intensity profiles extracted from
226: channel images with 16$''$ resolution (presented in MU08) with the corresponding ones made
227: with more uniform weighting of the raw visibilities (i.e., with a robustness
228: parameter ${\cal R}$ = $-1$), which leads to images with $12''$
229: resolution, albeit with rms noise about 40\% higher. We find that
230: the respective profiles and centroids agree to within the errors, although
231: the higher resolution images resolve out some of the more diffuse \HI\
232: component. The peak \HI\ brightness temperatures are $\sim 130$~K for
233: the $12''$ images and $\sim 108$~K for the $16''$ images, respectively, near the
234: position of the kinematic center of IC~2233 and at the systemic
235: velocity. Examination of the profiles shows that the \HI\ is optically
236: thin with $\tau\lsim0.02$. This is consistent with the generally
237: excellent agreement between the \HI\ and \HA\ rotation curves (see Figure~13 of MU08).
238:
239: To better constrain the nature and origin
240: of the corrugations in IC~2233, we have now extended our analysis of
241: its vertical disk structure using a number of additional data sets,
242: spanning far-ultraviolet (FUV) to far-infrared (FIR) wavelengths
243: (Table~1). For each wavelength, we have computed a corrugation curve in a
244: manner analogous to that used for the \HI\ data. The results are
245: presented in electronic form in Table~2.
246: We have compared the
247: positions of background radio sources and foreground stars
248: with catalogued values from the NRAO VLA Sky Survey (Condon et
249: al. 1998) and the Tycho Reference Catalogue (H$\o$g et al. 2000),
250: respectively.
251: With the exception of the 70$\mu$m and 160$\mu$m images (where no
252: foreground or background sources useful for registration were detected), we
253: find that astrometric registration between images at different
254: wavelengths is accurate to
255: within a small fraction of a resolution element. Therefore,
256: we assume that astrometric uncertainties do not
257: impact our results unless explicitly noted.
258:
259: Because of the low surface brightness nature of IC~2233, we have also
260: assumed that optical depth effects have a minimal impact on our
261: analysis at all available wavelengths. Above we noted that the \HI\
262: optical depth of the galaxy is
263: extremely low. At visible wavelengths the optical depth of IC~2233 also appears to be
264: minimal. MU08 estimated
265: the $B$-band extinction toward the center of the galaxy to be
266: $\sim$0.7 magnitudes, but this is likely to be an upper limit, as
267: fits to the radial surface brightness profiles of IC~2233 show that the
268: light distribution is more strongly peaked than predicted by a simple
269: exponential disk model, and both the WIYN images published by
270: MU08 and the {\it Hubble Space Telescope} images published by Seth et al. (2005) reveal
271: that there are very few optically thick dust clumps in this galaxy and no true dust
272: lane. Because of this, optical depth effects are expected to be
273: negligible in all of the {\it Spitzer} bands. The optical depth of
274: IC~2233 at UV wavelengths is more uncertain. However,
275: better characterization of this will require detailed radiative transfer
276: modelling (see e.g., Matthews \& Wood 2001)
277: and is beyond the scope of the present paper.
278:
279: \clearpage
280: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
281: % --- Table 1
282: %
283: \begin{deluxetable}{lccccl}
284: \tabletypesize{\tiny}
285: \tablewidth{0pc}
286: \tablenum{1}
287: \tablecaption{Data Sets used for Vertical Structure Analysis of
288: IC~2233}
289:
290: \tablehead{
291: \colhead{Descriptor} & \colhead{Wavelength} & \colhead{Telescope} &
292: \colhead{FWHM PSF ($''$)} & \colhead{Reference} & \colhead{Dominant Components
293: traced}
294: }
295:
296: \startdata
297:
298: NUV & 1350-1750\AA\ & {\it GALEX} & 4.6 & 1 &
299: young-to-intermediate age stars; B-star photospheres\\
300:
301: FUV & 1750-3000\AA\ & {\it GALEX} & 4.6 & 1 & young-to-intermediate age
302: stars ($<10^{8}$ yr); B-star photospheres\\
303:
304: $R$ & 5631-7156\AA\ & WIYN & 0.6 & 2 & young-to-intermediate age
305: stars (up to $\sim10^{9}$~yr)\\
306:
307: \HA$^{\rm a}$ & 6534-6606\AA\ & WIYN & 0.7 & 2 & ionized gas
308: associated with young ($<10^{7}$ yr), massive stars \\
309:
310: 3.6$\mu$m & 3.18-3.94$\mu$m & {\it Spitzer} (IRAC) &1.7 & 3
311: & old stellar populations; M-star photospheres\\
312:
313: 4.5$\mu$m &4.02-5.02$\mu$m & {\it Spitzer} (IRAC) &1.7 & 3
314: & old stellar populations; M-star photospheres\\
315:
316: %5.8$\mu$m$^{\rm b}$ & 5.02-6.44$\mu$m & {\it Spitzer} (IRAC) & 1.9 &
317: %3 & PAHs \\
318:
319: 8.0$\mu$m$^{\rm b}$ & 6.44-9.38$\mu$m & {\it Spitzer} (IRAC) & 2.0 &
320: 3 & PAHs (linked with spiral arms, molecular clouds)\\
321:
322: 24$\mu$m & 18.0-32.2$\mu$m & {\it Spitzer} (MIPS) &6 & 3 &
323: hot dust near sites of high-mass star formation\\
324:
325: 70$\mu$m & 50.0-111.0$\mu$m & {\it Spitzer} (MIPS) &18 & 3
326: & warm dust linked with star formation\\
327:
328: 160$\mu$m & 100.1-199.9$\mu$m & {\it Spitzer} (MIPS) & 40 &3
329: & cool, extended dust; infrared cirrus\\
330: %ref: Bendo et al. 2006; Hinz et al. 2004
331:
332: \HI\ & 21~cm & VLA & 16 & 2 & neutral, atomic gas\\
333:
334: \enddata
335:
336: %\tablecomments{}
337:
338: \tablenotetext{a}{Continuum-subtracted; includes a modest ($<10$\%)
339: contribution from [\NII].}
340: \tablenotetext{b}{Data are uncorrected for the contribution from stellar
341: photospheric emission.}
342:
343: \tablerefs{(1) Gil de Paz et al. 2007; (2) MU08; (3) L. D. Matthews \&
344: K. Wood, in prep. }
345:
346: \end{deluxetable}
347: \clearpage
348: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
349:
350:
351: \subsection{Results: Multiwavelength Corrugation Curves\protect\label{results}}
352: %
353: Figure~\ref{fig:corplots} shows corrugation plots derived from the
354: datasets summarized in Table~1. Alongside each curve, a
355: representation
356: of IC~2233 at the corresponding wavelength
357: is shown. For reference, each of the
358: panels shows overplotted a polynomial fit to the \HI\ data
359: points lying within the boundaries of the stellar disk
360: (i.e., excluding
361: the outer disk regions where warping dominates the
362: vertical structure). Gaps in the corrugation
363: plots near $x\approx50''-70''$ at some wavelengths are due to
364: contamination from a foreground star.
365:
366: Figure~\ref{fig:corplots} illustrates that excursions from the midplane
367: of up to $\sim5''$ ($\lsim$250~pc) are present in a variety of
368: tracers in IC~2233.
369: In the case of the mid-infrared (3.6$\mu$m and 4.5$\mu$m)
370: continuum, these highest-amplitude
371: excursions occur only at the edges of
372: the disk and can be attributed to the disk warp; however,
373: at all other wavelengths shown in Figure~\ref{fig:corplots},
374: undulations with amplitudes of up to
375: $\sim5''$ are present at low and intermediate projected radii
376: along the disk. None of these vertical undulations are as regular
377: as those observed in \HI; nonetheless, some interesting relationships
378: emerge between the patterns seen in various tracers.
379:
380: In the southern portion of the galaxy (i.e., along negative
381: $x$ values), we see that tracers of young to intermediate-age
382: stellar populations
383: (NUV, FUV, \HA, and $R$-band)
384: bend away from the plane with the same sign and
385: comparable
386: amplitude to that observed in \HI\ ($\Delta z\sim+5''$). For the
387: NUV and FUV light, there is some hint of a
388: slight phase lag with
389: respect to the \HI\ curve. This correlation is largely maintained in
390: the northern portion of the galaxy, to roughly $x\lsim 40''$. In contrast, further north
391: ($x\gsim 70''$), the vertical
392: structure of these
393: tracers diverges sharply from what is seen in \HI; here,
394: excursions are
395: observed toward positive $z$, while the \HI\ layer bends toward
396: negative $z$ values. Only beyond $x\gsim120''$ do the vertical
397: centroids again converge to values similar to
398: those observed in \HI. Visual
399: inspection of the UV, $R$-band, and \HA\ images
400: suggests that
401: higher frequency undulations may also be present in these bands. These
402: are difficult to quantitatively characterize, but
403: may account for some of the scatter seen in these tracers.
404:
405: Turning toward tracers of the dust component in IC~2233,
406: vertical undulations are also
407: clearly visible. The corrugation curve derived from the
408: 8$\mu$m light (believed to be dominated by PAH emission)
409: exhibits a pattern comparable in shape to the \HI\ data, but with
410: larger dispersion.
411: Both the 24$\mu$m and the 70$\mu$m corrugation curves also show
412: close agreement with the \HI\ data over much of the disk.
413: The exception is the region between $x\approx 40''-100''$ where the
414: 24$\mu$m and 70$\mu$m emission diverge sharply from the \HI.
415: In other galaxies
416: both the 8$\mu$m and 70$\mu$m emission have
417: been found to have distributions similar to the
418: \HI\ gas (e.g., Helou et al. 2001; Walter et al. 2007),
419: although the PAH emission tends to correlate more closely with the
420: molecular gas and cold dust, while the 70$\mu$m tends to be most prominent in
421: the highest \HI\ column density regions.
422:
423: The vertical structure of the cool dust traced by the 160$\mu$m light
424: shows relatively little correlation with any other wavelength. Our
425: sensitivity is too limited to detect the outer $\sim$20\% of the
426: galaxy at this wavelength, and in addition,
427: the low resolution of these data
428: ($40''$) makes the uncertainty in the
429: location of the zero point comparable to the
430: amplitude of the vertical excursions. Nonetheless, the data
431: are clearly inconsistent with a flat, planar
432: distribution for the cool dust. On the northern side of the galaxy,
433: the 160$\mu$m emission appears qualitatively similar to the 70$\mu$m
434: emission, although the amplitude of the vertical excursions
435: appears larger. On the
436: southern side of the disk, the 160$\mu$m emission appears to be
437: anticorrelated with the \HI\ (and with all the other
438: tracers). Convolving and resampling the 70$\mu$m image to match the resolution and
439: pixel size of the 160$\mu$m data, we were unable to reproduce either
440: of these trends from resolution effects alone.
441: %cf. Cannon et al. 2006
442:
443: The divergent behavior between several of the \popI\ tracers
444: on the northern side of IC~2233 complicates the description of the
445: galaxy as a simple
446: undulating plane. While projection effects due to warping or to the different
447: radial extents of various tracers may make some contribution to
448: these differences, there is no {\it a priori}
449: reason to expect that these effects should be more severe on the northern side
450: of the galaxy. Therefore, the observed differences between the vertical
451: displacements of different disk components should
452: offer some clues on the origin of
453: the corrugation patterns and their possible link to the regulation of star
454: formation in the galaxy. For this reason, we now examine some of these differences in
455: greater detail.
456:
457: Visual inspection of the UV, $R$, and \HA\ images between $x\approx70''$-$120''$
458: reveals that
459: the vertical intensity profiles in these bands are
460: dominated by the light associated with
461: a smattering of compact \HII\ regions located several arcseconds above the
462: plane. The brightest of these (near $x\approx80''$) has counterparts at
463: 24$\mu$m and 70$\mu$m.
464: Interestingly, this
465: position also corresponds to the location of the only major disparity between the \HI\
466: and \HA\ rotation curves for the IC~2233; here, the \HA\ curve dips
467: toward the systemic velocity by $\sim$~35~\kms\ (see Figure~13 of
468: MU08). This difference between the \HI\ and \HA\ rotation curves suggests
469: that either there is an absence of ionized gas at the tangent point
470: along this line-of-sight, or else that the ionized material along this
471: direction has been kinematically
472: perturbed. The former scenario
473: seems more likely given that we detect
474: significant \HI\ emission near $x=80''$ at the same
475: velocity as the \HA\ emission (see Figure~11 of MU08).
476: However, the second possibility cannot be ruled out (see also \S~\ref{tides}).
477:
478: In the \HI\ total intensity image of IC~2233, we see a distinct \HI\ clump
479: near $x\approx100''$ that is visibly
480: displaced toward negative $z$ values (Figure~1). Tracers of hot young stars (FUV,
481: NUV, \HA, $R$-band) all show a depressed surface brightness at
482: the corresponding location, although we do
483: detect counterparts to the \HI\ clump at
484: 8.0$\mu$m, 24$\mu$m, 70$\mu$m, and 100$\mu$m. This dearth of starlight coupled
485: with the presence of FIR emission suggests that this sight-line may
486: intersect a young star-forming region where the gas is still predominantly
487: cold and dense. Recent studies show
488: that PAH emission tends to be a good proxy for dense
489: molecular gas in quiescent galaxies (e.g.,
490: Haas et al. 2002; Paladino et al. 2008), while emission at longer IR
491: wavelengths can be a hallmark of hot young stellar objects that are still highly
492: embedded. The disparity between the vertical structure of different
493: \popI\ tracers near this location thus
494: could be partly a consequence of this region
495: being at an earlier evolutionary state compared with
496: some of the other optically prominent star-forming regions in the galaxy.
497:
498: \section{A Search for Velocity Corrugations}
499: %
500: Models for the origin
501: of structural corrugations in disk galaxies also predict corrugations in the
502: velocity field (see Alfaro et al. 2001 and references therein).
503: The amplitude of the velocity corrugations and the
504: relationship between velocity and structural
505: corrugations can in principle be used to distinguish between
506: various models for their origin.
507: Unfortunately, with the exception of the Milky Way, it is
508: difficult to measure both types of corrugations
509: in the same galaxy.
510:
511: To explore whether any systematic patterns are discernible in the velocity
512: field of IC~2233, we have re-examined the observed \HI\ rotation curve
513: from MU08. We have
514: parameterized the approaching and receding sides of the
515: curve with a
516: Brandt (1960) function of the form:
517:
518: \begin{equation}
519: V(x)=V_{\rm sys} + \left[V_{\rm max}
520: \left(\frac{x}{x_{\rm max}}\right)\right]
521: \left[\frac{1}{3} + \frac{2}{3}\left(\frac{x}{x_{\rm max}}\right)^n\right]^{\frac{-3~}{2n}}
522: \end{equation}
523: % p. 75 Combes et al.
524:
525: \noindent where $V_{\rm sys}=554.7$~\kms, $V_{\rm
526: max}=$85.0~\kms, $x_{\rm max}$=\as{281}{4}, and $n$=1.09.
527: A comparison with this type of smooth, idealized curve
528: can help to highlight subtle, systematic excursions from the
529: expected circular velocity at a given radius. In
530: Figure~\ref{fig:velres} we
531: plot the residual velocity difference between
532: the observed rotation curve and the Brandt model as a function of distance
533: along the major axis. The dashed sections of the curve designate the
534: portions of the \HI\ disk where warping dominates the vertical structure
535: (see above).
536:
537: The residual curve in Figure~\ref{fig:velres} reveals that the
538: observed radial velocities along the IC~2233 disk exhibit
539: systematic positive and negative excursions from the Brandt
540: model, with amplitudes of $\lsim\pm$5~\kms. This type of systematic
541: ``waviness''
542: has been seen previously in the rotation curves of other disk
543: galaxies, particularly those with spiral
544: arms (e.g., de Vaucouleurs \& de Vaucouleurs 1963;
545: Pi\c{s}mi\c{s} 1965; Fridman et al. 1998; Alfaro et al 2001).
546: However, what is particularly striking in the case of IC~2233 is
547: that the locations of the local minima and maxima in the residual velocity
548: curve correspond closely
549: to the locations of the peak vertical structural
550: excursions observed in the \HI\ gas.
551:
552:
553: \section{Discussion\protect\label{discussion}}
554: %
555: As noted above, a number of mechanisms have been proposed to
556: account for the observed corrugations in disk galaxies.
557: We now discuss the suitability of several of these mechanisms for
558: explaining the observed corrugations in IC~2233.
559:
560: \subsection{Tidal Interactions\protect\label{tides}}
561: %
562: Numerical modelling by Edelsohn \& Elmegreen (1997) demonstrated that tidal
563: interactions with a low-mass
564: companion are one means of producing a corrugated disk
565: structure. In this model, the
566: companion generates a spiral-shaped wave that
567: propagates inwards from the edge of the disk, resulting in perpendicular
568: motions. Although the simulations of Edelsohn \& Elmegreen
569: were performed for a Milky
570: Way-like galaxy and a perturber roughly 8\% as massive, the results exhibit
571: qualitative similarities to our observations of IC~2233. However,
572: MU08 found that IC~2233 appears to
573: be an extremely isolated galaxy, exhibiting no obvious signs of
574: a recent interaction or minor merger. This casts significant doubt upon
575: tidal effects as being the
576: primary driver of the vertical disk
577: structure of IC~2233. In
578: addition, since tidally induced corrugations are excited from the
579: outer regions of the disk (see Edelsohn \& Elmegreen 1997), this does
580: not provide a natural explanation for the ``null'' seen at the
581: kinematic center of IC~2233 (see
582: \S~\ref{data} and Figure~\ref{fig:corplots}).
583: Interestingly, at least one of the galaxies
584: found by Florido et al. (1991) to have disk corrugations (NGC~4244),
585: also appears to be quite isolated (Dahlem et al. 2005).
586: A search for corrugations in additional isolated systems, coupled with
587: deep searches for low-mass companions, could provide
588: better statistical constraints on the likely role of companions in
589: exciting corrugated patterns.
590:
591: While an intrusion from a companion galaxy seems unlikely in the case
592: of IC~2233, the influence of impacts from very
593: low-mass perturbers ($\lsim10^{6}~M_{\odot}$), such as
594: high-velocity clouds, cannot be entirely ruled out.
595: Based on their energetics, high-velocity cloud impacts were the
596: explanation favored by Alfaro et al. (1991) to account for vertical
597: displacements of the midplane of the Milky Way and their associated
598: star formation activity (see also Franco et al. 1988). Moreover,
599: IC~2233 is known to have a vertically
600: extended \HI\ component that is kinematically distinct from
601: the main disk component (MU08), and whose presence suggests that the
602: circulation of \HI\ material between the plane and higher
603: galactocentric latitudes is actively occurring (e.g., Fraternali \&
604: Binney 2008). While it would be difficult to explain how a {\it global}
605: corrugation structure as regular
606: as that seen in the \HI\ disk of IC~2233 could be explained by a series of cloud
607: impacts, such events may help to account for {\it local} vertical displacements
608: and offsets between certain disk components. For example, such an event offers
609: one possible explanation for the differences in the vertical structure
610: of various disk tracers that is observed over a portion of the
611: northern half of IC~2233 as well as the perturbation in the \HA\
612: rotation curve observed near this position (see \S~\ref{results}).
613:
614: \subsection{Galactic Bores}
615: %
616: The results presented
617: in Figure~\ref{fig:velres} seem to exclude another class of model for
618: explaining the
619: vertical meanderings of the IC~2233 disk. In
620: particular, our findings appear to be inconsistent with a scenario where
621: corrugations result from gas being
622: hydraulically ``lifted''
623: off the plane by a spiral arm as a result of interaction of the spiral
624: density wave with a thick, magnetized,
625: gas disk (Martos \& Cox 1998). In this so-called ``galactic bore''
626: model, the lifting effect is expected to show an even symmetry about
627: midplane (see Alfaro et al. 2001), resulting in some thickening of
628: the plane and
629: no net velocity excursions in an edge-on galaxy.
630:
631: \subsection{Parker Instabilities}
632: %
633: In contrast to the galactic bore picture,
634: the undular mode of the Parker (1966) instability in
635: a thick, magnetized gas disk predicts a velocity pattern similar
636: to that seen in Figure~\ref{fig:velres} (see Franco et al. 2002).
637: However, an additional prediction
638: of this model is that density enhancements should be present at
639: the locations of maximum deviation from the mean plane (e.g., Hanawa
640: 1995). Indeed, such a trend
641: has been observed in the corrugated Carina-Sagittarius arm of the Galaxy
642: (Franco et al. 2002).
643: While IC~2233 does show a series of \HI\ density
644: enhancements along its disk (MU08), we find no clear correlation between
645: the locations of these clumps and the maxima in the corrugated pattern
646: in the \HI\ disk.
647: Because corrugations resulting from the undular mode
648: of the Parker instability occur along the azimuthal direction,
649: line-of-sight integration effects may make it more
650: difficult to match the location of density enhancements
651: and vertical displacements
652: in an edge-on galaxy. However, for the case of IC~2233, the Parker
653: instability model
654: encounters an additional challenge in that
655: magnetic fields in small spiral galaxies with rotational velocities
656: comparable to IC~2233 are typically quite weak (e.g.,
657: Chy{\. z}y et al. 2007).
658:
659: \subsection{Spontaneous Gravitational Instabilities}
660: %
661: The observation that the corrugated structure of IC~2233 is more
662: pronounced in the younger stellar components than in the old stars
663: would seem to argue against
664: a purely gravitational origin for the corrugations, since both gas and
665: stars will be influenced by gravity. However, gas is in general
666: more dynamically responsive than stars owing to its dissipative nature and
667: its lower velocity dispersion (e.g., Kim \& Ostriker
668: 2007). In addition, gaseous distortions may be amplified by
669: self-gravity and/or magnetic effects (e.g,
670: Edelsohn \& Elmegreen 1997). For these reasons, even if the
671: corrugations have a purely gravitational origin, it is not entirely
672: unexpected to find the largest amplitude corrugations in the gaseous
673: components of the
674: galaxy. In this picture,
675: the youngest stars (which still reside near their birth
676: locations) would be expected to
677: exhibit a corrugated structure, while dynamical
678: evolution and heating would slowly erode these
679: signatures in the older stars.
680:
681: To determine whether an origin for the corrugations in
682: IC~2233 via gaseous instabilities
683: is feasible, it is valuable to compare the ages of the stellar
684: populations participating in the corrugations with relevant
685: dynamical timescales in the disk.
686: For example,
687: using equation 6-85 from Binney and Tremaine (1987), we can estimate
688: the oscillation period, $P$, for stars in the disk of
689: IC~2233. Assuming a mass equal to the dynamical mass of the galaxy
690: ($M_{d}=1.55\times10^{10}~M_{\odot}$), a disk radius of 9.2~kpc, and a
691: maximum rotational velocity $V_{\rm max}=85$~\kms\ (MU08), then at
692: intermediate galactocentric radii (near $r$=4.5~kpc),
693: we find $P\sim5\times10^{6}$~years. This is comparable to the
694: lifetime of an \HII\ region, implying
695: that the hot young stars giving rise to these ionized regions
696: must be born near their present off-planar locations.
697: If the corrugations arise initially in the gas, then the presence of
698: corrugations in the NUV and FUV light (corresponding to stars with
699: ages $<10^{8}$ years) implies that the midplane
700: deviations need to persist for only a few oscillation periods to be
701: visible in these bands. The mix of stars dominating
702: the $R$-band light in IC~2233 is more
703: uncertain, although the very blue color of this galaxy ($B-R$=0.67;
704: MU08) suggests that this band may too be weighted toward
705: moderately young stars, with ages no more than a few oscillation periods.
706:
707: As discussed
708: by Fridman \& Polyachenko (1984), vertical displacements in a galactic disk
709: may arise from two types of internal gravitational
710: mechanisms: spiral
711: density waves and vertical bending oscillations (see also Fridman et
712: al. 1998). Variations of both types of mechanisms
713: could be linked with disk corrugations, even in galaxies
714: with negligible magnetic fields. For example,
715: Nelson
716: (1976) suggested that corrugations could arise from the perturbations
717: of a spiral potential on a differentially rotating gas layer (see also
718: Nelson \& Matsuda 1980), while Masset
719: \& Tagger (1997) postulated that their origin could be the result of
720: a non-linear coupling between a spiral density wave
721: and two so-called ``warp waves''. In the model of Masset \& Tagger,
722: a transmitted wave results in an
723: integral sign warp, while a reflected wave produces
724: corrugations.
725: Several arguments suggest that IC~2233 is likely to exhibit at least
726: rudimentary spiral structure (see MU08), but
727: unfortunately its edge-on orientation makes it impossible to
728: discern the details of this spiral pattern and thus to examine any possible
729: relationship to the observed corrugations.
730:
731: Vertical bending oscillations in galaxy disks have been explored by
732: various authors as a possible origin for galaxy warps (e.g., Sellwood 1996;
733: Revaz \& Pfenniger 2004), but to our knowledge, relatively little attention
734: has been paid to these oscillations as a possible origin of disk
735: corrugations (although see Sparke 1995;
736: Fridman et al. 1998; Griv \& Chiueh 1998). While the sophisticated
737: numerical simulations needed to explore this phenomenon are beyond
738: the scope of the present paper, we point to the results of some
739: existing studies that suggest that such an exploration might be
740: fruitful. For example, in certain galaxy disk models,
741: Sellwood (1996) found higher order bending
742: modes whose amplitude and wavelength are reminiscent of
743: the corrugation pattern of IC~2233 (e.g., his Figure~1d), although it
744: remains to be explored how
745: these results would translate to a disk containing both
746: gas and stars. More recently, Revaz
747: \& Pfenniger (2004) used multi-component disk models to show
748: that bending instabilities can be
749: long-lived (i.e., persisting through several rotations)
750: provided that disks have sufficient self-gravity. In their
751: models it is assumed that some portion of the galaxy's dark matter
752: resides in the disk rather than in a halo. Revaz \& Pfenniger
753: explored only the low-order ($m=0$ and $m=1$)
754: bending modes relevant to producing
755: galaxy warps; however, a search for higher-order modes, as well as an
756: extension of their models to include the dissipational behavior of the
757: gas would be of interest.
758:
759: \section{Summary}
760: %
761: We have presented a multi-wavelength analysis of the vertical
762: structure of the late-type, edge-on galaxy IC~2233. Systematic
763: excursions from the mean plane with amplitude $\lsim5''$
764: ($\sim$250~pc) are observed in a variety of \popI\
765: tracers in this galaxy, including the neutral hydrogen gas, the young
766: stars, the \HII\ regions, and dust components of various
767: temperatures. This corrugated pattern appears most regular in the \HI\
768: gas, and is absent from the old stars traced by the mid-infrared
769: light.
770:
771: Over a significant fraction of IC~2233, the vertical
772: deviations observed in a variety of \popI\ tracers show similar signs
773: and amplitudes. A notable exception occurs along the disk region
774: between $x\approx 70''$-$120''$, thus complicating the interpretation
775: of the corrugation pattern in terms of a simple, global pattern.
776: One contribution to the differences seen along this region could be
777: variations in the filling
778: factors for various disk tracers.
779: Star-forming sites may also have different spectral
780: energy distributions depending on their ages, with the youngest being
781: dim at UV and optical wavelengths. A third possibility is that
782: perturbations (such as impacts from infalling gas clouds) may
783: locally influence the vertical structure of the disk.
784: Despite these complexities, we find that
785: the locations of maximum deviation from the plane in the \HI\
786: gas correspond to perturbations in the \HI\ rotation curve with
787: amplitude $\lsim 5$~\kms.
788:
789: A number of different scenarios have been suggested in the past
790: literature to account for the
791: corrugated structure in disk galaxies, and we have evaluated their
792: applicability to the case of IC~2233. Models invoking tidal
793: interactions with a companion, Parker instabilities, or a galactic bore all encounter
794: significant challenges in explaining the radial, galaxy-wide
795: structural and velocity
796: corrugations of IC~2233. Models involving gravitational instabilities
797: of the gas layer appear
798: to be more promising. However, sophisticated numerical modelling will
799: be needed to evaluate such models further. The presence of a
800: corrugated structure in this rather low surface brightness galaxy
801: implies that vigorous star formation is not a necessary condition for
802: the appearance of complex vertical structure in the disks of galaxies.
803: Indeed, the quiescent nature of IC~2233 coupled with its low star
804: formation density is undoubtedly an important factor in allowing us to
805: observe the correspondence between vertical structures at a variety of
806: wavelengths despite our edge-on viewing angle.
807:
808: \acknowledgements
809: We thank the referee for thoughtful comments that helped to improve
810: this manuscript.
811: A portion of this worked was based on observations
812: from the {\it Spitzer Space Telescope}, operated by the Jet Propulsion
813: Laboratory (JPL), California Institute of Technology,
814: under contract 1407 with the National Aeronautics and Space
815: Administration (NASA). Financial support for this work was
816: provided to LDM through JPL Contract 1279242. The National Radio Astronomy Observatory
817: (NRAO) is a facility of the National Science Foundation, operated under cooperative
818: agreement by Associated Universities, Inc. The \HI\ data presented
819: here were obtained as part of the NRAO observing program AM649.
820:
821: \begin{references}
822:
823: Alfaro, E. J. 2003, in Highlights of Spanish Astrophysics III,
824: ed. J. Gallego, J. Zamorano, and N. Cardiel, (Kluwer: Dordrecht), 195
825:
826: Alfaro, E. J., Cabrera-Ca\~{n}o, J., \& Delgado, A. J. 1991, ApJ, 378, 106
827:
828: Alfaro, E. J., Cabrera-Ca\~{n}o, J., \& Delgado, A. J. 1992, ApJ, 399, 576
829:
830: Alfaro, E. J. \& Efremov, Y. N. 1996, Rev. Mex. Astron. Conf. Ser., 4, 1
831:
832: Alfaro, E. J., P\'erez, E., Gonz\'alez Delgado, R. M., Martos, M. A.,
833: \& Franco, J. 2001, ApJ, 550, 253
834: %velocity corrugations in NGC5427
835:
836: Arp, H. A. 1964, ApJ, 139, 1045
837:
838: Binney, J. \& Tremaine, S. 1987, Galactic Dynamics, (Princeton:
839: Princeton University Press)
840:
841: Brandt, J. C. 1960, ApJ, 131, 293
842:
843: Chy{\. z}y, K. T., Bomans, D. J., Krause, M., Beck, R., Soida, M.,
844: \& Urbanik, M. 2007, A\&A, 462, 933
845:
846: Condon, J. J. Cotton, W. D., Greisen, E. W., Yin, Q. F., Perley, R. A.,
847: Taylor, G. B., \& Broderick, J. J. 1998, AJ, 115, 1693
848:
849: Dahlem, M., Ehle, M., Ryder, S. D., Vlaj\'\i c, M., \& Haynes,
850: R. F. 2005, A\&A, 432, 475
851:
852: de Vaucoleurs, G. \& de Vaucouleurs, A. 1963, ApJ, 137, 363
853:
854: Edelsohn, D. J. \& Elmegreen, B. G. 1997, MNRAS, 287, 947
855:
856: Florido, E., Battaner, E., Prieto, M., Mediavilla, E., \&
857: Sanchez-Saavedra, M. L. 1991, MNRAS, 251, 193
858: % corrugations in NGC4244 and NGC5023
859:
860: Florido, E., Battaner, E., Gros, A., Prieto, M., \& Mediavilla,
861: E. 1992, Ap\&SS, 190, 293
862:
863: Franco, J., Kim, J., Alfaro, E., \& Hong, S. S. 2002, ApJ, 570, 647
864: %Parker instability along Carina-Sagittarius Arm
865:
866: Franco, J., Tenorio-Tagle, G., Bodenheimer, P., R\'o{\. z}yczka, M.,
867: \& Mirabel, I. F. 1988, ApJ, 333, 826
868: % impact of high-velocity clouds
869:
870: Fraternali, F. \& Binney, J. J. 208, MNRAS, 386, 935
871:
872: Fridman, A. M., Koruzhii, O. V., Zasov, A. V., Sil'chenko, O. K.,
873: Moiseev, A. V., Burlak, A. N., Afanas'ev, V. L., Dodonov, S. N., \&
874: Knapen, J. 1998, Aston. Lett., 24, 764
875:
876: Fridman, A. M. \& Polyachenko, V. L. 1984, Physics of Gravitating
877: Systems, (New York: Springer-Verlag)
878:
879: Garc\'\i a-Ruiz, I., Sancisi, R., \& Kuijken, K. 2002, A\&A, 394, 769
880:
881: Gil de Paz, A. et al. 2007, ApJS, 173, 185
882:
883: Goad, J. W. \& Roberts, M. S. 1981, ApJ, 250, 79
884:
885: Griv, E. \& Chiueh, T. 1998, ApJ, 503, 186
886:
887: Gum, C. S., Kerr, F. J., \& Westerhout, G. 1960, MNRAS, 121, 132
888:
889: Haas, M., Klaas, \& Bianchi, S. 2002, A\&A, 385, L23
890:
891: Hanawa, T. 1995, in The Formation of the Milky Way, ed. E. J. Alfaro
892: and A. J. Delgado, (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press), 1
893:
894: Helou, G., Malhotra, S., Hollenbach, D. J., Dale, D. A., \& Contursi,
895: A. 2001, ApJ, 548, L73
896:
897: H$\o$g, E., Fabricius, C., Makarov, V. V., Urban, S., Corbin, T.,
898: Wychoff, G., Bastian, U., Schwekendiek, P., \& Wicenec, A. 2000, A\&A,
899: 355, L27
900:
901: Kim, W.-T. \& Ostriker, E. C. 2007, ApJ, 660, 1232
902:
903: Lockman, F. J. 1977, AJ, 82, 408
904:
905: Martos, M. A. \& Cox, D. P. 1998, ApJ, 509, 703
906:
907: Masset, F. \& Tagger, M. 1997, A\&A, 318, 747
908:
909: Matthews, L. D. \& Uson, J. M. 2008, AJ, 135, 291 (MU08)
910:
911: Matthews, L. D. \& Wood, K. 2001, ApJ, 593, 721
912:
913: Nelson, A. H. 1976, MNRAS, 177, 265
914:
915: Nelson, A. H. \& Matsuda, T. 1980, MNRAS, 191, 221
916:
917: Paladino, R., Murgia, M., Tarchi, A., Moscadelli, L., \& Comito,
918: C. 2008, A\&A, in press (astro-ph/0805.0250)
919:
920: Parker, E. N. 1966, ApJ, 145, 811
921:
922: Pi\c{s}mi\c{s}, P. 1965, BOTT, 4, 8
923:
924: Quiroga, R. J. 1974, Ap\&SS, 27, 323
925:
926: Quiroga, R. J. 1977, Ap\&SS, 50, 281
927:
928: Reshetnikov, V. \& Combes, F. 1998, A\&A, 337, 9
929:
930: Revaz, Y. \& Pfenniger, D. 2004, A\&A, 425, 67
931:
932: S\'anchez-Saavedra, M. L., Battaner, E., \& Florido, E. 1990, MNRAS,
933: 246, 458
934:
935: Sanders, D. B., Solomon, P. M., \& Scoville, N. Z. 1984, ApJ, 276, 182
936:
937: Santill\'an, A., Franco, J., Martos, M., Kim, J. 1999, ApJ, 515, 657
938: %impact of high-velocity clouds
939:
940: Santill\'an, A., Kim, J., Franco, J., Martos, M., Hong, S. S., \& Ryu,
941: D. 2000, ApJ, 545, 353
942: % Parker instability numerical simulations
943:
944: Sellwood, J. A. 1996, ApJ, 473, 733
945:
946: Seth, A. C., Dalcanton, J. J., \& de Jong, R. S. 2005, AJ, 129, 1331
947:
948: Sparke, L. S. 1995, ApJ, 439, 42
949:
950: Spicker J. \& Feitzinger, J. V. 1986, A\&A, 163, 43
951:
952: %Uson, J. M. \& Matthews, L. D. 2003, AJ, 125, 2455
953:
954: Walter, F. et al. 2007, ApJ, 661, 102
955:
956: \end{references}
957:
958: \clearpage
959:
960:
961: \begin{figure}
962: \vspace*{-7mm}
963: \centering
964: \includegraphics[width=0.7\textwidth]{f1a.ps}
965: \caption{Corrugation plots for IC~2233 derived at various
966: wavelengths, together with images of the galaxy in each band.
967: The image panels are $210''\times450''$ across and are
968: centered at $(x,z)=(0,0)$.
969: In the upper left panel, arrows denote the edges of the stellar
970: disk defined by the 25 mag arcsec$^{-2}$ $B$-band isophote. In
971: all other panels, the solid curve shows a polynomial fit to the \HI\
972: data points
973: interior to the arrows in the top left panel. At the distance of IC~2233,
974: $1''\approx$50~pc.}
975: \label{fig:corplots}
976:
977: \end{figure}
978:
979: \clearpage
980:
981: \begin{figure}
982: \figurenum{1}
983: \vspace*{-7mm}
984: \centering
985: \includegraphics[width=.7\textwidth]{f1b.ps}
986: \caption{cont.}
987:
988: \end{figure}
989:
990:
991: \clearpage
992:
993: \begin{figure}
994: \centering
995: \scalebox{0.7}{\rotatebox{90}{\includegraphics{f2.ps}}}
996: \caption{Velocity residuals after subtraction of a Brandt
997: model rotation curve from the observed \HI\ rotation curve of IC~2233. The
998: residual curve has been smoothed to a resolution of $\sim30''$ using
999: a boxcar function. The dashed portions of the curve designate the
1000: regions of the \HI\ disk where warping dominates the vertical
1001: structure (see upper left panel of
1002: Figure~\ref{fig:corplots}). The hash marks indicate
1003: the locations of the local minima and maxima of the vertical structural
1004: excursions of the \HI\ layer
1005: as seen in Figure~\ref{fig:corplots}. }
1006: \protect\label{fig:velres}
1007: \end{figure}
1008:
1009: %\clearpage
1010:
1011: \begin{deluxetable}{lccc}
1012: \tabletypesize{\tiny}
1013: \tablewidth{0pc}
1014: \tablenum{2}
1015: \tablecaption{IC~2233 Corrugation Curves}
1016:
1017: \tablehead{\colhead{Band} & \colhead{Major axis distance ($x$)}
1018: & \colhead{Vertical displacement ($z$)} & \colhead{$\sigma(z)$}\\
1019: \colhead{} & \colhead{(arcsec)} & \colhead{(arcsec)} &
1020: \colhead{(arcsec)} \\
1021: \colhead{(1)} & \colhead{(2)} & \colhead{(3)} & \colhead{(4)} }
1022:
1023: \startdata
1024:
1025: NUV & -106.72 & 4.86 & 0.04 \\
1026: & -96.52 & 2.07 & 0.05 \\
1027: & -86.32 & 0.40 & 0.04\\
1028: & -76.12 & 1.49 & 0.08\\
1029: & -65.92 & 1.43 & 0.08\\
1030: & -55.72 & -0.17 & 0.06\\
1031: & -45.52 & -1.54 & 0.06\\
1032: & -35.32 & -0.67 & 0.07\\
1033: & -25.12 & -0.38 & 0.07\\
1034: & -14.92 & -1.02 &0.06\\
1035: & -4.72 & -0.80 &0.04\\
1036: & 5.48 & 0.11 & 0.06\\
1037: & 15.68 & 0.07 & 0.07\\
1038: & 25.88 & 1.06 & 0.03\\
1039: & 36.08 & 1.99 & 0.03\\
1040: & 46.28 & 0.60 & 0.06\\
1041: & 56.48 & 0.74 & 0.09\\
1042: & 66.68 & 1.41 & 0.08\\
1043: & 76.88 & 0.00 & 0.09\\
1044: & 87.08 & 3.21 & 0.03\\
1045: & 97.28 & 2.46 & 0.05\\
1046: & 107.48 & 1.00 & 0.09\\
1047: & 117.68 & 3.88 & 0.10\\
1048: & 127.88 & 2.41 & 0.06\\
1049: & 138.08 & 1.36 & 0.06\\
1050: & 148.28 & -1.26 & 0.08\\
1051: & 158.48 & -0.09 & 0.11\\
1052: & 168.68 & 0.27 & 0.11\\
1053:
1054: \enddata
1055:
1056: \tablecomments{Table 2 is available in its entirety in the electronic
1057: edition of the {\it Astrophysical Journal}. Explanation of columns:
1058: col. (1) wavelength of the observation (see Table~1 for further
1059: details); col. (2): displacement along the galaxy major axis in
1060: arcseconds, with respect to the kinematic center (see \S~2.1);
1061: col. (3) displacement of the fitted centroid of the vertical intensity profile;
1062: (4) 1~$\sigma$ uncertainty in the position of the vertical centroid. }
1063:
1064: \end{deluxetable}
1065:
1066: \end{document}
1067:
1068:
1069: