1: \documentclass[12pt,preprint]{aastex}
2: %\doublespace
3: %\usepackage{natbib}
4: \citestyle{aa}
5: \slugcomment{In press ApJ Letters, 1 August 2008}
6:
7: \begin{document}
8:
9: \title{Detection of additional members of the 2003 EL61 collisional family via
10: near-infrared spectroscopy}
11:
12: \author{E.L. Schaller\altaffilmark{1},
13: M.E. Brown\altaffilmark{1}}
14: \altaffiltext{1}{Division of Geological and Planetary Sciences, California Institute
15: of Technology, Pasadena, CA 91125}
16: \email{schaller@caltech.edu}
17:
18: \begin{abstract}
19:
20: We have acquired near-infrared spectra of Kuiper belt objects
21: 2003 UZ117, 2005 CB79 and 2004 SB60 with NIRC on the Keck I Telescope.
22: These objects are dynamically close to the core
23: of the 2003 EL61 collisional family and were suggested to
24: be potential fragments of this collision by \citet{darin}.
25: We find that the spectra of 2003 UZ117 and 2005 CB79
26: both show the characteristic strong water ice absorption features seen exclusively on
27: 2003 EL61, its largest satellite, and the six other known collisional
28: fragments.
29: In contrast, we find that the near infrared spectrum of 2004 SB60 is essentially
30: featureless with a fraction of water ice of less than 5\%.
31: We discuss the implications of the discovery of these additional
32: family members for understanding the formation and evolution of this collisional family
33: in the outer solar system.
34:
35: \end{abstract}
36:
37: \keywords{Kuiper belt --- planets and satellites}
38: \section{Introduction}
39:
40: The only known collisional family in the Kuiper belt was detected because of the unique
41: spectral properties the family members (Brown et al. 2007).
42: The near-infrared spectra of all other
43: non-volatile rich Kuiper belt objects (KBOs)
44: lie on a continuum between those whose spectra
45: contain
46: moderate amounts of water ice absorptions to those
47: whose spectra are essentially
48: featureless \citep{2007Natur.446..294B, kris08}.
49: In contrast, the near-infrared spectra of 2003 EL61,
50: its largest
51: satellite, and five other small KBOs
52: resemble laboratory
53: spectra of pure crystalline water ice \citep{1999ApJ...519L.101B,kris06,2007ApJ...655.1172T,2007A&A...466.1185M,2007Natur.446..294B, kris08}.
54: Remarkably, these objects are also relatively clustered in orbital element space.
55: The largest object, 2003 EL61, had been previously suggested to have
56: experienced a massive collision that imparted its
57: fast (4-hour) rotation, stripped off most of its
58: icy mantle leaving it with a density close to rock (2.7 g/cc),
59: and formed its two satellites \citep{2006ApJ...639.1238R, 2006ApJ...639L..43B, 2008AJ....135.1749L}.
60: \citet{2007Natur.446..294B} concluded that the four extremely water ice rich
61: KBOs and the large satellite of 2003 EL61 were in fact
62: fragments of the icy mantle of the proto-2003 EL61 that had been ejected
63: during a massive collision.
64:
65:
66: While collisional families in the asteroid belt can be
67: identified by their dynamical clustering alone, families in the Kuiper belt are much
68: harder to identify because the
69: collisional ejection velocities can be a significant fraction of an object's
70: orbital velocity. Collisional fragments can therefore be spread out over a wide range of
71: orbital element space with the fastest ejected
72: fragments having
73: significantly different orbits from the family core.
74: The 2003 EL61
75: family members were all identified on the basis of their unique surface
76: properties: they are the only known objects
77: in the Kuiper belt with extremely pure water ice spectra and neutral
78: visible colors.
79: It is only because of this unique surface signature
80: that detection of the 2003 EL61 family members was possible.
81:
82: In order to determine if other known KBOs could be fragments of the
83: 2003 EL61 collision, \citet{darin} integrated the orbits of 131 high inclination
84: KBOs to determine their proper orbital elements
85: and minimum ejection velocities away from the 2003 EL61 family
86: core. They determined the minimum ejection velocity
87: a KBO must have had in order to reach its present orbit
88: from the modeled location of the family forming impact.
89: In Figure 1 we show object H-magnitude vs. minimum ejection velocity
90: (from \citet{darin}) for
91: the known KBOs closest to the family core. For KBOs in known
92: resonances, we plot the ejection velocity
93: accounting for resonance diffusion \citep{darin}.
94: A large fraction of these objects
95: have never been observed to determine if they have IR spectral signatures
96: consistent with the 2003 EL61 family members. It is important to note that
97: though all of the known 2003 EL61 family members have neutral visible
98: colors, visible color or visible spectroscopy alone \citep{PinAlons2008} is not sufficient for family
99: member identification. There are many KBOs with neutral visible colors
100: that do not also have strong water ice absorptions and are not members
101: of the 2003 EL61 collisional family.
102: Therefore, while visible colors can be used
103: to rule out objects as potential family members, near infrared
104: spectroscopy to determine water ice absorption
105: depths is necessary for definitive family member identification.
106:
107: Identifying additional
108: family members and characterizing the
109: extent of the spread of fragments throughout the Kuiper belt
110: may provide insight into the physics of this giant impact event
111: in the outer solar system.
112: In this letter we present near-infrared spectra
113: obtained with the Keck I telescope of KBOs 2003 UZ117, 2005 CB79
114: and 2004 SB60, objects that are located 67, 97, and 221 m/s away from the
115: modeled 2003 EL61 family core respectively (Fig 1).
116: 2003 UZ117 and 2005 CB79 were suggested
117: to be the most likely additional family candidates by \citet{darin}.
118:
119: \section{Observations and Results}
120:
121: Observations of 2003 UZ117, 2005 CB79, and 2004 SB60
122: were performed with the Near Infrared Camera (NIRC)
123: on the Keck I telescope.
124: Objects were identified in the field
125: by their motion relative to the background
126: stars. Targets were moved to the center of a
127: 0.525 arcsecond wide slit and were then observed with either
128: a J-through-H order sorting filter and a 120 lines per millimeter grism
129: (2003 UZ117 and 2005 CB79) or
130: an H-through-K order sorting filter and a 150 lines per millimeter grism
131: (2004 SB60).
132: In all cases, exposure times for the individual spectra were 200 seconds.
133: Targets were dithered along the slit in a five position nod pattern
134: with 5 arcseconds between each dither.
135: During observations the telescope tracked at each target's predicted
136: rate of motion.
137:
138: \subsection{2003 UZ117 \& 2005 CB79}
139: Low resolution spectral observations in the H--K (1.4-2.5 micron) region are ideal for
140: determining the presence or absence of water ice due to two
141: broad water ice absorption features centered at 1.5 and 2.0 microns
142: (Figure 2). \citet{kris08} observed
143: 45 KBOs and centaurs in this wavelength range
144: and parameterized all spectra with a two component model consisting of crystalline water
145: ice covering a fraction of the surface, f, mixed linearly with dark continuum component
146: with slope m, covering (1-f) of the surface.
147: They solved for m and f in each spectrum
148: by using a least squares minimization scheme using the Powell method.
149: Family members clearly stood out because of their high fractions
150: of water ice (f $>$ 0.8) in this parameterization
151: compared with all other objects in the survey (f $<$ 0.5).
152:
153: Low resolution spectral observations at H--K
154: with NIRC are only practical for objects with visual magnitudes
155: less than $\sim$21.
156: Spectral observations in the J--H region of the spectrum (1.1-1.6 microns)
157: allow us probe the spectra of objects
158: (vmag$\sim$21.5) that would
159: be too faint to detect or obtain sufficient signal to noise
160: in a reasonable amount of time with H--K spectroscopy.
161: Fortunately, the water ice absorption feature centered at $\sim$1.5 microns
162: is perfectly suited for detection
163: with J--H spectroscopy.
164: We can therefore observe KBOs up to half a magnitude fainter than previous
165: observations in H--K \citep{kris08} allowing
166: us to detect strong water ice absorptions and
167: determine if these smaller objects are also members of the
168: 2003 EL61 collisonal family.
169:
170: J--H spectra of two dynamically likely family members,
171: 2003 UZ117 and 2005 CB79 (visual magnitudes of 21.3 and 21.2 respectively)
172: were obtained.
173: 2003 UZ117 was observed on 23 September 2007 UT for a total integration time
174: of 4000 seconds.
175: 2005 CB79 was observed on 21 and 22 May 2007 UT for a total integration time of
176: 12200 seconds. Nearby G-type main sequence stars were observed
177: within 0.1 airmass of the targets for telluric calibration.
178: Variable seeing, sky conditions, and occasionally poor tracking (especially on
179: the 2005 CB79 observations) caused the individual
180: spectra of each of the KBOs to be of varying quality, thus only the highest signal-to-noise
181: spectra were included and the rest discarded for this analysis. The final
182: spectra consist of total integration times of 2800 seconds for 2003 UZ117 and 5200 seconds for 2005 CB79.
183: Spectral data reduction was carried out using standard procedures as described
184: in Brown (2000) and \citet{kris08}.
185:
186: The final 2003 UZ117 and 2005 CB79 spectra were
187: each binned over four pixels to increase the
188: signal to noise per pixel. We used a Gaussian weighting function
189: with a FWHM of 8 pixels resulting oversampled spectra with a spectral
190: resolution of $\sim$33.
191: In Figure 2 we show these spectra with one sigma error bars along with a model of
192: pure water ice with 50 micron grain sizes at 50 K \citep{1998JGR...10325809G}.
193: We can quantitatively parameterize the amount of
194: water ice using the same spectral model
195: as \citet{kris08} but considering the wavelength region from
196: 1.1-1.6 microns.
197: Using a Powell minimization scheme
198: to solve for the best fit of the parameters,
199: m and f, we find that the spectra of
200: 2003 UZ117 and 2005 CB79 are
201: fit by water ice fractions of 0.92 $\pm{0.16}$ and 1.02 $\pm{0.10}$ respectively.
202: The high fraction of water ice given by this parameterization for 2005 CB79
203: may be due to the fact that the water ice grain sizes on this object
204: are somewhat larger
205: than those modeled
206: by \citet{kris08}.
207: Nonetheless, the deep absorptions detected from $\sim$1.4-1.6 microns
208: on 2003 UZ117 and 2005 CB79 are clearly consistent with a
209: high fraction of water ice (in contrast with all other known
210: KBOs) but comparable to the other 2003 EL61 family members \citep{kris08}.
211:
212: \subsection{2004 SB60}
213: 2004 SB60, with a visual magnitude of 20.8 was
214: bright enough to be observed in
215: H - K. We observed it on 23 September 2007
216: for a total integration time of 3000 seconds.
217: Data reduction was carried out as described above.
218: A nearby G-type main sequence star was observed
219: at similar (within .03) airmass of the
220: target. Division of the 2004 SB60 spectrum by the star spectrum allowed us to calibrate
221: telluric features. The resulting spectrum has a resolution r$\sim$160.
222:
223: Using the same spectral parameterization of \citet{kris08} and
224: described above,
225: we find that the fraction of
226: water ice in the spectrum of 2004 SB60
227: is consistent with 0\% and can be no more than 0.05 (Figure 2).
228: The low water ice fraction seen in the spectrum of 2004 SB60
229: is similar to that seen in many small
230: KBOs (see \citet{kris08}). The spectrum of 2004 SB60 is clearly not consistent with the other
231: members of the 2003 EL61 collisional family that have water
232: ice fractions greater than 0.8 (Figure 2).
233:
234: \section{Discussion}
235:
236: 2003 UZ117 and 2005 CB79 contain high fractions
237: of pure water ice on their surfaces and appear
238: dynamically related to the other members of the 2003 EL61
239: collisional family. We therefore conclude that
240: they are members of this collisional family.
241: Thus far, all objects within
242: 130 m/s of the modeled collision center \citep{darin}
243: have been shown to have the
244: same unique strong water ice spectral
245: signatures.
246: 2004 SB60, at 221 m/s from the family core,
247: has an essentially featureless spectrum
248: inconsistent with 2003 EL61 and its family members
249: but comparable to many other small KBOs.
250: The flat spectrum we observed is consistent with infrared
251: photometric observations of 2004 SB60
252: with HST by \citet{2007DPS....39.3906S}.
253: Infrared spectral or spectrophotometric observations of more potential fragments with minimum
254: ejection velocities from $\sim$150 to $\sim$300 m/s
255: could help constrain the extent to which fragments
256: were scattered throughout the Kuiper belt
257: and could tell us about the physics of the giant impact itself.
258: In addition to the distribution of fragments,
259: any collisional model would also need to explain the the
260: presence of the two satellites of 2003 EL61.
261:
262: Though it does not have the spectral signature of the fragments
263: of the 2003 EL61 collision,
264: 2004 SB60 is an interesting object in its own right.
265: \citet{2008Icar..194..758N} have found this object
266: to be one of the few high inclination small binary objects
267: in the Kuiper belt.
268: It is worth noting
269: the possibility that
270: not all fragments of the 2003 EL61 collision
271: necessarily have the unique strong water ice signature.
272: Fragments from different locations in the initial
273: parent body may have had different initial compositions.
274: However, without
275: this unique spectral signature, identification of an object as a family
276: member is currently impossible.
277:
278: Another object near the center of the 2003 EL61
279: family is the third largest KBO, 2005 FY9. 2005 FY9 has a velocity closer to the
280: center of the collision (150 m/s) than one of the known fragments
281: but has a spectrum dominated by methane, not water ice absorptions.
282: We find it intriguing that two of the largest KBOs are so close to each other in
283: orbital element space but can think of no reason why they should be
284: physically related.
285:
286: The spectral signature of extremely pure water ice found
287: on 2003 EL61 and its fragments and nowhere else in the Kuiper belt
288: is the only reason definitive identification
289: of the collisonal family was possible.
290: A collision with a non differentiated parent body would likely
291: not produce such a distinct spectral signature in its fragments.
292: Future large scale surveys of the Kuiper belt such as PanSTARRS and
293: LSST are expected to increase
294: the numbers of known KBOs by over an order of magnitude. With higher
295: numbers of objects, overdensities
296: in certain regions may be revealed and families without unique spectral signatures
297: may be able to be identified by their dynamics alone.
298:
299: % {\it Acknowledgments:}
300: \acknowledgments
301: The data presented herein were obtained at the W.M.
302: Keck Observatory, which is operated as a scientific partnership among the California Institute of Technology, The University of California and the National
303: Aeronautics and Space Administration. The observatory was made
304: possible by the generous financial support of the W.M. Keck Foundation.
305: \clearpage
306:
307: \begin{thebibliography}{14}
308: \expandafter\ifx\csname natexlab\endcsname\relax\def\natexlab#1{#1}\fi
309:
310: \bibitem[{{Barkume} {et~al.}(2006){Barkume}, {Brown}, \& {Schaller}}]{kris06}
311: {Barkume}, K.~M., {Brown}, M.~E., \& {Schaller}, E.~L. 2006, \apjl, 640, L87
312:
313: \bibitem[{{Barkume} {et~al.}(2008){Barkume}, {Brown}, \& {Schaller}}]{kris08}
314: ---. 2008, \aj, 135, 55
315:
316: \bibitem[{{Brown} {et~al.}(2007){Brown}, {Barkume}, {Ragozzine}, \&
317: {Schaller}}]{2007Natur.446..294B}
318: {Brown}, M.~E., {Barkume}, K.~M., {Ragozzine}, D., \& {Schaller}, E.~L. 2007,
319: \nat, 446, 294
320:
321: \bibitem[{{Brown} {et~al.}(2006){Brown}, {van Dam}, {Bouchez}, {Le Mignant},
322: {Campbell}, {Chin}, {Conrad}, {Hartman}, {Johansson}, {Lafon}, {Rabinowitz},
323: {Stomski}, {Summers}, {Trujillo}, \& {Wizinowich}}]{2006ApJ...639L..43B}
324: {Brown}, M.~E., {van Dam}, M.~A., {Bouchez}, A.~H., {Le Mignant}, D.,
325: {Campbell}, R.~D., {Chin}, J.~C.~Y., {Conrad}, A., {Hartman}, S.~K.,
326: {Johansson}, E.~M., {Lafon}, R.~E., {Rabinowitz}, D.~L., {Stomski}, Jr.,
327: P.~J., {Summers}, D.~M., {Trujillo}, C.~A., \& {Wizinowich}, P.~L. 2006,
328: \apjl, 639, L43
329:
330: \bibitem[{{Brown} {et~al.}(1999){Brown}, {Cruikshank}, \&
331: {Pendleton}}]{1999ApJ...519L.101B}
332: {Brown}, R.~H., {Cruikshank}, D.~P., \& {Pendleton}, Y. 1999, \apjl, 519, L101
333:
334: \bibitem[{{Grundy} \& {Schmitt}(1998)}]{1998JGR...10325809G}
335: {Grundy}, W.~M. \& {Schmitt}, B. 1998, \jgr, 103, 25809
336:
337: \bibitem[{{Lacerda} {et~al.}(2008){Lacerda}, {Jewitt}, \&
338: {Peixinho}}]{2008AJ....135.1749L}
339: {Lacerda}, P., {Jewitt}, D., \& {Peixinho}, N. 2008, \aj, 135, 1749
340:
341: \bibitem[{{Merlin} {et~al.}(2007){Merlin}, {Guilbert}, {Dumas}, {Barucci}, {de
342: Bergh}, \& {Vernazza}}]{2007A&A...466.1185M}
343: {Merlin}, F., {Guilbert}, A., {Dumas}, C., {Barucci}, M.~A., {de Bergh}, C., \&
344: {Vernazza}, P. 2007, \aap, 466, 1185
345:
346: \bibitem[{{Noll} {et~al.}(2008){Noll}, {Grundy}, {Stephens}, {Levison}, \&
347: {Kern}}]{2008Icar..194..758N}
348: {Noll}, K.~S., {Grundy}, W.~M., {Stephens}, D.~C., {Levison}, H.~F., \& {Kern},
349: S.~D. 2008, Icarus, 194, 758
350:
351: \bibitem[{{Pinilla-Alonso} {et~al.}(2008){Pinilla-Alonso}, {Licandro}, \&
352: {Lorenzi}}]{PinAlons2008}
353: {Pinilla-Alonso}, N., {Licandro}, J., \& {Lorenzi}, V. 2008, ArXiv e-prints,
354: 807
355:
356: \bibitem[{{Rabinowitz} {et~al.}(2006){Rabinowitz}, {Barkume}, {Brown}, {Roe},
357: {Schwartz}, {Tourtellotte}, \& {Trujillo}}]{2006ApJ...639.1238R}
358: {Rabinowitz}, D.~L., {Barkume}, K., {Brown}, M.~E., {Roe}, H., {Schwartz}, M.,
359: {Tourtellotte}, S., \& {Trujillo}, C. 2006, \apj, 639, 1238
360:
361: \bibitem[{{Ragozzine} \& {Brown}(2007)}]{darin}
362: {Ragozzine}, D. \& {Brown}, M.~E. 2007, \aj, 134, 2160
363:
364: \bibitem[{{Stephens} \& {Noll}(2007)}]{2007DPS....39.3906S}
365: {Stephens}, D.~C. \& {Noll}, K.~S. 2007, in AAS/Division for Planetary Sciences
366: Meeting Abstracts, Vol.~39, AAS/Division for Planetary Sciences Meeting
367: Abstracts, 39.06
368:
369: \bibitem[{{Trujillo} {et~al.}(2007){Trujillo}, {Brown}, {Barkume}, {Schaller},
370: \& {Rabinowitz}}]{2007ApJ...655.1172T}
371: {Trujillo}, C.~A., {Brown}, M.~E., {Barkume}, K.~M., {Schaller}, E.~L., \&
372: {Rabinowitz}, D.~L. 2007, \apj, 655, 1172
373:
374: \end{thebibliography}
375:
376: \clearpage
377:
378: \begin{figure}
379: \plotone{f1.eps}
380: \caption{Kuiper belt object absolute magnitude (H) vs. the minimum velocity required for a given KBO
381: to reach its orbit from the modeled 2003 EL61 family forming collision
382: (from Ragozzine \& Brown 2007 Tables 1 \& 2).
383: Including 2003 UZ117 and 2005 CB79 (this paper), all of the objects within $\sim$130 m/s
384: have similar infrared spectra
385: showing extremely deep absorptions due to water ice on their surfaces.
386: These are the only
387: KBOs with such strong absorption features.
388: 2004 SB60 was found to have an featureless infrared spectrum inconsistent
389: with the other 2003 EL61 family members.}
390: \end{figure}
391:
392: \clearpage
393:
394: \begin{figure}
395: \epsscale{0.6}
396: \plotone{f2.eps}
397: \caption{Near infrared spectra of 2003 EL61 and its collisional family
398: members show strong signatures of nearly pure water ice on their surfaces.
399: Shown are the spectra of five KBOs along with a pure
400: crystalline water ice model \citep{1998JGR...10325809G}.
401: We observed KBOs 2003 UZ117, 2005 CB79 and 2004 SB60, objects 67, 97 and 221 m/s
402: away from the modeled 2003 EL61 family core \citep{darin}
403: to determine if their near infrared spectra contained the characteristic
404: strong water ice absorptions.
405: Spectra of 2003 UZ117
406: and 2005 CB79 show strong absorptions at 1.4-1.6
407: microns consistent with the presence of high fractions
408: of water ice on their surfaces. In contrast,
409: the spectrum of 2004 SB60 is essentially featureless. The
410: flat spectrum of 2003 VS2 (from \citet{kris08}), a typical non-family
411: member KBO, is shown for comparison.}
412: \end{figure}
413:
414:
415: \end{document}
416: