1: % iaus2esa.tex -- sample pages for Proceedings IAU Symposium document class
2: % (based on v1.0 cca2esam.tex)
3: % v1.04 released 17 May 2004 by TechBooks
4: %% small changes and additions made by KAvdH/IAU 4 June 2004
5: % Copyright (2004) International Astronomical Union
6:
7: \newcommand{\TP}{\emph{P-T} profile}
8: \newcommand{\hd}{\object{HD209458b}}
9:
10: \NeedsTeXFormat{LaTeX2e}
11:
12: \documentclass{iaus}
13: \usepackage{graphicx}
14:
15: \title[Atmospheric composition and structure of HD209458b] %% give here short title %%
16: {Atmospheric composition and structure of HD209458b}
17:
18:
19: \author[J.-M. D\'esert$^1$ et al.]
20: {J.-M. D\'esert$^1$, A. Vidal-Madjar$^1$, A. Lecavelier des
21: Etangs$^1$, D.Sing$^1$, D. Ehrenreich$^2$, G. H\'ebrard$^1$ \and
22: R. Ferlet$^1$}
23:
24:
25:
26: \affiliation{$^1$Institut d'Astrophysique de Paris, CNRS
27: (UMR~7095) \\ Universit\'e Pierre \& Marie Curie; 98 bis, boulevard Arago 75014 Paris, France \\ email: {\tt desert@iap.fr} \\[\affilskip]
28: $^2$Laboratoire d'Astrophysique, Observatoire de Grenoble, UJF, CNRS; \\
29: BP 53, F-38041 GRENOBLE Cedex 9 (France)}
30:
31: \pubyear{2008}
32: \volume{253} %% insert here IAU Symposium No.
33: \pagerange{119--126}
34: % \date{?? and in revised form ??}
35: \setcounter{page}{119} \jname{Transiting planets} \editors{F.
36: Pont, eds.}
37:
38: \begin{document}
39:
40: \maketitle
41:
42: \begin{abstract}
43: Transiting planets like HD209458b offer a unique opportunity to
44: scrutinize their atmospheric composition and structure. Transit
45: spectroscopy probes the transition region between the day and
46: night sides, called limb. We present a re-analysis of existing
47: HST/STIS transmission spectra of HD209458bs atmosphere. From
48: these observations we: Identify H2 Rayleigh scattering, derive the
49: absolute Sodium abundance and quantify its depletion in the upper
50: atmosphere, extract a stratospheric T-P profile with a
51: temperature inversion and explain broad band absorptions with the
52: presence of TiO and VO molecules in the atmosphere of this planet.
53:
54:
55: \keywords{planetary systems, radiative transfer, techniques:
56: spectroscopic}
57: %% add here a maximum of 10 keywords, to be taken form the file <Keywords.txt>
58: \end{abstract}
59:
60: \firstsection % if your document starts with a section,
61: % remove some space above using this command.
62: \section{Introduction}
63:
64: Because of the wavelength-dependent opacities of absorbing
65: species, measurement of relative changes in eclipse depth as a
66: function of wavelength during primary transit has the potential to
67: reveal the presence (or absence) of specific chemical species
68: (Seager et al.\ 2000a, Hubbard et al.\ 2001, Brown et al.\ 2001).
69:
70: In the case of HD~209458b's atmosphere, the transmission spectroscopy
71: method led to the detection of sodium (Charbonneau et~al. 2002,
72: Sing et~al. 2008b). In the UV, absorptions of several percents for
73: H\,{\sc i} Lyman-$\alpha$, O\,{\sc i} and C\,{\sc ii} have been
74: measured in the hydrodynamically escaping upper atmosphere
75: (Vidal-Madjar et al.\ 2003, 2004, 2008, D\'esert et al.\ 2004,
76: Lecavelier\ 2007, Ehrenreich et al. 2007).
77:
78: We use public archived {\it STIS} spectra obtained during
79: planetary transit at two spectral resolutions (low and medium).
80: Both datasets are combined to extend the measurements over the
81: entire optical regime to quantify possible absorbers appearing in
82: the transmission spectrum (Sing et al. 2008a).
83:
84:
85: In this poster we present the identification of Rayleigh
86: scattering by H$_2$ molecules (Lecavelier et~al. 2008b), the
87: depletion of NaI as well as the extraction of a \TP\ with
88: inversion (Sing et~al. 2008b). Finally, we derived the upper
89: limits for the TiO/VO molecular abundances in the atmosphere of
90: the planet (D\'esert et al. 2008).
91:
92:
93: \section{Observed features in the spectrum and interpretation}
94:
95: The \emph{HST-STIS} G750L, and G430L low resolution grating
96: observations (2003) of HD~209458b analyzed here are also detailed in
97: Knutson et al.\ (2007a), Barman (2007), Ballester et al.\ (2007)
98: and Sing et al. (2008a). For both the G750L, and G430L gratings,
99: two visits were done for each grating, of five consecutive orbits
100: each. Together they cover the combined range 2900-10300 \AA, with
101: some overlap around 5300 \AA\ with a resolving power $R=500$.
102:
103:
104: \begin{figure}[b]
105: % \vspace*{-2.0 cm}
106: \begin{center}
107: \includegraphics[angle=90,width=2.4in]{fig1.ps}
108: % \vspace*{-1.0 cm}
109: \caption{
110: The atmospheric Temperature-Pressure profile (\TP) with error
111: bars. The dashed lines correspond to the condensation curves for
112: Titanium, Vanadium and Sodium. The three points of this T-P
113: profile are derived from the fit of the observed absorption depth
114: curve. The hot point at a pressure of 0.05 Bar is imposed by the
115: Rayleigh scattering (See Lecavelier et al. 2008).}
116: \label{fig_TP}
117: \end{center}
118: \end{figure}
119:
120:
121:
122: \begin{figure}[b]
123: % \vspace*{-2.0 cm}
124: \begin{center}
125: \includegraphics[width=3.in]{fig2.ps}
126: % \vspace*{-1.0 cm}
127: \caption{
128: The low resolution STIS measurements of the planetary transit
129: absorption depth (AD) corrected from limb-darkenning effects and
130: binned by 60 pixels (histogram). The dashed line corresponds to
131: the best fit model assuming Rayleigh scattering and sodium
132: absorption with the physical T-P profile plotted in
133: Fig.~\ref{fig_TP}. Overplotted in continuous line, is the same
134: model, with best fit models assuming Rayleigh scattering, NaI, TiO
135: and VO absorptions. The dot-dash line correspond to the model with
136: a cold-trap. The two altitudes of condensation for the TiO and VO
137: molecules are plotted horizontally.}
138: \label{fig1}
139: \end{center}
140: \end{figure}
141: Lecavelier Des Etangs et al. (2008a) show that the observed
142: Absorption Depth (AD) is well approximated by:
143:
144: \begin{equation}
145: AD_{\lambda}=AD_0(1+\frac{2H}{R_P}\ln\frac{\sigma_{\lambda}}{\sigma_{\lambda_0}})
146: \label{ADbin}
147: \end{equation}
148:
149: \noindent where $AD_0$ is AD at $\lambda=\lambda_0$ and H the
150: scale height. Thus the observed mean AD over a wavelength range of
151: a given spectral element, is proportional to the temperature and
152: to the logarithm of the cross section.
153:
154: We use the absorption depth (AD) curve as a function of the
155: wavelength from 4000 \AA\ to 8000 \AA\ obtained by Sing et al.\
156: 2008a. The spectrum at wavelength below 8000 \AA\ is considered
157: here where the absorption due to water molecules is negligible
158: (Barman et al.\ 2007). This AD spectrum is composed of three
159: remarkable features (see Fig.~\ref{fig1}):
160:
161: \
162:
163: \begin{enumerate}
164:
165: \item \textit{Rayleigh scattering}. The feature in NUV, at
166: wavelength $\lambda$ $\le$ 5000 \AA, was first reported by
167: Ballester et al.\ 2007 and explained by the absorption of a hot
168: hydrogen layer within the atmosphere. Here we propose an
169: alternative explanation invoking the Rayleigh scattering by H$_2$
170: molecules (Lecavelier et al.\ 2008b).
171:
172: \
173:
174: \item \textit{Na depletion and atmospheric structure}. Within the
175: same datasets, we find that the Na spectral line profile is
176: characterized by a wide absorption with a sharp transition to a
177: narrow absorption profile at higher altitudes values (Sing et al.\
178: 2008b). This sharp transition is interpreted by condensation or
179: ionization which deplete Na atoms in the upper atmosphere. Using a
180: global fit to these data, from 3000 \AA\ to 6200 \AA, we determine
181: the average pressure-temperature profile ($P-T$), see
182: Fig.~\ref{fig_TP}, at the planetary terminator (Sing et al.\
183: 2008b).
184:
185: \
186:
187: \item \textit{TiO/VO}. A third broad band absorption feature in
188: the range 6200 \AA\ $-$ 8000 \AA\ appears on the absorption depth
189: spectrum and is still unexplained. Although no typical TiO and VO
190: spectral signatures have been identified unambiguously in the
191: observed spectrum, we suggest that the opacities of those
192: molecules are the best candidates to explain the remaining
193: continuous broad band absorption observed in this wavelength
194: domain (D\'esert et al. submitted). Using the \TP\ from Sing et
195: al.\ 2008b, we derived upper limits for the TiO and VO abundances.
196: We found that the abundance of TiO should be around $10^{-4}$ to
197: $10^{-3}$ solar, and the abundance VO around $10^{-3}$ to
198: $10^{-2}$ solar (D\'esert et al. submitted).
199:
200:
201: \end{enumerate}
202:
203:
204:
205:
206:
207:
208: \section{The Irradiated Atmospheres of HD209458b}
209:
210:
211: The temperature inversion leads to high temperature at both low
212: and high pressure. This temperature bifurcation was very well
213: predicted by atmospheric models of strongly irradiated planets (
214: Hubeny et al.\ 2003). In the lower part of the atmosphere
215: ($\sim$30 mbar), the temperature is found to be in the range $1900
216: -2400$ K (Lecavelier et~al. 2008b), which corresponds to the M/L/T
217: brown dwarf regime, as expected for a hot Jupiter such as HD~209458b
218: (Kirkpatrick et al.\ 2005).
219:
220: However, depending on the effective temperature, a large number of
221: diatomic and polyatomic molecules are predicted to be present
222: according to various models of brown dwarf and hot Jupiter
223: (Burrows et al.\ 1999, Lodders et al.\ 1999, Allard et al.\ 2001,
224: Lodders et al.\ 2002, Hubeny et al.\ 2003). Among those molecules
225: and at a temperature above 1800 K, titanium oxyde (TiO) and
226: vanadium oxyde (VO) in gas phase equilibrium are most probably
227: present with a high abundance in strongly irradiated planet
228: atmospheres (Seager et al.\ 1998, Hubeny et al.\ 2003, Fortney et
229: al.\ 2007). Furthermore, the low albedo measurements of HD~209458b (Rowe
230: et al.\ 2006) rule out most of the absorbants, but TiO and VO.
231: Recently, it has been found that a theoretical fit to the HD~209458b
232: near infrared observation at secondary eclipse requires that the
233: dayside atmosphere of HD 209458b have a thermal inversion and a
234: stratosphere (Knutson et al. 2008, Burrows et al.\ 2007c, Burrows
235: et al. 2008). Hubeny et al.\ (2003) and Fortney et al.\ (2007)
236: highlight the importance of gaseous TiO and VO opacity in their
237: model of highly irradiated close-in giant planets. The last
238: authors define two classes of irradiated atmospheres. Those which
239: are warm enough to have a strong opacity due to TiO and VO gases
240: (``pM Class'' planets), and those that are cooler (``pL Class''
241: planets) dominated by Na\,{\sc i} and K\,{\sc i}. Our possible
242: detection of TiO/VO and Na\,{\sc i} in the hot atmosphere of HD~209458b
243: confirm that this planet is located in the transition region
244: between the two classes defined by these authors.
245:
246: Further observation are necessary to better characterize the two
247: different type planets using TiO/VO. More planets can be likely
248: studied using transit observations which allowed discoveries,
249: detection, and characterization of extrasolar objects such as
250: planets and comets (Lecavelier des Etangs et al.\ 1995, 1999a,
251: 2005).
252:
253:
254:
255: \begin{thebibliography}{}
256:
257:
258: \bibitem[{{Allard} {et~al.} 2001}]{Allard01}
259: Allard, F., Hauschildt, P.~H., Alexander, D.~R., Tamanai, A., \&
260: Schweitzer, A.\ 2001, \textit{ApJ}, 556, 357
261:
262: \bibitem[{{Ballester} {et~al.} (2007)}]{Ballester07}
263: {Ballester}, G.~E., {Sing}, D.~K., \& {Herbert}, F. 2007,
264: \textit{Nature}, 445, 511
265:
266: \bibitem[{{Barman} 2007}]{Barman07}
267: {Barman}, T. 2007, \textit{ApJ} (Letters), 661, L191
268:
269: \bibitem[{{Brown} 2001}]{Brown01}
270: {Brown}, T.~M. 2001, \textit{ApJ}, 553, 1006
271:
272: \bibitem[{{Burrows} \& {Sharp} 1999}]{Burrows99}
273: {Burrows}, A. \& {Sharp}, C.~M. 1999, \textit{ApJ}, 512, 843
274:
275: \bibitem[{{Burrows} {et~al.} 2007c}]{Burrows07c}
276: Burrows, A., Hubeny, I., Budaj, J., Knutson, H.~A., \&
277: Charbonneau, D.\ 2007, \textit{ApJ} (Letters), 668, L171
278:
279: \bibitem[{{Burrows} {et~al.} 2008}]{Burrows08}
280: Burrows, A., Budaj, J., \& Hubeny, I.\ 2008, \textit{ApJ}, 678,
281: 1436
282:
283: \bibitem[{{Charbonneau} {et~al.} (2002)}]{Charbonneau02}
284: Charbonneau, D., Brown, T.~M., Noyes, R.~W., \& Gilliland, R.~L.\
285: 2002, \textit{ApJ}, 568, 377
286:
287: \bibitem[{{Charbonneau} {et~al.} 2005}]{Charbonneau05}
288: Charbonneau, D., Allen, L.~E., Megeath, S.~T., et al.\ 2005,
289: \textit{ApJ}, 626, 523
290:
291: \bibitem[2004]{Desert et al.2004}D{\'e}sert, J.-M., Vidal-Madjar, A., Lecavelier
292: Des {\'E}tangs, A., et al.\ 2004, Extrasolar Planets: Today and
293: Tomorrow, 321, 205
294:
295: \bibitem[2008]{Desert2008}D\'esert, J.-M., Lecavelier
296: des Etangs, A., Vidal-Madjar, A., Sing, D.~K., et al.\ 2008,
297: \textit{A\&A}, submitted
298:
299: \bibitem[{{Ehrenreich} {et~al.} 2008}]{Ehrenreich08}
300: Ehrenreich, D., Lecavelier Des Etangs, A., H{\'e}brard, G., et
301: al.\ 2008, \textit{A\&A}, 483, 933
302:
303: \bibitem[{{Fortney} {et~al.} 2003}]{Fortney03}Fortney, J.~J., Sudarsky, D., Hubeny, I.,
304: et al.\ 2003, \textit{ApJ}, 589, 615
305:
306: \bibitem[{{Fortney} {et~al.} 2006b}]{Fortney06}Fortney, J.~J., Cooper, C.~S., Showman,
307: A.~P., Marley, M.~S., \& Freedman, R.~S.\ 2006, \textit{ApJ}, 652,
308: 746
309:
310: \bibitem[{{Fortney} {et~al.} 2007}]{Fortney07}
311: Fortney, J.~J., Lodders, K., Marley, M.~S., \& Freedman, R.~S.\
312: 2008, \textit{ApJ}, 678, 1419
313:
314: \bibitem[{{Hubbard} {et~al.} 2001}]{Hubbard01}
315: Hubbard, W.~B., Fortney, J.~J., Lunine, J.~I., et al.\ 2001,
316: \textit{ApJ}, 560, 413
317:
318: \bibitem[{{Hubeny} {et~al.} 2003}]{Hubeny03}
319: Hubeny, I., Burrows, A., \& Sudarsky, D.\ 2003, \textit{ApJ}, 594,
320: 1011
321:
322: \bibitem[{{Knutson} {et~al.} (2007a)}]{Knutson07a}
323: Knutson, H.~A., Charbonneau, D., Noyes, R.~W., Brown, T.~M., \&
324: Gilliland, R.~L.\ 2007, \textit{ApJ}, 655, 564
325:
326: \bibitem[{{Knutson} {et~al.} 2008}]{Knutson08}
327: Knutson, H.~A., Charbonneau, D., Allen, L.~E., Burrows, A., \&
328: Megeath, S.~T.\ 2008, \textit{ApJ}, 673, 526
329:
330: \bibitem[{{Kirkpatrick} 2005}]{Kirkpatrick05}
331: {Kirkpatrick}, J.~D. 2005, \textit{ARAA}, 43, 195
332:
333: \bibitem[1995]{Lecavelier Des Etangs et al.1995}Lecavelier Des Etangs, A.,
334: Deleuil, M., Vidal-Madjar, A., et al.\ 1995, \textit{A\&A}, 299,
335: 557
336:
337: \bibitem[1999a]{Lecavelier Des Etangs et al.1999a}Lecavelier Des Etangs, A.,
338: Vidal-Madjar, A., \& Ferlet, R.\ 1999, \textit{A\&A}, 343, 916
339:
340: \bibitem[2007]{Lecavelier Des Etangs2007}Lecavelier Des Etangs, A.\ 2007,
341: \textit{A\&A}, 461, 1185
342:
343: \bibitem[2008]{Lecavelier Des Etangs et al.2008}Lecavelier Des Etangs, A.,
344: Vidal-Madjar, A., D{\'e}sert, J.-M., \& Sing, D.\ 2008,
345: \textit{A\&A}, 485, 865
346:
347: \bibitem[{{Lodders} 1999}]{Lodders99}
348: {Lodders}, K. 1999, \textit{ApJ}, 519, 793
349:
350: \bibitem[{{Lodders} 2002}]{Lodders02}
351: {Lodders}, K. 2002, \textit{ApJ}, 577, 974
352:
353: \bibitem[2000]{Nitschelm et al.2000}Nitschelm, C., Lecavelier des Etangs,
354: A., Vidal-Madjar, A., et al.\ 2000, \textit{A\&AS}, 145, 275
355:
356: \bibitem[{{Rowe} {et~al.} 2006}]{Rowe06}
357: Rowe, J.~F., Matthews, J.~M., Seager, S., et al.\ 2006,
358: \textit{ApJ}, 646, 1241
359:
360: \bibitem[1998]{Seager et al.1998}Seager, S.,
361: \& Sasselov, D.~D.\ 1998, \textit{ApJ}l, 502, L157
362:
363: \bibitem[{{Seager} \& {Sasselov} 2000}]{Seager2000a}
364: {Seager}, S. \& {Sasselov}, D.~D. 2000, \textit{ApJ}, 537, 916
365:
366: \bibitem[{{Sing} {et~al.} (2008a)}]{Sing08a}
367: Sing, D.~K., Vidal-Madjar, A., Desert, J.~-., Lecavelier des
368: Etangs, A., \& Ballester, G.\ 2008, ArXiv e-prints, 802,
369: arXiv:0802.3864
370:
371: \bibitem[{{Sing} {et~al.} (2008b)}]{Sing08b}
372: Sing, D.~K., Vidal-Madjar, A., Lecavelier des Etangs, A., et al.\
373: 2008, ArXiv e-prints, 803, arXiv:0803.1054
374:
375: \bibitem[{{Vidal-Madjar} {et~al.} 2003}]{Madjar03}Vidal-Madjar, A., Lecavelier des
376: Etangs, A., D{\'e}sert, J.-M., et al.\ 2003, \textit{Nature}, 422,
377: 143
378:
379: \bibitem[{{Vidal-Madjar} {et~al.} 2004}]{Madjar04}Vidal-Madjar, A., D{\'e}sert, J.-M.,
380: Lecavelier des Etangs, A., et al.\ 2004, \textit{ApJ} (Letters),
381: 604, L69
382:
383: \bibitem[{{Vidal-Madjar} {et~al.} 2008}]{Madjar08}Vidal-Madjar, A., Lecavelier des
384: Etangs, A., D{\'e}sert, J.-M., et al.\ 2008, \textit{ApJ}
385: (Letters), 676, L57
386:
387:
388: \end{thebibliography}
389:
390: \end{document}
391: