1: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% m o d i f i e d %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
2: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% author.tex %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
3: %
4: % sample root file for your contribution to a "contributed book"
5: %
6: % "contributed book"
7: %
8: % Use this file as a template for your own input.
9: %
10: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% Springer-Verlag %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
11:
12: %latex ms.tex
13: %dvips -Ppdf -t letter -o ms.ps ms.dvi
14: %ps2pdf13 ms.ps ms.pdf
15: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% DI-Brussels special notes %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
16: %
17: % when typing your contribution please keep in mind that
18: % we want to make up to three indices:
19: % author, object (i.e. comets other than 9PTempel 1) and
20: % subject
21: % for each author please insert e.g. a
22: % % \index{C}{Authorfamilyname, A.C.}
23: % _after_ the maketitle-command.
24: % Please use the commenting out via % for that.
25: %
26: % For other objects please use in the file the commented-out command
27: % e.g.
28: % % \index{B}{$\beta$-Pictoris}
29: % % \index{B}{73P/Schwassmann-Wachmann 3-C}
30: % please use the most common name
31: %
32: % For the subject index, please make suggestions in a comment box
33: % on top of your contribution; we will take care of the rest!
34: %
35: %
36: % For early rapid electronic access to your contribution you are
37: % encouraged to submit the contribution to astro-ph with the
38: % reference to the proceedings volume such as:
39: % to appear in the proceedings of "Deep Impact as a World Observatory Event -
40: % Synergies in Space, Time",
41: % ed. Hans Ulrich KƤufl and Chris Sterken, Springer
42: %
43: % Thanks for your co-opeartion
44: %
45: % Ulli Kaeufl, Garching, Aug. 21, 2006
46: %
47: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
48:
49:
50: % RECOMMENDED %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
51: \documentclass[multphys,vecphys]{svmult}
52:
53: % choose options for [] as required from the list
54: % in the Reference Guide, Sect. 2.2
55:
56: \usepackage{makeidx} % allows index generation
57: \usepackage{graphicx} % standard LaTeX graphics tool
58: % when including figure files
59: \usepackage{multicol} % used for the two-column index
60: \usepackage[bottom]{footmisc}% places footnotes at page bottom
61: % etc.
62: % see the list of further useful packages
63: % in the Reference Guide, Sects. 2.3, 3.1-3.3
64:
65: \makeindex % used for the subject index
66: % please use the style sprmidx.sty with
67: % your makeindex program
68: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
69: %%% Below: added by Aigen Li %%%
70: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
71: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% macro definitions %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
72: \newcommand \beq {\begin{equation}}
73: \newcommand \eeq {\end{equation}}
74: \newcommand \Ad {A_{\rm d}}
75: \newcommand \Angstrom {\,{\rm \AA}}
76: \newcommand \bT {{\bf T}}
77: \newcommand \C {{\rm C}}
78: \newcommand \cm {\,{\rm cm}}
79: \newcommand \cmr {\,{\rm cm}^{-1}}
80: \newcommand \Ed {E_{\rm d}}
81: \newcommand \erg {\,{\rm erg}}
82: \newcommand \eV {\,{\rm eV}\,}
83: \newcommand \g {\,{\rm g}}
84: \newcommand \gpers {\,{\rm g\,s^{-1}}}
85: \newcommand \rmH {{\rm H}}
86: \newcommand \K {\,{\rm K}}
87: \newcommand \Kd {K_{\rm d}}
88: \newcommand \kms {\,{\rm km \, s}^{-1}}
89: \newcommand \km {\,{\rm km}}
90: \newcommand \micron {\,\mu{\rm m}}
91: \newcommand \nH {n_{\rm H}}
92: \newcommand \pc {\,{\rm pc}}
93: \newcommand \s {\,{\rm s}}
94: \newcommand \pers {\,{\rm s}^{-1}}
95: \newcommand \uHab {u_{\rm Hab}^{\rm uv}}
96: \newcommand \urad {u_{\rm rad}}
97: \newcommand \yr {\,{\rm yr}}
98: \newcommand \yrs {\,{\rm yrs}}
99: \newcommand \Qabs {Q_{\rm abs}}
100: %\newcommand \simlt {\lesssim}
101: %\newcommand \simgt {\gtrsim}
102: %\newcommand \gtsim {\gtrsim}
103: %\newcommand \ltsim {\lesssim}
104: %
105: \newcommand \simlt {>}
106: \newcommand \simgt {>}
107: \newcommand \gtsim {>}
108: \newcommand \ltsim {<}
109: %
110: \newcommand \simali {\sim\,}
111: \newcommand \hab {{\rm HAeBe}}
112: \newcommand \Msun {\,{\rm M_{\odot}}}
113: \newcommand \Teff {T_{\rm eff}}
114: %
115: \newcommand \Stardust {{\it Stardust}}
116: %
117: \newcommand \um {\mu{\rm m}}
118: \newcommand \mum {\,{\rm \mu m}}
119: \newcommand \ppm {\,{\rm ppm}}
120: \newcommand \nm {\,{\rm nm}}
121: \newcommand \AU {\,{\rm AU}}
122: \newcommand \au {\,{\rm AU}}
123: \newcommand \ch {\rm C_{14}H_{10}}
124: \newcommand \rh {r_{\rm h}}
125: \newcommand \rsl {r_{\rm SL}}
126: \newcommand \Npah {N_{\rm PAH}}
127: \newcommand \Natom {N_{\rm atom}}
128: \newcommand \Qpahdot {\dot{Q}_{\rm PAH}}
129: \newcommand \vpah {v_{\rm PAH}}
130: \newcommand \taupah {\tau_{\rm PAH}}
131: \newcommand \tauh {\tau_{\rm H}}
132: \newcommand \mpah {m_{\rm PAH}}
133: \newcommand \Mpahdot {\dot{M}_{\rm PAH}}
134: \newcommand \Mdustdot {\dot{M}_{\rm dust}}
135: \newcommand \deltat {\Delta t}
136: \newcommand{\figwidth}{3.5in}
137: \newcommand{\figwidthland}{4.0in}
138: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
139: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
140: %%% Above: added by Aigen Li %%%
141: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
142:
143: \begin{document}
144: %
145: \title*{PAHs in Comets: An Overview}
146: \author{Aigen Li}
147: \institute{Department of Physics and Astronomy,
148: University of Missouri,\\
149: Columbia, MO 65211;
150: \texttt{LiA@missouri.edu}}
151: %
152: % Use the package "url.sty" to avoid
153: % problems with special characters
154: % used in your e-mail or web address
155: %
156: \maketitle
157:
158:
159:
160: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%% here goes the author index entry %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
161: %
162: % \index{C}{Authorfamilyname1, A.C.}
163: % \index{C}{Authorfamilyname2, B.A.}
164: %
165: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
166:
167: \setcounter{footnote}{0}
168:
169:
170:
171: %
172: % abstract is optional; as an example I have added an old one of mine
173: %
174:
175: \vspace{-0.4cm}
176: \begin{abstract}
177: \vspace{-0.8cm}
178: %
179: Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon (PAH) molecules,
180: ubiquitously seen in the interstellar medium (ISM)
181: of our own and external galaxies,
182: might have been incorporated into comets if they are
183: formed from relatively unprocessed interstellar matter.
184: The detection of PAHs in comets would be
185: an important link between the ISM and comets.
186: This review compiles our current knowledge on
187: cometary PAHs, based on ground-based and space-borne
188: observations of infrared vibrational and ultraviolet
189: fluorescence spectra of comets, and laboratory analysis of
190: interplanetary dust particles possibly of cometary origin
191: and cometary samples returned to Earth by the \Stardust\ spacecraft.
192: The latter provided the most unambiguous evidence
193: for the presence of PAHs in cometary nuclei.
194: \end{abstract}
195:
196: \vspace{-1.2cm}
197: \section{~Introduction: PAHs as a Link between
198: the Interstellar Medium and the Solar System}
199: \vspace{-0.2cm}
200: %
201: The major goals of cometary science are to determine
202: the chemical composition and physical structure of
203: cometary nuclei and to shed light on the origin of
204: the solar system. It is now widely recognized that
205: comets formed in the cold outer regions of
206: the solar nebula ($\simali$5--55$\AU$ from the Sun,
207: well beyond the ``snowline'') and have been stored
208: in two distant reservoirs (i.e. the Oort cloud and
209: the Kuiper Belt) for most of the age of the solar system
210: ($\simali$4.6$\times 10^9\yrs$).
211: %
212: Because of their cold formation and cold storage,\footnote{%
213: Long-period comets (with orbital periods ranging from
214: 200$\yrs$ up to $10^7\yrs$) originate in the Oort Cloud
215: ($\simali$3000--50,000$\AU$ from the Sun)
216: and formed in the giant planets region
217: from Jupiter to Neptune
218: of the pre-planetary nebula ($\simali$5--40$\AU$ from the Sun),
219: where the nebula temperature ranged from $>$120\,K near Jupiter
220: to $<$30\,K near Neptune.
221: The source of Jupiter-family short-period comets
222: (with periods shorter than 20$\yrs$),
223: formed further out than long-period comets
224: in the trans-Neptune region,
225: is the Kuiper Belt
226: ($\simali$30--50$\AU$ from the Sun).
227: Halley-family short-period comets
228: (with periods of 20$\yrs$\,$<$\,$P$\,$<$\,200$\yrs$)
229: originally came from the Oort cloud
230: and then have been scattered into short-period type orbits
231: by the perturbation of Jupiter and/or Saturn.
232: }
233: it is therefore also widely believed that comets
234: are the most primitive objects in the solar system.
235:
236: However, there is no consensus on to what
237: extent comets preserve the composition of
238: the presolar molecular cloud
239: and the early stages of the protosolar nebula.
240: A compelling theory is that comets are made of
241: unaltered pristine interstellar materials
242: with only the most volatile components partially
243: evaporated (Greenberg 1982).
244: Alternatively, it has also been proposed that
245: cometary materials have been subjected to evaporation,
246: recondensation and other reprocessing in the protosolar
247: nebula and therefore have lost all the records of
248: the presolar molecular cloud out of which they have formed.
249:
250: Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon (PAH) molecules,
251: composed of fused benzene rings
252: (see Fig.\,\ref{fig:pah_cartoon} for illustration),
253: and a significant constituent of
254: the interstellar medium (ISM) of the Milky Way
255: and external galaxies (see \S\ref{sec:ism}),
256: would also be present in comets if they
257: indeed contain unprocessed interstellar matter.
258: The detection of PAHs in comets would be an important
259: link between the ISM and comets and provides important
260: clues on the processes that occurred during the formation
261: of our solar system.
262:
263: In this review I attempt to compile all possible
264: evidence for the presence of PAHs in comets (\S\ref{sec:cometpah}),
265: focusing on ground-based and space-borne spectroscopy
266: of infrared vibrational and ultraviolet (UV)
267: fluorescent emission spectra of comets,
268: and laboratory analysis of stratospherically collected
269: interplanetary dust particles (IDPs)
270: thought to be cometary in origin
271: and cometary samples returned to Earth
272: by the \Stardust\ spacecraft,
273: with the latter providing the most unambiguous proof.
274: Using the PAHs in the ISM (\S\ref{sec:ism})
275: and circumstellar disks (\S\ref{sec:disk})
276: as a comparison basis,
277: the physical and chemical nature
278: and source of cometary PAHs are discussed in \S\ref{sec:discussion}.
279:
280: %%%%% Fig.1 %%%%%
281: \vspace{-0.1cm}
282: \begin{figure}
283: \centering
284: %\includegraphics[height=11.8cm, angle=270]{pah_cartoon.eps}
285: \includegraphics[width=11.6cm]{spitzer_pah_struct.cps}
286: \vspace{-0.2cm}
287: \caption{\label{fig:pah_cartoon}\footnotesize
288: Structures of 21 {\it specific} PAH molecules.
289: Both compact pericondensed molecules
290: ({\it pyrene}, {\it perylene})
291: and thermodynamically less favoured catacondensed
292: molecules ({\it naphthalene}, {\it phenanthrene})
293: and their alkylated homologs
294: were identified in the \Stardust\ samples
295: (Sandford et al.\ 2006, Clemett et al.\ 2007).
296: Naphthalene, phenanthrene and their alkylated derivatives
297: were found in IDPs possibly of cometary origin
298: (Clemett et al.\ 1993).
299: PAHs with up to 7 rings and their alkyl derivatives
300: are abundant in carbonaceous chondrites
301: (Sephton et al.\ 2004).
302: }
303: \end{figure}
304:
305: %\vspace{-1.0cm}
306: \section{~Ubiquity of PAHs in the Interstellar Medium of
307: the Milky Way and External Galaxies\label{sec:ism}}
308: %
309: \vspace{-0.2cm}
310: %
311: PAHs reveal their presence in the ISM
312: by emitting a distinctive set of emission features
313: at 3.3, 6.2, 7.7, 8.6, and 11.3$\mum$
314: (which are also collectively known as
315: the ``Unidentified Infrared'' [UIR] emission bands).\footnote{%
316: \vspace{-0.5mm}
317: These ``UIR'' emission features
318: are now generally identified as vibrational modes of
319: PAHs (L\'{e}ger \& Puget 1984; Allamandola et al.\ 1985):
320: C--H stretching mode (3.3$\mum$),
321: C--C stretching modes (6.2, 7.7$\mum$),
322: C--H in-plane bending mode (8.6$\mum$),
323: and C--H out-of-plane bending mode (11.3$\mum$).
324: Other C--H out-of-plane bending modes
325: at 11.9, 12.7 and 13.6$\mum$ have also been detected.
326: The wavelengths of the C--H out-of-plane bending modes
327: depend on the number of neighboring H atoms:
328: 11.3$\mum$ for solo-CH (no adjacent H atom),
329: 11.9$\mum$ for duet-CH (2 adjacent H atoms),
330: 12.7$\mum$ for trio-CH (3 adjacent H atoms),
331: and 13.6$\mum$ for quartet-CH (4 adjacent H atoms).
332: Other prominent features are the C-C-C bending modes
333: at 16.4$\mum$ (Moutou et al.\ 1996),
334: 17.1, 17.8, 18.9$\mum$
335: (Beintema et al.\ 1996;
336: Smith et al.\ 2004;
337: van Kerckhoven et al.\ 2000;
338: Werner et al.\ 2004).
339: }
340: Since their first detection in the planetary nebulae NGC\,7027
341: and BD+30$^{\rm o}$3639 (Gillett et al.\ 1973),
342: PAHs have been observed in a wide range of
343: Galactic and extragalactic regions
344: (see Fig.\,\ref{fig:pah_ism} and Draine \& Li 2007).
345:
346: In the Milky Way diffuse ISM,
347: PAHs, containing $\simali$45$\ppm$
348: (parts per million, relative to H) C,
349: account for $\simali$20\% of the total power emitted
350: by interstellar dust (Li \& Draine 2001b).
351: The {\it\small ISO} (Infrared Space Observatories)
352: and {\it Spitzer} imaging and spectroscopy
353: have revealed that PAHs are also a ubiquitous feature of
354: external galaxies (Tielens 2005; Smith et al.\ 2007).
355: Recent discoveries include
356: the detection of PAH emission in a wide range of systems:
357: distant Luminous Infrared Galaxies (LIRGs)
358: with redshift $z$ ranging from 0.1 to 1.2
359: (Elbaz et al.\ 2005),
360: distant Ultraluminous Infrared Galaxies
361: (ULIRGs) with redshift $z\sim$\,2 (Yan et al.\ 2005, 2007),
362: distant luminous submillimeter galaxies at
363: redshift $z\sim$\,2.8 (Lutz et al.\ 2005),
364: the distant Cloverleaf lensed QSO
365: at redshift $z\sim$\,2.56 (Lutz et al.\ 2007),
366: elliptical galaxies with a hostile environment
367: (containing hot gas of temperature $\sim$\,10$^7\K$)
368: where PAHs can be easily destroyed
369: through sputtering by plasma ions
370: (Kaneda et al.\ 2005),
371: faint tidal dwarf galaxies with metallicity
372: $\sim Z_\odot/3$ (Higdon et al.\ 2006),
373: and galaxy halos
374: (extending $\simali$6.5\,kpc
375: from the plane of NGC\,5907 [Irwin \& Madden 2006]
376: and $>$9.5\,kpc from the plane of M\,82
377: [Engelbracht et al.\ 2006]).
378:
379: However, the PAH features are weak or even absent
380: in AGNs (as first noticed by Roche et al.\ 1991)
381: and low-metallicity galaxies
382: (Thuan et al.\ 1999; Houck et al.\ 2004;
383: Engelbracht et al.\ 2005; Hunt et al.\ 2005;
384: Madden et al.\ 2006; Wu et al.\ 2006;
385: Rosenberg et al.\ 2006; Draine et al.\ 2007).
386: The exact reason for the deficiency or lack of PAHs
387: in low-metallicity galaxies and AGNs is not clear.
388: It is generally interpreted as the destruction of PAHs
389: (1) by hard UV photons (e.g. see Plante \& Sauvage 2002)
390: or supernova-driven shocks (O'Halloran et al.\ 2006)
391: in metal-poor galaxies,\footnote{%
392: %\vspace{-2mm}
393: Alternatively, these low-metallicity galaxies
394: may be truly young and PAHs have simply not had
395: time to form due to the delayed injection of carbon
396: molecules from low-mass stars into the ISM (Dwek 2005).
397: }
398: %
399: and
400: %
401: (2) by extreme UV and soft X-ray photons in AGNs
402: (Voit 1991, 1992; Siebenmorgen et al.\ 2004).
403: Observations also suggest that PAHs are destroyed in
404: star-forming regions with very strong and hard radiation fields
405: (Contursi et al. 2000; F\"{o}rster Schreiber et al.\ 2004;
406: Beir\~{a}o et al.\ 2006).
407:
408: %%%%% Fig.2 %%%%%
409: \vspace{-2mm}
410: \begin{figure}
411: \centering
412: \includegraphics[height=11cm]{iso_irs_pahs.cps}
413: \vspace{-3mm}
414: \caption{\label{fig:pah_ism} \footnotesize
415: Observed 5--20$\mum$ spectra for:
416: (a) Reflection nebula NGC\,7023
417: (Werner et al.\ 2004);
418: (b) Orion Bar photodissociated region
419: (PDR; Verstraete et al.\ 2001);
420: (c) M17 PDR
421: (Peeters et al.\ 2005);
422: (d) Planetary nebula NGC\,7027
423: (van Diedenhoven et al.\ 2004);
424: (e) Seyfert Galaxy NGC\,5194
425: (Smith et al.\ 2007).
426: Also shown (f) is the emission calculated for
427: the astro-PAH model of Draine \& Li (2007),
428: illuminated by starlight with an intensity
429: $U=1$ and $10^5$ times of the local interstellar
430: radiation field of Mathis et al.\ (1983).
431: Taken from Draine \& Li (2007).
432: }
433: %\label{fig:pah_obs} % Give a unique label
434: \end{figure}
435:
436: \vspace{-12mm}
437: \section{~PAHs in Circumstellar Dust Disks\label{sec:disk}}
438: \vspace{-1mm}
439: Dust disks around young stars, depending on their age,
440: are the source material or the remnants of
441: newly-formed planets, asteroids, and comets.
442: There exists observational evidence for
443: the presence of PAHs in protoplanetary disks
444: around the intermediate-mass ($\simali$2--10$\Msun$)
445: pre-main-sequence (PMS)
446: Herbig Ae/Be (hereafter HAeBe) stars
447: and their low-mass ($<$\,2$\Msun$) analog T Tauri stars,
448: as well as debris disks around main-sequence (MS) stars
449: (see Fig.\,\ref{fig:pah_disks} for illustration).
450:
451: \begin{itemize}
452: \vspace{-0.3em}
453: \item From an analysis of the space-borne and ground-based
454: spectra of 41 \hab\ stars in the 3$\mum$ region,
455: Brooke et al.\ (1993) reported a firm detection
456: of the 3.3$\mum$ PAH C--H stretching emission feature
457: in $\simali$20\% of these objects.
458: %
459: \vspace{-0.5em}
460: \item Acke \& van den Ancker (2004) found that the PAH features
461: have been detected in $\simali$57\% of the 46 \hab\ stars
462: for which the {\it\small ISO} spectroscopic data are available.
463: %
464: \vspace{0.4em}
465: \item Recent {\it Spitzer} observations have
466: obtained the PAH spectra of over 20 \hab\ stars
467: (Sloan et al.\ 2005; Keller et al.\ 2008).
468: Spectral variations among these stars
469: and their deviations from typical interstellar
470: PAH features were reported
471: (see Fig.\,\ref{fig:pah_disks}).
472: %
473: \vspace{0.4em}
474: \item Geers et al.\ (2006) analyzed the {\it Spitzer} IRS spectra
475: of 38 T Tauri stars and found PAHs in at least 8\%
476: (or probably as much as 45\%) of these objects.
477: The PAH spectra of T Tauri stars appear to be quite
478: different from those of \hab\ stars
479: and those typical in the ISM
480: (see Fig.\,\ref{fig:pah_disks}).
481: %The 7.7$\mum$ C-C stretching feature and the 8.6$\mum$
482: %C-H in-plane bending feature are hardly seen,
483: %but the 6.2$\mum$ C-C stretching feature and the 11.3$\mum$
484: %C-H out-of-plane bending feature are relatively strong.
485: %
486: %
487: \vspace{0.4em}
488: \item The PAH emission features have also been detected in
489: UV-poor dust debris disks around F- and G-type MS stars
490: (e.g. SAO\,206462 of spectral type F8V with
491: $\Teff\approx 6250\K$ [Coulson \& Walther 1995],
492: and HD\,34700 of spectral type G0V
493: with $\Teff\approx 5940\K$
494: [Sylvester et al.\ 1997;
495: Smith, Clayton, \& Valencic 2004;
496: see Fig.\,\ref{fig:pah_disks}]).
497: However, in an extensive {\it Spitzer} IRS spectroscopic
498: survey of 111 T Tauri stars in the Taurus star-forming region,
499: Furlan et al.\ (2006) found that the PAH emission
500: bands are not seen in dust disks around T Tauri stars of
501: spectral type later than G1.
502: %
503: \vspace{0.4em}
504: \item Ground-based spatially resolved spectroscopy
505: has revealed that the 3.3--12.7$\mum$ PAH emission
506: features in some HAeBe disks are spatially extended
507: (on a scale of several hundred AU for the 6.2--12.7$\mum$
508: bands; van Boekel et al.\ 2004; Geers et al.\ 2004;
509: Habart et al.\ 2006).
510: %
511: \vspace{0.4em}
512: \item Jura et al.\ (2006) reported the detection
513: of the PAH emission features in HD\,233517,
514: an evolved oxygen-rich K2III red giant
515: ($\Teff \approx 4390\K$) with circumstellar dust.
516: But Jura (2003) argued that
517: the IR excess around HD\,233517 is unlikely to
518: be produced by a recent outflow in a stellar wind.
519: Jura et al.\ (2006) hypothesized that
520: there is a passive, flared disk orbiting HD\,233517
521: and the PAH molecules in the orbiting disk
522: may be synthesized in situ as well as having been
523: incorporated from the ISM.\\[1mm]
524: Sloan et al.\ (2007) observed the PAH emission features
525: in the circumstellar disk of HD\,100764,
526: a carbon-rich red giant ($\Teff \approx 4850\K$),
527: and found that they are shifted to longer wavelengths
528: than normally seen, consistent with a ``Class C''
529: PAH spectrum (Peeters et al.\ 2002;
530: the PAH spectra of HD\,233517 and SU Aur also
531: belong to ``Class C''; see Fig.\,\ref{fig:pah_disks}).
532: %
533: %\footnote{%
534: % G\"urtler et al.\ (1999) reported the detection of the PAH
535: % emission features with ISOPHOT in the reflection nebulae
536: % illuminated by T Tauri stars in the Chamaeleon I dark cloud.
537: % }
538: %
539: \end{itemize}
540:
541: %%%%% Fig.3 %%%%%
542: \begin{figure}
543: \vspace{-3mm}
544: \centering
545: \includegraphics[height=11cm]{pah_disks.cps}
546: \vspace{-5mm}
547: \caption{\label{fig:pah_disks} \footnotesize
548: Observed 5--20$\mum$ spectra for:
549: (a) Protoplanetary disk around HAeBe star
550: HD\,141569A (B9.5V; $\Teff$\,$\approx$\,10,000$\K$;
551: Sloan et al.\ 2005);
552: (b) Protoplanetary disk around T Tauri star
553: SU Aur (G1III; $\Teff$\,$\approx$\,5945$\K$;
554: Furlan et al.\ 2006);
555: (c) Debris disk around HD\,34700
556: (G0V; $\Teff$\,$\approx$\,6000$\K$;
557: Li et al.\ 2008);
558: (d) Circumstellar disk around red giant
559: HD\,233517 (K2III; $\Teff$\,$\approx$\,4390$\K$;
560: Jura et al.\ 2006);
561: (e) Reflection nebula NGC\,2023
562: (illuminated by HD\,37903
563: [B1.5V; $\Teff$\,$\approx$\,22,000$\K$];
564: Verstraete et al.\ 2001).
565: Also shown (f) is the emission calculated for
566: phenanthrene C$_{14}$H$_{10}$
567: and its cation C$_{14}$H$_{10}^{+}$ at
568: $\rh$\,=\,1$\AU$ from the Sun (Li \& Draine 2008).
569: }
570: \vspace{-2mm}
571: \end{figure}
572:
573: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
574: %%%%% Fig.4 %%%%%
575: \begin{figure}
576: \vspace{-3mm}
577: \centering
578: \includegraphics[height=7.1cm]{halley_3.28um.eps}
579: \vspace{-4mm}
580: \caption{\label{fig:halley_3.28um} \footnotesize
581: IR emission spectrum of comet Halley
582: obtained by Baas et al.\ (1986) with
583: the 3.8\,m United Kingdom IR Telescope (UKIRT)
584: on Mauna Kea on 1986 April 25
585: at a heliocentric distance of $\rh$\,=\,1.6$\AU$.
586: In addition to the major feature at 3.36$\mum$
587: (often known as the ``cometary organic feature'';
588: the 3.33$\mum$ $\nu_2$ band and 3.37$\mum$ $\nu_9$ band
589: of methanol CH$_3$OH account for about half its total
590: intensity; Bockel\'ee-Morvan et al.\ 1995),
591: there were also subsidiary peaks at 3.28$\mum$
592: and 3.52$\mum$ ($\nu_3$ band of methanol; Hoban et al.\ 1993).
593: Taken from Baas et al.\ (1986).
594: }
595: \end{figure}
596:
597: %%% Fig.5 %%%%%
598: \begin{figure}
599: \vspace{-2mm}
600: \centering
601: \includegraphics[height=7.1cm]{levy_3.28um.eps}
602: %\picplace{5cm}{2cm}
603: % Give the correct figure height and width in cm
604: %
605: \vspace{-4mm}
606: \caption{\label{fig:levy_3.28um} \footnotesize
607: IR emission spectrum of comet Levy
608: obtained by Davies et al.\ (1991) with UKIRT
609: on 1990 August 27 at $\rh$\,=\,1.4$\AU$.
610: The 3.28$\mum$ feature was as prominent
611: as the broad 3.4$\mum$ (which was resolved
612: into two components peaking at 3.35$\mum$
613: and 3.41$\mum$). The dotted curve was
614: the relative transmission of
615: the atmosphere above Mauna Kea.
616: Comet Levy had the strongest 3.28$\mum$ feature
617: relative to the 3.4$\mum$ feature among all comets.
618: Taken from Davies et al.\ (1991).
619: }
620: \end{figure}
621: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
622:
623: %%%%% Fig.6 %%%%%
624: \begin{figure}
625: \vspace{-3.5mm}
626: \centering
627: \includegraphics[height=7.0cm]{moreels.eps}
628: \vspace{-3.5mm}
629: \caption{\label{fig:moreels} \footnotesize
630: Comparison of the near-UV emission spectrum
631: of comet Halley measured by TKS-Vega at
632: $\rh$\,=\,0.83$\AU$ (on 1986 March 9)
633: with the experimentally-measured
634: laser-induced fluorescence spectrum of
635: phenanthrene (upper curve).
636: Three main peaks coincide at 347, 356, and 364\,nm.
637: Taken from Moreels et al.\ (1994).
638: }
639: \vspace{-5mm}
640: \end{figure}
641:
642: %%%%% Fig.7 %%%%%
643: \begin{figure}
644: \vspace{-3.2mm}
645: \centering
646: %\includegraphics[height=11.2cm, angle=270]{clemett_stardust.eps}
647: \includegraphics[width=11.2cm]{clemett_pahs_comets.cps}
648: \vspace{-2mm}
649: \caption{\label{fig:clemett} \footnotesize
650: PAH mass spectrum distribution for a \Stardust\ sample
651: obtained with the two-step laser mass spectrometry.
652: The most commonly found PAH species are
653: naphthalene (C$_{10}$H$_8$),
654: phenanthrene (C$_{14}$H$_{10}$),
655: pyrene (C$_{16}$H$_{10}$),
656: perylene (C$_{20}$H$_{12}$),
657: and their alkylated homologs.
658: Interspersed within these species is
659: a rich suite of auxiliary peaks which appears to
660: represent the presence of O and N substitution,
661: where the heterofunctionality being
662: external to aromatic structure.
663: Taken from Clemett et al.\ (2007).
664: }
665: \vspace{-6mm}
666: \end{figure}
667:
668: \vspace{-7mm}
669: \section{~Evidence for PAHs in Comets\label{sec:cometpah}}
670: \vspace{-3mm}
671: %
672: The presence of PAHs in comets was an open issue
673: in the pre-\Stardust\ era. One of the most important
674: discoveries of the \Stardust\ Discovery Mission was
675: the first ever most unambiguous detection of PAHs in
676: a comet. Below, I summarize all {\it tentative} evidence
677: in the pre-\Stardust\ era which may suggest the presence
678: of PAHs in comets and finally, the more definite proof
679: from the \Stardust\ mission.\footnote{%
680: We should note that PAHs (e.g. naphthalene,
681: phenanthrene, pyrene, chrysene, perylene,
682: benzo[ghi]perylene, and coronene;
683: see Fig.\,\ref{fig:pah_cartoon}) with varying degrees
684: of alkylation have been identified in primitive
685: carbonaceous chondritic meteorites
686: (Sephton et al.\ 2004; Derenne et al.\ 2005).
687: Although most primitive meteorites are {\it asteroidal}
688: (originated in the asteroid belt, somewhere between
689: 2--5$\AU$ from the Sun), Campins \& Swindle (1998)
690: argued that some meteorites may have a {\it cometary} origin
691: (but so far no known meteorites appear to come from comets).
692: }
693: %
694: \begin{itemize}
695: %\vspace{-5mm}
696: \item Baas et al.\ (1986) by the first time reported
697: the detection of a discrete emission feature
698: at 3.28$\mum$ in comet Halley after perihelion,
699: at heliocentric distances of $\rh$\,=\,1.6$\AU$
700: (on 1986 April 25; see Fig.\,\ref{fig:halley_3.28um})
701: and 2.0$\AU$ (on 1986 May 24).
702: This feature was also seen in comet Levy
703: at $\rh$\,=\,1.4$\AU$
704: (on 1990 August 27; Davies et al.\ 1991;
705: see Fig.\,\ref{fig:levy_3.28um}).
706: It was tentatively attributed to the C--H stretching mode
707: of PAHs (e.g. see Bockelee-Morvan et al.\ 1995).
708: However, other species, such as CH$_4$ and OH prompt emission
709: are also contributing at this wavelength
710: (e.g. see Mumma et al.\ 2001).\\[1mm]
711: %This band is subject to blending with OH prompt emission
712: %and CH$_4$ fuorescence emission.
713: %
714: %This PAH band was not observed in Comet Hale-Bopp,
715: %either from the ground or with ISO, but the ISO spectra
716: %were obtained at relatively large heliocentric distances
717: %($r > 2.7\AU$) where the PAHs may not be emitting efficiently.
718: %No feature at 3.28um was reported from ground-based
719: %observations of this comet at small heliocentric
720: %distances, but it might have been hidden by
721: %the very strong dust continuum of this comet.
722: %
723: %\vspace{0.3em}
724: %\item
725: Using a $\chi^2$-fitting technique,
726: Lisse et al.\ (2006) found the 6.2, 7.7, 8.6
727: and 11.3$\mum$ emission features of {\small PAHs}
728: in the spectrum of the {\it Deep Impact} ejecta
729: of comet Tempel 1 (at $\rh$\,=\,1.51$\AU$),
730: obtained with {\it Spitzer} 45 minutes after impact.
731: This identification did not rely on a search for
732: individual spectral features, but from the decrease
733: of the residual $\chi^2$ after a fit of the observed
734: spectrum by a modeled spectrum.\footnote{%
735: In the ground-based 7.8--13.2$\mum$ mid-IR spectra
736: of comet Tempel 1 obtained with {\it Gemini-N}
737: 61--94 minutes after impact,
738: Harker et al.\ (2007) possibly detected emission
739: from PAHs at 8.25 and 8.6$\mum$
740: (perhaps also at 12.4 and 12.9$\mum$).
741: It is unclear whether the 11.3$\mum$ PAH feature
742: was present or not since it might have been hidden by
743: the much stronger 11.3$\mum$ crystalline olivine feature.
744: }
745: Using the same technique, Lisse et al.\ (2007) re-analyzed
746: the {\small\it ISO} spectrum of Hale-Bopp at $\rh$\,=\,2.8$\AU$
747: taken on 1996 October 6 and found PAH signals in this
748: \vspace{-6mm}
749: comet (but see Crovisier et al.\ 2000,
750: Crovisier \& Bockel\'{e}e-Morvan 2008).
751: %
752: %The ISO spectra of comet Hale-Bopp
753: %do not show any PAH signal, especially in the 6--8um
754: %region (Crovisier et al.\ 1999) where PAH bands well
755: %separated from silicate features are obvious in
756: %other objects (e.g. Malfait et al.\ 1998).
757: %However, Hale-Bopp could only be observed by
758: %ISO at heliocentric distances larger than 2.9AU
759: %because of visibility constrains; at these distances,
760: %the nucleus and dust temperatures may not be high
761: %enough to permit the release of PAHs in the gas phase.
762: %No feature at 3.28um was reported from ground-based
763: %observations of this comet at small heliocentric
764: %distances, but it might have been hidden by
765: %the very strong dust continuum of this comet.
766: %
767: %\vspace{-0.6em}
768: \vspace{0.6em}
769: \item Moreels et al.\ (1994) reported the detection of
770: four emission bands at 347, 356, 364 and 374$\nm$
771: in the near-UV spectrum of comet Halley
772: at $\rh$\,=\,0.83$\AU$ obtained with
773: the Three-Channel-Spectrometer (TKS)
774: on board the Vega-2 spacecraft (see Fig.\,\ref{fig:moreels}).
775: They attributed these bands to the fluorescence
776: of phenanthrene ($\ch$).
777: But the production rate of phenanthrene alone
778: required to account for the observed band intensities
779: ($\simali$1.5\,$\times$\,10$^{27}$\,mol\,$\s^{-1}$)
780: would be $\simali$100 times higher than
781: that of PAHs derived from the 3.28$\mum$ feature
782: (Bockel\'{e}e-Morvan et al.\ 1995).
783: More recently, Clairemidi et al.\ (2004) identified
784: in the TKS-Vega spectrum of the inner coma of comet Halley
785: a broad-band emission feature between 340 and 390$\nm$
786: with 3 peaks at 371, 376 and 382$\nm$.
787: They tentatively attributed these bands to
788: pyrene (C$_{16}$H$_{10}$).
789: %
790: \vspace{0.3em}
791: \item Clemett et al.\ (1993) identified small PAH molecules
792: (including naphthalene C$_{10}$H$_8$ and phenanthrene)
793: and their alkylated derivatives in the microprobe
794: two-step laser desorption laser ionization mass
795: spectrometry ($\mu$L$^2$MS) of
796: IDPs possibly of cometary origin.\footnote{%
797: Stratospheric IDPs are believed to have originated
798: primarily from asteroids and short-period comets
799: (i.e. collisional debris from main belt asteroids
800: and cometary dust captured in Earth's atmosphere
801: when spiraling toward the Sun due to
802: Poynting-Robertson drag).
803: Atmospheric entry velocities,
804: as determined from the atmospheric entry
805: temperatures measured from the stepped He-release
806: method (Nier \& Schlutter 1993)
807: and the atmospheric entry model of
808: Love \& Brownlee (1994),
809: have been used to distinguish between IDPs arising
810: from comets and asteroids, based on
811: the marked differences between typical
812: asteroidal and cometary orbits
813: -- asteroidal IDPs spiraling in toward the Sun
814: from low inclination, low eccentric asteroidal sources
815: will enter Earth's atmosphere, on average,
816: at relatively lower velocities
817: than cometary IDPs (Flynn 1989, Joswiak et al.\ 2007).
818: %
819: Very recently, Joswiak et al.\ (2007) analyzed 31 IDPs
820: and distinguished two groups:
821: 12 porous cometary IDPs with atmospheric entry velocities
822: $>$\,18$\km\s^{-1}$, an average density of
823: $\simali$1.0$\g\cm^{-3}$, and an anhydrous mineralogy;
824: 4 more compact asteroidal IDPs mainly composed
825: of hydrated minerals with atmospheric entry
826: velocities $<$\,14$\km\s^{-1}$, and an average density of
827: $\simali$3.3$\g\cm^{-3}$.
828: }
829: %
830: \vspace{0.3em}
831: \item Very recently, Sandford et al.\ (2006),
832: Keller et al.\ (2006), and Clemett et al.\ (2007)
833: analyzed the cometary materials
834: returned to Earth by the \Stardust\ spacecraft
835: and clearly demonstrated that PAHs are present
836: in comet Wild 2, the \Stardust\ mission target:
837: (1) The L$^2$MS (two-step laser desorption laser ionization
838: mass spectrometry) spectra of the \Stardust\ samples
839: revealed the presence of
840: naphthalene, phenanthrene, pyrene,
841: perylene (C$_{20}$H$_{12}$)
842: and their alkylated homologs extending up to
843: at least C$_4$-alkyl
844: %as well as O- and N-substituted aromatic species
845: (Sandford et al.\ 2006, Clemett et al.\ 2007;
846: Fig.\,\ref{fig:clemett});
847: (2) The Raman spectra of the \Stardust\ samples
848: exhibit pronounced ``D'' ($\simali$1360\,${\rm \Delta}\cm^{-1}$)
849: and ``G'' ($\simali$1580\,${\rm \Delta}\cm^{-1}$) bands,
850: characteristic of highly disordered sp$^2$-bonded
851: aromatic carbon (Sandford et al.\ 2006;
852: Fig.\,\ref{fig:Raman_FTIR}A); and
853: (3) The Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) spectra
854: clearly show an absorption feature at 3050$\cm^{-1}$,
855: corresponding to the aromatic C--H stretching mode
856: at 3.28$\mum$ (Keller et al.\ 2006;
857: Fig.\,\ref{fig:Raman_FTIR}B).
858: %
859: %a highly disordered graphitic carbon has been observed
860: %with Raman spectroscopy [the G bands are characteristic
861: %of aromatic carbon...
862: %Aromatic materials are also seen using Raman spectroscopy.
863: %Raman spectra, acquired for 12 Stardust particles ...
864: %are dominated by two broad bands centered at ...
865: %These "D" and "G" bands, respectively,
866: %are characteristic of "disordered carbonaceous material"
867: %-- graphite-like sp2-bonded carbon in the form of condensed
868: %carbon rings. Relative peak sizes, peak positions,
869: %and widths of the D and G bands reflect the degree
870: %of disorder of the material and can provide constraints
871: %on the degree of thermal metamorphism
872: %experienced by organic materials ...
873: %
874: \end{itemize}
875:
876: %%%%% Fig.8 %%%%%
877: %\begin{figure}
878: %\centering
879: %\includegraphics[height=8.4cm]{sandford_raman.eps}
880: %\vspace{-2mm}
881: %\caption{\label{fig:raman} \footnotesize
882: % Raman spectra of two \Stardust\ particles (top panel)
883: % compared with the spectra of organics from
884: % extraterrestrial (middle panel)
885: % and terrestrial (bottom panel)
886: % carbonaceous materials.
887: % All exhibit ``D'' and ``G'' bands
888: % characteristic of disordered sp$^2$-bonded aromatic carbon.
889: % Taken from Sandford et al.\ (2006).
890: % }
891: %\end{figure}
892:
893: %%%%% Fig.9 %%%%%
894: %\begin{figure}
895: %\centering
896: %\includegraphics[height=6.2cm]{keller_stardust_3.28um.eps}
897: %\vspace{-2mm}
898: %\caption{\label{fig:keller} \footnotesize
899: % Continuum-subtracted FTIR absorption spectrum
900: % of a \Stardust\ sample. Both aromatic ($\simali$3050$\cm^{-1}$)
901: % and aliphatic ($\simali$2967, 2928, 2872$\cm^{-1}$)
902: % C--H stretching bands are clearly seen.
903: % Taken from Keller et al.\ (2006).
904: % }
905: %\end{figure}
906:
907:
908: %%%%% *** NEW Fig.8 *** %%%%%
909: \vspace{-4.5mm}
910: \begin{figure}
911: \vspace{-4.5mm}
912: \centering
913: %\includegraphics[height=6.2cm]{keller_stardust_3.28um.eps}
914: \includegraphics[width=11.5cm]{Stardust_PAH_bands.cps}
915: \vspace{-0.5mm}
916: \caption{\label{fig:Raman_FTIR} \footnotesize
917: {\bf Left (A)}: Raman spectra of two \Stardust\ particles
918: (top panel) compared with the spectra of organics from
919: extraterrestrial
920: (IDPs and primitive meteorites; middle panel)
921: and terrestrial (bottom panel)
922: carbonaceous materials.
923: All exhibit ``D'' and ``G''
924: (6.2, 7.7$\mum$ C--C stretching) bands
925: characteristic of disordered sp$^2$-bonded {\bf aromatic} carbon.
926: Taken from Sandford et al.\ (2006).
927: {\bf Right (B)}: Continuum-subtracted FTIR absorption spectrum
928: of a \Stardust\ sample. Both {\bf aromatic} ($\simali$3050$\cm^{-1}$)
929: and aliphatic ($\simali$2967, 2928, 2872$\cm^{-1}$)
930: C--H stretching bands are clearly seen.
931: Taken from Keller et al.\ (2006).
932: }
933: \end{figure}
934:
935:
936: \vspace{-7mm}
937: \section{~Discussion\label{sec:discussion}}
938: \vspace{-3mm}
939: %
940: There is a long series of pieces of evidence which show that
941: comets have (at least partially) preserved the pristine
942: materials in the parent interstellar cloud out of which
943: the solar system has formed:
944: (1) the striking similarities in the composition of
945: cometary and interstellar ices;
946: (2) the large deviations of the isotopic ratios
947: for several elements from their terrestrial values
948: (especially the high deuterium abundance);
949: (3) the ortho-to-para ratios of cometary water, NH$_3$,
950: and CH$_4$ in several comets which imply a spin
951: temperature of $\simali$30$\K$ (which may be
952: characteristics of their formation temperature);
953: (4) the presence of volatiles, supervolatiles (e.g. CO),
954: and rare gases (e.g. N$_2$)
955: which may indicate that they were incorporated into
956: cometary nuclei at low temperatures
957: (e.g. 22$\K$ for pure CO ice);\footnote{%
958: However, large-scale extensive radial mixing
959: in the solar nebula must have occurred at
960: the early stage of the formation of the solar system,
961: as indicated by the detection of a large number
962: of crystalline olivine and pyroxene minerals
963: in the \Stardust\ comet samples
964: that, based on their solar isotopic compositions,
965: appear to have formed in the inner regions
966: of the solar nebula (Brownlee et al.\ 2006).
967: Also, the silicate dust in the diffuse ISM is
968: predominantly amorphous (Li \& Draine 2001a).
969: }
970: and probably also (5) the high abundance of cometary HNC
971: (see Crovisier 2006).
972: %
973: The {\it definite} detection of PAHs in comet Wild 2
974: by \Stardust\ provides another piece of evidence for
975: the connection between comets and the ISM and has
976: profound implications for the nature of the PAHs in
977: the ISM and dust disks.
978:
979: Admittedly, the hypothesis of PAHs as the carrier of
980: the ``UIR'' bands widely seen in the ISM (\S\ref{sec:ism})
981: and circumstellar dust disks (\S\ref{sec:disk})
982: is still a hypothesis, although the evidence in
983: support is very strong --
984: so far there is no actual precise identification
985: of a single specific PAH molecule
986: in interstellar space or dust disks,\footnote{%
987: Cernicharo et al.\ (2001) reported the detection
988: of benzene (C$_6$H$_6$), the basic aromatic unit,
989: in the protoplanetary nebula CRL 618.
990: }
991: although the PAH model is quite successful in explaining
992: the {\it general} pattern of band positions, relative intensities,
993: and profiles observed in the ``UIR'' emission spectra,
994: in terms of mixtures of highly vibrationally excited neutral
995: and charged PAHs.
996:
997: Details of the ``UIR'' spectra
998: (precise band positions, bandwidths, and relative band intensities)
999: remain hard to mimic exactly
1000: with the use of available PAH spectra
1001: obtained by experimental measurements or quantum
1002: chemical calculations (e.g. see Fig.\,\ref{fig:pah_disks}f).
1003: %
1004: Therefore, in modeling
1005: the observed PAH emission spectra,
1006: astronomers usually take an empirical approach
1007: by constructing ``astro-PAH''
1008: absorption properties that are consistent
1009: with spectroscopic observations of PAH emission
1010: from dust
1011: in various astrophysical environments
1012: (e.g. see D\'{e}sert et al.\ 1990, Schutte et al.\ 1993,
1013: Li \& Draine 2001, Draine \& Li 2001, 2007).
1014: The resulting ``astro-PAH'' absorption cross sections,
1015: although generally consistent with laboratory data
1016: (see Fig.\,2 of Draine \& Li 2007),
1017: do not represent any specific material,
1018: but approximate the actual absorption properties
1019: of the PAH mixture in astrophysical regions.
1020:
1021: It is not surprising that the astronomical PAH
1022: {\it emission} spectra
1023: do not closely resemble the laboratory spectrum of
1024: any {\it single individual} PAH species
1025: since interstellar or circumstellar PAHs are most likely
1026: a complex mixture of many individual molecules,
1027: radicals, and ions.
1028: As a matter of fact, Allamandola et al.\ (1999) have
1029: demonstrated that the laboratory {\it absorption} spectra
1030: produced by co-adding different PAH spectra were
1031: able to provide a detailed match to the observed
1032: {\it emission} spectra.
1033:
1034: One may still argue that the approach taken by
1035: Allamandola et al.\ (1999) was not perfectly appropriate
1036: because they compared the astronomical {\it emission}
1037: spectra with the co-added laboratory
1038: {\it absorption} spectra,
1039: while the IR emission spectrum of a PAH
1040: molecule does not only depend on its IR absorption spectrum,
1041: but also depends on its absorption at shorter wavelengths,
1042: its heat capacity, and the intensity and spectral shape
1043: of the illuminating radiation field
1044: (e.g. see Draine \& Li 2001).
1045: %
1046: This, together with the detection of individual
1047: {\it specific} PAH molecules in the \Stardust\ samples,
1048: suggests that it would be of great value to study
1049: the excitation, emission, and destruction
1050: of a large number of specific PAH molecules
1051: in the ISM, dust disks, and cometary comae,
1052: as well as the mechanism of releasing PAHs
1053: from the ice mantles of dust in comets
1054: and dust disks to the gas phase
1055: and their lifetime against photodestruction
1056: and photoionization (e.g. see Joblin et al.\ 1997,
1057: Li \& Lunine 2003, Li \& Draine 2007).
1058:
1059:
1060: \vspace{3mm}
1061: {\noindent {\bf Acknowledgements}~~ I thank J. Crovisier,
1062: D.E. Harker, C.M. Lisse, M.J. Mumma, and D.H. Wooden
1063: for helpful discussions. I thank G.C. Clayton,
1064: S.J. Clemett, E. Furlan, V.C. Geers, M. Jura, K.H. Kim,
1065: S.L. Liang, B. Sargent, G.C. Sloan, and T.L. Smith
1066: for their help in preparing for this article.
1067: Partial support by Spitzer Theory Programs and
1068: a HST Theory Program is gratefully acknowledged.}
1069:
1070: \vspace{-4mm}
1071: \begin{thebibliography}{99.}
1072: \vspace{-3mm}
1073: \bibitem{}Acke, B., \& van den Ancker, M.E.\ 2004, A\&A, 426, 151
1074: \bibitem{}Allamandola, L.J., Tielens, A.G.G.M., \& Barker, J.R.\
1075: 1985, ApJ, 290, L25
1076: \bibitem{}Allamandola, L.J., Sandford, S.A., \& Wopenka, B.\
1077: 1987, Science, 237, 56
1078: \bibitem{}Allamandola, L.J., Hudgins, D.M., \& Sandford, S.A.
1079: 1999, ApJ, 511, L115
1080: \bibitem{}Baas, F., Geballe, T.R., \& Walther, D.M.\ 1986,
1081: ApJ, 311, L97
1082: \bibitem{}Beintema, D.A., et al.\ 1996, A\&A, 315, L369
1083: \bibitem{}Beir\~ao, P., et al.\ 2006, ApJ, 643, 1
1084: \bibitem{}Bockel\'{e}e-Morvan, D., Brooke, T.Y., \& Crovisier, J.\
1085: 1995, Icarus, 116, 18
1086: \bibitem{}Brooke, T.Y., Tokunaga, A.T., \& Strom, S.E.\
1087: 1993, AJ, 106, 656
1088: \bibitem{}Brownlee, D.E., et al.\ 2006, Science, 314, 1711
1089: \bibitem{}Campins, H., \& Swindle, T.D.\ 1998,
1090: Meteoritics \& Planet. Sci., 33, 1201
1091: \bibitem{}Cernicharo, J., et al.\ 2001, ApJ, 546, L123
1092: \bibitem{}Clairemidi, J., Br{\'e}chignac, P., Moreels, G.,
1093: \& Pautet, D.\ 2004, Planet. Space Sci., 52, 761
1094: \bibitem{}Clemett, S.J., Maechling, C.R., Zare, R.N., Swan, P.D.,
1095: \& Walker, R.M.\ 1993, Science, 262, 721
1096: \bibitem{}Clemett, S.J., Nakamura-Messenger, K., McKay, D.S.,
1097: \& Sandford, S.A.\ 2007, Lunar \& Planet. Inst. Conf. Abs.,
1098: 38, 2091
1099: \bibitem{}Contursi, A., et al.\ 2000, A\&A, 362, 310
1100: \bibitem{}Coulson, I.M., \& Walther, D.M.\ 1995, MNRAS, 274, 977
1101: \bibitem{}Crovisier, J., 2006, Mol. Phys., 104, 2737
1102: \bibitem{}Crovisier, J., \& Bockel\'{e}e-Morvan, D.\
1103: 2008, Icarus, 195, 938
1104: \bibitem{}Crovisier, J., et al.\ 2000,
1105: in ASP Conf. Ser. 196,
1106: Thermal Emission Spectroscopy and Analysis of Dust,
1107: Disks, and Regoliths, 109
1108: %ed. M. L. Sitko, A. Sprague,
1109: %\& D. K. Lynch (San Francisco: ASP), 109
1110: \bibitem{}Davies, J.K., Green, S.F., \& Geballe, T.R.\
1111: 1991, MNRAS, 251, 148
1112: \bibitem{}Derenne, S., Rouzaud, J.N., Clinard, C.,
1113: \& Robert, F.\ 2005,
1114: Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta, 69, 3911
1115: \bibitem{}D{\'e}sert, F.X., Boulanger, F., \& Puget, J.L.\
1116: 1990, A\&A, 237, 215
1117: \bibitem{}Draine, B.T., \& Li, A.\ 2001, ApJ, 551, 807
1118: \bibitem{}Draine, B.T., \& Li, A.\ 2007, ApJ, 657, 810
1119: \bibitem{}Draine, B.T., et al.\ 2007, ApJ, 663, 866
1120: \bibitem{}Dwek, E.\ 2005, in AIP Conf. Proc. 761:
1121: SEDs of Gas-Rich Galaxies, 103
1122: \bibitem{}Elbaz, D., Le Floc'h, E., Dole, H.,
1123: \& Marcillac, D.\ 2005, A\&A, 434, L1
1124: \bibitem{}Engelbracht, C.W., et al.\ 2005, ApJ, 628, L29
1125: \bibitem{}Engelbracht, C.W., et al.\ 2006, ApJ, 642, L127
1126: \bibitem{}Flynn, G.J.\ 1989, Icarus, 77, 287
1127: \bibitem{}F\"{o}rster Schreiber, N. M., Roussel, H., Sauvage, M.,
1128: \& Charmandaris, V. 2004, A\&A, 419, 501
1129: \bibitem{}Furlan, E., et al.\ 2006, ApJS, 165, 568
1130: \bibitem{}Geers, V. C., et al.\ 2006, A\&A, 459, 545
1131: \bibitem{}Gillett, F.C., Forrest, W.J., Merrill, K.M.\
1132: 1973, ApJ, 183, 87
1133: \bibitem{}Greenberg, J.M. 1982, in Comets, ed. L.L. Wilkening
1134: (Tuscon: Univ. of Arizona Press), 131
1135: \bibitem{}Habart, E., Natta, A., Testi, L., \& Carbillet, M.\
1136: 2006, A\&A, 449, 1067
1137: \bibitem{}Harker, D.E., Woodward, C.E., Wooden, D.H.,
1138: Fisher, R.S., \& Trujillo, C.\ 2007,
1139: Icarus, 190, 432
1140: \bibitem{}Higdon, S.J., Higdon, J.L., \& Marshall, J.\
1141: 2006, ApJ, 640, 768
1142: \bibitem{}Hoban, S., Mumma, M.J., Reuter, D.C., Disanti, M.,
1143: Joyce, R.R., \& Storrs, A.\ 1991, Icarus, 93, 122
1144: \bibitem{}Hudgins, D.M., \& Allamandola, L.J.\ 2005,
1145: in Astrochemistry: Recent Successes
1146: and Current Challenges, 443
1147: \bibitem{}Hunt, L., Bianchi, S., \& Maiolino, R.\
1148: 2005, A\&A, 434, 849
1149: \bibitem{}Irwin, J.A., \& Madden, S.C.\ 2006, A\&A, 445, 123
1150: \bibitem{}Jura, M.,\ 2003, ApJ, 582, 1032
1151: \bibitem{}Jura, M., et al.\ 2006, ApJ, 637, L45
1152: \bibitem{}Joblin, C., Boissel, P., \& de Parseval, P. 1997,
1153: Planet. Space Sci., 45, 1539
1154: \bibitem{}Joswiak, D.J., Brownlee, D.E., Pepin, R.O.,
1155: \& Schlutter, D.J.\ 2007,
1156: in Dust in Planetary Systems (ESA SP-643), 141
1157: \bibitem{}Kaneda, H., Onaka, T., \& Sakon, I.\ 2005, ApJ, 632, L83
1158: \bibitem{}Keller, L.P., et al.\ 2006, Science, 314, 1728
1159: \bibitem{}Keller, L.D., et al.\ 2008, ApJ, 684, 411
1160: \bibitem{}L\'{e}ger, A., \& Puget, J.L.\ 1984, A\&A, 137, L5
1161: \bibitem{}Li, A., \& Draine, B.T.\ 2001a, ApJ, 550, L213
1162: \bibitem{}Li, A., \& Draine, B.T.\ 2001b, ApJ, 554, 778
1163: \bibitem{}Li, A., \& Draine, B.T.\ 2008, in preparation
1164: \bibitem{}Li, A., \& Lunine, J.I.\ 2003, ApJ, 594, 987
1165: \bibitem{}Li, A., et al.\ 2008, in preparation
1166: \bibitem{}Lisse, C.M., et al.\ 2006, Science, 313, 635
1167: \bibitem{}Lisse, C.M., Kraemer, K.E., Nuth, J.A., Li, A.,
1168: \& Joswiak, D.\ 2007, Icarus, 187, 69
1169: \bibitem{}Love, S.G., \& Brownlee, D.E.\ 1994, Meteoritics, 29, 69
1170: \bibitem{}Lutz, D., et al.\ 2005, ApJ, 625, L83
1171: \bibitem{}Lutz, D., et al.\ 2007, ApJ, 661, L25
1172: \bibitem{}Madden, S.C., Galliano, F., Jones, A.P.,
1173: \& Sauvage, M.\ 2006, A\&A, 446, 877
1174: \bibitem{}Mann, I., Murad, E., \& Czechowski, A.\
1175: 2007, Planet. Space Sci., 55, 1000
1176: \bibitem{}Mathis, J.S., Mezger, P.G., \& Panagia, N.\
1177: 1983, A\&A, 128, 212
1178: \bibitem{}Moutou, C., L\'{e}ger, A., D'Hendecourt, L.\
1179: 1996, A\&A, 310, 297
1180: \bibitem{}Mumma, M.J., et al.\ 2001, ApJ, 546, 1183
1181: \bibitem{}Moreels, G., Clairemidi, J., Hermine, P., Brechignac, P.,
1182: \& Rousselott, P.\ 1994, A\&A, 282, 643
1183: \bibitem{}Nier, A.O., \& Schlutter, D.J.\ 1993,
1184: Meteoritics, 28, 675
1185: \bibitem{}O'Halloran, B., Satyapal, S., \& Dudik, R.P.\
1186: 2006, ApJ, 641, 795
1187: \bibitem{}Peeters, E., et al.\ 2002, A\&A, 390, 1089
1188: \bibitem{}Peeters, E., et al.\ 2005, ApJ, 620, 774
1189: \bibitem{}Plante, S., \& Sauvage, M.\ 2002, AJ, 124, 1995
1190: %\bibitem{}Roche, P.F., Aitken, D.K., Smith, C.H., \& Ward, M.J.\
1191: % 1991, MNRAS, 248, 606
1192: \bibitem{}Roche, P.F., Aitken, D., Smith, C., \& Ward, M.
1193: 1991, MNRAS, 248, 606
1194: \bibitem{}Rosenberg, J.L., et al.\ 2006, ApJ, 636, 742
1195: \bibitem{}Sandford, S.A., et al.\ 2006, Science, 314, 1720
1196: \bibitem{}Schutte, W.A., Tielens, A.G.G.M.,
1197: \& Allamandola, L.J.\ 1993, ApJ, 415, 397
1198: \bibitem{}Sellgren, K.\ 2001, Spectrochimica Acta, 57, 627
1199: \bibitem{}Sephton, M.A., et al.\ 2004,
1200: Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta, 68, 1385
1201: \bibitem{}Siebenmorgen, R., Kr{\"u}gel, E., \& Spoon, H.W.W.\
1202: 2004, A\&A, 414, 123
1203: \bibitem{}Sloan, G.C., et al.\ 2005, ApJ, 632, 956
1204: \bibitem{}Sloan, G.C., et al.\ 2007, ApJ, 664, 1144
1205: \bibitem{}Smith, T.L., Clayton, G.C., \& Valencic, L.\
1206: 2004, AJ, 128, 357
1207: \bibitem{}Smith, J.D.T., et al.\ 2004, ApJS, 154, 199
1208: \bibitem{}Smith, J.D.T., et al.\ 2007, ApJ, 656, 770
1209: \bibitem{}Sylvester, R. J., et al.\ 1997, MNRAS, 289, 831
1210: \bibitem{}Thuan, T.X., Sauvage, M., \& Madden, S.\
1211: 1999, ApJ, 516, 783
1212: \bibitem{}Tielens, A. G. G. M. 2005, The Physics and Chemistry
1213: of the Interstellar Medium
1214: (Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press)
1215: \bibitem{}van Boekel, R., et al.\ 2004, A\&A, 418, 177
1216: \bibitem{}van Diedenhoven, B., et al.\ 2004, ApJ, 611, 928
1217: \bibitem{}van Kerckhoven, C., et al.\ 2000, A\&A, 357, 1013
1218: \bibitem{}Verstraete, L., et al.\ 2001, A\&A, 372, 981
1219: \bibitem{}Vijh, U.P., Witt, A.N., \& Gordon, K.D.\
1220: 2005, ApJ, 633, 262
1221: \bibitem{}Voit, G.M.\ 1991, ApJ, 379, 122
1222: \bibitem{}Voit, G.M.\ 1992, MNRAS, 258, 841
1223: \bibitem{}Werner, M.W., et al.\ 2004, ApJS, 154, 309
1224: %\bibitem{}Witt, A.N., Gordon, K.D., Vijh, U.P., Sell, P.H.,
1225: % Smith, T.L., \& Xie, R.-H.\ 2006, ApJ, 636, 303
1226: \bibitem{}Witt, A.N., et al.\ 2006, ApJ, 636, 303
1227: %\bibitem{}Wooden, D.H., Desch, S., Harker, D.E.,
1228: % Gail, H.-P., \& Keller, L.\ 2007,
1229: % Protostars and Planets V, 815
1230: \bibitem{}Wooden, D.H., et al.\ 2007,
1231: in Protostars and Planets V, 815
1232: \bibitem{}Wu, Y., et al.\ 2006, ApJ, 639, 157
1233: \bibitem{}Yan, L., et al.\ 2005, ApJ, 628, 604
1234: \bibitem{}Yan, L., et al.\ 2007, ApJ, 658, 778
1235: \end{thebibliography}
1236:
1237: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% }
1238:
1239: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
1240:
1241: \printindex
1242: \end{document}
1243:
1244:
1245:
1246:
1247:
1248: