1: %%
2: %% Beginning of file 'ms.tex'
3: %%
4:
5: %\documentclass[12pt,preprint]{aastex}
6:
7: \documentclass{emulateapj}
8: \usepackage{lscape}
9: \usepackage{rotate}
10: \usepackage{longtable}
11: \usepackage{natbib}
12: \citestyle{aa}
13:
14: \shorttitle{X-ray Selected AGN Hosts in the Cl1604 Supercluster}
15: \shortauthors{Kocevski et al.}
16:
17:
18: \begin{document}
19:
20: \title{Properties of Galaxies Hosting X-ray Selected Active Galactic Nuclei in the Cl1604 Supercluster at $z=0.9$}
21: \author{Dale D. Kocevski, Lori M. Lubin, Brian C. Lemaux, Roy Gal\altaffilmark{1}, Christopher D. Fassnacht, Robin Lin\altaffilmark{2}, Gordon K. Squires\altaffilmark{3}}
22:
23: \affil{Department of Physics, University of California, Davis, 1 Shields Avenue, Davis, CA 95616}
24: \altaffiltext{1}{Institute for Astronomy, University of Hawaii, 2680 Woodlawn Dr., Honolulu, HI 96822}
25: \altaffiltext{2}{Siemens Medical Solutions USA, Inc., 1230 Shorebird Way, MS 6-1, Mountain View CA 94043-1344}
26: \altaffiltext{3}{\emph{Spitzer} Science Center, M/S 220-6, California
27: Institute of Technology, 1200 East California Blvd, Pasadena, CA 91125}
28: \email{kocevski@physics.ucdavis.edu}
29:
30:
31: \begin{abstract}
32: Recent galaxy evolution models suggest that feedback from Active Galactic
33: Nuclei (AGN) may be responsible for suppressing star formation in their host
34: galaxies and the subsequent migration of these systems onto the red sequence.
35: To investigate the role of AGN in driving the evolution of their hosts, we
36: have carried out a study of the environments and optical properties of
37: galaxies harboring X-ray luminous AGN in the Cl1604 supercluster at
38: $z\sim0.9$. Making use of \emph{Chandra}, \emph{HST}/ACS and
39: \emph{Keck}/DEIMOS observations, we examine the integrated colors,
40: morphologies and spectral properties of nine moderate-luminosity ($L_{\rm X}
41: \sim 10^{43}$ erg s$^{-1}$) type 2 Seyferts detected in the Cl1604 complex.
42: We find that the AGN are predominantly hosted by luminous spheroids and/or
43: bulge dominated galaxies which have colors that place them in the
44: valley between the blue cloud and red sequence in color-magnitude space,
45: consistent with predictions that AGN hosts should constitute a transition
46: population. Half of the hosts have bluer overall colors as a result of blue
47: resolved cores in otherwise red spheroids and a majority show signs of recent
48: or pending interactions. We also find a substantial number exhibit strong
49: Balmer absorption features indicative of post-starburst galaxies, despite the
50: fact that we detect narrow [OII] emission lines in all of the host spectra.
51: If the [OII] lines are due in part to AGN emission, as we suspect, then this
52: result implies that a significant fraction of these galaxies (44\%) have
53: experienced an enhanced level of star formation within the last $\sim1$ Gyr which was
54: rapidly suppressed. Furthermore we observe that the hosts galaxies tend
55: to avoid the densest regions of the supercluster and are instead located in
56: intermediate density environments, such as the infall region of a massive
57: cluster or in poorer systems undergoing assembly. Overall we find that the
58: properties of the nine host galaxies are generally consistent with a scenario
59: in which recent interactions have triggered both increased levels of nuclear
60: activity and an enhancement of centrally concentrated star formation,
61: followed by a rapid truncation of the latter, possibly as a result of
62: feedback from the AGN itself. Our finding that the hosts of
63: moderate-luminosity AGN within the Cl1604 supercluster are predominantly a
64: transition population suggests AGN feedback may play an important role in
65: accelerating galaxy evolution in large-scale structures.
66: \end{abstract}
67:
68: \keywords{galaxies: clusters: general --- large-scale structure --- X-rays: galaxies: clusters}
69:
70:
71:
72:
73: \section{Introduction}
74:
75: Several studies have demonstrated that galaxies segregate by rest-frame color,
76: with passively evolving early-type galaxies forming a well defined ``red
77: sequence'' and gas-rich, star forming systems located in a more diffuse
78: ``blue cloud'' (e.g.~Baldry et al.~2004). This observed color bimodality is commonly thought to be
79: the result of an evolutionary sequence, such that galaxies in the blue cloud
80: quickly migrate onto the red sequence following the termination of star
81: formation, leading to a sparsely populated transition zone between the two
82: regions (Faber et al.~2007; although see Driver et al.~2006 for an alternative view).
83: While simple passive evolution likely contributes to the migration of
84: galaxies from blue to red, recent findings that galaxies exhibit reduced star
85: formation rates as they assemble into regions of even moderate density (Lewis
86: et al.~2002; Gomez et al.~2003) suggest that processes prevalent in richer
87: environments must also play a role in terminating star formation and driving
88: galaxy evolution. Recently merger-driven feedback from Active Galactic
89: Nuclei (AGN) has been suggested as one such process (Hopkins et al.~2005,
90: 2007; Somerville et al.~2008).
91:
92: In this scenario strong gravitational torques produced as a result of galaxy
93: mergers funnel material to the nuclear region of a system, leading to
94: elevated accretion onto the central black hole and enhanced star formation in
95: the form of a nuclear starburst (Barnes \& Hernquist 1991; Mihos \& Hernquist
96: 1996). If sufficiently energetic, the AGN eventually drives outflows that
97: disrupt the host, effectively quenching ongoing star formation by removing
98: the galaxy's gas supply (Springel et al.~2005; Hopkins et al.~2005). As the last generation
99: of newly formed stars fade, the galaxy quickly migrates from the blue cloud
100: to the red sequence, with the activity of the central black hole gradually
101: declining over the same period.
102:
103: This feedback mechanism provides a method by which the overall properties
104: of a galaxy can be regulated by its central black hole. Indeed there is a
105: growing body of evidence that suggests AGN are directly linked to the
106: evolution of their host galaxies. This includes the observed correlation
107: between central black hole mass and the stellar velocity dispersion of a host
108: galaxy's bulge (Gebhardt et al.~2000; Tremaine et al.~2002) and the coeval
109: decline in both the cosmic star formation rate and nuclear activity since
110: $z\sim1$ (Boyle \& Terlevich 1998).
111:
112: If AGN are directly responsible for driving the evolution of their hosts,
113: then signs of recent or ongoing transformation should be present in these
114: galaxies. This includes disturbed morphologies due to recent interactions,
115: post-starburst signatures resulting from rapidly quenched star formation
116: following a merger-induced enhancement, and colors consistent with the
117: sparsely populated transition zone in the color-magnitude diagram.
118: While many of these features are observed in the hosts of luminous quasars (QSO),
119: studies of moderate-luminosity Seyferts ($L_{\rm X}\sim10^{43}$ erg s$^{-1}$) in this regard have produced mixed
120: results. For example, while such AGN are predominantly found in massive,
121: early-type galaxies which have younger stellar populations than their
122: non-active counterparts (e.g. Kauffmann et al.~2003), only a
123: small fraction show signs of recent merger activity (De Robertis et al.~1998;
124: Grogin et al.~2005; Pierce et al.~2007). Likewise, although AGN are found in post-starburst galaxies
125: more often than in normal galaxies (Heckman 2004, Yan et al.~2006, Goto et
126: al.~2006), the fraction of Seyferts associated with post-starburst hosts at low redshift remains fairly
127: small; on the order of $4\%$ according to a recent study by Goto et al.~(2006).
128:
129: A clearer picture of the prevalence of AGN feedback as an evolutionary
130: driver may be obtained by studying host galaxies in and around large-scale
131: structures at high redshift. In addition to a considerably higher AGN density and galaxy
132: merger rate at $z\sim1$ relative to the present epoch (Barger et al.~2005;
133: Kartaltepe et al.~2007), there are indications that AGN are triggered more often
134: in structures than in the field (Gilli et al~2003; Cappelluti et al~2005; Eastman et al.~2007;
135: Kocevski et al.~2008), presumably due to the presence of richer, dynamic
136: environments where galaxy interactions are more common (Cavaliere et al.~1992).
137: Several recent wide-field surveys have found that the colors of higher-redshift
138: host galaxies are consistent with a population in transition (Sanchez et
139: al.~2004; Nandra et al.~2007; Georgakakis et al.~2008; Silverman et al.~2008;
140: although see also Westoby et al.~2007) and there are
141: indications the fraction of AGN hosts exhibiting post-starburst signatures
142: is higher at $z\sim0.8$ (Georgakakis et al.~2008). Furthermore, Silverman et
143: al.~(2008) found that a majority of host galaxies associated with two
144: large-scale structures in the Extended \emph{Chandra} Deep Field South
145: (E-CDF-S) at $z\sim0.7$ have colors consistent with the transition zone of the
146: color-magnitude diagram. Coupled with the increased incidence of AGN in such
147: regions, this finding implies that AGN related feedback may play an important
148: role in accelerating galaxy evolution in large-scale structures.
149:
150: In this study we examine the environments and optical properties of galaxies
151: hosting X-ray selected, moderate-luminosity AGN in the Cl1604 supercluster
152: at $z=0.9$. The system is the largest structure mapped at redshifts
153: approaching unity, consisting of eight spectroscopically confirmed galaxy
154: clusters and groups and a rich network of filamentary structures. The system
155: spans roughly 10 $h_{70}^{-1}$ Mpc on the sky and 100 $h_{70}^{-1}$ Mpc in depth.
156: The complex structure of the supercluster, as mapped by extensive
157: spectroscopic observations, is described in Gal et al.~(2008; hereafter G08) and our X-ray
158: observations of the system are discussed in Kocevski et al.~(2008; hereafter K08). The
159: Cl1604 supercluster is well suited for this study as it provides
160: a diverse set of structures within which AGN may be preferentially
161: found and a wide range of environments and local conditions that can help
162: constrain the mechanisms responsible for triggering their activity.
163:
164: In the following sections we begin by describing our X-ray and optical observations of
165: the Cl1604 system (\S2) and the process by which we identify AGN in the
166: supercluster (\S3). This is followed by an examination of the morphology
167: (\S4.1), optical colors (\S4.2), spectral properties (\S4.3), and
168: environments (\S4.4) of the galaxies found to host AGN. We also determine
169: the fraction supercluster members which harbor AGN and compare this to
170: low-redshift results in \S5. We discuss our results and
171: their implications for the AGN feedback model in driving galaxy evolution in
172: the Cl1604 system in \S6. Finally we summarize our results in \S7. Throughout
173: this paper all quoted line equivalent widths are in the rest frame,
174: magnitudes are in the AB system and we assume a $\Lambda$CDM cosmology with
175: $\Omega_{m} = 0.3$, $\Omega_{\Lambda} = 0.7$, and $H_{0} = 70$ $h_{70}$ km s$^{-1}$ Mpc$^{-1}$.
176:
177:
178: \section{Observations and Data Reduction}
179: \label{sect-data}
180:
181: \subsection{X-ray Observations}
182:
183: Observations of the Cl1604 supercluster were carried out with {\it
184: Chandra's} Advanced CCD Imaging Spectrometer (ACIS; Garmire et al.~2003)
185: on 2006 June 23 (obsID 7343), June 25 (obsID 6933), and October 01 (obsID
186: 6932). A detailed description of the observations and subsequent data reduction are
187: given in K08, therefore we only provide a brief summary
188: here. The three observations of the supercluster consist of two
189: pointings, one encompassing the northern portion of the system and the
190: other the southern portion, with a $4\farcm9$ overlap between the imaged
191: regions. Each pointing was imaged with the $16\farcm9\times16\farcm9$
192: ACIS-I array for total integration times of 19.4, 26.7, and 49.5 ksec for the
193: 7343, 6933, and 6932 datasets, respectively. All three datasets were
194: reprocessed and analyzed using standard CIAO 3.3 software tools and version
195: 3.2.2 of the {\it Chandra} calibration database available through {\it
196: Chandra} X-ray Center (CXC)\footnote{http://cxc.harvard.edu/}.
197:
198: We searched for point sources using the wavelet-based {\tt wavdetect}
199: procedure in CIAO, employing the standard $\sqrt2$$^i$ series of wavelet
200: pixel scales, with $i=0-16$. Object detection was carried out separately on
201: images in each of the 0.5-2 keV (soft), 2-8 keV (hard) and 0.5-8 keV (full)
202: X-ray bands and the source catalogs cross-correlated, resulting in 265 unique sources detected in the two pointings of
203: the Cl1604 system. Source properties, including count
204: rates and detection significances, were determined with follow-up aperture
205: photometry on all sources found by {\tt wavdetect}. The photometry was
206: carried out on the vignetting-corrected, soft- and hard-band images of both
207: pointings and an appropriate aperture correction (as determined from the PSF
208: libraries in the {\it Chandra} calibration database) was applied to the
209: background-subtracted net counts of each source. Counts in the full band
210: were then determined as a sum of the measured net counts in the soft and hard
211: bands. Of the 265 sources found by {\tt wavdetect}, 161 had detection
212: significances greater than $3\sigma$ in at least one X-ray band.
213:
214: Source fluxes in the soft and hard bands were determined by normalizing a
215: power-law spectral model to the net count rate measured for each source.
216: These rates were determined by dividing the net counts measured in the
217: vignetting-corrected images by the nominal exposure time at the aimpoint of
218: each observation. We assumed a photon index of $\gamma = 1.4$ for the
219: power-law model and a Galactic neutral hydrogen column density of
220: $1.21\times10^{20}$ cm$^{-2}$ (Dickey \& Lockman 1990), resulting in a count
221: rate to unabsorbed-flux conversion factor of $5.85\times10^{-12}$ and
222: $2.08\times10^{-11}$ erg cm$^{-2}$ s$^{-1}$ per cnts s$^{-1}$ in the
223: soft and hard bands, respectively. Full-band fluxes were again determined by
224: summing the flux in the soft and hard bands. Rest frame X-ray luminosities
225: were calculated for sources matched to galaxies with measured redshifts (see
226: \S\ref{sect-opt-matching}) using the standard luminosity distance equation
227: and a $(1+z)^{\gamma - 2}$ $k$-correction. Properties for the 161 unique
228: point sources detected with at least a $3\sigma$ significance in the field of
229: Cl1604 are listed in Table 3 of K08.
230:
231:
232:
233: \subsection{Optical Imaging}
234:
235: The optical imaging of the supercluster used for this study consists of 17
236: pointings of the Advanced Camera for Surveys (ACS) on the \emph{Hubble Space
237: Telescope (HST)}. The ACS camera consists of two $2048\times4096$ CCDs
238: with a pixel scale of 0.05 $^{\prime\prime}$/pixel, resulting in a
239: $\sim3^{\prime}\times3^{\prime}$ FOV. The 17 pointing mosaic was designed to
240: image nine of the ten galaxy density peaks observed in the field of the
241: supercluster by Gal et al.~(2005, 2008). Observations were taken in both the
242: F606W and F814W bands and consist of 15 pointings from GO-11003 (PI Lubin)
243: with effective exposure times of 1998 sec\footnote{With the exception of one
244: pointing which lost guiding due to an incorrect attitude, resulting in a
245: useable exposure time of 1505 sec and a gap in the mosaic.}
246: and 2 GTO pointings from G0-9919 (PI Ford) centered on clusters Cl1604+4304
247: and Cl1604+4321 with effective exposure time of 4840 sec. Our average
248: integration time of 1998 sec resulted in completeness depths of $\sim26.5$
249: mag in each band.
250:
251: \begin{figure}[t]
252: \epsscale{1.1}
253: \plotone{./f1.astroph.eps}
254: \caption{Positions and FOVs of the two ACIS-I and 17 ACS pointings
255: in the Cl1604 region. The positions of the ten red-galaxy overdensities found by Gal et
256: al. (2005, 2008) are marked and labeled following the naming convention of
257: Gal et al.~(2005) \label{fig-data_outline}}
258: \end{figure}
259:
260:
261: The ACS data were reduced using the pipeline developed by
262: the HST Archive Galaxy Gravitational Lens Survey (HAGGLES) team. The
263: pipeline processing consists of calibrating the raw data using the best
264: reference files provided by the Hubble Space Telescope archive, subtracting
265: the background on each chip, iteratively determining the best shifts between
266: the dithered exposures using multiple calls to {\tt SExtractor} (Bertin \&
267: Arnouts 1996) and {\tt multidrizzle} (Koekemoer et al.~2002), aligning the
268: final drizzled image to the USNO-B1 catalog (Monet et al.~2002) and
269: resampling the images to a pixel scale of 0.03$^{\prime\prime}$/pixel.
270: Object detection and photometry was carried out using {\tt SExtractor} in dual-image mode,
271: with the detection image being a weighted average of the F606W and F814W
272: images. Detection parameters DETECT\_MINAREA and DETECT\_THRESH were set to
273: three pixels above $3\sigma$, while the deblending parameters DEBLEND\_NTHRESH
274: and DEBLEND\_MINCONT were set to 32 and 0.03, respectively.
275: An outline of the region covered by the ACS mosaic relative to the ACIS-I observations is
276: shown in Figure \ref{fig-data_outline}. Full details of the HAGGLES pipeline
277: can be found in Marshall et al.~(2008) and Schrabback et al.~(2008).
278:
279:
280: \subsection{Optical Spectroscopy}
281: \label{opt-spect}
282: The Cl1604 supercluster has been extensively mapped using the
283: Low-Resolution Imaging Spectrograph (LRIS; Oke et al. 1995) and the
284: Deep Imaging Multi-object Spectrograph (DEIMOS; Faber et al.~2003) on
285: the \emph{Keck} 10-m telescopes (Oke, Postman, \& Lubin 1998; Postman, Lubin, \& Oke
286: 1998; Lubin et al.~1998; Gal \& Lubin 2004; G08). The
287: complex target selection, spectral reduction, and redshift measurements
288: are described in detail in Section 3 of G08. The final
289: spectroscopic catalog contains 1,618 unique objects. Redshifts derived for
290: these objects are given a spectroscopic quality, $Q_{spect}$, between 1 and
291: 4, where 1 indicates that a secure redshift could not be determined due to poor
292: signal, lack of features or reduction artifacts, 2 is a redshift obtained from either a single
293: feature or two marginally detected features, 3 is a redshift derived from at
294: least one secure and one marginal feature, and 4 is assigned to spectra with
295: redshifts obtained from several high signal-to-noise features.
296: $Q_{spect} = -1$ is used for sources securely identified as stars.
297:
298: In this sample, we find 140 stars and 1,138 extragalactic objects with $Q_{spect} \ge 3$.
299: A total of 417 galaxies are in the nominal redshift range of
300: the supercluster between $0.84 \le z \le 0.96$. This extensive
301: spectroscopic database is larger by a factor of $\sim 10$ than that
302: for any other known moderate-to-high redshift supercluster.
303:
304:
305:
306: \section{Identifying Supercluster AGN}
307: \label{sect-opt-matching}
308:
309: To find optical counterparts to the 161 X-ray point sources detected
310: in the field of the Cl1604 supercluster we employed a maximum likelihood
311: technique described by Sutherland \& Saunders (1992) and more recently
312: implemented by Taylor (2005) and Gilmour et al.~(2007). The method gauges
313: the likelihood that a given optical object is matched to an X-ray source by
314: comparing the probability of finding a genuine counterpart with the
315: positional offset and magnitude of the optical candidate relative to that of
316: finding a similar object by chance. The advantages of this approach over a
317: simple nearest neighbor match is that it takes into account the density of
318: objects as faint as the optical counterpart as well as the distance between
319: sources and the X-ray positional errors. The details of the process are
320: described in K08 and therefore we focus instead on the
321: results of the matching here.
322:
323: Using the maximum likelihood technique we have matched 125 optical sources to
324: our X-ray catalog. Of these 42 have spectroscopic information available and
325: we have derived reliable redshifts ($Q_{spect} \ge 3$)
326: for 35 of the sources. We find that while the matched sources cover a wide
327: range of redshifts ($0.055 \le z \le 2.30$), the distribution exhibits a
328: clear peak at $z=0.9$, the average redshift of the Cl1604 supercluster (see
329: Figure 6 of K08). A total of nine sources have redshifts
330: between $0.84<z<0.96$ and fall within the redshift boundaries of
331: the supercluster. Eight of these nine
332: galaxies were imaged by our ACS survey of the supercluster and therefore have
333: high-resolution imaging available for morphological and resolved color
334: analyses. The coordinates and redshifts of the nine supercluster AGN are
335: listed in Table \ref{tab-prop} and their location in the supercluster are
336: shown in Figure \ref{fig-agn-spatial-dist}.
337:
338: Also listed in Table \ref{tab-prop} are the X-ray properties of the nine AGN,
339: including their rest-frame 0.5-8 keV luminosities and hardness ratios, $HR$,
340: measured as $HR = \frac{H-S}{H+S}$ where $H$ and $S$ are the net counts in the
341: hard and soft bands, respectively. The AGN have luminosities ranging from
342: 0.78 to 4.47 $\times10^{43}$ $h_{70}^{-2}$ erg s$^{-1}$ and have predominantly soft
343: X-ray spectra; the nine sources have a median $HR$ of $-0.20$. It should be
344: noted that the luminosity of all nine AGN exceed the luminosity attributable
345: to starburst galaxies by over an order of magnitude ($L_{\rm X} \sim
346: 10^{42}$ erg s$^{-1}$; e.g. Bauer et al.~2002), making it highly
347: unlikely that their X-ray emission is powered exclusively by star formation
348: activity. On the other hand, their luminosities fall below the level of
349: bright QSOs ($L_{\rm X} \sim 10^{44}$ erg s$^{-1}$),
350: which often dominate the optical emission from their host galaxies.
351: Silverman et al.~(2005) have shown that the optical emission associated with
352: AGN with luminosities below $5\times10^{43}$ $h_{70}^{-2}$ erg s$^{-1}$ (0.5-8 keV) is
353: primarily due to light from the host galaxy. Since the luminosity of all our AGN fall
354: below this limit, we proceed under the assumption that the optical properties of
355: the nine supercluster host galaxies suffer minimal contamination from their active nuclei.
356:
357: \begin{figure}[t]
358: \epsscale{1.05}
359: \plotone{./f2.astroph.eps}
360: \caption{Spatial distribution of the 9 X-ray sources that fall within the
361: traditional redshift boundaries of the Cl1604 supercluster ($0.84<z<0.96$).
362: Individual clusters and groups in the Cl1604 system are labeled using the
363: naming convention of Gal et al.~(2005). The dashed circles extend 0.5
364: $h_{70}^{-1}$ Mpc from the center of each cluster. \label{fig-agn-spatial-dist}}
365: \end{figure}
366:
367: \section{AGN Host Properties}
368:
369: \subsection{Morphologies}
370:
371: \begin{figure}[t]
372: \epsscale{1.2}
373: \plotone{./f3.astroph.eps}
374: \caption{(\emph{left}) Thumbnail images of the eight supercluster AGN imaged
375: with \emph{HST}/ACS in the F814W band as well as one source imaged with
376: \emph{Palomar}/LFC in the $i^{\prime}$ band. Each image spans roughly
377: $10^{\prime\prime}$ on a side and is shown with a log scaling.
378: (\emph{right}) Optical spectra of all nine supercluster AGN obtained
379: with \emph{Keck}/DEIMOS. The flux scale is presented in
380: self consistent, arbitrary units. The spectra have typically been
381: binned by 10 pixels for clarity, where one pixel equals 0.33
382: \AA. \label{fig-thumbs+spect1}}
383: \end{figure}
384:
385: To gain insight into the possible triggering mechanisms of the X-ray-detected
386: AGN found in the Cl1604 supercluster we examined the morphologies of the host
387: galaxies within which they reside using both visual and automated techniques.
388: We limited this analysis to the 8 AGN which are covered by our high-resolution ACS imaging. Thumbnail
389: images in the F814W band of each supercluster AGN are show in Figures
390: \ref{fig-thumbs+spect1} and \ref{fig-thumbs+spect2}.
391:
392: Classification of the host morphologies was carried out via visual inspection
393: by one of the authors (L.M.L.). The resulting classifications are listed in
394: Table \ref{tab-prop}. Also noted are the interpretations of any observed
395: disturbances using the classification scheme of Smail et al.~(1997). We find
396: that a large majority (7/8) of the host galaxies are spheroidal systems. Five
397: of the supercluster AGN reside in early-type galaxies (E/S0), two hosts are
398: bulge dominated systems with faint spiral arms (Sa) and only a single host
399: is a clear disk dominated, late-type galaxy (Sb).
400:
401: These visual classifications were confirmed by the calculation of the Gini
402: coefficient, $G$, which is a measure of the symmetry in a galaxy's flux
403: distribution (Abraham et al.~2003) and the $M_{20}$ parameter, which is the
404: second-order moment of the brightest 20\% of a galaxy's flux and a measure of
405: central concentration (Lotz et al.~2004). We measured the parameters using
406: software written by one of the authors (R.L.) and described in Lin (2007).
407: We find that although our absolute scaling of both $G$ and $M_{20}$ differ
408: from that of other software used in the literature (due to a different
409: implementation and measurement aperture, see Lisker 2008), general trends remain,
410: with spheroids at lower $M_{20}$ values than disk dominated systems and both
411: being well separated from merger systems which have higher $G$ values for a given $M_{20}$ range.
412:
413: \begin{figure}[t]
414: \epsscale{1.2}
415: \plotone{./f4.astroph.eps}
416: \caption{(\emph{left}) Thumbnail images of the eight supercluster AGN imaged
417: with \emph{HST}/ACS in the F814W band as well as one source imaged with
418: \emph{Palomar}/LFC in the $i^{\prime}$ band. Each image spans roughly
419: $10^{\prime\prime}$ on a side and is shown with a log scaling.
420: (\emph{right}) Optical spectra of all nine supercluster AGN obtained
421: with \emph{Keck}/DEIMOS. The flux scale is presented in
422: self consistent, arbitrary units. The spectra have typically been
423: binned by 10 pixels for clarity, where one pixel equals 0.33 \AA.
424: \label{fig-thumbs+spect2}}
425: \end{figure}
426:
427: The location of the 8 host galaxies in the $G-M_{20}$
428: parameter space is shown in Figure \ref{fig-gini}. We again find that the supercluster
429: AGN largely favor early-type hosts. We find that 5 of 8
430: host galaxies have parameters consistent with spheroidal and bulge dominated
431: systems (E/S0/Sa), one source (\#4) lies in the intermediate region occupied by
432: Sb/bc galaxies, consistent with its visual classification as a spiral galaxy,
433: and two sources fall within the merger regime. The two merger
434: galaxies are sources 5 and 6, which have bright nearby companions. While it
435: remains uncertain whether the companion to source 6 is simply seen in
436: projection, spectroscopy has confirmed that source 5 and its spiral companion
437: are indeed a kinematic pair.
438:
439: Although only two galaxies fall within the merger regime of the $G-M_{20}$
440: plane, we find indications of merger activity and/or recent interactions in many of
441: the hosts. This is most evident in source 2, which appears to be a merger
442: remnant with a very compact core and faint tidal features. We suspect the flux contribution from the
443: tidal features was insufficent to alter the galaxy's symmetry and
444: concentration enough to move it into the merger regime of the $G-M_{20}$ parameter space.
445: Nonetheless, the multiple faint (and blue) tidal
446: features surrounding the source suggests the system underwent a disruptive
447: merger event in the recent past. Faint tidal features are also seen around
448: source 6 which has a nearby point-like companion. Furthermore, we find that
449: source 0, which falls outside of our ACS mosaic, also shows evidence of a
450: nearby companion in our ground-based imaging. An image of this galaxy taken
451: with the Large Format Camera (LFC) on \emph{Palomar} in the Sloan Digital Sky
452: Survey $i^{\prime}$ filter is shown in Figure \ref{fig-thumbs+spect1};
453: details of our ground-based imaging and its reduction are described in Gal et al.~(2005).
454:
455: Other merger indications include double and/or elongated cores. Source 3
456: has a partially resolved double core separated by $0.13^{\prime\prime}$ in
457: projection or $\sim1.0$ $h_{70}^{-1}$ kpc at $z=0.937$. This separation is similar to the
458: $z=0.709$ dual-AGN reported by Gerke et al.~(2007) which has a separation of roughly
459: 1.2 $h_{70}^{-1}$ kpc, although here we do not resolve spectral features from
460: multiple active nuclei. Despite the presence of multiple cores, the outer
461: portions of the galaxy appear fairly relaxed with no signs of tidal features
462: or significant disruptions. A two-dimension surface brightness fit using the GALFIT software (Peng et
463: al. 2002) found the galaxy's outer profile to be well fit by a Sersic index
464: (Sersic 1968) of $n=3.1$, close to a standard de Vaucouleurs profile (de
465: Vaucouleurs 1948). This suggests that if the galaxy is the result of a major
466: merger, sufficient time has elapsed since the event to render the galaxy
467: largely relaxed. Source 4 also shows signs of an elongated core, although here we do not
468: resolve multiple components.
469:
470: \begin{figure}[t]
471: \epsscale{1.05}
472: \plotone{./f5.astroph.eps}
473: \caption{Gini and $M_{20}$ parameters for the eight supercluster AGN imaged
474: with \emph{HST/ACS} along with a subsample of normal galaxies in the same
475: field. We find the AGN hosts are predominantly early-type or bulge
476: dominated galaxies. \label{fig-gini}}
477: \end{figure}
478:
479: In summary, our visual morphological classifications and those indicated by
480: the $G$ and $M_{20}$ parameters suggest that the AGN in Cl1604 supercluster
481: largely favor early-type and bulge dominated host galaxies. We also find a
482: majority (6/9) show signs of recent or pending interactions, with one AGN in
483: a clear merger remnant, three with nearby companions and an additional two with
484: disrupted cores, despite the fact that only two of these are identified
485: bona fide mergers by their $G$ and $M_{20}$ parameters alone. Our results are in good
486: agreement with the well established finding that AGN are predominantly hosted
487: by early-type galaxies (e.g.~Kauffman et al.~2003), although we do observe a
488: larger fraction of disturbed morphologies than was reported by Grogin et
489: al.~(2005) and Pierce et al.~(2007), who found little evidence for recent
490: mergers in the hosts high-redshift AGN. We discuss this disparity in greater depth in \S\ref{sect-discuss}.
491:
492:
493: \subsection{Colors}
494:
495: The optical colors and magnitudes of the 371 supercluster members observed with
496: ACS in the F606W and F814W bands are show in Figure \ref{fig-cmd}. The color
497: bimodality of the galaxies is clearly apparent, with members largely
498: separated into the supercluster red sequence and a more diffuse blue cloud. The presence of
499: such a large number of supercluster members in the blue cloud is a classic
500: example of the Butcher-Oemler effect (Butcher \& Oemler 1984), where
501: higher redshift clusters are observed to have an increased fraction of blue,
502: star forming galaxies relative to the passive cluster populations observed at low redshift.
503:
504: Also highlighted in Figure \ref{fig-cmd} are the colors of the eight AGN hosts
505: imaged with ACS. We find that with the exception of source 4, all of the host
506: galaxies are bluer than the red sequence. That said, only two sources are
507: clearly in the blue cloud. Depending on where one defines the boundary of the
508: blue cloud, we find that 4-5 of 8 hosts have intermediate colors between the
509: red and blue populations and are located in the transition zone of the
510: color-magnitude diagram. Regarding the reddest host, source 4, the galaxy is redder than the
511: supercluster red-sequence and has the hardest X-ray emission of the 9 AGN,
512: with $HR = 0.52$. This is indicative of heavy obscuration, suggesting the galaxy's
513: color is most likely due to heavy extinction rather than a passive stellar
514: population. The high fraction of hosts we find in the transition zone
515: of the color-magnitude diagram is in excellent agreement with the results of
516: Silverman et al.~(2008), who recently reported an increased fraction of hosts with
517: intermediate colors in a narrow redshift window containing two large-scale
518: structures in the E-CDF-S.
519:
520: Also apparent in Figure \ref{fig-cmd} is that 6 of 8 AGN ($\sim75\%$) are
521: located in luminous hosts with $m_{814} < 23$. This translates to a rest
522: frame $M_{V} = -21.1$ at $z=0.9$ using a $k$-correction appropriate for an Sb
523: galaxy spectrum. The preference for AGN to be located in optically luminous
524: host galaxies has been previously reported in low-redshift superclusters
525: (Gilmour et al.~2007) and in the field over a wide range of redshifts (Barger
526: et al.~2003; Nandra et al.~2007; Silverman et al.~2008). Silverman et
527: al.~(2008) found that $80\%$ of the moderate-luminosity AGN in their sample
528: reside in galaxies with $M_{V} < -20.7$, in excellent agreement with our
529: results, despite our small number statistics.
530:
531: \begin{figure}[t]
532: \epsscale{1.1}
533: \plotone{./f6.astroph.eps}
534: \caption{Optical color (F606W-F814W) as a function of apparent magnitude in
535: the F814W band for the eight supercluster AGN imaged with
536: \emph{HST/ACS}. Also shown are the colors of 363 normal supercluster members.\label{fig-cmd}}
537: \end{figure}
538:
539: Our high-resolution, dual-band ACS observations also allow us to resolve color
540: gradients in the AGN host galaxies in order to investigate any recent star
541: formation activity. These gradients are shown in Figures \ref{fig-color-grad1} and
542: \ref{fig-color-grad2}, along with color thumbnails of each host constructed
543: from observations in the F814W and F606W bands. We find that four sources
544: exhibit blue cores similar to those reported by Menanteau et al.~(2001a) and
545: Treu et al.~(2005). These include source 1, the double-cored source 3,
546: source 6 which has a nearby companion and the fairly undisturbed source 8.
547:
548: These blue cores may be due to contamination by scattered AGN emission, although we
549: find this unlikely as i.) the X-ray luminosity of our sources does not reach
550: the QSO level $(L_{\rm X} \sim 10^{44}$ erg s$^{-1})$ and ii.) the spectra of these four sources show
551: no signs of a rising blue continuum (see \S\ref{sect-spect}) indicative of QSO contamination.
552: The blue cores are more likely the result of nuclear and/or circumnuclear star formation
553: predicted from merger simulations (Mihos \& Hernquist 1996) and observed in low redshift AGN (e.g.~Gu
554: et al.~2001). In fact Menanteau et al.~(2001b) find that a merger induced episode of star
555: formation responsible for producing as little as $20\%$ of the total stellar mass of the system can
556: lead to blue cores in otherwise red spheroids similar to the galaxies
557: found by Menanteau et al.~(2001a) and Treu et al.~(2005). The formation
558: mechanism proposed by Menanteau et al.~(2001b) is consistent with our
559: observations as three of the sources have fairly red (F606W-F814W $\sim
560: 1.7-1.8$) colors outside their centers. We discuss the implications of
561: this observation further in \S\ref{sect-discuss}.
562:
563: \begin{figure}[t]
564: \epsscale{1.15}
565: \plotone{./f7.astroph.eps}
566: \caption{(\emph{left}) Color thumbnail images of the eight supercluster AGN
567: imaged with \emph{HST/ACS}. The color components are F606W and F814W for blue and red, respectively, while
568: green is represented by a weighted average of the two. (\emph{right}) Spatially resolved color profiles
569: (F606W-F814W) of each AGN host. The profiles are centered on the
570: galaxy nucleus and represents the median galaxy color in annuli one
571: pixel wide. \label{fig-color-grad1}}
572: \end{figure}
573:
574: \subsection{Spectral Properties}
575: \label{sect-spect}
576:
577: \begin{figure}[t]
578: \epsscale{1.15}
579: \plotone{./f8.astroph.eps}
580: \caption{(\emph{left}) Color thumbnail images of the eight supercluster AGN
581: imaged with \emph{HST/ACS}. The color components are F606W and F814W for blue and red, respectively, while
582: green is represented by a weighted average of the two.
583: F606W (blue)...] (\emph{right}) Spatially resolved color profiles
584: (F606W-F814W) of each AGN host. The profiles are centered on the
585: galaxy nucleus and represents the median galaxy color in annuli one
586: pixel wide. \label{fig-color-grad2}}
587: \end{figure}
588:
589: Spectra of all nine supercluster AGN hosts obtained with the DEIMOS spectrograph are
590: shown in Figures \ref{fig-thumbs+spect1} and \ref{fig-thumbs+spect2}. We
591: find that all of the hosts exhibit narrow [OII] emission lines of low to
592: moderate strength\footnote{Despite the low signal-to-noise of the source 2
593: spectrum and a problematic background subtraction, we do observe a
594: double-peaked emission line indicative of [OII] at $z=0.9134$ in the
595: extracted spectrum of this host.} . The equivalent widths (EW) of these
596: lines, which were measured using the bandpass definitions of Fisher et
597: al.~(1998), are listed in Table \ref{tab-spect}; the values range from -2.0
598: to -16.8 \AA. We also observe that a majority (6 of 8) show Balmer absorption features indicative of young
599: A-type stars and the lack of massive O and B-type stars. Two hosts (\#3 and
600: \#4) show H$\delta$ absorption lines with EWs of 5.2 and 6.0 \AA,
601: respectively, while a second pair (\#0 and \#8) exhibit a strong higher-order
602: Balmer series. The most dramatic sets of Balmer lines are seen in sources 3 and
603: 8, two of the blue-cored, early-type hosts. We note that none of the sources
604: show signs of broad line emission or significantly rising blue continua commonly found in
605: more luminous QSOs, suggesting little AGN contamination at shorter wavelengths.
606:
607: If not for the observed [OII] emission lines, many of the host galaxies would
608: be classified as post-starburst due to their Balmer absorption. Balmer lines
609: typically persist for up to $\sim1.0$ Gyr after the last major episode of
610: star formation due to the lifetime of A-type stars (Poggianti \& Barbaro
611: 1997) and are usually not visible in systems with high levels of ongoing star
612: formation due to emission filling from HII regions.
613: Unfortunately given our spectral window we can not use other diagnostic lines
614: such as H$\alpha$ to determine whether the [OII] features are due to ongoing
615: star formation or photoionization by the AGN. If we assume the [OII]
616: emission is due entirely to star formation, then converting the
617: [OII] line luminosities to star formation rates (SFR) using the relationship
618: of Kennicutt (1998) we obtain rates ranging from $0.6\pm0.5$ to $8.5\pm3.9$
619: M$_{\odot}$ yr$^{-1}$. All of the derived rates are listed in Table
620: \ref{tab-spect} and represent lower limits as they are not corrected for extinction.
621:
622: While it is more than feasible that many of these galaxies have some ongoing,
623: centrally-concentrated star formation given their bluer colors, our calculated rates
624: are likely overestimated (barring extinction corrections) as it is distinctly possible that AGN related
625: emission contributes to the [OII] line luminosity. This was recently
626: demonstrated by Yan et al.~(2006), who found that post-starburst galaxies in
627: the SDSS sample which show little (or no) H$\alpha$ emission, but have line
628: ratios consistent with Seyferts, often exhibit significant [OII] EWs. We
629: have recently undertaken near-infrared spectroscopy of a small subsample of
630: Cl1604 members using NIRSPEC on \emph{Keck} to determine H$\alpha$ line strengths in
631: order to perform a similar test at $z=0.9$. Of the X-ray sources discussed in
632: this study, only source 5 has thus far been observed. This galaxy has the highest
633: measured [OII] EW of the nine hosts and we find an [NII]/H$\alpha$ line ratio
634: consistent with the system being a transition object, which suggests
635: both star formation and AGN emission contribute to the system's [OII] line
636: flux. Therefore the [OII]-derived SFR for this galaxy is likely an overestimate
637: as it does not account for the AGN contribution. We plan to observe the
638: remaining eight sources, including the four post-starburst hosts, with NIRSPEC in the near future.
639:
640: It is worth noting that the highest measured SFRs, which are $7.7\pm3.5$ and
641: $8.5\pm3.9$ M$_{\odot}$ yr$^{-1}$, are found in sources 3 and 8,
642: respectively; the two galaxies with the most pronounced Balmer absorption.
643: It is unlikely that these absorption lines would be so prevalent in systems
644: that are forming stars as prodigiously as these rates suggest. Poggianti et
645: al. (1999) found that spectra with strong Balmer lines and measurable [OII]
646: can be reproduced with low-level star formation following a recent, strong
647: burst. This may in fact be what we are observing here if our [OII]-derived SFRs
648: are overestimated due to AGN contaimination. Alternatively the [OII] emission
649: may originate entirely from gas ionized by the AGN. In either case it would
650: seem a large fraction of our supercluster AGN are located in galaxies which
651: underwent a starburst phase within the last $\sim1$ Gyr and whose star
652: formation has since been truncated.
653:
654: In addition to the post-starburst features, most hosts also show Ca H\&K
655: lines and three sources have a clear continuum break at 4000\AA, features indicative of an underlying older stellar
656: population. This is observed in the spectra of sources 3, 6 and 8, all
657: of which are blue-cored galaxies with otherwise red colors. This set of
658: observed properties is consistent with a minor merger induced nuclear
659: starburst in a previously passive system, similar to the process described by
660: Menanteau et al.~(2001b).
661:
662:
663: \subsection{Environments}
664: \label{sect-enviro}
665:
666: The location of the nine AGN detected in the Cl1604 supercluster in relation
667: to the system's constituent clusters are shown in Figure
668: \ref{fig-agn-spatial-dist}. We find the greatest concentration of AGN near
669: Cl1604+4316 (hereafter Cluster C) at $z=0.935$. Four sources have redshifts
670: nearly equal to the cluster's systemic redshift (\#0, \#1, \#3, \#4), while a
671: single source is located in the foreground of the cluster (\#2 at $z=0.913$).
672: Three of the AGN are located on the outskirts of Cl1604+4314 (Cluster B) at
673: $z=0.865$; the two sources closest to the cluster center have nearly
674: identical redshifts to that of the cluster (\#6 and \#7), while the one with
675: the greatest projected distance is at a higher redshift (\#5 at $z=0.899$).
676: In Cl1604+4321 (Cluster D) we find a single AGN (\#8) with a redshift
677: identical to that of the systemic cluster redshift of $z=0.923$.
678:
679: \begin{figure}[t]
680: \epsscale{1.1}
681: \plotone{./f9.astroph.eps}
682: \caption{Projected galaxy density above the field density in the
683: direction of the Cl1604 Supercluster. Densities were calculated using all
684: galaxies down to $M_{V} = -19.27$ ($m_{814} = 24.82$). The density
685: distribution for supercluster members and X-ray AGN hosts are denoted by
686: the dashed red and vertical dotted magenta lines, respectively. The solid
687: histogram shows the density of all ACS detected galaxies within 0.5 $h_{70}^{-1}$ Mpc of
688: a cluster center. \label{fig-den7}}
689: \end{figure}
690:
691: A striking result is the general absence
692: of AGN in regions with the highest local galaxy densities. This includes
693: Cl1604+4304 (Cluster A) and the center of Cluster B. These systems are
694: the richest clusters in the Cl1604 complex, with the highest measured
695: velocity dispersions and X-ray luminosities (G08; K08). On the other hand,
696: we do find AGN near the centers of Cluster C
697: and D (both in projection and redshift space), both of which are poorer
698: systems that are not directly detected in our X-ray observations.
699:
700: The distribution of AGN in the supercluster suggests their activity may be
701: influenced by both local environment and more large-scale cluster properties
702: such as a system's dynamical state. This is highlighted by the presence of
703: AGN on the outskirts of Cluster B and the lack of a similar population around
704: Cluster A. While both systems are relatively massive, G08
705: found evidence of velocity segregation in the redshift distribution of
706: Cluster B, indicating the system may have undergone a recent merger or is
707: actively accreting a substantial number of galaxies. K08
708: also found the system to have a higher than expected velocity dispersion
709: relative to the $L_{\rm x}-\sigma_{v}$ relation, also suggesting the system
710: may not be fully relaxed. This is quite unlike Cluster A, which shows no
711: signs of recent merger activity and appears fairly relaxed (and consistent
712: with the $L_{\rm x}-\sigma_{v}$ relation). We speculate
713: that the difference in the dynamical activity of Clusters A and B may indicate
714: the global properties of these systems are affecting the level of AGN
715: activity observed around each cluster.
716:
717: In order to quanitify the local environments of the AGN and to compare
718: them to those of the entire supercluster population we calculated the local
719: projected galaxy density, $\Sigma$, near each host galaxy using the method employed by Dressler et
720: al.~(1980) and more recently by Smith et al.~(2005) and Postman et
721: al.~(2005). The method calculates the projected density as $\Sigma = N / \Omega_{N}$,
722: where $\Omega_{N}$ is the solid angle which encompasses a galaxy's $N$
723: nearest neighbors down to a certain absolute magnitude limit. For our
724: calculation we adopt the parameters used by Postman et al.~(2005) with
725: $N=7$ and an absolute $V$-band magnitude of $M_{V} = -19.27$. At $z=0.9$, the average
726: redshift of the supercluster, and using an Sb galaxy $k$-correction, the latter
727: translates to an observed magnitude of $m_{814} = 24.82$. We found that varying
728: these parameters in the range of $5 \le N \le 10$ and $24 \le m_{814}
729: \le 25$ did not significantly alter our results.
730:
731: Since the Cl1604 field lacks sufficient redshift information to calculate
732: $\Sigma$ using only confirmed supercluster members, we make use of all
733: galaxies falling above our magnitude limit to determine the projected
734: density and statistically correct for background and foreground
735: contamination. This correction is derived from the average surface density of
736: field galaxies with $m_{814} \le 24.82$ in seven blank fields observed with
737: ACS. These fields were chosen for their lack of cataloged structures and
738: include three fields from GO-9761 (PI Alamini) and four fields from GO-9468
739: (PI Yan)\footnote{The field centers are 03:42:48.37 -09:36:51.9, 09:54:34.40
740: +17:53:11.2, 10:01:46.32 +55:05:24.7, 16:36:58.01 +40:56:01.1, 16:37:04.11
741: +40:58:59.1, 16:37:04.11 +41:01:58.1, 21:55:42.97 -09:26:34.7.}. Each field was obtained from the HST archive and reduced in an
742: identical manner to that of the Cl1604 dataset. Since we correct for the background and foreground
743: contamination by subtracting the average surface density of a blank field our
744: projected densities differ from those of Smith et al.~(2005) and Postman et
745: al.~(2005) in that they are technically densities in excess to the field
746: densities. In other words, our projected densities have been normalized to
747: the field density at $z=0.9$.
748:
749: The distribution of projected densities for all 371 supercluster members
750: imaged by ACS is shown in Figure \ref{fig-den7}. Also shown are the local
751: densities of the eight AGN host galaxies. We find two sources (\#4 and \#5)
752: have densities similar to that of the field, which given our statistical correction is
753: set to $\Sigma = 0$ galaxies Mpc$^{-2}$. The remaining sources are located in regions of
754: intermediate density, with $\Sigma$ values larger than the field value, but well below the
755: densities found near the cluster centers which range from 700-800 galaxies
756: Mpc$^{-2}$ in the center of cluster C and D and $\sim1000$ galaxies Mpc$^{-2}$
757: in Cluster A and B. These densities confirm our conclusions determined by
758: visual inspection: the AGN are found in intermediate density environments,
759: either outside the centers of massive clusters or in poorer clusters. It has
760: long been thought that such regions are conducive to galaxy interactions due
761: to their higher densities compared to the field and their relatively low
762: velocity dispersions (Cavaliere et al.~1992). This finding is similar to the conclusions of Gilmour et al.~(2007) who found
763: AGN in the Abell 901/902 supercluster at $z\sim0.17$ avoid the densest environments
764: in the system and are instead located on the outskirts of clusters or in
765: galaxy groups. At higher redshifts, we also agree with the results of
766: Georgakakis et al.~(2007) who found AGN generally avoid underdense regions and are found in
767: richer environments than similar non-active galaxies.
768:
769:
770: \section{Cluster AGN Fraction}
771:
772: There are several lines of evidence that suggest AGN activity is triggered more often in
773: and around galaxy clusters than in the field. A growing number of observations have reported an
774: overdensity of X-ray point sources in the vicinity of clusters relative to
775: blank-field observations (Henry \& Briel 1991; Cappi et al.~2001; Ruderman \& Ebeling
776: 2005; K08) and there are indications this overdensity
777: increases with redshift (Cappelluti et al.~2005; Branchesi et al.~2007).
778: This trend was recently confirmed spectroscopically by Eastman et al.~(2007),
779: who found an order-of-magnitude increase in the number of cluster members hosting AGN in
780: four $z\sim0.6$ clusters compared to the fraction measured by Martini et
781: al.~(2006) in eight low-redshift clusters ($z < 0.31$) using the same
782: methodology. We can perform a similar analysis using the AGN in the Cl1604 supercluster to
783: investigate whether this trend continues out to $z\sim0.9$.
784:
785: Eastman et al.~(2007) found a total of eight galaxies hosting AGN with X-ray luminosities of
786: $L_{\rm X} > 10^{43}$ $h_{70}^{-2}$ erg s$^{-1}$ (2-10 keV) within the $R_{200}$ radius of four
787: higher-redshift clusters. This was out of $\sim400$ potential hosts brighter
788: than $M_{R} = -20$, resulting in an AGN fraction of $f_{A}(L_{\rm X} >
789: 10^{43};M_{R} < -20) = 0.020_{-0.008}^{+0.012}$. To calculate the $R_{200}$ radii of the
790: three clusters in the Cl1604 system which have associated AGN, we make use of the
791: velocity dispersions, $\sigma_{v}$, measured by G08 and the
792: equation $R_{200} = 2\sigma_{v} / [\sqrt{200} H(z)]$. The resulting
793: $R_{200}$ radii range from 0.52 to 1.01 $h_{70}^{-1}$ Mpc (or $1\farcm11$ to
794: $2\farcm18$ on the sky). Within these radii we find three supercluster AGN,
795: although only two have 2-10 keV X-ray luminosities greater than $10^{43}$
796: $h_{70}^{-2}$ erg s$^{-1}$. These are sources 7 and 8 in clusters B and D.
797:
798: To determine which non-active cluster galaxies are capable of hosting a
799: detectable AGN we construct a flux limit map covering our entire ACIS-I
800: mosaic. This map takes into account the local background level, the size of the
801: PSF and the detector vignetting at the location of each cluster member to
802: determine the faintest detectable AGN at that position; details on its
803: construction are given in K08. Within the $R_{200}$ radii
804: of clusters B and D we find 74 galaxies brighter than $M_{R} = -20$ within
805: which both AGN could have been detected. Rest-frame magnitudes for the
806: cluster members were calculated from our observed magnitudes in the F814W
807: band using an Sb galaxy $k$-correction\footnote{We also
808: convert our magnitudes from the AB to the Vega system using the
809: appropriate ACS zeropoint in order to match the magnitude limit of Eastman et al.~(2007).}.
810:
811: The resulting AGN fraction amounts to 2 AGN in 74 possible hosts or $f_{A}(L_{\rm X} >
812: 10^{43};M_{R} < -20) = 0.027_{-0.020}^{+0.045}$ (the uncertainties correspond to
813: 90\%, one-sided Poisson confidence limits). An important point to note is that we have treated the diffuse emission from
814: Cluster B as an enhanced local background in constructing our flux limit map.
815: Although this emission effectively raises our point source detection
816: threshold in the soft band, the emission does not affect our ability to detect sources in
817: the hard band. We calculate that both AGN detected within the
818: $R_{200}$ radius of clusters B and D would have been detected in all of the
819: cluster members with $M_{R} < -20$ out to the same radius. If we instead
820: wish to be conservative and remove all galaxies embedded in the cluster's
821: diffuse emission, which extends roughly $50^{\prime\prime}$, this reduces the
822: number of potential hosts by 14, resulting in an AGN fraction of $f_{A}(L_{\rm X} >
823: 10^{43};M_{R} < -20;$ No Cluster B$) = 0.033_{-0.025}^{+0.055}$.
824:
825: Our measured cluster AGN fraction within $R_{200}$ at $z\sim0.9$ is
826: significantly higher than the fraction measured at low-redshift by Martini et
827: al.~(2006), who found $f_{A}(L_{\rm X} > 10^{43};M_{R} < -20) =
828: 0.0007_{-0.0007}^{+0.0021}$, but largley consistent with the moderate-redshift results of
829: Eastman et al.~(2007). Even if we exclude galaxies embedded within the
830: diffuse emission of cluster B, we do not find a statistically significant
831: increase over the fraction measured at $z\sim0.6$ given our large errors ($0.033_{-0.025}^{+0.055}$
832: versus $0.020_{-0.008}^{+0.012}$). Therefore we can not report a substantial
833: change in AGN activity within the $R_{200}$ radius from $z\sim0.6$ to
834: $z\sim0.9$. This is perhaps not surprising
835: since, as we discussed in \S\ref{sect-enviro}, most of the AGN detected in
836: the supercluster (6 of 9) are found in intermediate density environments and
837: well outside the $R_{200}$ radius of its constituent clusters. A much larger
838: sample of AGN in $z\sim1$ clusters will be needed in order to determine
839: whether the AGN fraction increases substantially beyond the levels observed
840: at moderate redshifts.
841:
842:
843:
844: \section{Discussion}
845: \label{sect-discuss}
846:
847: In many cases the observed properties of the nine AGN hosts found in
848: the Cl1604 supercluster either confirm the findings of previous wide-field
849: galaxy surveys or extend to higher redshifts trends observed in
850: lower-redshift structures. With regard to overall host morphology, optical
851: luminosity and color, our findings are generally consistent with the results
852: of several past studies which find host galaxies to be largely massive,
853: early-type galaxies showing signs of recent star formation (Kauffman et
854: al.~2003; Heckman et al.~2004, Sanchez et al.~2004; Nandra et al.~2007;
855: Silverman et al.~2008). The fact that our supercluster AGN are found in
856: luminous spheroids which have bluer colors than similar non-active galaxies
857: is not surprising as it is precisely these galaxies that contain the two
858: ingrediants required for nuclear activity: a massive black hole and an
859: abundant gas supply (Kauffmann et al.~2003). Our finding of predominantly
860: blue-cored, early-type hosts agrees well with the growing consensus that
861: powerful AGN are located in massive galaxies with bulges containing younger
862: stellar populations.
863:
864: Our results also seem to confirm the increased post-starburst-AGN
865: connection reported at higher redshifts. While there is extensive evidence for
866: younger stellar ages and recent starburst activity in moderate-luminosity AGN
867: (Schmitt et al.~1999, Gonzalez Delgado et al.~2001; Cid Fernandes et
868: al.~2001; Kauffmann et al.~2003; Heckman 2004; Ho 2005), the fraction of
869: Seyferts associated with post-starburst hosts at low redshift remains fairly
870: small. Goto et al.~(2006) found that although post-starburst hosts were more
871: often associated with AGN than normal galaxies, hosts exhibiting strong
872: post-starburst spectral signatures were relatively rare, accounting for only
873: 4.2\% of narrow-line type 2 Seyferts in the SDSS sample. Recently
874: Georgakakis et al.~(2008) reported an increase in this fraction at higher
875: redshifts ($0.68 \le z \le 0.88$) using a sample of X-ray sources detected in
876: the Extended Groth Strip. They find that $21\%$ of AGN hosts located on the red sequence
877: exhibit post-starburst signatures. In the Cl1604 supercluster we find
878: a significant fraction ($\sim44\%$) of all host spectra show post-starburst
879: features, supporting the notion of an increased post-starburst-AGN association
880: at redshifts approaching unity. Of course we must use caution when directly
881: comparing these results as we have assumed at least some AGN emission
882: contributes to our observed [OII] lines whereas previous studies have
883: not. In fact Yan et al.~(2006) warn that AGN driven [OII] emission being
884: mistaken for ongoing star formation may have led previous studies to
885: underestimate the prevalence of the post-starburst-AGN connection at lower redshifts.
886:
887: On one important topic, merger activity as a triggering mechanism, our
888: observations do seem to be at odds with previous studies. Although luminous QSO
889: activity has been tied to merger activity (Canalizo \& Stockton 2001,
890: Bennert et al.~2008), a similar link has not been clearly established with
891: moderate-luminosity Seyferts (De Robertis et al.~1998; Grogin et al.~2003, 2005; Pierce et
892: al.~2007). In particular Grogin et al.~(2005) found that while higher-redshift hosts are
893: bulge dominated, their asymmetry and near-neighbor counts were consistent
894: with non-AGN control samples. We find that although only two of eight hosts
895: have asymmetry and concentration parameters indicative of ongoing mergers, several
896: galaxies do show signs of recent interactions (i.e.~tidal features or
897: assymetric/multiple cores). Many of these hosts appear otherwise relaxed (being fit with high Sersic
898: indicies, for example), implying that any merger activity was either fairly
899: minor so as to not disrupt the galaxy significantly or enough time has
900: transpired for the system to have sufficiently relaxed. That being said, we
901: note once again that the asymmetry of the single AGN that we find in an apparent
902: merger remnant was not greatly enhanced by the precence of faint tidal
903: features largely due to its considerably brighter and compact nucleus.
904:
905: Overall we find that the properties of the nine host galaxies are generally
906: consistent with a scenario in which recent interactions have triggered both
907: increased levels of nuclear activity and an enhancement of centrally
908: concentrated star formation, followed by a rapid truncation of the latter.
909: This is evidenced by the post-starburst signatures in several host spectra,
910: their blue-cored color morphologies, and the high fraction of hosts that show signs of
911: recent interactions. Whether the star formation and nuclear activity were
912: triggered simultaneously or with some delay remains to be determined, but the
913: AGN emission does seem to persists beyond the termination of starburst activity in these systems.
914: Given this fact, our observations are therefore consistent with models
915: in which feedback from the AGN itself is responsible for this supression
916: and the subsequent migration of these galaxies from the blue cloud to the red
917: sequence. We do find that a majority of the host galaxies have intermediate
918: colors that place them in the transition zone of the color-magnitude
919: diagram, which further supports this scenario. This is in agreement with
920: several recent studies which have also found that the color of host galaxies
921: cover a similar range, extending from the red edge of the blue cloud to the red sequence (Sanchez
922: et al.~2004; Nandra et al.~2007; Martin et al.~2007; Georgakakis et al.~2008;
923: Silverman et al.~2008; although see Westoby et al.~2007 for a differing conclusion).
924:
925: Of particular interest for our study are the results of Silverman et
926: al.~(2008), who found that within a redshift interval containing two
927: large-scale structures in the E-DF-S $(0.63 \le z \le 0.76)$ AGN hosts are
928: preferentially located in the transition zone. We find a similar result
929: within the Cl1604 complex, where a majority of host galaxies are located
930: between the blue cloud and the red sequence. These results suggest that the
931: hosts of moderate-luminosity AGN are predominantly a transition population
932: within these structures, caught in the process of migrating from blue to red.
933: Coupled with recent findings that AGN are more common in richer environments
934: than they are in the field (Gilli et al~2003; Cappelluti et al~2005; Eastman
935: et al.~2007; K08), this finding implies that AGN related
936: feedback may play an important role in accelerating galaxy evolution in
937: large-scale structures.
938:
939: That being said, we should note that in studying the low-redshift supercluster Abell 901/902,
940: Gilmour et al.~(2007) found many AGN hosts with colors similar to that of the
941: supercluster red sequence. Likewise Nandra et al.~(2007) and Silverman et
942: al.~(2008) found a significant population of field AGN associated with redder
943: hosts. As Silverman et al.~points out, most of these are found at lower-redshifts
944: where the strong color evolution of massive galaxies capable of hosting AGN
945: insures these galaxies will be redder than those found at $z=0.9$. We would
946: like to further point out that most of these galaxies harbor
947: AGN less luminous than those detected in the Cl1604 supercluster. For
948: example, a source detected at our $3\sigma$ flux limit would have a
949: rest-frame 0.5-8 keV luminosity of $\sim8\times10^{42}$ $h_{70}^{-2}$ erg
950: s$^{-1}$ at the average redshift of the Cl1604 supercluster. All of the X-ray sources detected by Gilmour et al.~(2007) have
951: luminosities below this limit. Likewise most of the sources detected by
952: Nandra et al.~(2007) on the red sequence have luminosities below $10^{43}$
953: $h_{70}^{-2}$ erg s$^{-1}$; only one of our AGN fall into this regime. This
954: is not extremely surprising as it has been observed for some time that less
955: luminous AGN have older stellar populations than their more powerful
956: counterparts (e.g. Kauffmann et al.~2003; Heckman 2004). The fact that we do
957: not observe any moderate-luminosity AGN on the red sequence is consistent
958: with the AGN feedback model of Hopkins et al.~(2005) which suggests AGN
959: should become less luminous as their hosts migrate from the blue cloud to the
960: red sequence due to the depletion of material which would otherwise feed the
961: central black hole.
962:
963: An alternative theory that is also consistent with our observations is one of
964: episodic star formation and AGN activity in red sequence galaxies. In this
965: scenario minor mergers that do not significantly disrupt the galaxy initiate
966: nuclear activity and trigger renewed star formation which temporarily moves
967: the system off of the supercluster red sequence. This produces a population
968: of young, blue stars we observe as the blue cores of these systems in a
969: process similar to the one described by Menanteau et al.~(2001b). This
970: results in a build-up of both stellar bulge mass and black hole mass that is
971: eventually regulated by the feedback mechanism. As star formation is
972: quenched, the newly formed stars fade and the galaxy returns to the red
973: sequence but this time with a higher luminosity. In this view, AGN hosts in the
974: supercluster are not in fact transitioning from blue to red, but instead from
975: low to high luminosity (mass) on the red sequence. This scenario does seem to be supported by
976: the relatively red colors we find in many of the blue-cored host galaxies.
977: If it were not for their cores, these galaxies would be on the red sequence.
978: Of course in order for this process to work, either the red sequence galaxies would
979: need to retain a significant reservoir of cold gas to fuel future activity or
980: a sufficient amount would need to be accreted from the merging, presumable
981: gas-rich, galaxy.
982:
983:
984:
985: \section{Conclusions}
986:
987: In summary, we find that the X-ray selected AGN detected in the Cl1604
988: supercluster are largely hosted by luminous ($M_{V} < -21.1$), spheroidal
989: and/or bulge dominated galaxies which are bluer than
990: similar galaxies on the system's red sequence.
991: The integrated colors of a majority of the hosts (5/8) place them in the
992: valley between the supercluster red sequence and the more diffuse blue cloud.
993: In half of the hosts, the bluer overall colors are the result of blue
994: resolved cores in otherwise red spheroids. Given that the supercluster AGN
995: luminosities do not reach the QSO level and the lack of obvious AGN contamination
996: in their optical spectra, we interpret the blue cores as the result of recent
997: star formation. Many of these galaxies do show signs of starburst
998: activity within the last $\sim1$ Gyr as $\sim44\%$ (4/9) of the host spectra exhibit
999: either strong H$-\delta$ absorption or a pronounced Balmer series. We also
1000: find a majority of hosts (6/9) show signs of recent or pending
1001: interactions, a possible indication of their triggering mechanism. With
1002: regard to environment, we observe that the hosts tend to avoid the densest regions of the
1003: supercluster and are instead located in intermediate density environments,
1004: such as the infall region of a massive cluster or in poorer systems
1005: undergoing assembly. Finally, we measure an increased fraction of
1006: supercluster members that harbor AGN relative to low-redshift ($z<0.3$) clusters,
1007: but we do not observe a substantial change from the fraction reported at
1008: $z\sim0.6$.
1009:
1010: In general our observations are fairly consistent with theories that link
1011: AGN activity to galaxies undergoing transformation from star forming systems in the
1012: blue cloud to passively evolving galaxies on the red sequence. This is
1013: evidenced by the fact that (i) a significant fraction of the AGN hosts are
1014: located in the transition zone of the color-magnitude diagram, which
1015: is normally sparsely populated, (ii) several hosts show evidence of a recent enhancement of star
1016: formation that was abruptly terminated and (iii) there are indications of
1017: recent merger activity in many of the hosts, which are located in
1018: moderate-density environments thought to be conducive to galaxy interactions.
1019: An alternative theory that is also consistent with our observations is one of
1020: episodic star formation and AGN activity in red sequence galaxies triggered
1021: by galaxy interactions. In this scenario, AGN hosts in the
1022: supercluster are not in fact transitioning from blue to red, but instead from
1023: low to high luminosity (mass) on the red sequence.
1024:
1025: Many of these conclusions, especially those regarding the post-starburst-AGN connection, depend on our assumption that the [OII]
1026: emission lines seen in the host galaxies are due in part to AGN emission. We
1027: plan to test this assumption in the near future with near-infrared spectroscopic
1028: observations of each AGN host in order to obtain H$\alpha$ and [NII] EWs and
1029: line ratios. The observations of one host which have already been completed have confirmed
1030: that AGN emission contributes to the galaxies [OII] line flux, leading to an
1031: overestimated SFR. If we find similar results for the remaining hosts, this
1032: will help confirm that a significant fraction of AGN in the Cl1604
1033: supercluster have experienced a recent and rapid truncation of their star
1034: formation activity.
1035:
1036:
1037:
1038: \acknowledgments
1039: This work is supported by the Chandra General Observing Program
1040: under award number GO6-7114X. Additional support for this program was
1041: provided by NASA through a grant HST-GO-11003 from the Space Telescope
1042: Science Institute, which is operated by the Association of Universities for
1043: Research in Astronomy, Inc. The
1044: spectrographic data used herein were obtained at the W.M. Keck Observatory,
1045: which is operated as a scientific partnership among the California Institute
1046: of Technology, the University of California and the National Aeronautics and
1047: Space Administration. The Observatory was made possible by the generous
1048: financial support of the W.M. Keck Foundation.
1049:
1050: % , under NASA contract NAS 5-26555
1051:
1052:
1053: \begin{center}
1054: \tabletypesize{\scriptsize}
1055: \begin{deluxetable*}{ccccccc}
1056: \tablewidth{0pt}
1057: \tablecaption{X-ray Properties of X-ray Selected AGN in the Cl1604 Supercluster \label{tab-prop}}
1058: \tablecolumns{7}
1059: \tablehead{\colhead{} & \colhead{} & \colhead{RA} & \colhead{Dec} &
1060: \colhead{} & \colhead{$L_{\rm x}$ (0.5-8 keV)} & \colhead{} \\
1061: \colhead{ID} & \colhead{Name} & \colhead{(J2000)} & \colhead{(J2000)} &
1062: \colhead{$z$} & \colhead{($\times10^{43}$)$^{\dagger}$} & \colhead{HR} }
1063: \startdata
1064: 0 & J160401.3+431351 & 241.00546 & 43.23089 & 0.927 & 3.44 & -0.31 \\
1065: 1 & J160405.1+431519 & 241.02139 & 43.25551 & 0.934 & 0.78 & -0.50 \\
1066: 2 & J160406.1+431807 & 241.02528 & 43.30222 & 0.913 & 2.99 & -0.36 \\
1067: 3 & J160408.2+431736 & 241.03416 & 43.29359 & 0.937 & 2.75 & 0.12 \\
1068: 4 & J160410.9+432111 & 241.04547 & 43.35318 & 0.935 & 1.12 & 0.52 \\
1069: 5 & J160415.6+431016 & 241.06492 & 43.17134 & 0.900 & 4.47 & -0.35 \\
1070: 6 & J160423.9+431125 & 241.09959 & 43.19052 & 0.867 & 3.39 & -0.42 \\
1071: 7 & J160425.9+431245 & 241.10783 & 43.21265 & 0.871 & 1.31 & -0.42 \\
1072: 8 & J160436.7+432141 & 241.15290 & 43.36147 & 0.923 & 2.28 & -0.10 \\
1073: \vspace*{-0.075in}
1074: \enddata
1075: \tablecomments{$^{\dagger}$ in units of $h_{70}^{-2}$ erg s$^{-1}$}
1076: \end{deluxetable*}
1077: \end{center}
1078:
1079:
1080: \begin{center}
1081: \tabletypesize{\scriptsize}
1082: \begin{deluxetable*}{cccccccl}
1083: \tablewidth{0pt}
1084: \tablecaption{Optical Properties of X-ray Selected AGN in the Cl1604 Supercluster \label{tab-spect}}
1085: \tablecolumns{8}
1086: \tablehead{\colhead{} & \colhead{} & \colhead{[OII] EW} & \colhead{H$\delta$ EW} & \colhead{SFR} & \colhead{Morph} & \colhead{} & \colhead{} \\
1087: \colhead{ID} & \colhead{Name} & \colhead{(\AA)} & \colhead{(\AA)} & \colhead{M$_{\odot}$ yr$^{-1}$} & \colhead{Class} & \colhead{Int$^{\dagger}$} & \colhead{Notes}}
1088: \startdata
1089: 0 & J160401.3+431351 & -3.3 & 1.8 & 2.7$\pm$1.3 & - & - & No ACS data available \\
1090: 1 & J160405.1+431519 & -2.5 & --- & 1.6$\pm$0.9 & E & - & Blue core, faint elongation, possible tidal feature \\
1091: 2 & J160406.1+431807 & -2.0 & --- & 0.6$\pm$0.5 & E/X & T & Merger remnant, tidal features \\
1092: 3 & J160408.2+431736 & -7.2 & 5.2 & 7.7$\pm$3.5 & Epec & M & Blue, double peaked core \\
1093: 4 & J160410.9+432111 & -5.2 & 6.0 & 0.9$\pm$0.6 & Sa & - & Red galaxy with elongated core \\
1094: 5 & J160415.6+431016 & -16.8 & --- & 4.5$\pm$2.1 & Sb & M & Spiral with kinematic companion \\
1095: 6 & J160423.9+431125 & -7.5 & --- & 4.3$\pm$2.0 & Sa & M & Blue core, nearby companion, tidal features \\
1096: 7 & J160425.9+431245 & -13.7 & --- & 1.3$\pm$0.7 & E & - & \\
1097: 8 & J160436.7+432141 & -7.0 & --- & 8.5$\pm$3.9 & E & - & Blue core, appears relaxed \\
1098: \vspace*{-0.075in}
1099: \enddata
1100: \tablecomments{ $^{\dagger}$ Interpretation of disturbance: T = Tidal Feature, M = Merger}
1101: \end{deluxetable*}
1102: \end{center}
1103:
1104:
1105: \clearpage
1106:
1107:
1108:
1109:
1110: \bibliographystyle{apj}
1111: \bibliography{/Users/kocevski/LaTex/ORELSE/SuperclusterII/ms}
1112:
1113: \end{document}
1114: