1:
2: \documentclass[oldversion]{aa}
3:
4: \usepackage{graphicx}
5: \usepackage{txfonts}
6: \usepackage{natbib}
7: \usepackage{supertabular}
8: \usepackage{longtable}
9: \usepackage{url}
10: \usepackage{dcolumn}
11:
12: \begin{document}
13: \newcommand{\dla}{damped Lyman-$\alpha$}
14: \newcommand{\Dla}{Damped Lyman-$\alpha$}
15: \newcommand{\lya}{Ly-$\alpha$}
16: \newcommand{\lyb}{Ly-$\beta$}
17:
18:
19: %Title of paper
20: \title{HD molecules at high redshift \thanks{Based on observations carried out at the European Southern Observatory, under programme 278.A-5062
21: with the Ultraviolet and Visual Echelle Spectrograph installed at the Very Large Telescope, unit Kueyen,
22: on mount Paranal in Chile.}}%:
23: \subtitle{A low astration factor of deuterium in a solar-metallicity DLA system at $z$~=~2.418
24: }
25:
26: \author{P. Noterdaeme\inst{1}, P. Petitjean\inst{1}, C. Ledoux\inst{2}, R. Srianand\inst{3} and A. Ivanchik\inst{4}}
27: \institute{Institut d'Astrophysique de Paris, CNRS - Universit\'e Pierre et Marie Curie, 98bis bd Arago, 75014 Paris, France\\
28: \email{noterdaeme@iap.fr, petitjean@iap.fr}
29: \and
30: European Southern Observatory, Alonso de C\'{o}rdova 3107, Casilla 19001, Vitacura, Santiago 19, Chile\\
31: \email{cledoux@eso.org}
32: \and
33: Inter University Centre for Astronomy and Astrophysics, Post Bag 4, Ganesh Khind, Pune 411\,007, India\\
34: \email{anand@iucaa.ernet.in}
35: \and
36: Ioffe Physical Technical Institute, St Petersburg 194021, Russia\\
37: \email{iav@astro.ioffe.ru}
38: }
39: \authorrunning{P. Noterdaeme et al.}
40: \titlerunning{HD at high-$z$: A low astration factor of deuterium in a solar metallicity DLA system at $z=2.418$}
41:
42: \abstract{
43: We present the detection of deuterated molecular hydrogen (HD) in
44: the remote Universe in a damped Lyman-$\alpha$ cloud at $z_{\rm abs}=2.418$
45: toward the quasar SDSS\,J143912.04$+$111740.5. This is a unique system in which
46: H$_2$ and CO molecules are also detected. The chemical enrichment of this gas derived from Zn\,{\sc ii} and
47: S\,{\sc ii} is as high as in the Sun.
48: We measure $N({\rm HD})/2 N({\rm H_2})=1.5^{+0.6}_{-0.4}\times10^{-5}$, which is significantly higher than the same
49: ratio measured in the Galaxy and close to the primordial D/H ratio estimated from the WMAP constraint on the baryonic
50: matter density ($\Omega_{\rm b}$). This indicates a low astration factor of deuterium that contrasts with the unusually
51: high chemical enrichment of the gas. This can be interpreted as the consequence of an intense infall of primordial gas onto
52: the associated galaxy.
53: Detection of HD molecules at high-$z$ also opens the possibility to obtain an independent
54: constraint on the cosmological-time variability of $\mu$, the proton-to-electron mass ratio.
55: }
56:
57: \keywords{Cosmology: observations --
58: Galaxies: high-redshift --
59: Galaxies: ISM --
60: Quasars: absorption lines --
61: Quasars: individual: SDSS J143912.04$+$111740.5}
62:
63: \maketitle
64:
65:
66:
67: \section{Introduction}
68:
69: Deuterium is produced by primordial nucleosynthesis and is subsequently destroyed in stars.
70: Therefore measurements of D/H from primordial gas provide important constraints on the
71: baryonic matter density $\Omega_{\rm b}$ in the framework of Big-Bang cosmology \citep{Wagoner73}.
72: Measurements at different redshifts in turn provide important clues on the star formation history
73: \citep{Daigne04,Steigman07}.
74: All the available D/H measurements at high-$z$ are based on the determination of the
75: $N($D$^0)/N($H$^0)$ ratio in low-metallicity QSO absorption line systems.
76: These measurements are difficult mainly because the velocity separation between
77: D\,{\sc i} and H\,{\sc i} absorption lines is small
78: ($\Delta v_{\ion{D}{i}/\ion{H}{i}}\sim80$~km\,s$^{-1}$) implying the lines are easily blended.
79: An additional difficulty is the presence of the Lyman-$\alpha$ forest, making
80: hard to find the true continuum position and to discern between D\,{\sc i} absorption lines and
81: intervening Ly-$\alpha$ forest lines.
82: This explains why, despite more than a decade of efforts, only seven robust measurements of D/H at high-redshift have been performed \citep{OMeara06,Pettini08a}.
83: It happens that these measurements are consistent with the
84: value [D/H]$_{\rm p}$ = 2.55$\pm 0.10\times10^{-5}$ derived from
85: the Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) five year data
86: \citep{Komatsu08} together with the $\eta\leftrightarrow$ [D/H]$_{\rm p}$ conversion from \citet{Burles01}, where
87: $\eta$ is the baryon-to-photon ratio.
88: We consider this [D/H]$_{\rm p}$ value as the primordial D abundance in this work.
89: %
90: \par
91: Damped Lyman-$\alpha$ systems (DLAs) are absorbers with the highest
92: neutral hydrogen column densities among H\,{\sc i} absorption line systems
93: ($N($H$^0)\ga10^{20}$~cm$^{-2}$) and are thought
94: to arise from the neutral interstellar medium (ISM) of distant galaxies \citep{Wolfe05}.
95: Only a small fraction ($\sim$10-15\%) of them show detectable amounts of H$_2$ \citep{Ledoux03,Noterdaeme08}.
96: Among the 14 high-$z$ H$_2$-bearing DLAs known to date, only two show HD absorption
97: \citep{Varshalovich01,Srianand08}. The $z_{\rm abs}=2.418$ system toward
98: SDSS\,J143912$+$111740 we present here is the only one where, in
99: addition to H$_2$ and HD, CO is detected.
100: From the excitation of CO it is possible to derive in a straightforward way
101: an accurate estimate of the Cosmic Microwave Background Radiation temperature
102: at the redshift of the absorber \citep{Srianand08}.
103: Here we focus on the HD/H$_2$ ratio and its implications for the star-formation history in the DLA galaxy.
104:
105:
106: \section{Observations and Analysis\label{obs}}
107:
108: Observations were performed with the Ultraviolet and Visual Echelle
109: Spectrograph of the Very Large Telescope at the European Southern
110: Observatory on March 21-25, 2007 with total exposure time on source exceeding 8\,h. Both blue and
111: red spectroscopic arms were
112: used simultaneously using dichroic settings with central wavelengths of resp. 390~nm and 580~nm (or 610~nm).
113: The resulting wavelength coverage is 330$-$710~nm with a small gap between 452 and 478~nm.
114: The CCD pixels were binned 2$\times$2 and the slit width adjusted to $1^{\prime\prime}$ matching the seeing
115: conditions of $\sim 0.\!\!^{\prime\prime}9$. This yields a resolving power of $R=50\,000$, as measured on the
116: thorium-argon lines from the calibration lamp.
117: The data were reduced using the UVES pipeline v\,3.3.1 based on the ESO common pipeline library system.
118: Accurate tracking of the object is achieved even in case of very low signal-to-noise ratio.
119: Both the object and sky spectra are optimaly extracted and cosmic ray impacts and CCD defects are
120: rejected iteratively.
121: Wavelengths were rebinned to the vacuum-heliocentric rest frame and individual scientific
122: exposures were co-added using a sliding window and weighting the signal by the total errors in each pixel.
123: The dispersion around the wavelength calibration solution is 150~m\,s$^{-1}$.
124: Standard Voigt-profile fitting methods were used for the analysis to determine column densities, redshifts, and
125: Doppler parameters~$b$.
126:
127: \begin{figure}%[!Ht]
128: \centering
129: \includegraphics[bb=85 90 570 730,angle=90,width=\hsize,clip=]{fig1.ps}
130: \caption{Voigt profile fits to the Ly$\alpha$ (top panel) and Ly$\beta$ (middle panel) lines.
131: The bottom panel shows the absorption profile of O\,{\sc i} to visualize the positions
132: of individual H\,{\sc i} components (vertical dotted lines). The solid red
133: lines indicate the overall fit-model. Profiles are plotted on a velocity scale with
134: origin set at $z_{\rm abs} = 2.41837$.
135: Blue profiles at $v=0$~km\,s$^{-1}$ represent the main H$^0$ component and the associated
136: uncertainty as a shaded region. }
137: \label{HI}
138: \end{figure}
139:
140:
141: H\,{\sc i}~absorption corresponding to the DLA is spread over $\sim$1000 km~s$^{-1}$.
142: The velocity structure can be modeled using the asymmetry of the \lya\ line and
143: the profile of the \lyb\ line (see Fig.~\ref{HI}).
144: The derived structure is consistent with the velocity profile of the
145: O\,{\sc i} absorption. The latter species
146: is believed to track H\,{\sc i} closely through charge exchange reactions
147: for $\log N($H$^0)\ge19.0$ \citep{Viegas95}.
148: The continuum is fitted at the same time as the absorption lines with a large-scale low-order
149: spline.
150:
151: The column density in the main clump is strongly constrained by the red damping wing and the gaps
152: in the Ly-$\beta$ absorption.
153: The best fit gives $\log N($H$^0)=20.10^{+0.10}_{-0.08}$ for the main clump at $z_{\rm abs}$ = 2.41837.
154: Note that a column density of $\log N($H$^0)$~=~20.2 would fill in the whole red profile (see Fig.~1).
155: For a column density smaller than $\log N($H$^0)$~=~20, the shape of the profile can not be reproduced
156: by any absorption located at $-$117~km\,s$^{-1}$.
157:
158:
159: The overall fit is represented in red on Fig.~\ref{HI}, while the contribution from the main
160: clump only is shown by the blue profile and the associated uncertainties by the shaded region.
161: Indicative column densities for other components are $\log N($H$^0)=$~17.9, 19.25, 19.20 and 19.20 at
162: velocities $v$~=~$-$892, $-$594, $-$382, and $-$117~km\,s$^{-1}$, relative to the main clump
163: studied here.
164: The complex velocity structure and/or insufficient signal-to-noise ratio in the blue prevent the determination of
165: $N($D$^0)$ in these individual components directly from D\,{\sc i} lines.
166: From fitting together various optically thin transitions of S\,{\sc ii}, Zn\,{\sc ii}, Si\,{\sc ii} and
167: Fe\,{\sc ii}, we derive metallicities in the main clump (at $v=0$~km\,s$^{-1}$; see Table~\ref{abundances}).
168: No ionisation correction is applied. The presence of strong neutral carbon and molecular lines in
169: the main clump, including easily photo-dissociated CO \citep[][]{Srianand08} indicates that the effect
170: of ionisation on abundances should be negligible. Indeed, in the abscence of neutral carbon, the ionisation
171: correction for $\log N($H\,{\sc i}$)=20.1$ is smaller than 0.10~dex \citep[see Fig.~23 of][]{Peroux07}.
172: The S and Zn metallicities are solar and the relative depletion
173: pattern (from Si and Fe) is typical of what is seen in cold neutral ISM
174: clouds in the Galaxy (see Table~\ref{abundances}).
175:
176: %ABUNDANCES
177: \begin{table}
178: \centering
179: \caption{\label{abundances} Observed metal abundances}
180: \begin{tabular}{c c c}
181: \hline
182: \hline
183: Ion (X) & $\log N$(X) & [X/H]$^1$ \\
184: \hline %with M03
185: S$^+$ & $15.27\pm0.06$ & $-0.03\pm0.12$ \\
186: Zn$^+$ & $12.93\pm0.04$ & $+0.16\pm0.11$ \\
187: Si$^+$ & $14.80\pm0.04$ & $-0.86\pm0.11$ \\
188: Fe$^+$ & $14.28\pm0.05$ & $-1.32\pm0.11$ \\
189: N$^0$ & $\ge15.71$ & $\ge-0.34$ \\
190: \hline
191: \end{tabular}\\
192: \footnotesize
193: $^1$ with respect to solar abundances from \citet{Morton03}.
194: \normalsize
195: \end{table}
196:
197: \section{Column densities of molecules and D/H ratio \label{dh}}
198:
199: %H2
200: Absorption lines from more than one hundred H$_2$ transitions
201: from rotational levels J~=~0 up to J~=~5 are detected in the main H\,{\sc i} component
202: in six components spread over 50 km~s$^{-1}$. Column densities in different J levels
203: are obtained by simultaneous fits and are especially well constrained by the presence
204: of damping wings seen on the corresponding lines from the Lyman 2-0, 4-0, 5-0, 7-0,
205: 8-0, 9-0, and 10-0 bands and from the Werner 0-0 and 1-0 bands. Examples are shown on Fig.~\ref{fits},
206: with $\chi^2$~=~1.04, 0.99 and 0.98 for J~=~0, 1 and 3, respectively.
207: We measure a total column density of $\log N({\rm H_2})=19.38\pm0.10$ and
208: a molecular fraction, $f=2N({\rm H_2})/[2N({\rm H_2})+N($H$^0)]=0.27^{+0.10}_{-0.08}$.
209: The uncertainty on $N($H$_2$) is dominated by the error from fitting the
210: damping wings of low rotational level lines (J~=~0 and 1).
211:
212: %HD
213: Deuterated molecular hydrogen is detected in the first rotational level in three components
214: associated to the strongest H$_2$ components. Five HD absorption lines
215: (L3-0\,R0, L5-0\,R0, L7-0\,R0, L8-0\,R0 and W0-0\,R0) are clearly detected
216: and were fitted simultaneously. The fits are shown on Fig.~\ref{fits}. Signal-to-noise
217: ratios are $\sim$12 for L0-0\,R0, L3-0\,R0 and L5-0\,R0, and $\sim$6 for the remaining lines.
218: $\chi^2$ values for the fit to these lines are 0.43 (L0-0\,R0), 1.04 (L3-0\,R0),
219: 1.36 (L7-0\,R0), 1.07 (L8-0\,R0) and 1.49 (W0-0\,R0).
220: Note that fittings were done independently by two of us (PN and RS) with two different
221: tools (FITLYMAN and VPFIT), yielding same results.
222: The strongest constraint comes from L3-0\,R0 transition which has good SNR and is optically thin (see Fig.~2).
223: Note that L5-0\,R0 is blended with another absorption and is not included in the fit.
224: Results of the fits are summarized in Table~\ref{HDtab}. Errors correspond the fit
225: of both the lines and the continuum.
226: The total HD column density is $\log N({\rm HD})=14.87\pm0.025$.
227:
228: \begin{figure}
229: \centering
230: \includegraphics[bb=85 90 570 730,angle=90,width=\hsize,clip=]{fig2.ps}
231: \caption{\label{fits} Molecular hydrogen absorption lines.
232: The normalized flux is given on a velocity scale with the origin set at
233: $z_{\rm abs}=2.41837$. The Voigt profile fits as well as the residuals are also plotted.
234: The blue dashed profile overplotted on HD\,L5-0\,R0 corresponds to the contribution from HD only.
235: The grey regions for H$_2$\,L4-0\,R0 and H$_2$\,L4-0\,R1 represent the 1$\sigma$ uncertainty around
236: the best fit. Short vertical lines mark the position of individual components.}
237: \end{figure}
238:
239: \begin{table}%[!Ht]
240: \centering
241: \caption{\label{HDtab} Voigt profile fitting results for HD}
242: \begin{tabular}{c c c c}
243: \hline
244: \hline
245: $z_{\rm abs}$ & $v^1$ & $b$ & $\log N$(HD) \\
246: & (km\,s$^{-1}$) & (km\,s$^{-1}$) & \\
247: \hline
248: 2.41835 & $-$1.9 & $2.9\pm0.8$ & $13.89\pm0.08$\\
249: 2.41851 & 12.0 & $5.0\pm1.0$ & $14.57\pm0.04$\\
250: 2.41866 & 25.3 & $3.5\pm0.3$ & $14.46\pm0.03$\\
251: \hline
252: \end{tabular}\\
253: \footnotesize
254: $^1$ Velocity relative to $z_{\rm abs}=2.41837$.
255: \normalsize
256: \end{table}
257:
258: Although each HD component is associated to one of the H$_2$ components, the strong blending of the latter,
259: especially in low rotational levels, does not allow for the determination of $N($HD$)/2N($H$_2)$
260: in individual components.
261: We therefore use the column densities integrated over the whole profile for both HD and H$_2$
262: and obtain $N({\rm HD})/2N({\rm H_2})=1.5^{+0.6}_{-0.4}\times10^{-5}$.
263: In Fig.~\ref{HDH2}, we compare the $N($HD$)/2N($H$_2)$ ratio with similar measurements
264: in the Galactic ISM \citep{Lacour05b}.
265: It is apparent that the $N({\rm HD})/2N({\rm H_2})$ ratio in
266: the present system is an order of magnitude higher than the values for similar
267: molecular fraction (and $N({\rm H_2})$) measured in the Galaxy.
268: We also compare these results to D$^0$/H$^0$ measurements in low metallicity
269: clouds toward high-redshift quasars \citep{Pettini08a},
270: the Galactic disk, the Galactic halo and the primordial D/H ratio estimated from the
271: five-year WMAP results \citep{Komatsu08}.
272:
273: From the molecular ratio, HD/2H$_2$, we derive
274: (D/H)$_{DLA}>0.7\times10^{-5}$ at the 95\% confidence level. This
275: corresponds to an astration factor $f_{\rm D}=({\rm D/H})_{\rm p}/{(\rm D/H)_{\rm DLA}}<3.6$
276: where (D/H)$_{\rm p}$ refers to the primordial abundance derived from WMAP.
277: However, the true (D/H) ratio (resp. astration factor) is probably well above the
278: derived lower limit (resp. well below the upper limit) for various reasons:
279:
280:
281: First, the quoted HD/2H$_2$ ratio could represent a lower limit on the
282: actual ratio in individual components as H$_2$ and HD are possibly
283: not co-spatial. Indeed, the maximum HD column density does
284: not arise in the strongest CO component \citep[see][]{Srianand08}, suggesting a
285: fraction of the molecular hydrogen is not associated with HD.
286:
287: Second, deriving the deuterium abundance from the HD column density is difficult
288: because of the complex chemistry \citep[e.g.][]{Cazaux08} and the sensitivity of the HD
289: abundance on the particle density, cosmic ray density and UV field \citep{LePetit02}.
290: However FUSE and Copernicus observations have shown that in the ISM of the Galaxy, the HD/H$_2$ ratio
291: increases with the molecular fraction and that HD/2H$_2$ could trace D/H well only when
292: $f\sim1$ \citep{Lacour05b}, when both HD and H$_2$ are self-shielded from photo-dissociation.
293: In diffuse gas, the HD optical depth is expected to be smaller than that of H$_2$ --as
294: the deuterium abundance is low-- and HD/2H$_2$ will provide a lower limit on D/H
295: \citep{LePetit02,Liszt06}. This is also supported by recent FUSE observations by \citet{Snow08}.
296:
297: Finally, the D/H ratio in the gas phase, as measured by HD/2H$_2$, could itself be a lower limit on the
298: true abundance ratio if depletion on dust is significant \citep{Prochaska05hd,Draine06}.
299:
300:
301:
302: \begin{figure}[!t]
303: \includegraphics[width=\hsize,bb=23 410 600 750]{fig3.ps}
304: \caption{\label{HDH2} The {\bf HD/2H$_2$} ratio vs the molecular fraction.
305: The filled square is the new measurement at
306: $z_{\rm abs}=2.418$ toward SDSS\,J143912$+$111740.
307: The empty circles are {\sc fuse} and Copernicus measurements in
308: the Galactic ISM \citep{Lacour05b}. The grey region
309: marks the D$^0$/H$^0$ ratio in the Galactic disk \citep{Linsky06},
310: the light grey region marks this ratio in the Galactic halo
311: \citep{Savage07} and the vertically-dashed one that in the Local Bubble \citep{Moos02,Linsky06}.
312: The oblique dashed lines stand for D$^0$/H$^0$ measurements in high-redshift quasar absorption-line systems
313: \citep[QSO ALS;][]{Pettini08a}.
314: Finally, the solid line corresponds to the D/H ratio estimated from the baryon/photon ratio \citep[WMAP;][]{Komatsu08}.
315: }
316: \end{figure}
317:
318:
319:
320:
321:
322: \section{Discussion}
323: \subsection*{Evidence for infall?}
324: The high D/H ratio inferred above indicates that astration of deuterium
325: is low eventhough metallicity is solar. This situation is well explained
326: in our Galaxy by models including infall of primordial material \citep{Steigman07,Romano06,Prodanovic08}.
327:
328: If we use the sulfur abundance as a proxy for that of oxygen,
329: we note that the [N/O] ratio in the main H\,{\sc i} component
330: is consistent with the ratio expected for secondary nitrogen production at
331: solar metallicity \citep{Centurion03,Petitjean08,Pettini08b}. In addition, the [S/Zn]
332: ratio is consistent with the solar value and does not indicate any $\alpha$-enhancement.
333:
334: The inferred lower limit on D/H, the near solar value of [$\alpha$/Fe] and
335: [N/$\alpha$] rule out rapid star formation that is generally invoked to explain
336: high chemical enrichment in elliptical galaxies.
337:
338: Speculating slightly further, we note that the metal profile is spread over at least $800$~km\,s$^{-1}$ (see Fig.~\ref{HI}).
339: This, together with the solar metallicity, is consistent with the gas being associated with
340: a deep potential well \citep{Ledoux06a}.
341:
342: The properties of the gas in the present system are similar to those of
343: the ISM in our Galaxy.
344: But these properties are reached on a time-scale five times smaller for the DLA galaxy than for the
345: Milky Way, as the age of the Universe at $z = 2.42$ is 20\% of its present age adopting the most recent
346: cosmological parameters \citep{Komatsu08}. This must imply that the system has
347: undergone continuous star-formation and infall.
348:
349: If one assumes negligible production of deuterium by cosmic rays and that this element
350: is completely destroyed
351: in the material that goes through stars then the gas infall rate ${\rm \dot M_{in}}$ should on
352: average be of the order of the star formation rate ${\rm \dot M_{SFR}}$
353: in order to replenish deuterium.
354: Recently several observational evidences have been published
355: for cold gas accretion onto massive galaxies
356: at high-$z$ \citep{Weidinger05,Nilsson06,Dijkstra06}
357: and low-$z$ \citep{Fraternali08}.
358: In addition, numerical simulations suggest that at $z= 2-3$ the accretion of cold material from
359: the IGM dominates for halos with masses $<\sim3\times10^{11}$ M$_\odot$ \citep{Keres05}. Interestingly,
360: the inference that ${\rm \dot M_{in}}\sim {\rm \dot M_{SFR}}$ is also required to understand
361: the properties of $z = 2-3$ Lyman-break galaxies \citep{Erb08}.
362: Our observations reinforce this important finding.
363:
364:
365:
366:
367: \subsection*{Constraint on the variability of $\mu$}
368:
369: The detection of several HD transitions should make it possible to test the
370: time variation of $\mu=m_p/m_e$, the proton-to-electron mass ratio.
371: H$_2$ transitions at high redshift have been used \citep[e.g.,][]{Ivanchik05,Reinhold06,King08}
372: to probe the variability of~$\mu$.
373: %
374: This is done by measuring the relative position of the lines around the overall
375: redshift of the absorbing cloud,
376: \[
377: \zeta_i={(z_i-\overline{z}_{\rm abs})/(1+\overline{z}_{\rm abs})}={{\Delta \mu} \over \mu} K_i~ ,
378: \]
379: where $z_i=\lambda_i/\lambda_i^0-1$ is the observed redshift of line $i$ and
380: $K_i=d \ln \lambda_{i}^0/ d \ln \mu$ is the sensitivity on $\mu$ calculated for each transition.
381: $\overline{z}_{\rm abs}$ is taken for each component as the weighted mean redshift from the
382: different transitions.
383: %
384: As these measurements may involve various
385: unknown systematics, it is important to use different sets of lines
386: and different techniques. Sensitivity coefficients and accurate wavelengths for HD transitions
387: have been published very recently \citep{Ivanov08}.
388: However, the SNR of our data at the position of the HD absorption lines
389: prevents us to perform a measurement at the level of current studies.
390: Additional data on this quasar are needed to be able to derive an independent
391: constraint on the variability of $\mu$.
392:
393: \section{Conclusion}
394: We reported the detection of HD molecules at $z_{\rm abs}=2.418$ toward
395: SDSS\,J143912$+$111740, following a careful selection of quasars in the
396: SDSS database and intensive observations with UVES at the Very Large Telescope.
397: The system presents characteristics very similar to what is observed in the solar
398: neighbourhood. We find HD/2H$_2=1.5\times10^{-5}$, consistent with an astration factor
399: of deuterium less than 1.7 which is contrasting with the high chemical enrichment.
400: This is best explained by a scenario in which the gas that goes through star formation
401: is replenished by continuous infall of ambient primordial gas.
402: Similar results arise from recent numerical simulations
403: and semi-analytical models \citep[e.g.][]{Keres05,Erb08}.
404: Interestingly, dynamical studies of nearby galaxies \citep{Fraternali08} as
405: well as interpretation of Ly-$\alpha$ blobs at high redshift \citep{Weidinger05,Nilsson06,Dijkstra06}
406: provide independent observational evidences for accretion of gas onto massive galaxies.
407:
408: We finally stress the importance of detecting similar systems
409: to probe the time-variation of the proton-to-electron mass ratio from HD lines.
410: Although such a independent test would be welcome to characterize possible unknown systematics,
411: significantly higher signal-to-noise ratio is required to obtain limits comparable to those obtained
412: with other techniques.
413:
414: \acknowledgement{We thank an anonymous referee for comments and suggestions that
415: improved the quality of the paper.
416: We warmly thank the ESO Director Discretionary Time allocation committee
417: and the ESO Director General, Catherine Cesarsky, for allowing us to carry out these observations.
418: PPJ and RS gratefully acknowledge support from the Indo-French Centre for the Promotion of
419: Advanced Research (Centre Franco-Indien pour la Promotion de la Recherche Avanc\'ee).}
420:
421: \bibliographystyle{/scisoft/share/texmf/aa/aa-package/bibtex/aa}
422: \bibliography{hdbib}
423: \end{document}
424: