1: %%
2: %% modified on 26 September 2008 with some minor changes specific to ICHEP08
3: %%
4: %% ****** Start of file LA.tex ****** %
5: %%
6: %%
7: %% This file is part of the APS files in the REVTeX 4 distribution.
8: %% Version 4.0 of REVTeX, August 2001
9: %%
10: %%
11: %% Copyright (c) 2001 The American Physical Society.
12: %%
13: %% See the REVTeX 4 README file for restrictions and more information.
14: %%
15: %
16: % This is a template for producing manuscripts for use with REVTEX 4.0
17: % Copy this file to another name and then work on that file.
18: % That way, you always have this original template file to use.
19: %
20: \documentclass[slac_one]{revtex4}
21: \usepackage{graphicx}
22: \usepackage{fancyhdr}
23: \pagestyle{fancy}
24: %%
25: %% Please do not change the header and footer -- specific to ICHEP08
26: %%
27: \fancyhead{} % clear all fields
28: \fancyhead[LO]{34$^{\rm th}$ International Conference on High Energy
29: Physics, Philadelphia, 2008}
30: \fancyfoot{} % clear all fields
31: \fancyfoot[RO]{\thepage} % PSN not used for ICHEP08
32: %\fancyfoot[LE,LO]{Insert PSN Here} % PSN not used for ICHEP08
33: \renewcommand{\headrulewidth}{0pt}
34: \renewcommand{\footrulewidth}{0pt}
35: \renewcommand{\sfdefault}{phv}
36: \renewcommand{\baselinestretch}{1.2}
37: \setlength{\textheight}{235mm}
38: \setlength{\textwidth}{178mm}%{170mm}
39: \setlength{\topmargin}{-20mm}
40:
41: \begin{document}
42:
43: \newcommand{\dedx}{\mbox{${\rm d}E/{\rm d}x$}}
44:
45: %Title of paper
46: \title{Large-angle hadron production cross-sections for the neutrino
47: factory} %% Paper title goes here
48:
49: % Repeat the \author .. \affiliation etc. as needed
50: %
51: % \affiliation command applies to all authors since the last
52: % \affiliation command. The \affiliation command should follow the
53: % other information
54:
55: \author{I. Boyko (for the
56: HARP--CDP group\footnote{The members of the
57: HARP--CDP group are:
58: A.~Bolshakova,
59: I.~Boyko,
60: G.~Chelkov,
61: D.~Dedovitch,
62: A.~Elagin,
63: M.~Gostkin,
64: S.~Grishin,
65: A.~Guskov,
66: Z.~Kroumchtein,
67: Yu.~Nefedov,
68: K.~Nikolaev and
69: A.~Zhemchugov
70: from the Joint Institute for Nuclear Research,
71: Dubna, Russian Federation;
72: F.~Dydak and
73: J.~Wotschack
74: from CERN, Geneva, Switzerland;
75: A.~De~Min
76: from the Politecnico di Milano and INFN,
77: Sezione di Milano-Bicocca, Milan, Italy; and
78: V.~Ammosov,
79: V.~Gapienko,
80: V.~Koreshev,
81: A.~Semak,
82: Yu.~Sviridov,
83: E.~Usenko and
84: V.~Zaets
85: from the Institute of High Energy Physics, Protvino,
86: Russian Federation.}
87: )}
88: \affiliation{Joint Institute for Nuclear Research, Dubna,
89: Russian Federation}
90: %
91:
92: \begin{abstract}
93: Precise measurements of neutrino oscillation parameters
94: and of neutrino--nucleon cross-sections require a good
95: understanding of neutrino beams: flux as a function of
96: energy, transverse beam profile, and flavour composition.
97: For this, hadron production spectra in proton--nucleus
98: collisions are essential.
99: We report on double-differential inclusive large-angle cross-sections of
100: the production of secondary protons and charged pions, in the
101: interactions with a 5\% $\lambda_{\rm abs}$
102: thick stationary beryllium target, of proton and pion beams with
103: momentum from $\pm3$~GeV/{\it c} to $\pm15$~GeV/{\it c}.
104: Our results show
105: cross-sections reported by the `HARP Collaboration' to be
106: wrong by factors of up to two.
107: \end{abstract}
108:
109: %\maketitle must follow title, authors, abstract
110: \maketitle
111:
112: \thispagestyle{fancy}
113:
114: % body of paper here - Use proper section commands
115: % References should be done using the \cite, \ref, and \label commands
116: % Put \label in argument of \section for cross-referencing
117: %\section{\label{}}
118:
119: \section{INTRODUCTION} % Section title should be in all capitals.
120:
121: Precise cross-sections of secondary hadron production from the
122: interactions of protons and pions with nuclei are, {\it inter alia\/},
123: of importance for the understanding of the characteristics of
124: muons from the decay of pions that are produced by the proton
125: driver of a neutrino factory. Surprisingly,
126: inclusive differential cross-sections of hadron production
127: in the interactions of few GeV/{\it c} protons with nuclei are
128: known only within a factor of two to three. Consequently,
129: the HARP detector was designed to carry
130: out a programme of systematic and precise measurements of
131: hadron production by protons and pions with momenta from
132: 1.5 to 15~GeV/{\it c}.
133:
134: The detector combined a forward spectrometer with a
135: large-angle spectrometer. The latter comprised a
136: cylindrical Time Projection
137: Chamber (TPC) around the target and an array of
138: Resistive Plate Chambers (RPCs) that surrounded the
139: TPC. The purpose of the TPC was track
140: reconstruction and particle identification by \dedx . The
141: purpose of the RPCs was to complement the
142: particle identification by time of flight.
143:
144: The HARP experiment was performed at the CERN Proton Synchrotron
145: in 2001 and 2002 with a set of stationary targets ranging
146: from hydrogen to lead, including beryllium.
147:
148: We have measured~\cite{Beryllium1,Beryllium2} the inclusive
149: cross-sections of the large-angle production (polar angle $\theta$
150: in the range from 20 to 125$^\circ$)
151: of secondary protons and charged pions in
152: the interactions with a 5\% $\lambda_{\rm abs}$ beryllium target
153: of protons and pions with beam momenta of $\pm3.0$,
154: $\pm5.0$, $-8.0$, $+8.9$, $\pm12.0$, and $\pm15.0$~GeV/{\it c}.
155:
156: \section{DETECTOR CHARACTERISTICS AND PERFORMANCE}
157:
158: % tables should appear as floats within the text
159:
160: For the work reported here, only the HARP large-angle spectrometer
161: was used~\cite{TPCpub,RPCpub}. Its salient technical
162: characteristics are stated in Table~\ref{LAcharacteristics}. The
163: good particle identification
164: capability stemming from \dedx\ in the TPC and from time of flight
165: in the RPC's is demonstrated in Fig.~\ref{dedxandbeta}.
166: %
167: \begin{table}[ht]
168: \vspace*{2mm}
169: \begin{center}
170: \caption{Technical characteristics of the HARP large-angle spectrometer}
171: \begin{tabular}{|c|c|}
172: \hline
173: \textbf{TPC} & \textbf{RPCs} \\
174: \hline
175: \hline
176: $\sigma(1/p_{\rm T}) \sim 0.20-0.25$~(GeV/{\it c})$^{-1}$ &
177: Intrinsic efficiency $\sim 98$\% \\
178: $\sigma(\theta) \sim 9$~mrad & $\sigma$(TOF) $\sim 175$~ps \\
179: $\sigma({\rm d}E/{\rm d}x) / {\rm d}E{\rm d}x \sim 0.16$ & \\
180: \hline
181: \end{tabular}
182: \label{LAcharacteristics}
183: \end{center}
184: \end{table}
185: %
186: \begin{figure*}[h]
187: \begin{center}
188: \begin{tabular}{cc}
189: \includegraphics[height=0.3\textwidth]{dedx2.eps} &
190: \includegraphics[height=0.3\textwidth]{beta2.eps} \\
191: \end{tabular}
192: \end{center}
193: \caption{Specific ionization d$E$/d$x$ (left panel) and velocity $\beta$
194: (right panel) versus the charge-signed momentum of positive and
195: negative tracks
196: in $+8.9$~GeV/{\it c} data.}
197: \label{dedxandbeta}
198: \end{figure*}
199: %
200:
201: \section{INCLUSIVE CROSS-SECTIONS}
202:
203: Figure~\ref{xsvsmom} shows examples of inclusive cross-sections of
204: proton and $\pi^{\pm}$ production on beryllium nuclei. Double-differential
205: cross-sections with a typical precision of a few per cent are available
206: in tabular form in Refs.~\cite{Beryllium1,Beryllium2} for the polar-angle
207: range of 20 to 125$^\circ$ and for the $p_{\rm T}$ range
208: of 0.10 to 1.25~GeV/{\it c}.
209: %
210: \begin{figure*}[ht]
211: \begin{center}
212: \begin{tabular}{ccc}
213: \includegraphics[height=0.25\textheight]{xsvsmomplotprobe8.eps} &
214: \includegraphics[height=0.25\textheight]{xsvsmomplotpipbe8.eps} &
215: \includegraphics[height=0.25\textheight]{xsvsmomplotpimbe8.eps} \\
216: \end{tabular}
217: \caption{Inclusive cross-sections of the production of secondary
218: protons, $\pi^+$'s, and $\pi^-$'s, in the polar-angle range
219: 20 to 30$^\circ$, by protons (left panel),
220: $\pi^+$ (middle panel) and $\pi^-$ (right panel) with
221: beam momentum of $+8.9$~GeV/{\it c} on beryllium nuclei,
222: as a function of the charge-signed
223: $p_{\rm T}$ of the secondaries; the shown errors are total errors.}
224: \label{xsvsmom}
225: \end{center}
226: \end{figure*}
227:
228:
229: \section{COMPARISON WITH CROSS-SECTIONS FROM THE E802, E910, AND HARP
230: COLLABORATIONS}
231:
232: The left panel in Fig.~\ref{comparisonwithE802andE910andOH} shows
233: the Lorentz-invariant
234: cross-section of $\pi^+$ and $\pi^-$ production by
235: $+14.6$~GeV/{\it c} proton interactions with beryllium nuclei,
236: in the rapidity range $1.2 < y < 1.4$,
237: published by the E802
238: Collaboration~\cite{E802}. Their data are compared
239: with our cross-sections from the interactions of $+15.0$~GeV/{\it c}
240: protons, expressed in E802 units. We note good agreement.
241: %
242: \begin{figure*}[ht]
243: \begin{center}
244: \begin{tabular}{ccc}
245: \includegraphics[width=0.3\textwidth]{e802_15.eps} &
246: \includegraphics[width=0.3\textwidth]{e910_12-mod.eps} &
247: \includegraphics[width=0.3\textwidth]{cdpoh_12-mod.eps} \\
248: \end{tabular}
249: \caption{Left panel: comparison of our cross-sections (black dots)
250: of $\pi^\pm$ production by $+15.0$~GeV/{\it c}
251: protons off beryllium nuclei with the cross-sections
252: published by the E802 Collaboration for the proton beam
253: momentum of $+14.6$~GeV/{\it c} (open circles);
254: middle panel: comparison of our cross-sections (black dots)
255: of $\pi^\pm$ production by $+12.0$~GeV/{\it c}
256: protons off beryllium nuclei with the cross-sections
257: published by the E910 Collaboration for the proton beam
258: momentum of $+12.3$~GeV/{\it c} (open circles);
259: right panel: comparison of our cross-sections (black dots)
260: of $\pi^\pm$ production by $+12.0$~GeV/{\it c}
261: protons off beryllium nuclei with the cross-sections
262: published by the HARP Collaboration (open circles).}
263: \label{comparisonwithE802andE910andOH}
264: \end{center}
265: \end{figure*}
266: %
267:
268: The middle panel in Fig.~\ref{comparisonwithE802andE910andOH} shows the
269: cross-section ${\rm d}^2 \sigma / {\rm d}p {\rm d}\Omega$
270: of $\pi^\pm$ production by $+12.3$~GeV/{\it c} protons,
271: in the polar-angle range $0.8 < \cos\theta < 0.9$, published by
272: the E910 Collaboration~\cite{E910}. Their data are compared
273: with our cross-sections from the interactions of $+12.0$~GeV/{\it c}
274: protons, expressed in E910 units. We note reasonable agreement.
275:
276: The right panel of Fig.~\ref{comparisonwithE802andE910andOH} shows the
277: HARP Collaboration's cross-sections~\cite{OffLApaper}
278: of $\pi^\pm$ production by $+12.0$~GeV/{\it c}
279: protons off beryllium nuclei. Their data are compared
280: with our respective cross-sections, expressed in
281: the units used by the HARP Collaboration. We note striking
282: disagreement.
283:
284: As detailed in Ref.~\cite{JINSTpub} and in references cited
285: therein, the HARP Collaboration's
286: data analysis is affected by their
287: lack of understanding of TPC track distortions which
288: leads to (i) a bias of $\Delta (1/p_{\rm T})
289: \simeq 0.3$~(GeV/{\it c})$^{-1}$; (ii)
290: a resolution of $\sigma (1/p_{\rm T})
291: \simeq 0.6$~(GeV/{\it c})$^{-1}$ which is by a factor of two worse
292: than claimed by them; and (iii) a bad overall RPC time-of-flight
293: resolution of 305~ps and
294: an apparent advance of the timing signal of protons
295: with respect to that of pions by $\sim$500~ps
296: (`500~ps effect'). All this causes distorted momentum spectra of secondary
297: hadrons especially in regions where there is a
298: strong momentum dependence, and the misidentification of
299: protons as pions. The HARP Collaboration's pion
300: production cross-sections are fatally biased and
301: unsuitable for the design of a neutrino factory.
302:
303:
304: \begin{thebibliography}{9} % Use for 1-9 references
305: %\begin{thebibliography}{99} % Use for 10-99 references
306:
307: \bibitem{Beryllium1} A.~Bolshakova {\it et al.},
308: Cross-sections of large-angle hadron production
309: in proton-- and pion--nucleus interactions I:
310: beryllium nuclei and beam momenta of
311: $+8.9$~GeV/{\it c} and $-8.0$~GeV/{\it c},
312: {\it http://cern.ch/harp-cdp/Bepub.pdf},
313: to be submitted to Eur. Phys. J. C.
314:
315: \bibitem{Beryllium2} A.~Bolshakova {\it et al.},
316: Cross-sections of large-angle hadron production
317: in proton-- and pion--nucleus interactions II:
318: beryllium nuclei and beam momenta from $\pm3$~GeV/{\it c}
319: to $\pm15$~GeV/{\it c},
320: {\it http://cern.ch/harp-cdp/Bepub2.pdf},
321: to be submitted to Eur. Phys. J. C.
322:
323: \bibitem{TPCpub} V.~Ammosov {\it et al.},
324: Nucl. Instrum. Methods Phys. Res. {\bf A588} (2008) 294
325:
326: \bibitem{RPCpub} V.~Ammosov {\it et al.},
327: Nucl. Instrum. Methods Phys. Res. {\bf A578} (2007) 119
328:
329: \bibitem{E802} T.~Abbott {\it et al.},
330: Phys. Rev. {\bf D45} (1992) 3906
331:
332: \bibitem{E910} I.~Chemakin {\it et al.},
333: Phys. Rev. {\bf C65} (2002) 024904
334:
335: \bibitem{OffLApaper} M.G.~Catanesi {\it et al.},
336: Phys. Rev. {\bf C77} (2008) 055207
337:
338: \bibitem{JINSTpub} V.~Ammosov {\it et al.},
339: J. Instrum. {\bf 3} (2008) P01002
340:
341: \end{thebibliography}
342:
343:
344: \end{document}
345:
346: