0810.2029/ms.tex
1: %%
2: %% This is file `template-6s.tex',
3: %%
4: 
5: %\input{aipcheck}
6: 
7: \documentclass[
8:     ,final            % use final for the camera ready runs
9: %%  ,draft            % use draft while you are working on the paper
10: %%  ,numberedheadings % uncomment this option for numbered sections
11: %%  ,                 % add further options here if necessary
12:   ]
13:   {aipproc}
14: 
15: \layoutstyle{6x9}
16: 
17: 
18: \begin{document}
19: 
20: \title{Stars and brown dwarfs, spatial distribution, multiplicity, X-rays,
21: discs, and the complete mass function of the $\sigma$~Orionis cluster}
22: % Reference: N3
23: 
24: \classification{95.80.+p; 97.10.Xq; 97.10.Yp; 97.21.+a; 97.82.Jw; 98.20.Di}
25: \keywords      {astronomical data bases: miscellaneous; 
26: stars: luminosity function, mass function; 
27: stars: pre-main sequence;
28: stars: low mass, brown dwarfs; 
29: stars: binaries: visual;
30: Galaxy: open clusters and associations: individual: $\sigma$~Orionis}
31: 
32: \author{Jos\'e A. Caballero}{address={Departamento de Astrof\'{\i}sica y
33: Ciencias de la Atm\'osfera, Facultad de F\'{\i}sica, Universidad Complutense de
34: Madrid, E-28040 Madrid, Spain},email={caballero@astrax.fis.ucm.es}} 
35: 
36: \begin{abstract}
37: The young $\sigma$~Orionis cluster in the Orion Belt is an incomparable site for
38: studying the formation and evolution of high-mass, solar-like, and low-mass
39: stars, brown dwarfs, and substellar objects below the deuterium burning mass
40: limit. 
41: The first version of the Mayrit catalogue was a thorough data compilation of
42: cluster members and candidates, which is regularly used by many authors of
43: different disciplines. 
44: I show two new applications of the catalogue and advance preliminar results on
45: very wide binarity and the initial mass function from 18 to 0.035\,$M_\odot$ in
46: $\sigma$~Orionis. 
47: The making-up of a new version of the Mayrit catalogue with additional useful
48: data is in progress.
49: \end{abstract}
50: 
51: \maketitle
52: 
53: 
54: \section{The {\em Mayrit} catalogue}
55: 
56: The constellation of Orion has pulled in the attention of astronomers and
57: sky-watchers since the ancient times: 
58: it was mentioned in the Bible, Homer's Odyssey and Virgil's Aeneid, has been
59: widely used in celestial navigation, and represented important characters,
60: deities, or tools in mythologies all over the world (it was the Babylonian
61: Shepherd of Anu, the Finnish V\"ain\"am\"oinen, and the Julpan, a canoe of the
62: Australian aborigines).
63: Within the constellation, the prominent Orion Belt, formed by {Alnitak}
64: ($\zeta$~Ori), {Alnilam} ($\epsilon$~Ori), and {Mintaka} ($\delta$~Ori), is
65: perhaps the most famous asterism in the sky.  
66: Thought to be mapped in the Giza pyramid complex by the ancient Egyptians, the
67: Orion Belt has also been of great significance in other cultures: it was the
68: Scandinavian Freyja's distaff, the Iberian Tres Mar\'{\i}as, the
69: Northern-European Three Kings, and the Chinese lunar mansion Shen (literally
70: ``three'' in Chinese). 
71: %It appears in Hollywood films ({\em Men in Black}: 
72: %``To prevent war, the Galaxy is on Orion's belt'').  
73: 
74: The fourth brightest star in the Orion Belt, about 2\,mag fainter than the three
75: main stars, is {$\sigma$~Ori}. 
76: The star, which is actually the hierarchical multiple Trapezium-like stellar
77: system that illuminates the famous {Horsehead Nebula}, has taken a great
78: importance in the last decade. 
79: Its significance lies in the very early spectral type of the hottest component
80: ($\sigma$~Ori~A, O9.5V) and in the homonymous star cluster that surrounds the
81: system (Garrison 1967).  
82: The $\sigma$~Orionis star cluster, re-discovered due to its large number of
83: X-ray emitters (Wolk 1996), contains one of the best known
84: brown dwarf and planetary-mass object populations (B\'ejar et~al. 1999; Zapatero
85: Osorio et~al. 2000; Caballero et~al. 2007), and is an excellent laboratory
86: to study the evolution of discs and angular momenta (Reipurth et~al. 1998;
87: Caballero et~al. 2004; Scholz \& Eisl\"offel 2004; Oliveira et~al. 2006;
88: Hern\'andez et~al. 2007).
89: Approximate canonical ages, heliocentric distances and visual extinctions are
90: $\tau \sim$ 3\,Ma, $d \sim$ 385\,pc and $A_V \sim$ 0.3\,mag.
91: 
92: The knowledge of the whole stellar and substellar populations in a cluster in
93: general, and in $\sigma$~Orionis in particular, has serious implications on the
94: accuracy of the determination of some important parameters, such asthe slope of
95: the initial mass function, frequency of discs, and degree of radial
96: concentration.
97: These observational parameters are, in their turn, fundamental for the
98: theoretical scenarios that predict the formation of stars, brown dwarfs, and
99: planets.
100: The Mayrit catalogue of stars and brown dwarfs in the $\sigma$~Orionis cluster,
101: built by Caballero (2008b), was an effort to compile key data on confirmed and
102: candidate cluster members. 
103: The basis of that work was an optical-near infrared correlation between the
104: 2MASS and DENIS catalogues in a circular area of radius 30\,arcmin contred on
105: the $\sigma$~Ori stellar system.
106: The analysis was supported by an exhaustive bibliographic search of confirmed
107: cluster members with signposts of youth and by additional X-ray, mid-infrared,
108: and astrometric data.
109: 
110: 
111: \section{\em Mayrit reloaded}
112: 
113: \begin{figure}
114: %\centering
115: \includegraphics[width=0.55\textwidth]{caballero_f1a.eps}
116: \includegraphics[width=0.55\textwidth]{caballero_f1b.eps}
117: \caption{{\em Left:} 
118: separation to the nearest Mayrit neighbour as a function of the angular
119: separation to the $\sigma$~Orionis centre.
120: The segmented curves denote probabilities of alignment by chance of 5 (top)
121: and 1\,\% (bottom). 
122: {\em Right:} 
123: mass function in the $\sigma$~Orionis cluster from 18 to 0.035\,$M_\odot$ using
124: the Mayrit catalogue.
125: {\em Top window:} cumulative number of stars and brown dwarfs per mass
126: interval.
127: The vertical dashed line line denotes the stellar/substellar boundary.
128: {\em Bottom window:} mass spectrum.
129: The diagonal dash-dotted lines indicate the slopes corresponding to $\alpha$ =
130: +2.35 (at high masses) and $\alpha$ = +0.3 (at low~masses).
131: }
132: \label{thefigure}
133: \end{figure}
134: 
135: The Mayrit catalogue has turned out to be a very useful tool for studying the
136: spatial and radial velocity distributions (Caballero 2008a, 2008c; Bouy et~al.
137: 2008), disc frequency as a function of stellar mass (Luhman et~al. 2008), and
138: X-ray emission in the $\sigma$~Orionis cluster (L\'opez-Santiago \& Caballero
139: 2008; E.~Franciosoni et~al., in~prep.).
140: In this proceeding, I advance some preliminar results on two new specific
141: topics: very wide binarity and initial mass function. 
142: 
143: \paragraph{Very wide binaries} 
144: I~have searched for very wide ($\Delta >$ 1000\,AU) systems among the Mayrit
145: cluster members and candidates following a simple statistical approach.
146: The method is based on the study of the variation of the separation to the
147: nearest neighbour, $\rho_{\rm min}$, with the separation to the cluster centre,
148: $r$ (left window of Fig.~\ref{thefigure}).  
149: The shorter the $\rho_{\rm min}$ between two objects is, the larger the
150: probability to be bound is.
151: However, a pair of cluster members can be separated by a short angular
152: separation but be located at different heliocentric distances due to a
153: projection effect.
154: I~have estimated the values of $\rho_{\rm min}$ that correspond to
155: probabilities of random alignments of 5 and 1\,\% for a configuration with the
156: same (symmetrical) radial profile as $\sigma$~Orionis. 
157: For that, I~have used 1000 Monte Carlo simulated distributions following the
158: power-law radial distribution quantified in Caballero (2008a), that corresponds
159: to a volume density proportional to $r^{-2}$.
160: Three $\sigma$~Orionis pairs of objects, listed in Table~\ref{thetable}, have
161: probabilities of random alignment of $\sim$1\,\%.
162: Interestingly, two of the ``pairs'' are actually hierarchical triple
163: system candidates.
164: Projected physical separations, of $\Delta \approx$ 2700--5100\,AU, are not rare
165: in the solar neighbourhood. 
166: Compare these values with $\Delta = 1700 \pm 300$\,AU, % ($\rho \approx$ 4.6\,arcsec), 
167: which is the separation between the $\sigma$~Orionis X-ray brown
168: dwarf {[SE2004]~70} and the L5$\pm$2-type, planetary-mass, object candidate
169: {S\,Ori~68} (Caballero et~al.~2006). 
170: 
171: \begin{table}
172: \begin{tabular}{lrr rrr rr}
173: \hline
174: 	\tablehead{1}{r}{b}{Binary\\system}  		& 
175: 	\tablehead{1}{r}{b}{Primary\\Mayrit}  		& 
176: 	\tablehead{1}{r}{b}{Secondary\\Mayrit}  	&	 
177: 	\tablehead{1}{r}{b}{$\rho$\\(arcsec)} 		& 
178: 	\tablehead{1}{r}{b}{$\theta$\\(deg)}  		& 
179: 	\tablehead{1}{r}{b}{$\Delta$\\(AU)}  		& 
180: 	\tablehead{1}{r}{b}{$M_1$\\($M_\odot$)}  	& 
181: 	\tablehead{1}{r}{b}{$M_2$\\($M_\odot$)}   	\\
182: \hline
183: 1\tablenote{AB: [W96] 4771--899 AB, C: S\,Ori J053847.5--022711 (first proposed
184: 	by Caballero 2005).
185: 	The primary is a close binary ($\rho = 0.40 \pm 0.08$\,arcsec) resolved
186: 	by Caballero (2005).
187: 	}	& 
188: 	528005~AB	& 530005	& 7.63$\pm$0.10	    	& 287.1$\pm$0.8	& 2700	& 1.6+?	& 0.61	  \\ % Ca05   10.156,12.143 Ca05 Mayrit  528005  & + 530005	 
189: 2\tablenote{AB: OriNTT 429 AB, C: [SWW2004] 22 (first proposed here).
190: 	The primary is a spectroscopic binary discovered by Lee et~al. (1994).}	& 
191: 	1415279~AB	& 1416280 	& 12.18$\pm$0.10	& 4.4$\pm$0.5	& 4400 	& 1.3+?	& 0.24	  \\ %        10.876,13.487 2M   Mayrit 1415279  & + 1416280	 
192: 3\tablenote{A: V507 Ori, B: S\,Ori 7 (first proposed by Caballero 2006).
193: 	} 	& 
194: 	397060		& 410059 	& 14.12$\pm$0.10	& 40.4$\pm$0.5	& 5100 	& 1.1	& 0.19	  \\ % Ca06   11.298,13.798 2M   Mayrit  397060  & + 410059	 
195: \hline
196: \end{tabular}
197: \caption{Visual systems in $\sigma$~Orionis with probability of alignment by
198: chance of $\sim$1\,\%} 
199: \label{thetable}
200: \end{table}
201: 
202: 
203: \paragraph{Initial mass function}
204: B\'ejar et~al. (2001), Tej et~al. (2002), Gonz\'alez-Garc\'{\i}a et~al. (2006), 
205: Caballero (2007), and Caballero et~al. (2007) have determined the slope of the
206: mass spectrum ($\Delta N / \Delta M \approx a M^{-\alpha}$) at different mass
207: intervals in $\sigma$~Orionis.
208: In right window of Fig.~\ref{thefigure}, I display the cluster (initial) mass
209: function in the interval 18--0.035\,$M_\odot$.
210: Individual masses were derived from the $J$-band magnitudes tabulated in the
211: Mayrit catalogue and using the 3\,Ma-old theoretical isochrones of Schaller
212: et~al. (1992), Baraffe et~al. (1998), and Chabrier et~al. (2000) depending on
213: the corresponding effective temperature.
214: The majority of the investigated stars have masses between 0.12 and
215: 1.9\,$M_\odot$.
216: While the slope $\alpha$ of the mass spectrum in the range 18--0.7\,$M_\odot$
217: follows the Salpeter value ($\alpha \approx$ +2.35), it smoothly decreases down
218: to $\alpha \approx$ +0.3 in the mass range 0.3--0.035\,$M_\odot$. 
219: The transition between both slope domains is not abrupt at all, and occurs at
220: $M \sim$ 0.4--0.6\,$M_\odot$.
221: A careful derivation of the $\sigma$~Orionis initial mass function in the
222: interval $18 \le M/M_{\odot} \le 0.025$, acounting for a precise heliocentric
223: distance, incompleteness of the Mayrit catalogue, and decontamination by
224: late-type field dwarfs, neighbouring young stellar populations, and red quasars,
225: is ongoing. 
226: 
227: 
228: \section{\em Mayrit revolutions}
229: 
230: I~have used the first version of the Mayrit catalogue in Caballero (2008b) as a
231: basis to create an updated version, Mayrit~2.0, which will be published in a
232: forthcoming paper. 
233: I have incorporated the latest spectroscopic results from Gatti et~al. (2008),
234: Sacco et~al. (2008), Maxted et~al. (2008), Gonz\'alez-Hern\'andez et~al. (2008),
235: and Caballero et~al.~(2008).  
236: The new catalogue contains UKIDSS $YZJHK$ magnitudes, radial velocities, and
237: lithium equivalent widths for about 350 $\sigma$~Orionis members and candidates.
238: 
239: 
240: \begin{theacknowledgments}
241: %I~thank E.~Stempels for editing this contribution.
242: Partial financial support was provided by the Spanish Ministerio Educaci\'on y
243: Ciencia, the Comunidad Aut\'onoma de Madrid, the Universidad Complutense de
244: Madrid, the Spanish Virtual Observatory, and the European Social Fund.  
245: %Partial financial support was provided by the Spanish Ministerio Educaci\'on y
246: %Ciencia, the Comunidad Aut\'onoma de Madrid, the Universidad Complutense de
247: %Madrid, the Spanish Virtual Observatory and the European Social Fund under
248: %grants AyA2005--02750, AyA2005--04286, AyA2005--24102--E, AyA2007--67458 and
249: %S--0505/ESP--0237.  
250: JAC is an {\em Investigador Juan de la Cierva} at the~UCM.
251: \end{theacknowledgments}
252: 
253: 
254: \begin{thebibliography}{9}
255: 
256: \bibitem{Ba98}
257: I. Baraffe, G. Chabrier, F. Allard and P.~H. Hauschildt, 
258: \emph{A\&A} \textbf{337}, 403 (1998). 
259: 
260: \bibitem{Be99}
261: V.~J.~S. B\'ejar, M.~R. Zapatero Osorio and R. Rebolo, 
262: \emph{ApJ} \textbf{521}, 671 (1999). 
263: 
264: \bibitem{Be01}
265: V.~J.~S. B\'ejar, E.~L. Mart\'{\i}n, M.~R. Zapatero Osorio et~al., 
266: \emph{ApJ} \textbf{556}, 830 (2001). 
267: 
268: \bibitem{Bo08}
269: H. Bouy, N. Hu\'elamo, E.~L. Mart\'{\i}n et~al., 
270: \emph{A\&A} in~press, arXiv:0808.3890 (2008).
271: 
272: \bibitem{Ca05}
273: J.~A. Caballero, 
274: \emph{AN} \textbf{326}, 1007 (2005).
275: 
276: \bibitem{Ca06}
277: J.~A. Caballero, 
278: PhD thesis, Universidad de La Laguna, Tenerife, Spain (2006).
279: 
280: \bibitem{Ca07a}
281: J.~A. Caballero, 
282: \emph{A\&A} \textbf{466}, 917 (2007).
283: 
284: %\bibitem{Ca07b}
285: %J.~A. Caballero, 
286: %\emph{AN} \textbf{328}, 917 (2007b).
287: 
288: \bibitem{Ca08a}
289: J.~A. Caballero, 
290: \emph{MNRAS} \textbf{383}, 375 (2008a).
291: 
292: %\bibitem{Ca08b}
293: %J.~A. Caballero, 
294: %\emph{MNRAS} \textbf{383}, 750 (2008a).
295: 
296: \bibitem{Ca08c}
297: J.~A. Caballero, 
298: \emph{A\&A} \textbf{478}, 667 (2008b).
299: 
300: \bibitem{Ca08d}
301: J.~A. Caballero, 
302: \emph{MNRAS}, submitted (2008c).
303: 
304: \bibitem{Ca04}
305: J.~A. Caballero, V.~J.~S. B\'ejar, R.~Rebolo and M.~R. Zapatero Osorio, 
306: \emph{A\&A} \textbf{424}, 857 (2004).
307: 
308: \bibitem{Ca06b}
309: J.~A. Caballero, E.~L. Mart\'{\i}n, P.~D. Dobbie and D. Barrado y Navascu\'es, 
310: \emph{A\&A} \textbf{460}, 635 (2006).
311: 
312: \bibitem{Ca07}
313: J.~A. Caballero, V.~J.~S. B\'ejar, R.~Rebolo et~al., 
314: \emph{A\&A} \textbf{470}, 903 (2007).
315: 
316: \bibitem{Ca08}
317: J.~A. Caballero, L. Valdivielso, E.~L. Mart\'{\i}n et~al., 
318: \emph{A\&A} in~press, arXiv:0809.0996 (2008).
319: 
320: \bibitem{Ch00}
321: G. Chabrier,I. Baraffe,  F. Allard and P.~H. Hauschildt, 
322: \emph{ApJ} \textbf{542}, 464 (2000). 
323: 
324: \bibitem{Ga67}
325: R.~F. Garrison, 
326: \emph{PASP}, \textbf{79}, 433 (1967).
327: 
328: \bibitem{GG06}
329: B.~M. Gonz\'alez-Garc\'{\i}a, M.~R. Zapatero Osorio, V.~J.~S. B\'ejar, 
330: \emph{A\&A}, \textbf{460}, 799 (2006).
331: 
332: \bibitem{Ga08}
333: T. Gatti, A. Natta, S. Randich, L. Testi and G. Sacco, 
334: \emph{A\&A} \textbf{481}, 423 (2008). 
335: 
336: \bibitem{GH08}
337: J.~I. Gonz\'alez Hern\'andez, J.~A. Caballero, R. Rebolo et~al., 
338: \emph{A\&A} in~press, arXiv:0809.0090 (2008).
339: 
340: \bibitem{He07}
341: J. Hern\'andez, L. Hartmann, T. Megeath et~al., 
342: \emph{ApJ} \textbf{662}, 1067 (2007). 
343: 
344: \bibitem{LSC08}
345: J. L\'opez-Santiago and J.~A. Caballero, 
346: \emph{A\&A} in~press, arXiv:0809.0990 (2008).
347: 
348: \bibitem{Lu08}
349: K.~L. Luhman, J. Hern\'andez, J.~J. Downes et~al., 
350: \emph{ApJ} in~press, arXiv:0808.0471 (2008).
351: %
352: %\bibitem{Lu08}
353: %K.~L. Luhman, J. Hern\'andez, J.~J. Downes, L. Hartmann and C. Brice\~no, 
354: %\emph{ApJ} in~press, arXiv:0808.0471 (2008).
355: 
356: \bibitem{Ma08}
357: P.~F.~L. Maxted, R.~D. Jeffries, J.~M. Oliveira, T. Naylor and R.~J. Jackson,
358: \emph{MNRAS} \textbf{385}, 2210 (2008). 
359: 
360: \bibitem{MN08}
361: N.~J. Mayne and T. Naylor, 
362: \emph{MNRAS} \textbf{386}, 261 (2008). 
363: 
364: \bibitem{Ol06}
365: J.~M. Oliveira, R.~D. Jeffries, J.~Th. van~Loon and M.~T. Rushton, 
366: \emph{MNRAS} \textbf{369}, 272 (2006). 
367: 
368: \bibitem{Sa08}
369: G.~G. Sacco, E. Franciosini, S. Randich and R. Pallavicini, 
370: \emph{A\&A} \textbf{488}, 167 (2008). 
371: 
372: \bibitem{Sc92}
373: G. Schaller, D. Schaerer, G. Meynet and A. Maeder, 
374: \emph{A\&AS} \textbf{96}, 269 (1992). 
375: 
376: \bibitem{SE04}
377: A. Scholz and J. Eisl\"offel, 
378: \emph{A\&A} \textbf{419}, 249 (2004). 
379: 
380: \bibitem{Sh08}
381: W.~H. Sherry, F.~M. Walter, S.~J. Wolk and N.~R. Adams, 
382: \emph{AJ} \textbf{135}, 1616 (2008). 
383: 
384: \bibitem{Tej02}
385: A. Tej, K.~C. Sahu, T. Chandrasekhar and  N.~M. Ashok, 
386: \emph{ApJ} \textbf{578}, 523 (2002). 
387: 
388: \bibitem{Wo96}
389: S.~J.~Wolk, PhD thesis, State University New York at Stony Brook, NY, USA
390: (1996). 
391: 
392: \bibitem{ZO00}
393: M.~R. Zapatero Osorio, V.~J.~S. B\'ejar, E.~L. Mart\'{\i}n et~al.,
394: \emph{Science} \textbf{290}, 103 (2000). 
395: 
396: \end{thebibliography}
397: 
398: \end{document}
399: %%
400: %% End of file `template-6s.tex'.
401: 
402: