1: %%
2: %% This is file `template-6s.tex',
3: %% generated with the docstrip utility.
4: %%
5: %% The original source files were:
6: %%
7: %% template.raw (with options: `6s')
8: %%
9: %% Template for the LaTeX class aipproc.
10: %%
11: %% (C) 1998,2000,2001 American Institute of Physics and Frank Mittelbach
12: %% All rights reserved
13: %%
14: %%
15: %% $Id: template.raw,v 1.12 2005/07/06 19:22:14 frank Exp $
16: %%
17:
18: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
19: %% Please remove the next line of code if you
20: %% are satisfied that your installation is
21: %% complete and working.
22: %%
23: %% It is only there to help you in detecting
24: %% potential problems.
25: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
26:
27: % \input{aipcheck}
28:
29: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
30: %% SELECT THE LAYOUT
31: %%
32: %% The class supports further options.
33: %% See aipguide.pdf for details.
34: %%
35: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
36:
37: \documentclass[
38: ,final % use final for the camera ready runs
39: %% ,draft % use draft while you are working on the paper
40: %% ,numberedheadings % uncomment this option for numbered sections
41: %% , % add further options here if necessary
42: ]
43: {aipproc}
44:
45: \layoutstyle{6x9}
46:
47: \usepackage{natbib}
48: \usepackage{graphics}
49: \usepackage{epsfig}
50: \usepackage{amssymb}
51: \usepackage{graphicx}
52:
53: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
54: %% FRONTMATTER
55: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
56:
57: \begin{document}
58:
59: \title{Young Cool Stars Divided on the Issue of Rotation}
60:
61: \classification{97.10.Kc}
62: \keywords {Stars: late-type, rotation}
63:
64: \author{S{\o}ren Meibom}{
65: address={Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics, 60 Garden Street, Cambridge, MA, 02138}
66: }
67:
68: % \author{<author2>}{
69: % address={<common address for author2 and author3>}
70: % }
71:
72: % \author{<author3>}{
73: % address={<common address for author2 and author3>}
74: % ,altaddress={<author1 address>} % additional visiting address
75: % }
76:
77:
78: \begin{abstract}
79:
80: We present the results of a combination of new stellar rotation periods
81: and extensive information about membership in the young open clusters
82: M\,35 and M\,34. The observations show that late-type members of both
83: M\,35 and M\,34 divide into two distinct groups, each with a different
84: dependence of rotation on mass (color). We discuss these new results in
85: the context of existing rotation data for cool stars in older clusters,
86: with a focus on the dependence of rotation on mass and age. We mention
87: briefly tests of rotation as an ``astronomical clock'' (gyrochronology),
88: and our plans to use the Kepler space mission to push observations of
89: stellar rotation periods beyond the age of the Hyades and the Sun.
90:
91: \end{abstract}
92:
93: \maketitle
94:
95: % ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
96:
97: \section{Introduction}
98:
99: Understanding the evolution of stellar rotation is an integral part of
100: understanding stellar evolution. Clusters of stars allow us to probe
101: their rotational evolution as a function of their most fundamental
102: properties - mass and age. For cool stars (here: $0.5 < M_{\odot} < 1.25$)
103: in young open clusters, rotational periods can be measured to very
104: high precision. Combined with cluster membership information, such
105: observations now reveal clear relations between stellar rotation,
106: age, and mass.
107:
108: Early observations of cool stars in open clusters younger than the
109: Hyades discovered that they rotate with periods ranging over two orders
110: of magnitude - from near breakup to periods similar to the Sun
111: \citep[see e.g.][and references therein]{va82,sh87,ssm+93}. This early
112: information was primarily from spectroscopic observations giving
113: projected rotational velocities ($v\sin i$), affected by the $\sin i$
114: ambiguity and the need to determine the stellar radius to derive
115: the angular rotation velocity. Despite these ambiguities, some structure
116: in the distribution of $v\sin i$ with stellar color was noted, as was
117: an emerging time- and mass-dependence for the presence of ultra fast
118: rotators (UFR). UFR were primarily found among the K and M dwarfs in
119: $\alpha$ Persei and the Pleiades, while lacking altogether in the older
120: Hyades cluster. These observations prompted ideas about the processes
121: in cool stars responsible for their rotational evolution, such as
122: the suggestion of epochs of decoupling and recoupling of the stellar
123: core and envelope \citep{shs+84,ssm+93}.
124:
125: Recently, from a study of rotational period data for several young open
126: clusters, Barnes (2003) \cite[][hereinafter B03]{barnes03a} proposed
127: that stars fall along two ``rotational sequences'' in the color vs.
128: period plane. From an analysis of these sequences and their dependencies
129: on stellar age, B03 proposed a framework for connecting internal and external
130: magneto-hydrodynamic processes to explain the evolution in the observed
131: period distributions. This approach combines the ideas of initial
132: decoupling of the stellar core and envelope, with re-connection of
133: the two zones through a global dynamo-field at a later and mass-dependent
134: time. B03 also proposed that the evolution of the rotational sequences
135: in the color-period diagram, could be used to measure the age of a stellar
136: population, much like the sequences in the color-magnitude diagram.
137: A similar idea had been proposed by \citet{kawaler89}. \citet{barnes07}
138: further developed this idea of ``gyrochronology''.
139:
140: Interpretation aside, it is desirable and increasingly possible to
141: eliminate the ambiguities of $v\sin i$ data by measuring rotational
142: periods from light modulation by star-spots. It has also become more
143: feasible to carry out comprehensive surveys for kinematic membership
144: in star clusters. Combining the two reveals new details about dependencies
145: of rotation on the most fundamental stellar properties - mass and age.
146:
147: \begin{figure}
148: \includegraphics[height=.35\textheight]{f1a.eps}
149: \includegraphics[height=.35\textheight]{f1b.eps}
150: \caption{The distribution of stellar rotation periods with (B-V)
151: color index for 310 members of M\,35 ({\it left}; \citep{mms08}) and
152: 79 members of M\,34 ({\it right}). Dark blue plotting symbols are used
153: for radial-velocity members and light blue for photometric members.}
154: \label{m3534pbv}
155: \end{figure}
156:
157: % ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
158:
159: \section{New observations of two young clusters}
160:
161: We carried out photometric monitoring campaigns over 5 consecutive months
162: for rotational periods, and nearly decade-long radial-velocity surveys for
163: cluster membership and binarity, on the 150\,Myr and 200\,Myr open clusters
164: M\,35 and M\,34. For full descriptions of the observations, data-reduction,
165: and data-analysis, see \citet{mm05,mms06,mms08}, and \citet{bmm08}.
166:
167: {\it Time-Series Photometric Observations}:
168: We surveyed, over a timespan of 143 days, a region of $40 \times 40$ arc
169: minutes centered on each cluster. Images were acquired at a frequency of
170: once a night both before and after a central block of 16 full nights with
171: observations at a frequency of once per hour. The data were obtained in
172: the Johnson V band with the WIYN 0.9m telescope on Kitt Peak. Instrumental
173: magnitudes were determined from Point Spread Function photometry. Light
174: curves were produced for more than 14,000 stars with $12 < V < 19.5$.
175: Rotational periods were determined for 441 and 120 stars in the fields
176: of M\,35 and M\,34, respectively (see Figure~\ref{m3534pbv}).
177:
178: {\it The spectroscopic surveys}:
179: M\,35 and M\,34 have been included in the WIYN Open Cluster Study
180: (WOCS; \citet{mathieu00}) since 1997 and 2001. As part of WOCS, 1-3
181: radial-velocity measurements per year were obtained on both clusters
182: within the 1-degree field of the WIYN 3.5m telescope with the multi-object
183: fiber positioner (Hydra) feeding a bench mounted echelle spectrograph.
184: Observations were done at central wavelengths of 5130\AA\ or 6385\AA\
185: with a wavelength range of $\sim$200\AA\ . From this spectral region with
186: many narrow absorption lines, radial velocities were determined with a
187: precision of $< 0.4~$km/s \citep{gmh+08,mbd+01}. Of the stars
188: with measured rotational periods in M\,35 and M\,34, 203 and 56, respectively,
189: are radial-velocity members of the clusters (dark blue symbols in
190: Figure~\ref{m3534pbv}). Including photometric members (light blue
191: symbols in Figure~\ref{m3534pbv}), the total number of stars with
192: measured rotational periods in M\,35 and M\,34, are 310 and 79, respectively.
193:
194: % ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
195:
196: \section{The color-period diagram}
197:
198: Figure~\ref{m3534pbv} shows the rotational periods in M\,35 and M\,34
199: plotted against $B-V$ color. The coeval stars fall along two well-defined
200: sequences representing two different rotational states. One sequence
201: displays a clear correlation between period and color, and forms a
202: diagonal band of stars whose periods are increasing with increasing
203: color index (decreasing mass). The second sequence consists of UFR
204: and shows little mass dependence. Finally, a small subset of stars is
205: distributed between the two sequences. The distribution of stars in
206: the color-period diagrams suggests that the rotational evolution is
207: slow where we see the sequences, and fast in the gap between them,
208: while other areas of the color-period plane are either unlikely or
209: ``forbidden''.
210:
211: \begin{figure}
212: \includegraphics[height=.35\textheight]{f2a.eps}
213: \includegraphics[height=.35\textheight]{f2b.eps}
214: \vspace{36pt}
215: \caption{{\it Left}: The color-period diagrams for clusters M\,35
216: (150\,Myr; top), NGC\,3532 (300\,Myr; center), and M37 (550\,Myr; bottom).
217: {\it Right}: Figure 3 from B03 with M\,35 and M\,34 added. The figure shows
218: the fractions of stars with $0.5 \le (B-V)_0 \le 1.5$ on the I sequence
219: (circles), the C sequence (stars), and C sequence and gap stars (squares),
220: for clusters of different ages.}
221: \label{3pbv}
222: \end{figure}
223:
224: While much more apparent in M\,35 and M\,34, and in the study by
225: \citet{hgp+08} of the 550\,Myr cluster M37 (see below), the sequences
226: seen in Figure~\ref{m3534pbv} are the same as identified by B03.
227: B03 named the diagonal sequence the {\it interface} (I) sequence,
228: and the sequence of UFR the {\it convective} (C) sequence. Barnes
229: argues that stars on the C sequence have decoupled radiative cores
230: and convective envelopes, and suggests that the evolution of their
231: surface rotation is governed primarily by the moment of inertia
232: of the envelope and by inefficient loss of angular momentum linked
233: to small-scale convective magnetic fields. For stars on the I sequence,
234: B03 suggests that large-scale (sun-like) magnetic fields, produced
235: by an interface dynamo, provide more efficient Skumanich-style
236: angular momentum loss. B03 suggests that a late-type star evolves
237: from the C sequence and onto the I sequence when rotational shear
238: between the stellar core and envelope establish a large-scale dynamo
239: field. This happens sooner in higher mass stars as they have thinner
240: convective envelopes with smaller moments of inertia.
241:
242:
243: \subsubsection{The evolving color-period diagram: timescales, and
244: mass-dependence}
245:
246: Color-period diagrams for clusters of different ages allow us to
247: study the rotation of cool stars as a function of mass and age.
248: In Figure~\ref{3pbv} (left) we show the color-period diagrams for
249: M\,35 (150\,Myr), NGC\,3532 (B03; 300\,Myr), and M37 (550\,Myr).
250: This diagram reveals both stellar spin-down on the I sequence and
251: a mass-dependence of the timescale for ``migration'' from the C
252: to the I sequence. At 150\,Myr (M\,35) G dwarfs have evolved onto
253: the I sequence, by 300\,Myr (NGC\,3532) the early K dwarfs have
254: followed, and by 550\,Myr (M\,37) most of the late K dwarfs are
255: on the I sequence as well. In Figure~\ref{3pbv} (right), we add
256: M\,35 and M\,34 to Fig. 3 in B03 which shows the fractions of cluster
257: stars on the I and C sequences as a function of their ages. M\,35
258: and M\,34 fit well the evolutionary trends of a decreasing fraction
259: of C sequence (and gap) stars and an increasing fraction of I sequence
260: stars with age. The almost linear trends suggest an exponential change
261: in time of the number of stars on the sequences. By counting stars
262: on both sequences and in the gap in the M\,35 color-period diagram,
263: and making the assumption that all stars start on the C sequence at
264: the ZAMS, we estimate the characteristic timescale for the rotational
265: evolution of stars off the C sequence and onto the I sequence. We
266: derive $\tau_c^G = 60$ Myr and $\tau_c^K = 140$ Myr for G and K dwarfs,
267: respectively. Such timescales may offer valuable constraints on the
268: evolution of stellar dynamos and internal and external angular momentum
269: transport.
270:
271: \begin{figure}
272: \includegraphics[height=.35\textheight]{f3a.eps}
273: \includegraphics[height=.35\textheight]{f3b.eps}
274: \caption{The M\,35 ({\it left}) and M\,34 ({\it right}) color-period
275: diagrams with 25 Hyades stars overplotted (red symbols). In both plots,
276: the Hyades rotation periods were spun-up by factors of $\sqrt{625/150}$
277: and $\sqrt{625/200}$, respectively, in accordance with the Skumanich
278: $\sqrt{t}$ time-dependence on stellar rotation evolution, and an age
279: of 625\,Myr for the Hyades \citep{pbl+98}.}
280: \label{m3534pbv_hyades}
281: \end{figure}
282:
283:
284: \subsubsection{Testing the Skumanich relationship ($P_{rot} \propto
285: \sqrt{age}$)}
286:
287: On the I sequence, angular momentum loss ($dJ/dt$) is thought to be
288: proportional to the angular rotation velocity ($\Omega$) to the third
289: power ($dJ/dt \propto \Omega^{3}$). This relationship has been used
290: in the most recent models of angular momentum evolution for late-type
291: stars \citep[e.g.][]{pkd90,cdp95,bs96,kpb+97,spt00}. Its origin is
292: in magnetized stellar wind theory \citep[][and references therein]
293: {kawaler88}. However, assumptions were made about the geometry of
294: the global magnetic field ($B$), and about the relation between $B$
295: and $\Omega$, in order to satisfy the Skumanich relationship ($P_{rot}
296: \propto \sqrt{age}$). We note that the Skumanich relationship was
297: derived based on $v\sin i$ data for solar-like stars (G dwarfs) in
298: open clusters and for the Sun. We ask here if the Skumanich relationship
299: is also valid for stars of lower mass?
300:
301: Figure~\ref{m3534pbv_hyades} shows color-period diagrams in which the
302: M\,35 and M\,34 stars are plotted together with Hyades stars. The Hyades
303: stars have been spun-up in accordance with the Skumanich $\sqrt{t}$
304: time-dependence. Comparing stars on the I sequence, the $\sqrt{t}$
305: dependence appears to represent well the rotational evolution of the
306: G dwarfs between 150\,Myr/200\,Myr and 625\,Myr, whereas the spun-up
307: Hyades K-dwarfs have rotation periods systematically shorter than the
308: M\,35 and M\,34 K dwarfs. This suggests that the time-dependence on
309: spin-down of K dwarfs is slower than $\sqrt{t}$ in the age-interval
310: studied. A more detailed study of deviations from the Skumanich
311: relationship is underway.
312:
313:
314: \subsubsection{Testing gyrochronology}
315:
316: The idea of using the relations between stellar rotation, color (mass),
317: and age, to determine the latter from observations of the former two,
318: was proposed by \citet{kawaler89} and B03 (gyrochronology). Each proposed
319: an expression relating the age of a star to its rotation period and $B-V$
320: color. We show in Figure~\ref{gyroages}, the distributions of ages calculated
321: using the expression in B03 for I sequence stars in M\,35 and M\,34.
322: The mean gyro-ages for M\,35 and M\,34 are 137\,Myr and 188\,Myr. The
323: corresponding mean gyro-ages using the \citet{kawaler89} expression
324: are 161\,Myr and 217\,Myr. Both sets of gyro-ages fall within the range
325: of the isochrone ages determine for the two clusters (see \citet{mms08}
326: for a more detailed comparison and discussion).
327:
328: \begin{figure}
329: \includegraphics[height=.35\textheight]{f4a.eps}
330: \includegraphics[height=.35\textheight]{f4b.eps}
331: \caption{The distributions of stellar ages for I sequence stars in M\,35
332: (left) and M\,34 (right) calculated using the B03 empirical age-rotation-color
333: relationship.
334: }
335: \label{gyroages}
336: \end{figure}
337:
338:
339: \subsubsection{The Kepler mission - a unique opportunity}
340:
341: The Kepler space mission - a search for transiting earth-like planets -
342: will provide time-series photometry of unprecedented duration, cadence,
343: and precision. The location of 4 open clusters within the Kepler field
344: of view, with ages from $\sim$0.5\,Gyr till $\sim$8\,Gyr, offers a unique
345: opportunity to measure rotational periods for cool stars beyond the age
346: of the Hyades and the Sun, and thereby extent the age-dimension of studies
347: of stellar angular momentum evolution. The author is leading an effort
348: to study the clusters with Kepler.
349:
350:
351: \begin{theacknowledgments}
352: We thank the organizers for a wonderful meeting.
353: \end{theacknowledgments}
354:
355: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
356: %% The bibliography can be prepared using the BibTeX program or
357: %% manually.
358: %%
359: %% The code below assumes that BibTeX is used. If the bibliography is
360: %% produced without BibTeX comment out the following lines and see the
361: %% aipguide.pdf for further information.
362: %%
363: %% For your convenience a manually coded example is appended
364: %% after the \end{document}
365: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
366:
367: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
368: %% You may have to change the BibTeX style below, depending on your
369: %% setup or preferences.
370: %%
371: %%
372: %% For The AIP proceedings layouts use either
373: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
374:
375: \bibliographystyle{aipproc} % if natbib is available
376: %\bibliographystyle{aipprocl} % if natbib is missing
377:
378: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
379: %% You probably want to use your own bibtex database here
380: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
381: \bibliography{refs}
382:
383: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
384: %% Just a reminder that you may have to run bibtex
385: %% All of it up to \end{document} can be removed
386: %% if you don't like the warning.
387: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
388: % \IfFileExists{\jobname.bbl}{}
389: % {\typeout{}
390: % \typeout{******************************************}
391: % \typeout{** Please run "bibtex \jobname" to optain}
392: % \typeout{** the bibliography and then re-run LaTeX}
393: % \typeout{** twice to fix the references!}
394: % \typeout{******************************************}
395: % \typeout{}
396: % }
397:
398: \end{document}
399:
400: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
401: %% The following lines show an example how to produce a bibliography
402: %% without the help of the BibTeX program. This could be used instead
403: %% of the above.
404: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
405:
406: %\begin{thebibliography}{9}
407: %
408: %\bibitem{Brown2000}
409: %M.~P. Brown, and K.~Austin, \emph{The New Physique}, Publisher Name,
410: % Publisher City, 2000, pp. 212--213.
411: %
412: %\bibitem{BrownAustin:2000}
413: %M.~P. Brown, and K.~Austin, \emph{Appl. Phys. Letters} \textbf{85},
414: % 2503--2504 (2000).
415: %
416: %\bibitem{Wang}
417: %R.~Wang, ``Title of Chapter,'' in \emph{Classic Physiques}, edited by
418: % R.~B. Hamil, Publisher Name, Publisher City, 2000, pp. 212--213.
419: %
420: %\bibitem{SJ:1999}
421: %C.~D.~Smith and E.~F.~Jones, ``Load-Cycling in Cubic Press,'' in
422: % \emph{Shock Compression of Condensed Matter-1999}, edited by M.~D.~F. et~al.,
423: % AIP Conference Proceedings 505, American Institute of Physics, New York,
424: % 1999, pp. 651--654.
425: %
426: %\end{thebibliography}
427: %
428: %\endinput
429: %%
430: %% End of file `template-6s.tex'.
431: