1: \begin{abstract}

2: We consider a group of agents on a graph who 

3: repeatedly play the prisoner's dilemma game against their neighbors.

4: The players adapt their actions to the past

5: behavior of their opponents by applying the win-stay

6: lose-shift strategy. On a finite connected graph, it is easy to see that the

7: system learns to cooperate by converging 

8: to the all-cooperate state in a finite time. 

9: We analyze the rate of convergence in terms

10: of the size and structure of the graph.

11: [Dyer et al., 2002] showed that the system converges rapidly on the

12: cycle, but that it takes a time exponential in the size of the graph to converge 

13: to cooperation on

14: the complete graph. 

15: We show that the emergence of cooperation is exponentially slow in 

16: some expander graphs. More surprisingly, we show that 

17: it is also exponentially slow 

18: in bounded-degree trees, where many

19: other dynamics are known to converge rapidly. 

20: \end{abstract}

21: