1: \begin{abstract}

2: We present a trust-region augmented Hessian implementation (TRAH-SCF) for restricted and 

3:  unrestricted Hartree--Fock and Kohn--Sham methods.

4: With TRAH-SCF convergence can always be achieved with tight 

5:  convergence thresholds, which requires just a modest number of iterations.

6: %

7: Our convergence benchmark study and our illustrative applications focus on

8:  open-shell molecules, also antiferromagnetically coupled systems, 

9:  for which it is notoriously complicated to converge

10:  the Roothaan--Hall self-consistent field (SCF) equations. 

11: %

12: We compare the number of TRAH iterations to reach convergence with those of

13:  Pulay's and Kolmar's (K) variant of the \emph{direct inversion of the iterative subspace} (DIIS)

14:  method and also analyze the obtained SCF solutions.

15: %

16: Often TRAH-SCF finds a symmetry-broken solution with a lower energy than DIIS and KDIIS. 

17: For unrestricted calculations, this is accompanied by a larger spin contamination, i.e.\ larger

18:  deviation from the desired spin-restricted $\langle S^2 \rangle$ expectation value.

19: However, there are also rare cases in which DIIS finds a solution with a lower energy than KDIIS and TRAH.

20: %

21: In rare cases, both TRAH-SCF and KDIIS may also converge to an excited-state determinant solution.

22: For those calculations with negative-gap TRAH solutions, standard DIIS always diverges.

23: %

24: If comparable, TRAH usually needs more iterations to converge than DIIS and KDIIS

25:  because for every new set of orbitals

26:  the level-shifted Newton-Raphson equations are solved approximately and iteratively by means 

27:  of an eigenvalue problem.

28: Nevertheless, the total runtime of TRAH-SCF is still competitive with the DIIS-based approaches

29:  even if extended basis sets are employed,

30:  which is illustrated for a large hemocyanin model complex.

31: %

32: \end{abstract}

33: