1: \begin{abstract}

2: In this work we demonstrate the robustness of a real-space approach for the treatment of infinite systems 

3: described with periodic boundary conditions that we have recently proposed [J. Phys. Chem. Lett. 17, 7090].

4: In our approach we extract a fragment, i.e., a supercell, out of the infinite system, and

5: then modifying its topology into the that of a Clifford torus which is a flat, finite and border-less manifold.

6: We then renormalize the distance between two points by defining it as the Euclidean distance in the embedding space

7: of the Clifford torus.

8: With our method we have been able to calculate the reference results available 

9: in the literature with a remarkable accuracy, and at a very low computational effort.

10: In this work we show that our approach is robust with respect to the shape of the supercell.

11: In particular, we show that the Madelung constants converge to the same values but that the convergence properties are different.

12: Our approach scales linearly with the number of atoms.

13: The calculation of Madelung constants only takes a few seconds on a laptop computer for a relative precision of about 10$^{-6}$.

14: \end{abstract}

15: