1: \begin{abstract}

2:   We consider nucleon-nucleon scattering using the

3: formulation of chiral effective field theory which is claimed to be 

4: renormalization group invariant. The

5: cornerstone of this framework

6: is the existence of a well-defined 

7: infinite-cutoff limit for the scattering amplitude at each order of

8: the expansion, which should not depend on a particular regulator form.

9: Focusing on the $^3P_0$ partial wave as a

10: representative example, we show that this requirement can in general

11: not be fulfilled beyond the leading order, in spite of the perturbative

12: treatment of subleading contributions to the amplitude. 

13: Several previous studies along these lines, including the

14: next-to-leading order calculation by Long and Yang [Phys. Rev. C84, 057001 (2011)] 

15: and a toy model example with singular long-range potentials by Long and van Kolck

16: [Annals Phys. 323, 1304-1323 (2008)],

17: are critically reviewed and scrutinized in detail.

18: \end{abstract}

19: