1: \begin{abstract}

2: Shadowing methods compute derivatives of averaged objectives of chaos with respect to parameters of the dynamical system. However, previous convergence proofs of shadowing methods wrongly assume that shadowing trajectories are representative. In contrast, the linear response formula is proved rigorously, but is more difficult to compute.

3: 

4: 

5: In this paper, we first prove that the shadowing method computes a part of the linear response formula, which we call the shadowing contribution. Then we show that the error of shadowing is typically small for systems with small ratio of unstable directions. For partly reducing this error, we give a correction which can be easily implemented. Finally, we prove the convergence of the non-intrusive shadowing, the fastest shadowing algorithm, to the shadowing contribution.

6: \end{abstract}