1: \begin{abstract}

2: We give the first mathematically rigorous analysis of an emerging approach to finite element analysis (see, e.g., Bauer et al. [Appl. Numer. Math., 2017]), which we hereby refer to as \emph{the surrogate matrix methodology}.

3: This methodology is based on the piece-wise smooth approximation of the matrices involved in a standard finite element discretization.

4: In particular, it relies on the projection of smooth so-called stencil functions onto high-order polynomial subspaces.

5: The performance advantage of the surrogate matrix methodology is seen in constructions where each stencil function uniquely determines the values of a significant collection of matrix entries.

6: Such constructions are shown to be widely achievable through the use of locally-structured meshes.

7: Therefore, this methodology can be applied to a wide variety of physically meaningful problems, including nonlinear problems and problems with curvilinear geometries. Rigorous \textit{a priori} error analysis certifies the convergence of a novel surrogate method for the variable coefficient Poisson equation.

8: The flexibility of the methodology is also demonstrated through the construction of novel methods for linear elasticity and nonlinear diffusion problems.

9: In numerous numerical experiments, we demonstrate the efficacy of these new methods in a matrix-free environment with geometric multigrid solvers.

10: In our experiments, up to a twenty-fold decrease in computation time is witnessed over the classical method with an otherwise identical implementation.

11: \end{abstract}

12: