1: \begin{abstract}

2: We consider numerical approximations of ill-posed elliptic problems with conditional stability.

3: The notion of {\emph{optimal error estimates}} is defined including both convergence with respect to discretization and perturbations in data.

4: The rate of convergence is determined by the conditional stability of the underlying continuous problem and the polynomial order of the approximation space.

5: A proof is given that no approximation can converge at a better rate than that given by the definition without increasing the sensitivity to perturbations, thus justifying the concept.

6: A recently introduced class of primal-dual finite element methods with weakly consistent regularisation is recalled and the associated error estimates are shown to be optimal in the sense of this definition. 

7: \keywords{unique continuation \and conditional stability \and finite element methods \and stabilised methods \and error estimates \and optimality  \and optimal convergence}

8: % \PACS{PACS code1 \and PACS code2 \and more}

9: \subclass{65N20}

10: \end{abstract}

11: