1: \begin{abstract}

2: The recently developed semiclassical variational Wigner-Kirkwood (VWK)

3: approach is applied to finite nuclei using external potentials and

4: self-consistent mean fields derived from Skyrme interactions and from

5: relativistic mean field theory. VWK consists of the Thomas-Fermi part

6: plus a pure, perturbative $\hbar^2$ correction. In external

7: potentials, VWK passes through the average of the quantal values of

8: the accumulated level density and total energy as a function of the

9: Fermi energy. However, there is a problem of overbinding when the

10: energy per particle is displayed as a function of the particle number.

11: The situation is analyzed comparing spherical and deformed harmonic

12: oscillator potentials. In the self-consistent case, we show for Skyrme

13: forces that VWK binding energies are very close to those obtained from

14: extended Thomas-Fermi functionals of $\hbar^4$ order, pointing to the

15: rapid convergence of the VWK theory. This satisfying result, however,

16: does not cure the overbinding problem, i.e., the semiclassical energies

17: show more binding than they should. This feature is more pronounced in

18: the case of Skyrme forces than with the relativistic mean field

19: approach. However, even in the latter case the shell correction energy

20: for e.g. $^{208}$Pb turns out to be only $\sim -6$ MeV what is about a

21: factor two or three off the generally accepted value. As an ad hoc

22: remedy, increasing the kinetic energy by 2.5\%, leads to shell

23: correction energies well acceptable throughout the periodic table. The

24: general importance of the present studies for other finite Fermi

25: systems, self-bound or in external potentials, is pointed out.

26: \end{abstract}

27: