1: \begin{abstract} 

2: The outcome of interactions in many real-world systems can be often explained

3: by a hierarchy between the participants.

4: Discovering hierarchy from a given directed network 

5: can be formulated as follows: partition vertices into levels 

6: such that, ideally, there are only forward edges, that is, edges from upper levels to lower levels.

7: In practice, the ideal case is impossible, so instead we minimize some

8: penalty function on the backward edges. One practical option for such a penalty

9: is agony, where the penalty depends on the severity of the violation.

10: In this paper we extend the definition of agony to temporal networks.  In this

11: setup we are given a directed network with time stamped edges,

12: and we allow the rank assignment to

13: vary over time.

14: We propose 2 strategies for controlling the variation of individual ranks.  In

15: our first variant, we penalize the fluctuation of the rankings over time by

16: adding a penalty directly to the optimization function.  

17: In our second variant we allow the rank change at most once.

18: We show that the first variant can be solved exactly in polynomial time

19: while  the second variant is \np-hard, and in fact inapproximable.  However, we

20: develop an iterative method, where we first fix the change point and

21: optimize the ranks, and then fix the ranks and optimize the change points, and

22: reiterate until convergence.

23: We show empirically that the algorithms are reasonably fast in practice, and

24: that the obtained rankings are sensible.

25: \end{abstract}

26: