1: \begin{abstract}

2: Theories of scalars and gravity, with an Einstein-Hilbert term and  non-minimal interactions, 

3: $M^2R/2 -\alpha\phi^2R/12 $, have graviton exchange induced contact interactions.

4: These modify the renormalization group, leading to a discrepancy between 

5: the conventional calculations in the Jordan frame that ignore this effect

6: (and are found to be incorrect),

7: and the Einstein frame in which $\alpha$ does not exist.

8: Thus, the calculation of quantum effects in the Jordan and Einstein frames does not generally commute

9:   with the transition from the Jordan to the Einstein frame.

10: In the Einstein frame, though $\alpha$ is absent,  for small steps in scale $\delta\mu/\mu$

11: infinitesimal contact terms $\sim \delta\alpha$ are induced, that are then

12: absorbed back into other couplings by the contact terms. 

13: This modifies the $\beta$-functions in the Einstein frame.  We show how

14: correct results can be obtained in a simple model by including this effect.

15: \end{abstract}

16: