1: \begin{abstract} 

2: This paper considers the fundamental convergence 

3: time for opportunistic scheduling over time-varying channels. 

4: The channel state probabilities are unknown and algorithms must

5: perform some type of estimation and learning while they 

6: make decisions to optimize network utility.  Existing schemes can 

7: achieve a utility within $\epsilon$ of optimality, for any desired

8: $\epsilon>0$,  with convergence

9: and adaptation times of $O(1/\epsilon^2)$.  This paper shows that 

10: if the utility function is concave and smooth, then  

11: $O(\log(1/\epsilon)/\epsilon)$ convergence time is possible

12: via an existing stochastic variation on the Frank-Wolfe algorithm, 

13: called the RUN algorithm. 

14: Next, a converse result is proven to show it is impossible for any algorithm 

15: to have convergence time better than $O(1/\epsilon)$, provided the algorithm

16: has no a-priori knowledge of channel state probabilities.  Hence, RUN is 

17: within a logarithmic factor of convergence time optimality. 

18: However, RUN has a vanishing stepsize and hence has an 

19: infinite adaptation time.  Using stochastic Frank-Wolfe with a fixed stepsize

20: yields improved $O(1/\epsilon^2)$ adaptation 

21: time, but convergence time increases to $O(1/\epsilon^2)$, similar

22: to existing drift-plus-penalty based algorithms.  This raises important open questions

23: regarding optimal adaptation. 

24: \end{abstract}