1: \begin{abstract}

2: We study the exponent of the exponential rate of convergence in terms of the   number of degrees of freedom for various non-standard   {$p$-version} finite element spaces employing  reduced cardinality basis. 

3: More specifically, we show that  serendipity finite element methods  and  discontinuous Galerkin finite element methods  with  total degree $\mathcal{P}_p$ basis have a faster   exponential convergence with respect to  the number of degrees of freedom than their counterparts employing  the tensor product $\mathcal{Q}_p$ basis for quadrilateral/hexahedral elements, for piecewise  analytic problems under $p$-refinement. The above results are proven by using a new $p$-optimal error bound for  the $L^2$-orthogonal projection onto the total degree $\mathcal{P}_p$ basis, and for  the  $H^1$-projection onto the serendipity finite element space  over  tensor product elements with dimension $d\geq2$. These new $p$-optimal error bounds  lead to a larger exponent of the exponential rate of convergence  with respect to the   number of degrees of freedom. Moreover, these results show that part of the basis functions in $\mathcal{Q}_p$ basis  {plays} no roles  in achieving the $hp$-optimal error bound in the Sobolev space. The sharpness of theoretical results is also  verified  by a series of numerical examples.

4: 

5: \keywords{$hp$-finite element method; discontinuous Galerkin   method; serendipity basis; $\mathcal{P}_p$ basis;  reduced cardinality basis; exponential convergence. }

6: % \PACS{PACS code1 \and PACS code2 \and more}

7: \subclass{65N30 \and  65N15\and  65N50.}

8: \end{abstract}

9: