1: \begin{abstract}

2: We calculate the nature of magnetic interactions in transition-metal doped ZnO using the 

3: local spin density approximation and LSDA+\textit{U} method of density functional theory. 

4: We investigate the following four cases: (i) single transition metal ion types (Cr, Mn, 

5: Fe, Co, Ni and Cu) substituted at Zn sites, (ii) substitutional magnetic transition metal 

6: ions combined with additional Cu and Li dopants, (iii) substitutional magnetic transition 

7: metal ions combined with oxygen vacancies and (iv) pairs of magnetic ion types (Co and Fe,

8: Co and Mn, etc.). Extensive convergence tests indicate that the 

9: calculated magnetic ground state is unusually sensitive to the k-point mesh and energy cut-off, 

10: the details of the geometry optimizations and the choice of the exchange-correlation functional. 

11: We find that ferromagnetic coupling is sometimes favorable for single type substitutional 

12: transition metal ions 

13: within the local spin density approximation. However, the nature of magnetic interactions 

14: changes when correlations on the transition-metal ion are treated within the more realistic 

15: LSDA + \textit{U} method, often disfavoring the ferromagnetic state. The magnetic configuration

16: is sensitive to the detailed arrangement of the ions and the amount of lattice relaxation, 

17: except in the case of oxygen vacancies when an antiferromagnetic state is always favored. 

18: \end{abstract}

19: