1: \begin{abstract}

2: Hessian recovery has been commonly used in mesh adaptation for obtaining the required magnitude and direction information of the solution error.

3: Unfortunately, a recovered Hessian from a linear finite element approximation is nonconvergent in general as the mesh is refined.

4: It has been observed numerically that adaptive meshes based on such a nonconvergent recovered Hessian can nevertheless lead to an optimal error in the finite element approximation.

5: This also explains why Hessian recovery is still widely used despite its nonconvergence.

6: In this paper we develop an error bound for the linear finite element solution of a general boundary value problem under a mild assumption on the closeness of the recovered Hessian to the exact one.

7: Numerical results show that this closeness assumption is satisfied by the recovered Hessian obtained with commonly used Hessian recovery methods.

8: Moreover, it is shown that the finite element error changes gradually with the closeness of the recovered Hessian.

9: This provides an explanation on how a nonconvergent recovered Hessian works in mesh adaptation.

10: 

11: %--- keywords --------------------------------------------------------

12: \begin{keywords}

13:    Hessian recovery, mesh adaptation, anisotropic mesh, finite element, convergence analysis, error estimate

14: \end{keywords}

15: 

16: %--- ams --------------------------------------------------------

17: \begin{AMS}

18:    65N50, 65N30

19: \end{AMS}

20: \end{abstract}

21: