1: \begin{abstract}

2: \noindent

3: %1         2         3         4         5         6         7         8

4: %1234567890123456789012345678901234567890123456789012345678901234567890123456780

5: 

6: 

7: 

8: 

9: 

10: We investigate the $XY$ spin-glass model in two and three dimensions 

11: using the 

12: domain-wall renormalization-group method. The results for systems 

13: of linear sizes up to  $L=12$ (2D) and $L=8$ (3D) strongly suggest 

14: that the lower critical dimension for spin-glass ordering may be 

15: $d_{\rm 

16: c}\approx 3$ rather than four as is 

17: commonly believed. Our 3D data favor the scenario of a low but 

18: finite spin-glass 

19: ordering temperature below the chiral transition but they are also 

20: compatible with the system 

21: being at or slightly below its lower critical 

22: dimension.

23: \end{abstract}

24: