1: \begin{abstract}  Attached    to a singular  analytic curve germ in $d$-space is  a  numerical

2: semigroup: a subset  $S$ of the non-negative integers  which is  closed under addition and  whose complement is

3: finite. 

4:  Conversely, associated to any numerical semigroup $S$ is a canonical mononial curve in $e$-space where $e$ is the number of minimal generators of the semigroup.    It may happen that  $d < e = e(S)$

5:  where $S$ is the semigroup of the curve in $d$-space.  Define the minimal (or `honest') embedding

6: of a  numerical semigroup to be the smallest $d$ such that $S$ is realized by a curve in

7: $d$-space.    Problem: characterize  the numerical semigroups having minimal embedding

8: dimension $d$.  The answer is known for the case $d=2$ of planar curves

9: and  reviewed  in an Appendix to this paper.

10: The case $d =3$ of   the problem is  open. Our main result is

11: a characterization of the  multiplicity $4$ numerical semigroups whose minimal embedding dimension is $3$.  See figure 1.    

12: The motivation for this work came from thinking about Legendrian curve singularities. 

13: \end{abstract}