1: \begin{abstract}

2: Recent simulations of self-gravitating accretion discs, carried out using a three-dimensional 

3: Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics (SPH) code by Meru and Bate, have been interpreted as 

4: implying that three-dimensional global discs fragment much more easily than would be expected 

5: from a two-dimensional 

6: local model. Subsequently, global and local two-dimensional models have been shown to display similar fragmentation 

7: properties, leaving it unclear whether the three-dimensional results reflect a physical effect 

8: or a numerical problem associated with the treatment of cooling or artificial viscosity in SPH. 

9: Here, we study how fragmentation of self-gravitating disc flows in SPH depends upon the 

10: implementation of cooling. We run disc simulations that compare a simple cooling scheme, in 

11: which each particle loses energy based upon its internal energy per unit mass, with a method 

12: in which the cooling is derived from a smoothed internal energy density field. For the 

13: simple per particle cooling scheme, we find a significant increase in the minimum cooling 

14: time scale for fragmentation with increasing resolution, matching previous results. Switching 

15: to smoothed cooling, however, results in lower critical cooling time scales, and tentative 

16: evidence for convergence at the highest spatial resolution tested. We conclude that precision 

17: studies of fragmentation using SPH require careful consideration of how cooling (and, probably, 

18: artificial viscosity) is implemented, and that the apparent non-convergence of the fragmentation 

19: boundary seen in prior simulations is likely a numerical effect. In real discs, where cooling 

20: is physically smoothed by radiative transfer effects, the fragmentation boundary is probably 

21: displaced from the two-dimensional value by a factor that is only of the order of unity.

22: \end{abstract}

23: