1: \begin{abstract}

2: We consider three distinct discrete-time models of learning and evolution in games:

3: a biological model based on intra-species selective pressure,

4: the dynamics induced by \acl{PPI},

5: and

6: the \acl{EW} algorithm for online learning.

7: Even though these models share the same continuous-time limit \textendash\ the \acl{RD} \textendash\ we show that second-order effects play a crucial role and may lead to drastically different behaviors in each model, even in very simple, symmetric $2\times2$ games.

8: Specifically, we study the resulting discrete-time dynamics in a class of parametrized congestion games, and we show that

9: \begin{enumerate*}

10: [\upshape(\itshape i\hspace*{.5pt}\upshape)]

11: \item

12: in the biological model of intra-species competition, the dynamics remain convergent for any parameter value;

13: \item

14: the dynamics of \acl{PPI} for different equilibrium configurations exhibit an entire range of behaviors for large step size (stability, instability, and even Li-Yorke chaos);

15: while

16: \item

17: for the \ac{EW} algorithm increasing step size will (almost) inevitably %exhibits a phase transition from global convergence to 

18: lead to chaos (again, in the formal, Li-Yorke sense).

19: \end{enumerate*}

20: This divergence of behaviors comes in stark contrast to the globally convergent behavior of the \acl{RD}, and serves to delineate the extent to which the \acl{RD} provide a useful predictor for the long-run behavior of their discrete-time origins.

21: \end{abstract}

22: