1: \begin{abstract} 

2: \noindent The diameter of a disc filling

3: a loop in the universal covering 

4: of a Riemannian manifold $M$ may be measured {\em{extrinsically}} using the

5: distance function on the ambient space or \emph{intrinsically} using the

6: induced length metric on the disc. Correspondingly, the diameter of a 

7:  van~Kampen diagram $\Delta$ filling a word that

8: represents the identity in a finitely presented group $\Gamma$ can either be measured

9: \emph{intrinsically} in the 1--skeleton of $\Delta$  or

10: \emph{extrinsically} in the Cayley graph of $\Gamma$. We construct

11: the first examples of closed manifolds $M$ and finitely

12: presented groups $\G=\pi_1M$ for which this choice --- intrinsic

13: versus extrinsic --- gives rise to qualitatively different min--diameter

14: filling functions.\ms

15: \\

16: \footnotesize{\ni \textbf{2000 Mathematics Subject

17: Classification: 53C23, 20F65, 20F10}  \\ \ni \emph{Key words and phrases:} diameter,

18: isodiametric inequality, van~Kampen diagram}

19: \end{abstract}

20: