1: \begin{abstract}    

2: Gordon and Wilton recently proved that the double $D$ of a free group $F$ amalgamated along a cyclic subgroup $C$ of $F$ contains a surface group if a generator $w$ of $C$ satisfies a certain $3$--manifold theoretic condition, called virtually geometricity. Wilton and the author defined the polygonality of $w$ which also guarantees the existence of a surface group in $D$. In this paper, virtual geometricity is shown to imply polygonality up to descending to a finite-index subgroup of $F$. That the converse does not hold will follow from an example formerly considered by Manning.

3: \end{abstract}

4: