1: \begin{abstract}

2: At the mean-field level, on fully connected lattices, several disordered spin models have been shown to belong to 

3: the universality class of ``structural glasses'', with a ``random first-order transition'' (RFOT) characterized by 

4: a discontinuous jump of the order parameter and no latent heat. However, their behavior in finite dimensions  is 

5: often drastically different, displaying either no glassiness at all or a conventional spin-glass transition. We 

6: clarify the physical reasons for this phenomenon and stress the unusual fragility of the RFOT to \textit{short-range} 

7: fluctuations, associated \textit{e.g.} with the mere existence of a finite number of neighbors.  Accordingly, the 

8: solution of fully connected models is only predictive in very high dimension whereas, despite being also mean-field 

9: in character, the Bethe approximation provides valuable information on the behavior of finite-dimensional systems. 

10: We suggest that before embarking on a full-blown account of fluctuations on all scales through computer simulation or 

11: renormalization-group approach, models for structural glasses should first be tested for the effect of short-range 

12: fluctuations and we discuss ways to do it. Our results indicate that disordered spin models do not appear to pass 

13: the test and are therefore questionable models for investigating the glass transition in three dimensions. This also 

14: highlights how nontrivial is the first step of deriving an effective theory for the RFOT phenomenology from a rigorous 

15: integration over the short-range fluctuations.

16: \end{abstract}

17: