1: \begin{abstract}

2: Effective theories for random critical points are usually

3: non-unitary, and thus may contain relevant operators with negative 

4: scaling dimensions. To study the consequences of the existence of

5: negative dimensional operators, we consider the random-bond $XY$ model.

6: It has been argued that the $XY$ model on a square lattice, when

7: weakly perturbed by random phases, 

8: has a quasi-long-range ordered phase (the random spin wave phase)

9: at sufficiently low temperatures.

10: We show that infinitely many relevant perturbations to the

11: proposed critical action for the random spin wave phase

12: were omitted in all previous treatments.

13: The physical origin of these perturbations is intimately related to

14: the existence of broadly distributed correlation functions.

15: We find that those relevant perturbations do enter the

16: Renormalization Group equations, and affect critical behavior.

17: This raises the possibility that the random $XY$ model has no

18: quasi-long-range ordered phase and no Kosterlitz-Thouless (KT) 

19: phase transition.

20: \end{abstract}

21: