1: \begin{abstract}

2: We study the ratio ergodic theorem (RET) of Hopf for group actions.

3: Under a certain technical condition, if a sequence of sets $\{F_{n}\}$

4: in a group satisfy the RET, then there is a finite set $E$ such that

5: $\{EF_{n}\}$ satisfies the Besicovitch covering property. Consequently

6: for the abelian group $G=\oplus_{n=1}^{\infty}\mathbb{Z}$ there is

7: no sequence $F_{n}\subseteq G$ along which the RET holds, and in

8: many finitely generated groups, including the discrete Heisenberg

9: group and the free group on $\geq2$ generators, there is no (sub)sequence

10: of balls, in the standard generators, along which the RET holds. 

11: 

12: On the other hand, in groups with polynomial growth (including the

13: Heisenberg group, to which our negative results apply) there always

14: exists a sequence of balls along which the RET holds if convergence

15: is understood as a.e. convergence in density (i.e. omitting a sequence

16: of density zero). 

17: \end{abstract}

18: