1: \begin{abstract}

2: In this article, we assume that there exists a scalar $D_s^\ast

3: {\bar D}_s^\ast$ molecular state in the $J/\psi \phi$ invariant mass

4: distribution, and study its mass using the QCD sum rules. The

5: predictions depend heavily on  the two criteria (pole dominance and

6: convergence of the operator product expansion) of the QCD sum rules.

7: The  value of the mass is about   $M_{D_s^\ast {\bar

8: D}_s^\ast}=(4.43\pm0.16)\,\rm{GeV}$, which

9:  is  inconsistent with the experimental data.

10:     The $D_s^\ast {\bar

11: D}_s^\ast$  is probably  a virtual state and not related to the

12: meson $Y(4140)$. Other possibility, such as a hybrid charmonium is

13: not excluded.

14: \end{abstract}

15: