1: \begin{abstract}

2: Chaos in the orbits of black hole pairs has

3: by now been confirmed by several independent groups. 

4: While the chaotic behavior of binary black hole orbits is no longer

5: argued, it remains difficult to quantify the importance of chaos to

6: the evolutionary dynamics of a pair of

7: comparable mass black holes. None of our existing approximations are

8: robust enough to offer convincing quantitative conclusions in the most

9: highly nonlinear regime. 

10: It is intriguing to note that

11: in three different approximations to 

12: a black hole pair built of a spinning black hole and a {\it

13:   non-spinning} companion,  

14: two approximations exhibit chaos and one approximation does not. The

15: fully relativistic scenario of 

16: a spinning test-mass around a Schwarzschild black hole shows chaos, as does the

17: Post-Newtonian Lagrangian approximation. However, the approximately

18: equivalent Post-Newtonian Hamiltonian approximation does not show

19: chaos when only one body spins.

20: It is well known in dynamical

21: systems theory that one system can be regular while an approximately

22: related system is chaotic, so there is no formal conflict. However,the 

23: physical question remains, Is there chaos for comparable mass

24: binaries when only one object spins? We are unable to answer this

25: question given the poor convergence of the Post-Newtonian

26: approximation to the fully relativistic system. A resolution awaits

27: better approximations that can be trusted in the highly nonlinear regime.

28: \end{abstract}

29: