1: \begin{abstract}

2: We explore the properties of non-piecewise syndetic sets with positive upper density, which we call \textit{discordant}, in  countably infinite  amenable (semi)groups.

3: Sets of this kind are involved in many questions of Ramsey theory and manifest the difference in complexity between the classical van der Waerden's theorem and Szemer\'{e}di's theorem.

4: We generalize and unify old constructions and obtain new results about these historically interesting sets.

5: Along the way, we draw from various corners of mathematics, including classical Ramsey theory, ergodic theory, number theory, and topological and symbolic dynamics.

6: % Here is a small sample of our results.

7: % \begin{itemize}

8: % \item

9: % We connect discordant sets to recurrence in dynamical systems, and in this setting we exhibit an intimate analogy between discordant sets and nowhere dense sets having positive measure.

10: 

11: % \item

12: % We introduce a wide-ranging generalization of the squarefree numbers, producing many examples of discordant sets in $\Z$, $\Z^d$, and the Heisenberg group.

13: % We develop a unified method to compute densities of these discordant sets.

14: 

15: % \item

16: % We show that, for any countable abelian group $G$, any F\o lner sequence $\Phi$ in $G$, and any $c \in (0, 1)$, there exists a discordant set $A \subseteq G$ with $d_\Phi(A) = c$.

17: % Here $d_\Phi$ denotes density along $\Phi$.

18: % \end{itemize}

19: % Along the way, we draw from various corners of mathematics, including classical Ramsey theory, ergodic theory, number theory, and topological and symbolic dynamics.

20: \end{abstract}

21: