1: \documentclass{aastex}
2:
3: \begin{document}
4:
5: \title{Spectrum Analysis of the Type Ib Supernova 1999dn:
6: Probable Identifications of C II and H$\alpha$}
7:
8: \author{J. S. Deng \altaffilmark{1,2}, Y. L. Qiu
9: \altaffilmark{2} and J. Y. Hu \altaffilmark{2}}
10: \affil{Beijing
11: Astronomical Observatory, Chaoyang, Beijing 100012, P.R.China}
12: \email{djs@nova.bao.ac.cn, qiuyl@nova.bao.ac.cn,
13: hjy@class1.bao.ac.cn}
14:
15: \author{K. Hatano and D. Branch}
16: \affil{Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of
17: Oklahoma, Norman, Oklahoma 73019, USA}
18: \email{hatano@mail.nhn.ou.edu, branch@mail.nhn.ou.edu}
19:
20: \altaffiltext{1}{Corresponding author}
21: \altaffiltext{2}{Chinese
22: National Astronomical Observatories}
23:
24: \begin{abstract}
25:
26: Low resolution spectra of SN 1999dn at early times are presented
27: and compared with synthetic spectra generated with the
28: parameterized supernova synthetic-spectrum code SYNOW. We find
29: that the spectra of SN 1999dn strongly resemble those of SN 1997X
30: and SN 1984L, and hence we classify it as a Type Ib event.
31: Line-identifications are established through spectrum synthesis.
32: Strong evidence of both ${\rm H}{\alpha}$ and C II $\lambda 6580$
33: is found. We infer that ${\rm H}{\alpha}$ appears first, before
34: the time of maximum brightness, and then is blended with and
35: finally overwhelmed by the C II line after maximum; this favors a
36: thin high-velocity hydrogen skin in this Type Ib supernova.
37:
38: \end{abstract}
39:
40: \keywords{radiative transfer --- supernovae: individual (SN
41: 1999dn) --- supernovae: general}
42:
43: \section{Introduction}
44:
45: Type Ib and Ic supernovae (SNe Ib and SNe Ic) are distinguished
46: from SNe Ia primarily by their lack of a strong $6150{\rm~\AA}$ Si
47: II absorption feature in early-time spectra \citep{fil97}. Their
48: nature is still in debate due to their relative rareness
49: \citep{cap99} and faintness \citep{pie97}. The most widely
50: accepted scenario is the core-collapse of a massive star that has
51: lost its hydrogen (SN Ib) and possibly helium envelope (SN Ic)
52: either through a stellar wind or the effects of a close companion,
53: although other models like the thermonuclear explosions of white
54: dwarfs have not been completely excluded. Currently, there is
55: intense interest in SNe Ib/Ic because of their possible connection
56: with $\gamma$-ray bursts \citep{whe99}.
57:
58: SN 1999dn, located in NGC 7714, was discovered by \citet{qiu199}
59: on Aug. 19.76UT with the BAO 0.6-m telescope. It was originally
60: identified as a Type Ic \citep{aya99,tur99} or Ib/c event
61: \citep{pas99}. The derived velocity of the weak ``Si II $\lambda
62: 6355$'' absorption line is much smaller than that of other lines,
63: which encouraged us to reconsider the line-identification and
64: spectroscopic classification through spectrum synthesis. We used
65: the fast parameterized LTE code SYNOW and early-time spectra
66: observed with the BAO 2.16-m telescope. The observations, spectrum
67: synthesis procedure, and results are presented and discussed here.
68:
69: \section{Observations}
70:
71: Three spectra of SN 1999dn were obtained with the 2.16-m telescope
72: of Beijing Astronomical Observatory. The first spectrum was taken
73: with BFSOC spectrograph with a 2048x2048 pixel CCD, just after the
74: discovery of the supernova. The other two spectra were taken with
75: the OMR spectrograph with a Tek 1024x1024 CCD. We used a grating
76: of $200{\rm~\AA/mm}$, whose spectral resolution is about
77: $10{\rm~\AA}$. The standard IRAF (Image Reduction and Facilities)
78: package was used to reduce the spectra. The observations are
79: listed in table \ref{tbl-1}.
80:
81: During the reduction process, the telluric emission lines were
82: subtracted automatically. We did not remove any telluric
83: absorption lines from the first two spectra. We used an early-type
84: standard star, which has no strong features in the red part of its
85: spectrum, to obtain the profiles of the telluric lines and remove
86: them from the third supernova spectrum. The spectra of SN 1999dn
87: are shown in Figures 1 --- 3.
88:
89: \section{Spectrum Synthesis}
90:
91: To establish line-identifications, we used the parameterized
92: supernova spectrum-synthesis code SYNOW to analyze the spectra of
93: SN 1999dn. This code makes simplifying approximations, including
94: the LTE, resonant scattering, and Sobolev approximations
95: \citep{jef90,fis97}.
96:
97: \citet{hat99} have calculated LTE Sobolev line optical depths for
98: various temperatures and for six different compositions that could
99: be encountered in supernovae. We used their results to determine
100: which ions should be considered in our synthesis procedure. For
101: each ion, the optical depth of a reference line is a fitting
102: parameter. Optical depths of the other lines for that ion are
103: calculated assuming Boltzmann excitation, with excitation
104: temperature also a fitting parameter. The continuum is fitted with
105: a blackbody; its temperature $T_{bb}$ is not assigned much
106: physical significance.
107:
108: The radial dependence of the line optical depths is taken to be
109: exponential with the e-folding velocity
110: $v_{e}=1000{\rm~km~s^{-1}}$. The velocity interval within which an ion
111: is present is characterized by such fitting parameters as the minimum
112: and maximum velocities $v_{\min}$ and $v_{\max}$. We use
113: $v_{\max}=5\times 10^{4}{\rm~km~s^{-1}}$, and in most cases $v_{\min}$
114: is the same as the velocity at the photosphere, $v_{ph}$. When we
115: assign to some ion a $v_{\min}$ that is larger than $v_{ph}$, we mean
116: that this ion is detached from the photosphere.
117:
118: We have experimented with many combinations of fitting parameters.
119: The best-fit synthetic spectra are compared with the observed
120: spectra of August 21, August 31 and September 14 in the upper
121: panels of Figure 1, Figure 2, and Figure 3, respectively.
122:
123: The synthetic spectrum of Aug. 21 has $T_{bb}=7500{\rm~K}$ and
124: $v_{ph}=16,000{\rm~km~s^{-1}}$. As shown in the upper panel of
125: Figure 1, the Fe II features from $4500{\rm~\AA}$ to
126: $5500{\rm~\AA}$ and the Ca II IR triplet around $8200{\rm~\AA}$
127: are prominent. The inconspicuous absorption near $7160{\rm~\AA}$
128: can also be attributed to Fe II. The absorption near
129: $7500{\rm~\AA}$ is usually attributed to O I $\lambda 7773$, but
130: the absorption here is too red for O I to fit it well. So we
131: introduce Mg II $\lambda\lambda 7877,7896$ and blend it with the O
132: I line. Both the Na I D lines and He I $\lambda 5876$ are
133: candidates for the strong P Cygni feature around $5700{\rm~\AA}$.
134: We favor He I because it can also account for other observed
135: features with the $\lambda\lambda 6678$ and $7065$ lines. The
136: absorption minimum at $6200{\rm~\AA}$ was originally identified as
137: Si II $\lambda 6355$ \citep{aya99,qiu299,tur99}, but through
138: spectrum synthesis we have found that it is better fit by the
139: $\lambda 6580$ line of C II, detached at $20,000{\rm~km~s^{-1}}$.
140: C II $\lambda\lambda 4738,4745$ may also contribute to the
141: absorption near $4500{\rm~\AA}$.
142:
143: The observed spectrum of Aug. 31 is similar to that of Aug. 21 in
144: the overall shape and can be synthesized with $T_{bb}=7000{\rm~K}$
145: and $v_{ph}=12,000{\rm~km~s^{-1}}$. Now the C II $\lambda 6580$ P
146: Cygni feature becomes distinct from that of He I $\lambda 6678$.
147: The minimum velocity of the detached C II is now taken to be
148: $19,000{\rm~km~s^{-1}}$. Now the optical depth of Fe II is too
149: small to produce the observed absorption around $7190{\rm~\AA}$.
150: We find that only [O II] $\lambda\lambda 7320,7330$ can match it
151: while not contaminating the synthetic spectrum elsewhere. But we
152: are not sure that whether the physical conditions to form the
153: forbidden lines can be satisfied (see also \citep{fis97,mil99}).
154: The strong P Cygni feature near $3800{\rm~\AA}$ is Ca II H\&K.
155:
156: We use the parameters $T_{bb}=5300{\rm~K}$ and
157: $v_{ph}=9000{\rm~km~s^{-1}}$ to synthesize the spectrum of Sep.
158: 14. From the upper panel of Figure 3, we can see that the He I P
159: Cygni lines of $\lambda\lambda 5876$, $6678$ and $7065$ are
160: strong. He I also helps to form the observed features near
161: $4360{\rm~\AA}$, $4580{\rm~\AA}$ and $4860{\rm~\AA}$. The deep
162: absorptions at $4360{\rm~\AA}$ and $9000{\rm~\AA}$ can be matched
163: mostly with Mg II $\lambda 4481$ and $\lambda\lambda 9218,9244$,
164: which supports our identification of this ion above. The gentle
165: slope from $6210{\rm~\AA}$ to $6410{\rm~\AA}$ is produced by Ca I
166: lines, Fe II lines, and C II $\lambda 6580$ detached at
167: $10,000{\rm~km~s^{-1}}$. C II $\lambda\lambda 4738,4745$, blended
168: with He I $\lambda 4713$, can also account for the absorption at
169: $4580{\rm~\AA}$. Similarly, the absorptions at $4150{\rm~\AA}$,
170: $5420{\rm~\AA}$ and $6130{\rm~\AA}$ can be partially or entirely
171: explained by Ca I. Ni II line is used to fit the absorption at
172: ${3930 \rm~\AA}$. Note the signal-to-noise ratio per pixel around
173: this feature is $\sim 50$. This ion also brings two absorption
174: features around ${3660 \rm~\AA}$ and ${3500 \rm~\AA}$. Another
175: slope from $7900{\rm~\AA}$ to $8150{\rm~\AA}$ is explicable if Na
176: I $\lambda\lambda 8183,8195$ and C I $\lambda 8335$ are
177: introduced, but then the synthetic spectrum around $5700{\rm~\AA}$
178: and $9000{\rm~\AA}$ gets worse. For comparison, we plot the
179: synthetic spectrum without Ca I, Ni II, Na I and C I as the dotted
180: line in the upper panel of Figure 3.
181:
182: The optical depths of the reference lines and other fitting
183: parameters for Figure 1 --- Figure 3 are listed in table 1 ---
184: table 3, respectively.
185:
186: \section{Discussion}
187:
188: \citet{pas99} indicated that the spectra of SN 1999dn were very
189: similar to that of SN 1997X and identified it as a Type Ib/c event
190: in accordance with the previous classification of the latter
191: \citep{gar97,mun98}, while others noted both as Type Ic supernovae
192: \citep{sun97,ben97,aya99,tur99}. But by comparing the spectrum of
193: SN 1999dn in Aug. 30 and of SN 1997X, presented by \citet{mun98},
194: with that of the prototypical Type Ib SN 1984L of Aug. 30, plotted
195: by \citet{har87} in their Figure 3, one can see that those three
196: spectra, all near maximum light, strikingly resemble each other
197: almost in all features and differ with the early-time spectrum of
198: Type Ic supernovae mainly in two aspects: (1) the He I optical P
199: Cygni lines of SN 1999dn, SN 1997X and SN 1984L are prominent,
200: while in the prototypical Type Ic SN 1994I He I line are hardly
201: discernible, although \citet{clo96} claimed evidence of very weak
202: He I lines in spectra with good signal-to-noise ratio; and (2)
203: unlike the $6150{\rm~\AA}$ absorption feature usually seen in the
204: early-time spectra of SNe Ic, the minimum at $\sim
205: 6200{\rm~\AA}-6400{\rm~\AA}$ in SN 1999dn, SN 1997X and SN 1984L
206: is hard to attribute to Si II $\lambda 6355$, as demonstrated in
207: the lower panels of Figure 1 --- Figure 3 . It has been supposed
208: that C II $\lambda 6580$ is responsible for this feature in SNe Ib
209: \citep{har87}; this is supported by our spectrum synthesis here
210: and in particular by the identification of C II $\lambda\lambda
211: 4738,4745$ in the Sep. 14 spectrum of SN 1999dn. We regard both SN
212: 1999dn and SN 1997X as typical Type Ib supernovae.
213:
214: The relative strengths of the He I lines $\lambda\lambda 5876$,
215: $6678$ and $7065$ can not be completely fitted by SYNOW. In
216: Figure 1 and Figure 2, we choose to fit $\lambda 5876$ best, and
217: then $\lambda\lambda 6678$, $7065$ are somewhat weaker than
218: observed. In Figure 3, the calculated $\lambda 6678$ is the right
219: strength, but $\lambda 5876$ is too strong and $\lambda 7065$ is
220: too weak. Such NLTE effects may be caused by nonthermal excitation
221: from Comptonized gamma rays released in the decay of $^{56}{\rm
222: Ni}$ that has been mixed into the helium envelope
223: \citep{shi90,luc91}. Note the Ni II line which we introduced above
224: to fit the ${3930 \rm~\AA}$ absorption in the spectrum of Sep. 14.
225: This could be direct early-time spectral evidence of $^{56}{\rm
226: Ni}$ mixing in the explosion of a Type Ib supernova. As for the
227: Aug. 31 spectrum, despite its poor signal-to-noise ratio, we are
228: sure that the introduction of Ni II lines to the synthetic
229: spectrum can not improve the fit. The velocity upper limit of the
230: mixed $^{56}{\rm Ni}$ may be $\sim 10,000{\rm~km~s^{-1}}$, which
231: is larger than the value predicted by explosion simulations
232: \citep{har94,kif99}.
233:
234: One question remains of the minimum velocity of C II that we used
235: to explain the absorption near $6300{\rm~\AA}$. Why should this
236: ion be detached around $20,000{\rm~km~s^{-1}}$ at the earliest
237: times, but then detached at a much lower velocity of $\sim
238: 10,000{\rm~km~s^{-1}}$ on Sep. 14? Does it imply two different C
239: II velocity components in the helium layer? An alternative
240: scenario that seems more attractive and probable, is that at the
241: earliest times this feature is produced by ${\rm H}{\alpha}$,
242: which always fits as well as C II $\lambda 6580$ (see the dotted
243: lines in the lower panels of Figure 1 --- Figure 3). In the Aug.
244: 21 and Aug. 31 spectra, H I would be detached by
245: $19,000{\rm~km~s^{-1}}$ and $18,000{\rm~km~s^{-1}}$, respectively.
246: In the Sep. 14 spectrum, on the other hand, the identification of
247: C II $\lambda 6580$ is unambiguous because H I can not explain the
248: observed absorption at $4580{\rm~\AA}$. Actually, on Aug. 31 a
249: contribution from C II can not be excluded because the observed
250: feature is stronger than in Aug. 21 and Sep. 14. The other
251: synthesized H I lines like ${\rm H}{\beta}$ are swamped by Fe II
252: lines and are too weak to be identified.
253:
254: To summarize, we suppose that a thin high-velocity hydrogen skin
255: exits outside of the helium layer in SN 1999dn, with ${\rm
256: H}{\alpha}$ appearing only before and near maximum light. As the
257: envelope expands and the photosphere recedes deeper into the
258: helium layer, the optical depth of ${\rm H}{\alpha}$ diminishes
259: naturally and eventually is overwhelmed by C II $\lambda 6580$. We
260: note that other authors \citep{fil90,jef91} have presented some
261: evidence, though inconclusive, of ${\rm H}{\alpha}$ in some Type
262: Ic supernovae, especially SN 1987M, and argued that SNe II and SNe
263: Ic have similar physical origins. Similarly, our identification of
264: ${\rm H}{\alpha}$ in SN 1999dn provides a link between the
265: progenitors and explosion mechanisms of Type Ib supernovae and
266: Type IIb events such as 1987K and 1993J.
267:
268: \acknowledgments
269:
270: We would like to thank all observational astronomers at the 2.16m
271: telescope of BAO, in particular J. Y. Wei, D. W. Xu and L. Cao,
272: for their help in our observations of SN 1999dn. This work is
273: supported in part by the National Science Foundation of China.
274:
275: \begin{thebibliography}{}
276: \bibitem[Ayani et al.(1999)]{aya99} Ayani, K., Furusho, R.,
277: Kawakita, H., Fujii, M., and Yamaoka, H. 1999, \iaucirc, 7244
278: \bibitem[Benetti et al.(1997)]{ben97} Benetti, S., Turatto, M.,
279: Perez, I., and Wisotzki, L. 1997, \iaucirc, 6554
280: \bibitem[Cappellaro, Evans and Turatto(1999)]{cap99} Cappellaro,
281: E., Evans, R., and Turrato, M. 1999, \aap, 351, 459
282: \bibitem[Clocchiatti et al.(1996)]{clo96} Clocchiatti, A.,
283: Wheeler, J. C., Brotherton, M. S., Cochran, A. L., Wills, D., and
284: Barker, E. S. 1996, \apj, 462, 462
285: \bibitem[Filippenko, Porter and Sargent(1990)]{fil90} Filippenko, A. V.,
286: Porter, A .C. and Sargent, W. W. 1990, \aj, 100, 1575
287: \bibitem[Filippenko(1997)]{fil97} Filippenko, A. V. 1997, \araa,
288: 35, 309
289: \bibitem[Fisher et al.(1997)]{fis97} Fisher, A., Branch, D.,
290: Nugent, P., and Baron, E. 1997, \apj, 481, L89
291: \bibitem[Garnavich, Kirshner and Berlind(1997)]{gar97} Garnavich, P., Kirshner,
292: R., and Berlind, P. 1997, \iaucirc, 6552
293: \bibitem[Harchisu(1994)]{har94} Harchisu, I., Matsuda, T., Nomoto,
294: K., and Shigeyama, T, 1994, \aaps, 104, 341
295: \bibitem[Harkness et al.(1987)]{har87} Harkness, R. P., Wheeler,
296: J. C., Margon, B., Downes, R. A., Kirshner, R. P., Uomoto, A.,
297: Barker, E. S., Cochran, A. L., Dinerstein, H. L., Garnett,
298: D. R., and Leverault, R. M. 1987, \apjs, 317, 355
299: \bibitem[Hatano et al.(1999)]{hat99} Hatano, K., Branch, D.,
300: Fisher, A., Deaton, J., and Baron, E. 1999, \apjs, 121, 233
301: \bibitem[Jeffery and Branch(1990)]{jef90} Jeffery, D. J.,
302: and Branch, D. 1990, in ``Supernova'', ed. J. C. Wheeler, T. Piran,
303: and S. Weinberg, Singapore: World Scientific, 149
304: \bibitem[Jeffery et al.(1991)]{jef91} Jeffery, D. J., Branch, D.,
305: Filippenko, A. V., and Nomoto, K. 1991, \apj, 377, L89
306: \bibitem[Kifonidis et al.(1999)]{kif99} Kifonidis, K., Plewa, T.,
307: Janka, H. Th., and M\"{u}ller, E. 1999, \apj, submitted
308: (astro-ph/9911183)
309: \bibitem[Lucy(1991)]{luc91} Lucy, L. B. 1991, \apj, 383, 308
310: \bibitem[Millard et al. (1999)]{mil99} Millard, J. et al. 1999, \apj,
311: 527, 746
312: \bibitem[Munari et al.(1998)]{mun98} Munari, U., Barbon, R.,
313: Piemonte, A., Tomasella, L., and Rejkuba, M. 1998, \aap, 333,
314: 159
315: \bibitem[Pastorello et al.(1999)]{pas99} Pastorello, A., Turatto,
316: M., Rizzi, L., Cappellaro, E., Benetti, S., and Patat, F. 1999,
317: \iaucirc, 7245
318: \bibitem[Piemonte(1997)]{pie97} Piemonte, A. 1997, in "SN 1987A: Ten Years After", ed. M.
319: Phillips and N. Suntzeff, preprint
320: \bibitem[Qiu et al.(1999 Paper I)]{qiu199} Qiu, Y. L., Qiao, Q. Y., Hu, J,
321: Y., Zhou, X., and Zheng, Z. 1999, \iaucirc, 7241
322: \bibitem[Qiu et al.(1999 Paper II)]{qiu299} Qiu, Y. L., Huang, L., Yao, B.,
323: and Li, H. 1999, \iaucirc, 7244
324: \bibitem[Shigeyama et al.(1990)]{shi90} Shigeyama, T., Nomoto, K.,
325: Tsujimoto, T., and Hashimoto, M. 1990, \apj, 361, L23
326: \bibitem[Suntzeff et al.(1997)]{sun97} Suntzeff, N. B.,
327: Clocchiatti, A., Phillips, M. M., and Kim, D. W. 1997,
328: \iaucirc, 6552
329: \bibitem[Turatto et al.(1999)]{tur99} Turatto, M., Rizzi, L.,
330: Salvo, M., Cappellaro, E., Benetti, S., and Patat, F. 1999,
331: \iaucirc, 7244
332: \bibitem[Wheeler et al.(1994)]{whe94} Wheeler, J. C., Harkness, R.
333: P., Clocchiatti, A., Benetti, S., and Brotherton, M. S. 1994,
334: \apj, 436, L35
335: \bibitem[Wheeler, H\"{o}flich and Wang(1999)]{whe99} Wheeler, J. C.,
336: H\"{o}flich, P., and Wang, L. F. 1999, in workshop on Future
337: Directions of Supernova Research: Progenitors to Remnants,
338: preprint (astro-ph/9904047)
339: \end{thebibliography}
340:
341: \clearpage
342:
343: \begin{deluxetable}{lcr}
344: \tabletypesize{\scriptsize} \tablecaption{The BAO Spectra of SN
345: 1999dn \label{tbl-1}} \tablewidth{0pt} \tablehead{ \colhead{Date
346: (UT)} & \colhead{Exposure (seconds)} & \colhead{Standard}}
347: \startdata 1999 Aug. 21.5 & 3600 & Feige110\\ 1999 Aug. 31.6 &
348: 2400 & BD284211\\ 1999 Sep. 14.5 & 3600 & BD284211\\
349: \enddata
350: \end{deluxetable}
351:
352: \begin{deluxetable}{lcrccc}
353: \tabletypesize{\scriptsize} \tablecaption{Fitting Parameters for
354: Figure 1 ($v_{ph}=16,000{\rm~km~s^{-1}}$, $T_{bb}=7500{\rm~K}$)
355: \label{tbl-2}} \tablewidth{0pt} \tablehead{\colhead{Ion} &
356: \colhead{$\lambda({\rm\AA})$} & \colhead{$\tau$} &
357: \colhead{$v_{\min}(10^{3}{\rm~km~s^{-1}})$} &
358: \colhead{$v_{\max}(10^{3}{\rm~km~s^{-1}})$} &
359: \colhead{$T_{exc}(10^{3}{\rm~K})$}} \startdata He I & 5876 & 10 &
360: 16 & 50 & 7.5\\ O I & 7772 & 1 & 16 & 50 & 7.5\\ Mg II & 4481 & 3
361: & 16 & 50 & 7.5\\ Ca II & 3934 & 500 & 16 & 50 & 7.5\\ Fe II &
362: 5018 & 15 & 16 & 50 & 7.5\\ H I & 6563 & 3 & 19 & 50 & 7.5\\ C II
363: & 4267 & 0.02 & 20 & 50 & 7.5\\ Si II & 6347 & 3 & 16 & 50 & 7.5\\
364: \enddata
365: \end{deluxetable}
366:
367: \begin{deluxetable}{lcrccc}
368: \tabletypesize{\scriptsize} \tablecaption{Fitting Parameters for
369: Figure 2 ($v_{ph}=12,000{\rm~km~s^{-1}}$, $T_{bb}=7000{\rm~K}$)
370: \label{tbl-3}} \tablewidth{0pt} \tablehead{\colhead{Ion} &
371: \colhead{$\lambda({\rm\AA})$} & \colhead{$\tau$} &
372: \colhead{$v_{\min}(10^{3}{\rm~km~s^{-1}})$} &
373: \colhead{$v_{\max}(10^{3}{\rm~km~s^{-1}})$} &
374: \colhead{$T_{exc}(10^{3}{\rm~K})$}} \startdata He I & 5876 & 7 &
375: 12 & 50 & 7\\ O I & 7772 & 1 & 12 & 50 & 7\\ Mg II & 4481 & 3 & 12
376: & 50 & 7\\ Ca II & 3934 & 200 & 12 & 50 & 7\\ Fe II & 5018 & 10 &
377: 12 & 50 & 7\\ $[$O II$]$ & 7321 & 0.5 & 12 & 50 & 7\\ H I & 6563 &
378: 1 & 18 & 50 & 7\\ C II & 4267 & 0.005 & 19 & 50 & 7\\ Si II & 6347
379: & 2 & 12 & 50 & 7\\
380: \enddata
381: \end{deluxetable}
382:
383: \begin{deluxetable}{lcrccc}
384: \tabletypesize{\scriptsize} \tablecaption{Fitting Parameters for
385: Figure 3 ($v_{ph}=9000{\rm~km~s^{-1}}$, $T_{bb}=5300{\rm~K}$)
386: \label{tbl-4}} \tablewidth{0pt} \tablehead{\colhead{Ion} &
387: \colhead{$\lambda({\rm\AA})$} & \colhead{$\tau$} &
388: \colhead{$v_{\min}(10^{3}{\rm~km~s^{-1}})$} &
389: \colhead{$v_{\max}(10^{3}{\rm~km~s^{-1}})$} &
390: \colhead{$T_{exc}(10^{3}{\rm~K})$}} \startdata He I & 5876 & 10 &
391: 9 & 50 & 5.3\\ O I & 7772 & 0.3 & 9 & 50 & 5.3\\ Mg II & 4481 & 4
392: & 9 & 50 & 5.3\\ Ca II & 3934 & 700 & 9 & 50 & 5.3\\ Fe II & 5018
393: & 5 & 9 & 50 & 7\\ $[$O II$]$ & 7321 & 0.2 & 9 & 50 & 5.3\\ H I &
394: 6563 & 0.8 & 9 & 50 & 5.3\\ C II & 4267 & 0.0005 & 10 & 50 & 5.3\\
395: Si II & 6347 & 0.5 & 9 & 50 & 5.3\\ C I & 9095 & 6 & 9 & 50 &
396: 5.3\\ Na I & 5890 & 12 & 9 & 50 & 5.3\\ Ca I & 4227 & 3 & 9 & 50 &
397: 9\\ Ni II & 4067 & 2.5 & 9 & 50 & 7\\
398: \enddata
399: \end{deluxetable}
400:
401: \clearpage
402:
403: \begin{figure}
404: \epsscale{0.8} \plotone{f1.eps} \caption{The observed spectrum of
405: Aug. 21 (thin solid lines) is compared with synthetic spectra
406: which have $T_{bb}=7500{\rm~K}$ and
407: $v_{ph}=16,000{\rm~km~s^{-1}}$. In the upper panel, the synthetic
408: spectrum with C II is plotted on the thick solid line. In the
409: lower panel, C II is replaced by Si II (thick solid line) and H I
410: (dotted line), respectively. }
411: \end{figure}
412:
413:
414: \begin{figure}
415: \epsscale{0.8} \plotone{f2.eps} \caption{The observed spectrum of
416: Aug. 31 (thin solid lines) is compared with synthetic spectra
417: which have $T_{bb}=7000{\rm~K}$ and
418: $v_{ph}=12,000{\rm~km~s^{-1}}$. In the upper panel, the synthetic
419: spectrum with C II is plotted on the thick solid line. In the
420: lower panel, C II is replaced by Si II (thick solid line) and H I
421: (dotted line), respectively.}
422: \end{figure}
423:
424:
425: \begin{figure}
426: \epsscale{0.8} \plotone{f3.eps} \caption{The observed spectrum of
427: Sep. 14 (thin solid lines) is compared with synthetic spectra
428: which have $T_{bb}=5300{\rm~K}$ and $v_{ph}=9000{\rm~km~s^{-1}}$.
429: In the upper panel, the synthetic spectrum with C II is plotted on
430: the thick solid line, while on the dotted line Ca I, Ni II, Na I
431: and C I are removed. In the lower panel, C II is replaced by Si II
432: (thick solid line) and H I (dotted line), respectively.}
433: \end{figure}
434:
435: \end{document}
436: