1: % Contributed paper for FIRSED
2: % Almudena Prieto
3: %
4:
5: \documentclass{elsart}
6:
7: \usepackage{graphics}
8: \usepackage{natbib}
9: \usepackage{amssymb}
10:
11: \begin{document}
12:
13: \begin{frontmatter}
14:
15: \title{The origin of the mid- and far-infrared emission in AGN}
16:
17: \author[eso,iac]{M. Almudena Prieto}
18: %\ead{aprieto@eso.org}
19: \author[iac]{Ana P\'erez-Garc\'{\i}a}
20: %\ead{apg@ll.iac.es}
21: \author[iac]{Jos\'e M. Rodr\'{\i}guez-Espinosa}
22: %\ead{jre@ll.iac.es}
23:
24: \address[eso]{European\,Southern\,Observatory, Karl-Schwarzschild-Strasse\,2, D--85748~Garching}
25: \address[iac]{Instituto de Astrof\'{\i}sica de Canarias,
26: E-38200~La~Laguna, Tenerife}
27:
28: \begin{abstract}
29: The relation between the X-ray emission, the infrared emission and
30: the coronal line emission in a sample of the
31: brightest known Seyfert galaxies is analyzed.
32: A close relationship between the absorption-corrected soft X-ray emission
33: and both the mid-infrared and the coronal line emission is found among the
34: Seyfert type\,2 objects studied in this work.
35: Being both the coronal line and the X-ray emissions main
36: tracers of the AGN activity, their relation with the mid-infrared
37: emission adds further support to the claim that the mid-infrared
38: emission is primarily due to dust heated
39: directly by the central AGN. No apparent relationship
40: between the soft X-ray emission
41: and the coronal line and/or the mid-infrared emissions is seen within
42: Seyfert\,1 objects, the number of objects of this class in the sample
43: is comparatively smaller though.
44: That discrepancy is partially due to the fact that the soft X-ray emission in
45: the Seyfert\,1s is
46: systematically larger by at least one order of magnitude
47: than that in their Seyfert\,2 counterparts.
48: Finally, the hard X-ray emission in both Seyfert types
49: shows unrelated to the mid-infrared and coronal line emissions.
50: \end{abstract}
51: \begin{keyword}
52: continuum: IR, X-rays -- emission lines: coronal -- galaxies: Seyfert
53: \end{keyword}
54:
55: \end{frontmatter}
56:
57: \vspace{-12mm}
58: \section{Introduction}
59: \vspace{-6mm}
60: Coronal lines arising in the spectra of AGNs are unique tracers of the
61: pure AGN power mechanism. These lines require ionization potentials
62: (IP) beyond 50\,eV, and thus their study provides clues on the ionizing
63: continuum spectrum, which on the other hand is difficult to probe
64: from observations, because of the heavy absorption.
65:
66: In a previous work (Prieto et al. 2000) the emission from the two
67: strongest coronal lines, [O\,IV]$\lambda$25.9\,$\mu$m and
68: [Ne\,V]$\lambda$14.5\,$\mu$m, in the ISO
69: spectra of a sample of bright Seyfert galaxies was found to be
70: related to the mid-infrared continuum emission arising in these
71: objects. Because of the nuclear origin of coronal lines, this
72: relation was interpreted as the mid-infrared being due to
73: emission by dust heated primarily by the central AGN.
74:
75: In this paper, that relation is explored further on the basis of X-ray
76: data available for the galaxies in the sample. The reasoning behind is
77: as follows. Being the IP of $O^{2+}$ about 50\,eV and that of
78: $Ne^{3+}$ 100\,eV, a correlation between the [O\,IV] and [Ne\,V] line
79: fluxes and the soft X-ray emission might be anticipated. If, as argued
80: in Prieto et al. (2000), the emission in the mid-infrared is due to
81: dust mostly
82: heated within the AGN nuclear region, a further relation between the
83: mid-infrared continuum emission and the soft X-ray emission is also
84: expected. We explore those predictions, taking as a reference a sample
85: of the brightest known Seyfert galaxies which are studied by us in
86: detail with ISO. This sample contains seven Seyfert type\,2 and four
87: Seyfert type\,1 and includes prototypes objects such as NGC\,1068,
88: NGC\,4151
89: and Circinus. The ISO coronal line spectrum of the sample is studied
90: in Prieto and Viegas (2000); the mid- to far-infrared continuum emission is
91: studied in P\'erez-Garc\'{\i}a et al. (2000); the relationship between the infrared
92: continuum and the coronal line emission is discussed in Prieto et al.
93: (2000).
94:
95: \vspace{-6mm}
96: \section{Observational data}
97: \vspace{-7mm}
98: The sample of Seyfert galaxies used in this work is originally
99: presented in Prieto \& Viegas (2000). All the galaxies were observed
100: with ISO SWS at the wavelengths of [O\,IV]$\lambda$25.9\,$\mu$m,
101: [Ne\,V]$\lambda 14.3$\,$\mu$m, [Mg\,VIII]$\lambda 3.02$\,$\mu$m and
102: [Si\,IX]$\lambda 2.58$\,$\mu$m. Integrated line fluxes from the two
103: strongest lines in the Seyfert spectra, [O\,IV] and [Ne\,V], are used
104: in this work.
105: Continuum fluxes at 16, 25 and 60\,$\mu$m measured with ISOPHOT
106: and 10\,$\mu$m ground-based data
107: existing for all the sources are also used. Those data are taken from
108: P\'erez-Garc\'{\i}a et al. (2000).
109:
110: \vspace{-1mm}
111: The soft X-ray emission, namely in the 0.2--2.4\,keV region, is primarily
112: derived from the ROSAT PSPC. For homogeneity purposes, when available
113: PSPC pointing observations, the absorption-corrected X-ray emission is derived
114: by us after applying an absorbed power-law fit to the PSPC spectrum.
115: In all cases, statistically acceptable fits were derived, with all the
116: fitting parameters; column density, power-law spectral index and
117: normalization, derived within reasonable constraints. For those
118: cases in which the derived column density was lower than the
119: corresponding Galactic value, this was used instead as a fixed parameter
120: in the fit and the integrated X-ray emission derived accordingly. In
121: either case, the
122: error associated to the X-ray flux refers to 1\,$\sigma$ uncertainty in the
123: fit. For those sources with known complex spectrum and/or morphology,
124: integrated absorption corrected fluxes were taken from the literature. In these
125: cases, the error considered represents the amplitude of the variation
126: between different measurements in the literature.
127:
128: Finally, for the hard X-ray emission, namely the 2--10\,keV region,
129: absorption-corrected fluxes are in all cases taken from the
130: literature. Preference was given to ASCA or BESPOSAX data.
131: In general, when several absorption-corrected fluxes were reported, an
132: average value is used and the associated error reflects the amplitude
133: of the variation. The sample includes three known Compton thick
134: sources: NGC\,1068, Mrk\,533 and Circinus. In these cases, the associated
135: hard X-ray emission may be subjected to large uncertainties as the
136: derived values are strongly model dependent.
137: Further details on the analysis of the X-ray data are given in Prieto
138: et al. (2000).
139:
140:
141: \begin{figure}
142: %\vspace{22.0cm}
143: \begin{center}
144: \resizebox{14cm}{!}{\includegraphics{aprieto_fig1.ps}}
145: \parbox[b]{14cm}{
146: \vspace{2mm}
147: \caption[] {The relation between the soft X-ray emission and
148: the coronal line and mid-infrared emission in Seyfert galaxies. Filled
149: circles represent Seyfert 2 objects and the intermediate
150: Seyfert type NGC4151.}
151: }
152: \label{Figure 1}
153: \end{center}
154: \end{figure}
155:
156:
157: \vspace{-8mm}
158: \section{Results}
159: \vspace{-6mm}
160: For all the galaxies in the sample, Fig.~1 compares the integrated
161: absorption-corrected soft X-ray emission with respectively the coronal
162: line fluxes of [O\,IV] and [Ne\,V] (first row), and with the 10, 16, 25
163: and 60\,$\mu$m continuum emission (second and third rows in Fig.~1).
164: The comparison with the respective warm and cold infrared emission as
165: defined in P\'erez-Garc\'{\i}a et al. (2000) is shown in the last row of the
166: figure. Seyfert\,2 galaxies are marked with circles to differentiate
167: them from their Seyfert\,1 counterparts.
168:
169: A rather scatter diagram is present in all cases; yet, when the
170: comparison is restricted to the Seyfert\,2 objects, a trend is
171: apparent. This is particularly clear when considering the coronal line
172: emission and the 10\,$\mu$m flux emission; the trend becomes less
173: clear when involving colder infrared fluxes and almost vanishes when
174: considering the 60\,$\mu$m flux. The apparent relationship involving
175: the Seyfert\,2 objects shows again when comparing the soft X-rays with
176: the warm infrared flux whereas no correlation is seen with the cold
177: infrared flux.
178:
179: The intermediate Seyfert type\,1.5 galaxy NGC\,4151, also shares the
180: same increasing trend as the Seyfert\,2 type objects. However, the
181: position in the diagrams of the four Seyfert\,1 objects in the sample,
182: NGC\,5548, NGC\,5033, Mrk\,335 and Mrk\,817 markedly depart from the
183: Seyfert\,2 trend. That is in part due to the fact that their integrated soft
184: X-ray emission is substantially larger by more than one order of
185: magnitude than that from the Seyfert\,2 objects.
186:
187: On the other hand, the trends above described contrast with the pure
188: scatter diagram arising when the comparison is done with the
189: absorption-corrected hard X-ray fluxes (not shown).
190:
191: \vspace{-5mm}
192: \section{Discussion}
193: \vspace{-5mm}
194: The [O\,IV] and [Ne\,V] coronal lines discussed in this work imply the
195: presence of ions with
196: ionization potential of 50\,eV and 100\,eV respectively. Thus,
197: a correlation between the coronal line emission and
198: the soft-Xray emission is
199: somewhat expected if considered that the energy required to produce
200: those high ionization species is very close to the soft X-ray energies
201: here considered.
202:
203: The soft X-ray emission shows also related to the mid-infrared emission
204: arising from these galaxies. In Prieto et al. (2000), the mid-infrared
205: emission was also found closely related to the coronal line emission
206: arising in the nucleus of these galaxies. Both results point to the
207: AGN as the dominant heating source of the circumnuclear dust. On the
208: other hand, circumnuclear star-forming regions are expected to further
209: contribute to the heating of the dust at mid-infrared wavelengths. Indeed,
210: ISOCAM images in the 5--8\,$\mu$m range reveal disks and/or multiple
211: emitting structures in some of these objects (P\'erez-Garc\'{\i}a et
212: al. in preparation). Thus, some dispersion in the relation between the
213: soft X-ray and the mid-infrared continuum might be expected, particularly
214: taking into account the large aperture size of the ISOPHOT
215: measurements. Note that the relationship shows however more clear when
216: involving the ground-base 10\,$\mu$m emission, which is measured in
217: apertures about or smaller than $10''$.
218:
219: The few Seyfert\,1 galaxies in the sample present a soft X-ray
220: emission larger by at least an order of magnitude than those measured
221: in their
222: Seyfert\,2 counterparts. Such difference seems to be a
223: characteristic of Seyfert\,1 galaxies: Rush et al. (1996) reported on
224: systematically larger soft X-ray luminosities in Seyfert\,1 galaxies
225: on the basis of a much larger sample of Seyfert galaxies.
226: The authors report also on
227: a correlation -- in luminosities -- between the 12\,$\mu$m
228: IRAS emission and the soft X-ray emission for all the galaxies in their
229: sample regardless of the Seyfert type. In the present sample,
230: we find that the larger soft X-ray emission of the Seyfert\,1
231: objects make them already depart from the overall trend shown by the
232: Seyfert\,2s; subjected to the small number of Seyfert\,1
233: objects considered, the
234: soft X-ray emission of these objects shows indeed no trend at all with
235: their either coronal line or mid-infrared emission.
236: The discrepancy is somewhat unexpected, in particular if
237: considered the positive trends --in fluxes-- found within
238: the Seyfert\,2 class. If confirmed on a much larger sample, it would
239: indicate the presence of an additional X-ray component that is
240: dominant and rather anisotropic in Seyfert\,1s but unseen in
241: Seyfert\,2 objects.
242:
243: Moving to the hard X-rays, not apparent trend between the
244: absorption-corrected emission and either
245: the coronal line or the infrared continuum
246: emissions is detected.
247: This is somewhat expected if considered that first,
248: heating of the dust from energies beyond 2\,keV would lead to hotter
249: dust emitting at higher infrared frequencies;
250: second, the energies required to produce the high ionization species
251: considered in this work, $O^{2+}$ and $Ne^{3+}$, is well below 2\,keV.
252:
253:
254: Contini et al. (1998 and
255: references therein) have modeled the
256: spectral energy distribution of Seyfert\,2 galaxies and
257: shown that the re-emission
258: by dust in the infrared is closely related to bremsstrahlung from hot gas
259: (X-ray) in the
260: vicinity of the nucleus. Indeed, the temperature of the gas and that
261: of the grains are found to be closely related. In particular, in
262: models that account for the combined effect of photoionization and
263: shocks, soft X-ray are found mainly emitted from hot gas in the
264: immediate post shock region. Mutual heating between dust and gas
265: leads to the corresponding emission by dust in the near--mid infrared. The
266: observed relationship between the mid-infrared and the soft X-ray emissions
267: revealed by this sample provides support to that scenario.
268:
269: The detailed analysis of this work will appear in Prieto, P\'erez-Garc\'{\i}a
270: \& Rodr\'{\i}guez-Espinosa (2000).
271:
272: \label{}
273:
274:
275: \begin{thebibliography}{}
276:
277: % \bibitem[Names(Year)]{label} or \bibitem[Names(Year)Long names]{label}.
278: % (\harvarditem{Name}{Year}{label} is also supported.)
279: % Text of bibliographic item
280: %{\bf References}
281:
282: \bibitem[TC(98)]{a} Contini M., Prieto M.A., Viegas S.M., 1998, ApJ~505,~621
283: \bibitem[ampc(00)]{b} P\'erez-Garc\'{\i}a A.M.,
284: Rodr\'{\i}guez-Espinosa J.M., 2000, ApJ~in press (astro-ph/003349)
285:
286: \bibitem[map(00)]{c} Prieto M.A., Viegas S.M., 2000, ApJ~252,~238
287:
288: \bibitem[map(00a)]{d} Prieto M.A., P\'erez-Garc\'{\i}a A.M.,
289: Rodr\'{\i}guez-Espinosa J.M., 2000, A\&A~in press
290:
291: \bibitem[br(96)]{e} Rush B., Malkan M., Fink H., Voges W. 1996, ApJ~471,~190
292:
293: \end{thebibliography}
294:
295: \end{document}
296:
297: