1: % \documentclass{aastex}
2: \documentclass[preprint]{aastex}
3: % \documentclass[preprint2]{aastex}
4: % \usepackage{emulateapj5}
5:
6: \received{2001 March 20}
7: \accepted{2001 April 17}
8:
9: \slugcomment{To appear in the {\em Astrophysical Journal Letters.}}
10:
11: \shorttitle{Inner Light Year of Seyfert Nucleus in NGC\,4395}
12: \shortauthors{Wrobel, Fassnacht, \& Ho}
13:
14: \begin{document}
15:
16: \title{The Inner Light Year of the Nearest Seyfert~1 Nucleus in NGC\,4395}
17: \author{J.~M. Wrobel and C.~D. Fassnacht\altaffilmark{1}}
18: \affil{National Radio Astronomy Observatory,
19: P.O. Box O, Socorro, New Mexico 87801}
20: \and
21: \author{L.~C. Ho}
22: \affil{The Observatories of the Carnegie Institution of Washington,\\
23: 813 Santa Barbara Street, Pasadena, CA 91101}
24: \email{jwrobel@nrao.edu, cfassnacht@nrao.edu, lho@ociw.edu}
25:
26: \altaffiltext{1}{Current address: Space Telescope Science
27: Institute, 3700 San Martin Drive, Baltimore, MD 21218}
28:
29: \begin{abstract}
30: The NRAO VLBA was used at 1.4~GHz to image the inner 550~mas
31: (23~lt-years) of the nearest known Seyfert~1 nucleus, in the Sm galaxy
32: NGC\,4395. One continuum source was detected, with flux density
33: $530\pm130~\mu$Jy, diameter $d < 11$~mas (0.46~lt-year), and
34: brightness temperature $T_{\rm b} > 2.0\times10^6$~K. The spectral
35: power $P\/$ of the VLBA source is intermediate between those of
36: Sagittarius\,A and Sagittarius\,A$^*$ in the Galactic Center. For the
37: VLBA source in NGC\,4395, the constraints on $T_b$, $d\/$, and $P\/$
38: are consistent with an origin from a black hole but exclude an origin
39: from a compact starburst or a supernova remnant like Cassiopeia\,A.
40: Moreover, the spectral powers of NGC\,4395 at 1.4 and 4.9~GHz appear
41: to be too low and too constant to allow analogy with SN\,1988Z, a
42: suggested prototype for models of compact supernova remnants. The
43: variable and warm X-ray absorber in NGC\,4395 has a free-free optical
44: depth much larger than unity at 1.4~GHz and, therefore, cannot fully
45: cover the VLBA source.
46: \end{abstract}
47:
48: \keywords{galaxies: active -
49: galaxies: individual (NGC\,4395, UGC\,07524) -
50: galaxies: nuclei -
51: galaxies: Seyfert -
52: radio continuum: galaxies -
53: X-rays: galaxies}
54:
55: \section{MOTIVATION}
56:
57: The Seyfert~1 nucleus of NGC\,4395 holds three unique distinctions.
58: First, in the optical regime it is the least luminous Seyfert nucleus
59: known, with an absolute blue magnitude of only $M_B=-9.8$~mag. On
60: energetics grounds it is therefore essential to explore both black
61: hole and stellar origins for the Seyfert activity
62: \citep{fil89,fil93,lir99}. Second, it is the only Seyfert nucleus
63: known to be hosted by an Sm galaxy. Proving that the Seyfert traits
64: of NGC\,4395 are inconsistent with a stellar origin, but consistent
65: with a black hole origin, would thus bolster claims of black hole
66: ubiquity in the local universe \citep{mag98}. Finally, NGC\,4395 lies
67: at a distance $D=2.6$~Mpc \citep{row85}, making it the nearest known
68: Seyfert~1 nucleus. The corresponding scale is 10~mas $=$
69: 0.42~lt-year, so the inner light year can, in theory, be probed
70: directly with the NRAO Very Long Baseline Array (VLBA). Direct
71: imaging of radio emission on light-year scales can be a powerful
72: discriminant between black hole and stellar origins: a black hole
73: could launch jets \citep{fal00}, while stellar processes could result
74: in a compact starburst \citep{con91}, a supernova remnant resembling
75: Galactic ones \citep{gre84}, or a compact supernova remnant
76: \citep{ter95}.
77:
78: Recent observations of NGC\,4395 with the NRAO Very Large Array (VLA)
79: showed an unresolved source at a frequency $\nu=1.4$~GHz, with a flux
80: density $S=1680\pm94~\mu$Jy; a diameter $d < 550$~mas (23~lt-years);
81: and a spectral index $\alpha = -0.60\pm0.08$ ($S \propto
82: \nu^{\alpha}$) between 1.4 and 4.9~GHz, indicating synchrotron
83: emission from a nonthermal plasma \citep{ho01a}. A VLA source of this
84: strength is too weak to be imaged with the VLBA if just traditional
85: self-calibration techniques are applied. However, the prospects for
86: successfully imaging NGC\,4395 with the VLBA are good if
87: phase-referencing techniques are employed \citep{wro00b}. Section~2
88: of this Letter reports the detection of one VLBA source at 1.4~GHz,
89: using phase-referenced observations of a 550-mas region in NGC\,4395.
90: Section~3 examines the implications of this VLBA detection, plus
91: published radio photometry, for black hole and stellar models for the
92: origin of the radio emission. These data are shown to be consistent
93: with an origin from a black hole but inconsistent with an origin from
94: a compact starburst, a supernova remnant like Cassiopeia\,A, or a
95: compact supernova remnant resembling SN\,1988Z.
96:
97: \section{OBSERVATIONS, CALIBRATION, AND IMAGING}
98:
99: The VLBA \citep{nap94} was used to observe NGC\,4395 and calibrators
100: on 2000 April 11 UT. Data were acquired in dual circular
101: polarizations with 4-level sampling and at a center frequency
102: 1.43840~GHz with bandwidth 32~MHz. Phase-referenced observations were
103: made in the nodding style. A 3-minute observation of NGC\,4395 was
104: preceded and followed by a 2-minute observation of the phase, rate,
105: and delay calibrator J1220+3431 \citep{wil98} about $1.5\arcdeg$ from
106: NGC\,4395. Sources J1215+3448 and J1310+3220 were also observed,
107: respectively, to check the astrometric accuracy and to align the
108: phases of the independent baseband channels \citep{ma98}. Observation
109: and correlation assumed a coordinate equinox of 2000. The {\em a
110: priori\/} position adopted for NGC\,4395 was very close to that in
111: \citet{ho01a}.
112:
113: Data editing and calibration were done using the 1999 December 31
114: release of the NRAO AIPS software and following the strategies
115: outlined by \citet{ulv00}. After data deletion based on {\em a
116: priori\/} flags, data were deleted on all baselines involving any
117: antenna observing below an elevation of $20\arcdeg$. Such
118: elevation-based editing minimized differential ionospheric conditions
119: between the lines of sight to J1220+3431 and NGC\,4395. Despite this
120: step, it was impossible to calibrate the phases on baselines to the
121: VLBA antenna on Manua Kea in Hawaii, and those baselines were also
122: deleted. This resulted in an observed baseline range of 240--5800~km
123: and, for NGC\,4395, a total of 129~baseline-hours of integration.
124: VLBA system temperatures and gains were used to set the amplitude
125: scale to an accuracy of about 5\%, after first correcting for sampler
126: errors. No self-calibrations were performed on NGC\,4395.
127:
128: The AIPS task IMAGR was used to form and deconvolve an image of the
129: Stokes $I\/$ emission from NGC\,4395, with the visibility data being
130: naturally weighted to optimize image sensitivity. This image, given
131: in Figure~1, was restored with an elliptical-Gaussian beam with FWHM
132: dimensions of 13.9~mas (0.59~lt-year) by 10.7~mas (0.45~lt-year) and
133: elongation orientation of $-20.3\arcdeg$, and has an rms noise value
134: of 51~microjanskys ($\mu$Jy) per beam area. The left panel of
135: Figure~1 shows that only one VLBA source was detected above 4.5 times
136: the rms noise, within a region centered on the unresolved VLA
137: detection and spanning 550~mas (23~lt-years), which matches the upper
138: limit to the diameter of the VLA detection at 1.4~GHz \citep{ho01a}.
139: A quadratic fit to the peak of the VLBA detection yielded a position
140: of $\alpha(J2000) = 12^{h} 25^{m} 48^{s}.874$ and $\delta(J2000) =
141: 33^{\circ} 32' 48''.69$. This position carries an absolute
142: 2-dimensional error of 55~mas, set by the position error of J1220+3431
143: and verified with a phase-referenced image of J1215+3448. Given the
144: signal-to-noise ratio of the VLBA detection of NGC\,4395, its position
145: can, in principal, be determined with an error of 1-2~mas
146: \citep{bal75} and efforts are underway to reach that limiting
147: accuracy.
148:
149: \placefigure{fig1}
150:
151: The right panel of Figure~1 displays the inner 76~mas (3.2~lt-years)
152: centered on the position of the VLBA detection. The VLBA source seems
153: to be slightly resolved but this apparent resolution is likely to be
154: artifical, due to the weakness of the source and/or residual errors in
155: the phase calibration. As a gauge of the importance of the latter
156: effect, before self-calibration an image of the strong source
157: J1215+3448 had a peak intensity only 88\% of the peak after phase
158: self-calibration. For the VLBA detection of NGC\,4395, (1) image
159: integration over $N=5.8$ beam areas gives a total flux density of
160: $530\pm130~\mu$Jy, where the error is the quadratic sum of a 5\% scale
161: error and $\sqrt{N}$ times the rms noise; and (2) a conservative
162: estimate to the diameter is $d < 11$~mas (0.46~lt-year). Traits (1)
163: and (2) imply that the VLBA detection has a brightness temperature
164: $T_{\rm b} > 2.0\times10^6$~K.
165:
166: \section{IMPLICATIONS}
167:
168: Figure~2 shows that the VLA detections of NGC\,4395 \citep{ho01a}
169: match the spectral powers and spectral index of Sagittarius\,A in the
170: Galactic Center \citep{ped89}. The VLA size limit for NGC\,4395,
171: conveyed by the dimension of the left panel of Figure~1, is also
172: comparable to the diameter of 26~lt-years for Sagittarius\,A
173: \citep{ped89}. But the VLBA detection of NGC\,4395 at 1.4~GHz is less
174: powerful (Figure~2) and more compact (Figure~1, left panel) than
175: Sagittarius\,A. This hints that the VLBA source in NGC\,4395 could be
176: an extragalactic analog to Sagittarius\,A$^*$ \citep{fal98}, thought
177: to mark the massive black hole at the dynamical center of the Galaxy
178: \citep{rei99}. An accurate position is not available for the
179: dynamical center of NGC\,4395 \citep{swa99}. The position of the VLBA
180: detection does agree with positions for the optical continuum
181: \citep{cot99}, X-ray continuum \citep{ho01b}, and nuclear H$\alpha$
182: emission \citep{van98}, but these agreements carry combined errors of
183: order 1000~mas (42~lt-years). However, a stringent mass limit is
184: available for a putative black hole in NGC\,4395: \citet{fil01} report
185: detection of the \ion{Ca}{2} infrared triplet lines in absorption from
186: echelle spectra taken with the Keck~I telescope, yielding estimates
187: for the strength of the stellar contribution to the nuclear light
188: ($M_B=-7.3$~mag) and the central LOS velocity dispersion ($\sigma \sim
189: 30$~km~s$^{-1}$), which, in combination with the star cluster size
190: from {\em HST\/} images, limit any black hole mass to $M_{\rm BH}
191: \lesssim 80,000~M_{\sun}$.
192:
193: \placefigure{fig2}
194:
195: An accreting black hole could launch jets. While \citet{fal00} use a
196: spectral analysis to build a case for a jet origin for
197: Sagittarius\,A$^*$, morphological evidence for an outflow would be far
198: more compelling. In the case of NGC\,4395, the VLBA source is
199: unresolved at a linear resolution of 0.46~lt-year or 170~lt-days, and
200: only 0.32$\pm$0.26 times as strong as the VLA source spanning
201: 23~lt-years or less. A few nearby galaxies have had their radio
202: nuclei probed on similar scales, or even finer scales down to a
203: resolution of 10~lt-days (eg, NGC\,3031, Bietenholz, Bartel, \& Rupen
204: 2000). While jets or jet-like structures are invariably observed,
205: those galaxies exhibit spectral powers at 1.5~GHz that are an order of
206: magnitude, or more, above the power of the source in NGC\,4395 at
207: comparable VLA resolutions \citep{wro01}. Still, the VLA and VLBA
208: sources in NGC\,4258 at 1.5~GHz \citep{cec00} are only about a factor
209: of ten more powerful than their counterparts in NGC\,4395. At a
210: linear resolution of 0.94~lt-year, the VLBA source in NGC\,4258 is
211: resolved into two jets elongated over 5.9~lt-years. Similar jets, if
212: present in NGC\,4395, could account for some of the VLA flux density
213: missing from Figure~1: a deeper VLBA image of NGC\,4395 is required to
214: search for such jets. The present VLBA detection could then
215: correspond to the brightest region in the jets, an hypothesis that
216: could be tested with VLBA imaging at higher linear resolution.
217:
218: On energetics grounds it is reasonable also to explore a stellar
219: origin for the Seyfert activity in NGC\,4395 \citep{fil93,lir99}. In
220: the radio regime, stellar processes could result in a compact
221: starburst, a supernova remnant resembling Galactic ones, or a compact
222: supernova remnant.
223:
224: For a compact starburst, \citet{con91} use an empirical scaling
225: relation between thermal and nonthermal radio continuum, based on more
226: extended star-forming galaxies with thermal electron temperature
227: $T_{\rm e} = 10^4$~K, to derive a limiting brightness temperature of
228: $T_{\rm b} \lesssim 10^5$~K at 1.4~GHz. The VLBA source in NGC\,4395,
229: with brightness temperature $T_{\rm b} > 2.0\times10^6$~K, clearly
230: exceeds this limit, excluding a compact starburst origin.
231:
232: The Galactic supernova remnant Cassiopeia\,A, of age $t \lesssim
233: 400$~years, has spectral powers and a spectral index
234: \citep{baa77,gre84,fil93} very similar to those derived from the VLA
235: detections of NGC\,4395 \citep{ho01a}. These photometric similarities
236: are displayed in Figure~2. The upper limit $d = 23$~lt-years to the
237: diameter of the VLA source in NGC\,4395 is also consistent with the
238: diameter $d = 13$~lt-years for Cassiopeia\,A \citep{gre84}. But the
239: VLBA source in NGC\,4395 is about a third as powerful (Figure~2) and
240: considerably more compact ($d < 0.46$~lt-year) than Cassiopeia\,A.
241: This VLBA size constraint strongly excludes further analogy with
242: Cassiopeia\,A.
243:
244: Could the VLBA source in NGC\,4395 be a compact supernova remnant
245: (cSNR) whose evolution is governed by a supernova expanding into
246: dense circumstellar material \citep{ter95}? Such an interpretation
247: encounters some successes and some difficulties \citep{fil93,lir99}.
248: In the optical regime, published images of NGC\,4395 plus the POSS
249: revealed the presence of a starlike nucleus, visible at similar
250: brightness levels since 1956 May 8 UT and implying an age $t \gtrsim
251: 36$~years in 1992. \citet{lir99} find that, while this slow blue
252: photometric evolution could just be a signpost of a cSNR of age $t
253: \sim 300$~years, the observed line properties roughly match those
254: expected for a cSNR of age $t \sim 34$~years. The large-amplitude
255: variability observed on time scales of days to months, in both the
256: optical and X-ray regimes, remains a problem for the cSNR model.
257:
258: In the radio regime, the record of photometric evolution of the VLA
259: source, while sparse, supports approximate constancy over 1--2 decades
260: at 1.4 and 4.9~GHz, since 1982 \citep{mor99,ho01a}. Also,
261: \citet{hee64} used the NRAO 91-m telescope in 1963 to set an upper
262: limit of 0.2~Jy for the peak flux density of NGC\,4395 at 1.4~GHz. Is
263: this record consistent with a cSNR origin? Models for cSNRs do not,
264: as yet, predict radio light curves, although \citet{ter95} do remark
265: on the relevance of SN\,1988Z, a radio supernova, to their models.
266: Figure~3 shows the model light curves for SN\,1988Z at 1.4 and
267: 4.9~GHz, based on three years of monitoring in the radio regime
268: \citep{van93} but extrapolated to an age of 50~years. The powers of
269: the VLA detections of NGC\,4395, measured on 1982 Feb 8 UT and 1990
270: Mar 3 UT by \citet{mor99} with matched resolutions, and on 1999 Aug 29
271: and Oct 31 UT by \citet{ho01a} also with matched resolutions, are
272: plotted at their minimum possible ages assuming a reference date of
273: 1956 May 8 UT. (No point appears for the VLBA detection due to
274: concern about the effects of source resolution between VLA and VLBA
275: scales.) The power of the 91-m upper limit, obtained during 1963
276: between Feb 1 UT and Dec 31 UT, is also plotted at the minimum
277: possible age of about 7.2~years relative to the same reference date.
278: Figure~3 shows that NGC\,4395 is observed to be less powerful than
279: SN\,1988Z, by factors ranging from at least 60 at an age of about
280: 7~years to about 100--700 at an age of 43~years. This latter
281: discrepancy could reflect the failure of the SN\,1988Z model after a
282: few decades but model problems are unlikely through the first decade
283: \citep{hym95}. The spectral powers of NGC\,4395 at 1.4 and 4.9~GHz
284: thus appear to be too low since 1963 and too steady since 1982 to
285: allow analogy with SN\,1988Z. The former trait is more constraining
286: than the latter, as the degree of variability could be artificially
287: suppressed if only a small fraction of the VLA emission arises from a
288: cSNR.
289:
290: \placefigure{fig3}
291:
292: In summary, for the VLBA source in NGC\,4395, the constraints on
293: $T_b$, $d\/$, and $P\/$ are consistent with an origin from a black
294: hole but exclude an origin from a compact starburst or a supernova
295: remnant like Cassiopeia\,A. Also, the spectral powers of NGC\,4395 at
296: 1.4 and 4.9~GHz seem both too low and too stable for analogy with
297: SN\,1988Z, a suggested prototype for models of compact supernova
298: remnants. Future studies of the VLBA source in NGC\,4395 should focus
299: on measuring its spectral index, reducing the upper limit to its
300: diameter or seeking evidence for jet-like structures, assessing its
301: astrometric stability (cf.\ Wrobel 2000), and imaging the missing VLA
302: flux density.
303:
304: Like other Seyfert galaxies, NGC\,4395 exhibits copious evidence for
305: thermal nuclear plasma. Estimates of the associated free-free optical
306: depths $\tau_{\rm ff}$ at 1.4~GHz can constrain the relative
307: geometries of the thermal and nonthermal plasmas. Equation~1 of
308: \citet{ulv99} reduces to $\tau_{\rm ff} = 0.038~T_{\rm e}^{-1.35}~E$
309: at 1.4~GHz for a thermal plamsa with electron temperature $T_{\rm e}$
310: in units of K and emission measure $E\/$ in units of cm$^{-6}$~pc.
311: While $T_{\rm e}$ is either readily observed or plausibly estimated,
312: neither condition generally applies to $E$. However, a notable
313: exception is the thermal plasma responsible for the variable warm
314: X-ray absorber in NGC\,4395 \citep{iwa00}. For this plasma, $T_{\rm
315: e} = 10^6$~K is plausibly adopted, the column density is measured, and
316: the variability time scale sets a lower limit to the density. The
317: latter two quantities imply $E \gtrsim 2 \times 10^{13}$~cm$^{-6}$~pc,
318: which, in combination with $T_{\rm e} = 10^6$~K, leads to $\tau_{\rm
319: ff} \gtrsim 6000$. The variable warm X-ray absorber in NGC\,4395 has
320: a free-free optical depth much larger than unity at 1.4~GHz and,
321: therefore, cannot fully cover the VLBA source. Arguments such as
322: these should be folded into discussions of unifying structures for the
323: inner regions of quasars (eg, Elvis 2000).
324:
325: \acknowledgments The authors thank Dr.\ J.\ Ulvestad for discussions.
326: This research has made use of the NASA/IPAC Extragalactic Database
327: (NED) which is operated by the Jet Propulsion Laboratory, Caltech,
328: under contract with the National Aeronautics and Space Administration.
329: NRAO is a facility of the National Science Foundation operated under
330: cooperative agreement by Associated Universities, Inc.
331: \clearpage
332:
333: \begin{thebibliography}{}
334: \bibitem[Baars et al.(1977)]{baa77}
335: Baars, J.~W.~M., Genzel, R., Pauliny-Toth, I.~I.~K., \& Witzel, A.
336: 1977, \aap, 61, 99
337: \bibitem[Ball(1975)]{bal75}
338: Ball, J.~A. 1975, in Methods in Computational Physics,
339: Volume 14, eds.\ B. Alder, S. Fernbach, \& M. Rotenberg
340: (New York: Academic Press), 177
341: \bibitem[Bietenholz, Bartel, \& Rupen(2000)]{bie00}
342: Bietenholz, M.F., Bartel, N., \& Rupen, M.P. 2000, \apj, 532, 895
343: \bibitem[Cecil et al.(2000)]{cec00}
344: Cecil, G., et al. 2000, \apj, 536, 675
345: \bibitem[Condon et al.(1991)]{con91}
346: Condon, J.~J., Huang, Z.-P., Yin, Q.~F., \& Thuan, T.~X. 1991,
347: \apj, 378, 65
348: \bibitem[Cotton, Condon, \& Arbizzani(1999)]{cot99}
349: Cotton, W.~D., Condon, J.~J., \& Arbizzani, E. 1999, \apjs, 125,
350: 409
351: \bibitem[Elvis(2000)]{elv00}
352: Elvis, M. 2000, \apj, 545, 63
353: \bibitem[Falcke et al.(1998)]{fal98}
354: Falcke, H., Goss, W.~M., Matsuo, H., Teuben, P., Zhao, J.-H., \&
355: Zylka, R. 1998, \apj, 499, 731
356: \bibitem[Falcke \& Markoff(2000)]{fal00}
357: Falcke, H., \& Markoff, S. 2000, \aap, 362, 113
358: \bibitem[Filippenko \& Sargent(1989)]{fil89}
359: Filippenko, A.~V., \& Sargent, W.~L.~W. 1989, \apj, 342, L11
360: \bibitem[Filippenko, Ho, \& Sargent(1993)]{fil93}
361: Filippenko, A.~V., Ho, L.~C., \& Sargent, W.~L.~W. 1993, \apj, 410,
362: L75
363: \bibitem[Filippenko \& Ho(2001)]{fil01}
364: Filippenko, A.~V., \& Ho, L.~C. 2001, \apj, submitted
365: \bibitem[Green(1984)]{gre84}
366: Green, D.~A. 1984, \mnras, 209, 449
367: \bibitem[Heeschen \& Wade(1964)]{hee64}
368: Heeschen, D.~S., \& Wade, C.~M. 1964, \aj, 69, 277
369: \bibitem[Ho \& Ulvestad(2001)]{ho01a}
370: Ho, L.~C., \& Ulvestad, J.~S. 2001, \apjs, 133, 77
371: \bibitem[Ho et al.(2001)]{ho01b}
372: Ho, L.~C., et al.\ 2001, \apj, 549, L51
373: \bibitem[Hyman et al.(1995)]{hym95}
374: Hyman, S.~D., Van Dyk, S.~D., Sramek, R.~A., \& Weiler, K.~W. 1995,
375: \apj, 443, L77
376: \bibitem[Iwasawa et al.(2000)]{iwa00}
377: Iwasawa, K., Fabian, A.~C., Almaini, O., Lira, P., Lawrence, A.,
378: Hayashida, K., \& Inoue, H. 2000, \mnras, 318, 879
379: \bibitem[Lira et al.(1999)]{lir99}
380: Lira, P., Lawrence, A., O'Brien, P., Johnson, R.~A., Terlevich, R.,
381: \& Bannister, N. 1999, \mnras, 305, 109
382: \bibitem[Ma et al.(1998)]{ma98}
383: Ma, C., et al.\ 1998, \aj, 116, 516
384: \bibitem[Magorrian et al.(1998)]{mag98}
385: Magorrian, J., et al.\ 1998, \aj, 115, 2285
386: \bibitem[Moran et al.(1999)]{mor99}
387: Moran, E.~C., Filippenko, A.~V., Ho, L.~C., Shields, J.~C.,
388: Belloni, T., Comastri, A., Snowden, S.~L., \& Sramek, R.~A. 1999,
389: \pasp, 111, 801
390: \bibitem[Napier et al.(1994)]{nap94}
391: Napier, P.~J., Bagri, D.~S., Clark, B.~G., Rogers, A.~E.~E.,
392: Romney, J.~D., Thompson, A.~R., \& Walker, R.~C. 1994, Proc.\ IEEE,
393: 82, 658
394: \bibitem[Pedlar et al.(1989)]{ped89}
395: Pedlar, A., Anatharmaiah, K.~R., Ekers, R.~D., Goss, W.~M., van
396: Gorkom, J.~H., Schwarz, U.~J., \& Zhao, J.-H. 1989, \apj, 342, 769
397: \bibitem[Reid et al.(1999)]{rei99}
398: Reid, M.~J., Readhead, A.~C.~S., Vermeulen, R.~C., \& Treuhaft,
399: R.~N. 1999, \apj, 524, 816
400: \bibitem[Rowan-Robinson(1985)]{row85}
401: Rowan-Robinson, M. 1985, The Cosmological Distance Ladder (New
402: York: Freeman)
403: \bibitem[Swaters et al.(1999)]{swa99}
404: Swaters, R.~A., Schoenmakers, R.~H.~M., Sancisi, R., \& van
405: Albada, T.~S. 1999, \mnras, 304, 330
406: \bibitem[Terlevich et al.(1995)]{ter95}
407: Terlevich, R., Tenorio-Tagle, G., Rozyczka, M., Franco, J., \&
408: Melnick, J. 1995, \mnras, 272, 198
409: \bibitem[Ulvestad et al.(1999)]{ulv99}
410: Ulvestad, J.~S., Wrobel, J.~M., Roy, A.~L., Wilson, A.~S., Falcke,
411: H., \& Krichbaum, T.~P. 1999, \apj, 517, L81
412: \bibitem[Ulvestad(2000)]{ulv00}
413: Ulvestad, J.~S. 2000, VLBA Scientific Memorandum 25
414: \bibitem[Van Dyk et al.(1993)]{van93}
415: Van Dyk, S.~D., Weiler, K.~W., Sramek, R.~A., \& Panagia, N. 1993,
416: \apj, 419, L69
417: \bibitem[van Zee et al.(1998)]{van98}
418: van Zee, L., Salzer, J.~J., Haynes, M.~P., O'Donoghue, A.~A., \&
419: Balonek, T.~J. 1998, \aj, 116, 2805
420: \bibitem[Wilkinson et al.(1998)]{wil98}
421: Wilkinson, P.~N., Browne, I.~W.~A., Patnaik, A.~R., Wrobel, J.~M.,
422: \& Sorathia, B. 1998, \mnras, 300, 790
423: \bibitem[Wrobel(2000)]{wro00a}
424: Wrobel, J.~M. 2000, \apj, 531, 716
425: \bibitem[Wrobel et al.(2000)]{wro00b}
426: Wrobel, J.~M., Walker, R.~C., Benson, J.~M, \& Beasley, A.~J.,
427: 2000, VLBA Scientific Memorandum 24
428: \bibitem[Wrobel, Machalski, \& Condon(2001)]{wro01}
429: Wrobel, J.~M., Machalski, J., \& Condon, J.~J. 2001, in preparation
430: \end{thebibliography}
431: \clearpage
432:
433: \figcaption{VLBA images of Stokes $I\/$ emission from NGC\,4395 at
434: a frequency of 1.4~GHz. Hatched ellipse shows the restoring beam area
435: at FWHM. Contour levels are $\pm$2, $\pm$4, and $\pm$6 times the
436: image rms noise level of 51~$\mu$Jy per beam area. Negative contours
437: are dashed and positive ones are solid.
438: {\em Left:} Inner 550~mas (23~lt-years) centered on the position of
439: the VLA detection at 1.4~GHz by Ho \& Ulvestad (2001). The image size
440: matches the upper limit to the diameter of the unresolved VLA
441: detection. One-sigma position errors are shown by the cross for the
442: VLA detection and by the cross with a gap for the VLBA detection.
443: {\em Right:} Inner 76~mas (3.2~lt-years) centered on the position of
444: the VLBA detection.
445: \label{fig1}}
446:
447: \figcaption{Spectral power as a function of frequency. One-sigma
448: error bars are shown for NGC\,4395. Error bars for the Galactic
449: sources are smaller and not shown to reduce plot clutter.
450: \label{fig2}}
451:
452: \figcaption{Spectral powers at 1.4~GHz (circles) and 4.9~GHz (squares)
453: as a function of age. The model light curves for SN\,1988Z, shown at
454: monthly intervals, are from three years of monitoring in the radio
455: regime but extrapolated to an age of 50~years. The data points are
456: from measurements of NGC\,4395 during 1963--1999 but referenced to
457: 1956 May 8 UT, the epoch of the first optical detection of the
458: Seyfert~1 nucleus. One-sigma error bars are shown for NGC\,4395.
459: \label{fig3}}
460:
461: % Note1 - pgplot files must be edited to move the bounding box to
462: % the front from the end. Otherwise there are lots of problems
463: % in plotone. Same for kntr with grey scale, it seems.
464: % Note2 - Montages must be built with divps -E and then bounding
465: % boxes adjusted by hand based on gv to avoid 72 72 72 72.
466: %
467: \newpage
468: \epsscale{1.0} \plottwo{f1a.eps}{f1b.eps}
469:
470: \centerline{Figure~1}
471:
472: \newpage
473: \epsscale{2.0} \plotone{f2.eps}
474:
475: \centerline{Figure~2}
476:
477: \newpage
478: \epsscale{1.7} \plotone{f3.eps}
479:
480: \centerline{Figure~3}
481:
482: \end{document}
483: