1: %\documentclass{aastex}
2: \documentclass[12pt,preprint]{aastex}
3:
4: \shortauthors{Feuchtgruber et al.}
5: \shorttitle{New wavelength determinations}
6: \slugcomment{Submitted March 2001}
7: \begin{document}
8:
9: \title{New rest wavelength determinations for 7 mid-infrared fine structure
10: lines by ISO-SWS\footnote
11: {Based on observations made with ISO, an project of ESA with
12: participation of ISAS and NASA, and the SWS, a joint project of SRON
13: and MPE with contributions from KU Leuven, Steward Observatory and
14: Phillips Laboratory.}}
15:
16: \author{H. Feuchtgruber, D. Lutz}
17: \affil{Max-Planck-Institut f\"ur extraterrestrische Physik,
18: Postfach 1312, D--85741 Garching, Germany}
19:
20: \email{fgb@mpe.mpg.de}
21:
22: \author{D. A. Beintema}
23: \affil{SRON Laboratory for Space Research, P.O. Box 800,
24: 9700 AV Groningen, The Netherlands}
25:
26:
27: \begin{abstract}
28:
29: Observations of the planetary nebulae NGC\,6302, NGC\,6543 and NGC\,7027
30: by the Short Wavelength Spectrometer (SWS) on
31: board the Infrared Space Observatory (ISO) have been used to determine
32: rest wavelengths of spectral lines. We report
33: on improved accuracies for wavelengths of 7 mid-infrared ionic fine structure
34: lines.
35:
36: \end{abstract}
37:
38: \keywords{ Atomic data ---
39: Line: identification ---
40: Infrared: ISM: lines and bands
41: }
42:
43: \section{Introduction}
44:
45: Mid infrared atomic fine structure lines are important probes for a variety of
46: astrophysical environments like planetary nebulae (e.g., Beintema
47: et al. 1996), shocked regions (e.g., Oliva et al. 1999) and
48: galaxies (e.g., Lutz et al. 2000). Due to their low magnetic dipole transition
49: probabilities the lines are usually optically thin ($\tau = 10^{-2}$ to a few)
50: and measurements of these lines give handles on luminosities and
51: spatial distribution of abundant atoms and ions. In addition they provide
52: also valuable information on the density, temperature and ionization
53: structure of targets
54: with little or no dependence on dust extinction that hampers observations in
55: the visible. Accurate laboratory measurements of highly ionized species are
56: difficult and line rest wavelengths are mostly based on energy level
57: differences reconstructed from UV and optical spectroscopy. The knowledge of
58: accurate rest wavelengths of these lines will enhance their diagnostic value
59: for many spectroscopic studies in the mid-infrared wavelength range.
60:
61:
62: New wavelength determinations by the Short Wavelength
63: Spectrometer (SWS; de Graauw et al. 1996) on board the Infrared
64: Space Observatory (ISO; Kessler et al. 1996) have been reported
65: by Feuchtgruber et al. 1997 (hereafter paper I).
66: The observations therein were taken early during the ISO mission
67: and the subsequent analysis was focused mainly on bright lines. Long
68: integration observations on NGC\,6302, NGC\,6543 and NGC\,7027 obtained later
69: during the operational lifetime of ISO revealed another 7 lines where SWS
70: data provide improved accuracies on their rest wavelengths. Thus, the
71: present work represents an extension of paper I towards fainter lines.
72: Transitions from [Cl IV], [Cl V], [Ca V], Ca [VII]
73: and [Al VI] have been measured in SWS AOT06 grating mode, while the
74: 21.8 $\mu$m line of [Ar III] has been detected with the SWS Fabry-Perot (FP),
75: improving significantly on its accuracy as compared to the SWS grating
76: observation reported in paper I.
77:
78: The accuracy of the SWS wavelength calibration has been established initially
79: by Valentijn et al. 1996 down to an uncertainty of 0.5-1.0 steps
80: of the grating scanner. This value, translated from its instrumental unit into
81: wavelength, typically corresponds to $\lambda/\Delta\lambda=1\times 10^{4}$.
82: The nominal 2 steps uncertainty of the FP at 21.8 micron correspond
83: to $\lambda/\Delta\lambda=1\times 10^{5}$. While the FP wavelength calibration
84: has proven to be stable throughout the whole ISO mission, the SWS grating
85: wavelength calibration has shown a slight shift in time ($<0.1$ step/month).
86: Regular calibration observations of the internal SWS grating calibration
87: source and external astronomical wavelength calibration targets have however
88: allowed to maintain the initial accuracy by interpolation between the
89: various measurements. For more details regarding the accuracy of
90: wavelengths in SWS observations see paper I and
91: Valentijn et al. 1996.
92:
93:
94: \begin{deluxetable}{ccccccrc}
95: \tablewidth{0pc}
96: \tabletypesize{\scriptsize}
97: \tablecaption{Summary of new wavelength determinations \label{newlambda}}
98: \tablehead{
99: \colhead{Ion} & \colhead{Transition} & \colhead {Vac. Wavelength$^*$} &
100: \colhead{Rest wavenumber$^*$} &\colhead{$\chi_{lower}$} &
101: \colhead{$\chi_{upper}$} &\colhead{Obs. Date} &\colhead{Target}\\
102: \colhead{}&\colhead{$u-l$}&\colhead{[$\mu$m]}&\colhead{[cm$^{-1}$]} &
103: \colhead{[eV]}&\colhead{[eV]}&\colhead{}&\colhead{}}
104:
105: \startdata
106: [Al VI] & $^3$P$_1$-$^3$P$_2$ & 3.65971$\pm$(62) &
107: 2732.46$\pm$(46) & 153.83& 190.48& 1997-Feb-20$^a$ & NGC\,6302 \\
108:
109: [Ca VII] & $^3$P$_2$-$^3$P$_1$ & 4.0858$\pm$(12) &
110: 2447.5$\pm$(7) & 108.78 & 127.20& 1997-Feb-20$^a$ & NGC\,6302 \\
111:
112: [Ca V] & $^3$P$_1$-$^3$P$_2$ & 4.15937$\pm$(62) &
113: 2404.21$\pm$(36) & 67.27 & 84.50& 1996-Oct-19$^a$ & NGC\,7027 \\
114:
115: [Cl V] & $^2$P$_{3/2}$-$^2$P$_{1/2}$ & 6.70667$\pm$(62) &
116: 1491.05$\pm$(14) & 53.46 & 67.82 & 1996-Oct-19$^a$ & NGC\,7027 \\
117:
118: [Cl IV] & $^3$P$_{2}$-$^3$P$_{1}$ & 11.7619$\pm$(11) &
119: 850.203$\pm$(79) & 39.61 & 53.46 & 1996-Oct-19$^a$ & NGC\,7027 \\
120:
121: [Cl IV] & $^3$P$_{1}$-$^3$P$_{0}$ & 20.3107$\pm$(21) &
122: 492.351$\pm$(51) & 39.61 & 53.46 & 1997-Feb-20$^a$ & NGC\,6302 \\
123:
124: [Ar III] & $^3$P$_0$-$^3$P$_1$ & 21.8302$\pm$(3) &
125: 458.081$\pm$(6) & 27.63 & 40.74 & 1997-Feb-11$^b$ & NGC\,6543 \\
126:
127: \tablenotetext{a}{Grating scan}
128: \tablenotetext{b}{Fabry-Perot line scan}
129: \tablenotetext{*}{Numbers in brackets give errors on last decimals}
130: \tablecomments{$\chi_{lower}$ and $\chi_{upper}$ denote excitation and
131: ionization potentials}
132: \enddata
133: \end{deluxetable}
134:
135:
136: \section{Observations and data reduction}
137:
138: We have analyzed observations, taken in SWS AOT06 grating mode of the
139: planetary nebulae NGC\,6302 and NGC\,7027. NGC\,6543 has been observed in
140: SWS AOT07 Fabry-Perot mode. The rich SWS spectra of these targets are
141: discussed e.g. by Beintema et al. 1996,
142: Pottasch et al. 1996, Beintema \& Pottasch 1999 and
143: Pottasch \& Beintema 1999. Here, we focus exclusively
144: on wavelength determination and report only about those lines
145: observed by SWS for which we could improve on the accuracy of the rest
146: wavelengths.
147:
148: The data reduction of all measurements was done using the SWS Interactive
149: Analysis software (SIA; Wieprecht et al. 1998) package on
150: ISO pipeline products of version OLP 8.4.
151: Particular attention has been payed to remove instrumental fringing in the
152: wavelength range between 12 $\mu$m and 29 $\mu$m by the dedicated fourier
153: filtering modules of SIA.
154: The same procedure was used as for paper I.
155: Gaussian fits to the spectral lines provided the
156: center wavelengths,
157: which were corrected for the heliocentric radial velocity and for the mean
158: ISO radial velocity. Typical velocity changes during an observation were
159: less than 0.3 km/s, so could be neglected.
160: The observed profiles of all lines with new wavelengths are presented in
161: Fig.~1.
162:
163: \subsection{Use of reference lines}
164:
165: Small pointing errors and spatial inhomogeneities of the targets can induce
166: apparent velocity shifts in SWS grating data.
167: We have corrected for this effect using reference lines of accurately known
168: wavelengths, observed in the same SWS aperture during the same observation.
169: Details of this strategy are given in paper I and will not be repeated here.
170: Although at similar accuracy, some reference lines with rest
171: wavelengths determined in paper I have been used (see Table~\ref{reflambda}),
172: to improve on fixing the reference frame and to illustrate the good agreement
173: with the more accurate reference lines.
174:
175: The new wavelength determinations together with some other line properties are
176: summarized in Table~\ref{newlambda}. The framework of fine structure
177: and hydrogen or helium recombination reference
178: lines which were used for the indvidual observations of our targets is listed
179: in Table~\ref{reflambda}. The offsets
180: reflect the pointing error and the effects of the spatial structure of the
181: source of the particular observation.
182: Together with the uncertainty of the literature wavenumber, the
183: `SWS uncertainty' in Table~\ref{reflambda} is propagated into the uncertainty
184: of new wavelength determinations that are tied to this line.
185:
186: Apart from literature wavenumbers, Table~\ref{reflambda} also includes a
187: rest wavenumber for NGC\,6302 which was determined during the independent
188: observation by the SWS FP on NGC\,6543.
189:
190: \begin{figure}
191: \plotone{f1.eps}
192: \caption{Observed fine structure lines: [Al VI], [Ca VII] and [Cl IV]
193: (20.3 $\mu$m) from
194: NGC\,6302; [Ca V], [Cl V] and [ClIV] (11.76 $\mu$m) from NGC\,7027;
195: [Ar III] from NGC\,6543}
196: \end{figure}
197:
198: \subsection{NGC\,6302}
199:
200: The SWS grating observation of NGC\,6302 has been carried out on
201: 1997 February 20. The total integration time has been 8532 s. Beintema \& Pottasch (1999)
202: have presented the first analysis of this AOT SWS06 observation and provided
203: an extensive
204: line list for the SWS wavelength range.
205: From this observation we derived improved rest wavelengths for the three
206: lines reported in table~\ref{newlambda}. The [CL IV] line has escaped the
207: analysis by Beintema \& Pottasch, who quote an upper limit to the line flux.
208: For the faint lines of [Al VI] and [Ca VII] the uncertainties of the
209: wavelength determinations are dominated by detector noise.
210:
211: From the analysis of the set of reference lines
212: (see table~\ref{reflambda}), measured at
213: similar wavelength and with the same SWS aperture, the observed lines
214: in NGC\,6302
215: had to be shifted by $-4 km s^{-1}$ for [Cl IV] and $-26 km s^{-1}$
216: for [Al VI] and [Ca VII] with respect to the heliocentric velocity
217: of $-39\pm2 km s^{-1}$ given by Acker et al. (1992), probably due
218: to a pointing error. Note that a pointing error may translate into
219: different shifts for the short wavelength and long wavelength sections of SWS
220: because their beam profiles are centered on slightly different positions on
221: the sky (Salama 2000), and since the velocity shift corresponding to a given
222: angular shift differs for different order and aperture combinations.
223:
224: \subsection{NGC\,6543}
225:
226: The ionic line from [Ar\,III] at 21.83 $\mu$m has been detected by the ISO SWS
227: FP during an observation of 6750 s on 1997 February 11.
228: The wavelengths from the [Ne\,III] line at
229: 15.5 $\mu$m and of the [S\,III] line at 18.71 $\mu$m have been remeasured
230: during the same observation. Both reproduce the results from paper I within
231: their quoted uncertainties, confirming the assumption of sufficient velocity
232: and spatial averaging across the target through the SWS slit sizes, since the
233: [Ne\,III] wavelength has been originally determined on NGC\,7027 and the
234: [S\,III] line has been observed at a different position angle of the SWS slit
235: on NGC\,6543.
236: The heliocentric velocity correction of -66.1$\pm$0.4 km/s for NGC\,6543 has
237: been taken from Schneider et al. (1983).
238: The determined rest wavelength for the [Ar\,III] transition is in agreement
239: with the SWS grating result from paper I, however its accuracy is now
240: significantly improved.
241:
242: \subsection{NGC\,7027}
243:
244: The planetary nebula NGC\,7027 has been observed with SWS on 1996 October 19.
245: The total integration time of the AOT06 observation has been 7962 s.
246: New wavelength have been
247: determined for ionic lines of [Ca V], [Cl IV] and [Cl V]. The data are
248: presented in Fig.~1 and their new rest wavelengths in Table~\ref{newlambda}.
249: For this observation we found a mean shift of $+24 km s^{-1}$ of
250: the reference lines (Table~\ref{reflambda}) with respect to the
251: heliocentric velocity of $+8.8\pm0.6 km s^{-1}$ from Schneider
252: et al. (1983).
253:
254:
255: \begin{deluxetable}{cccccccc}
256: \tablewidth{0pc}
257: \tabletypesize{\scriptsize}
258: \tablecaption{Summary of reference wavenumbers. See section 2.1 and paper I
259: for explanations. \label{reflambda}}
260: \tablehead{
261: \colhead{Obs. Date} &\colhead{Target} & \colhead{Ion} & \colhead{Transition} &
262: \colhead{Ref. Wavenumber} &\colhead{Offset$^a$} &
263: \colhead{SWS uncertainty$^b$} &\colhead{Reference}\\
264: \colhead{}&\colhead{}&\colhead{}&\colhead{$u-l$} &
265: \colhead{[cm$^{-1}$]}&\colhead{[cm$^{-1}$]}&\colhead{[cm$^{-1}$]}&\colhead{}}
266:
267: \startdata
268: 1997-Feb-20 & NGC\,6302 & H$_2 \,O(5) $ & 1 - 0 & 3091.20$\pm \le$0.03& 0.05 & 0.19 &
269: Black \& Dishoek 1987\\
270: 1997-Feb-20 & NGC\,6302 & HI & 9 - 5 & 3033.07$\pm \le$0.03& 0.08 & 0.19 &
271: van Hoof \& Verner 1997\\
272: 1997-Feb-20 & NGC\,6302 & HI & 8 - 5 & 2673.40$\pm \le$0.03& 0.14 & 0.28 &
273: van Hoof \& Verner 1997\\
274: 1997-Feb-20 & NGC\,6302 & [Mg IV] & $^2$P$_{1/2}$-$^2$P$_{3/2}$ & 2228.82$\pm$0.15& -0.02 & 0.15 &
275: Feuchtgruber et al. 1997\\
276: 1997-Feb-20 & NGC\,6302 & [Ar VI] & $^2$P$_{3/2}$-$^2$P$_{1/2}$ & 2207.74$\pm$0.15& 0.02 & 0.15 &
277: Feuchtgruber et al. 1997\\
278: 1997-Feb-20 & NGC\,6302 & [K III] & $^2$P$_{1/2}$-$^2$P$_{3/2}$ & 2165.43$\pm$0.22& 0.07 & 0.22 &
279: Feuchtgruber et al. 1997\\
280: 1997-Feb-20 & NGC\,6302 & HI & 7 - 5 & 2148.79$\pm \le$0.02& -0.06 & 0.14 &
281: van Hoof \& Verner 1997\\
282: 1997-Feb-20 & NGC\,6302 & [Na VII] & $^2$P$_{3/2}$-$^2$P$_{1/2}$ & 2134.60$\pm$0.15& 0.02 & 0.15 &
283: Feuchtgruber et al. 1997\\
284: 1997-Feb-20 & NGC\,6302 & HeII & 8 - 7 & 2099.29$\pm \le$0.02& -0.07 & 0.13 &
285: van Hoof \& Verner 1997\\
286: 1997-Feb-20 & NGC\,6302 & [Mg V] & $^3$P$_1$-$^3$P$_2$ & 1782.58$\pm$0.20& 0.02& 0.20 &
287: Feuchtgruber et al. 1997\\
288: 1997-Feb-20 & NGC\,6302 & [Ar II] & $^2$P$_{1/2}$-$^2$P$_{3/2}$ & 1431.5831$\pm$0.0007& -0.11& 0.13&
289: Yamada et al. 1985\\
290: 1997-Feb-20 & NGC\,6302 & [S III] & $^3$P$_2$-$^3$P$_1$ & 534.387$\pm$0.005& 0.008 & 0.03 &
291: Kelly \& Lacy 1995\\
292: 1997-Feb-20 & NGC\,6302 & [Ar III] & $^3$P$_0$-$^3$P$_1$ & 458.081$\pm$0.006& 0.002 & 0.04 &
293: Table 1\\
294: 1997-Feb-20 & NGC\,6302 & [Ne V] & $^3$P$_2$-$^3$P$_1$ & 411.226$\pm$0.006& -0.007 & 0.04 &
295: Feuchtgruber et al. 1997\\
296: 1997-Feb-20 & NGC\,6302 & [O IV] & $^2$P$_{3/2}$-$^2$P$_{1/2}$ & 386.245$\pm$0.005& -0.001 & 0.03 &
297: Feuchtgruber et al. 1997\\
298:
299: 1996-Oct-19 & NGC\,7027 & HI & 12 - 6 & 2284.95$\pm$0.02& -0.03 & 0.15 &
300: van Hoof \& Verner 1997\\
301: 1996-Oct-19 & NGC\,7027 & HI & 7 - 5 & 2148.79$\pm$0.02& 0.06 & 0.15 &
302: van Hoof \& Verner 1997\\
303: 1996-Oct-19 & NGC\,7027 & HI & 9 - 6 & 1692.56$\pm$0.02& 0.09 & 0.18 &
304: van Hoof \& Verner 1997\\
305: 1996-Oct-19 & NGC\,7027 & HI & 6 - 5 & 1340.51$\pm$0.01& -0.04 & 0.11 &
306: van Hoof \& Verner 1997\\
307: 1996-Oct-19 & NGC\,7027 & [Ar II] & $^2$P$_{1/2}$-$^2$P$_{3/2}$ & 1431.5831$\pm$0.0007& 0.00 & 0.13 &
308: Yamada et al. 1985\\
309: 1996-Oct-19 & NGC\,7027 & [S III] & $^3$P$_2$-$^3$P$_1$ & 534.387$\pm$0.005& 0.006 & 0.03 &
310: Kelly \& Lacy 1995\\
311: 1996-Oct-19 & NGC\,7027 & [Ne V] & $^3$P$_1$-$^3$P$_0$ & 411.226$\pm$0.006& -0.006 & 0.04 &
312: Feuchtgruber et al. 1997\\
313: 1996-Oct-19 & NGC\,7027 & [O IV] & $^2$P$_{3/2}$-$^2$P$_{1/2}$ & 386.245$\pm$0.005& 0.002 & 0.03 &
314: Feuchtgruber et al. 1997\\
315: 1996-Oct-19 & NGC\,7027 & [Ar V] & $^3$P$_{2}$-$^3$P$_{1}$ & 1265.57$\pm$0.04& -0.08 & 0.10 &
316: Kelly \& Lacy 1995\\
317: 1996-Oct-19 & NGC\,7027 & [Ar III] & $^3$P$_1$-$^3$P$_2$ & 1112.176$\pm$0.015& -0.01 & 0.07 &
318: Kelly \& Lacy 1995\\
319: 1996-Oct-19 & NGC\,7027 & [S IV] & $^2$P$_{3/2}$-$^2$P$_{1/2}$ & 951.430$\pm$0.01& 0.013 & 0.05 &
320: Serabyn, priv. com.\\
321:
322: \tablenotetext{a}{Difference between observed and literature wavenumber of the
323: reference line.}
324: \tablenotetext{b}{Measurement uncertainty in the SWS observation of the
325: reference line.}
326:
327: \enddata
328: \end{deluxetable}
329:
330:
331: \section{Conclusions}
332: Extending the results of paper I towards fainter lines, the ISO Short
333: Wavelength Spectrometer has been used to obtain new rest wavelengths for
334: 7 mid-infrared fine structure lines. 6 of these are from species with lower
335: ionization potentials $\geq40eV$, detectable in high excitation planetary
336: nebulae and active galactic nuclei.
337:
338:
339: \acknowledgments
340: This work was suported by DARA grants 50 QI9402 3 and 50 QI 8610 8.
341:
342:
343: \begin{references}
344:
345: \reference{1} Acker et al., 1992 Strasbourg-ESO catalogue of
346: galactic planetary nebulae, ESO
347: \reference{2} Beintema, D.A., van Hoof, P.A.M., Lahuis, F., et al., 1996,
348: \aap, 315, L253-257
349: \reference{102}Beintema, D.A. and Pottasch, S.R., 1999, \aap, 347, 942-948
350: \reference{105}Black, J.H. and van Dishoeck, E.F., 1987, \apj, 322, 412-449
351: \reference{101}Feuchtgruber, H., Lutz, D., Beintema, D.A., et al., 1997,
352: \apj, 487, 962-966, (Paper I)
353: \reference{5} de Graauw, Th., Haser, L.N., Beintema, D.A., et al., 1996,
354: \aap, 315, L49-L54
355: \reference{104}van Hoof, P.A.M., Verner, D.A., 1997, in First ISO Workshop
356: on Analytical Spectroscopy,
357: ed. A.M. Heras (ESA SP-419; Noordwijk:ESA), 273
358: \reference{6} Kelly, D.M., Lacy, J.H., 1995, \apj, 454, L161-L164
359: \reference{21}Kessler, M.F.K., et al., 1996, \aap, 315, L27-L31
360: \reference{109}Lutz, D., Sturm, E., Genzel, R., Moorwood, A.F.M.,
361: Alexander, T., Netzer, H., Sternberg, A., 2000,
362: \apj, 536, 697-709
363: \reference{108}Oliva, E., Moorwood, A.F.M., Drapatz, S., Lutz, D., Sturm, E.,
364: 1999, \aap, 343, 943-952
365: \reference{17}Pottasch, S.R., Beintema, D.A., Dominguez-Rodriguez, F.J.,
366: Schaeidt, S., Valentijn, E., Vandenbussche, B., 1996, \aap, 315,
367: L261-L264
368: \reference{103}Pottasch, S.R. and Beintema, D.A., 1999, \aap, 347, 975-982
369: \reference{106}Salama, A., 2000, 7-10, in ISO beyond point sources: studies of
370: extended infrared emission, ed. R. Laureijs, K. Leech,
371: M.F. Kessler, (ESA-SP455; Noordwijk:ESA)
372: \reference{13}Schneider, S.E., Terzian, Y., Purgathofer, A.,
373: Perinotto, M., 1983, \apjs, 52, 399
374: \reference{12}Serabyn, E., 1991, private communication
375: \reference{14}Valentijn, E.A., Feuchtgruber, H., Kester, D.J.M. et al., 1996,
376: \aap, 315, L60-L63
377: \reference{107}Wieprecht, E., Lahuis, F., Vandenbussche, B., et al., 1998,
378: The Interaction of the
379: SWS Pipeline Software and the ISO-SWS Interactive Analysis
380: System, ADASS VII, ASP Conference Series, Vol. 145, R. Albrecht,
381: R.N. Hook and H.A. Bushhouse, eds.
382: \reference{15}Yamada, C., Kanamori, H., Hirota, E., 1985, J. chem.
383: Phys., 83, 552
384:
385: \end{references}
386:
387: %\figcaption{Observed fine structure lines: [Al VI], [Ca VII] and [Cl IV]
388: % (20.3 $\mu$m) from
389: % NGC\,6302; [Ca V], [Cl V] and [ClIV] (11.76 $\mu$m) from NGC\,7027;
390: % [Ar III] from NGC\,6543}
391:
392: \end{document}
393: